Skip to content

AI-powered virtual executive team — a single coherent executive persona backed by 8 specialist agents (FastAPI + Next.js).

fix(integrations): save briefs and digests into the chat-app conversation (#636)

Rufuse500883008ca
diff --git a/packages/core/openexecutive/architecture/architecture-facts.yaml b/packages/core/openexecutive/architecture/architecture-facts.yaml
index 0c408c54..ddbde170 100644
--- a/packages/core/openexecutive/architecture/architecture-facts.yaml
+++ b/packages/core/openexecutive/architecture/architecture-facts.yaml
@@ -8166,6 +8166,16 @@ integrations:
• After a conversation's first exchange it is titled in the
background (utils.session_title, else its first words).
• Threads, email and web chats are never cut.
+ • What the Executive sends into the stream on its own (a brief,
+ the evening digest, a workflow report, a reminder; the
+ scheduler's _send_on_plan) is saved into the current
+ conversation as its message once sent (record_delivery; a held
+ message when it goes out) and counts as activity, so the reply
+ joins it with the message in view. Without this a reply like
+ "can you fix it?" reached a turn with nothing before it.
+ In a chat-app conversation get_recent_history puts a placeholder
+ user turn before history that opens with an assistant message
+ instead of dropping it (web chats still drop it).
• What spans the stream compares base ids: inbound_resolver
(an approval asked before a cut is answered after it) and the
session-scoped decisions/advice in format_for_prompt.
diff --git a/packages/core/openexecutive/architecture/prebuilt/integrations.json b/packages/core/openexecutive/architecture/prebuilt/integrations.json
index c80e0b9c..636fcbb8 100644
--- a/packages/core/openexecutive/architecture/prebuilt/integrations.json
+++ b/packages/core/openexecutive/architecture/prebuilt/integrations.json
@@ -1,7 +1,7 @@
{
"section_id": "integrations",
"title": "Integrations",
- "markdown": "External channels connect callers to the Executive. Each inbound adapter resolves the sender to a Person — the chat adapters via `find_person_by_{slack,discord,telegram}_id`, the email poller via `people.identity.resolve_email_sender` (a primary address or an alias, then the company-domain rule; see Org) — and threads `person_id` into `Executive.chat()`. A sender who resolves to nobody is no longer simply dropped: see **New senders (roster requests)** below.\n\n### Inbound channels\n\n- **Slack** (`integrations.slack_bot`) — async Bolt app (`AsyncApp`) embedded in the lifespan, hearing Slack one of two ways: socket mode (`AsyncSocketModeHandler`, with `SLACK_APP_TOKEN`) or, with only `SLACK_SIGNING_SECRET`, the Events API over HTTP at `POST /webhook/slack` (`integrations.slack_events`), where the route checks each request's signature and age (and a 1 MB cap) before Bolt sees it, so unsigned traffic never reaches Bolt's logging; it then takes each signed request once, answering an identical replay (same signature) or Slack's re-signed retry of an `event_id` it already took with an empty 200 that never reaches Bolt (an in-memory, per-process set kept for twice the signature window and capped in size; keys are forgotten if Bolt fails, so a retry of a failed delivery still runs), and Bolt acknowledges at once while the listener runs. Either way a repeated event id is dropped (Slack resends what it thinks went unacknowledged), as is an event delivered for another workspace. Responds to `@mention`s, DMs, and thread continuations, with per-conversation session memory (see **Conversation state** below). Text only: there is no interactivity endpoint and no Block Kit, so nothing Slack sends carries a button.\n- **Discord** (`integrations.discord_bot`) — discord.py gateway embedded in the lifespan; per-thread auto-titling, session-scoped memory, author attribution, configurable `@mention` thread promotion.\n- **Telegram** — webhook gating + per-chat history. Replies (and every outbound Telegram message) go out as Telegram's HTML subset (`utils.markdown_telegram`: markdown-it-py with raw HTML and images off, text escaped), so the Executive's Markdown shows as formatting; links show as their text and target in plain text and never become tags, so quoted text can't hide where one goes; a chunk Telegram refuses is sent again as plain text.\n- **Google Chat** — webhook + service-account auth. It resolves no approval gates and has no roster gate (the webhook authenticates Google, not the sender), and it never populates the session's trusted alert ids, so `ack_alert`'s trust check — which now runs on every session rather than only those declaring an `origin_channel` — refuses there by default, and its `<channel>` block says plainly that a sign-off cannot be answered from it. It does look its sender up on People by the Google account email on the signed event, but hands that entry only to the department gate (`Session.gate_sender_person_id`): the principal's own sends and edits go, a teammate's meet their department's authority, and anyone else's wait for approval. It is never `caller_person_id`, so it grants nothing else.\n- **Email** (`integrations.email_poller`) — MCP poll loop over the Executive's own mailbox — Gmail via `workspace-mcp` or Outlook via `ms-365-mcp-server`, chosen by `EMAIL_PROVIDER` (see *Workspace providers* below); it starts only once the MCP gateway is up, never surfaces Reply-To redirects, filters auto-replies. Its sessions carry `origin_channel=\"email\"`: the untrusted-content policy (`orchestrator.content_trust`) reads that tag to tell mail from the principal's own surfaces — left empty, as it once was, every stranger's body reached the decision extractor as the principal's words. The mail goes into the turn inside an `<untrusted_content source=\"email\" author=\"<sender>\" author_verified=\"no\">` block that says it carries none of the principal's authority, with the framing line and any `[POLICY]` notice outside it; mail from the principal's primary address that Gmail authenticated (`dmarc=pass`) is their own words — but only their new text goes in unwrapped: when the mail quotes or forwards another message (`_new_text_lines` cut something), the message as received follows in an `<untrusted_content source=\"email_quoted\">` block, since a stranger's text they replied to or passed on is not theirs. While the Executive is paused (`scheduler.pause`) it skips each poll and leaves the inbox unread, so held mail is processed on the first poll after resume; the chat adapters above are not paused. The poller handles one message at a time, so each Executive turn on an email has a deadline, `EMAIL_TURN_TIMEOUT_S` (300 s): past it the turn is cut off, an `integration_inbound` row with outcome `turn_timeout` records it, and the message is marked read and not run again (it may already have replied). A message whose handling keeps raising is given up after three tries in a run and marked read, rather than retried every poll. Each gateway call it makes is bounded by `MCP_TOOL_TIMEOUT_S` (see Lifecycle). The Executive sees the whole message; peer memory records only `_email_memory_text` — the subject, the sender's new text (cut at the first quoted or forwarded message) and the attachment filenames — parsed from the rendered message with any trailing `--- REPLY ---` block dropped first, without backtracking-prone regexes, since the text is sender-controlled, and only for a rostered sender, the only kind with a peer to record into. The poller's `integration_inbound` row keeps the mail's text for the audit log, the way the reply's `chat_turn` row keeps the Executive's answer: `full.message` is the sender's new text (what web chat keeps for a turn), `full.attachments` the attachment filenames, and `details.preview` the first 120 characters of the new text, so /audit shows what was asked next to what was answered (the summary still reads `Inbound email from <sender>: <subject>`). The whole body with its quoted chain (`full.body`) is kept only on a row private to the principal: the chain is other people's mail — a contact's, on the principal's reply to one — and every signed-in user reads a public row. Each field is cut by its escaped JSON length (20,000 characters of text, 8,000 of attachment names), the measure the logger's 64 KB cap uses, so a long mail in a non-Latin script loses its tail rather than the row's structure. Outbound, the principal briefs and the client-rotation digest are emailed through the same gateway with the configured backend's send tool (`google_workspace__send_gmail_message` or `microsoft_365__send-mail`, via `workspace.registry.send_from_executive`, from the Executive's own mailbox to the principal's address, subject `<brief title> — <date>`, the date in the user's zone) as formatted HTML — rendered from the brief's Markdown with raw HTML and images off, so text quoted from outside shows as text and opening the email loads nothing remote. Email is first when the principal prefers it, and otherwise the backup after every chat channel, tried only when Slack, Discord and Telegram are missing or fail; an in-band error from the tool counts as a failed send and the next channel is tried. An emailed brief is not a DM, so the per-Person outbound guard below does not apply — the gateway's roster egress gate does.\n\n Two senders get their own framing. Mail from one of the principal's **contacts** (a `kind=\"contact\"` People row — see Org) replaces the non-roster `[POLICY]` notice with a contact one: it names them (name and role/company), says not to reply unless the principal asks and not to tell anyone else, and asks for a summary in an alert for the principal instead. Mail from anyone not in People, a contact or a stranger, is held as outside content for its whole turn (`orchestrator.outside_content`): no connected-app write, contact change, follow-up, link, script or workflow, no direct message, only reads and an alert private to the principal. Both this turn and the forwarded-by-principal turn below are marked `Session.private_to_principal`: they can email, DM or invite only the principal, an alert they raise is private to the principal, and they are not offered the tools that reach anyone else or start work outside the turn (`schedule_tools.PRIVATE_TURN_WITHHELD_TOOLS`: broadcasts, meeting bookings, workflows, follow-ups, watches, artifacts, goal updates, skill drafts, connecting a new MCP server), and of the MCP tools only Google Workspace reads and the gated Gmail send (see MCP below). Every audit row about such mail is private to the principal (see Audit Log), the poller's two `integration_inbound` rows included (`_private_to_principal_mail`), so the audit log's other readers see none of it. The poller holds `audit.private_rows` for the whole handling of such a mail, because some rows are written before the turn binds its private session: the knowledge retrieval quotes the mail's From line, subject and opening. The rows themselves read exactly like an outside sender's: the `integration_inbound` row is the non-roster one (`accepted_non_roster`), and the notice opens with the non-roster notice's exact sentence. The poller handles each message with no session bound, so one message's private turn never marks the next message's rows. The turn stays unattributed (`person_id` None — no peer memory, no co-presence), and the gateway refuses mail to a contact on a poller turn anyway. Mail **forwarded by the principal** — the sender resolves to the principal and `_new_text_lines` reports a forwarded message — is wrapped in a `<forwarded_by_principal>` block: summarise it, draft a reply the principal could send (as text in the reply, never sent or saved as a Gmail draft), note any commitment or date, and offer to add the original sender as a contact (confirmed from the web app or the principal's Slack / Discord, since an ordinary email turn cannot change the People list — the one email that can is the principal's tokened reply to a roster-request email, which is parsed before any model turn; see below). The reply still goes to the principal only. The From header is unauthenticated, so this framing grants nothing: a spoofed \"forward\" just gets the real principal a summary.\n\n **An email that got no reply goes to Needs you.** Mail from the team or the principal is answered by the model calling the mailbox's send tool, so a turn can end with nothing sent (a tool refused, the answer only written). The gateway marks on the conversation who each accepted send reached (`Session.mail_sent_to`: Gmail `send_gmail_message` to/cc, Outlook `send-mail` recipients; `mail_replied_ids`: the message an Outlook `reply-mail-message` / `reply-all-mail-message` answered). After the turn the poller (`_note_reply_outcome`) checks the sender, by any of their addresses, or the message id; with no reply it files a card through `integrations.unanswered_mail` (source `unanswered_email`, high, tagged `private:principal` and routed to the principal, so only their own /today shows it), whatever the model did. Repeats in the thread fold into it (one card per thread, occurrence count), and a later turn that does reply resolves it. A reply the poller sees is also logged (`unanswered_mail.record_reply`, a private `integration_outbound` row keyed by thread), and the briefs read both: each INBOUND email from the roster says \"the Executive replied\" only on that evidence, or \"no reply went out\" while its card is open (`open_thread_keys`), so the brief stops telling the principal to answer mail the Executive already answered. Only mail Gmail proved is the principal's (`Session.email_authenticated`) reads \"Your email got no reply\" with its subject and what the Executive wrote, which never reached them; a teammate's card names who is waiting and never their subject or text (their conversation is theirs alone); mail that only claims a teammate's or the principal's address says it could not be proven and carries nothing the sender wrote. A plain-text `Error …` tool result is not counted as a send. Contacts and senders off the team are not answered by design and keep their own paths. Why: the brief read the inbound log and said people were waiting while Needs you, which shows alerts only, stayed empty, since an alert depended on the model choosing `create_alert`.\n\n **Other mail sources** (`integrations.mail_sources`). Mail read from anywhere but the Executive's own mailbox (a hosted inbound address, a relay) follows the same rules through a vendor-neutral hook. Nothing is registered by default and the hook has no settings: a deployment registers a `MailSource` (its loop, an `enabled` check, and how to replay a held message), the lifespan starts the enabled ones, and each message goes to `handle_inbound` as an `InboundMail`: the parsed message, the address it came to, `prove_sender` (DMARC, or SPF and DKIM aligned, as the source can tell), `send_answer`, an optional attachment reader and what a held message keeps. `handle_inbound` runs the poller's own handling (`email_poller._handle_mail`): sender resolution, private-to-principal rows, the teammate's own rows only when proven, untrusted-content wrapping, the principal's proven mail, the forwarded-by-principal framing, hydration and the turn deadline. Because a source mails the answer itself (with the AI line, and an `integration_outbound` row) rather than the model calling a send tool, three things differ: a stranger is held for the principal silently, with no acknowledgement and no turn, and replayed through the source that read it (`replay_held_mail` dispatches on the payload's `mail_source`); a contact's mail, and mail claiming a teammate that nothing proves, is answered to the principal and never to the sender; and roster-request and fact confirmations are answered only from the mailbox they were sent from. A source must be registered to be handled, it does nothing while the Executive is paused (`handle_inbound` returns `PAUSED` and the source keeps the message), a stranger the request queue won't take is logged as not held, and a sender who is neither team nor contact by the time the turn runs gets no answer at all.\n\nSlack, Discord, and Telegram are roster-gated on inbound: an unrostered sender's message never reaches the Executive (`details.outcome=\"rejected_unknown_sender\"`). The gates look up **team members only** — a contact's Slack, Discord or Telegram id is treated as unknown, so a contact can never talk to the bot (nor count as a co-present peer). What happens next is the roster request below — except for a contact, a thread continuation, a Telegram group or an unverified Telegram webhook, which stay silent. Email is not inbound-gated — non-roster mail flows through with a `[POLICY]` notice so triage can classify it. Slack/Discord thread continuations pass the shared `integrations.response_gate` (utility-fast model, biased toward replying). Slack only continues a thread it has replied in: it reads the thread with `conversations_replies` (5 s bound) and looks for its own user id, which `auth_test` resolves at startup. If that lookup fails, mentions and DMs still work and thread continuations stop until a retry succeeds (`slack_bot._resolve_bot_user_id`, at most once a minute, from the channel `message` listener). When Slack doesn't return the thread in time, the thread's stored history (`slack:thread:{channel}:{thread_ts}`, written on every turn the bot answers there) stands in: with history, a rostered sender gets an ephemeral \"I couldn't read this thread just now… @-mention me\" and the drop is audited (`outcome=dropped_thread_unreadable`). A thread the bot never answered in stays silent. A message the gate skips is audited (`outcome=skipped_gate`, with the gate's reason) and gets an :eyes: reaction (`reactions_add`, which needs the bot's `reactions:write` scope; without it the reaction is skipped), so a sender the gate misjudged can see the message was read and @-mention the bot.\n\n**No link previews on replies.** The Executive's replies go out with previews off — Telegram `sendMessage` carries `link_preview_options.is_disabled`, Slack's reply `say` passes `unfurl_links=False` / `unfurl_media=False`, and every Discord reply send passes `suppress_embeds=True`. The direct messages the Executive starts are the same: `send_slack_dm` posts with `unfurl_links=False` / `unfurl_media=False`, and Discord's `send_dm` sets the `SUPPRESS_EMBEDS` flag on each chunk, so a reminder or a brief sent by DM carries no preview either. Otherwise the chat service fetches a link in the text on its own, so a reply that quotes someone's mail (Act as me reads it) could carry data to a sender's server with no click. The web chat does the same for images: `Message.tsx` loads only an image the app itself serves (`lib/markdownImages.loadsInline`) and shows any other as a link.\n\n### Alert triage of chat messages\n\nEvery chat-app message that passes the roster gate (Telegram, Slack, Discord, Google Chat) is also handed to alert triage through `alerts.pipeline.schedule_chat_message_evaluation`. The sender is named by their People record (`full_name`), not by the name they typed into the chat app, so a person whose account there is called something else is never read as a stranger; the chat app's own name (or raw user id) is used only when nobody on the roster matched. The principal's own messages to their Executive are a conversation, not news for their brief, so they are not triaged at all. Triage sees the sender as `sender:` and the room as `channel:`. Google Chat's inbound audit row also carries the matched People id (`sender_person_id`), looked up before the row is written, so the brief can tell the principal's own messages apart by id, never by a display name anyone can set.\n\n### New senders (roster requests)\n\nSomeone who writes in and is not on the People list — and is not one of the principal's contacts — is **held, acknowledged and asked about** instead of dropped (`integrations.roster_intake.intake` over the `people.roster_requests` ledger; lifecycle in Org). Each adapter calls it after its gate:\n\n- **Slack** — a DM or an `@mention` (not a thread continuation: the bot was not addressed there). The name and profile email come from `users_info` (5 s timeout). The acknowledgement goes in the DM, or as an **ephemeral** message for a mention, so nobody else in the channel learns who is and is not on the roster. The held event keeps only a fixed set of keys (text, user, channel, ts, thread, files).\n- **Discord** — a DM or a mention (not a thread the bot merely follows). The acknowledgement goes in the DM, or by DM for a channel mention; `/ask` answers the interaction with an ephemeral acknowledgement first (Discord allows 3 s), then holds the prompt. Its old \"ask the admin to add you\" reply is gone.\n- **Telegram** — only a **private** chat, and only when `TELEGRAM_WEBHOOK_SECRET` is set and valid: Telegram identifies the chat rather than the sender, and without the secret anyone could forge an update. A group, or an unverified webhook, stays silent as before. Attachment file ids are held and downloaded only on replay.\n- **Email** — non-roster mail that is not private to the principal (so never a contact's) and does not look machine-sent (`looks_automated`: a no-reply / notifications / billing-style local part, a `List-Id` / `List-Unsubscribe` / `Auto-Submitted` / bulk `Precedence` header, or a DMARC failure). The mail is **still triaged** by the Executive on this pass; its `[POLICY]` notice now says the sender was already told their message is waiting and the principal was asked who they are, so the model raises no second alert just to add them, and that the email will come back once they are added.\n\nEvery path skips a contact first (`find_person_by_*_id(..., include_contacts=True)`, or the email poller's private-mail rule): a contact has no chat access and gets no request and no acknowledgement, and the team-visible `rejected_unknown_sender` / `accepted_non_roster` rows read the same for a contact as for a stranger.\n\n**The acknowledgement** is one fixed text (`roster_intake.ACK_TEXT` — \"your message arrived … waiting for confirmation\"), never the model and never an echo of what they wrote, so a forged sender gains nothing by triggering it. It is sent at most once per sender per `ROSTER_ACK_WINDOW_DAYS` (7) and at most `ROSTER_ACK_DAILY_CAP` (20) a day across all senders (`claim_ack`, one transaction; a failed send releases its claim). An email acknowledgement is the one send the MCP gateway lets reach an address off the roster: `send_email_ack` sets `mcp_gateway.roster_ack_grant`, a one-shot ContextVar grant that admits a single `send_gmail_message` with exactly the granted recipient (a plain string, no list), subject and body and no other key, then is spent (audited `integration_outbound`, `kind: roster_ack`, private). An email sender is acknowledged only when Gmail authenticated them: once `claim_ack` succeeds, the poller's `send_ack` re-reads the mail as raw MIME and needs Gmail's own topmost `Authentication-Results` reporting `dmarc=pass` for the From domain (`fact_confirmation.sender_authenticated`, fail-closed). The printed headers the poller reads never carry that header, so without the second read a forged From would draw the acknowledgement to whoever it names — backscatter from the Executive's mailbox. An unauthenticated sender makes `send_ack` raise `roster_intake.AckWithheld`: the claim is released, and they are held silently. `authenticated_by_gmail` strips quoted strings and comments before reading the verdict — Gmail copies the envelope sender and DKIM tags into its own stamp, and a quoted local part could otherwise carry a fake `dmarc=pass` — and needs exactly one `dmarc=` verdict reading exactly `dmarc=pass header.from=<domain>` (Gmail may follow it with its own `dara=` resinfo, so its position is not checked). A From domain with no DMARC record (no verdict, or `dmarc=none`) passes only on a DKIM signature Gmail verified for exactly that domain, or Google Workspace's default key for it (`<domain-with-hyphens>.<date>.gappssmtp.com`, read back only for a two-label domain without hyphens). SPF alone never counts, since a domain that lists Google's servers passes anyone sending through Google. Mail a list or group resent (`List-Id`, `X-Google-Group-Id`, a Groups `+bnc` envelope) is never proven, since an open group in the domain's own Workspace resends an outsider's forged From under its signature, and a stamp echoing `smtp.helo=` proves nothing. A withheld acknowledgement is audited `roster_ack_withheld`. `intake` acknowledges before surfacing the card and telling the principal, and both follow the request's `ack_sent_at`: a withheld, failed or capped acknowledgement reads \"haven't been told anything yet\" on the Today card, in the principal's prompt and in the email `[POLICY]` notice.\n\n**Telling the principal.** A new request puts a private card on the principal's `/today` (see Today) and pushes a prompt on their delivery plan — preferred chat DM, then the others, then email — for a chat sender or an email sender on the company's own domain; an outside email sender waits on the card, as does everything past `ROSTER_REQUEST_DAILY_CAP` (30) pushes a day (the same cap bounds how many requests open a day; a declined sender is not raised again for 30 days). A chat prompt can be answered in place (\"that's Annamarie, add her to the team\"). An email prompt carries a one-time token (`RR-` + 20 base32 characters, stored hashed); the poller checks every inbound mail for one **before** triage (`try_email_roster_answer`): the reply must come from the principal's primary address exactly (not an alias, not the company-domain rule), carry the token of a pending request, not be an automatic reply, and not fail DMARC where the header is visible; and is parsed by `parse_decision`'s `roster_identity` shape — anything else falls through to the ordinary path. The token is hidden (`RR-[hidden]`) in every other Google Workspace result the gateway returns — the confirmation sits in the Executive's Sent folder, and any turn could otherwise read it — except the poller's own fetch of an inbound message (`mcp_gateway.reveal_roster_tokens`); a token-bearing mail that is not an answer is scrubbed before triage.\n\n**Replay.** Once the principal answers (web card, chat tool, email reply) — or a People-page / `upsert_person` write makes the sender match someone (`after_roster_write`) — the held messages are replayed through the adapter that received them (`register_replayer`: Slack re-runs the held event, Discord and Telegram their held text, email re-fetches the message from Gmail and handles it as mail from a known sender), oldest first, now attributed to the new Person. A teammate gets every held message; a new contact only held email (it takes the private contact path; held chat is dropped); a decline drops everything. Replays run in a **fresh `contextvars.Context`**: the answer may have come from the principal's own verified turn, and a stranger's message must never be read with the principal's session — and their contacts — still bound.\n\n### Standing facts by email (confirm by reply)\n\nThe principal can ask for a standing fact, a retirement or a company-profile edit by email, and the fact tools check it exactly as in chat (the own-words gates run on `_email_memory_text`, the sender's new text, not the quoted chain or attachments). An email's From line proves nothing, though, and a standing fact is read by every later prompt as the principal's own account. So an emailed change is **held, never applied**, until the principal's own mailbox confirms it (`integrations.fact_confirmation`, `memory.facts.fact_confirmations`):\n\n- **Who may ask.** The poller stamps every email turn with `Session.email_from` (the bare lowercased From address) and `email_authenticated`. The text the poller reads never carries `Authentication-Results` (workspace-mcp prints a fixed set of headers), so for mail claiming the principal's primary address it reads the message again as raw MIME (`fact_confirmation.sender_authenticated`) and requires Gmail's own stamp: the **topmost** `Authentication-Results` header (Gmail adds it on receipt, above anything the sender wrote), authserv-id `mx.google.com`, reporting `dmarc=pass` for the From address's domain, with the raw From matching (`authenticated_by_gmail`). It fails closed: no header, `dmarc=none`, a temporary error or a failed read all leave the turn unauthenticated. Mail from a teammate other than the principal is read the same way, before its inbound audit row is written: authenticated, the whole handling of it is theirs alone in the audit log (`rows_for_person`, see Audit) and the turn reads their own mail as them (`Session.email_sender_authenticated`); unauthenticated, it keeps the ordinary rule. Mail from anyone else costs no second read and is never authenticated. `fact_tools._gate` admits an email turn only from the principal's **primary** address, exactly (no alias, no company-domain rule), authenticated, and not private to the principal (mail they forwarded stays refused, as do contacts, teammates and unknown senders).\n- **The hold.** The tool returns `awaiting_confirmation` (no action chip, and the model is told to say nothing has changed). `request_confirmation` stores the change with the SHA-256 of a fresh one-time token (`FC-` + 20 base32 characters, 100 bits; 7-day expiry; at most 10 waiting at once) and emails the token to the principal's roster address, outside any turn's outbound context. A profile edit is dry-run first, so one that cannot apply is reported in the turn, before any email goes out. If the email fails, nothing is held.\n- **Keeping the token from any model.** The tool result never carries it, and `mcp_gateway.hide_roster_tokens` now scrubs `FC-` tokens as well as `RR-` ones (`FC-[hidden]`) from every Google Workspace result except the poller's own fetch of an inbound message. Act as me's reads of the principal's own Gmail, where the confirmation email lands, hide them too (`delegation.gmail.parse_message` and the thread search), so the drafting model never sees a live token either.\n- **The reply.** `_handle_one_email` hands every message to `try_email_fact_confirmation` right after the roster-answer check, before any model turn. It acts only on a reply from the principal's primary address carrying the token of a **pending** confirmation. A made-up, spent, cancelled or expired reference matches nothing and falls through to the ordinary path with the token hidden, so no old or forged token can make the Executive email the principal. A reply with a live token is read again as raw MIME (`read_raw`) and must pass the same Gmail DMARC check as the request; one that doesn't (or whose raw read fails) is refused, the change keeps waiting, and the principal is told. Then an **automatic reply** is consumed quietly — no answer, no model turn, the change keeps waiting: the printed headers catch a Gmail vacation reply (`Precedence: bulk`), and the raw headers catch what they don't show (`automatic_reply`: `Auto-Submitted` other than `no`, `X-Auto-Response-Suppress` and similar, `Precedence: auto_reply`, an out-of-office subject), since an Exchange out-of-office echoes the token from the principal's own address and may well say \"I'll confirm on my return\". The raw message starts at the tool's exact separator line (`\\n\\n--- RAW MIME ---\\n`), so a sender-written Subject imitating it cannot supply the headers. CONFIRM (or yes / approve) applies the change through `fact_tools.apply_confirmed`, the same apply step chat uses. CANCEL (or no) drops it, and an unclear reply leaves it waiting. The principal gets a one-line result either way. A compare-and-set on the row means two replies can apply it only once.\n- **Audit.** Private `fact_confirmation` rows record held / applied / cancelled / refused. The applied change also writes the fact tools' usual private rows, with `source_channel=\"email\"` as its provenance.\n\n### Checking a channel is set up\n\nSettings → Setup status (`GET /setup/status`, `api/setup_checks.py`) gives each channel a light and a plain-language fix. It tests the credentials with one free read-only call — Slack `auth.test`; Telegram `getMe`, then `getWebhookInfo` (is a webhook registered, is it this app's `/webhook/telegram`, did a delivery fail in the past day); Discord `users/@me`, only while the bot is still connecting — and reads what the lifespan left on `app.state`: the Slack socket's `is_connected()`, the Discord bot's `is_ready()` together with its gateway socket being open (discord.py stays ready while it reconnects after a drop), or the exception its task stopped with (`LoginFailure`, `PrivilegedIntentsRequired`), and the MCP gateway. A listening Slack is amber while the listener hasn't resolved its own user id (`slack_bot.bot_user_id()`), since thread continuations are off until it does. Because inbound is roster-gated, a connected Slack, Discord or Telegram is amber while nobody on the roster has its id (`slack_user_id`, `discord_user_id`, `telegram_chat_id`), or when its latest `integration_inbound` row is a `Rejected: …` from the past day whose sender still isn't on the roster — the page shows the sender's id, never message text. Local login with no `TELEGRAM_WEBHOOK_SECRET` is red for Telegram, since the local-login gate turns its webhook away. Google Chat and Gmail are checked from configuration: a numeric project number and a readable service-account key; the OAuth client (or service-account key) the workspace-mcp child signs in with. Gmail is also amber when startup priming could not find every pinned Google tool (`MCPGateway.prime_pinned_tools`, whose result the gateway keeps on `pinned_tools`): the row names a few of the missing tools and counts the rest, and points at the `MCPGateway` log lines. It is amber too while that probe has not finished, and when the probe itself failed — the one check that reads green is the one that ran and found everything, so a crashed probe is never silently fine. The row speaks for the whole `google_workspace` server, so a missing Docs or Drive tool shows up under Email (Gmail).\n\nA channel setting written `KEY= # note` in a `.env` file arrives as the note's text, because python-dotenv strips only a comment that follows a value. `Settings` reads such a value as unset for the Slack, Telegram, Discord and Google Chat credentials, so the line no longer switches a channel on with its own comment as the token. `TELEGRAM_WEBHOOK_SECRET` is the exception, because read as unset a junk secret would turn the webhook's check off. It is kept instead, and since Telegram can only ever send 1–256 of `A-Z a-z 0-9 _ -` (what `setWebhook` accepts), a secret outside that set — a leftover comment, a pasted `<value from Step 2>` — could only be matched by someone who guessed it: while it is set the webhook refuses every update, neither the local-login gate nor the roster tools count it as proof (`Settings.telegram_webhook_secret_valid`), and Setup status shows it red (`.env.example` shipped four such lines; the notes now sit on their own lines).\n\n### Picking people and rooms by name (chat directory)\n\nNobody has to copy a raw Slack, Discord or Telegram id. The person page, Add person and a department's Channels settings pick them by name from what the bots this instance runs can reach (`integrations/chat_directory.py`, served at `GET /chat-directory/people`, `/channels` and `/slack/lookup`, the principal's alone). The id is still what is saved; the by-hand field stays under \"Enter an ID by hand\", and is all there is for a provider with no bot.\n\n- **Slack** — channels from `conversations.list` (public, plus the private ones the bot is in; scopes `channels:read`, `groups:read`, and public only when `groups:read` is missing) and people from `users.list` (no bots, no deactivated accounts; `users:read`, and `users:read.email` for their profile email). A person with a work email is matched by it (`users.lookupByEmail`, after the cached list): the picker pre-selects \"Found by email\" with a \"Not them?\".