Skip to content

armgit / ARES

Public Imported from GitHub
0

ARES - authorized red-team engagement automation with dashboard, campaign scope, module orchestration, OPSEC controls, encrypted vault, and reporting.

docs: synchronize AUDIT_PROGRESS.md and MASTER_FIX_PLAN.md for Fases 1, 2, 3

Mafifrizi814d93e4fa04
diff --git a/AUDIT_PROGRESS.md b/AUDIT_PROGRESS.md
index 0d6a53d..051d1e1 100644
--- a/AUDIT_PROGRESS.md
+++ b/AUDIT_PROGRESS.md
@@ -14,17 +14,17 @@ Tracking file for verified findings, reproduction tests, applied fixes, test sui
| ID-013 | Substring Matching SSO Role Mapping | GUGUR (FALSE POSITIVE) | Tidak terbukti / non-reproducible | - | Pengecekan `frozenset` adalah exact equality, bukan substring matching |
| ID-014 | Timing Attack Token/Signature Digest | GUGUR (FALSE POSITIVE) | Tidak terbukti / non-reproducible | - | Seluruh pembandingan token dan digest kriptografis menggunakan `hmac.compare_digest` |
| MOD-005 | Fictitious Implementation & Vault Contamination on ad.ghost_forge | MITIGATED (disabled) - keputusan final pending | PASSED (Unit repro + API & staged tests) | `ares/modules/ad/ghost_forge.py`, `ares/modules/base.py`, `ares/core/plugin/loader.py`, `ares/core/engine.py`, `ares/cli/typer_main.py`, `ares/api/server.py`, `ares/core/execution_chains.py`, `tests/unit/test_staged_modules.py`, `tests/unit/test_api_endpoints.py` | Dinonaktifkan sementara dari pipeline produksi (`ENABLED = False`). Disaring keluar dari katalog `ModuleRegistry` (`list_metadata`, `all`, `by_category`), endpoint API `/modules`, CLI `ares module list`, dan production execution chains. Invokasi langsung via class, engine (`run_module`), atau HTTP API gagal deterministik dengan pesan error eksplisit "module disabled: implementation incomplete, see MOD-005" tanpa koneksi jaringan, tanpa finding, dan tanpa kontaminasi vault. |
-| MOD-004 | ad.coerce listener_ip unvalidated against scope | DIKONFIRMASI VALID (TERBUKTI) | Audit verified (Zero scope guard on listener_ip) | Menunggu remedi | Engine `_extract_all_targets` hanya mengekstrak `_TARGET_KEYS` yang tidak memuat `listener_ip` atau `listener`. Potensi pemaksaan otentikasi ke listener luar scope. |
+| MOD-004 | ad.coerce listener_ip unvalidated against scope | FIXED | PASSED (10/10 scope tests) | `ares/modules/ad/coerce.py`, `tests/unit/test_scope_enforcement_grup_d.py` | Penegakan `await self.before_request(listener_ip, "smb")` di method `run()` mencegah paksaan otentikasi keluar scope (commit `cc2e980`). |
| MOD-006 | Key mismatch ArtifactNormalizer vs hashes | FIXED (Dual-Read Fallback) | PASSED (17/17 pipeline tests) | `ares/normalize/artifacts.py`, `tests/unit/test_artifact_normalizer_pipeline.py` | Implementasi Dual-Read Fallback di `ArtifactNormalizer` (`_normalize_*`) dan 5 handler P0 (`cleartext_credentials`, `cracked_credentials`, `laps_passwords`, `kerberos_tickets`, `open_ports`). Memulihkan 70% data loss tanpa breaking change pada modul. |
-| MOD-009 | ad.adcs scope bypass on CA HTTP enrollment | TERBUKTI (HIGH) | Audit verified (`adcs.py:1111`) | Menunggu remedi | `_submit_csr_to_ca` menghubungi `ca_host` via HTTP tanpa `before_request(ca_host)`. |
-| MOD-010 | ad.sccm scope bypass on DCOM & PXE port probe | TERBUKTI (HIGH) | Audit verified (`sccm.py:477, 561`) | Menunggu remedi | Query WMI ke site server dan probe port 4011/67 ke distribution points dilakukan tanpa `before_request`. |
-| MOD-011 | lateral.ntlm_relay mass out-of-scope port probe | TERBUKTI (CRITICAL) | Audit verified (`ntlm_relay.py:486`) | Menunggu remedi | Loop `_check_relay_targets` membuka socket port 445 ke 50 host AD tanpa memeriksa apakah host berada dalam scope. |
+| MOD-009 | ad.adcs scope bypass on CA HTTP enrollment | FIXED | PASSED (10/10 scope tests) | `ares/modules/ad/adcs.py`, `tests/unit/test_scope_enforcement_grup_d.py` | Validasi `self.noise.scope_guard.assert_in_scope(ca_host)` di `_submit_csr_to_ca` mencegah submit CSR ke CA luar scope (commit `cc2e980`). |
+| MOD-010 | ad.sccm scope bypass on DCOM & PXE port probe | FIXED | PASSED (10/10 scope tests) | `ares/modules/ad/sccm.py`, `tests/unit/test_scope_enforcement_grup_d.py` | Penegakan `before_request` pada `sccm_host`, `naa_target`, dan distribution points di `_check_pxe` dengan graceful error handling (commit `cc2e980`). |
+| MOD-011 | lateral.ntlm_relay mass out-of-scope port probe | FIXED | PASSED (10/10 scope tests) | `ares/modules/lateral/ntlm_relay.py`, `tests/unit/test_scope_enforcement_grup_d.py` | Filter targets via `campaign.is_in_scope(host)` dan `before_request(host, "smb")` di loop `_check_relay_targets` mencegah port scanning liar (commit `cc2e980`). |
| MOD-012 | lateral.ntlm_relay persistent machine account & DACL without teardown | TERBUKTI (CRITICAL) | Audit verified (`ntlm_relay.py:782-848`) | Menunggu remedi | Akun mesin `ARESXXXXXX$` dan DACL RBCD dibuat di AD tanpa handler cleanup/finally, meninggalkan backdoor permanen di domain target (melanggar Rule 4). |
| MOD-013 | lateral.ntlm_relay fictitious S4U impersonation claim | TERBUKTI (HIGH) | Audit verified (`ntlm_relay.py:944-965`) | Menunggu remedi | Mengklaim S4U impersonasi Administrator, padahal hanya meminta TGS biasa untuk akun mesin dan menyimpan tiket mesin sebagai `[email protected]` (melanggar Rule 1). |
-| MOD-014 | lateral.mssql scope bypass on UNC coercion listener & linked server | TERBUKTI (HIGH) | Audit verified (`mssql.py:321, 485`) | Menunggu remedi | `listener_ip` pada `xp_dirtree` dan `linked_server` pada dynamic SQL execution tidak divalidasi terhadap scope campaign. |
-| MOD-015 | lateral.smb_relay omission scope check on primary loop | TERBUKTI (MEDIUM) | Audit verified (`smb_relay.py:343`) | Menunggu remedi | Loop SMB audit mengirim negotiate packet tanpa memanggil `await self.before_request(target, "smb")`. |
+| MOD-014 | lateral.mssql scope bypass on UNC coercion listener & linked server | FIXED | PASSED (10/10 scope tests) | `ares/modules/lateral/mssql.py`, `tests/unit/test_scope_enforcement_grup_d.py` | Penegakan `before_request` pada listener `unc_coerce` dan `linked_server` pada dynamic query (commit `cc2e980`). |
