Skip to content

Official Codebase of 3DCodeVerse

Python

docs: section 7 said the surfaced-vs-deep split holds on the strength of one manual run; the four-CLI negative control says it does not

gaoypenge4a5d20e8ca6
diff --git a/harness/docs/SKILLS.md b/harness/docs/SKILLS.md
index 57abb045..80ed0b65 100644
--- a/harness/docs/SKILLS.md
+++ b/harness/docs/SKILLS.md
@@ -227,6 +227,11 @@ Two contradiction checks are worth separating, because they answer different que
that index is a pointer, not a matcher.
* **The live smoke had never run.** It skipped every CLI because it looked for a binary
named after the agent kind — `gemini-cli` runs `gemini`, `claude-code` runs `claude`.
+* **A body could name one of our constants without pinning it.** `cv3d-glsl-craft` quoted
+ `DUPLICATE_DIFF` at `1e-4` with no claim row behind it, so moving the constant would have
+ left a confident sentence with the old number and nothing to notice.
+* **The read probe was measuring git**, not the agent (§1). The most consequential finding
+ of the pass, and the reason the control bundle exists.
---
@@ -257,11 +262,20 @@ that had only been argued statically:
* gemini-cli's `activate_skill` consent prompt does not block us under
`--approval-mode yolo`. This was the one claim that could not be verified statically.
-**The surfaced-vs-deep split holds.** Controlled check: a bundle whose description does
-*not* match the task, with the prompt "do not read any files, do not activate any skill" —
-codex opened `SKILL.md` (its discovery scan reads the frontmatter) and left
-`references/zebra.md` at `atime == mtime`. That is exactly the design: tier-1 scan bumps
-SKILL.md, only a real read bumps `references/`.
+**And the same run refutes the surfaced-vs-deep split.** Negative control, same rig: a
+bundle whose description does *not* match the task, prompt "do not read any files, do not
+activate any skill". All four CLIs opened `SKILL.md` **and** `references/`:
+
+| CLI | `.agents/` SKILL.md | `.agents/` references | `.claude/` SKILL.md | `.claude/` references |
+|---|---|---|---|---|
+| codex | opened | **opened** | — | — |
+| agy | opened | **opened** | — | — |
+| gemini-cli | opened | **opened** | — | — |
+| claude-code | opened | **opened** | opened | **opened** |
+
+Each touched only the root it owns (claude-code reads both), which is a second, independent
+confirmation of the mapping above — and the reason `deep` had to stop meaning "the agent
+chose to go deeper" (§1).
---