\n- **Discord** — text and announcement channels of the servers the bot is in (only `DISCORD_GUILD_IDS` when set) and their members over the REST API. Members need the Server Members privileged intent; when Discord refuses, the list is empty with `members_available` false, not an error.\n- **Telegram** — there is no list API, so the webhook records each chat an update comes from in `telegram_chats` (`integrations/telegram_chats.py`): private chats are people, groups and supergroups are rooms. Only a webhook whose `TELEGRAM_WEBHOOK_SECRET` checked out records anything, since without it anyone could post a made-up name for a chat id. A row is a suggestion only and grants nothing: the roster still decides who is answered.\n\nA department's Slack and Discord pickers pre-select the room named most like the department; it is saved only when the person presses Save. Lists are cached in-process for 60 s and capped at 2,000; a provider that fails reads as an empty list. Tokens go only in the Authorization header to the provider's own API host and are never returned.\n\n### Conversation state\n\nEvery adapter keys a deterministic `session_id` off the conversation surface and replays that session's stored turns into `Session.conversation_history`, so a follow-up (\"yes, go ahead\") lands with the question still in context. Slack's ids are `slack:dm:{user}`, `slack:thread:{channel}:{thread_ts}`, and `slack:channel:{channel}:{user}` for a mention that starts a thread; because the bot's reply roots a Slack thread at that message's `ts`, the turn is double-written to that thread's session too, so the first continuation inside it is not cold. A reply inside a thread THAT PERSON ROOTED also offers the parent `slack:channel:{channel}:{user}` id when matching an approval gate, since a gate raised on the mention recorded that session while the answer arrives under the thread's. The root-author check is load-bearing: widening on \"threaded and not a DM\" alone offered one person's channel session inside any thread in that channel, so a remark they made to a colleague could resolve their open gate and post the run's title into that colleague's thread. Discord has the same shape — its auto-thread router promotes a mention reply into a bot-owned thread — and the same alias. An @-mention inside a DM is handled once, by the DM path: Slack fires both events, and taking both forked the conversation across two session ids. The same id is the audit grouping key and the scope passed to `format_for_prompt`. A per-session `asyncio.Lock` serializes turns within one conversation — the inflight semaphore caps fan-out across the workspace, which does nothing to stop two messages in the same thread from both reading history before either writes it. Persistence happens after the reply is sent and its failure is logged, never surfaced: the user already has their answer.\n\n**Conversations within a chat app.** A Telegram chat, a Slack or Discord DM and a person's @mentions in one channel (`slack:channel:…`, `discord:channel:…`) are each one endless stream, so they are cut into conversations (`memory.conversations`, shared helpers in `integrations/conversations.py`). Each adapter computes the stream's base id as before and asks `conversation_for` which conversation a message belongs to: the newest, unless the stream has been quiet for two hours (`CONVERSATION_GAP`), when the next one starts. The first conversation keeps the bare base id; later ones add `~2`, `~3`, … (`memory.conversation_ids`). A whole message of `/new`, \"new chat\" or \"new conversation\" starts a fresh one instead of a turn and is answered with the name of the one it ended; the new row has no messages and stays off the Chats page until its first turn. After a conversation's first exchange `title_after_turn` names it in the background with `utils.chat_topics.name_chat` (the first words of the message if that fails), as a web chat's first turn does: the same call files it under one of its owner's chat topics, so a Telegram or Slack conversation sits beside the web chats about the same matter in the Chats page's Topic view. Threads (`slack:thread:…`, `discord:thread:…`), email and every other id are left whole. What has to see the whole stream compares base ids: the inbound resolver, so an approval asked before a cut is answered after it, and the session-scoped decisions and advice `format_for_prompt` renders. At boot `split_existing_streams` cuts history saved before this by the same rule, once (`app_migrations`), titling each part from its first message and carrying a read-mail lock to every part. An adapter installed outside the package adds its streams with `conversation_ids.register_rolling` and cuts its own old history once, with its own migration name and an `only` filter for its base ids, because the built-in sweep may already have run without it.\n\nThis was absent on Slack until #136. Every message built a fresh `Session` and minted a per-*message* id (`thread_ts` falls back to the message's own `ts`, so a DM never repeated one), which meant a multi-turn confirmation could not work: the Executive asked whether to send a briefing to Slack, the user said yes, and the next turn had no record of the question.\n\n### What the model is told about the channel\n\nChat adapters pass a `<channel>` block (`integrations.channel_context`) in the **user turn** — never a cached system block. It names the surface, states that the person cannot see the app's cards or buttons (except where a chat shows them, below), and draws the line the assistant kept crossing: briefing proposals and alerts are actioned on the briefing page; a proposal that books something can only be approved there; a workflow sign-off the Executive is explicitly waiting on *can* be answered in the conversation.\n\n**Approval cards with buttons (Telegram, Slack and Discord DMs).** In a private Telegram chat on a webhook only Telegram can call (`TELEGRAM_WEBHOOK_SECRET` set and valid; `integrations.channel_cards.shows_cards`), the cards a reply leaves are sent as they are shown under a web chat reply: a meeting to book, a card of actions from `propose_actions`, and a change to a saved workflow (`orchestrator/workflow_change.py`; of the `app_action` cards only those in `decisions.CHAT_APP_ACTIONS`, whose action checks the tapper itself). `Executive.chat(cards=...)` collects their ids from the turn's `action_taken` events; the adapter sends each as a plain-text message with **Approve** and **Skip** inline buttons (`callback_data` `card:<id>:a|s`), and the `<channel>` block tells the model the card is there and that a typed yes does not approve it. A tap arrives as a `callback_query` and is taken only from a private chat whose sender is that chat (`from.id` = chat id), on the verified webhook; the chat's rostered person is the tapper. `api.routes.decisions.resolve_in_chat` applies the web chat's rule (a card of actions is its person's alone; a meeting is the principal's, or its approver's unless it is the principal's private booking), books or carries out the card exactly as stored (`delegation.verified.ChatTap` stands in for the signed-in caller on an action card), or records the skip. The card's message is then edited to show the outcome without buttons. A Slack DM (with `SLACK_CARD_BUTTONS` on, which needs Interactivity turned on in the Slack app and the `im:write` scope) and a Discord DM work the same way. Slack gets Block Kit buttons (`oe_card_approve` / `oe_card_skip`, the callback data as the value, the card as plain text), and a tap counts only when `conversations.open` for the tapper returns that same DM. Discord gets a View whose buttons carry the callback data as `custom_id`, and `on_interaction` takes a tap only in a DM whose recipient is the tapper. Either way the tapper must be on the roster by their app id. Elsewhere (a Slack or Discord channel or thread, Google Chat, a Telegram group, an unverified webhook) no card is sent and `propose_actions` tells the model the card is on Today. The principal's DMs on Slack, Discord and Telegram also receive the open-alert digest (`briefing.context.format_open_alerts_for_prompt`) as the `<briefing>` block, gated to DMs because the board is company-wide and a shared channel must not pull it in. That digest is the ONLY trusted source of an `alert_id` for `ack_alert`. The briefing page's `[Discuss mode — alert_id=N]` primer is a pointer to which item is under discussion, not authority on its own: the server accepts that id only if it is also on the live board it derived itself. An id appearing anywhere else, including inside an alert's own body, is not trusted: alerts are minted from inbound email and chat, so their bodies are attacker-controlled. Two mechanisms enforce that rather than one prompt rule. Every field the digest interpolates is collapsed to a single line, because a newline in an attacker-written headline, suggested action, tag or review note would otherwise forge a whole extra `[N]` line — a fabricated instruction to clear somebody else's alert. And the live board the server derived is recorded on the session, so `ack_alert` refuses any id outside it — on EVERY session, web included; the web previously had no check at all. The recorded set is the whole live board (the cap `/today` renders as cards), not just the rows the digest printed, so a card past the digest's 30-row render cap is still ackable rather than sending the principal back to the page. Be precise about what this buys: it stops an id that is invented, closed, snoozed or expired, including one quoted out of an attacker-written alert body. It does NOT stop the model being argued into acking the wrong LIVE card — one alert's body can still make a case about another id that is genuinely open. Scoping trust to the single item under discussion would need the primer id carried server-side, which it is not.\n\n### Handler failures\n\nAn adapter's catch-all replies \"I encountered an error processing your request.\" On Slack that used to be the whole story — one uncorrelated log line, no audit row, and an unguarded error-send that could itself escape into Bolt. It now logs with the session, sender, channel, thread and mode, and writes an `integration_inbound` row with `details.outcome=\"handler_error\"`, joining the inbound row under the same `session_id`. Upstream, a single crashing tool handler no longer takes the turn down at all: the orchestrator's tool gathers use `return_exceptions=True`, hand the model an error `tool_result`, and audit it with `ok=false` (cancellation is re-raised, not swallowed).\n\n### Attachments\n\n`integrations.attachments` handles web chat, Discord, Telegram, Slack and Google Chat. Images become Anthropic vision blocks; documents (PDF/DOCX/XLSX/TXT/MD/CSV) are inlined into the turn that carried them — inside an `<untrusted_content source=\"attachment\" author=\"<name>\">` block (`content_trust.wrap_untrusted`, whose closing tag the text cannot forge), under an `[Attached: <name>]` label, which the open-loop pass reads as \"not the speaker's words\" and the decision extractor strips before it reads the turn — and indexed into the ChromaDB `inbound_attachments` collection. 20 MB/file cap; web chat uses `POST /chat/upload`.\n\n**Voice notes** are transcribed before the turn, since the model takes no audio. `providers.transcription` calls any OpenAI-compatible `POST {base}/audio/transcriptions` server: `TRANSCRIPTION_BASE_URL` (with `TRANSCRIPTION_API_KEY` / `TRANSCRIPTION_MODEL`) wins, otherwise OpenRouter when `OPENROUTER_API_KEY` is set (`elevenlabs/scribe-v2`), otherwise there is none and a voice note becomes a line asking the sender to type it. Recordings are capped at 25 MB and `TRANSCRIPTION_MAX_SECONDS` (300), the length read on the server from the Ogg, WebM, MP4 or WAV container (`recording_seconds`), since the servers bill by length and the browser's own stop can be skipped; a file whose length can't be read (mp3, flac, aac) is held to 16 KB per allowed second. A file can misstate its own length, so the bound that holds is bytes: at most `TRANSCRIPTION_MAX_MB_PER_DAY` (200) go to the speech server per UTC day, failed calls included. A voice note the sender recorded in the chat app (a Telegram voice or video note, a Discord voice message, a Slack clip; `AttachmentItem.voice_note`) becomes their own words (`[Voice note, transcribed]`; those senders are roster-gated). The reply is the answer alone, with no echo of what was heard. Any other audio (a Telegram audio file, an uploaded recording, anything on Google Chat) may hold someone else's voice, so its words are attachment text, untrusted-wrapped like a document's. An email's audio attachments (up to 2) are transcribed into attachment text, untrusted-wrapped like a document's. Each call writes one usage row (actor `transcription`, with the cost the server reports) and tells any `add_usage_listener` listener. The web chat mic records in the browser and posts to `POST /chat/transcribe`; the words go into the message box to read and send.\n\n**Scanned PDFs** are read, not reported empty. A PDF with no text layer goes through `knowledge.pdf_reader`: with `PDF_PROVIDER_READING=true` (opt-in, off by default) the deployment's own model reads it through its provider's PDF support (Anthropic natively, OpenRouter's `file-parser`, a local server only with `LOCAL_PDF_INPUT`); otherwise, and as the fallback, local OCR (pypdfium2 + RapidOCR, offline, no key) — so every deployment converts them. The label then reads `(converted from scanned pages)`, and an unreadable one says why. The index takes the text already extracted for the turn, so a scan is converted once. A file a channel delivered (everything here except `POST /chat/upload`, where the signed-in user sends it) converts at most `PDF_INBOUND_MAX_PAGES` (30) pages and draws on a rolling `PDF_INBOUND_PAGES_PER_HOUR` (300) budget shared by all senders, so sending scans cannot run up unbounded model spend or CPU.\n\nPer channel:\n- **Slack** — a `file_share` message (previously dropped outright for its `subtype`) is handled like any message; files download only after the roster gate and the response gate, with the bot token sent only to `https://files.slack.com/` (needs the `files:read` scope). History and peer memory record the words plus `(Attached files: …)`, never a document's text.\n- **Google Chat** — uploaded attachments download through `media.download` with the reply credentials (`chat.bot`), checked against the 20 MB cap per chunk, 5 per message; an attachment-only message is no longer dropped. The webhook authenticates Google, not the sender, so files are read only when the event's `user.email` is on the People roster (a team member); anyone else's files are named to the Executive, never downloaded. A Drive file shared into a message is left to the Drive tools, with its id.\n- **Email** — the poller (`integrations.email_attachments`) downloads up to 5 readable attachments of the message itself via `get_gmail_attachment_content` — workspace-mcp in stdio mode saves the file and answers `Saved to: <path>`, which must start its line, be the last such line and end in the answer's `Saved filename:` (the answer echoes the sender-chosen attachment name first, and a name carrying `Saved to: /…` must not redirect the read), then resolve inside the tool download folders — and appends their text to the turn (15k chars each). Image attachments (PNG/JPEG/GIF/WebP) go the same way into vision blocks for the turn: up to 3, none under 10 KB (signature logos, tracking pixels) and none over 3 MB (the model API's 5 MB base64 limit). A registered mail source's `read_attachments` may return images too (`EmailAttachments`). Only for a sender the principal knows (team, contact, principal); a stranger's files stay a list. It runs outside the model loop, so it works on private turns without adding the attachment tool to `PRIVATE_TURN_MCP_TOOLS`.\n- Anything else (a Drive PDF, a skipped attachment) — the Executive's `read_document` tool.\n\nIndexed chunks are keyed on `attachment:<bare filename>` and tagged `type=attachment`. An attachment's name is chosen by whoever sent the message and the name is the chunk-id namespace, so without the prefix an inbound `strategy-2026.md` would upsert over the curated company document of that name. The prefix separates inbound content from curated uploads and keeps provenance visible; it does not separate senders from one another.\n\nIsolation is the **collection**: `retriever.retrieve` never queries `inbound_attachments` at all, so an attachment cannot resurface as company knowledge in a later, unrelated turn. Attachment processing is roster-gated on Discord too — it previously ran before the gate, so an unrostered sender's file was downloaded and indexed before their message was dropped. These rows still have no operator surface: they are never written to `company/docs/`, so `GET /documents` does not list them.\n\nThis replaced a domain-based scheme that did not work. The chunks lived in `company_docs` under a domain outside the specialist set, on the premise that an unrecognised domain matched no filter. It matched every one — `ChromaDBStore.query` attaches a `where` clause only when a domain filter is present, and an Executive-level retrieval passes none — so attachments came back under “From your company documents”, top-ranked and indistinguishable from a curated upload. Legacy rows are migrated across on boot.\n\n### MCP gateway & outbound\n\nMCP runs in **both directions**. As a *client*, `orchestrator.mcp_gateway.MCPGateway` proxies MCP servers (Gmail, Calendar, Drive, Outlook mail and calendar — whatever `mcp_servers.json` configures) as Executive tools, with egress gating on Gmail recipients, Calendar attendees, Drive share grantees, and Microsoft 365 recipients/attendees against the roster (and a refusal of public / whole-domain Drive sharing). The Gmail gate also accepts only a fixed set of argument keys, so workspace-mcp's `reply_all` (recipients taken from the thread, never checked) and `forward_message_id` / `include_forwarded_attachments` (forwarding any inbox message) are refused; a reply is `thread_id` plus an explicit, roster-checked `to`. Three more refusals close paths around those gates: every Apps Script tool (code running as the Executive's account, outside the gates, and since workspace-mcp 1.29.0 schedulable to keep running); any argument that makes the server fetch a URL (`fileUrl` / `file_url` on the Drive and import tools, a Gmail attachment given as a `url`), since the fetch can carry data out in its query string before any recipient gate matters; and text Google would mail to someone the roster never checked (`rsvp_comment` to an event's organizer, an out-of-office `decline_message` to whoever invites the Executive). Every gate reads its arguments by normalized spelling: workspace-mcp 1.29.0 renames a camelCase key such as `Attendees`, `userGoogleEmail` or `rsvpComment` to the real parameter, so a gate matching the exact key would never see it. Arguments that are not a JSON object are refused for the same reason. Google-side fetches are refused too: any key ending in `url` / `uri` at any depth whose value has a URL scheme (a Slides image or page background, a Docs or Forms image; a document hyperlink and a meeting link are stored, not fetched, and pass, as does a Drive file id), (a value is a URL after the characters a URL parser strips are removed, and `//host` counts), and on every tool that can write cells — the Sheets tools and the Drive create / update / import tools, which turn CSV into a Sheet — any string anywhere holding a formula call that fetches (`IMPORTDATA`, `IMPORTXML`, `IMPORTHTML`, `IMPORTFEED`, `IMAGE`), JSON-encoded or mid-CSV included: a string argument that encodes JSON is read as the server decodes it (one too large to read is refused), text is also scanned with character references decoded and comments / CDATA removed, and an upload that would become a native Sheet may only be text `content` — a `base64_content` or server-side `file_path` upload there is refused, since an XLSX hides its formulas behind zip members and XML encodings; a PNG to Drive or a DOCX to Docs is untouched. Not covered, unverified: whether Drive's HTML / Markdown import fetches an `<img src>` when it converts `content` into a Doc. A `manage_event` call that names no attendees is sent with `send_updates=\"none\"`, so the event's existing guests are not emailed text the gate never checked. A delete is sent the same way, except the typed `cancel_calendar_event` of a meeting the Executive booked, which keeps its cancellation notice. Google Docs, Sheets, Slides, Forms and Drive writes run only on files and folders the Executive's own Google account owns (`_check_google_file_write`, read through `get_drive_file_permissions` at call time, fail-closed; only a name starting with a read verb skips it), as OneDrive writes do. Someone added to People in the current turn is left out of the allow-list until the next turn. The allow-list (`_egress_sets`, built by `_roster_allow_set` as a `people.identity.RosterAllow`) is every team member's email and email aliases plus the Executive's own address, always, and — for a teammate — any address on one of the company's own domains whose local part (`+tag` dropped) matches theirs, the same rule inbound mail is matched by; a **contact's** email joins it only when `people_tools.contacts_reachable_now()` is true — a turn the principal started on a verified surface (web chat, their own Slack or Discord, a verified private Telegram chat), or inside `grant_contact_egress()` (the decisions approve route, when the approver is the principal). On any other turn — an inbound email, a teammate, the scheduler, a workflow, the alert review — a contact's address is refused exactly like a stranger's, so the refusal cannot reveal that it belongs to a contact (contacts are private to the principal). The single exception to the roster rule is the fixed roster-request acknowledgement above, under its one-shot `roster_ack_grant`. A turn about the principal's private mail (`Session.private_to_principal`) narrows the list to the principal's own address and the Executive's. Such a turn may call only the MCP tools in `schedule_tools.PRIVATE_TURN_MCP_TOOLS`: Google Workspace reads (`search_gmail_messages`, `get_gmail_message_content`, `get_events`, `list_calendars`, `query_freebusy`, and the Drive, Docs and Sheets reads such as `search_drive_files`, `get_drive_file_content`, `get_doc_content` and `read_sheet_values`) and the two Gmail tools this gate narrows to the principal (`send_gmail_message`, `draft_gmail_message`). It is an exact allow-list, not a server: workspace-mcp runs at the tier `WORKSPACE_MCP_TOOL_TIER` names, `complete` by default, where a Google Chat message to a space, a Docs, Sheets or Drive write into a file already shared with others, `manage_event` on a shared calendar (its gate checks attendees and pins notifications, nothing else) reaches people with no recipient check; and every other server has none at all (a Slack or Notion server, the default `fetch` server, whose URL can carry the turn's content, a server loaded at runtime). Its `search_tools` results show only the allowed tools (`workflows.tool_catalog.filter_search_results`; output it cannot parse reads as no match), and a `call_tool` naming anything else is refused with an error tool_result and an audit row private to the principal (`schedule_tools.private_turn_withholds`), a missing name included. `search_tools` and `call_tool` stay offered, so the tool list and its cached prefix do not change. The typed calendar tool (`_resolve_attendees`) and the chat DM tools (`message_person`, `send_telegram_message`, `send_discord_dm` and their person-id recovery) apply the same rule — a contact's id reads as an unknown one off the principal's turn — and a private turn may DM or invite only the principal (`PRIVATE_TURN_REFUSAL` otherwise); `message_person` never falls back to a \"Needs you\" alert for a contact, who cannot sign in to see it. The Google Workspace server (`workspace-mcp`) behind those Gmail/Calendar/Drive tools runs **co-located inside the API** as a stdio child of the gateway — fitting the single-tenant model (one install = one company = one exec Google account), so there's no separate service to operate. It's baked into the API image and launched by `docker/workspace-mcp-launch.sh`, which selects single-user OAuth (token persisted at `/data/google_credentials`) or service-account domain-wide delegation from `GWORKSPACE_AUTH_MODE`. The optional `WORKSPACE_MCP_TOOLS` (comma-separated service names, default `all`) limits which Google services it loads. The gateway forwards the Google secrets to the child via `_FORWARDED_ENV_VARS`. Every `google_workspace__*` call acts as the Executive's own account. workspace-mcp takes the acting account per call (`user_google_email`) and nothing used to check it, so under domain-wide delegation a model-chosen address could open anyone's mailbox in the domain; `mcp_gateway._check_acting_account` now refuses a value naming any other address — before every other gate, with an `integration_outbound_blocked` audit row. An absent value stays allowed (the server's own account).\n\n**What the model is told is connected.** `MCPGateway.start()` records the configured server names (`server_names`), and the Executive renders them with the channel settings into block 0's *Connected Systems* section (`prompts.connected_systems`; see the caching section). While Google is connected that section pins the Google tool names the Executive uses constantly (`GOOGLE_TOOL_MANIFEST`, narrowed by `connected_systems.google_tool_manifest` to the services and tier actually loaded) and tells it to call them with `call_tool` directly, with no `search_tools` round trip. The narrowing is the point: a name pinned for a service workspace-mcp never imported is not in the index, so the model calls it, receives extensible-mcp's “has not been discovered via search_tools” refusal, and has no way to square that with its own instructions. extensible-mcp only runs a tool one of the session's searches has returned, and remembers it for the session's life, so the gateway does that discovery itself: the lifespan starts `MCPGateway.prime_pinned_tools()` in the background once the gateway is up with `google_workspace` configured (an exact-name search per pinned tool, the way `workflows.tool_catalog.resolve` does it, over the same narrowed set the prompt advertises — `connected_systems.pinned_google_tools`, so priming never probes a service that was not loaded). A name neither the prompt nor priming can account for is logged once, naming both causes: excluded by `WORKSPACE_MCP_TOOLS` / `WORKSPACE_MCP_TOOL_TIER`, or renamed by workspace-mcp since the pin. A pinned call that still comes back with extensible-mcp's \"has not been discovered via search_tools\" refusal, for example before priming finished, is discovered and retried once. That happens after every gate has passed the same arguments, and only for pinned names: any other tool still needs the model's own search, and nothing here widens what a call may do, including the private-turn allow-list.\n\n**Microsoft 365** is the Outlook twin: `@softeria/ms-365-mcp-server` (a Node package, pinned) is installed in a throwaway Node build stage and only the `node` binary plus the package are copied into the API image, launched by `docker/ms365-mcp-launch.sh` as the `microsoft_365` entry with an **explicit tool allow-list** (`--enabled-tools`, an anchored regex) rather than the upstream `mail,calendar` preset — that preset also registers inbox forwarding rules, mailbox settings (external auto-reply), calendar sharing and event forwarding, which can address people the gateway never sees. Exactly the Outlook mail + calendar tools and the OneDrive tools are exposed (`microsoft_365__send-mail`, `microsoft_365__create-calendar-event`, `microsoft_365__search-onedrive-files`, …; hyphenated Graph endpoint aliases, proxied verbatim), and every admitted tool is either roster-gated or carries no recipient; the gate also covers the excluded writers in case an operator widens the list. Both servers can be configured at once. Auth is the MSAL device-code flow against the operator's own Entra app registration (`MS365_MCP_CLIENT_ID` is required; the server's built-in public client is refused); the refresh token persists at `/data/ms365_credentials` and is seeded once with `ms365-mcp-launch.sh --login` from inside the container — the server has a native device-code CLI, so there is no mint script and nothing to copy. The launcher scrubs the literal `$VAR` placeholders extensible-mcp leaves for unset variables (otherwise MSAL would be handed `$MS365_MCP_TENANT_ID` as an authority), and `MS365_MCP_EXPECTED_USERNAME` pins the bound mailbox. The egress gate for this family walks Graph's nested shapes (`body.Message.toRecipients[].emailAddress.address`, `body.attendees[]…`) — every email-shaped string outside the free-text fields must be on the roster, control characters and non-ASCII addresses are refused, unforeseen keys are still scanned (fail-closed) — and covers the whole write surface: send, reply, reply-all, forward, every draft tool, `update-mail-message` (it can PATCH recipients onto a draft) and create-/update-calendar-event; reads pass through. `delete-calendar-event` makes Exchange mail every attendee, so it reads the event and roster-checks the attendees first, except the typed `cancel_calendar_event` of that same event. Graph's reply, reply-all and send-draft actions carry no recipient in their arguments (the recipient is whoever the referenced `messageId` names), so for those the gate first reads the referenced message through the server and roster-checks the recipients Graph will derive (`replyTo` else `from` for a reply; `replyTo` and `from` together, plus the original to/cc, for reply-all; the draft's own to/cc/bcc for send-draft), refusing on any lookup failure; RSVP and cancel actions get the same treatment through an event lookup, because their comment is emailed to the organizer or every attendee; `download-bytes` is pinned to mail attachment bytes and OneDrive file content (`/drives/{id}/items/{id}/content`, optionally Graph's `?format=pdf` rendering), and a OneDrive result comes back as the file's extracted text rather than base64 — the attachment pin is what makes the poller's promise that an unrostered sender cannot be auto-replied to hold on Outlook as it does on Gmail; and the rendered inbound text quotes any forged `--- REPLY ---` line inside a body so the persona only ever reads the real block. Every mail write's `from`, `sender` and `replyTo` may name only the Executive's own address (the Outlook twin of the Gmail acting-account pin), so the model cannot send as a rostered colleague's mailbox or steer replies elsewhere; and `move-mail-message` into Deleted Items, Junk Email or Recoverable Items is refused, so a move cannot trash mail ungated. The server registers its account tools whatever its tool allow-list says, so the gateway itself refuses `login`, `logout`, `select-account` and `remove-account` (audited like any other refusal) and drops them from `search_tools` results — a chat turn cannot sign the mailbox out, switch accounts or start a sign-in; setup is only the launcher's `--login`, and the read-only `verify-login` / `list-accounts` stay callable. The example config's hyphenated patterns still deny `delete-mail-*`, `logout`, `remove-account` and `download-bytes-to-file` as defense in depth. A successful `send-mail` records the same outbound-context linkage Gmail does.\n\n**OneDrive in chat** (opt-in with `MS365_MCP_ONEDRIVE=true` and a fresh `--login`, since the server asks for its tools' permissions on every token refresh and a sign-in without file consent would otherwise fail mail and calendar too) matches what the Executive can do on Google Drive: search, list a folder, read a file, upload and edit, create folders, move, rename, copy and share; there is no delete tool. The launcher adds `Files.Read.All` at sign-in (`--extra-scopes`), so folders shared *with* the Executive can be read too; writes (upload, new folder, move, copy) land only in the Executive's own drives, checked against `list-drives` at call time, so a planted instruction cannot save company files into a stranger's shared folder. Sharing is gated like Drive sharing: `share-drive-item` invitees must be People on the roster and named by email (an `objectId` or `alias` grantee is refused, since nothing can check it), no `owner` role, and `create-drive-item-share-link` must be scoped to specific people (`scope: \"users\"`): an anonymous or whole-organization link, or one with no scope (the tenant default), is refused. An invite must require sign-in and grant only view or edit, a link must be a view or edit link, and `search-onedrive-files` takes plain words only, since its query goes into the request path unencoded. Files Act as me's `save_my_email_attachment` copied from someone's own mail into the Executive's Drive or OneDrive (`delegation.saved_files`) are that person's alone: on any other turn the gateway refuses a call whose arguments name a recorded file id and drops the entries or lines of a result that name one, failing closed for the file tools when the record can't be read. The folders those copies go in are made by the save (never adopted by name) and recorded, and a model call naming one, by id or by an OneDrive path through it, is refused on every turn, the owner's too, with their ids hidden from results. That tool's own calls are the only Drive and OneDrive writes a turn that read the owner's mail may make: built in code, admitted past the lockdown as those exact objects (`code_built_call`), and still checked by every gate above.\n\nAs a *server*, `openexecutive.mcp_server` exposes OE's own company context and specialist council to external MCP clients at `/mcp` — the inverse direction; see the dedicated **MCP Server** section. The gateway launches extensible-mcp as a `uvx` subprocess whose fastembed tool-search index uses an embedding model baked into the API image and loaded offline, so it no longer re-downloads that model from the Hugging Face Hub on every cold start. extensible-mcp is pinned twice over: to a commit, which fixes its own code, and with `--exclude-newer`, which fixes the resolution of its dependencies — without the cutoff uvx re-resolves them against PyPI on every networked start, so a new release of any of them would reach running deployments on restart. Both live in `_EXTENSIBLE_MCP_LAUNCH_ARGS` in `orchestrator/mcp_gateway.py`, the Dockerfile's pre-warm uses the same arguments (a unit test enforces the match), so an image whose pre-warm succeeded starts the gateway with no network. The pre-warm is best-effort (`|| true`): an image built while GitHub was unreachable fetches the pinned commit on its first start instead. Updating the gateway is a deliberate bump of the commit and cutoff; `uv` itself is not pinned. Because the MCP stdio client does not inherit the parent environment, `MCPGateway.start()` explicitly forwards the embedding-cache/offline env vars (`FASTEMBED_CACHE_PATH`, `HF_HUB_OFFLINE`, …) into the child.\n\n**Emailing an artifact.