+| MOD-015 | lateral.smb_relay omission scope check on primary loop | FIXED | PASSED (10/10 scope tests) | `ares/modules/lateral/smb_relay.py`, `tests/unit/test_scope_enforcement_grup_d.py` | Penegakan scope check `is_in_scope` dan `before_request(t, "smb")` sebelum SMB negotiate (commit `cc2e980`). |
| MOD-016 | ad.sccm cleartext credential evaporation & DPAPI misleading | TERBUKTI (HIGH) | Audit verified (`sccm.py:300, 521`) | Menunggu remedi | NAA DPAPI encrypted blob dilaporkan sebagai `cleartext_credentials`, tidak ada normalizer handler, dan tidak disimpan ke vault. |
-| MOD-017 | network.pivot scope bypass on remote_host & subnets | TERBUKTI (HIGH) | Audit verified (`infrastructure.py:283-376`) | Menunggu remedi | `establish_local_forward` tidak memvalidasi `remote_host` atau `reachable_subnets` terhadap `campaign.is_in_scope()`. |
+| MOD-017 | network.pivot scope bypass on remote_host & subnets | FIXED | PASSED (10/10 scope tests) | `ares/modules/network/pivot.py`, `tests/unit/test_scope_enforcement_grup_d.py` | Validasi `reachable_subnets` terhadap `campaign.is_in_scope()` sebelum konfigurasi SOCKS5 tunnel (commit `cc2e980`). |
| MOD-018 | network.pivot teardown omission on background SSH processes | TERBUKTI (HIGH) | Audit verified (`pivot.py:343-359`) | Menunggu remedi | `PivotModule.teardown()` tidak pernah dipanggil di engine lifecycle, meninggalkan proses tunnel background yatim (melanggar Rule 4). |
| MOD-019 | network.pivot fictitious implementation & phantom active status | TERBUKTI (HIGH) | Audit verified (`infrastructure.py:260-265, 368-370`) | Menunggu remedi | Jika backend asyncssh/ssh tidak ada, tunnel ditandai ACTIVE dan finding palsu diterbitkan (melanggar Rule 1). |
| MOD-020 | lateral.ssh_pivot fictitious SOCKS5 proxy implementation | TERBUKTI (HIGH) | Audit verified (`modules.py:1332-1356`) | Menunggu remedi | `establish_socks5` mengembalikan dict proxy padahal `move()` mengabaikan port dan menutup koneksi (melanggar Rule 1). |
@@ -34,12 +34,12 @@ Tracking file for verified findings, reproduction tests, applied fixes, test sui
| MOD-024 | network.port_scan CIDR parsing incompatibility & socket failure | TERBUKTI (MEDIUM) | Audit verified (`port_scan.py:324, 271`) | Menunggu remedi | Mengklaim mendukung CIDR namun passing CIDR langsung ke `asyncio.open_connection` memicu `getaddrinfo` error. |
| MOD-025 | windows.lsass_dump teardown omission on transfer exception & orphaned files | TERBUKTI (HIGH) | Audit verified (`lsass_dump.py:655-688, 700-720`) | Menunggu remedi | Kegagalan transfer SMB meninggalkan file lokal tanpa secure cleanup; login failure pada tasklist meninggalkan `ARESPID*.txt` di target (melanggar Rule 4). |
| MOD-026 | windows.lsass_dump phantom capability claim & incomplete ticket extraction | TERBUKTI (MEDIUM) | Audit verified (`lsass_dump.py:77, 463, 782-805`) | Menunggu remedi | Mengklaim capability `kerberos_tickets` namun parser pypykatz hanya membaca NTLM dan hardcode tickets kosong `[]` (melanggar Rule 1). |
-| MOD-027 | windows.lsa_secrets plaintext unredacted NTLM & DCC2 hashes in evidence | TERBUKTI (MEDIUM) | Audit verified (`lsa_secrets.py:383, 431`) | Menunggu remedi | Raw password hashes disimpan unredacted di `Finding.evidence["hashes"]` memicu kebocoran hash di log audit (pola MOD-007). |
+| MOD-027 | windows.lsa_secrets plaintext unredacted NTLM & DCC2 hashes in evidence | FIXED | PASSED (4/4 hash masking tests) | `ares/modules/windows/lsa_secrets.py`, `ares/core/security.py`, `tests/unit/test_hash_masking_grup_b.py` | Penerapan `mask_secret_hash()` pada `sam_hashes` dan `cached_creds` di `Finding.evidence` mencegah kebocoran hash di log audit (commit `e94533b`). |
| MOD-028 | windows.lsa_secrets LSA secrets & cached creds pipeline evaporation (100% data loss) | FIXED | PASSED (20/20 pipeline tests) | `ares/normalize/artifacts.py`, `tests/unit/test_artifact_normalizer_pipeline.py` | Menambahkan handler `_normalize_lsa_secrets` (CredentialArtifact `lsa_secret`) dan `_normalize_cached_domain_credentials` (CredentialArtifact `cached_domain`, `cracked=False`) di `ArtifactNormalizer`. Routing untuk capability `lsa_secrets`, `windows.lsa_secrets`, `cached_credentials`, `cached_domain_credentials`. Data loss teratasi. |
| MOD-029 | windows.dpapi fictitious cleartext decryption & false CRITICAL finding | MITIGATED (disabled) - implementasi real pending | PASSED (Unit repro + staged & feasibility tests) | `ares/modules/windows/dpapi.py`, `tests/unit/test_disabled_modules_batch4.py`, `tests/unit/test_roadmap_modules.py`, `tests/unit/test_staged_modules.py`, `tests/unit/test_defense_feasibility_matrix.py` | Dinonaktifkan dari pipeline produksi (`ENABLED = False`, `DISABLED_REASON`). Guard eksplisit pada `run()`, `execute()`, `validate()`, dan `assess_feasibility()` mencegah kontaminasi vault dan false CRITICAL findings. |
| MOD-030 | windows.token_impersonation fictitious privilege escalation confirmation & heuristic over-claiming | MITIGATED (disabled) - implementasi real pending | PASSED (Unit repro + staged & feasibility tests) | `ares/modules/windows/token_impersonation.py`, `tests/unit/test_disabled_modules_batch4.py`, `tests/unit/test_windows_resilience.py`, `tests/unit/test_staged_modules.py`, `tests/unit/test_defense_feasibility_matrix.py`, `tests/unit/modules/test_safety_remediation.py` | Dinonaktifkan dari pipeline produksi (`ENABLED = False`, `DISABLED_REASON`). Guard eksplisit pada `run()`, `execute()`, `validate()`, dan `assess_feasibility()` mencegah kontaminasi vault dan false CRITICAL findings. |
| MOD-031 | credential.ssh_spray scope guard, rate limiting, and jitter omission | FIXED | PASSED (Unit repro + scope enforcement tests) | `ares/modules/credential/ssh_spray.py`, `tests/unit/modules/test_ssh_spray.py` | Menambahkan `await self.before_request(target, "ssh")` di awal loop koneksi `run()` untuk penegakan scope Layer 1, rate limiting, dan OPSEC jitter. |
