The truly free, open-source, local-first, cross-platform CapCut replacement. Scriptable through a JSON-RPC API & MCP.
Rust ffmpegfree-video-editormodel-context-protocolnon-linear-editoroffline-firstopen-source-video-editorself-hostedvideo-editingvideo-editing-automationvideo-editing-softwarevideo-editing-toolsvideo-editorvoice-cloningyoutube-automationyoutube-shorts
Compare Concat with CapCut and OpenCut in the README
Jareere70aa9d3d345
diff --git a/README.md b/README.mdindex d6c111a7..d71b3ebc 100644--- a/README.md+++ b/README.md@@ -38,6 +38,60 @@ start cutting, no account, no extra downloads, no setup.- 🖥️ Works the same on macOS, Windows and Linux- 🌍 Twelve languages, and a new one is a single JSON file — see [TRANSLATING.md](TRANSLATING.md)+## Concat vs CapCut vs OpenCut++Three editors, three different deals. The short version: CapCut has the most features and the worst terms, OpenCut has the biggest community and the least finished editor, Concat has the best terms and a real native engine, but it is a beta with gaps it has not closed yet. Details below, with nothing hidden.++| | **Concat** | **CapCut** | **OpenCut** |+|---|---|---|---|+| Price | Free, no tiers | Free tier; Standard $9.99/mo, Pro $19.99/mo or $179.99/yr | Free |+| Watermark | Never | On Pro templates and effects unless you pay | Never |+| 4K export | Yes, free | Pro only (free caps at 1080p) | Depends on the browser and machine |+| Source code | Open, AGPL-3.0 | Closed | Open, MIT |+| Who owns your footage | You. Nothing leaves your machine | You grant ByteDance a perpetual, irrevocable, sublicensable licence to anything you upload, including face and voice data (ToS, June 2025) | You. Processed locally |+| Account required | No | Yes, for most features | No |+| Runs as | One native Rust binary, FFmpeg linked in | Native apps plus a heavy cloud dependency | Web app first; desktop and mobile are a 2026 rewrite in progress |+| Rendering | CPU and GPU (wgpu) compositors, same maths in preview and export | Native, GPU accelerated, mature | Browser stack (WebAssembly FFmpeg); slower on long or heavy timelines |+| Auto captions | On device, whisper.cpp compiled in | Cloud, fast, very good, feeds the ToS above | Transcription service, less integrated |+| Text to speech | On device, Kokoro, free | Cloud, many voices, partly behind Pro | Not a headline feature |+| Background removal | Automatic person cutout, brush cleanup, green and blue screen, all on device | Auto, custom brush, chroma key. Best in class | Via a separate Python service |+| Effects and filters | About 80 built in, data driven packages, WGSL shader support | Thousands, plus a marketplace | Basic set |+| Transitions | Basic and motion sets | Hundreds | Basic set |+| Keyframe animation | Not yet, on the roadmap | Yes, mature | Partial |+| Templates | Yes, local | Huge community library | Early |+| Stock music and media | No | Large library (licence terms apply) | No |+| Export formats | MP4 (H.264 + AAC) only | MP4, MOV, GIF, more | MP4, WebM |+| Multiple timelines per project | Yes | No | No |+| Languages | 12, add one with a JSON file | 20+ | Fewer |+| Plugins and scripting | Planned (Concat API, plugin exception in the licence) | No | Editor API, MCP server, plugins |+| Mobile | Android and iOS builds exist, untested | Excellent, where CapCut started | In progress |+| Maturity | Beta, 0.2.1 | Production, hundreds of millions of users | Alpha-grade editor with a very large GitHub following |++### Where Concat wins++- **The deal is clean.** No account, no telemetry, no upload, no watermark, no Pro tier, no licence over your footage. CapCut cannot offer that and OpenCut only matches it in a browser tab.+- **It is a real engine, not a web page.** Decoding, mixing, compositing and encoding happen in one native Rust process with FFmpeg linked in. That is why 4K export, on-device captions, on-device speech and on-device cutouts all work offline on a laptop with nothing installed.+- **Preview and export agree.** One code path draws the monitor and writes the file. What you see is what you get, which is not a given in editors that preview with one stack and export with another.+- **Free 4K and free speech tools.** The two things CapCut charges for most are free here and run locally.+- **Several timelines in one project.** Cut the long video and the three shorts from it in one file.++### Where Concat loses, honestly++- **CapCut has far more content.** Thousands of effects, transitions, stickers, fonts, templates and stock tracks against Concat's few dozen of each. If your workflow is "pick a trending template and swap the clips", CapCut is still the tool.+- **No keyframes yet.** You cannot animate position, scale or an effect parameter over time. This is the biggest missing feature and it is on the roadmap.+- **One export format.** H.264 MP4 with AAC. No MOV, no ProRes, no GIF, no HEVC yet.+- **It is a beta.** Things break. macOS builds are unsigned and need a `xattr` command to open. Mobile builds compile but nobody has tested them properly. Expect rough edges that a product with ByteDance's budget does not have.+- **Speech models download on first use.** Captions and text to speech pull their models the first time you run them. After that they are fully offline, but the first run is not "zero downloads".+- **AGPL is not for everyone.** Concat's code is copyleft. Plugins are exempt (see [LICENSE-EXCEPTIONS.md](LICENSE-EXCEPTIONS.md)) but if you want to embed the engine in a closed product, OpenCut's MIT licence is friendlier.+- **The community is small.** OpenCut has tens of thousands of stars and a developer ecosystem around its Editor API. Concat has a Discord and a handful of contributors. Bugs get fixed, but not at CapCut's pace.+- **Fewer tracked and AI features.** No object tracking, no masks that follow a subject, no auto reframe, no beat sync, no filler word removal. All of these are on the roadmap, none of them ship today.++### Who should pick what++- **Pick CapCut** if you need the template library, the mobile experience, or the latest AI toys, and you are fine with the terms of service.+- **Pick OpenCut** if you want an MIT-licensed editor to build on, or you live in the browser and never edit anything heavy.+- **Pick Concat** if you want CapCut's core workflow, offline, free, with your footage staying yours, and you can live with a beta that is still filling in the long tail.+## Get startedConcat is currently in **Beta version (pre-release)**. **Download** the latest build from [Releases](https://github.com/jub0t/Concat/releases).