** A Gmail send or draft may carry `attachments=[{\"artifact_id\": \"alert:12\", \"as\"?: \"docx\"}]`. `call_tool` runs the recipient gate first; only if it passes does `_expand_artifact_attachments` replace each such entry with the rendered file (`content` base64 + `filename` + `mime_type`, workspace-mcp's own attachment shape), produced by `artifact_records.render_artifact_file` — the same renderer as `/artifacts/{id}/download`. Only artifact rows resolve (never an arbitrary alert), links have no file, and an entry mixing `artifact_id` with other keys is refused. A stringified or single-object `attachments` is normalised first, so an artifact entry can never reach workspace-mcp unexpanded (it would silently drop it). At most 5 distinct artifacts per email (repeats are dropped) and 15 MB rendered in total; rendering runs off the event loop via `asyncio.to_thread`. A refusal writes `artifact_attachment_refused`; a successful send writes `artifact_attached` — both carry the recipients. Other attachment entries pass through unchanged. The same expansion serves the Microsoft 365 mail writes: the entry becomes a Graph `#microsoft.graph.fileAttachment` (`name`, `contentType`, `contentBytes`) placed where Graph expects it for that tool (`body.Message.attachments` for `send-mail`, reply, forward and the createReply drafts; `body.attachments` for `create-draft-email`), whether the model put it at the top level or inside the message; an entry anywhere else, one on `update-mail-message` or `send-draft-message` (their requests cannot carry attachments), or one behind a body that is not an object is refused rather than forwarded unexpanded.\n\n**Enablement, and why it degrades instead of dying.** `MCP_ENABLED` left unset is inferred from the presence of `mcp_servers_config_path` — dropping an `mcp_servers.json` next to `profile.yaml` turns MCP on with no further configuration. An **explicit** setting always wins in both directions: `MCP_ENABLED=false` keeps MCP off with the file still in place. It did not: `_resolve_mcp` tested `not self.mcp_enabled`, which cannot tell \"never set\" from \"set to false\", so the file's presence silently overrode the operator. The file is probed through `config.mcp_config_file_present`, never `Path.exists` directly — that re-raises an EACCES on a parent directory, and from inside a validator that comes out of `Settings()` itself, which `api/main.py` calls at module level. The check now reads `model_fields_set` (the fields the env actually supplied) and stores that on a private attr behind the read-only `mcp_auto_enabled` property, because the validator's own assignment joins that set and would otherwise make every auto-enable look explicit downstream.\n\nStartup is **best-effort**, in `main._start_mcp_gateway`. Two checks come before the subprocess: MCP off is a no-op, and a config defining no servers under `mcpServers` is logged and skipped — extensible-mcp's own loader raises on that and exits, and because the child is already gone the only thing that surfaces is anyio's \"Attempted to exit cancel scope in a different task\" from `stdio_client` unwinding, a traceback naming nothing about configuration. The start is also bounded (120s, generous because that child may still clone extensible-mcp on a cold start if the image's pre-warm failed): `ClientSession` carries no `read_timeout_seconds`, so `initialize()` waits forever on a child that is *alive but silent*, and an unbounded wait is a lifespan that never yields — the same healthcheck-never-passes symptom, which no `except` can see. A gateway that fails anyway is logged at ERROR with the config path, the servers it named, and whether the config file or an explicit `MCP_ENABLED` turned MCP on, then torn down under its own timeout; the API boots **without MCP tools and without the email poller** rather than refusing to boot. The guard catches `BaseException`, not `Exception`, re-raising a bare `CancelledError` first: the original failure came from anyio, which wraps a task group's failures in `BaseExceptionGroup` as soon as one is a `BaseException` — and that group is not an `Exception`, so `except Exception` would miss the very shape this contains. The teardown is contained too, since it runs from inside that `except` and would otherwise replace the actionable log with the crash it prevents. `configured_server_names` never raises either, and deliberately catches broadly: it reads an operator-owned path during startup, where an exception is the crash loop rather than a bug report — `Path.is_file` re-raises an EACCES on a parent directory, and `json.loads` answers deeply-nested input with `RecursionError`, which is not a `ValueError`. It tests `is_file()` so a directory or a symlink to a FIFO is never opened, and caps the read at 1 MiB. That exception used to propagate out of the lifespan and kill the container — under `restart: unless-stopped`, a crash loop whose only outward symptom was a healthcheck that never passed. Outbound tools: per-Person DMs (`send_slack_dm`, `send_discord_dm`, `send_telegram_message`) plus room-targeted `send_department_message` and `send_company_broadcast`. All three per-Person DMs refuse a recipient id that matches no non-archived Person row (`schedule_tools._dm_recipient_on_roster`), which is what stops untrusted content in a turn — inbound mail, a chat message, a knowledge document — from directing a DM at an arbitrary workspace member. `send_slack_dm` previously consulted the roster only when the turn was already private to the principal, so on an ordinary turn it applied no roster check at all while its Discord and Telegram siblings did; the room-targeted tools are deliberately ungated, since those channels are team-visible. The per-Person DMs are additionally rate-limited and de-duplicated by the outbound anti-spam guard (below).\n\n### Outbound anti-spam guard\n\nEvery per-Person DM passes a deterministic guard (`orchestrator.outbound_guard.check_outbound_allowed`) after the roster gate and recipient-id recovery but before the network send — the single chokepoint **all** proactive DM paths reach (ad-hoc chat sends, the scheduler's followup/nudge dispatch, principal-brief delivery, the reflection turn, and research-finding routing). On a violation it returns a human-readable reason and the handler **suppresses** the send (`{\"status\":\"suppressed\",\"reason\":…}`), writes a `tool_invocation` audit row with `suppressed=true`, and writes **no** `done` activity row — so a blocked attempt never counts toward its own rate cap, and the Executive can read the reason and hold or `schedule_followup` for the recipient's next window. Three controls: **content dedup** (a near-identical message — whitespace/case-normalized, first 160 chars — already sent to the same recipient within `OUTBOUND_DEDUP_WINDOW_MINUTES`, default 360); a **per-recipient rate cap** (`OUTBOUND_MAX_PER_RECIPIENT_PER_WINDOW`, default 5, over `OUTBOUND_RATE_WINDOW_MINUTES`, default 60); and **quiet hours / availability** (`OUTBOUND_RESPECT_QUIET_HOURS`, default on — refuse while the recipient is on leave or outside their `people.channel` availability windows, surfacing the next open window). Delivery history is read from the existing `status='done'` `scheduled_actions` rows (`episodic.recent_sends_for_channel_ref`), so there is no new table. The guard is **fail-open**: any internal lookup error returns \"allow\", so it can never turn a working send into a crash or a silently-dropped message. Principal briefs and the internal heartbeat kinds use the `__internal__` channel and never reach these handlers, so they are unaffected. Once the guard allows a send, the handlers apply the recipient's own notification settings to the Executive's own (tagged) outreach: in their quiet hours, or when they chose *In my briefs*, the DM is stored and returned as `{\"status\":\"held\"}` rather than sent, and goes when quiet hours end or with their next brief (`outbound_guard.check_hold`; see Org).\n\n### AI disclosure\n\nWhat the Executive sends says it is an AI assistant (`orchestrator.disclosure`), added by plain code so a reply the model writes can't leave it out. **Mail** from its own mailbox gets a line under the body, by default \"<EXEC_DISPLAY_NAME> is an AI assistant working for <company>. To reach a person, reply and ask, or write to <principal's address>.\": the MCP gateway adds it to every Gmail send and draft and every Outlook send, reply, forward and draft (`mcp_gateway._with_disclosure`) **after** every outbound gate has passed and only on what goes to the server, so the gates, the outbound-context record and the audit see the model's own words, and `send_from_executive` gets it the same way. It counts as already there only when it is the last line that shows (in a quoted earlier message or hidden in markup it doesn't), and a send of an existing draft and mail whose every recipient is the principal go as they are. HTML that could hide what follows (an unclosed comment, a style or script block, text styled out of sight: `disclosure.hides_what_follows`) is refused, so the line can't be hidden after it; the model is told to send plain text. The roster acknowledgement to a new sender, the one send to an address nobody checked, gets `BARE_MAIL_LINE` (\"This message was sent by an AI assistant.\"), which names no one, like the acknowledgement itself. **Chat** gets a shorter line (\"<name> · AI assistant\", in italics) on the Executive's replies in Slack, Telegram, Discord and Google Chat and on its own DMs and room posts (`send_slack_dm`, `send_discord_dm`, `send_telegram_message`, `broadcast_tools._dispatch`), but only on the first message in a conversation and again after 24 hours without one (`with_chat_line`, kept in memory, so a restart shows it once more); session history keeps the reply without it. `AI_DISCLOSURE` (default on) turns it off; `AI_DISCLOSURE_MAIL_TEXT` / `AI_DISCLOSURE_CHAT_TEXT` reword the lines, and a wording that doesn't say \"AI\" is ignored for the built-in one. It fails open: a line that can't be built is left off, never a send refused. Replies sent *as a person* under Act as me are the delegation section's (**AI line on replies**).\n\n### Calendar & video links\n\nThe Executive books meetings through two typed tools over the configured calendar backend (`CALENDAR_PROVIDER`: Google Calendar via `manage_event`, or Outlook via `create-calendar-event` — see *Workspace providers*). `create_calendar_event` schedules a **future** meeting (propose→approve by default, or auto-execute once that decision class is promoted) and may be used proactively when a stalled goal warrants a sync. `create_instant_meeting` spins up an **impromptu call starting now**, auto-executing without the approval step and skipping the business-hours/horizon caps, so the Executive can hand back a join link immediately. Because nothing approves it, an instant meeting, and `cancel_calendar_event` too, runs only when someone on the team asked on a surface that verified who they are (the principal, or a rostered teammate in the app or their own chat); a turn an inbound email started gets a refusal to pass on instead, and a team-mode `create_calendar_event` the operations department would auto-execute is proposed instead. Both attach a video-meeting link by default (`add_video_link`; opt out for in-person) — a **Google Meet** link read from `manage_event`'s plain-text reply (which also carries the event id, inside the event link's `eid`), or a **Microsoft Teams** link from `onlineMeeting.joinUrl` — surfaced to the caller plus persisted on the decision ledger as `meet_link`. The tool descriptions are static, backend-neutral text, so the cached tool block never depends on settings; the pre-rename `add_google_meet` key is still honoured for old ledger rows. Either way the caps that matter still hold — roster membership, principal-protection, max attendees, and a daily booking ceiling. A proposal raised in the web chat by the person who approves it (the principal, or its approver when it isn't the principal's private booking) says `approve_here`; its `action_taken` chip then carries the `decision_id`, and the chat shows the approval card (Approve, Edit, Dismiss) under the reply as well as on the briefing — answering either clears both. A booked meeting whose event id was never read can't be cancelled from the app: both cancel paths refuse rather than report a cancel that left it on the calendar.\n\n**Around-the-meeting participation.** The Executive doesn't join the call as a live voice; instead, on every successful booking it schedules a best-effort post-meeting follow-up (~5 min after the end) that DMs a human attendee asking for a quick recap — key decisions and action items. The reply flows back through the same cross-session DM context linkage described below, so the Executive can act on it (summarize, follow up) in a later turn. No meeting-transcript or Drive integration is required.\n\n### Workspace providers\n\nThe Executive can *discover* any mail or calendar tool the gateway exposes, but three code paths call a fixed backend with no model in the loop and used to spell Gmail tool names inline: the inbound mailbox poller (list unread → fetch → mark read), alert email dispatch plus the scheduler's email send-tool hint, and the typed booking tools plus the approval-time conflict check. `integrations.workspace` puts those behind two Protocols (`MailProvider`, `CalendarProvider`) with one module per backend (`google.py`, `microsoft.py`) and a registry keyed on `EMAIL_PROVIDER` / `CALENDAR_PROVIDER` — separate switches (Outlook mail with a Google calendar is legitimate), both defaulting to `google`, so an existing install changes nothing until an operator opts in. The Google backend is the old inline code moved verbatim; tests pin its argument dicts byte-for-byte. The Microsoft backend polls only the Inbox folder (`list-mail-folder-messages` with `isRead eq false`, never the all-folders listing that includes Junk), converts Graph's HTML bodies to text with a real parser, lists a message's attachments so the names appear in the same `N. name (mime, size KB)` shape Gmail's text uses (and reach peer memory), marks read with `update-mail-message`, sends through `send-mail`'s nested shape, books with `isOnlineMeeting` + `onlineMeetingProvider=teamsForBusiness`, cancels with `delete-calendar-event`, and answers the advisory conflict check from the Executive's **own** calendar view (delegated permissions cannot read attendees' free/busy — narrower than Google's `query_freebusy`).\n\nEvery backend renders an inbound message into the same `Subject:` / `From:` / `To:` / `Cc:` + `--- BODY ---` text the persona already expects, and the poller adds a `--- REPLY ---` block naming the exact reply tool and threading ids for *that* message (Gmail: `send_gmail_message` + `thread_id`; Outlook: `reply-mail-message` + `messageId`) after the mail's `<untrusted_content>` block, never inside it. The block rides in the user turn — which is what lets the cached persona say \"use the reply tool in the REPLY block\" instead of naming a vendor tool — and the scheduler's proactive-email trigger names the backend's send tool the same way. Providers never raise on a malformed backend response (they return empty / `None` / `{\"error\": …}`), so one bad cycle never kills a loop, and a chosen backend whose MCP server is missing from `mcp_servers.json` is logged at startup and skipped by the poller: fail-soft, never a boot failure. The poller's newer checks run on that rendered text for both backends (contacts and private turns, roster requests and their emailed answers, the audit row), with three Outlook differences that fail closed: a sender is authenticated from Exchange's own stamp instead of Gmail's (`fact_confirmation.sender_authenticated` reads the message's Graph `internetMessageHeaders` and applies `delegation.outlook.exchange_authenticated`: the topmost `Authentication-Results` with EOP's `compauth=`, a DMARC pass for the From domain, or for a domain with no DMARC record a single DKIM pass with `header.d=` that domain, and never mail a list resent or a stamp echoing `smtp.helo=`; it relies on Exchange Online stamping every message, so a tenant whose mail arrives through another server without that stamp gets no real proof), but there is no acknowledgement to an unknown sender (the one-shot grant admits only Gmail's send tool); attachments stay a list (the download is Gmail's); and the brief's calendar block is skipped (its listing is Google Calendar's). The code's own emails to the principal (roster prompts, fact confirmations, scheduled deliveries) go through `workspace.registry.send_from_executive`, and `runner.email_ready` follows `EMAIL_PROVIDER`. A private turn's allow-list (`schedule_tools.PRIVATE_TURN_MCP_TOOLS`) and Act as me's mail-touched reads include the Outlook twins of the Gmail and Calendar tools, and roster answer tokens are hidden from Microsoft 365 results as from Google's.\n\n### Cross-session DM context\n\nWhen the principal says \"DM Alex about X\" in one session, OE sends the DM and — if a live conversation is active and the recipient is not one of the principal's contacts (a contact cannot DM the bot, and quoting the principal's conversation into their email reply's unattended turn would put it in the audit log) — records an `outbound_context` linkage row (recipient, full outbound text, originating session id). Email is covered too but recorded one layer deeper — there is no `send_email` tool, so the linkage is written in `orchestrator.mcp_gateway` after a successful `google_workspace__send_gmail_message` or `microsoft_365__send-mail`, one row per `to`/`cc` recipient keyed by the bare lowercased address (OE's own address skipped). When Alex later replies on the 1:1 DM path — or by email — the shared helper `integrations.inbound_hydration.hydrate_user_message` (called by the Discord, Telegram, and Slack handlers, and by the email poller keyed on the sender address) looks up the most-recent `open` linkage for that sender within 72h and prepends an `<outbound_reply_context>` block — the outbound text plus a backstory excerpt from the originating session — to the message handed to `Executive.chat()`. So OE knows what the reply is about instead of starting from an empty per-person session. The block is context for the LLM turn only: peer memory strips it before recording what the person said (`strip_outbound_reply_context`, applied in `sync_turn`, `sync_department_turn` and to the prefetch query), so the Executive's own DM is never attributed to the person who replied to it. The block lands in the user turn (caching rule) and is injected into a copy only — the pristine reply is persisted to history. The linkage is one-shot (consumed on first matched reply, race-safe) so an unrelated later DM isn't re-hydrated. This is deterministic and independent of the per-person `peer_memory` (Honcho) layer.\n\nEvery adapter that persists a turn (Slack, Discord, Telegram, and the web route) records the message's **resolved sender** on `chat_messages.sender_person_id` — the rostered Person the adapter matched, or NULL for an unrostered sender — independently of the session owner, which falls back to the principal on Discord and Telegram so those threads stay visible. Attunement's open loops and feedback rely on this so an outsider's words are never read as someone on the roster's.\n\n### OneDrive folder sync\n\nThe Microsoft twin of the Drive folder sync below (`knowledge.onedrive_sync`, `ONEDRIVE_SYNC_ENABLED`; setup in `docs/onedrive_sync_setup.md`). It copies the files in `ONEDRIVE_SYNC_FOLDERS` (`<drive id>/<item id>` pairs; `openexecutive onedrive-folder <link>` resolves a sharing link) into the isolated `onedrive_docs` collection on its own heartbeat, and shows them on the knowledge page as \"OneDrive\" rows with a **Sync now** button. Microsoft has no service account that sees only what is shared with it (app-only Graph access covers the whole tenant), so it reads as the Executive's own Microsoft 365 sign-in, and the folder list is the scope. It never stores a credential: each tick asks the launcher for a token (`ms365-mcp-launch.sh --access-token`, which runs `docker/ms365-access-token.mjs` through the server's own token cache and will only mint file-read tokens), keeps it in memory, and sends it only to Graph. `knowledge.onedrive_client` issues GETs only, follows a paging link only back to Graph, and fetches a file's pre-authenticated download link without the token; errors never carry that link. PowerPoint and older Office formats are read through Graph's PDF rendering.\n\n### Google Drive folder sync\n\nThe synced files show on the knowledge page's Company documents list as \"Google Drive\" rows (sync time, last edit in Drive, an Open in Drive link and a text view), and the page's source card shows the last run, any sign-in error or count of files that failed to sync, and a **Sync now** button that runs one tick on demand.\n\n\nSeparate from the Drive tools the gateway proxies. The optional folder sync (`knowledge.drive_sync`, `DRIVE_SYNC_ENABLED`; setup in `docs/drive_sync_setup.md`) copies the files in `DRIVE_SYNC_FOLDER_IDS` into the isolated `drive_docs` knowledge collection on a scheduler heartbeat, so the Executive knows those folders without searching Drive live (see RAG). It calls the Drive v3 API directly (`knowledge.drive_client`, `httpx`) as a **service account** with the `drive.readonly` scope (`DRIVE_SYNC_SERVICE_ACCOUNT_FILE`), not as the Executive's own account through workspace-mcp. Google enforces the folder scope, because the account sees only what is shared with it, and the sync can change nothing. Structured JSON means no display text to parse, and every file or folder id is checked against `[A-Za-z0-9_-]{1,128}` before it goes into a URL or a query. The two paths meet in two places. A synced chunk carries its Drive file id and sync time, so the Executive can open the live file with its own `get_drive_file_content`. The setup doc says to share each synced folder with the Executive's account too, so that live open works.\n\n### Confluence space sync\n\nThe optional Confluence sync (`knowledge.confluence_sync`, `CONFLUENCE_SYNC_ENABLED`; setup in `docs/confluence_sync_setup.md`) copies the pages of the spaces in `CONFLUENCE_SYNC_SPACE_KEYS` into the isolated `confluence_wiki` knowledge collection on a scheduler heartbeat, so the Executive knows the company wiki without a tool call (see RAG). It works with Confluence Cloud and Server/Data Center: `knowledge.confluence_client` calls the v1 REST API both serve, directly with `httpx`, signing in with a personal access token (Server/DC) or a username and API token (Cloud). It reads only, never follows a redirect (so the token stays on the configured site), streams responses with a 20 MB cap, and checks page ids and space keys before they reach a URL or a CQL query. The URL must be `https://` unless `CONFLUENCE_SYNC_ALLOW_HTTP` is set, and `CONFLUENCE_SSL_VERIFY` takes `true`, `false` or a CA bundle path for a private certificate authority. With `CONFLUENCE_SYNC_PUBLIC_HOSTS_ONLY` (off by default, for an install where whoever sets the URL must not reach the backend's own network) every request resolves the site's host, refuses it when any address is not public (loopback, private, link-local, shared), and connects to the checked address with the site's name kept for the Host header and the TLS certificate check, directly rather than through a proxy. `confluence_client.config_problem` is the same settings check the app runs at start, for a caller that writes these settings on someone's behalf.\n\nIt is separate from a Confluence MCP server such as mcp-atlassian, which a deployment can add to `mcp_servers.json` for live reads and edits in chat. The two share the env names `CONFLUENCE_URL`, `CONFLUENCE_PERSONAL_TOKEN`, `CONFLUENCE_USERNAME`, `CONFLUENCE_API_TOKEN` and `CONFLUENCE_SSL_VERIFY`, so one set of values serves both, and a synced chunk carries its page id so the Executive can open the live page with such a tool. A Confluence token is a user's, and what the sync reads becomes retrievable by everyone who talks to the Executive, so the space list is required and pages with a read restriction (their own or a parent's) are skipped unless `CONFLUENCE_SYNC_SKIP_RESTRICTED=false`. That keeps any existing member's token safe to use, without a dedicated licence. Manual runs: `openexecutive sync-confluence` / `purge-confluence`.\n\n### Your own Gmail or Outlook (Act as me)\n\nA second, separate mail connection, for **Act as me** (see **Act as Me (Delegation)**): a person's *own* mailbox, which `delegation.gmail.DelegateGmail` reads and drafts into over the Gmail REST API. It is never registered with the MCP gateway, so the model can reach it only through the typed `ghostwrite_email` handler — never by tool name through `call_tool`. The credential is one file per person in `DELEGATION_GOOGLE_CREDENTIALS_DIR` (default `company/delegation_google/`, `/data/delegation_google` in Docker), minted on a computer with a browser by `scripts/connect-own-gmail.py --email <you>` with the Executive's own OAuth client and the scopes `gmail.readonly` and `gmail.compose` — the same seed-it-yourself flow as the Executive's token, since the API serves no OAuth callback. It never lives in `WORKSPACE_MCP_CREDENTIALS_DIR`, where workspace-mcp picks a credential by address.\n\nEvery use re-checks with Google that the credential opens the mailbox on the person's People entry, and refuses outright when that address is the Executive's own: a shared mailbox would make everything the Executive writes look like theirs. Drafts are threaded (`In-Reply-To`, `References` of whole ids ending with the parent, `threadId`) and stamped `X-OE-Ghostwritten`; the only send is `drafts.send` of an existing draft by id, when the person taps Send on its reply card (`delegation.reply_send`). A Gmail rate limit, even as a 403, is an error to retry rather than a reconnect. The voice learner and the thread shown to the ghostwriter keep only each sender's own words through `email_poller.sender_new_text`, the poller's quoted-reply stripper made public. Setup status shows it as **Your own mailbox (Act as me)**.\n\nThe same file can instead hold an Outlook sign-in (`\"provider\": \"microsoft\"`), minted by `scripts/connect-own-outlook.py --email <you>` with a device-code sign-in on the Executive's own Entra app (`MS365_MCP_CLIENT_ID`, `MS365_MCP_TENANT_ID`, default `common`) and the delegated scopes `User.Read`, `Mail.ReadWrite`, `Mail.Send` and `offline_access`. `delegation.gmail.gmail_for` then hands back `delegation.outlook.DelegateOutlook`, which talks to Microsoft Graph directly — never the Microsoft 365 MCP server the Executive's own Outlook uses — with the same methods and the same one send: Graph's `send` on an existing draft, with no body. Microsoft rotates the refresh token on use and the new one is written back into the file. A sender counts as verified only from the topmost `Authentication-Results`, the one Exchange wrote, and only mail in their Sent Items counts as theirs.",
+ "markdown": "External channels connect callers to the Executive. Each inbound adapter resolves the sender to a Person — the chat adapters via `find_person_by_{slack,discord,telegram}_id`, the email poller via `people.identity.resolve_email_sender` (a primary address or an alias, then the company-domain rule; see Org) — and threads `person_id` into `Executive.chat()`. A sender who resolves to nobody is no longer simply dropped: see **New senders (roster requests)** below.\n\n### Inbound channels\n\n- **Slack** (`integrations.slack_bot`) — async Bolt app (`AsyncApp`) embedded in the lifespan, hearing Slack one of two ways: socket mode (`AsyncSocketModeHandler`, with `SLACK_APP_TOKEN`) or, with only `SLACK_SIGNING_SECRET`, the Events API over HTTP at `POST /webhook/slack` (`integrations.slack_events`), where the route checks each request's signature and age (and a 1 MB cap) before Bolt sees it, so unsigned traffic never reaches Bolt's logging; it then takes each signed request once, answering an identical replay (same signature) or Slack's re-signed retry of an `event_id` it already took with an empty 200 that never reaches Bolt (an in-memory, per-process set kept for twice the signature window and capped in size; keys are forgotten if Bolt fails, so a retry of a failed delivery still runs), and Bolt acknowledges at once while the listener runs. Either way a repeated event id is dropped (Slack resends what it thinks went unacknowledged), as is an event delivered for another workspace. Responds to `@mention`s, DMs, and thread continuations, with per-conversation session memory (see **Conversation state** below). Text only: there is no interactivity endpoint and no Block Kit, so nothing Slack sends carries a button.\n- **Discord** (`integrations.discord_bot`) — discord.py gateway embedded in the lifespan; per-thread auto-titling, session-scoped memory, author attribution, configurable `@mention` thread promotion.\n- **Telegram** — webhook gating + per-chat history. Replies (and every outbound Telegram message) go out as Telegram's HTML subset (`utils.markdown_telegram`: markdown-it-py with raw HTML and images off, text escaped), so the Executive's Markdown shows as formatting; links show as their text and target in plain text and never become tags, so quoted text can't hide where one goes; a chunk Telegram refuses is sent again as plain text.\n- **Google Chat** — webhook + service-account auth. It resolves no approval gates and has no roster gate (the webhook authenticates Google, not the sender), and it never populates the session's trusted alert ids, so `ack_alert`'s trust check — which now runs on every session rather than only those declaring an `origin_channel` — refuses there by default, and its `<channel>` block says plainly that a sign-off cannot be answered from it. It does look its sender up on People by the Google account email on the signed event, but hands that entry only to the department gate (`Session.gate_sender_person_id`): the principal's own sends and edits go, a teammate's meet their department's authority, and anyone else's wait for approval. It is never `caller_person_id`, so it grants nothing else.\n- **Email** (`integrations.email_poller`) — MCP poll loop over the Executive's own mailbox — Gmail via `workspace-mcp` or Outlook via `ms-365-mcp-server`, chosen by `EMAIL_PROVIDER` (see *Workspace providers* below); it starts only once the MCP gateway is up, never surfaces Reply-To redirects, filters auto-replies. Its sessions carry `origin_channel=\"email\"`: the untrusted-content policy (`orchestrator.content_trust`) reads that tag to tell mail from the principal's own surfaces — left empty, as it once was, every stranger's body reached the decision extractor as the principal's words. The mail goes into the turn inside an `<untrusted_content source=\"email\" author=\"<sender>\" author_verified=\"no\">` block that says it carries none of the principal's authority, with the framing line and any `[POLICY]` notice outside it; mail from the principal's primary address that Gmail authenticated (`dmarc=pass`) is their own words — but only their new text goes in unwrapped: when the mail quotes or forwards another message (`_new_text_lines` cut something), the message as received follows in an `<untrusted_content source=\"email_quoted\">` block, since a stranger's text they replied to or passed on is not theirs. While the Executive is paused (`scheduler.pause`) it skips each poll and leaves the inbox unread, so held mail is processed on the first poll after resume; the chat adapters above are not paused. The poller handles one message at a time, so each Executive turn on an email has a deadline, `EMAIL_TURN_TIMEOUT_S` (300 s): past it the turn is cut off, an `integration_inbound` row with outcome `turn_timeout` records it, and the message is marked read and not run again (it may already have replied). A message whose handling keeps raising is given up after three tries in a run and marked read, rather than retried every poll. Each gateway call it makes is bounded by `MCP_TOOL_TIMEOUT_S` (see Lifecycle). The Executive sees the whole message; peer memory records only `_email_memory_text` — the subject, the sender's new text (cut at the first quoted or forwarded message) and the attachment filenames — parsed from the rendered message with any trailing `--- REPLY ---` block dropped first, without backtracking-prone regexes, since the text is sender-controlled, and only for a rostered sender, the only kind with a peer to record into. The poller's `integration_inbound` row keeps the mail's text for the audit log, the way the reply's `chat_turn` row keeps the Executive's answer: `full.message` is the sender's new text (what web chat keeps for a turn), `full.attachments` the attachment filenames, and `details.preview` the first 120 characters of the new text, so /audit shows what was asked next to what was answered (the summary still reads `Inbound email from <sender>: <subject>`). The whole body with its quoted chain (`full.body`) is kept only on a row private to the principal: the chain is other people's mail — a contact's, on the principal's reply to one — and every signed-in user reads a public row. Each field is cut by its escaped JSON length (20,000 characters of text, 8,000 of attachment names), the measure the logger's 64 KB cap uses, so a long mail in a non-Latin script loses its tail rather than the row's structure. Outbound, the principal briefs and the client-rotation digest are emailed through the same gateway with the configured backend's send tool (`google_workspace__send_gmail_message` or `microsoft_365__send-mail`, via `workspace.registry.send_from_executive`, from the Executive's own mailbox to the principal's address, subject `<brief title> — <date>`, the date in the user's zone) as formatted HTML — rendered from the brief's Markdown with raw HTML and images off, so text quoted from outside shows as text and opening the email loads nothing remote. Email is first when the principal prefers it, and otherwise the backup after every chat channel, tried only when Slack, Discord and Telegram are missing or fail; an in-band error from the tool counts as a failed send and the next channel is tried. An emailed brief is not a DM, so the per-Person outbound guard below does not apply — the gateway's roster egress gate does.\n\n Two senders get their own framing. Mail from one of the principal's **contacts** (a `kind=\"contact\"` People row — see Org) replaces the non-roster `[POLICY]` notice with a contact one: it names them (name and role/company), says not to reply unless the principal asks and not to tell anyone else, and asks for a summary in an alert for the principal instead. Mail from anyone not in People, a contact or a stranger, is held as outside content for its whole turn (`orchestrator.outside_content`): no connected-app write, contact change, follow-up, link, script or workflow, no direct message, only reads and an alert private to the principal. Both this turn and the forwarded-by-principal turn below are marked `Session.private_to_principal`: they can email, DM or invite only the principal, an alert they raise is private to the principal, and they are not offered the tools that reach anyone else or start work outside the turn (`schedule_tools.PRIVATE_TURN_WITHHELD_TOOLS`: broadcasts, meeting bookings, workflows, follow-ups, watches, artifacts, goal updates, skill drafts, connecting a new MCP server), and of the MCP tools only Google Workspace reads and the gated Gmail send (see MCP below). Every audit row about such mail is private to the principal (see Audit Log), the poller's two `integration_inbound` rows included (`_private_to_principal_mail`), so the audit log's other readers see none of it. The poller holds `audit.private_rows` for the whole handling of such a mail, because some rows are written before the turn binds its private session: the knowledge retrieval quotes the mail's From line, subject and opening. The rows themselves read exactly like an outside sender's: the `integration_inbound` row is the non-roster one (`accepted_non_roster`), and the notice opens with the non-roster notice's exact sentence. The poller handles each message with no session bound, so one message's private turn never marks the next message's rows. The turn stays unattributed (`person_id` None — no peer memory, no co-presence), and the gateway refuses mail to a contact on a poller turn anyway. Mail **forwarded by the principal** — the sender resolves to the principal and `_new_text_lines` reports a forwarded message — is wrapped in a `<forwarded_by_principal>` block: summarise it, draft a reply the principal could send (as text in the reply, never sent or saved as a Gmail draft), note any commitment or date, and offer to add the original sender as a contact (confirmed from the web app or the principal's Slack / Discord, since an ordinary email turn cannot change the People list — the one email that can is the principal's tokened reply to a roster-request email, which is parsed before any model turn; see below). The reply still goes to the principal only. The From header is unauthenticated, so this framing grants nothing: a spoofed \"forward\" just gets the real principal a summary.