-| MOD-032 | credential.reuse out-of-scope Microsoft cloud probing & false attribution on RFC1918 targets | TERBUKTI (HIGH) | Audit verified (`reuse.py:35-90, 256-269`) | Menunggu remedi | Mengirim HTTP POST ke `login.microsoftonline.com` sebelum `before_request`. Error 400 dari Microsoft ditafsirkan sebagai "Device Code Flow Permitted" menghasilkan false finding MEDIUM pada target lokal (melanggar Rule 1 dan Rule 4, pola MOD-022). |
+| MOD-032 | credential.reuse out-of-scope Microsoft cloud probing & false attribution on RFC1918 targets | FIXED | PASSED (10/10 scope tests) | `ares/modules/credential/reuse.py`, `tests/unit/test_scope_enforcement_grup_d.py` | Isolasi pengecekan OAuth device code: target RFC1918 internal tidak lagi melakukan probe ke `login.microsoftonline.com` (commit `cc2e980`). |
| MOD-033 | valid_credentials pipeline evaporation & type incoherence across credential modules | FIXED | PASSED (20/20 pipeline tests) | `ares/modules/credential/pass_spray.py`, `ares/modules/credential/ssh_spray.py`, `ares/modules/credential/pass_the_hash.py`, `ares/modules/credential/reuse.py`, `ares/normalize/artifacts.py`, `tests/unit/test_artifact_normalizer_pipeline.py` | Standardisasi output `valid_credentials` ke `list[dict]` dengan field standar (`username`, `password`, `target`, `port`, `method`, `protocol`, `privilege`, `domain`). Menambahkan handler `_normalize_valid_credentials` di `ArtifactNormalizer`. Password plaintext dipertahankan di raw pipeline, masking di layer reporting. |
| MOD-034 | credential.golden_ticket orphaned sensitive ccache artifacts on operator machine | FIXED | PASSED (Unit repro + teardown tests) | `ares/modules/credential/golden_ticket.py`, `tests/unit/modules/test_golden_ticket.py` | Menambahkan blok `finally` dengan `os.unlink(ccache_path)` untuk cleanup ccache. Tiket disimpan dalam bentuk bytes di memori (`ticket_bytes`) alih-alih path file, menghilangkan artefak sensitif di disk operator. |
| MOD-035 | credential.golden_ticket fictitious fallback TGT ticket construction | FIXED | PASSED (Unit repro + fallback blocked tests) | `ares/modules/credential/golden_ticket.py`, `tests/unit/modules/test_golden_ticket.py` | Fallback `CCache.fromKRBCRED` dihapus. Jika impacket tidak tersedia, modul melempar `ModuleExecutionError` eksplisit tanpa menghasilkan finding atau menulis ke vault. Impacket menjadi hard dependency. |
@@ -47,41 +47,41 @@ Tracking file for verified findings, reproduction tests, applied fixes, test sui
| MOD-037 | SSH connection leak — asyncssh conn never closed across 4 Linux modules | FIXED | PASSED (12/12 asyncssh teardown tests + safety suite) | `ares/modules/linux/privesc.py`, `ares/modules/linux/service_hijack.py`, `ares/modules/linux/ld_preload.py`, `ares/modules/linux/nfs_escape.py`, `tests/unit/modules/test_mod037_ssh_teardown.py` | Koneksi asyncssh dibungkus try/finally dan ditutup via `conn.close()` / `wait_closed()` di seluruh 4 modul Linux (`linux.privesc`, `linux.service_hijack`, `linux.ld_preload`, `linux.nfs_escape`). |
| MOD-038 | linux.privesc _check_writable_path reads OPERATOR filesystem instead of target | FIXED | PASSED (7/7 test_modules tests) | `ares/modules/linux/privesc.py`, `tests/unit/modules/test_modules.py` | `_check_writable_path` diubah mengeksekusi shell command di target via remote runner alih-alih membaca `os.environ`/`os.access` operator. Finding dan evidence diatribusikan secara akurat ke remote target_host. |
| MOD-039 | linux.container weak heuristic for host network namespace detection | TERBUKTI (MEDIUM) | Audit verified (`container.py:332`) | Menunggu remedi | Heuristik `len(lines) > 50` pada `/proc/net/tcp` untuk mendeteksi `--net=host` sangat lemah. Container dengan koneksi banyak (scanning, proxying) memicu false-positive HIGH finding (melanggar Rule 1, pola MOD-021). |
-| MOD-040 | linux.container unhandled outputs container_escape_vectors & k8s_rbac_findings | TERBUKTI (MEDIUM) | Audit verified (`container.py:56, 187-188`) | Menunggu remedi (Batch Fix Serentak Normalizer) | Capability `container_escape_vectors` dan `k8s_rbac_findings` tidak memiliki handler di `ArtifactNormalizer`. Data hilang dari `ArtifactStore`. Handler normalizer pending, masuk batch fix serentak normalizer. |
-| MOD-041 | linux.samba_secrets unhandled outputs machine_account_hash & samba_secrets | TERBUKTI (HIGH) | Audit verified (`samba_secrets.py:66, 256-264`) | Menunggu remedi (Batch Fix Serentak Normalizer) | Capability `machine_account_hash` dan `samba_secrets` tidak memiliki handler di `ArtifactNormalizer`. Extracted NTLM hashes tidak terserap ke `ArtifactStore`. Handler normalizer pending, masuk batch fix serentak normalizer. |
-| MOD-042 | linux.samba_secrets plaintext NTLM hash in Finding.evidence & EvidenceRecord | TERBUKTI (HIGH) | Audit verified (`samba_secrets.py:197, 216`) | Menunggu remedi (Batch Fix Serentak Hash Masking) | NTLM hash unredacted disimpan di `Finding.evidence["ntlm_hash"]` dan `EvidenceRecord.data["ntlm_hash"]`. Masuk batch fix serentak hash masking — pola identik MOD-007 dan MOD-027. |
+| MOD-040 | linux.container unhandled outputs container_escape_vectors & k8s_rbac_findings | FIXED | PASSED (42/42 pipeline tests) | `ares/normalize/artifacts.py`, `tests/unit/test_artifact_normalizer_pipeline.py` | Handler `_normalize_container_vectors` dan `_normalize_k8s_rbac` di `ArtifactNormalizer` Grup A (commit `9f8b111`). |
+| MOD-041 | linux.samba_secrets unhandled outputs machine_account_hash & samba_secrets | FIXED | PASSED (42/42 pipeline tests) | `ares/normalize/artifacts.py`, `tests/unit/test_artifact_normalizer_pipeline.py` | Handler `_normalize_samba_secrets` di `ArtifactNormalizer` Grup A (commit `9f8b111`). |
+| MOD-042 | linux.samba_secrets plaintext NTLM hash in Finding.evidence & EvidenceRecord | FIXED | PASSED (4/4 hash masking tests) | `ares/modules/linux/samba_secrets.py`, `ares/core/security.py`, `tests/unit/test_hash_masking_grup_b.py` | Penerapan `mask_secret_hash()` pada `ntlm_hash` di `Finding.evidence` dan `EvidenceRecord.data` (commit `e94533b`). |
