Skip to content

Official Codebase of 3DCodeVerse

Python

docs: D46(j) — an OPEN planned join stays report-only, now with the census behind it

gaoypeng4ec7753a1f22
diff --git a/harness/docs/DECISIONS.md b/harness/docs/DECISIONS.md
index 63eacaba..a7dc4d8f 100644
--- a/harness/docs/DECISIONS.md
+++ b/harness/docs/DECISIONS.md
@@ -415,6 +415,22 @@ written) that were accepted because the code works that way and the tests pin it
`JUDGE_NOISE` already tables, so the corpus's 0.072 round-to-round spread is generation, not
the judge. Rejected on the way: a through-ratio ERROR line (d), and a per-part ground gap
for every part (a shade is legitimately 400 mm off the floor).
+ (j) **An OPEN planned join stays report-only** — the (e) policy, now measured (census
+ 2026-08-30: 217 static_object runs, 2 106 resolved planned rows — 0 unresolved names, was
+ 965 — 223 OPEN across 92 runs). 181/223 are a child measurably welded to OTHER parts (mean
+ overall 0.630; the judge had already priced 74 %), 41/41 genuinely detached children already
+ carry the floating ERROR (mean 0.326, their runs already fail), and the class an upgrade
+ exists to catch — touches nothing, unflagged — is EMPTY. An ERROR's entire marginal bite is
+ 46 currently-passing runs (mean 0.643, seven at 0.83–0.96) whose 94 open rows all read as
+ planner noise on the sheets (0/19 eyeballed rows show a defect the gate+judge miss in a
+ passing run: aprons weld into legs, a wheel rim rides its 8 spokes 419 mm from the hub the
+ plan named) — the invented `attach_to` edge becoming law, D45's failure verbatim, plus a
+ PROTECTED refine round each. Severity may not be smuggled through the kind string either:
+ `rubrics._finding_tokens` matches cap kinds against data/message/target, so `kind=open_join`
+ caps nothing while `kind=no_contact` silently adds the 0.6 cap AND blocks the measured-absent
+ veto. Re-open only if a future battery's ledger census shows a touches-nothing-unflagged row
+ (free to count), or a paired A/B (~$5.50, 46 runs × 2 arms) shows the judge under-prices the
+ OPEN lines it already reads.
## Rejected / deferred