\n\n **An email that got no reply goes to Needs you.** Mail from the team or the principal is answered by the model calling the mailbox's send tool, so a turn can end with nothing sent (a tool refused, the answer only written). The gateway marks on the conversation who each accepted send reached (`Session.mail_sent_to`: Gmail `send_gmail_message` to/cc, Outlook `send-mail` recipients; `mail_replied_ids`: the message an Outlook `reply-mail-message` / `reply-all-mail-message` answered). After the turn the poller (`_note_reply_outcome`) checks the sender, by any of their addresses, or the message id; with no reply it files a card through `integrations.unanswered_mail` (source `unanswered_email`, high, tagged `private:principal` and routed to the principal, so only their own /today shows it), whatever the model did. Repeats in the thread fold into it (one card per thread, occurrence count), and a later turn that does reply resolves it. A reply the poller sees is also logged (`unanswered_mail.record_reply`, a private `integration_outbound` row keyed by thread), and the briefs read both: each INBOUND email from the roster says \"the Executive replied\" only on that evidence, or \"no reply went out\" while its card is open (`open_thread_keys`), so the brief stops telling the principal to answer mail the Executive already answered. Only mail Gmail proved is the principal's (`Session.email_authenticated`) reads \"Your email got no reply\" with its subject and what the Executive wrote, which never reached them; a teammate's card names who is waiting and never their subject or text (their conversation is theirs alone); mail that only claims a teammate's or the principal's address says it could not be proven and carries nothing the sender wrote. A plain-text `Error …` tool result is not counted as a send. Contacts and senders off the team are not answered by design and keep their own paths. Why: the brief read the inbound log and said people were waiting while Needs you, which shows alerts only, stayed empty, since an alert depended on the model choosing `create_alert`.\n\n **Other mail sources** (`integrations.mail_sources`). Mail read from anywhere but the Executive's own mailbox (a hosted inbound address, a relay) follows the same rules through a vendor-neutral hook. Nothing is registered by default and the hook has no settings: a deployment registers a `MailSource` (its loop, an `enabled` check, and how to replay a held message), the lifespan starts the enabled ones, and each message goes to `handle_inbound` as an `InboundMail`: the parsed message, the address it came to, `prove_sender` (DMARC, or SPF and DKIM aligned, as the source can tell), `send_answer`, an optional attachment reader and what a held message keeps. `handle_inbound` runs the poller's own handling (`email_poller._handle_mail`): sender resolution, private-to-principal rows, the teammate's own rows only when proven, untrusted-content wrapping, the principal's proven mail, the forwarded-by-principal framing, hydration and the turn deadline. Because a source mails the answer itself (with the AI line, and an `integration_outbound` row) rather than the model calling a send tool, three things differ: a stranger is held for the principal silently, with no acknowledgement and no turn, and replayed through the source that read it (`replay_held_mail` dispatches on the payload's `mail_source`); a contact's mail, and mail claiming a teammate that nothing proves, is answered to the principal and never to the sender; and roster-request and fact confirmations are answered only from the mailbox they were sent from. A source must be registered to be handled, it does nothing while the Executive is paused (`handle_inbound` returns `PAUSED` and the source keeps the message), a stranger the request queue won't take is logged as not held, and a sender who is neither team nor contact by the time the turn runs gets no answer at all.\n\nSlack, Discord, and Telegram are roster-gated on inbound: an unrostered sender's message never reaches the Executive (`details.outcome=\"rejected_unknown_sender\"`). The gates look up **team members only** — a contact's Slack, Discord or Telegram id is treated as unknown, so a contact can never talk to the bot (nor count as a co-present peer). What happens next is the roster request below — except for a contact, a thread continuation, a Telegram group or an unverified Telegram webhook, which stay silent. Email is not inbound-gated — non-roster mail flows through with a `[POLICY]` notice so triage can classify it. Slack/Discord thread continuations pass the shared `integrations.response_gate` (utility-fast model, biased toward replying). Slack only continues a thread it has replied in: it reads the thread with `conversations_replies` (5 s bound) and looks for its own user id, which `auth_test` resolves at startup. If that lookup fails, mentions and DMs still work and thread continuations stop until a retry succeeds (`slack_bot._resolve_bot_user_id`, at most once a minute, from the channel `message` listener). When Slack doesn't return the thread in time, the thread's stored history (`slack:thread:{channel}:{thread_ts}`, written on every turn the bot answers there) stands in: with history, a rostered sender gets an ephemeral \"I couldn't read this thread just now… @-mention me\" and the drop is audited (`outcome=dropped_thread_unreadable`). A thread the bot never answered in stays silent. A message the gate skips is audited (`outcome=skipped_gate`, with the gate's reason) and gets an :eyes: reaction (`reactions_add`, which needs the bot's `reactions:write` scope; without it the reaction is skipped), so a sender the gate misjudged can see the message was read and @-mention the bot.\n\n**No link previews on replies.** The Executive's replies go out with previews off — Telegram `sendMessage` carries `link_preview_options.is_disabled`, Slack's reply `say` passes `unfurl_links=False` / `unfurl_media=False`, and every Discord reply send passes `suppress_embeds=True`. The direct messages the Executive starts are the same: `send_slack_dm` posts with `unfurl_links=False` / `unfurl_media=False`, and Discord's `send_dm` sets the `SUPPRESS_EMBEDS` flag on each chunk, so a reminder or a brief sent by DM carries no preview either. Otherwise the chat service fetches a link in the text on its own, so a reply that quotes someone's mail (Act as me reads it) could carry data to a sender's server with no click. The web chat does the same for images: `Message.tsx` loads only an image the app itself serves (`lib/markdownImages.loadsInline`) and shows any other as a link.\n\n### Alert triage of chat messages\n\nEvery chat-app message that passes the roster gate (Telegram, Slack, Discord, Google Chat) is also handed to alert triage through `alerts.pipeline.schedule_chat_message_evaluation`. The sender is named by their People record (`full_name`), not by the name they typed into the chat app, so a person whose account there is called something else is never read as a stranger; the chat app's own name (or raw user id) is used only when nobody on the roster matched. The principal's own messages to their Executive are a conversation, not news for their brief, so they are not triaged at all. Triage sees the sender as `sender:` and the room as `channel:`. Google Chat's inbound audit row also carries the matched People id (`sender_person_id`), looked up before the row is written, so the brief can tell the principal's own messages apart by id, never by a display name anyone can set.\n\n### New senders (roster requests)\n\nSomeone who writes in and is not on the People list — and is not one of the principal's contacts — is **held, acknowledged and asked about** instead of dropped (`integrations.roster_intake.intake` over the `people.roster_requests` ledger; lifecycle in Org). Each adapter calls it after its gate:\n\n- **Slack** — a DM or an `@mention` (not a thread continuation: the bot was not addressed there). The name and profile email come from `users_info` (5 s timeout). The acknowledgement goes in the DM, or as an **ephemeral** message for a mention, so nobody else in the channel learns who is and is not on the roster. The held event keeps only a fixed set of keys (text, user, channel, ts, thread, files).\n- **Discord** — a DM or a mention (not a thread the bot merely follows). The acknowledgement goes in the DM, or by DM for a channel mention; `/ask` answers the interaction with an ephemeral acknowledgement first (Discord allows 3 s), then holds the prompt. Its old \"ask the admin to add you\" reply is gone.\n- **Telegram** — only a **private** chat, and only when `TELEGRAM_WEBHOOK_SECRET` is set and valid: Telegram identifies the chat rather than the sender, and without the secret anyone could forge an update. A group, or an unverified webhook, stays silent as before. Attachment file ids are held and downloaded only on replay.\n- **Email** — non-roster mail that is not private to the principal (so never a contact's) and does not look machine-sent (`looks_automated`: a no-reply / notifications / billing-style local part, a `List-Id` / `List-Unsubscribe` / `Auto-Submitted` / bulk `Precedence` header, or a DMARC failure). The mail is **still triaged** by the Executive on this pass; its `[POLICY]` notice now says the sender was already told their message is waiting and the principal was asked who they are, so the model raises no second alert just to add them, and that the email will come back once they are added.\n\nEvery path skips a contact first (`find_person_by_*_id(..., include_contacts=True)`, or the email poller's private-mail rule): a contact has no chat access and gets no request and no acknowledgement, and the team-visible `rejected_unknown_sender` / `accepted_non_roster` rows read the same for a contact as for a stranger.\n\n**The acknowledgement** is one fixed text (`roster_intake.ACK_TEXT` — \"your message arrived … waiting for confirmation\"), never the model and never an echo of what they wrote, so a forged sender gains nothing by triggering it. It is sent at most once per sender per `ROSTER_ACK_WINDOW_DAYS` (7) and at most `ROSTER_ACK_DAILY_CAP` (20) a day across all senders (`claim_ack`, one transaction; a failed send releases its claim). An email acknowledgement is the one send the MCP gateway lets reach an address off the roster: `send_email_ack` sets `mcp_gateway.roster_ack_grant`, a one-shot ContextVar grant that admits a single `send_gmail_message` with exactly the granted recipient (a plain string, no list), subject and body and no other key, then is spent (audited `integration_outbound`, `kind: roster_ack`, private). An email sender is acknowledged only when Gmail authenticated them: once `claim_ack` succeeds, the poller's `send_ack` re-reads the mail as raw MIME and needs Gmail's own topmost `Authentication-Results` reporting `dmarc=pass` for the From domain (`fact_confirmation.sender_authenticated`, fail-closed). The printed headers the poller reads never carry that header, so without the second read a forged From would draw the acknowledgement to whoever it names — backscatter from the Executive's mailbox. An unauthenticated sender makes `send_ack` raise `roster_intake.AckWithheld`: the claim is released, and they are held silently. `authenticated_by_gmail` strips quoted strings and comments before reading the verdict — Gmail copies the envelope sender and DKIM tags into its own stamp, and a quoted local part could otherwise carry a fake `dmarc=pass` — and needs exactly one `dmarc=` verdict reading exactly `dmarc=pass header.from=<domain>` (Gmail may follow it with its own `dara=` resinfo, so its position is not checked). A From domain with no DMARC record (no verdict, or `dmarc=none`) passes only on a DKIM signature Gmail verified for exactly that domain, or Google Workspace's default key for it (`<domain-with-hyphens>.<date>.gappssmtp.com`, read back only for a two-label domain without hyphens). SPF alone never counts, since a domain that lists Google's servers passes anyone sending through Google. Mail a list or group resent (`List-Id`, `X-Google-Group-Id`, a Groups `+bnc` envelope) is never proven, since an open group in the domain's own Workspace resends an outsider's forged From under its signature, and a stamp echoing `smtp.helo=` proves nothing. A withheld acknowledgement is audited `roster_ack_withheld`. `intake` acknowledges before surfacing the card and telling the principal, and both follow the request's `ack_sent_at`: a withheld, failed or capped acknowledgement reads \"haven't been told anything yet\" on the Today card, in the principal's prompt and in the email `[POLICY]` notice.\n\n**Telling the principal.** A new request puts a private card on the principal's `/today` (see Today) and pushes a prompt on their delivery plan — preferred chat DM, then the others, then email — for a chat sender or an email sender on the company's own domain; an outside email sender waits on the card, as does everything past `ROSTER_REQUEST_DAILY_CAP` (30) pushes a day (the same cap bounds how many requests open a day; a declined sender is not raised again for 30 days). A chat prompt can be answered in place (\"that's Annamarie, add her to the team\"). An email prompt carries a one-time token (`RR-` + 20 base32 characters, stored hashed); the poller checks every inbound mail for one **before** triage (`try_email_roster_answer`): the reply must come from the principal's primary address exactly (not an alias, not the company-domain rule), carry the token of a pending request, not be an automatic reply, and not fail DMARC where the header is visible; and is parsed by `parse_decision`'s `roster_identity` shape — anything else falls through to the ordinary path. The token is hidden (`RR-[hidden]`) in every other Google Workspace result the gateway returns — the confirmation sits in the Executive's Sent folder, and any turn could otherwise read it — except the poller's own fetch of an inbound message (`mcp_gateway.reveal_roster_tokens`); a token-bearing mail that is not an answer is scrubbed before triage.\n\n**Replay.** Once the principal answers (web card, chat tool, email reply) — or a People-page / `upsert_person` write makes the sender match someone (`after_roster_write`) — the held messages are replayed through the adapter that received them (`register_replayer`: Slack re-runs the held event, Discord and Telegram their held text, email re-fetches the message from Gmail and handles it as mail from a known sender), oldest first, now attributed to the new Person. A teammate gets every held message; a new contact only held email (it takes the private contact path; held chat is dropped); a decline drops everything. Replays run in a **fresh `contextvars.Context`**: the answer may have come from the principal's own verified turn, and a stranger's message must never be read with the principal's session — and their contacts — still bound.\n\n### Standing facts by email (confirm by reply)\n\nThe principal can ask for a standing fact, a retirement or a company-profile edit by email, and the fact tools check it exactly as in chat (the own-words gates run on `_email_memory_text`, the sender's new text, not the quoted chain or attachments). An email's From line proves nothing, though, and a standing fact is read by every later prompt as the principal's own account. So an emailed change is **held, never applied**, until the principal's own mailbox confirms it (`integrations.fact_confirmation`, `memory.facts.fact_confirmations`):\n\n- **Who may ask.** The poller stamps every email turn with `Session.email_from` (the bare lowercased From address) and `email_authenticated`. The text the poller reads never carries `Authentication-Results` (workspace-mcp prints a fixed set of headers), so for mail claiming the principal's primary address it reads the message again as raw MIME (`fact_confirmation.sender_authenticated`) and requires Gmail's own stamp: the **topmost** `Authentication-Results` header (Gmail adds it on receipt, above anything the sender wrote), authserv-id `mx.google.com`, reporting `dmarc=pass` for the From address's domain, with the raw From matching (`authenticated_by_gmail`). It fails closed: no header, `dmarc=none`, a temporary error or a failed read all leave the turn unauthenticated. Mail from a teammate other than the principal is read the same way, before its inbound audit row is written: authenticated, the whole handling of it is theirs alone in the audit log (`rows_for_person`, see Audit) and the turn reads their own mail as them (`Session.email_sender_authenticated`); unauthenticated, it keeps the ordinary rule. Mail from anyone else costs no second read and is never authenticated. `fact_tools._gate` admits an email turn only from the principal's **primary** address, exactly (no alias, no company-domain rule), authenticated, and not private to the principal (mail they forwarded stays refused, as do contacts, teammates and unknown senders).\n- **The hold.** The tool returns `awaiting_confirmation` (no action chip, and the model is told to say nothing has changed). `request_confirmation` stores the change with the SHA-256 of a fresh one-time token (`FC-` + 20 base32 characters, 100 bits; 7-day expiry; at most 10 waiting at once) and emails the token to the principal's roster address, outside any turn's outbound context. A profile edit is dry-run first, so one that cannot apply is reported in the turn, before any email goes out. If the email fails, nothing is held.\n- **Keeping the token from any model.** The tool result never carries it, and `mcp_gateway.hide_roster_tokens` now scrubs `FC-` tokens as well as `RR-` ones (`FC-[hidden]`) from every Google Workspace result except the poller's own fetch of an inbound message. Act as me's reads of the principal's own Gmail, where the confirmation email lands, hide them too (`delegation.gmail.parse_message` and the thread search), so the drafting model never sees a live token either.\n- **The reply.** `_handle_one_email` hands every message to `try_email_fact_confirmation` right after the roster-answer check, before any model turn. It acts only on a reply from the principal's primary address carrying the token of a **pending** confirmation. A made-up, spent, cancelled or expired reference matches nothing and falls through to the ordinary path with the token hidden, so no old or forged token can make the Executive email the principal. A reply with a live token is read again as raw MIME (`read_raw`) and must pass the same Gmail DMARC check as the request; one that doesn't (or whose raw read fails) is refused, the change keeps waiting, and the principal is told. Then an **automatic reply** is consumed quietly — no answer, no model turn, the change keeps waiting: the printed headers catch a Gmail vacation reply (`Precedence: bulk`), and the raw headers catch what they don't show (`automatic_reply`: `Auto-Submitted` other than `no`, `X-Auto-Response-Suppress` and similar, `Precedence: auto_reply`, an out-of-office subject), since an Exchange out-of-office echoes the token from the principal's own address and may well say \"I'll confirm on my return\". The raw message starts at the tool's exact separator line (`\\n\\n--- RAW MIME ---\\n`), so a sender-written Subject imitating it cannot supply the headers. CONFIRM (or yes / approve) applies the change through `fact_tools.apply_confirmed`, the same apply step chat uses. CANCEL (or no) drops it, and an unclear reply leaves it waiting. The principal gets a one-line result either way. A compare-and-set on the row means two replies can apply it only once.\n- **Audit.** Private `fact_confirmation` rows record held / applied / cancelled / refused. The applied change also writes the fact tools' usual private rows, with `source_channel=\"email\"` as its provenance.\n\n### Checking a channel is set up\n\nSettings → Setup status (`GET /setup/status`, `api/setup_checks.py`) gives each channel a light and a plain-language fix. It tests the credentials with one free read-only call — Slack `auth.test`; Telegram `getMe`, then `getWebhookInfo` (is a webhook registered, is it this app's `/webhook/telegram`, did a delivery fail in the past day); Discord `users/@me`, only while the bot is still connecting — and reads what the lifespan left on `app.state`: the Slack socket's `is_connected()`, the Discord bot's `is_ready()` together with its gateway socket being open (discord.py stays ready while it reconnects after a drop), or the exception its task stopped with (`LoginFailure`, `PrivilegedIntentsRequired`), and the MCP gateway. A listening Slack is amber while the listener hasn't resolved its own user id (`slack_bot.bot_user_id()`), since thread continuations are off until it does. Because inbound is roster-gated, a connected Slack, Discord or Telegram is amber while nobody on the roster has its id (`slack_user_id`, `discord_user_id`, `telegram_chat_id`), or when its latest `integration_inbound` row is a `Rejected: …` from the past day whose sender still isn't on the roster — the page shows the sender's id, never message text. Local login with no `TELEGRAM_WEBHOOK_SECRET` is red for Telegram, since the local-login gate turns its webhook away. Google Chat and Gmail are checked from configuration: a numeric project number and a readable service-account key; the OAuth client (or service-account key) the workspace-mcp child signs in with. Gmail is also amber when startup priming could not find every pinned Google tool (`MCPGateway.prime_pinned_tools`, whose result the gateway keeps on `pinned_tools`): the row names a few of the missing tools and counts the rest, and points at the `MCPGateway` log lines. It is amber too while that probe has not finished, and when the probe itself failed — the one check that reads green is the one that ran and found everything, so a crashed probe is never silently fine. The row speaks for the whole `google_workspace` server, so a missing Docs or Drive tool shows up under Email (Gmail).\n\nA channel setting written `KEY= # note` in a `.env` file arrives as the note's text, because python-dotenv strips only a comment that follows a value. `Settings` reads such a value as unset for the Slack, Telegram, Discord and Google Chat credentials, so the line no longer switches a channel on with its own comment as the token. `TELEGRAM_WEBHOOK_SECRET` is the exception, because read as unset a junk secret would turn the webhook's check off. It is kept instead, and since Telegram can only ever send 1–256 of `A-Z a-z 0-9 _ -` (what `setWebhook` accepts), a secret outside that set — a leftover comment, a pasted `<value from Step 2>` — could only be matched by someone who guessed it: while it is set the webhook refuses every update, neither the local-login gate nor the roster tools count it as proof (`Settings.telegram_webhook_secret_valid`), and Setup status shows it red (`.env.example` shipped four such lines; the notes now sit on their own lines).\n\n### Picking people and rooms by name (chat directory)\n\nNobody has to copy a raw Slack, Discord or Telegram id. The person page, Add person and a department's Channels settings pick them by name from what the bots this instance runs can reach (`integrations/chat_directory.py`, served at `GET /chat-directory/people`, `/channels` and `/slack/lookup`, the principal's alone). The id is still what is saved; the by-hand field stays under \"Enter an ID by hand\", and is all there is for a provider with no bot.\n\n- **Slack** — channels from `conversations.list` (public, plus the private ones the bot is in; scopes `channels:read`, `groups:read`, and public only when `groups:read` is missing) and people from `users.list` (no bots, no deactivated accounts; `users:read`, and `users:read.email` for their profile email). A person with a work email is matched by it (`users.lookupByEmail`, after the cached list): the picker pre-selects \"Found by email\" with a \"Not them?\".\n- **Discord** — text and announcement channels of the servers the bot is in (only `DISCORD_GUILD_IDS` when set) and their members over the REST API. Members need the Server Members privileged intent; when Discord refuses, the list is empty with `members_available` false, not an error.\n- **Telegram** — there is no list API, so the webhook records each chat an update comes from in `telegram_chats` (`integrations/telegram_chats.py`): private chats are people, groups and supergroups are rooms. Only a webhook whose `TELEGRAM_WEBHOOK_SECRET` checked out records anything, since without it anyone could post a made-up name for a chat id. A row is a suggestion only and grants nothing: the roster still decides who is answered.\n\nA department's Slack and Discord pickers pre-select the room named most like the department; it is saved only when the person presses Save. Lists are cached in-process for 60 s and capped at 2,000; a provider that fails reads as an empty list. Tokens go only in the Authorization header to the provider's own API host and are never returned.\n\n### Conversation state\n\nEvery adapter keys a deterministic `session_id` off the conversation surface and replays that session's stored turns into `Session.conversation_history`, so a follow-up (\"yes, go ahead\") lands with the question still in context. Slack's ids are `slack:dm:{user}`, `slack:thread:{channel}:{thread_ts}`, and `slack:channel:{channel}:{user}` for a mention that starts a thread; because the bot's reply roots a Slack thread at that message's `ts`, the turn is double-written to that thread's session too, so the first continuation inside it is not cold. A reply inside a thread THAT PERSON ROOTED also offers the parent `slack:channel:{channel}:{user}` id when matching an approval gate, since a gate raised on the mention recorded that session while the answer arrives under the thread's. The root-author check is load-bearing: widening on \"threaded and not a DM\" alone offered one person's channel session inside any thread in that channel, so a remark they made to a colleague could resolve their open gate and post the run's title into that colleague's thread. Discord has the same shape — its auto-thread router promotes a mention reply into a bot-owned thread — and the same alias. An @-mention inside a DM is handled once, by the DM path: Slack fires both events, and taking both forked the conversation across two session ids. The same id is the audit grouping key and the scope passed to `format_for_prompt`. A per-session `asyncio.Lock` serializes turns within one conversation — the inflight semaphore caps fan-out across the workspace, which does nothing to stop two messages in the same thread from both reading history before either writes it. Persistence happens after the reply is sent and its failure is logged, never surfaced: the user already has their answer.\n\n**Conversations within a chat app.** A Telegram chat, a Slack or Discord DM and a person's @mentions in one channel (`slack:channel:…`, `discord:channel:…`) are each one endless stream, so they are cut into conversations (`memory.conversations`, shared helpers in `integrations/conversations.py`). Each adapter computes the stream's base id as before and asks `conversation_for` which conversation a message belongs to: the newest, unless the stream has been quiet for two hours (`CONVERSATION_GAP`), when the next one starts. The first conversation keeps the bare base id; later ones add `~2`, `~3`, … (`memory.conversation_ids`). A whole message of `/new`, \"new chat\" or \"new conversation\" starts a fresh one instead of a turn and is answered with the name of the one it ended; the new row has no messages and stays off the Chats page until its first turn. After a conversation's first exchange `title_after_turn` names it in the background with `utils.chat_topics.name_chat` (the first words of the message if that fails), as a web chat's first turn does: the same call files it under one of its owner's chat topics, so a Telegram or Slack conversation sits beside the web chats about the same matter in the Chats page's Topic view. What the Executive sends into a person's Telegram chat or Slack or Discord DM on its own (a brief, the evening digest, a workflow's report, a reminder; `scheduler.runner._send_on_plan`) is saved into that stream's current conversation as its message once it is sent (`record_delivery`; a held message is saved when it goes out), and counts as activity, so a reply to it lands in the same conversation with the message in view. A conversation can therefore open with the Executive's message; `Session.get_recent_history` puts a short placeholder user turn before it rather than dropping it. Threads (`slack:thread:…`, `discord:thread:…`), email and every other id are left whole. What has to see the whole stream compares base ids: the inbound resolver, so an approval asked before a cut is answered after it, and the session-scoped decisions and advice `format_for_prompt` renders. At boot `split_existing_streams` cuts history saved before this by the same rule, once (`app_migrations`), titling each part from its first message and carrying a read-mail lock to every part. An adapter installed outside the package adds its streams with `conversation_ids.register_rolling` and cuts its own old history once, with its own migration name and an `only` filter for its base ids, because the built-in sweep may already have run without it.\n\nThis was absent on Slack until #136. Every message built a fresh `Session` and minted a per-*message* id (`thread_ts` falls back to the message's own `ts`, so a DM never repeated one), which meant a multi-turn confirmation could not work: the Executive asked whether to send a briefing to Slack, the user said yes, and the next turn had no record of the question.\n\n### What the model is told about the channel\n\nChat adapters pass a `<channel>` block (`integrations.channel_context`) in the **user turn** — never a cached system block. It names the surface, states that the person cannot see the app's cards or buttons (except where a chat shows them, below), and draws the line the assistant kept crossing: briefing proposals and alerts are actioned on the briefing page; a proposal that books something can only be approved there; a workflow sign-off the Executive is explicitly waiting on *can* be answered in the conversation.\n\n**Approval cards with buttons (Telegram, Slack and Discord DMs).** In a private Telegram chat on a webhook only Telegram can call (`TELEGRAM_WEBHOOK_SECRET` set and valid; `integrations.channel_cards.shows_cards`), the cards a reply leaves are sent as they are shown under a web chat reply: a meeting to book, a card of actions from `propose_actions`, and a change to a saved workflow (`orchestrator/workflow_change.py`; of the `app_action` cards only those in `decisions.CHAT_APP_ACTIONS`, whose action checks the tapper itself). `Executive.chat(cards=...)` collects their ids from the turn's `action_taken` events; the adapter sends each as a plain-text message with **Approve** and **Skip** inline buttons (`callback_data` `card:<id>:a|s`), and the `<channel>` block tells the model the card is there and that a typed yes does not approve it. A tap arrives as a `callback_query` and is taken only from a private chat whose sender is that chat (`from.id` = chat id), on the verified webhook; the chat's rostered person is the tapper. `api.routes.decisions.resolve_in_chat` applies the web chat's rule (a card of actions is its person's alone; a meeting is the principal's, or its approver's unless it is the principal's private booking), books or carries out the card exactly as stored (`delegation.verified.ChatTap` stands in for the signed-in caller on an action card), or records the skip. The card's message is then edited to show the outcome without buttons. A Slack DM (with `SLACK_CARD_BUTTONS` on, which needs Interactivity turned on in the Slack app and the `im:write` scope) and a Discord DM work the same way. Slack gets Block Kit buttons (`oe_card_approve` / `oe_card_skip`, the callback data as the value, the card as plain text), and a tap counts only when `conversations.open` for the tapper returns that same DM. Discord gets a View whose buttons carry the callback data as `custom_id`, and `on_interaction` takes a tap only in a DM whose recipient is the tapper. Either way the tapper must be on the roster by their app id. Elsewhere (a Slack or Discord channel or thread, Google Chat, a Telegram group, an unverified webhook) no card is sent and `propose_actions` tells the model the card is on Today. The principal's DMs on Slack, Discord and Telegram also receive the open-alert digest (`briefing.context.format_open_alerts_for_prompt`) as the `<briefing>` block, gated to DMs because the board is company-wide and a shared channel must not pull it in. That digest is the ONLY trusted source of an `alert_id` for `ack_alert`. The briefing page's `[Discuss mode — alert_id=N]` primer is a pointer to which item is under discussion, not authority on its own: the server accepts that id only if it is also on the live board it derived itself. An id appearing anywhere else, including inside an alert's own body, is not trusted: alerts are minted from inbound email and chat, so their bodies are attacker-controlled. Two mechanisms enforce that rather than one prompt rule. Every field the digest interpolates is collapsed to a single line, because a newline in an attacker-written headline, suggested action, tag or review note would otherwise forge a whole extra `[N]` line — a fabricated instruction to clear somebody else's alert. And the live board the server derived is recorded on the session, so `ack_alert` refuses any id outside it — on EVERY session, web included; the web previously had no check at all. The recorded set is the whole live board (the cap `/today` renders as cards), not just the rows the digest printed, so a card past the digest's 30-row render cap is still ackable rather than sending the principal back to the page. Be precise about what this buys: it stops an id that is invented, closed, snoozed or expired, including one quoted out of an attacker-written alert body. It does NOT stop the model being argued into acking the wrong LIVE card — one alert's body can still make a case about another id that is genuinely open. Scoping trust to the single item under discussion would need the primer id carried server-side, which it is not.\n\n### Handler failures\n\nAn adapter's catch-all replies \"I encountered an error processing your request.\" On Slack that used to be the whole story — one uncorrelated log line, no audit row, and an unguarded error-send that could itself escape into Bolt. It now logs with the session, sender, channel, thread and mode, and writes an `integration_inbound` row with `details.outcome=\"handler_error\"`, joining the inbound row under the same `session_id`. Upstream, a single crashing tool handler no longer takes the turn down at all: the orchestrator's tool gathers use `return_exceptions=True`, hand the model an error `tool_result`, and audit it with `ok=false` (cancellation is re-raised, not swallowed).\n\n### Attachments\n\n`integrations.attachments` handles web chat, Discord, Telegram, Slack and Google Chat. Images become Anthropic vision blocks; documents (PDF/DOCX/XLSX/TXT/MD/CSV) are inlined into the turn that carried them — inside an `<untrusted_content source=\"attachment\" author=\"<name>\">` block (`content_trust.wrap_untrusted`, whose closing tag the text cannot forge), under an `[Attached: <name>]` label, which the open-loop pass reads as \"not the speaker's words\" and the decision extractor strips before it reads the turn — and indexed into the ChromaDB `inbound_attachments` collection. 