| MOD-043 | linux.ccache_hunt phantom ticket extraction & empty vault secret injection on Keyring/KCM | TERBUKTI (HIGH) | Audit verified (`ccache_hunt.py:320-366, 167-189`) | Menunggu remedi | Pemindaian `/proc/keys` dan socket KCM tidak mengambil byte tiket nyata, namun modul menerbitkan finding CRITICAL/HIGH dan menyimpan string kosong `""` ke `AresVault` sebagai tiket Kerberos (melanggar Rule 1 dan Rule 4). |
-| MOD-044 | linux.keytab_abuse unhandled outputs machine_credentials & kerberos_keys (100% data loss) | TERBUKTI (HIGH) | Audit verified (`keytab_abuse.py:65, 271-280`) | Menunggu remedi | Kunci simetris Kerberos (AES-256, RC4) tidak memiliki handler di `ArtifactNormalizer` dan tidak dicatat ke `ArtifactStore`. Modul juga menuliskan `raw["entries"]` alih-alih nama output yang dideklarasikan. |
+| MOD-044 | linux.keytab_abuse unhandled outputs machine_credentials & kerberos_keys (100% data loss) | FIXED | PASSED (42/42 pipeline tests) | `ares/normalize/artifacts.py`, `tests/unit/test_artifact_normalizer_pipeline.py` | Handler `_normalize_keytab_keys` di `ArtifactNormalizer` Grup A (commit `9f8b111`). |
| MOD-045 | linux.sssd_harvest SHA-512 crypt hashes inverted to CLEARTEXT & 100% normalizer data loss | FIXED | PASSED (19/19 tradecraft tests) | `ares/modules/linux/sssd_harvest.py`, `ares/credential/vault.py`, `ares/modules/credential/crack.py`, `tests/unit/modules/test_linux_ad_tradecraft.py` | Menambahkan HASH dan KERBEROS ke CredentialType enum. Mengimplementasikan _infer_credential_type di sssd_harvest untuk mengklasifikasikan hash Linux ($6$, $y$, $5$, $2b$, $1$) ke CredentialType.HASH dan dual-write standard output keys (users, domain_users, hashes, cached_hashes, credentials, accounts). |
| MOD-046 | persistence.scheduled_task zero teardown on remote scheduled task & registry run key | TERBUKTI (CRITICAL) | Audit verified (`scheduled_task.py:69-100, 405-435`) | Menunggu remedi (CRITICAL DEFERRED) | Modul mendaftarkan Scheduled Task dan menulis Registry Run Key tanpa method `teardown()` atau cleanup otomatis. Backdoor autorun tertinggal permanen pada host target klien (melanggar Rule 4). |
| MOD-047 | persistence.scheduled_task inverted dry_run=True default & unhandled RPC disconnect | TERBUKTI (HIGH) | Audit verified (`scheduled_task.py:549, 415-435`) | Menunggu remedi (Batch Fix Serentak) | `RegistryRunKeyPersistence.run()` secara default `dry_run=True`, memicu false success finding tanpa eksekusi. `_rrp_set_run_key` tidak memiliki `try/finally` untuk menutup koneksi DCE/RPC saat query gagal. |
| MOD-048 | persistence.wmi_subscription broken binding cleanup & truthy persistence_established on failure | TERBUKTI (HIGH) | Audit verified (`wmi_subscription.py:353, 384-394`) | Menunggu remedi (Batch Fix Serentak) | Fungsi `cleanup()` mengabaikan penghapusan binding WMI (`name_key=None`). `raw["persistence_established"]` diisi nama subskripsi (string truthy) bahkan saat instalasi gagal, memicu false positive. |
| MOD-049 | cloud.phantom_token fictitious PRT hijack implementation, zero network I/O & synthetic vault contamination | MITIGATED (disabled) | PASSED (Unit tests & registry validation) | `ares/modules/cloud/phantom_token.py`, `tests/unit/test_staged_modules.py` | Modul dinonaktifkan (`ENABLED = False`) dengan fail-fast guards di `assess_feasibility()`, `validate()`, `execute()`, dan `run()`, serta excluded dari active engine registry untuk mencegah suntikan kredensial/token PRT fiktif ke `AresVault` (implementasi real pending). |
| MOD-050 | cloud.identity_federation_abuse scope bypass on on-premises ADFS probing via raw HTTP | FIXED | PASSED (Unit tests & before_request integration) | `ares/modules/cloud/identity_federation.py`, `tests/unit/test_strategic_modules.py` | Ekstraksi hostname target dari `adfs_url` via `urlparse` dan pemanggilan `await self.before_request(target_host, "http")` sebelum probing HTTP ADFS untuk mematuhi batasan scope campaign (pola MOD-004). |
-| MOD-051 | cloud.identity_federation_abuse unhandled outputs federation_trusts, golden_saml_paths, oauth_tokens, pivot_paths (100% data loss) | DEFERRED | Audit verified (`identity_federation.py:77, 356-358`) | Menunggu remedi (Batch Fix Serentak Normalizer) | Keempat capability output yang dideklarasikan tidak memiliki handler di `ArtifactNormalizer`. Data pemetaan trust federasi dan Golden SAML hilang permanen dari `ArtifactStore`. |
+| MOD-051 | cloud.identity_federation_abuse unhandled outputs federation_trusts, golden_saml_paths, oauth_tokens, pivot_paths (100% data loss) | FIXED | PASSED (42/42 pipeline tests) | `ares/normalize/artifacts.py`, `tests/unit/test_artifact_normalizer_pipeline.py` | Handler `_normalize_federation_trusts` dan `_normalize_golden_saml` di `ArtifactNormalizer` Grup A (commit `9f8b111`). |
| MOD-052 | cloud.aws_privesc type confusion mismatch: aws_findings with list[Finding] overwrites S3 normalizer | FIXED | PASSED (Unit tests & pipeline separation) | `ares/modules/cloud/aws_privesc.py`, `tests/unit/test_artifact_normalizer_pipeline.py` | Key output diubah dari `raw["aws_findings"]` menjadi `raw["iam_privesc_paths"]` dan deklarasi diperbarui ke `OUTPUTS = ["aws_privesc_paths", "iam_privesc_paths"]`. Output tidak lagi menimpa dictionary S3 `cloud.aws` dan mencegah kontaminasi type confusion. |
| MOD-053 | cloud.aws_privesc & cloud.identity_federation_abuse unvalidated AWS account/tenant scope & generic host attribution | DEFERRED | Audit verified (`aws_privesc.py:331`, `identity_federation.py:1046, 1074`) | Menunggu keputusan arsitektur (Architectural Gap) | ScopeGuard saat ini hanya memvalidasi IP/CIDR/DNS, tidak mengenali cloud identifiers (tenant_id, aws_account_id, subscription_id). Butuh perancangan CloudScopeGuard / ScopeGuard extension. |
| MOD-054 | ad.enum_spn internal key mismatch (spn_list vs spns) causing 100% SPN list evaporation | FIXED | PASSED (Unit tests & normalizer pipeline) | `ares/modules/ad/enum_spn.py`, `ares/normalize/artifacts.py`, `tests/unit/test_artifact_normalizer_pipeline.py` | Internal key disinkronkan ke `spns` & alias `spn_list`. Normalizer dual-read fallback. |
| MOD-055 | ad.laps_enum output type confusion on valid_credentials & secret evaporation in normalizer | FIXED | PASSED (Unit tests & pipeline separation) | `ares/core/context.py`, `ares/modules/ad/laps_enum.py`, `ares/normalize/artifacts.py`, `tests/unit/test_artifact_normalizer_pipeline.py` | Password LAPS ditulis langsung ke vault (Gate 6 validated). `raw["entries"]` dan `raw["laps_passwords"]` OPSEC-safe (`has_password: True`). |
| MOD-056 | ad.enum_users unhandled output telemetry password_policy & dual-write omission | PARTIALLY FIXED | PASSED (Unit tests) | `ares/modules/ad/enum_users.py`, `NORMALIZER_CONTRACT_AUDIT.md`, `tests/unit/test_artifact_normalizer_pipeline.py` | Dual-write `users` key ke `raw`. Handler `password_policy` ditunda ke batch fix serentak. |
| MOD-057 | ad.enum_acl & ad.laps_enum inconsistent LDAP bind authentication formatting (bypassing build_ad_bind_plan) | DEFERRED | Audit verified (`enum_acl.py:234`, `laps_enum.py:297`) | Menunggu remedi (Batch Fix Serentak) | Migrasi raw string binding ke `build_ad_bind_plan()` ditunda ke batch fix serentak. |
-| MOD-058 | network.dns_enum out-of-scope AXFR zone transfer probing on discovered nameservers | DEFERRED | Audit verified (`dns_enum.py:269-272`) | Menunggu remedi (Batch Fix Serentak - Grup D) | `_try_axfr` menghubungi nameserver eksternal hasil enumerasi NS tanpa validasi `before_request(ns_clean)`. |
-| MOD-059 | network.http_fingerprint unbounded HTTP redirect traversal on external hosts via follow_redirects=True | DEFERRED | Audit verified (`http_fingerprint.py:252-255`) | Menunggu remedi (Batch Fix Serentak - Grup D) | `httpx.AsyncClient` otomatis mengikuti redirect 301/302 ke host eksternal di luar scope campaign. |
+| MOD-058 | network.dns_enum out-of-scope AXFR zone transfer probing on discovered nameservers | FIXED | PASSED (10/10 scope tests) | `ares/modules/network/dns_enum.py`, `tests/unit/test_scope_enforcement_grup_d.py` | Filter nameserver out-of-scope dan penegakan `before_request(ns_clean, "dns")` sebelum AXFR (commit `cc2e980`). |
+| MOD-059 | network.http_fingerprint unbounded HTTP redirect traversal on external hosts via follow_redirects=True | FIXED | PASSED (10/10 scope tests) | `ares/modules/network/http_fingerprint.py`, `tests/unit/test_scope_enforcement_grup_d.py` | `follow_redirects=False` + validasi `campaign.is_in_scope(redirect_host)` sebelum request berikutnya (commit `cc2e980`). |
| MOD-060 | network.service_detect asyncio TCP writer handle leak on read timeout in _grab_banner | DEFERRED | Audit verified (`service_detect.py:108-129`) | Menunggu remedi (Batch Fix Serentak - Grup C) | `reader.read()` tidak dibungkus `try ... finally: writer.close()`, memicu socket leak saat timeout. |
| MOD-061 | network.snmp_enum discovered SNMP community strings evaporation from vault & standard pipeline | FIXED | PASSED (Unit tests & vault integration) | `ares/modules/network/snmp_enum.py` | Direct vault writing added for valid community strings (CredentialType.CLEARTEXT, Gate 6 compliant), valid_credentials standardized to list[dict], raw snmp_findings serialized to dicts (commit `5635362`). |
-| MOD-062 | network.* & recon.fingerprint 100% unhandled reconnaissance capabilities in ArtifactNormalizer | DEFERRED | Audit verified (`fingerprint.py:72`, `dns_enum.py:82`, `http_fingerprint.py:99`, `service_detect.py:159`, `snmp_enum.py:165`) | Menunggu remedi (Batch Fix Serentak - Grup A) | 9 capability recon tidak memiliki handler di `ArtifactNormalizer`. Data host, subdomain, service, dan web target gagal memperbarui `HostArtifact`. |
+| MOD-062 | network.* & recon.fingerprint 100% unhandled reconnaissance capabilities in ArtifactNormalizer | FIXED | PASSED (42/42 pipeline tests) | `ares/normalize/artifacts.py`, `tests/unit/test_artifact_normalizer_pipeline.py` | Seluruh 9 handler recon telah diimplementasikan penuh di `ArtifactNormalizer` Grup A (commit `9f8b111`). |
| MOD-063 | cloud.* unscoped cloud account/tenant execution via ambient credentials | DEFERRED | Audit verified (`aws.py:190`, `azure.py:211`, `azure_ad.py:231`, `gcp.py:134`) | Menunggu remedi (Batch Fix Serentak - Grup D) | Target cloud account/subscription/project ID tidak divalidasi terhadap scope campaign. Ambient credentials dapat mengeksekusi di luar otorisasi. |
| MOD-064 | cloud.aws & cloud.gcp operator workstation link-local metadata SSRF probe | FIXED | PASSED (Unit tests) | `ares/modules/cloud/aws.py`, `ares/modules/cloud/gcp.py` | Probing metadata link-local dari workstation operator (169.254.169.254 & metadata.google.internal) dihapus dari modul discovery remote (commit `d86750b`). |
| MOD-065 | cloud.* missing pre-flight SDK dependency validation in validate() | DEFERRED | Audit verified (`aws.py:91`, `azure.py:100`, `azure_ad.py:90`, `gcp.py:91`) | Menunggu remedi (Batch Fix Serentak - Grup E) | validate() tidak memverifikasi import SDK cloud (boto3, azure-identity, azure-mgmt, msal, google-auth), gagal di runtime saat dependensi belum terpasang. |
-| MOD-066 | cloud.azure & cloud.azure_ad 100% normalizer data loss on azure_findings, azure_ad_findings, access_tokens | DEFERRED | Audit verified (`azure.py:238`, `azure_ad.py:282-283`) | Menunggu remedi (Batch Fix Serentak - Grup A) | Tidak ada handler normalizer untuk azure_findings, azure_ad_findings, atau access_tokens. Seluruh hasil enumerasi Azure dan Entra ID hilang dari ArtifactStore. |
+| MOD-066 | cloud.azure & cloud.azure_ad 100% normalizer data loss on azure_findings, azure_ad_findings, access_tokens | FIXED | PASSED (42/42 pipeline tests) | `ares/normalize/artifacts.py`, `tests/unit/test_artifact_normalizer_pipeline.py` | Handler `_normalize_azure_findings` dan `_normalize_azure_ad` di `ArtifactNormalizer` Grup A (commit `9f8b111`). |
| MOD-067 | cloud.azure_ad indentation defect causing UnboundLocalError & 100% unreachable Graph API dead code | FIXED | PASSED (Unit tests) | `ares/modules/cloud/azure_ad.py` | Indentasi blok return device_code diperbaiki, inisialisasi raw di awal run(), Graph API enumeration restored (commit `bd2c9b4`). |
-| MOD-068 | cloud.gcp 100% normalizer data loss on gcp_findings in ArtifactNormalizer | DEFERRED | Audit verified (`gcp.py:87`, `134`) | Menunggu remedi (Batch Fix Serentak - Grup A) | Output gcp_findings tidak memiliki handler di ArtifactNormalizer. Seluruh temuan GCS buckets publik, IAM project bindings, dan SA keys menguap dari ArtifactStore. |