20 MB/file cap; web chat uses `POST /chat/upload`.\n\n**Voice notes** are transcribed before the turn, since the model takes no audio. `providers.transcription` calls any OpenAI-compatible `POST {base}/audio/transcriptions` server: `TRANSCRIPTION_BASE_URL` (with `TRANSCRIPTION_API_KEY` / `TRANSCRIPTION_MODEL`) wins, otherwise OpenRouter when `OPENROUTER_API_KEY` is set (`elevenlabs/scribe-v2`), otherwise there is none and a voice note becomes a line asking the sender to type it. Recordings are capped at 25 MB and `TRANSCRIPTION_MAX_SECONDS` (300), the length read on the server from the Ogg, WebM, MP4 or WAV container (`recording_seconds`), since the servers bill by length and the browser's own stop can be skipped; a file whose length can't be read (mp3, flac, aac) is held to 16 KB per allowed second. A file can misstate its own length, so the bound that holds is bytes: at most `TRANSCRIPTION_MAX_MB_PER_DAY` (200) go to the speech server per UTC day, failed calls included. A voice note the sender recorded in the chat app (a Telegram voice or video note, a Discord voice message, a Slack clip; `AttachmentItem.voice_note`) becomes their own words (`[Voice note, transcribed]`; those senders are roster-gated). The reply is the answer alone, with no echo of what was heard. Any other audio (a Telegram audio file, an uploaded recording, anything on Google Chat) may hold someone else's voice, so its words are attachment text, untrusted-wrapped like a document's. An email's audio attachments (up to 2) are transcribed into attachment text, untrusted-wrapped like a document's. Each call writes one usage row (actor `transcription`, with the cost the server reports) and tells any `add_usage_listener` listener. The web chat mic records in the browser and posts to `POST /chat/transcribe`; the words go into the message box to read and send.\n\n**Scanned PDFs** are read, not reported empty. A PDF with no text layer goes through `knowledge.pdf_reader`: with `PDF_PROVIDER_READING=true` (opt-in, off by default) the deployment's own model reads it through its provider's PDF support (Anthropic natively, OpenRouter's `file-parser`, a local server only with `LOCAL_PDF_INPUT`); otherwise, and as the fallback, local OCR (pypdfium2 + RapidOCR, offline, no key) — so every deployment converts them. The label then reads `(converted from scanned pages)`, and an unreadable one says why. The index takes the text already extracted for the turn, so a scan is converted once. A file a channel delivered (everything here except `POST /chat/upload`, where the signed-in user sends it) converts at most `PDF_INBOUND_MAX_PAGES` (30) pages and draws on a rolling `PDF_INBOUND_PAGES_PER_HOUR` (300) budget shared by all senders, so sending scans cannot run up unbounded model spend or CPU.\n\nPer channel:\n- **Slack** — a `file_share` message (previously dropped outright for its `subtype`) is handled like any message; files download only after the roster gate and the response gate, with the bot token sent only to `https://files.slack.com/` (needs the `files:read` scope). History and peer memory record the words plus `(Attached files: …)`, never a document's text.\n- **Google Chat** — uploaded attachments download through `media.download` with the reply credentials (`chat.bot`), checked against the 20 MB cap per chunk, 5 per message; an attachment-only message is no longer dropped. The webhook authenticates Google, not the sender, so files are read only when the event's `user.email` is on the People roster (a team member); anyone else's files are named to the Executive, never downloaded. A Drive file shared into a message is left to the Drive tools, with its id.\n- **Email** — the poller (`integrations.email_attachments`) downloads up to 5 readable attachments of the message itself via `get_gmail_attachment_content` — workspace-mcp in stdio mode saves the file and answers `Saved to: <path>`, which must start its line, be the last such line and end in the answer's `Saved filename:` (the answer echoes the sender-chosen attachment name first, and a name carrying `Saved to: /…` must not redirect the read), then resolve inside the tool download folders — and appends their text to the turn (15k chars each). Image attachments (PNG/JPEG/GIF/WebP) go the same way into vision blocks for the turn: up to 3, none under 10 KB (signature logos, tracking pixels) and none over 3 MB (the model API's 5 MB base64 limit). A registered mail source's `read_attachments` may return images too (`EmailAttachments`). Only for a sender the principal knows (team, contact, principal); a stranger's files stay a list. It runs outside the model loop, so it works on private turns without adding the attachment tool to `PRIVATE_TURN_MCP_TOOLS`.\n- Anything else (a Drive PDF, a skipped attachment) — the Executive's `read_document` tool.\n\nIndexed chunks are keyed on `attachment:<bare filename>` and tagged `type=attachment`. An attachment's name is chosen by whoever sent the message and the name is the chunk-id namespace, so without the prefix an inbound `strategy-2026.md` would upsert over the curated company document of that name. The prefix separates inbound content from curated uploads and keeps provenance visible; it does not separate senders from one another.\n\nIsolation is the **collection**: `retriever.retrieve` never queries `inbound_attachments` at all, so an attachment cannot resurface as company knowledge in a later, unrelated turn. Attachment processing is roster-gated on Discord too — it previously ran before the gate, so an unrostered sender's file was downloaded and indexed before their message was dropped. These rows still have no operator surface: they are never written to `company/docs/`, so `GET /documents` does not list them.\n\nThis replaced a domain-based scheme that did not work. The chunks lived in `company_docs` under a domain outside the specialist set, on the premise that an unrecognised domain matched no filter. It matched every one — `ChromaDBStore.query` attaches a `where` clause only when a domain filter is present, and an Executive-level retrieval passes none — so attachments came back under “From your company documents”, top-ranked and indistinguishable from a curated upload. Legacy rows are migrated across on boot.\n\n### MCP gateway & outbound\n\nMCP runs in **both directions**. As a *client*, `orchestrator.mcp_gateway.MCPGateway` proxies MCP servers (Gmail, Calendar, Drive, Outlook mail and calendar — whatever `mcp_servers.json` configures) as Executive tools, with egress gating on Gmail recipients, Calendar attendees, Drive share grantees, and Microsoft 365 recipients/attendees against the roster (and a refusal of public / whole-domain Drive sharing). The Gmail gate also accepts only a fixed set of argument keys, so workspace-mcp's `reply_all` (recipients taken from the thread, never checked) and `forward_message_id` / `include_forwarded_attachments` (forwarding any inbox message) are refused; a reply is `thread_id` plus an explicit, roster-checked `to`. Three more refusals close paths around those gates: every Apps Script tool (code running as the Executive's account, outside the gates, and since workspace-mcp 1.29.0 schedulable to keep running); any argument that makes the server fetch a URL (`fileUrl` / `file_url` on the Drive and import tools, a Gmail attachment given as a `url`), since the fetch can carry data out in its query string before any recipient gate matters; and text Google would mail to someone the roster never checked (`rsvp_comment` to an event's organizer, an out-of-office `decline_message` to whoever invites the Executive). Every gate reads its arguments by normalized spelling: workspace-mcp 1.29.0 renames a camelCase key such as `Attendees`, `userGoogleEmail` or `rsvpComment` to the real parameter, so a gate matching the exact key would never see it. Arguments that are not a JSON object are refused for the same reason. Google-side fetches are refused too: any key ending in `url` / `uri` at any depth whose value has a URL scheme (a Slides image or page background, a Docs or Forms image; a document hyperlink and a meeting link are stored, not fetched, and pass, as does a Drive file id), (a value is a URL after the characters a URL parser strips are removed, and `//host` counts), and on every tool that can write cells — the Sheets tools and the Drive create / update / import tools, which turn CSV into a Sheet — any string anywhere holding a formula call that fetches (`IMPORTDATA`, `IMPORTXML`, `IMPORTHTML`, `IMPORTFEED`, `IMAGE`), JSON-encoded or mid-CSV included: a string argument that encodes JSON is read as the server decodes it (one too large to read is refused), text is also scanned with character references decoded and comments / CDATA removed, and an upload that would become a native Sheet may only be text `content` — a `base64_content` or server-side `file_path` upload there is refused, since an XLSX hides its formulas behind zip members and XML encodings; a PNG to Drive or a DOCX to Docs is untouched. Not covered, unverified: whether Drive's HTML / Markdown import fetches an `<img src>` when it converts `content` into a Doc. A `manage_event` call that names no attendees is sent with `send_updates=\"none\"`, so the event's existing guests are not emailed text the gate never checked. A delete is sent the same way, except the typed `cancel_calendar_event` of a meeting the Executive booked, which keeps its cancellation notice. Google Docs, Sheets, Slides, Forms and Drive writes run only on files and folders the Executive's own Google account owns (`_check_google_file_write`, read through `get_drive_file_permissions` at call time, fail-closed; only a name starting with a read verb skips it), as OneDrive writes do. Someone added to People in the current turn is left out of the allow-list until the next turn. The allow-list (`_egress_sets`, built by `_roster_allow_set` as a `people.identity.RosterAllow`) is every team member's email and email aliases plus the Executive's own address, always, and — for a teammate — any address on one of the company's own domains whose local part (`+tag` dropped) matches theirs, the same rule inbound mail is matched by; a **contact's** email joins it only when `people_tools.contacts_reachable_now()` is true — a turn the principal started on a verified surface (web chat, their own Slack or Discord, a verified private Telegram chat), or inside `grant_contact_egress()` (the decisions approve route, when the approver is the principal). On any other turn — an inbound email, a teammate, the scheduler, a workflow, the alert review — a contact's address is refused exactly like a stranger's, so the refusal cannot reveal that it belongs to a contact (contacts are private to the principal). The single exception to the roster rule is the fixed roster-request acknowledgement above, under its one-shot `roster_ack_grant`. A turn about the principal's private mail (`Session.private_to_principal`) narrows the list to the principal's own address and the Executive's. Such a turn may call only the MCP tools in `schedule_tools.PRIVATE_TURN_MCP_TOOLS`: Google Workspace reads (`search_gmail_messages`, `get_gmail_message_content`, `get_events`, `list_calendars`, `query_freebusy`, and the Drive, Docs and Sheets reads such as `search_drive_files`, `get_drive_file_content`, `get_doc_content` and `read_sheet_values`) and the two Gmail tools this gate narrows to the principal (`send_gmail_message`, `draft_gmail_message`). It is an exact allow-list, not a server: workspace-mcp runs at the tier `WORKSPACE_MCP_TOOL_TIER` names, `complete` by default, where a Google Chat message to a space, a Docs, Sheets or Drive write into a file already shared with others, `manage_event` on a shared calendar (its gate checks attendees and pins notifications, nothing else) reaches people with no recipient check; and every other server has none at all (a Slack or Notion server, the default `fetch` server, whose URL can carry the turn's content, a server loaded at runtime). Its `search_tools` results show only the allowed tools (`workflows.tool_catalog.filter_search_results`; output it cannot parse reads as no match), and a `call_tool` naming anything else is refused with an error tool_result and an audit row private to the principal (`schedule_tools.private_turn_withholds`), a missing name included. `search_tools` and `call_tool` stay offered, so the tool list and its cached prefix do not change. The typed calendar tool (`_resolve_attendees`) and the chat DM tools (`message_person`, `send_telegram_message`, `send_discord_dm` and their person-id recovery) apply the same rule — a contact's id reads as an unknown one off the principal's turn — and a private turn may DM or invite only the principal (`PRIVATE_TURN_REFUSAL` otherwise); `message_person` never falls back to a \"Needs you\" alert for a contact, who cannot sign in to see it. The Google Workspace server (`workspace-mcp`) behind those Gmail/Calendar/Drive tools runs **co-located inside the API** as a stdio child of the gateway — fitting the single-tenant model (one install = one company = one exec Google account), so there's no separate service to operate. It's baked into the API image and launched by `docker/workspace-mcp-launch.sh`, which selects single-user OAuth (token persisted at `/data/google_credentials`) or service-account domain-wide delegation from `GWORKSPACE_AUTH_MODE`. The optional `WORKSPACE_MCP_TOOLS` (comma-separated service names, default `all`) limits which Google services it loads. The gateway forwards the Google secrets to the child via `_FORWARDED_ENV_VARS`. Every `google_workspace__*` call acts as the Executive's own account. workspace-mcp takes the acting account per call (`user_google_email`) and nothing used to check it, so under domain-wide delegation a model-chosen address could open anyone's mailbox in the domain; `mcp_gateway._check_acting_account` now refuses a value naming any other address — before every other gate, with an `integration_outbound_blocked` audit row. An absent value stays allowed (the server's own account).\n\n**What the model is told is connected.** `MCPGateway.start()` records the configured server names (`server_names`), and the Executive renders them with the channel settings into block 0's *Connected Systems* section (`prompts.connected_systems`; see the caching section). While Google is connected that section pins the Google tool names the Executive uses constantly (`GOOGLE_TOOL_MANIFEST`, narrowed by `connected_systems.google_tool_manifest` to the services and tier actually loaded) and tells it to call them with `call_tool` directly, with no `search_tools` round trip. The narrowing is the point: a name pinned for a service workspace-mcp never imported is not in the index, so the model calls it, receives extensible-mcp's “has not been discovered via search_tools” refusal, and has no way to square that with its own instructions. extensible-mcp only runs a tool one of the session's searches has returned, and remembers it for the session's life, so the gateway does that discovery itself: the lifespan starts `MCPGateway.prime_pinned_tools()` in the background once the gateway is up with `google_workspace` configured (an exact-name search per pinned tool, the way `workflows.tool_catalog.resolve` does it, over the same narrowed set the prompt advertises — `connected_systems.pinned_google_tools`, so priming never probes a service that was not loaded). A name neither the prompt nor priming can account for is logged once, naming both causes: excluded by `WORKSPACE_MCP_TOOLS` / `WORKSPACE_MCP_TOOL_TIER`, or renamed by workspace-mcp since the pin. A pinned call that still comes back with extensible-mcp's \"has not been discovered via search_tools\" refusal, for example before priming finished, is discovered and retried once. That happens after every gate has passed the same arguments, and only for pinned names: any other tool still needs the model's own search, and nothing here widens what a call may do, including the private-turn allow-list.\n\n**Microsoft 365** is the Outlook twin: `@softeria/ms-365-mcp-server` (a Node package, pinned) is installed in a throwaway Node build stage and only the `node` binary plus the package are copied into the API image, launched by `docker/ms365-mcp-launch.sh` as the `microsoft_365` entry with an **explicit tool allow-list** (`--enabled-tools`, an anchored regex) rather than the upstream `mail,calendar` preset — that preset also registers inbox forwarding rules, mailbox settings (external auto-reply), calendar sharing and event forwarding, which can address people the gateway never sees. Exactly the Outlook mail + calendar tools and the OneDrive tools are exposed (`microsoft_365__send-mail`, `microsoft_365__create-calendar-event`, `microsoft_365__search-onedrive-files`, …; hyphenated Graph endpoint aliases, proxied verbatim), and every admitted tool is either roster-gated or carries no recipient; the gate also covers the excluded writers in case an operator widens the list. Both servers can be configured at once. Auth is the MSAL device-code flow against the operator's own Entra app registration (`MS365_MCP_CLIENT_ID` is required; the server's built-in public client is refused); the refresh token persists at `/data/ms365_credentials` and is seeded once with `ms365-mcp-launch.sh --login` from inside the container — the server has a native device-code CLI, so there is no mint script and nothing to copy. The launcher scrubs the literal `$VAR` placeholders extensible-mcp leaves for unset variables (otherwise MSAL would be handed `$MS365_MCP_TENANT_ID` as an authority), and `MS365_MCP_EXPECTED_USERNAME` pins the bound mailbox. The egress gate for this family walks Graph's nested shapes (`body.Message.toRecipients[].emailAddress.address`, `body.attendees[]…`) — every email-shaped string outside the free-text fields must be on the roster, control characters and non-ASCII addresses are refused, unforeseen keys are still scanned (fail-closed) — and covers the whole write surface: send, reply, reply-all, forward, every draft tool, `update-mail-message` (it can PATCH recipients onto a draft) and create-/update-calendar-event; reads pass through. `delete-calendar-event` makes Exchange mail every attendee, so it reads the event and roster-checks the attendees first, except the typed `cancel_calendar_event` of that same event. Graph's reply, reply-all and send-draft actions carry no recipient in their arguments (the recipient is whoever the referenced `messageId` names), so for those the gate first reads the referenced message through the server and roster-checks the recipients Graph will derive (`replyTo` else `from` for a reply; `replyTo` and `from` together, plus the original to/cc, for reply-all; the draft's own to/cc/bcc for send-draft), refusing on any lookup failure; RSVP and cancel actions get the same treatment through an event lookup, because their comment is emailed to the organizer or every attendee; `download-bytes` is pinned to mail attachment bytes and OneDrive file content (`/drives/{id}/items/{id}/content`, optionally Graph's `?format=pdf` rendering), and a OneDrive result comes back as the file's extracted text rather than base64 — the attachment pin is what makes the poller's promise that an unrostered sender cannot be auto-replied to hold on Outlook as it does on Gmail; and the rendered inbound text quotes any forged `--- REPLY ---` line inside a body so the persona only ever reads the real block. Every mail write's `from`, `sender` and `replyTo` may name only the Executive's own address (the Outlook twin of the Gmail acting-account pin), so the model cannot send as a rostered colleague's mailbox or steer replies elsewhere; and `move-mail-message` into Deleted Items, Junk Email or Recoverable Items is refused, so a move cannot trash mail ungated. The server registers its account tools whatever its tool allow-list says, so the gateway itself refuses `login`, `logout`, `select-account` and `remove-account` (audited like any other refusal) and drops them from `search_tools` results — a chat turn cannot sign the mailbox out, switch accounts or start a sign-in; setup is only the launcher's `--login`, and the read-only `verify-login` / `list-accounts` stay callable. The example config's hyphenated patterns still deny `delete-mail-*`, `logout`, `remove-account` and `download-bytes-to-file` as defense in depth. A successful `send-mail` records the same outbound-context linkage Gmail does.\n\n**OneDrive in chat** (opt-in with `MS365_MCP_ONEDRIVE=true` and a fresh `--login`, since the server asks for its tools' permissions on every token refresh and a sign-in without file consent would otherwise fail mail and calendar too) matches what the Executive can do on Google Drive: search, list a folder, read a file, upload and edit, create folders, move, rename, copy and share; there is no delete tool. The launcher adds `Files.Read.All` at sign-in (`--extra-scopes`), so folders shared *with* the Executive can be read too; writes (upload, new folder, move, copy) land only in the Executive's own drives, checked against `list-drives` at call time, so a planted instruction cannot save company files into a stranger's shared folder. Sharing is gated like Drive sharing: `share-drive-item` invitees must be People on the roster and named by email (an `objectId` or `alias` grantee is refused, since nothing can check it), no `owner` role, and `create-drive-item-share-link` must be scoped to specific people (`scope: \"users\"`): an anonymous or whole-organization link, or one with no scope (the tenant default), is refused. An invite must require sign-in and grant only view or edit, a link must be a view or edit link, and `search-onedrive-files` takes plain words only, since its query goes into the request path unencoded. Files Act as me's `save_my_email_attachment` copied from someone's own mail into the Executive's Drive or OneDrive (`delegation.saved_files`) are that person's alone: on any other turn the gateway refuses a call whose arguments name a recorded file id and drops the entries or lines of a result that name one, failing closed for the file tools when the record can't be read. The folders those copies go in are made by the save (never adopted by name) and recorded, and a model call naming one, by id or by an OneDrive path through it, is refused on every turn, the owner's too, with their ids hidden from results. That tool's own calls are the only Drive and OneDrive writes a turn that read the owner's mail may make: built in code, admitted past the lockdown as those exact objects (`code_built_call`), and still checked by every gate above.\n\nAs a *server*, `openexecutive.mcp_server` exposes OE's own company context and specialist council to external MCP clients at `/mcp` — the inverse direction; see the dedicated **MCP Server** section. The gateway launches extensible-mcp as a `uvx` subprocess whose fastembed tool-search index uses an embedding model baked into the API image and loaded offline, so it no longer re-downloads that model from the Hugging Face Hub on every cold start. extensible-mcp is pinned twice over: to a commit, which fixes its own code, and with `--exclude-newer`, which fixes the resolution of its dependencies — without the cutoff uvx re-resolves them against PyPI on every networked start, so a new release of any of them would reach running deployments on restart. Both live in `_EXTENSIBLE_MCP_LAUNCH_ARGS` in `orchestrator/mcp_gateway.py`, the Dockerfile's pre-warm uses the same arguments (a unit test enforces the match), so an image whose pre-warm succeeded starts the gateway with no network. The pre-warm is best-effort (`|| true`): an image built while GitHub was unreachable fetches the pinned commit on its first start instead. Updating the gateway is a deliberate bump of the commit and cutoff; `uv` itself is not pinned. Because the MCP stdio client does not inherit the parent environment, `MCPGateway.start()` explicitly forwards the embedding-cache/offline env vars (`FASTEMBED_CACHE_PATH`, `HF_HUB_OFFLINE`, …) into the child.\n\n**Emailing an artifact.** A Gmail send or draft may carry `attachments=[{\"artifact_id\": \"alert:12\", \"as\"?: \"docx\"}]`. `call_tool` runs the recipient gate first; only if it passes does `_expand_artifact_attachments` replace each such entry with the rendered file (`content` base64 + `filename` + `mime_type`, workspace-mcp's own attachment shape), produced by `artifact_records.render_artifact_file` — the same renderer as `/artifacts/{id}/download`. Only artifact rows resolve (never an arbitrary alert), links have no file, and an entry mixing `artifact_id` with other keys is refused. A stringified or single-object `attachments` is normalised first, so an artifact entry can never reach workspace-mcp unexpanded (it would silently drop it). At most 5 distinct artifacts per email (repeats are dropped) and 15 MB rendered in total; rendering runs off the event loop via `asyncio.to_thread`. A refusal writes `artifact_attachment_refused`; a successful send writes `artifact_attached` — both carry the recipients. Other attachment entries pass through unchanged. The same expansion serves the Microsoft 365 mail writes: the entry becomes a Graph `#microsoft.graph.fileAttachment` (`name`, `contentType`, `contentBytes`) placed where Graph expects it for that tool (`body.Message.attachments` for `send-mail`, reply, forward and the createReply drafts; `body.attachments` for `create-draft-email`), whether the model put it at the top level or inside the message; an entry anywhere else, one on `update-mail-message` or `send-draft-message` (their requests cannot carry attachments), or one behind a body that is not an object is refused rather than forwarded unexpanded.\n\n**Enablement, and why it degrades instead of dying.** `MCP_ENABLED` left unset is inferred from the presence of `mcp_servers_config_path` — dropping an `mcp_servers.json` next to `profile.yaml` turns MCP on with no further configuration. An **explicit** setting always wins in both directions: `MCP_ENABLED=false` keeps MCP off with the file still in place. It did not: `_resolve_mcp` tested `not self.mcp_enabled`, which cannot tell \"never set\" from \"set to false\", so the file's presence silently overrode the operator. The file is probed through `config.mcp_config_file_present`, never `Path.exists` directly — that re-raises an EACCES on a parent directory, and from inside a validator that comes out of `Settings()` itself, which `api/main.py` calls at module level. The check now reads `model_fields_set` (the fields the env actually supplied) and stores that on a private attr behind the read-only `mcp_auto_enabled` property, because the validator's own assignment joins that set and would otherwise make every auto-enable look explicit downstream.\n\nStartup is **best-effort**, in `main._start_mcp_gateway`. Two checks come before the subprocess: MCP off is a no-op, and a config defining no servers under `mcpServers` is logged and skipped — extensible-mcp's own loader raises on that and exits, and because the child is already gone the only thing that surfaces is anyio's \"Attempted to exit cancel scope in a different task\" from `stdio_client` unwinding, a traceback naming nothing about configuration. The start is also bounded (120s, generous because that child may still clone extensible-mcp on a cold start if the image's pre-warm failed): `ClientSession` carries no `read_timeout_seconds`, so `initialize()` waits forever on a child that is *alive but silent*, and an unbounded wait is a lifespan that never yields — the same healthcheck-never-passes symptom, which no `except` can see. A gateway that fails anyway is logged at ERROR with the config path, the servers it named, and whether the config file or an explicit `MCP_ENABLED` turned MCP on, then torn down under its own timeout; the API boots **without MCP tools and without the email poller** rather than refusing to boot. The guard catches `BaseException`, not `Exception`, re-raising a bare `CancelledError` first: the original failure came from anyio, which wraps a task group's failures in `BaseExceptionGroup` as soon as one is a `BaseException` — and that group is not an `Exception`, so `except Exception` would miss the very shape this contains. The teardown is contained too, since it runs from inside that `except` and would otherwise replace the actionable log with the crash it prevents. `configured_server_names` never raises either, and deliberately catches broadly: it reads an operator-owned path during startup, where an exception is the crash loop rather than a bug report — `Path.is_file` re-raises an EACCES on a parent directory, and `json.loads` answers deeply-nested input with `RecursionError`, which is not a `ValueError`. It tests `is_file()` so a directory or a symlink to a FIFO is never opened, and caps the read at 1 MiB. That exception used to propagate out of the lifespan and kill the container — under `restart: unless-stopped`, a crash loop whose only outward symptom was a healthcheck that never passed. Outbound tools: per-Person DMs (`send_slack_dm`, `send_discord_dm`, `send_telegram_message`) plus room-targeted `send_department_message` and `send_company_broadcast`. All three per-Person DMs refuse a recipient id that matches no non-archived Person row (`schedule_tools._dm_recipient_on_roster`), which is what stops untrusted content in a turn — inbound mail, a chat message, a knowledge document — from directing a DM at an arbitrary workspace member. `send_slack_dm` previously consulted the roster only when the turn was already private to the principal, so on an ordinary turn it applied no roster check at all while its Discord and Telegram siblings did; the room-targeted tools are deliberately ungated, since those channels are team-visible. The per-Person DMs are additionally rate-limited and de-duplicated by the outbound anti-spam guard (below).\n\n### Outbound anti-spam guard\n\nEvery per-Person DM passes a deterministic guard (`orchestrator.outbound_guard.check_outbound_allowed`) after the roster gate and recipient-id recovery but before the network send — the single chokepoint **all** proactive DM paths reach (ad-hoc chat sends, the scheduler's followup/nudge dispatch, principal-brief delivery, the reflection turn, and research-finding routing). On a violation it returns a human-readable reason and the handler **suppresses** the send (`{\"status\":\"suppressed\",\"reason\":…}`), writes a `tool_invocation` audit row with `suppressed=true`, and writes **no** `done` activity row — so a blocked attempt never counts toward its own rate cap, and the Executive can read the reason and hold or `schedule_followup` for the recipient's next window. Three controls: **content dedup** (a near-identical message — whitespace/case-normalized, first 160 chars — already sent to the same recipient within `OUTBOUND_DEDUP_WINDOW_MINUTES`, default 360); a **per-recipient rate cap** (`OUTBOUND_MAX_PER_RECIPIENT_PER_WINDOW`, default 5, over `OUTBOUND_RATE_WINDOW_MINUTES`, default 60); and **quiet hours / availability** (`OUTBOUND_RESPECT_QUIET_HOURS`, default on — refuse while the recipient is on leave or outside their `people.channel` availability windows, surfacing the next open window). Delivery history is read from the existing `status='done'` `scheduled_actions` rows (`episodic.recent_sends_for_channel_ref`), so there is no new table. The guard is **fail-open**: any internal lookup error returns \"allow\", so it can never turn a working send into a crash or a silently-dropped message. Principal briefs and the internal heartbeat kinds use the `__internal__` channel and never reach these handlers, so they are unaffected. Once the guard allows a send, the handlers apply the recipient's own notification settings to the Executive's own (tagged) outreach: in their quiet hours, or when they chose *In my briefs*, the DM is stored and returned as `{\"status\":\"held\"}` rather than sent, and goes when quiet hours end or with their next brief (`outbound_guard.check_hold`; see Org).\n\n### AI disclosure\n\nWhat the Executive sends says it is an AI assistant (`orchestrator.disclosure`), added by plain code so a reply the model writes can't leave it out. **Mail** from its own mailbox gets a line under the body, by default \"<EXEC_DISPLAY_NAME> is an AI assistant working for <company>. To reach a person, reply and ask, or write to <principal's address>.\": the MCP gateway adds it to every Gmail send and draft and every Outlook send, reply, forward and draft (`mcp_gateway._with_disclosure`) **after** every outbound gate has passed and only on what goes to the server, so the gates, the outbound-context record and the audit see the model's own words, and `send_from_executive` gets it the same way. It counts as already there only when it is the last line that shows (in a quoted earlier message or hidden in markup it doesn't), and a send of an existing draft and mail whose every recipient is the principal go as they are. HTML that could hide what follows (an unclosed comment, a style or script block, text styled out of sight: `disclosure.hides_what_follows`) is refused, so the line can't be hidden after it; the model is told to send plain text. The roster acknowledgement to a new sender, the one send to an address nobody checked, gets `BARE_MAIL_LINE` (\"This message was sent by an AI assistant.\"), which names no one, like the acknowledgement itself. **Chat** gets a shorter line (\"<name> · AI assistant\", in italics) on the Executive's replies in Slack, Telegram, Discord and Google Chat and on its own DMs and room posts (`send_slack_dm`, `send_discord_dm`, `send_telegram_message`, `broadcast_tools._dispatch`), but only on the first message in a conversation and again after 24 hours without one (`with_chat_line`, kept in memory, so a restart shows it once more); session history keeps the reply without it. `AI_DISCLOSURE` (default on) turns it off; `AI_DISCLOSURE_MAIL_TEXT` / `AI_DISCLOSURE_CHAT_TEXT` reword the lines, and a wording that doesn't say \"AI\" is ignored for the built-in one. It fails open: a line that can't be built is left off, never a send refused. Replies sent *as a person* under Act as me are the delegation section's (**AI line on replies**).\n\n### Calendar & video links\n\nThe Executive books meetings through two typed tools over the configured calendar backend (`CALENDAR_PROVIDER`: Google Calendar via `manage_event`, or Outlook via `create-calendar-event` — see *Workspace providers*). `create_calendar_event` schedules a **future** meeting (propose→approve by default, or auto-execute once that decision class is promoted) and may be used proactively when a stalled goal warrants a sync. `create_instant_meeting` spins up an **impromptu call starting now**, auto-executing without the approval step and skipping the business-hours/horizon caps, so the Executive can hand back a join link immediately. Because nothing approves it, an instant meeting, and `cancel_calendar_event` too, runs only when someone on the team asked on a surface that verified who they are (the principal, or a rostered teammate in the app or their own chat); a turn an inbound email started gets a refusal to pass on instead, and a team-mode `create_calendar_event` the operations department would auto-execute is proposed instead. Both attach a video-meeting link by default (`add_video_link`; opt out for in-person) — a **Google Meet** link read from `manage_event`'s plain-text reply (which also carries the event id, inside the event link's `eid`), or a **Microsoft Teams** link from `onlineMeeting.joinUrl` — surfaced to the caller plus persisted on the decision ledger as `meet_link`. The tool descriptions are static, backend-neutral text, so the cached tool block never depends on settings; the pre-rename `add_google_meet` key is still honoured for old ledger rows. Either way the caps that matter still hold — roster membership, principal-protection, max attendees, and a daily booking ceiling. A proposal raised in the web chat by the person who approves it (the principal, or its approver when it isn't the principal's private booking) says `approve_here`; its `action_taken` chip then carries the `decision_id`, and the chat shows the approval card (Approve, Edit, Dismiss) under the reply as well as on the briefing — answering either clears both. A booked meeting whose event id was never read can't be cancelled from the app: both cancel paths refuse rather than report a cancel that left it on the calendar.