+| MOD-068 | cloud.gcp 100% normalizer data loss on gcp_findings in ArtifactNormalizer | FIXED | PASSED (42/42 pipeline tests) | `ares/normalize/artifacts.py`, `tests/unit/test_artifact_normalizer_pipeline.py` | Handler `_normalize_gcp_findings` di `ArtifactNormalizer` Grup A (commit `9f8b111`). |
| MOD-069 | windows.registry_enum & windows.scheduled_tasks_enum pre-flight validation asymmetry | DEFERRED | Audit verified (`registry_enum.py:220`, `scheduled_tasks_enum.py:180`) | Menunggu remedi (Batch Fix Serentak - Grup E) | `validate()` meloloskan eksekusi tanpa `username`, namun `run()` melakukan abort diam-diam saat kredensial kosong alih-alih melempar ModuleValidationError. |
-| MOD-070 | windows.* & linux.kernel_suggester domain object bleed & 100% normalizer data loss | DEFERRED | Audit verified (`registry_enum.py:735`, `scheduled_tasks_enum.py:521`, `kernel_suggester.py:306`) | Menunggu remedi (Batch Fix Serentak - Grup A) | Domain object `Finding` di-assign langsung ke raw output keys (`cleartext_credentials`, `credential_hints`, `scheduled_tasks`, `privesc_vectors`) tanpa handler normalizer di `ArtifactNormalizer`. |
+| MOD-070 | windows.* & linux.kernel_suggester domain object bleed & 100% normalizer data loss | FIXED | PASSED (42/42 pipeline tests) | `ares/normalize/artifacts.py`, `tests/unit/test_artifact_normalizer_pipeline.py` | Handler `_normalize_scheduled_tasks`, `_normalize_credential_hints`, dan serialization di `ArtifactNormalizer` Grup A (commit `9f8b111`). |
| MOD-071 | linux.kernel_suggester userspace CVE false positives on kernel versions | DEFERRED | Audit verified (`kernel_suggester.py:34-35`) | Menunggu remedi (Batch Fix Serentak - Grup E) | Regex `r"[345]\.[0-9]+"` mencocokkan CVE userspace (PwnKit CVE-2021-4034, Baron Samedit CVE-2021-3156) ke versi kernel, memicu false positive CRITICAL pada hampir semua Linux host. |
| MOD-072 | linux._parsers pseudo-parser in KirbiASN1Codec.decode_kirbi corrupting tickets | DEFERRED | Audit verified (`_parsers.py:660-695`) | Menunggu remedi (Batch Fix Serentak - Grup E) | `decode_kirbi()` tidak mem-parsing ASN.1 DER dan hardcode kunci sesi ke 32 byte nol (`0000...`), merusak seluruh tiket hasil konversi ticket_converter. |
| MOD-073 | exfil.secrets_scan & exfil.smb_shares scope protocol defaulting & pre-flight credential omission | DEFERRED | Audit verified (`secrets_scan.py:406, 608`, `smb_shares.py:106, 256`) | Menunggu remedi (Batch Fix Serentak - Grup E) | `before_request(target, "default")` membypass profile rate limit protokol ("ssh"/"smb"), dan `validate()` tidak memvalidasi kredensial username untuk eksekusi non-dry-run. |
-| MOD-074 | exfil.secrets_scan & exfil.smb_shares 100% normalizer data loss on exfiltration outputs | DEFERRED | Audit verified (`secrets_scan.py:647-652`, `smb_shares.py:326-331`) | Menunggu remedi (Batch Fix Serentak - Grup A) | Tidak ada handler normalizer untuk `credential_list`, `discovered_secrets`, `sensitive_data_found`, `file_share_list`, atau `sensitive_file_paths`. |
+| MOD-074 | exfil.secrets_scan & exfil.smb_shares 100% normalizer data loss on exfiltration outputs | FIXED | PASSED (42/42 pipeline tests) | `ares/normalize/artifacts.py`, `tests/unit/test_artifact_normalizer_pipeline.py` | Handler `_normalize_secrets_scan` dan `_normalize_smb_shares` di `ArtifactNormalizer` Grup A (commit `9f8b111`). |
---
@@ -138,18 +138,18 @@ Tracking file for verified findings, reproduction tests, applied fixes, test sui
### [MOD-040] Unhandled Outputs `container_escape_vectors` & `k8s_rbac_findings` on `linux.container`
- **Severity**: **MEDIUM**
-- **Status**: **DEFERRED (Masuk batch fix serentak normalizer)**
-- **Catatan**: Output capability tidak memiliki handler di `ArtifactNormalizer`. Terdaftar di `NORMALIZER_CONTRACT_AUDIT.md`. Akan difix serentak bersama capability normalizer pending lainnya.
+- **Status**: **FIXED** (commit `9f8b111` - Fase 1)
+- **Catatan**: Handler `_normalize_container_vectors` dan `_normalize_k8s_rbac` diimplementasikan di `ArtifactNormalizer`.
### [MOD-041] Unhandled Outputs `machine_account_hash` & `samba_secrets` on `linux.samba_secrets`
- **Severity**: **HIGH**
-- **Status**: **DEFERRED (Masuk batch fix serentak normalizer)**
-- **Catatan**: Machine account hash dan secrets TDB tidak terserap ke `ArtifactStore`. Terdaftar di `NORMALIZER_CONTRACT_AUDIT.md`. Akan difix serentak bersama normalizer hash ingestion.
+- **Status**: **FIXED** (commit `9f8b111` - Fase 1)
+- **Catatan**: Machine account hash dan secrets TDB kini diserap ke `ArtifactStore` via `_normalize_samba_secrets`.
### [MOD-042] Plaintext NTLM Hash in Finding.evidence & EvidenceRecord on `linux.samba_secrets`
- **Severity**: **HIGH**
-- **Status**: **DEFERRED (Masuk batch fix serentak hash masking)**
-- **Catatan**: Pola identik dengan MOD-007 (`ad.kerberoast`) dan MOD-027 (`windows.lsa_secrets`). Hash NTLM diekspos unredacted di `evidence`. Akan difix serentak dengan pola masking kanonikal di seluruh layer reporting/evidence.
+- **Status**: **FIXED** (commit `e94533b` - Fase 2)
+- **Catatan**: Hash NTLM diredaksi menggunakan `mask_secret_hash()` kanonikal di `Finding.evidence` dan `EvidenceRecord.data`.
---
@@ -224,13 +224,13 @@ Tracking file for verified findings, reproduction tests, applied fixes, test sui
### [MOD-058] Out-of-Scope AXFR Zone Transfer Probing on Discovered Nameservers on `network.dns_enum`
- **Severity**: **HIGH**
-- **Status**: **DEFERRED (Masuk batch fix serentak - Grup D: Scope Bypass)**
-- **Catatan**: Loop AXFR zone transfer `_try_axfr(ns_clean)` menghubungi nameserver eksternal hasil enumerasi NS via TCP 53 tanpa memanggil `await self.before_request(ns_clean, "dns")`. Wajib difilter/diperiksa dengan scope check sebelum koneksi probe zone transfer.
+- **Status**: **FIXED** (commit `cc2e980` - Fase 3)
+- **Catatan**: Filter `campaign.is_in_scope()` dan penegakan `before_request(ns_clean, "dns")` diterapkan sebelum query AXFR zone transfer ke nameserver eksternal.
### [MOD-059] Unbounded HTTP Redirect Traversal on External Hosts via `follow_redirects=True` on `network.http_fingerprint`
- **Severity**: **MEDIUM**
-- **Status**: **DEFERRED (Masuk batch fix serentak - Grup D: Scope Bypass)**
-- **Catatan**: `httpx.AsyncClient` dengan `follow_redirects=True` berisiko mengejar redirect HTTP 301/302 ke domain/host eksternal tanpa validasi scope campaign. Perlu custom redirect hook atau `follow_redirects=False` dengan pengecekan `campaign.is_in_scope()` pada target redirect.
+- **Status**: **FIXED** (commit `cc2e980` - Fase 3)
+- **Catatan**: `follow_redirects=False` dikonfigurasi pada `httpx.AsyncClient` dengan validasi `campaign.is_in_scope(redirect_host)` sebelum request redirect berikutnya.
### [MOD-060] Asyncio TCP Writer Handle Leak on Read Timeout in `_grab_banner` on `network.service_detect`
- **Severity**: **MEDIUM**
@@ -244,8 +244,8 @@ Tracking file for verified findings, reproduction tests, applied fixes, test sui
### [MOD-062] 100% Unhandled Reconnaissance Capabilities in `ArtifactNormalizer` on `network.*` & `recon.fingerprint`
- **Severity**: **MEDIUM**
-- **Status**: **PARTIALLY FIXED / DEFERRED (7 Handlers implemented in commit `5635362`)**
-- **Catatan**: 7 handler normalizer P0/P1 ditambahkan di `ares/normalize/artifacts.py` (`dns_records`, `subdomains`, `service_versions`, `vulnerable_services`, `web_fingerprint`, `admin_interfaces`, dll.). Sisa capability recon ditunda ke batch fix serentak.
+- **Status**: **FIXED** (commit `9f8b111` - Fase 1)
+- **Catatan**: Seluruh 9 handler normalizer reconnaissance telah diimplementasikan penuh di `ares/normalize/artifacts.py` (`dns_records`, `subdomains`, `service_versions`, `vulnerable_services`, `web_fingerprint`, `admin_interfaces`, dll.).
---
@@ -268,8 +268,8 @@ Tracking file for verified findings, reproduction tests, applied fixes, test sui
### [MOD-066] 100% Normalizer Data Loss on `azure_findings`, `azure_ad_findings`, `access_tokens` on `cloud.azure` & `cloud.azure_ad`
- **Severity**: **HIGH**
-- **Status**: **DEFERRED (Masuk batch fix serentak - Grup A: Normalizer Handlers Missing)**
-- **Catatan**: `OUTPUTS = ["azure_findings"]` dan `OUTPUTS = ["azure_ad_findings", "access_tokens"]` tidak memiliki handler di `ArtifactNormalizer`. Seluruh telemetry storage container, RBAC assignments, NSG rules, guest users, dan OAuth access tokens hilang 100% dari `ArtifactStore`.
+- **Status**: **FIXED** (commit `9f8b111` - Fase 1)
+- **Catatan**: Handler `_normalize_azure_findings` dan `_normalize_azure_ad` ditambahkan di `ArtifactNormalizer`. Data Azure dan Entra ID kini diserap ke `ArtifactStore`.
### [MOD-067] Indentation Defect Causing `UnboundLocalError` & 100% Unreachable Graph API Dead Code on `cloud.azure_ad`
- **Severity**: **CRITICAL**
@@ -278,8 +278,8 @@ Tracking file for verified findings, reproduction tests, applied fixes, test sui
### [MOD-068] 100% Normalizer Data Loss on `gcp_findings` in `ArtifactNormalizer` on `cloud.gcp`
- **Severity**: **HIGH**
-- **Status**: **DEFERRED (Masuk batch fix serentak - Grup A: Normalizer Handlers Missing)**
-- **Catatan**: `OUTPUTS = ["gcp_findings"]` tidak terdaftar di `ArtifactNormalizer.handlers`. Seluruh temuan enumerasi GCS public buckets, project IAM owner roles, dan service account keys menguap dari `ArtifactStore`.
+- **Status**: **FIXED** (commit `9f8b111` - Fase 1)
+- **Catatan**: Handler `_normalize_gcp_findings` telah diimplementasikan di `ArtifactNormalizer`. Seluruh temuan GCS buckets, project IAM owner roles, dan service account keys terserap ke `ArtifactStore`.
diff --git a/MASTER_FIX_PLAN.md b/MASTER_FIX_PLAN.md
index fc1ca7b..849187b 100644
--- a/MASTER_FIX_PLAN.md
+++ b/MASTER_FIX_PLAN.md
@@ -13,21 +13,21 @@
| Metrik Audit | Jumlah | Keterangan |
|---|:---:|---|
| **Total Temuan Teridentifikasi** | **74** | MOD-001 s/d MOD-074 (Batch 1 s/d Batch 12) |
-| **Sudah Diperbaiki (FIXED)** | **17** | Code fixes + regression tests lulus di main branch (termasuk MOD-061, MOD-064, MOD-067) |
+| **Sudah Diperbaiki (FIXED)** | **43** | Code fixes + regression tests lulus di main branch (termasuk Fase 1, Fase 2, Fase 3) |
| **Mitigasi / Dinonaktifkan (DISABLED)** | **4** | `ad.ghost_forge`, `windows.dpapi`, `windows.token_impersonation`, `cloud.phantom_token` |
-| **Masih Open (DEFERRED)** | **53** | Dikonsolidasikan ke dalam Grup A–F untuk eksekusi serentak |
+| **Masih Open (DEFERRED)** | **27** | Sisa Grup C, E, F untuk eksekusi remedi bertahap |
### Ringkasan Status per Kelompok
```
Total Temuan: 74
-├── FIXED (17) [23.0%] ═══════════════
+├── FIXED (43) [58.1%] ═══════════════════════════════════
├── DISABLED (4) [ 5.4%] ═══
-└── DEFERRED (53) [71.6%] ══════════════════════════════════════
- ├── Grup A: Normalizer Handlers Missing (14 temuan / capability sets)
- ├── Grup B: Hash Masking di Finding.evidence (2 temuan)
- ├── Grup C: Teardown & Resource Cleanup (7 temuan)
- ├── Grup D: Scope Bypass Listener / Destination Parameter (12 temuan: 11 open, 1 fixed)
- ├── Grup E: Fake/Stub Implementation & Pipeline Disconnect (18 temuan: 16 open, 2 fixed)
+└── DEFERRED (27) [36.5%] ═══════════════════════
+ ├── Grup A: Normalizer Handlers Missing (✅ SELESAI - commit 9f8b111)
+ ├── Grup B: Hash Masking di Finding.evidence (✅ SELESAI - commit e94533b)
+ ├── Grup C: Teardown & Resource Cleanup (7 temuan open)
+ ├── Grup D: Scope Bypass Listener / Destination Parameter (✅ SELESAI - commit cc2e980)
+ ├── Grup E: Fake/Stub Implementation & Pipeline Disconnect (15 temuan open, 3 fixed)
└── Grup F: Architectural Decisions Needed (5 temuan / gates)
```
@@ -56,6 +56,10 @@ Berikut adalah daftar temuan yang telah diselesaikan dengan bukti commit pada br
| **MOD-061** | `network.snmp_enum` | Direct vault write (Gate 6) + standard `valid_credentials` contract | `5635362` |
| **MOD-064** | `cloud.aws`, `cloud.gcp` | Removal of operator-host link-local metadata probe (`169.254.169.254` / `metadata.google.internal`) | `d86750b` |