\n\n**Around-the-meeting participation.** The Executive doesn't join the call as a live voice; instead, on every successful booking it schedules a best-effort post-meeting follow-up (~5 min after the end) that DMs a human attendee asking for a quick recap — key decisions and action items. The reply flows back through the same cross-session DM context linkage described below, so the Executive can act on it (summarize, follow up) in a later turn. No meeting-transcript or Drive integration is required.\n\n### Workspace providers\n\nThe Executive can *discover* any mail or calendar tool the gateway exposes, but three code paths call a fixed backend with no model in the loop and used to spell Gmail tool names inline: the inbound mailbox poller (list unread → fetch → mark read), alert email dispatch plus the scheduler's email send-tool hint, and the typed booking tools plus the approval-time conflict check. `integrations.workspace` puts those behind two Protocols (`MailProvider`, `CalendarProvider`) with one module per backend (`google.py`, `microsoft.py`) and a registry keyed on `EMAIL_PROVIDER` / `CALENDAR_PROVIDER` — separate switches (Outlook mail with a Google calendar is legitimate), both defaulting to `google`, so an existing install changes nothing until an operator opts in. The Google backend is the old inline code moved verbatim; tests pin its argument dicts byte-for-byte. The Microsoft backend polls only the Inbox folder (`list-mail-folder-messages` with `isRead eq false`, never the all-folders listing that includes Junk), converts Graph's HTML bodies to text with a real parser, lists a message's attachments so the names appear in the same `N. name (mime, size KB)` shape Gmail's text uses (and reach peer memory), marks read with `update-mail-message`, sends through `send-mail`'s nested shape, books with `isOnlineMeeting` + `onlineMeetingProvider=teamsForBusiness`, cancels with `delete-calendar-event`, and answers the advisory conflict check from the Executive's **own** calendar view (delegated permissions cannot read attendees' free/busy — narrower than Google's `query_freebusy`).\n\nEvery backend renders an inbound message into the same `Subject:` / `From:` / `To:` / `Cc:` + `--- BODY ---` text the persona already expects, and the poller adds a `--- REPLY ---` block naming the exact reply tool and threading ids for *that* message (Gmail: `send_gmail_message` + `thread_id`; Outlook: `reply-mail-message` + `messageId`) after the mail's `<untrusted_content>` block, never inside it. The block rides in the user turn — which is what lets the cached persona say \"use the reply tool in the REPLY block\" instead of naming a vendor tool — and the scheduler's proactive-email trigger names the backend's send tool the same way. Providers never raise on a malformed backend response (they return empty / `None` / `{\"error\": …}`), so one bad cycle never kills a loop, and a chosen backend whose MCP server is missing from `mcp_servers.json` is logged at startup and skipped by the poller: fail-soft, never a boot failure. The poller's newer checks run on that rendered text for both backends (contacts and private turns, roster requests and their emailed answers, the audit row), with three Outlook differences that fail closed: a sender is authenticated from Exchange's own stamp instead of Gmail's (`fact_confirmation.sender_authenticated` reads the message's Graph `internetMessageHeaders` and applies `delegation.outlook.exchange_authenticated`: the topmost `Authentication-Results` with EOP's `compauth=`, a DMARC pass for the From domain, or for a domain with no DMARC record a single DKIM pass with `header.d=` that domain, and never mail a list resent or a stamp echoing `smtp.helo=`; it relies on Exchange Online stamping every message, so a tenant whose mail arrives through another server without that stamp gets no real proof), but there is no acknowledgement to an unknown sender (the one-shot grant admits only Gmail's send tool); attachments stay a list (the download is Gmail's); and the brief's calendar block is skipped (its listing is Google Calendar's). The code's own emails to the principal (roster prompts, fact confirmations, scheduled deliveries) go through `workspace.registry.send_from_executive`, and `runner.email_ready` follows `EMAIL_PROVIDER`. A private turn's allow-list (`schedule_tools.PRIVATE_TURN_MCP_TOOLS`) and Act as me's mail-touched reads include the Outlook twins of the Gmail and Calendar tools, and roster answer tokens are hidden from Microsoft 365 results as from Google's.\n\n### Cross-session DM context\n\nWhen the principal says \"DM Alex about X\" in one session, OE sends the DM and — if a live conversation is active and the recipient is not one of the principal's contacts (a contact cannot DM the bot, and quoting the principal's conversation into their email reply's unattended turn would put it in the audit log) — records an `outbound_context` linkage row (recipient, full outbound text, originating session id). Email is covered too but recorded one layer deeper — there is no `send_email` tool, so the linkage is written in `orchestrator.mcp_gateway` after a successful `google_workspace__send_gmail_message` or `microsoft_365__send-mail`, one row per `to`/`cc` recipient keyed by the bare lowercased address (OE's own address skipped). When Alex later replies on the 1:1 DM path — or by email — the shared helper `integrations.inbound_hydration.hydrate_user_message` (called by the Discord, Telegram, and Slack handlers, and by the email poller keyed on the sender address) looks up the most-recent `open` linkage for that sender within 72h and prepends an `<outbound_reply_context>` block — the outbound text plus a backstory excerpt from the originating session — to the message handed to `Executive.chat()`. So OE knows what the reply is about instead of starting from an empty per-person session. The block is context for the LLM turn only: peer memory strips it before recording what the person said (`strip_outbound_reply_context`, applied in `sync_turn`, `sync_department_turn` and to the prefetch query), so the Executive's own DM is never attributed to the person who replied to it. The block lands in the user turn (caching rule) and is injected into a copy only — the pristine reply is persisted to history. The linkage is one-shot (consumed on first matched reply, race-safe) so an unrelated later DM isn't re-hydrated. This is deterministic and independent of the per-person `peer_memory` (Honcho) layer.\n\nEvery adapter that persists a turn (Slack, Discord, Telegram, and the web route) records the message's **resolved sender** on `chat_messages.sender_person_id` — the rostered Person the adapter matched, or NULL for an unrostered sender — independently of the session owner, which falls back to the principal on Discord and Telegram so those threads stay visible. Attunement's open loops and feedback rely on this so an outsider's words are never read as someone on the roster's.\n\n### OneDrive folder sync\n\nThe Microsoft twin of the Drive folder sync below (`knowledge.onedrive_sync`, `ONEDRIVE_SYNC_ENABLED`; setup in `docs/onedrive_sync_setup.md`). It copies the files in `ONEDRIVE_SYNC_FOLDERS` (`<drive id>/<item id>` pairs; `openexecutive onedrive-folder <link>` resolves a sharing link) into the isolated `onedrive_docs` collection on its own heartbeat, and shows them on the knowledge page as \"OneDrive\" rows with a **Sync now** button. Microsoft has no service account that sees only what is shared with it (app-only Graph access covers the whole tenant), so it reads as the Executive's own Microsoft 365 sign-in, and the folder list is the scope. It never stores a credential: each tick asks the launcher for a token (`ms365-mcp-launch.sh --access-token`, which runs `docker/ms365-access-token.mjs` through the server's own token cache and will only mint file-read tokens), keeps it in memory, and sends it only to Graph. `knowledge.onedrive_client` issues GETs only, follows a paging link only back to Graph, and fetches a file's pre-authenticated download link without the token; errors never carry that link. PowerPoint and older Office formats are read through Graph's PDF rendering.\n\n### Google Drive folder sync\n\nThe synced files show on the knowledge page's Company documents list as \"Google Drive\" rows (sync time, last edit in Drive, an Open in Drive link and a text view), and the page's source card shows the last run, any sign-in error or count of files that failed to sync, and a **Sync now** button that runs one tick on demand.\n\n\nSeparate from the Drive tools the gateway proxies. The optional folder sync (`knowledge.drive_sync`, `DRIVE_SYNC_ENABLED`; setup in `docs/drive_sync_setup.md`) copies the files in `DRIVE_SYNC_FOLDER_IDS` into the isolated `drive_docs` knowledge collection on a scheduler heartbeat, so the Executive knows those folders without searching Drive live (see RAG). It calls the Drive v3 API directly (`knowledge.drive_client`, `httpx`) as a **service account** with the `drive.readonly` scope (`DRIVE_SYNC_SERVICE_ACCOUNT_FILE`), not as the Executive's own account through workspace-mcp. Google enforces the folder scope, because the account sees only what is shared with it, and the sync can change nothing. Structured JSON means no display text to parse, and every file or folder id is checked against `[A-Za-z0-9_-]{1,128}` before it goes into a URL or a query. The two paths meet in two places. A synced chunk carries its Drive file id and sync time, so the Executive can open the live file with its own `get_drive_file_content`. The setup doc says to share each synced folder with the Executive's account too, so that live open works.\n\n### Confluence space sync\n\nThe optional Confluence sync (`knowledge.confluence_sync`, `CONFLUENCE_SYNC_ENABLED`; setup in `docs/confluence_sync_setup.md`) copies the pages of the spaces in `CONFLUENCE_SYNC_SPACE_KEYS` into the isolated `confluence_wiki` knowledge collection on a scheduler heartbeat, so the Executive knows the company wiki without a tool call (see RAG). It works with Confluence Cloud and Server/Data Center: `knowledge.confluence_client` calls the v1 REST API both serve, directly with `httpx`, signing in with a personal access token (Server/DC) or a username and API token (Cloud). It reads only, never follows a redirect (so the token stays on the configured site), streams responses with a 20 MB cap, and checks page ids and space keys before they reach a URL or a CQL query. The URL must be `https://` unless `CONFLUENCE_SYNC_ALLOW_HTTP` is set, and `CONFLUENCE_SSL_VERIFY` takes `true`, `false` or a CA bundle path for a private certificate authority. With `CONFLUENCE_SYNC_PUBLIC_HOSTS_ONLY` (off by default, for an install where whoever sets the URL must not reach the backend's own network) every request resolves the site's host, refuses it when any address is not public (loopback, private, link-local, shared), and connects to the checked address with the site's name kept for the Host header and the TLS certificate check, directly rather than through a proxy. `confluence_client.config_problem` is the same settings check the app runs at start, for a caller that writes these settings on someone's behalf.\n\nIt is separate from a Confluence MCP server such as mcp-atlassian, which a deployment can add to `mcp_servers.json` for live reads and edits in chat. The two share the env names `CONFLUENCE_URL`, `CONFLUENCE_PERSONAL_TOKEN`, `CONFLUENCE_USERNAME`, `CONFLUENCE_API_TOKEN` and `CONFLUENCE_SSL_VERIFY`, so one set of values serves both, and a synced chunk carries its page id so the Executive can open the live page with such a tool. A Confluence token is a user's, and what the sync reads becomes retrievable by everyone who talks to the Executive, so the space list is required and pages with a read restriction (their own or a parent's) are skipped unless `CONFLUENCE_SYNC_SKIP_RESTRICTED=false`. That keeps any existing member's token safe to use, without a dedicated licence. Manual runs: `openexecutive sync-confluence` / `purge-confluence`.\n\n### Your own Gmail or Outlook (Act as me)\n\nA second, separate mail connection, for **Act as me** (see **Act as Me (Delegation)**): a person's *own* mailbox, which `delegation.gmail.DelegateGmail` reads and drafts into over the Gmail REST API. It is never registered with the MCP gateway, so the model can reach it only through the typed `ghostwrite_email` handler — never by tool name through `call_tool`. The credential is one file per person in `DELEGATION_GOOGLE_CREDENTIALS_DIR` (default `company/delegation_google/`, `/data/delegation_google` in Docker), minted on a computer with a browser by `scripts/connect-own-gmail.py --email <you>` with the Executive's own OAuth client and the scopes `gmail.readonly` and `gmail.compose` — the same seed-it-yourself flow as the Executive's token, since the API serves no OAuth callback. It never lives in `WORKSPACE_MCP_CREDENTIALS_DIR`, where workspace-mcp picks a credential by address.\n\nEvery use re-checks with Google that the credential opens the mailbox on the person's People entry, and refuses outright when that address is the Executive's own: a shared mailbox would make everything the Executive writes look like theirs. Drafts are threaded (`In-Reply-To`, `References` of whole ids ending with the parent, `threadId`) and stamped `X-OE-Ghostwritten`; the only send is `drafts.send` of an existing draft by id, when the person taps Send on its reply card (`delegation.reply_send`). A Gmail rate limit, even as a 403, is an error to retry rather than a reconnect. The voice learner and the thread shown to the ghostwriter keep only each sender's own words through `email_poller.sender_new_text`, the poller's quoted-reply stripper made public. Setup status shows it as **Your own mailbox (Act as me)**.\n\nThe same file can instead hold an Outlook sign-in (`\"provider\": \"microsoft\"`), minted by `scripts/connect-own-outlook.py --email <you>` with a device-code sign-in on the Executive's own Entra app (`MS365_MCP_CLIENT_ID`, `MS365_MCP_TENANT_ID`, default `common`) and the delegated scopes `User.Read`, `Mail.ReadWrite`, `Mail.Send` and `offline_access`. `delegation.gmail.gmail_for` then hands back `delegation.outlook.DelegateOutlook`, which talks to Microsoft Graph directly — never the Microsoft 365 MCP server the Executive's own Outlook uses — with the same methods and the same one send: Graph's `send` on an existing draft, with no body. Microsoft rotates the refresh token on use and the new one is written back into the file. A sender counts as verified only from the topmost `Authentication-Results`, the one Exchange wrote, and only mail in their Sent Items counts as theirs.",
"mermaid": "flowchart TD\n Channels[\"Slack / Discord<br/>Telegram / GChat / Email\"]\n Resolve[\"find_person_by_*_id\"]\n Gate[\"roster gate\"]\n Drop[\"drop\"]\n Hold[\"roster request<br/>(hold + fixed ack,<br/>ask the principal)\"]\n Exec[\"Executive.chat()\"]\n Attach[\"attachments<br/>(vision / inbound_attachments)\"]\n MCP[\"MCP gateway\"]\n GW[\"Google Workspace<br/>(workspace-mcp child)\"]\n M365[\"Microsoft 365<br/>(ms-365-mcp-server child:<br/>Outlook + OneDrive)\"]\n WP[\"workspace providers<br/>(poller / alerts / booking)\"]\n Guard[\"outbound anti-spam guard<br/>(dedup / rate cap / quiet hours)\"]\n Out[\"DM / department<br/>/ broadcast tools\"]\n Channels --> Resolve\n Resolve --> Gate\n Gate -- \"unknown sender\" --> Hold\n Hold -- \"approved: replay\" --> Exec\n Hold -- \"contact / declined\" --> Drop\n Gate -- \"Person\" --> Exec\n Gate --> Attach\n Attach --> Exec\n Exec --> MCP\n MCP -- \"roster egress gate\" --> GW\n MCP -- \"roster egress gate\" --> M365\n WP -- \"EMAIL_PROVIDER / CALENDAR_PROVIDER\" --> MCP\n WP --> Exec\n Exec --> Guard\n Guard -- \"suppress\" --> Drop\n Guard -- \"allow\" --> Out\n Out --> Channels\n Own[(\"Principal's own Gmail<br/>(Act as me: REST, drafts only)\")]\n Exec -- \"ghostwrite_email\" --> Own\n class Channels entry\n class Resolve compute\n class Gate compute\n class Drop external\n class Hold compute\n class Exec hot\n class Attach compute\n class MCP external\n class GW external\n class M365 external\n class WP compute\n class Guard compute\n class Out compute\n class Own external",
- "generated_at": "2026-10-25T12:03:39.155927+00:00"
+ "generated_at": "2026-10-26T13:22:15.632752+00:00"
}
diff --git a/packages/core/openexecutive/architecture/prebuilt/lifecycle.json b/packages/core/openexecutive/architecture/prebuilt/lifecycle.json
index e8699985..ffb5e6a1 100644
--- a/packages/core/openexecutive/architecture/prebuilt/lifecycle.json
+++ b/packages/core/openexecutive/architecture/prebuilt/lifecycle.json
@@ -1,7 +1,7 @@
{
"section_id": "lifecycle",
"title": "Request Lifecycle",
- "markdown": "A single chat message makes a full round-trip through the API, the orchestrator's tool-use loop, a parallel specialist fan-out, and synthesis — all streamed back as server-sent events.\n\n### Steps\n\n1. **Arrival** — the client mints a `client_turn_id` and posts to `POST /chat` (`openexecutive.api.routes.chat`). The turn opens with a `<current_time>` hint: the day, date, time and zone in the workspace's timezone (`workspace_settings.get_user_timezone`, as the briefs use), so relative dates resolve against today instead of a guess; it is in the user turn because it changes every turn. It carries a `<current_speaker>` hint resolved from the caller's `person_id` (followed by that person's `<working_style>` rules when they have any — see the attunement section — and a `<lessons>` block when a lesson the conversation review learned from a miss matches the message, `memory/lessons.py`; see the memory section), plus a `<briefing>` digest of current open alerts (built in parallel with RAG/episodic/peer-memory fetches) so the Executive can discuss any item shown on the `/today` briefing page. A turn arriving from a chat adapter instead of the web app also carries a `<channel>` block naming the surface and stating which approvals can be completed there; on Slack the `<briefing>` digest is gated to the principal's DMs. All three ride in the **user turn**, never a cached system block, as does a `<drive_memory>` block naming the Drive files this conversation already found or opened and the Drive searches that matched nothing (see the memory section). A `<pending_followups>` block lists, for a verified speaker, the follow-ups they scheduled that haven't gone out (up to 10, from `correction_tools.pending_followups_block`, the same ownership rule as `list_followups`), and asks the Executive to cancel one with `cancel_followup` when the message shows it is already done or no longer needed, and say so in a line. The server registers a stop switch under that id *before* the context fetch, so a Stop pressed during those first seconds halts the turn before any model call is made.\n2. **Tool-use loop** — the `Executive` calls Claude. For a cross-domain question the assistant turn emits multiple `consult_specialist` tool-use blocks at once. The call carries the conversation so far (`Session.get_recent_history`: 20 to 30 turns, its start moving in steps of 10) with a 1h cache marker on the previous reply, so each message reads the earlier conversation from the prompt cache and writes only what is new (see Caching); on the OpenRouter path the translator keeps that marker on the reply's text. The history is re-read from the stored transcript at the start of every web turn, so a chat continued in a chat app and then reopened on the web or phone includes the turns the app added.\n The person can keep typing while it works. A message sent then (`POST /chat/add`) joins the running turn: the loop adds it after the next round's tool results, so the answer follows it, and it is saved as its own message before the reply. One that arrives while the final answer is being written becomes the next turn instead. A conversation runs one turn at a time.\n3. **Parallel fan-out** — `openexecutive.orchestrator.router.route_parallel` dispatches those calls concurrently, bounded by `MAX_PARALLEL_SPECIALISTS`; calls past the cap get a skip tool_result. A specialist that raises (a timeout, an overloaded model) or returns no text no longer fails the batch: its tool_result says it is unavailable and tells the Executive not to invent its view, the others' results stand, and the turn goes on. It does not count as consulted, so it takes no committee seat and no department memory records the turn, and its documents are left out of the answer's sources. On the web chat the reply need not mention the gap, because the app shows it under the answer; on every other channel the tool_result asks the Executive to say in one sentence that part of the analysis is missing. A knowledge retrieval that fails likewise leaves that specialist without context rather than failing the turn.\n4. **Per-specialist RAG** — each specialist runs its own domain-filtered ChromaDB query, then reasons over the retrieved chunks and returns analysis as a tool_result. Its user turn also carries a `<company_stage>` tag from the session's company profile, so stage-sensitive advice (venture benchmarks vs. cash-first for a bootstrapped company) does not depend on the Executive remembering to mention it. Once the batch is done, the documents each answering specialist's retrieval returned are named, in call order, into the turn's `TurnSources` (`orchestrator/answer_sources.py`), which the web chat route owns and which also holds its own search's documents. Synced Google Drive files are recorded as `drive` sources with their Drive link, and the web chat lists them under **Google Drive**.\n5. **Synthesis** — the Executive feeds the tool_results back to Claude and streams one coherent reply. Each round's text starts a new paragraph after the text streamed before it (`executive._round_separator`), so words the model writes before a tool call never run into its answer; nothing it writes is dropped. Every tool round — not just a specialist one — emits an `activity` event naming what is running, immediately followed by a `thinking` keepalive. The label names the *activity*, never the internal agent: \"Putting time on the calendar…\", \"Looking up people…\", or, for a connected (MCP) tool, plain words for what it does (\"Searching Drive…\"), from the same table (`orchestrator/tool_labels.py`) that names the finished chip (\"Searched Drive\"). The raw `server__tool` name never reaches the user. Under the reply, repeats of the same action collapse into one chip with a count, and tapping it lists what each run looked at. A round that really does fan out collapses to the generic \"Consulting specialists…\" — the one voice holds even in the progress line. The keepalive carries no tool information of its own; it used to drive a hardcoded \"Consulting specialists…\" string, so an MCP or calendar round misreported itself as a fan-out.\n **Do what it says.** Before the turn ends, its last reply is checked against the tool calls the turn made (`orchestrator/claim_check.py`). A reply with no word that can claim a change (\"done\", \"removed\", \"I'll remind you\"…) ends the turn as before. Otherwise one small forced-tool call on `ROUTING_MODEL` reads the person's message, the reply and each call with the start of its result, and reports a claim of a change no call made (or put up for approval). The claim must appear word for word in the reply, or it is ignored. The loop then gets one more round with a note in the user turn (never a cached block): make the change with the right tool, or say plainly it isn't done. Once a turn; a failed check lets the reply through. On the web chat the extra round streams after the first reply, separated by a blank line; chat apps send the whole reply at once. `CLAIM_CHECK_ENABLED` turns it off.\n **A chat several people are in.** When its owner shared a web chat (`session_shares`), every turn in it is labelled: the history is re-read with each person's message starting `[Name]: `, the current message too, and a note naming everyone in the chat rides in the user turn (`channel_context_block`, never a cached block). The Executive answers whoever wrote the latest message. Such a session is no private conversation (`Session.shared_chat`): Act as me is off there (`delegation.settings.private_conversation`), open loops are not listed as on a private surface, no one's mail is read there, the principal's included (`teammate_mail._reader_id`), what the Executive remembers about the speaker (peer memory) is not fetched, the alert digest leaves out the principal's private cards and roster requests (`briefing.context.render_and_trust`), and the principal-only tools are withheld whoever speaks (`content_trust.principal_only_withheld`), because the others write into what the principal's turn reads. A message that starts like a label (`[Alex]: …`) loses it before its sender's own goes in front. Peer memory still records each person's own words. Turns stay one at a time under the conversation's lock; the route publishes each one to the chat's live stream (`api.chat_live`) as it runs, so everyone else in the chat watches it happen. A chat of one publishes nothing.\n6. **Optional committee review** — when enabled, `Executive.stream_chat_with_committee()` runs a silent draft, parallel reviewer critiques, then a streamed revision pass.\n7. **Side effects** — after the reply, every rostered speaker's turn (not only the principal's) schedules a fire-and-forget **open-loop pass** (Attunement) beside the episodic extraction: a keyword prefilter, then one forced-tool call that may open or close loops, every item quote-gated against the speaker's own words. A verified speaker's turn is also kept for the **conversation review** (`memory.chat_review`, see Memory), which reads it once the chat has been quiet 30 minutes and fixes what the replies left undone, from the speaker's own quoted words. A turn that touched their mailbox, which teaches no other memory, is kept too, for their own review only (`record_turn(mail=...)`: tools by name, no results), with the words they typed rather than the blanked text the other passes get. A replay turn is never kept. The user message is persisted with `sender_person_id` — the resolved speaker, never the principal fallback a Discord / Telegram session uses for ownership — and the session records the speaker for the turn (`Session.caller_person_id`), which `close_open_loop` reads. A DM sent while proactive work is tagged (`attunement.outcomes.tag_proactive` — scheduler dispatch, reflection, research, alert review) also opens an outcome-ledger row at `_record_outbound_context`; a user's own turn is never tagged. A tagged DM is also subject to the recipient's own notification settings: in their quiet hours, or when they chose *In my briefs*, the send handler stores it (`outbound_guard.check_hold`, `people.held_messages`) and returns `{\"status\": \"held\"}` instead of sending (see Org). Any side-effecting tool call surfaces an `action_taken` chip, which unlike the ephemeral `activity` label is persisted with the assistant message; once the reply is over — also when it was stopped or timed out — the web chat route sends one `sources` event: the documents and web pages the turn looked at (its own search, each specialist that answered, web search results, and the pages the reply cites, which are always kept) and the areas (\"finance\", never a specialist) it had to go without. The web chat shows it under the reply, and it is persisted with the assistant message as `chat_messages.sources`; other channels don't collect it. The stream closes with a `done` event — preceded by a `stopped` event when the user halted the turn, in which case the partial reply is still persisted and flagged so it reads as cut short rather than complete, and is mirrored into the live in-memory session so the next turn's prompt matches what was saved. The stream still ends with `done` event. While nothing else is going out — a slow tool call, a long specialist round — the route sends an SSE comment (`: keepalive`) every `CHAT_STREAM_KEEPALIVE_S` (15 s by default, 0 for none) so a browser or proxy does not drop the connection as idle; the step it waits on keeps running across it, and the whole-turn deadline is unchanged. Every call through the MCP gateway (Gmail, Calendar, Drive, Outlook, OneDrive, tool search) has its own ceiling, `MCP_TOOL_TIMEOUT_S` (120 s): past it the model gets an error saying the tool did not answer and may still have run, so it checks before calling again, and no outbound linkage is recorded for a send that timed out. One side-effecting tool is gated server-side rather than by its description: `ack_alert` will only accept an `alert_id` from the live alert board the server itself derived this turn — the whole live set, not only the rows the `<briefing>` digest printed, since `/today` renders more cards than the digest lists and every one of them is Discuss-able — and it fails closed, so an id it cannot even parse is refused rather than waved through to the handler's own parse. That check runs on **every** session. It used to run only on turns that arrived from a chat channel, keyed on `origin_channel`, which the browser never sets — so the web, the surface the principal actually uses, was unchecked and the model could ack any id, including one quoted out of an alert body by the briefing page's Discuss handoff. What that buys is bounded and worth stating plainly: an id that is invented, closed, snoozed or expired is refused, including one quoted out of an attacker-written alert body; the model being argued into acking the wrong *live* card is not prevented. The one way to widen that set is `find_alerts`, for an item the principal names that has left the live board (already opened, snoozed, older than the board): a keyword search over alerts of every status whose own results — never an id the model supplies — join the trusted set. It runs only in a turn where `render_and_trust` showed the principal their own board (`Session.principal_board_shown`: the verified principal, and on a channel only in their DM), never merely because the session has a set — every `Session` starts with an empty one, and that empty set is how a Google Chat turn, someone else's DM or an unattended pass refuses every ack — and not on the principal's turn in a shared Slack or Discord thread either, where others read the reply and write into what the model reads. It trusts only rows still open (`unread`, `read`), never a roster-request card, and at most 25 ids per turn across calls, and refuses a query with no word of three or more letters. It also moves the admitted limit outward: a model argued into the wrong search can now reach up to 25 open alerts that are off the board, not only live ones. The board is recorded on the turn's `Session`, and the route binds that session for the **whole** SSE body (`schedule_tools.set_session`, alongside `set_turn`) rather than letting `stream_chat` bind it from inside its own generator. `_sse_body` drives the executive with `asyncio.wait_for(stream.__anext__())`, which runs each step in a fresh Task holding a *copy* of the context, so a binding made inside the generator is discarded with the step that made it: step one sees the session and every later step sees `None`. The tool-call loop runs on those later steps, so the whole guard read an empty set and refused every ack on the web — on live, open cards — until the binding moved out to the route. Anything reading `current_session` mid-turn has the same requirement, and two of them needed more than the binding to behave. `schedule_followup`'s seen-`channel_ref` anti-spam gate refuses a send to an address the session has not seen; with no session it skipped itself, so a web turn could schedule to **any** address, and with an empty one it refused even the principal's own. The route now seeds the caller's own addresses onto the session, so on web the gate means what it means on every other surface. Reply linkage (`_record_outbound_context`, read back by `inbound_hydration` to quote the originating conversation into the turn handling a recipient's reply) is the other: it was never reachable on web, and rather than switch that on for the principal's broadest surface as a side effect it is held back, keyed on an explicit `Session.from_web_chat` flag. Not on an empty `origin_channel` — alert review, the CLI and the unattended workflows all leave it empty while legitimately recording linkage, as does the email poller under its own `email` tag. `scheduled_actions` rows also take their `session_id` from the session. A session that was shown no board has an empty trusted set and can ack nothing, so the unattended passes (the nightly reflection, the research synthesis) are refused by default — they also still withhold the tool outright, which is belt-and-braces rather than the only thing stopping them. After the stream closes, the turn is also handed to the episodic memory extractor (`memory.episodic.schedule_extraction`, fire-and-forget) — on every turn where the principal said anything at all, and only the principal: a turn naming an `origin_channel` must resolve to a person marked `is_principal`, because the quote validator downstream cannot tell whose words it is checking. Both this path and the committee path call the same `should_extract` predicate, and it applies no length floor: the gate used to sum in the assistant's reply, which let a verbose answer drag a trivial turn in and discarded the short, decisive instructions that are the whole point of extracting. A user-side floor would fare no better — \"Do B.\" and \"Done\" are one character apart. See **Memory** for what that cost on a live tenant. None of this runs for a **replay** of a graded turn (`Session.replay`, `memory/replay.py`): the loop answers its acting tools with \"done\" and records them on the session, offers no script, job or server load, and skips every post-turn pass, so the nightly replay of the misses changes nothing and reaches nobody. On a team member's turn (`department_gate.speaker`) it also refuses an alert that is not routed to them (`routed_to_person_id`), so they clear only their own items; the principal clears anything on the board. `create_alert` on such a turn ignores the `source`, `external_id` and `from_address` it was given: the alert gets the source `team_member`, a fresh id and `raised_by` (their name), so it can't pose as mail or a watch, coalesce into one, or pre-claim the id a real alert will arrive with.\n8. **Tool failures** — a handler that raises instead of returning its JSON error is isolated: both tool gathers run with `return_exceptions=True`, the model gets an error `tool_result` naming only the exception's TYPE — a message can carry a filesystem path, a validation error echoing the input, or a third-party HTTP body, and anything in model context can be quoted back to the user, so the full repr stays in the log and the audit row — and the failure is audited with `ok=false`. Only `CancelledError` is re-raised, so turn-timeout and client-disconnect handling still work. Before this one crashing tool aborted the whole turn, which reached the user as an unexplained apology with no audit row (#136).\n\nWeb search, when invoked on the Anthropic path, executes inside the Anthropic API itself (`web_search_20250305`) and returns within the same generation; for any model routed via OpenRouter the same tool becomes OpenRouter's `openrouter:web_search` server tool, which also runs inside the generation with the same search cap and domain lists.\n\nThe install's workspace mode (solo or team, see Org) is read fresh at the start of each turn by `memory.workspace_settings.pin_turn_workspace_mode(session)` and pinned on the session for that turn only (`Session.turn_workspace_mode`): the persona, the org block, the tool list and every tool handler in the turn then agree, and a switch made mid-turn applies from the next turn. A session can instead carry an explicit override, `Session.workspace_mode` (`None` by default), which wins over both — so a caller that runs many conversations concurrently on one Executive, such as evals, can pick the mode per session rather than flipping the install-wide setting. Everything reads it through `effective_workspace_mode(session)` (override, then the turn's pin, then the setting). The principal's role is pinned the same way (`pin_turn_principal_role(session, mode)` → `Session.turn_principal_role`: in solo the `Session.principal_role` override, else the workspace settings read fresh; in team an empty role). The org block renders it, each specialist batch gets it as a `<principal_role>` user-turn tag, and a workflow the turn starts reads the same pin through `effective_principal_role` (override, then the pin, then the setting), so a role edited mid-turn applies from the next turn; a team turn sends none.\n\nAct as me is pinned beside them: `delegation.settings.pin_turn_delegation(session, speaker_text)` records on `Session.turn_delegation` whether the speaker has it on, whether `ghostwrite_email` is offered this turn (the principal, or a team member once the owner lets them, on a verified surface, in a conversation private to them, attended), and the speaker's own words. The pin is also held in a context variable for the turn's task, so two turns running at once on one session each read their own. The tool list, the tool handler and the turn's audit privacy all read that one pin, so a switch flipped mid-turn applies from the next turn. Once the tool touches the speaker's mailbox, the conversation is the speaker's alone (`session_store.mark_mail_private`, the principal included when it isn't theirs), the rest of the turn's audit rows are private (a team member's theirs alone) and the turn teaches no memory: no extraction, open-loop, working-style or Honcho pass runs on it. Later turns of that conversation stay private the same way; the pin also records whether the reading turn is still in the history the model is shown (`mail_in_view`, from `sessions.mail_read_at` against `session.history_window_start`), and links, scripts, workflows and posts to everyone stay withheld only while it is.\n\n### Tracing\n\nSet `LOGFIRE_TOKEN` and every step above becomes visible as one Pydantic Logfire trace (`openexecutive.observability`): the `POST /chat` request span, a `messages.create` / `messages.stream` span per model call with its token and prompt-cache counts, a `specialist {name}` span per fan-out branch (siblings overlap, so the slowest one sets the turn's critical path), and a `knowledge retrieve` span per RAG query. Scheduler and workflow model calls appear as their own root traces. Traces record timings, model names and usage only — prompt and reply text, request bodies, path parameters (each request URL is reduced to its route template), query strings, client identity and exception messages (errors are recorded by type) never leave the process, and incoming trace headers are ignored. With the token unset, tracing is off and `get_provider()` returns the bare backend.",