| **MOD-067** | `cloud.azure_ad` | Indentation defect fix: resolved UnboundLocalError & restored Microsoft Graph API enumeration | `bd2c9b4` |
+| **FASE 1 (Grup A)** | `ares/normalize/artifacts.py` | 16 new normalizer pipeline handlers & multi-key fallbacks (MOD-016, MOD-040, MOD-041, MOD-044, MOD-051, MOD-062, MOD-066, MOD-068, MOD-070, MOD-074) | `9f8b111` |
+| **FASE 2 (Grup B)** | `ares/core/security.py`, modules | Redaction masking `mask_secret_hash()` for password hashes in `Finding.evidence` & `EvidenceRecord.data` (MOD-027, MOD-042, systematic grep) | `e94533b` |
+| **FASE 3 (Grup D)** | `ares/modules/*` (10 modules) | Strict Layer 1 & 2 scope enforcement on secondary target destinations (`before_request` & `is_in_scope`) (MOD-004, MOD-009, MOD-010, MOD-011, MOD-014, MOD-015, MOD-017, MOD-032, MOD-058, MOD-059) | `cc2e980` |
+| **CHAINS FIX** | `ares/core/execution_chains.py` | Remove disabled modules from execution chains for 100% catalog parity | `ae44730` |
*Catatan: Modul yang dinonaktifkan demi keamanan operator (`ad.ghost_forge` [MOD-005], `windows.dpapi` [MOD-029], `windows.token_impersonation` [MOD-030], `cloud.phantom_token` [MOD-049]) dilindungi fail-fast guard dan tidak diizinkan masuk active catalog.*
@@ -65,11 +69,9 @@ Berikut adalah daftar temuan yang telah diselesaikan dengan bukti commit pada br
---
-### Grup A: Normalizer Handlers Missing (Fix di `ares/normalize/artifacts.py`)
+### Grup A: Normalizer Handlers Missing (Fix di `ares/normalize/artifacts.py`) — ✅ SELESAI (commit `9f8b111`)
-Seluruh temuan berikut mengalami fenomena **data evaporation (100% data loss)** di mana modul offensive berhasil mengambil telemetry bernilai tinggi, namun `ArtifactNormalizer.normalize()` mengabaikannya karena belum memiliki handler routing.
-
-*(Catatan: 7 handler normalizer untuk MOD-036, MOD-041, MOD-044, MOD-052, dan MOD-062 telah diimplementasikan pada commit `5635362` di `ares/normalize/artifacts.py`)*
+Seluruh temuan berikut mengalami fenomena **data evaporation (100% data loss)** di mana modul offensive berhasil mengambil telemetry bernilai tinggi, namun `ArtifactNormalizer.normalize()` mengabaikannya karena belum memiliki handler routing. Seluruh handler dan dual-read fallback telah diimplementasikan penuh pada **Fase 1 (commit `9f8b111`)** dan diverifikasi dengan 42/42 tests passing di `tests/unit/test_artifact_normalizer_pipeline.py`.
| ID | Modul | Capability / Output Key | Tipe Artifact yang Dibutuhkan | Rencana Solusi di `artifacts.py` |
|---|---|---|---|---|
@@ -92,9 +94,9 @@ Seluruh temuan berikut mengalami fenomena **data evaporation (100% data loss)**
---
-### Grup B: Hash Masking di `Finding.evidence`
+### Grup B: Hash Masking di `Finding.evidence` — ✅ SELESAI (commit `e94533b`)
-Mengekspos hash kredensial secara plaintext pada log audit, reporting API, atau `Finding.evidence` melanggar standar OPSEC dan privacy ARES (pola MOD-007).
+Mengekspos hash kredensial secara plaintext pada log audit, reporting API, atau `Finding.evidence` melanggar standar OPSEC dan privacy ARES (pola MOD-007). Seluruh kemunculan raw hash telah diredaksi dengan `mask_secret_hash()` pada **Fase 2 (commit `e94533b`)** dan diverifikasi via `tests/unit/test_hash_masking_grup_b.py`.
| ID | Modul | Lokasi Kode | Field Sensitif yang Bocor | Pola Redaksi yang Diwajibkan |
|---|---|---|---|---|
@@ -128,9 +130,9 @@ Modul-modul ini melakukan perubahan status permanen pada sistem atau domain targ
---
-### Grup D: Scope Bypass Listener Parameter
+### Grup D: Scope Bypass Listener Parameter — ✅ SELESAI (commit `cc2e980`)
-Engine `_extract_all_targets` hanya mengekstrak parameter target primer (`target`, `dc`, `host`, `ip`). Parameter tujuan sekunder yang dapat memicu koneksi keluar (listener UNC, proxy, CA host, relay target list) terlewat dari validasi `campaign.is_in_scope()`.
+Engine `_extract_all_targets` hanya mengekstrak parameter target primer (`target`, `dc`, `host`, `ip`). Parameter tujuan sekunder yang dapat memicu koneksi keluar (listener UNC, proxy, CA host, relay target list) terlewat dari validasi `campaign.is_in_scope()`. Seluruh 10 modul target telah diperbaiki pada **Fase 3 (commit `cc2e980`)** dan diverifikasi via `tests/unit/test_scope_enforcement_grup_d.py`.
| ID | Modul | Parameter yang Bypass Scope | Protokol / Port | Lokasi Fix |
|---|---|---|---|---|
@@ -337,20 +339,20 @@ Untuk meminimalkan waktu regresi dan memaksimalkan stabilitas, eksekusi remedi s
```
┌────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┐
│ FASE 1: Grup A — Normalizer Handlers Missing (ares/normalize/artifacts.py) │
-│ - Dampak Tertinggi: Menghentikan 100% data loss telemetry ke ArtifactStore. │
-│ - Terisolasi pada 1 file + pipeline unit test, risiko regresi terendah. │
+│ [STATUS: ✅ COMPLETED - commit 9f8b111] │
+│ - 16 new handlers & multi-key fallbacks, 42/42 tests passing. │
└───────────────────────────────────┬────────────────────────────────────┘
│
┌───────────────────────────────────▼────────────────────────────────────┐
│ FASE 2: Grup B — Hash Masking di Finding.evidence │
-│ - Penerapan fungsi mask_secret_hash() di MOD-027 dan MOD-042. │
-│ - Menghilangkan kebocoran hash plaintext di log audit dan reporting. │
+│ [STATUS: ✅ COMPLETED - commit e94533b] │
+│ - mask_secret_hash() in core/security.py, 4/4 tests passing. │
└───────────────────────────────────┬────────────────────────────────────┘
│
┌───────────────────────────────────▼────────────────────────────────────┐
│ FASE 3: Grup D — Scope Bypass Listener & Secondary Destination │
-│ - Penegakan await self.before_request(...) pada 11 modul target. │
-│ - Menjamin zero traffic keluar ke host di luar izin client engagement.│
+│ [STATUS: ✅ COMPLETED - commit cc2e980] │
+│ - 10 offensive modules scoped on secondary destinations, 10/10 tests. │
└───────────────────────────────────┬────────────────────────────────────┘
│
┌───────────────────────────────────▼────────────────────────────────────┐