+ "markdown": "A single chat message makes a full round-trip through the API, the orchestrator's tool-use loop, a parallel specialist fan-out, and synthesis — all streamed back as server-sent events.\n\n### Steps\n\n1. **Arrival** — the client mints a `client_turn_id` and posts to `POST /chat` (`openexecutive.api.routes.chat`). The turn opens with a `<current_time>` hint: the day, date, time and zone in the workspace's timezone (`workspace_settings.get_user_timezone`, as the briefs use), so relative dates resolve against today instead of a guess; it is in the user turn because it changes every turn. It carries a `<current_speaker>` hint resolved from the caller's `person_id` (followed by that person's `<working_style>` rules when they have any — see the attunement section — and a `<lessons>` block when a lesson the conversation review learned from a miss matches the message, `memory/lessons.py`; see the memory section), plus a `<briefing>` digest of current open alerts (built in parallel with RAG/episodic/peer-memory fetches) so the Executive can discuss any item shown on the `/today` briefing page. A turn arriving from a chat adapter instead of the web app also carries a `<channel>` block naming the surface and stating which approvals can be completed there; on Slack the `<briefing>` digest is gated to the principal's DMs. All three ride in the **user turn**, never a cached system block, as does a `<drive_memory>` block naming the Drive files this conversation already found or opened and the Drive searches that matched nothing (see the memory section). A `<pending_followups>` block lists, for a verified speaker, the follow-ups they scheduled that haven't gone out (up to 10, from `correction_tools.pending_followups_block`, the same ownership rule as `list_followups`), and asks the Executive to cancel one with `cancel_followup` when the message shows it is already done or no longer needed, and say so in a line. The server registers a stop switch under that id *before* the context fetch, so a Stop pressed during those first seconds halts the turn before any model call is made.\n2. **Tool-use loop** — the `Executive` calls Claude. For a cross-domain question the assistant turn emits multiple `consult_specialist` tool-use blocks at once. The call carries the conversation so far (`Session.get_recent_history`: 20 to 30 turns, its start moving in steps of 10), with a short placeholder user turn first when that history opens with the Executive's own message (a chat-app conversation can start with a brief or digest it sent) with a 1h cache marker on the previous reply, so each message reads the earlier conversation from the prompt cache and writes only what is new (see Caching); on the OpenRouter path the translator keeps that marker on the reply's text. The history is re-read from the stored transcript at the start of every web turn, so a chat continued in a chat app and then reopened on the web or phone includes the turns the app added.\n The person can keep typing while it works. A message sent then (`POST /chat/add`) joins the running turn: the loop adds it after the next round's tool results, so the answer follows it, and it is saved as its own message before the reply. One that arrives while the final answer is being written becomes the next turn instead. A conversation runs one turn at a time.\n3. **Parallel fan-out** — `openexecutive.orchestrator.router.route_parallel` dispatches those calls concurrently, bounded by `MAX_PARALLEL_SPECIALISTS`; calls past the cap get a skip tool_result. A specialist that raises (a timeout, an overloaded model) or returns no text no longer fails the batch: its tool_result says it is unavailable and tells the Executive not to invent its view, the others' results stand, and the turn goes on. It does not count as consulted, so it takes no committee seat and no department memory records the turn, and its documents are left out of the answer's sources. On the web chat the reply need not mention the gap, because the app shows it under the answer; on every other channel the tool_result asks the Executive to say in one sentence that part of the analysis is missing. A knowledge retrieval that fails likewise leaves that specialist without context rather than failing the turn.\n4. **Per-specialist RAG** — each specialist runs its own domain-filtered ChromaDB query, then reasons over the retrieved chunks and returns analysis as a tool_result. Its user turn also carries a `<company_stage>` tag from the session's company profile, so stage-sensitive advice (venture benchmarks vs. cash-first for a bootstrapped company) does not depend on the Executive remembering to mention it. Once the batch is done, the documents each answering specialist's retrieval returned are named, in call order, into the turn's `TurnSources` (`orchestrator/answer_sources.py`), which the web chat route owns and which also holds its own search's documents. Synced Google Drive files are recorded as `drive` sources with their Drive link, and the web chat lists them under **Google Drive**.\n5. **Synthesis** — the Executive feeds the tool_results back to Claude and streams one coherent reply. Each round's text starts a new paragraph after the text streamed before it (`executive._round_separator`), so words the model writes before a tool call never run into its answer; nothing it writes is dropped. Every tool round — not just a specialist one — emits an `activity` event naming what is running, immediately followed by a `thinking` keepalive. The label names the *activity*, never the internal agent: \"Putting time on the calendar…\", \"Looking up people…\", or, for a connected (MCP) tool, plain words for what it does (\"Searching Drive…\"), from the same table (`orchestrator/tool_labels.py`) that names the finished chip (\"Searched Drive\"). The raw `server__tool` name never reaches the user. Under the reply, repeats of the same action collapse into one chip with a count, and tapping it lists what each run looked at. A round that really does fan out collapses to the generic \"Consulting specialists…\" — the one voice holds even in the progress line. The keepalive carries no tool information of its own; it used to drive a hardcoded \"Consulting specialists…\" string, so an MCP or calendar round misreported itself as a fan-out.\n **Do what it says.** Before the turn ends, its last reply is checked against the tool calls the turn made (`orchestrator/claim_check.py`). A reply with no word that can claim a change (\"done\", \"removed\", \"I'll remind you\"…) ends the turn as before. Otherwise one small forced-tool call on `ROUTING_MODEL` reads the person's message, the reply and each call with the start of its result, and reports a claim of a change no call made (or put up for approval). The claim must appear word for word in the reply, or it is ignored. The loop then gets one more round with a note in the user turn (never a cached block): make the change with the right tool, or say plainly it isn't done. Once a turn; a failed check lets the reply through. On the web chat the extra round streams after the first reply, separated by a blank line; chat apps send the whole reply at once. `CLAIM_CHECK_ENABLED` turns it off.\n **A chat several people are in.** When its owner shared a web chat (`session_shares`), every turn in it is labelled: the history is re-read with each person's message starting `[Name]: `, the current message too, and a note naming everyone in the chat rides in the user turn (`channel_context_block`, never a cached block). The Executive answers whoever wrote the latest message. Such a session is no private conversation (`Session.shared_chat`): Act as me is off there (`delegation.settings.private_conversation`), open loops are not listed as on a private surface, no one's mail is read there, the principal's included (`teammate_mail._reader_id`), what the Executive remembers about the speaker (peer memory) is not fetched, the alert digest leaves out the principal's private cards and roster requests (`briefing.context.render_and_trust`), and the principal-only tools are withheld whoever speaks (`content_trust.principal_only_withheld`), because the others write into what the principal's turn reads. A message that starts like a label (`[Alex]: …`) loses it before its sender's own goes in front. Peer memory still records each person's own words. Turns stay one at a time under the conversation's lock; the route publishes each one to the chat's live stream (`api.chat_live`) as it runs, so everyone else in the chat watches it happen. A chat of one publishes nothing.\n6. **Optional committee review** — when enabled, `Executive.stream_chat_with_committee()` runs a silent draft, parallel reviewer critiques, then a streamed revision pass.\n7. **Side effects** — after the reply, every rostered speaker's turn (not only the principal's) schedules a fire-and-forget **open-loop pass** (Attunement) beside the episodic extraction: a keyword prefilter, then one forced-tool call that may open or close loops, every item quote-gated against the speaker's own words. A verified speaker's turn is also kept for the **conversation review** (`memory.chat_review`, see Memory), which reads it once the chat has been quiet 30 minutes and fixes what the replies left undone, from the speaker's own quoted words. A turn that touched their mailbox, which teaches no other memory, is kept too, for their own review only (`record_turn(mail=...)`: tools by name, no results), with the words they typed rather than the blanked text the other passes get. A replay turn is never kept. The user message is persisted with `sender_person_id` — the resolved speaker, never the principal fallback a Discord / Telegram session uses for ownership — and the session records the speaker for the turn (`Session.caller_person_id`), which `close_open_loop` reads. A DM sent while proactive work is tagged (`attunement.outcomes.tag_proactive` — scheduler dispatch, reflection, research, alert review) also opens an outcome-ledger row at `_record_outbound_context`; a user's own turn is never tagged. A tagged DM is also subject to the recipient's own notification settings: in their quiet hours, or when they chose *In my briefs*, the send handler stores it (`outbound_guard.check_hold`, `people.held_messages`) and returns `{\"status\": \"held\"}` instead of sending (see Org). Any side-effecting tool call surfaces an `action_taken` chip, which unlike the ephemeral `activity` label is persisted with the assistant message; once the reply is over — also when it was stopped or timed out — the web chat route sends one `sources` event: the documents and web pages the turn looked at (its own search, each specialist that answered, web search results, and the pages the reply cites, which are always kept) and the areas (\"finance\", never a specialist) it had to go without. The web chat shows it under the reply, and it is persisted with the assistant message as `chat_messages.sources`; other channels don't collect it. The stream closes with a `done` event — preceded by a `stopped` event when the user halted the turn, in which case the partial reply is still persisted and flagged so it reads as cut short rather than complete, and is mirrored into the live in-memory session so the next turn's prompt matches what was saved. The stream still ends with `done` event. While nothing else is going out — a slow tool call, a long specialist round — the route sends an SSE comment (`: keepalive`) every `CHAT_STREAM_KEEPALIVE_S` (15 s by default, 0 for none) so a browser or proxy does not drop the connection as idle; the step it waits on keeps running across it, and the whole-turn deadline is unchanged. Every call through the MCP gateway (Gmail, Calendar, Drive, Outlook, OneDrive, tool search) has its own ceiling, `MCP_TOOL_TIMEOUT_S` (120 s): past it the model gets an error saying the tool did not answer and may still have run, so it checks before calling again, and no outbound linkage is recorded for a send that timed out. One side-effecting tool is gated server-side rather than by its description: `ack_alert` will only accept an `alert_id` from the live alert board the server itself derived this turn — the whole live set, not only the rows the `<briefing>` digest printed, since `/today` renders more cards than the digest lists and every one of them is Discuss-able — and it fails closed, so an id it cannot even parse is refused rather than waved through to the handler's own parse. That check runs on **every** session. It used to run only on turns that arrived from a chat channel, keyed on `origin_channel`, which the browser never sets — so the web, the surface the principal actually uses, was unchecked and the model could ack any id, including one quoted out of an alert body by the briefing page's Discuss handoff. What that buys is bounded and worth stating plainly: an id that is invented, closed, snoozed or expired is refused, including one quoted out of an attacker-written alert body; the model being argued into acking the wrong *live* card is not prevented. The one way to widen that set is `find_alerts`, for an item the principal names that has left the live board (already opened, snoozed, older than the board): a keyword search over alerts of every status whose own results — never an id the model supplies — join the trusted set. It runs only in a turn where `render_and_trust` showed the principal their own board (`Session.principal_board_shown`: the verified principal, and on a channel only in their DM), never merely because the session has a set — every `Session` starts with an empty one, and that empty set is how a Google Chat turn, someone else's DM or an unattended pass refuses every ack — and not on the principal's turn in a shared Slack or Discord thread either, where others read the reply and write into what the model reads. It trusts only rows still open (`unread`, `read`), never a roster-request card, and at most 25 ids per turn across calls, and refuses a query with no word of three or more letters. It also moves the admitted limit outward: a model argued into the wrong search can now reach up to 25 open alerts that are off the board, not only live ones. The board is recorded on the turn's `Session`, and the route binds that session for the **whole** SSE body (`schedule_tools.set_session`, alongside `set_turn`) rather than letting `stream_chat` bind it from inside its own generator. `_sse_body` drives the executive with `asyncio.wait_for(stream.__anext__())`, which runs each step in a fresh Task holding a *copy* of the context, so a binding made inside the generator is discarded with the step that made it: step one sees the session and every later step sees `None`. The tool-call loop runs on those later steps, so the whole guard read an empty set and refused every ack on the web — on live, open cards — until the binding moved out to the route. Anything reading `current_session` mid-turn has the same requirement, and two of them needed more than the binding to behave. `schedule_followup`'s seen-`channel_ref` anti-spam gate refuses a send to an address the session has not seen; with no session it skipped itself, so a web turn could schedule to **any** address, and with an empty one it refused even the principal's own. The route now seeds the caller's own addresses onto the session, so on web the gate means what it means on every other surface. Reply linkage (`_record_outbound_context`, read back by `inbound_hydration` to quote the originating conversation into the turn handling a recipient's reply) is the other: it was never reachable on web, and rather than switch that on for the principal's broadest surface as a side effect it is held back, keyed on an explicit `Session.from_web_chat` flag. Not on an empty `origin_channel` — alert review, the CLI and the unattended workflows all leave it empty while legitimately recording linkage, as does the email poller under its own `email` tag. `scheduled_actions` rows also take their `session_id` from the session. A session that was shown no board has an empty trusted set and can ack nothing, so the unattended passes (the nightly reflection, the research synthesis) are refused by default — they also still withhold the tool outright, which is belt-and-braces rather than the only thing stopping them. After the stream closes, the turn is also handed to the episodic memory extractor (`memory.episodic.schedule_extraction`, fire-and-forget) — on every turn where the principal said anything at all, and only the principal: a turn naming an `origin_channel` must resolve to a person marked `is_principal`, because the quote validator downstream cannot tell whose words it is checking. Both this path and the committee path call the same `should_extract` predicate, and it applies no length floor: the gate used to sum in the assistant's reply, which let a verbose answer drag a trivial turn in and discarded the short, decisive instructions that are the whole point of extracting. A user-side floor would fare no better — \"Do B.\" and \"Done\" are one character apart. See **Memory** for what that cost on a live tenant. None of this runs for a **replay** of a graded turn (`Session.replay`, `memory/replay.py`): the loop answers its acting tools with \"done\" and records them on the session, offers no script, job or server load, and skips every post-turn pass, so the nightly replay of the misses changes nothing and reaches nobody. On a team member's turn (`department_gate.speaker`) it also refuses an alert that is not routed to them (`routed_to_person_id`), so they clear only their own items; the principal clears anything on the board. `create_alert` on such a turn ignores the `source`, `external_id` and `from_address` it was given: the alert gets the source `team_member`, a fresh id and `raised_by` (their name), so it can't pose as mail or a watch, coalesce into one, or pre-claim the id a real alert will arrive with.\n8. **Tool failures** — a handler that raises instead of returning its JSON error is isolated: both tool gathers run with `return_exceptions=True`, the model gets an error `tool_result` naming only the exception's TYPE — a message can carry a filesystem path, a validation error echoing the input, or a third-party HTTP body, and anything in model context can be quoted back to the user, so the full repr stays in the log and the audit row — and the failure is audited with `ok=false`. Only `CancelledError` is re-raised, so turn-timeout and client-disconnect handling still work. Before this one crashing tool aborted the whole turn, which reached the user as an unexplained apology with no audit row (#136).\n\nWeb search, when invoked on the Anthropic path, executes inside the Anthropic API itself (`web_search_20250305`) and returns within the same generation; for any model routed via OpenRouter the same tool becomes OpenRouter's `openrouter:web_search` server tool, which also runs inside the generation with the same search cap and domain lists.\n\nThe install's workspace mode (solo or team, see Org) is read fresh at the start of each turn by `memory.workspace_settings.pin_turn_workspace_mode(session)` and pinned on the session for that turn only (`Session.turn_workspace_mode`): the persona, the org block, the tool list and every tool handler in the turn then agree, and a switch made mid-turn applies from the next turn. A session can instead carry an explicit override, `Session.workspace_mode` (`None` by default), which wins over both — so a caller that runs many conversations concurrently on one Executive, such as evals, can pick the mode per session rather than flipping the install-wide setting. Everything reads it through `effective_workspace_mode(session)` (override, then the turn's pin, then the setting). The principal's role is pinned the same way (`pin_turn_principal_role(session, mode)` → `Session.turn_principal_role`: in solo the `Session.principal_role` override, else the workspace settings read fresh; in team an empty role). The org block renders it, each specialist batch gets it as a `<principal_role>` user-turn tag, and a workflow the turn starts reads the same pin through `effective_principal_role` (override, then the pin, then the setting), so a role edited mid-turn applies from the next turn; a team turn sends none.\n\nAct as me is pinned beside them: `delegation.settings.pin_turn_delegation(session, speaker_text)` records on `Session.turn_delegation` whether the speaker has it on, whether `ghostwrite_email` is offered this turn (the principal, or a team member once the owner lets them, on a verified surface, in a conversation private to them, attended), and the speaker's own words. The pin is also held in a context variable for the turn's task, so two turns running at once on one session each read their own. The tool list, the tool handler and the turn's audit privacy all read that one pin, so a switch flipped mid-turn applies from the next turn. Once the tool touches the speaker's mailbox, the conversation is the speaker's alone (`session_store.mark_mail_private`, the principal included when it isn't theirs), the rest of the turn's audit rows are private (a team member's theirs alone) and the turn teaches no memory: no extraction, open-loop, working-style or Honcho pass runs on it. Later turns of that conversation stay private the same way; the pin also records whether the reading turn is still in the history the model is shown (`mail_in_view`, from `sessions.mail_read_at` against `session.history_window_start`), and links, scripts, workflows and posts to everyone stay withheld only while it is.\n\n### Tracing\n\nSet `LOGFIRE_TOKEN` and every step above becomes visible as one Pydantic Logfire trace (`openexecutive.observability`): the `POST /chat` request span, a `messages.create` / `messages.stream` span per model call with its token and prompt-cache counts, a `specialist {name}` span per fan-out branch (siblings overlap, so the slowest one sets the turn's critical path), and a `knowledge retrieve` span per RAG query. Scheduler and workflow model calls appear as their own root traces. Traces record timings, model names and usage only — prompt and reply text, request bodies, path parameters (each request URL is reduced to its route template), query strings, client identity and exception messages (errors are recorded by type) never leave the process, and incoming trace headers are ignored. With the token unset, tracing is off and `get_provider()` returns the bare backend.",
"mermaid": "sequenceDiagram\n participant C as Client\n participant API as FastAPI /chat\n participant E as Executive\n participant CL as Claude\n participant S as Specialists\n participant KB as ChromaDB\n C->>API: POST /chat message\n API->>E: start turn\n E->>CL: messages (tool-use loop)\n CL-->>E: consult_specialist calls\n E->>S: route_parallel fan-out\n S->>KB: domain-filtered RAG\n KB-->>S: chunks\n S-->>E: analysis tool_results\n E->>CL: synthesize\n CL-->>E: streamed reply\n E-->>API: SSE chunks then done\n API-->>C: streamed response",
- "generated_at": "2026-10-20T16:25:55+00:00"
+ "generated_at": "2026-10-26T13:22:39.814989+00:00"
}
diff --git a/packages/core/openexecutive/architecture/prebuilt/scheduler.json b/packages/core/openexecutive/architecture/prebuilt/scheduler.json
index a3ce3503..22d9f033 100644
--- a/packages/core/openexecutive/architecture/prebuilt/scheduler.json
+++ b/packages/core/openexecutive/architecture/prebuilt/scheduler.json
@@ -1,7 +1,7 @@
{
"section_id": "scheduler",
"title": "Scheduler & Cadences",
- "markdown": "The scheduler is an asyncio task started in the FastAPI lifespan (`openexecutive.scheduler.runner.run_scheduler`). It polls every 30s and reads due rows from `scheduled_actions` (in `episodic_memory.db`). The due query uses `claim_due_actions`, an UPDATE…RETURNING claim, so each row fires at most once per process — this assumes a single scheduler instance per database. Each due row runs in its own task, started with no audit scope (`audit.context.unscoped_audit_rows`): a scheduled action is unattended and never part of the turn that scheduled it, so its audit rows follow the ordinary rule. Polls are gated on an active company profile via `_company_profile_active()`; before onboarding, due rows stay `pending`.\n\n### Operator pause\n\nA global pause switch (`openexecutive.scheduler.pause`, one row in the `executive_control` table) stops everything the Executive starts on its own. It is the first check of every scheduler tick: while paused the tick does nothing — no alert/watchlist sweep, no claim — so due rows stay `pending` and fire on the first tick after resume. Actions already claimed when the pause lands run to completion; pausing holds work, it never cancels it. The same check gates the Gmail poller (the inbox is left unread) and the workflow resumer (no `wait_for_human` timeouts or resumes, and `apply_resolution` records a reply without kicking the run). Inbound conversations — web chat, Slack, Discord, Telegram, Google Chat — are deliberately not gated. The switch is set from the sidebar, the paused banner or Settings in the UI, or via `POST /executive/pause` / `POST /executive/resume`; each flip writes an `executive_paused` / `executive_resumed` audit row. Any signed-in caller may pause (it only holds work); resuming releases every held action at once, so it is the principal's alone (open only while no principal is on the roster). The state persists across restarts (boot logs a warning while paused) and across client-slot switches. `is_paused()` is read-only: a DB file or table that does not exist yet reads as \"running\", but a read error on an existing DB reads as \"paused\" — the brake fails closed, so a storage fault holds work rather than silently releasing it while the UI still shows \"paused\" (the UI shows \"status unknown\" when it cannot read the state).\n\n### Liveness heartbeat\n\nEvery tick ends by recording when it finished and what it did — `ran`, `paused`, `waiting_for_company`, `rotating`, or `failed` when the tick raised — and `run_scheduler` notes when it started. `scheduler_heartbeat()` returns both; they live in process memory, not the database. Settings → Setup status (`GET /setup/status`) reads them: no start means the task isn't running; no tick five minutes after starting, or none for three poll intervals (at least 90 s), means the loop has stopped; `failed` and `waiting_for_company` get their own light. Liveness is judged before the pause switch, because a paused scheduler still ticks: one that has stopped shows as stopped, where the Resume button wouldn't help. A restart clears the previous run's last tick. Due actions run as their own tasks, so a slow brief never ages the heartbeat.\n\n### A teammate's scheduled rows\n\n`schedule_followup` and `suggest_workflow` keep the speaker on the row (`scheduled_actions.created_by_person_id`, from `Session.caller_person_id`). A due row whose creator is the principal, or that has no creator (the system's own rows, rows from before the column), takes the ordinary dispatch. A row a teammate queued runs as that teammate (`runner._run_teammate_followup`), because its intent is their own text: it is cancelled unless the creator is still an active team member and the row's address is one of their own; the Executive only writes the message, on an unattended session with `run_for_person_id` naming the teammate, which makes it read-only like a turn from another AI app that may not act (`schedule_tools.read_only_turn`: none of `MCP_CLIENT_WITHHELD_TOOLS` and only the gateway reads in `MCP_CLIENT_MCP_TOOLS`); its context is the decisions and advice of the conversation that queued it (nothing when there is none), never the company-wide list; and the runner sends the text to the teammate's own address on the row's channel (`_send_on_plan`), retrying on a failed send. A fork that limits what a teammate's turns may use applies the same limit to the run through `run_for_person_id`.\n\n**A follow-up overtaken by events.** An ad hoc follow-up back to the person who set it (the row's creator, else its conversation's owner, the principal when it has none; and only when its address is their own, `runner._followup_owner`) fires with what they wrote in chat since it was set: up to 30 of their own messages, 300 characters each, across all their conversations (`session_store.own_messages_since`; only their words, never a reply or someone else's line), in `<since_scheduled>` tags as data. The run is asked first whether that shows it is already done or no longer needed, and if so to send nothing and answer `ALREADY_HANDLED: <why>`. The runner then records the row `cancelled` with `skipped: already handled (<why>)` and a `scheduled_action` audit row with phase `skipped`, instead of `done`. A teammate's row gets the same block and check before the runner sends what it wrote. A follow-up to anyone else, or with no chat since, fires exactly as before.\n\n### Cadence DSL\n\n`openexecutive.departments.cadence` supports, all in UTC for department and workflow cadences:\n\n- `daily@HH:MM`\n- `weekly@DOW@HH:MM` or `weekly@DOW-HH:MM` (DOW is a 3-letter day, e.g. `weekly@thu@09:00`)\n- `quarterly@DD-HH:MM`\n\n`PATCH /departments/{slug}` rejects a spec that does not parse (bad format, unknown DOW, out-of-range time) with a 422 naming the valid formats, so a typo is caught at save time instead of silently never firing. An empty spec means no cadence (the department page's **Off**). A new department starts weekly, `weekly@mon@09:00`. Changing a department's `check_in` through that route re-times it at once: `cadence.reschedule_check_in()` cancels its pending `dept_cadence` row and queues the next occurrence of the new spec (nothing when it is off or in solo); a check-in already running finishes, and its chain adds nothing because the new row is pending.\n\nWhen a department cadence is due, the runner invokes the `department_check_in` workflow and chains the following occurrence via `cadence.enqueue_next()`. The fire is not passed through the authority gate: the check-in sends nothing (it grades Goals, writes one audit row and a Honcho note), and every action it proposes carries its own `gate_action` verdict in the report. Before creating a run the runner applies a skip rule (`department_check_in.needs_check_in`): the check-in is skipped when the department has no specialist agent, has no Goals, or nothing is new since its Goals were last reviewed — no decision or audit row tagged to the department (the check-in's own review row aside) since the oldest Goal's `last_reviewed_at`, and no Goal edited after it was graded. A Goal never reviewed always runs it. A skip leaves no run in the activity rail, is recorded as `cancelled` with its reason (`skipped: …` in `last_error`) rather than `done` — a done cadence row means \"the check-in ran\" to the nudge engine — and still chains the next occurrence; so does a check-in that fails once its retries are spent, so one broken department does not fall out of its cycle. That final failure also files one Home card, \"*Finance* check-in didn't finish\" (`workflows.failure_alerts`, source `workflow_failed`, tagged `failed_run:<run id>`; repeats of the same check-in coalesce into it), because nobody watches a scheduled run; a scheduled saved workflow (`dynamic_workflow`) that fails files the same card, routed to the person it delivers to. The card's **Run again** (`POST /workflows/runs/{run_id}/rerun`) queues the same action, due now, with `scope_key` `rerun:<run id>`: it skips the skip rule and does not chain another occurrence, and re-timing the check-in leaves it queued (the dept chain is idempotent anyway; a saved workflow's `schedule_dynamic_workflow_cadence` is skipped). Chaining is idempotent: while a next occurrence for the department is already pending nothing is added, so a row that chained and then failed to record its outcome never leaves two. Seeded departments start with no Goals, so their weekly check-ins cost nothing until someone adds one. Goals no check-in grades (no department, or a department with no specialist) are graded by the recurring `goal_review` kind instead (`GOAL_REVIEW_TIME`, default `weekly@mon@09:00` in the user's zone, both modes), seeded with the principal's rhythm and chained like the reflection: it runs `departments.goal_review.run_review` under `unscoped_audit_rows()`, delivers nothing, and a failed week never breaks the chain. Deleting a department cancels its pending `dept_cadence` rows, and `cancel_orphaned_cadences()` sweeps orphans on boot.\n\nIn **solo mode** (one person using Open Executive just for themselves; see Org) there are no department check-ins: `bootstrap_cadences()` is a no-op, switching to solo cancels every pending `dept_cadence` row, a row that was already pending is marked `cancelled` by the runner without running and without chaining — ahead of the authority gate, so a `propose_only` department cannot turn it into an approval card, and cancelled rather than done because the nudge engine reads a done check-in as a recent department pulse — and a check-in already running across the switch finishes without `enqueue_next` scheduling another. Switching back to team re-bootstraps them. Solo has one kind of its own, the **weekly review** (`principal_weekly_review`, below): switching to solo seeds it (`seed_weekly_review`), switching to team cancels its pending row (`cancel_weekly_reviews`), and one that fires while the stored mode is team is marked `cancelled` without running or chaining. That check reads the mode strictly (`workspace_settings.read_stored_mode`) and fails open: a mode that can't be read (a locked database) is not taken for team, so one bad read neither retires the review nor breaks its chain — the next run checks again.\n\nThe parser also takes a zone: `_parse_cadence_spec(spec, after, tz=UTC)` builds the wall-clock time in `tz` and only then converts to UTC, so a local schedule stays at the same local time across daylight-saving changes (a time the spring-forward gap skips fires once, just after the jump; a time the fall-back repeats fires at its first occurrence).\n\n### The principal's rhythm\n\nThe morning brief (`principal_brief_morning`, 08:00), end-of-day digest (`principal_brief_eod`, 18:00) and reflection (`executive_reflection`, 07:30) are seeded once per database by `seed_principal_briefs()` and each chains its next occurrence when it fires. In a solo workspace it also seeds the **weekly review** (`principal_weekly_review`, Friday 16:00 local by default), which runs the `weekly_review` workflow and is delivered like the briefs; its `PRINCIPAL_WEEKLY_REVIEW_TIME` takes a whole weekly spec (`weekly@fri@16:00`), read as UTC when valid, like the pinned times below, and it chains only while the workspace is still solo — and never when a weekly row is already pending, so a switch to solo while a review finishes cannot leave two. Their default times are local to the user's zone — `memory.workspace_settings.get_user_timezone()`: the zone set through `PUT /workspace`, else `USER_TIMEZONE`, else UTC — computed with the cadence parser above. An operator who pinned a valid `HH:MM` in `PRINCIPAL_BRIEF_MORNING_TIME` / `PRINCIPAL_BRIEF_EOD_TIME` / `PRINCIPAL_REFLECTION_TIME` keeps that time read as UTC, as before zones existed, so a pinned time never moves; a malformed value is logged and treated as unset. An install that set `USER_TIMEZONE` but pinned nothing does move to that zone, from each kind's first fire after the upgrade (a row seeded before it keeps its old UTC time once). When the zone in effect changes, `reschedule_principal_rhythm()` re-times each kind's pending, not-yet-due row **in place** — it only updates `run_at` (guarded on the row being unchanged since it was read), never inserts or cancels, so it cannot race a chain into a duplicate. The new time is the next occurrence in the new zone after `max(now, last fired run + 12h)`, so a kind never runs twice within 12 hours; and if that is more than 12 hours later than the row's current time — moving would skip a day, as when someone switches to Europe/London at 07:59 UTC with the 08:00 UTC brief a minute away — the row keeps its time once. A kind with no such row is left alone: a row that is running, one between being marked done and its chain insert, or a due row held by a pause or a missing company profile. Its chain times the next one in the new zone, and the chain itself starts from `max(now, fired run + 12h)`, so a zone change while a brief runs cannot put a second brief a few hours after it. The weekly review follows the same rules with a 3.5-day gap (`_min_gap`) in place of 12 hours, so a zone change can neither run it twice in a week nor skip one.\n\nUser-created (dynamic) workflows can carry the same cadence DSL. A cadence-enabled definition enqueues a `dynamic_workflow` action (`workflows.dynamic_cadence`); when due, the runner runs the stored `DynamicWorkflow`, DMs the definition's `cadence_person_id` what the run came to (`workflows/run_message`: a fast-model message written from the full report for its reader — what came of the run in their timezone, no tool or step names — or no message at all when the run found nothing and did nothing they need to hear about; the full report stays on the run), and re-chains the next occurrence. A workflow that reads its creator's own mail or calendar (`delegation.workflow_reads`) runs as theirs instead: the run is created with them as its owner (their history alone), its steps run as them, every audit row is theirs (`private_run`), and the artifact, a held-writes pause's eventual delivery and a failure card go to them whatever the cadence names. Saving/updating/deleting the definition reconciles its pending `dynamic_workflow` rows. A cadence definition may not contain an approval gate — a cron fire has no human to ask — with one exception, the **held-writes** pause: when an action step holds a write to a new target, the runner checkpoints the run (`checkpoint_gate`, the owner is DMed), still marks the row done and re-chains the cadence, and stamps `deliver_to_person_id` on the resume payload so the resumer sends that same message to the cadence recipient once the owner answers (or the 48 h timeout skips the held writes). Any other gate is still refused at execution: it calls `workflows.gate.ensure_workflow_event`, which raises on a gate so the run is recorded as failed. It previously ignored the gate and stored a completed run with `\"(no artifact)\"` as its body, which looked like a success every period.\n\n**Monthly tally.** On the first weekday of each month, in daytime (09:00–18:00 local), a tick hook beside the reminders (`_maybe_send_monthly_value` → `briefing.value_summary.maybe_send_monthly`, checked every 15 minutes) sends the owner last month's counted lines and a link to Pulse → Your month through `_deliver_to_principal`, in solo and team mode alike. It is claimed once per month (`briefing_narrative` scope `value_summary:YYYY-MM`, never released, so one try), skipped for an empty month, audited `value_summary_sent` / `value_summary_not_sent`, and off with `VALUE_SUMMARY_MONTHLY_ENABLED=false`. It is not a `scheduled_actions` row.\n\n### Department authority & cancelling\n\nA department-scoped row passes the authority gate (`departments.authority.gate_action`, see Org) before it is dispatched: `auto_execute` dispatches; `propose_only` raises an approval card and marks the row done without dispatching (deferred to the approver's next availability window when they are outside it); `escalate` raises an urgent `[ESCALATION]` card (severity high) straight away — never deferred — and likewise does not dispatch, because approving the card is what sends it. As that card is the action's only trace it always lands: unrouted when there is no approver and no principal, and deduped on the whole action (kind, channel, recipient and intent) rather than the summary's first 60 characters, so another escalation sharing an opening — or the same text for someone else — cannot swallow it. An identical escalation folds into a still-open card and gets a fresh one once that card was handled, and a card that cannot be written retries the row with backoff and, once the retries are spent, marks it `failed` — never `done`. (It used to raise the card *and* dispatch.) The runner records which action each card holds (`alert_held_actions`, server-side only, never a tag a model could write): approving one (`POST /alerts/{id}/approve`) queues a copy of that exact action with no department, so it goes out on the next tick without meeting the gate again. A `dept_cadence` row is not gated at all — gating it turned every check-in on a propose-only department (all eight seeded ones) into a one-shot card, and the row never chained its next occurrence. Nudge-engine rows carry no department and bypass the gate.\n\nA `pending` row can be cancelled with `DELETE /scheduled/{id}` — the Pulse page's Cancel; the update only moves a row that is still `pending`, so one the scheduler has just claimed is never overwritten. Cancelling only stops work, so, like pause, any signed-in user may: the route accepts a signed-in caller through the UI proxy (its `x-caller-email`, trusted only alongside the `BACKEND_SHARED_SECRET` `x-api-key`), a matching `X-Admin-Token` (`SCHEDULED_ADMIN_TOKEN`, for scripts), or a loopback caller when no token is set — otherwise 401 (token set) or 503. Each cancel is audited as `scheduled_action_cancelled` with who did it.\n\n### Channel routing & nudges\n\nThe delivery channel lives on the `scheduled_actions` row (`channel` / `channel_ref`); the runner dispatches through whichever was set at enqueue time — `telegram`, `slack_dm`, `discord_dm`, `email`, or `__internal__` (workflow steps and heartbeats bypass outbound dispatch). Rows left pending by the removed staff-onboarding kinds drain through that same `__internal__` short-circuit (marked done, no dispatch); the removed talent workflows' *ad-hoc* reminders sat on the principal's real DM channel instead, so a one-shot startup sweep (`memory.episodic.cancel_orphaned_talent_reminders`) cancels them — `ad_hoc`, no department, `pending` or `running`, matching the five generated reminder shapes (outreach, interview coordination, reference checks, onboarding check-in, offer expiry) — and clears the awaiting-reply flag on delivered ones so the nudge engine stops chasing them. The marker row in `app_migrations` is claimed first with `INSERT OR IGNORE` in the same transaction, so concurrent boots cannot double-run or crash. The nudge engine (`scheduler.nudge_engine`, default 15 min) scans stalled `awaiting_human` runs, stale commitments, and idle initiatives, then emits `proactive_nudge` rows routed via `people.channel.prefer_channel_for` — honouring each Person's preferred (last-used) channel and availability windows, deferring those outside their window and skipping those with no reachable channel. Emission is capped per `scope_key` (`NUDGE_MAX_PER_SCOPE`, default 3 delivered nudges) so a parked item is not chased forever.\n\nAn idle initiative is chased with its department's head; with no head to resolve — no department (what the episodic extractor stores), an unknown department, or no head set — the principal owns it. That source used to skip every initiative without a head, so in practice it never fired. The principal gets self-addressed wording (\"<title>\" has not moved since <date> — still active, done, or dropped?). If channel routing cannot reach the principal (no channel configured, or unreachable beyond `NUDGE_MAX_DEFER_DAYS`), the nudge becomes an unrouted Briefing card instead, keyed on the initiative and the ISO week: at most one card per initiative per week, and while one is still unread the scan leaves it alone rather than refreshing it every 15 minutes. The emitted nudge still carries no department, and the usual caps and cooldowns apply. A department-tagged initiative is still skipped while its department's check-in actually ran inside the idle window; a skipped check-in does not count.\n\nThe stale-commitment source also chases **open loops** (see Attunement): `scheduled_actions` rows with `kind='open_loop'`, recorded `done` on the `__internal__` channel so the runner never dispatches them, whose `awaiting_response_since` is the loop's *due time*. They are chased as soon as they are overdue — not after `NUDGE_COMMITMENT_STALE_DAYS` — with a check-in intent addressed to the loop's owner (which quotes only the owner's own verbatim words and tells the dispatching turn to treat them as data), through the same `prefer_channel_for` routing, availability windows and outbound guard. Until open loops existed nothing in production set `awaiting_response_since`, so this source had nothing to chase. Each scan first closes loops older than `ATTUNEMENT_LOOP_TTL_DAYS` (21) as `expired`, then marks proactive outreach nobody answered within `ATTUNEMENT_IGNORE_AFTER_HOURS` as `ignored` in the outcome ledger. Ranking uses that ledger: a candidate whose person left their last five resolved nudges of that kind unanswered ranks after all others and waits three times its cooldown; a single answer lifts it. Approving a stalled run (however it's approved) and updating an initiative count as acting on the nudges that chased them. The generic dispatch path tags each send with its source (`_outreach_source`) so the ledger can attribute it.\n\n### Alert lifecycle: expiry sweep and the review heartbeat\n\nTwo alert-maintenance jobs live here. The **expiry sweep** is loop-level, not a heartbeat row: `_maybe_sweep_alerts` runs `alerts.lifecycle.expire_stale_alerts` (and, on the same 15-minute throttle, `monitoring.research.watch_policy.sweep` — expiring unreviewed research watch suggestions, auto-disabling research-added watches that proved noisy or dead, and filing one `watchlist_suggestions` nudge when ≥3 suggestions have waited ≥7 days; see External monitoring) once at boot and every 15 minutes at the top of the tick — before the company-profile and rotation gates, so an old backlog expires even before onboarding completes, flipping `unread` alerts past their category TTL to `expired` and auditing `alert_sweep`. Pure DB hygiene, no model call, reversible via `POST /alerts/{id}/reopen`. The same throttled call also deletes Always in the loop notes past their expiry (`memory.history.sweep_expired`; reads already skip them, and it never raises). Each tick also calls `_maybe_remind_notes` → `memory.history_reminders.maybe_remind` (its own 15-minute throttle, 09:00–18:00 local, one task at a time): a person whose notes say something they promised by email is due today gets one message saying how many, through `deliver_to_person` — the brief's own channel order for any Person, never a shared channel (`delivery_order` now skips a Telegram group id, for the briefs too), with the senders' audit rows private to that person. A hook rather than a `scheduled_actions` row, which `/scheduled` would show to everyone (see Memory).\n\nThe **Executive alert review** is a real heartbeat — kind `alert_review_scan`, `__internal__` channel, bootstrapped idempotently at startup when `ALERT_REVIEW_ENABLED` and chained every `ALERT_REVIEW_INTERVAL_HOURS` (6) with the same crash-resilient run → mark-done → chain shape as `nudge_scan`. `_run_principal_brief` also runs a `pre_brief` pass right before the morning brief (a review failure never blocks the brief). Each pass re-examines open alerts with evidence and, within department authority and the privacy rule, routes, nudges, escalates, drafts, merges or resolves them — see the Today section for the policy. The moves go through the real handlers (`message_person`, `draft_artifact`), so the outbound anti-spam guard applies, and `ALERT_REVIEW_MAX_MOVES_PER_SCAN` bounds side effects per pass.\n\nThe /today **\"What's going on\" header** is kept current from the tick too, so it is fresh before anyone opens the page. `_maybe_refresh_narrative` is a throttled call inside the loop, like the alert sweep — no `scheduled_actions` row. It runs after the pause, company-profile and rotation gates, every `BRIEFING_NARRATIVE_REFRESH_MINUTES` (10; 0 turns it off) and only between `BRIEFING_NARRATIVE_REFRESH_START_HOUR` and `_END_HOUR` (06–22) in the user's zone. It starts `today.refresh_principal_narrative` as its own task, so a slow model call never holds the tick, and never starts a second while one runs. That refreshes the cached calendar read (`live_signals.refresh_calendar`, at most once per 15 minutes) and rewrites the principal's header only when its key moved — new mail, a held reply, a proposal, the hour — with the route's own per-scope lock, so a page view and the tick never write the same header twice (see Today).\n\nAct as me's **reminders** are loop-level too: `_maybe_send_reminders` starts `delegation.reminders.maybe_send` at most once a minute, which claims each due `delegation_reminders` row once (due times are stored in UTC, so they compare in order) (compare-and-set on `claimed_at`) and sends its stored text, prefixed \"Reminder you set on <date>:\", to the person who set it alone through `deliver_to_person`. No model and no tool run; a reminder missed by more than two days is dropped rather than sent late, and one due in the person's quiet hours or leave waits, unclaimed, until they end; audit rows are private to the person. They are not `scheduled_actions` rows for the same reason as the scan below: that list is everyone's, and its rows run an Executive turn when they fire.\n\n**Held messages** are loop-level as well: `_maybe_release_held` starts `people.held_messages.maybe_release` at most once a minute, which sends each person whatever is due to them — messages held for their quiet hours once those end, and brief-held messages made due when the briefs run — as one *While you were away* message through `deliver_to_person`, claims each row first so a brief can't send it too, marks them sent only once that went, postpones a person back in quiet hours, on leave or outside their windows to when that ends, backs off 2, 4, 8 … minutes (at most an hour) after any other failure, and audits every drop (too old, over the cap) privately as a count, and writes audit rows private to the person. The principal-brief handler appends the principal's brief-held messages to the morning brief or end-of-day digest it delivers (`_with_held_messages`; the stored run artifact is unchanged), claims them, marks them sent only when the brief went (otherwise frees the claim), then makes everyone else's due (`_release_others_digests`). The `proactive_nudge` re-check calls `prefer_channel_for` / `next_available_window` with `quiet_hours=True` (urgent for a `nudge:stalled:` scope key), so a nudge due in the person's quiet hours is deferred to their end like one outside an availability window. A dispatch whose message was held is audited `held`, not `delivered`. See Org for the notification settings.\n\nAct as me's **inbox watcher** is loop-level the same way: `_maybe_scan_inbox`, after the same gates, starts the due scans (`delegation.inbox.maybe_scan`) as one task and never a second while one runs. A person is due every `DELEGATION_INBOX_POLL_MINUTES` (default 5) once their **Draft replies to my inbox** switch is on, unless a Gmail failure set a back-off; nobody is scanned while a client slot is active. It is deliberately not a `scheduled_actions` row: those are listed on `/scheduled` for everyone and anyone may cancel them, and a scan reads the owner's own mail. Every row a scan writes is private to the principal (see Act as Me).\n\nThe **contact keeper** is loop-level too: `_maybe_keep_contacts`, right after the inbox watcher, calls `people.contact_keeper.maybe_run`, which starts one pass at most every 6 hours (an in-process start time plus the stored `last_run_at`, so a restart doesn't re-run it) and never a second while one runs. Like the scans it is not a `scheduled_actions` row, because it reads the principal's own mail. See Org.\n\n### Principal briefs\n\nThe `principal_brief_morning` / `principal_brief_eod` / `principal_weekly_review` rows (and the client-rotation digest) are delivered by `_deliver_to_principal`, not through a row channel. The principal's `preferred_channel` (`slack` / `discord` / `telegram` / `email` / `any`, where `any` means the chat app they last talked in) is tried first, then the other chat channels they have an id for (Slack → Discord → Telegram), by `people.reach.reach_order`. Email goes through the active MCP gateway: first when the preference is `email`, and otherwise last, as the backup after every chat channel. Before planning, the delivery asks the gateway supervisor for a start if the gateway is down (`runner.ensure_email_ready` → `mcp_gateway.ensure_active_gateway`, the lazy re-check), and a row action resolves the gateway at execution time rather than from what boot had, so a gateway that failed at boot and came up on a retry carries the brief. The outcome names what happened: `gateway_down` when email is set up but the gateway is not running (the Executive's fault, with the start failure, never `no_channel`, which blamed the owner's setup), and a `send_failed` detail that quotes each channel's own error (`email: invalid_grant …`, `slack_dm: channel_not_found`), stored with the outcome (`brief_state.record_delivery_outcome(detail=…)`) and shown on the Briefing notice and the Setup page's *Daily brief* light, whose fix says to reconnect when the detail shows a dead grant. Delivery stops at the first channel that sends, so an owner linked by email at setup keeps their Slack delivery without extra email, and gets the brief by email only when Slack is missing or fails. The email is formatted HTML (`utils.markdown_email`: raw HTML and images off, unsafe link schemes dropped) with a subject dated in the user's zone (\"Morning Brief — Fri 25 Sep\"). Email counts as ready only when the MCP gateway runs the Google Workspace server. Every run's outcome — delivered, no owner, nowhere to send it, every send failed, or the brief couldn't be written at all (the workflow failed or produced nothing) — is recorded with the channel's name (never an address) under `brief_state`, for the Briefing's notice and the Setup status \"Daily brief\" light (the weekly review's outcome too — `brief_state.DELIVERY_KINDS` — so a weekly review that wasn't sent is reported the same way). The light also turns amber when a brief got through only on a backup channel, naming the one that failed. `_run_principal_brief` sets `morning_brief.PRINCIPAL_DELIVERY` for the run, because it goes to the principal alone: only then (or on the principal's own verified chat turn) does the morning brief read what is private to them. When the workflow reports `private_to_principal` on its `result` event — it did read such a row — the run history keeps `persistence.PRIVATE_RUN_ARTIFACT` in place of the text (`stored_artifact`), since `/workflows/runs` is readable by everyone signed in; the principal gets the full text where it is delivered. When no channel can deliver at all (a web-only principal, or email with no gateway), the brief is still generated and stored as a run with its artifact — a web-only principal reads it on the Artifacts page — it is just not delivered, and the next occurrence is chained; see Workflows.\n\n## Client rotation claim pause\n\nThe `client_rotation` kind (multi-client practice mode, opt-in via `CLIENT_ROTATION_ENABLED`) adds one loop-level behavior: while a rotation's `.rotation_in_progress` marker exists, the scheduler **skips claiming entirely** for that tick. Rotation switches the live company context between parked clients; claiming during the window would fire the just-activated client's overdue outbound follow-ups from a context nobody is watching. Everything due fires on the first tick after the original client is restored. Stale markers (crash mid-rotation) are reconciled at scheduler startup, and the rotation row is idempotently re-seeded both at boot and after every slot activation (scheduled rows swap with the client). See the Client Companies section for the rotation's full design.\n\nAn optional `notion_sync_scan` heartbeat (`NOTION_SYNC_ENABLED`, off by default) incrementally re-indexes Notion pages the workspace integration can see into the isolated `notion_wiki` collection (not COMPANY), reconciles un-shared pages, then chains the next tick. An optional `drive_sync_scan` heartbeat (`DRIVE_SYNC_ENABLED`, off by default, bootstrapped in the lifespan beside it) does the same for the configured Google Drive folders, into the isolated `drive_docs` collection (see RAG). An optional `onedrive_sync_scan` heartbeat (`ONEDRIVE_SYNC_ENABLED`, off by default) does the same for the configured OneDrive folders, into `onedrive_docs`. An optional `confluence_sync_scan` heartbeat (`CONFLUENCE_SYNC_ENABLED`, off by default, bootstrapped in the lifespan the same way) re-indexes the changed pages of the configured Confluence spaces into the isolated `confluence_wiki` collection, leaving out restricted pages, and purges pages that were deleted, moved out or restricted.\n\n**Take the lead wakes.** With Take the lead as the Executive on, a turn from a channel (mail, Slack, Discord, Telegram, Google Chat) calls `take_the_lead.wake`, which inserts one `take_the_lead_wake` `__internal__` action five minutes out. It does nothing while one is pending or running, and nothing within 30 minutes of the last wake. The runner's `_run_take_the_lead_wake` runs the same reflection as the daily rhythm (`_reflect`, shared with `_run_executive_reflection`), only if the switch is still on, and never chains. The pause holds it like every claim.\n\n**Conversation reviews.** A kept chat turn (`memory.chat_review.record_turn`) makes sure one `chat_review` `__internal__` action is waiting for that conversation (`channel_ref` = session id), 30 minutes (`CHAT_REVIEW_QUIET_MINUTES`) out. `_run_chat_review` marks it done, then `chat_review.run_scheduled` either schedules a fresh one for 30 minutes after the newest turn (the chat is still going) or reviews the turns not yet reviewed. It never chains, and the pause holds it like every claim.\n\n**Replay of the misses.** The `chat_replay` kind (`memory.replay`) is seeded with the briefs by `seed_principal_briefs()` and chains its next occurrence like the reflection (`_run_chat_replay`; `CHAT_REPLAY_TIME`, 03:30 in the user's zone, pinned as UTC when set). It replays the turns the conversation review graded a miss with the lessons and facts in force today, in a dry run, judges each, and records the night (`chat_review_replay_runs`) whether or not anything was due; a failed night still marks done and chains. The pause holds it like every claim.",
+ "markdown": "The scheduler is an asyncio task started in the FastAPI lifespan (`openexecutive.scheduler.runner.run_scheduler`). It polls every 30s and reads due rows from `scheduled_actions` (in `episodic_memory.db`). The due query uses `claim_due_actions`, an UPDATE…RETURNING claim, so each row fires at most once per process — this assumes a single scheduler instance per database. Each due row runs in its own task, started with no audit scope (`audit.context.unscoped_audit_rows`): a scheduled action is unattended and never part of the turn that scheduled it, so its audit rows follow the ordinary rule. Polls are gated on an active company profile via `_company_profile_active()`; before onboarding, due rows stay `pending`.\n\n### Operator pause\n\nA global pause switch (`openexecutive.scheduler.pause`, one row in the `executive_control` table) stops everything the Executive starts on its own. It is the first check of every scheduler tick: while paused the tick does nothing — no alert/watchlist sweep, no claim — so due rows stay `pending` and fire on the first tick after resume. Actions already claimed when the pause lands run to completion; pausing holds work, it never cancels it. The same check gates the Gmail poller (the inbox is left unread) and the workflow resumer (no `wait_for_human` timeouts or resumes, and `apply_resolution` records a reply without kicking the run). Inbound conversations — web chat, Slack, Discord, Telegram, Google Chat — are deliberately not gated. The switch is set from the sidebar, the paused banner or Settings in the UI, or via `POST /executive/pause` / `POST /executive/resume`; each flip writes an `executive_paused` / `executive_resumed` audit row. Any signed-in caller may pause (it only holds work); resuming releases every held action at once, so it is the principal's alone (open only while no principal is on the roster). The state persists across restarts (boot logs a warning while paused) and across client-slot switches. `is_paused()` is read-only: a DB file or table that does not exist yet reads as \"running\", but a read error on an existing DB reads as \"paused\" — the brake fails closed, so a storage fault holds work rather than silently releasing it while the UI still shows \"paused\" (the UI shows \"status unknown\" when it cannot read the state).\n\n### Liveness heartbeat\n\nEvery tick ends by recording when it finished and what it did — `ran`, `paused`, `waiting_for_company`, `rotating`, or `failed` when the tick raised — and `run_scheduler` notes when it started. `scheduler_heartbeat()` returns both; they live in process memory, not the database. Settings → Setup status (`GET /setup/status`) reads them: no start means the task isn't running; no tick five minutes after starting, or none for three poll intervals (at least 90 s), means the loop has stopped; `failed` and `waiting_for_company` get their own light. Liveness is judged before the pause switch, because a paused scheduler still ticks: one that has stopped shows as stopped, where the Resume button wouldn't help. A restart clears the previous run's last tick. Due actions run as their own tasks, so a slow brief never ages the heartbeat.\n\n### A teammate's scheduled rows\n\n`schedule_followup` and `suggest_workflow` keep the speaker on the row (`scheduled_actions.created_by_person_id`, from `Session.caller_person_id`). A due row whose creator is the principal, or that has no creator (the system's own rows, rows from before the column), takes the ordinary dispatch. A row a teammate queued runs as that teammate (`runner._run_teammate_followup`), because its intent is their own text: it is cancelled unless the creator is still an active team member and the row's address is one of their own; the Executive only writes the message, on an unattended session with `run_for_person_id` naming the teammate, which makes it read-only like a turn from another AI app that may not act (`schedule_tools.read_only_turn`: none of `MCP_CLIENT_WITHHELD_TOOLS` and only the gateway reads in `MCP_CLIENT_MCP_TOOLS`); its context is the decisions and advice of the conversation that queued it (nothing when there is none), never the company-wide list; and the runner sends the text to the teammate's own address on the row's channel (`_send_on_plan`), retrying on a failed send. A fork that limits what a teammate's turns may use applies the same limit to the run through `run_for_person_id`.\n\n**A follow-up overtaken by events.** An ad hoc follow-up back to the person who set it (the row's creator, else its conversation's owner, the principal when it has none; and only when its address is their own, `runner._followup_owner`) fires with what they wrote in chat since it was set: up to 30 of their own messages, 300 characters each, across all their conversations (`session_store.own_messages_since`; only their words, never a reply or someone else's line), in `<since_scheduled>` tags as data. The run is asked first whether that shows it is already done or no longer needed, and if so to send nothing and answer `ALREADY_HANDLED: <why>`. The runner then records the row `cancelled` with `skipped: already handled (<why>)` and a `scheduled_action` audit row with phase `skipped`, instead of `done`. A teammate's row gets the same block and check before the runner sends what it wrote. A follow-up to anyone else, or with no chat since, fires exactly as before.\n\n### Cadence DSL\n\n`openexecutive.departments.cadence` supports, all in UTC for department and workflow cadences:\n\n- `daily@HH:MM`\n- `weekly@DOW@HH:MM` or `weekly@DOW-HH:MM` (DOW is a 3-letter day, e.g. `weekly@thu@09:00`)\n- `quarterly@DD-HH:MM`\n\n`PATCH /departments/{slug}` rejects a spec that does not parse (bad format, unknown DOW, out-of-range time) with a 422 naming the valid formats, so a typo is caught at save time instead of silently never firing. An empty spec means no cadence (the department page's **Off**). A new department starts weekly, `weekly@mon@09:00`. Changing a department's `check_in` through that route re-times it at once: `cadence.reschedule_check_in()` cancels its pending `dept_cadence` row and queues the next occurrence of the new spec (nothing when it is off or in solo); a check-in already running finishes, and its chain adds nothing because the new row is pending.\n\nWhen a department cadence is due, the runner invokes the `department_check_in` workflow and chains the following occurrence via `cadence.enqueue_next()`. The fire is not passed through the authority gate: the check-in sends nothing (it grades Goals, writes one audit row and a Honcho note), and every action it proposes carries its own `gate_action` verdict in the report. Before creating a run the runner applies a skip rule (`department_check_in.needs_check_in`): the check-in is skipped when the department has no specialist agent, has no Goals, or nothing is new since its Goals were last reviewed — no decision or audit row tagged to the department (the check-in's own review row aside) since the oldest Goal's `last_reviewed_at`, and no Goal edited after it was graded. A Goal never reviewed always runs it. A skip leaves no run in the activity rail, is recorded as `cancelled` with its reason (`skipped: …` in `last_error`) rather than `done` — a done cadence row means \"the check-in ran\" to the nudge engine — and still chains the next occurrence; so does a check-in that fails once its retries are spent, so one broken department does not fall out of its cycle. That final failure also files one Home card, \"*Finance* check-in didn't finish\" (`workflows.failure_alerts`, source `workflow_failed`, tagged `failed_run:<run id>`; repeats of the same check-in coalesce into it), because nobody watches a scheduled run; a scheduled saved workflow (`dynamic_workflow`) that fails files the same card, routed to the person it delivers to. The card's **Run again** (`POST /workflows/runs/{run_id}/rerun`) queues the same action, due now, with `scope_key` `rerun:<run id>`: it skips the skip rule and does not chain another occurrence, and re-timing the check-in leaves it queued (the dept chain is idempotent anyway; a saved workflow's `schedule_dynamic_workflow_cadence` is skipped). Chaining is idempotent: while a next occurrence for the department is already pending nothing is added, so a row that chained and then failed to record its outcome never leaves two. Seeded departments start with no Goals, so their weekly check-ins cost nothing until someone adds one. Goals no check-in grades (no department, or a department with no specialist) are graded by the recurring `goal_review` kind instead (`GOAL_REVIEW_TIME`, default `weekly@mon@09:00` in the user's zone, both modes), seeded with the principal's rhythm and chained like the reflection: it runs `departments.goal_review.run_review` under `unscoped_audit_rows()`, delivers nothing, and a failed week never breaks the chain. Deleting a department cancels its pending `dept_cadence` rows, and `cancel_orphaned_cadences()` sweeps orphans on boot.\n\nIn **solo mode** (one person using Open Executive just for themselves; see Org) there are no department check-ins: `bootstrap_cadences()` is a no-op, switching to solo cancels every pending `dept_cadence` row, a row that was already pending is marked `cancelled` by the runner without running and without chaining — ahead of the authority gate, so a `propose_only` department cannot turn it into an approval card, and cancelled rather than done because the nudge engine reads a done check-in as a recent department pulse — and a check-in already running across the switch finishes without `enqueue_next` scheduling another. Switching back to team re-bootstraps them. Solo has one kind of its own, the **weekly review** (`principal_weekly_review`, below): switching to solo seeds it (`seed_weekly_review`), switching to team cancels its pending row (`cancel_weekly_reviews`), and one that fires while the stored mode is team is marked `cancelled` without running or chaining. That check reads the mode strictly (`workspace_settings.read_stored_mode`) and fails open: a mode that can't be read (a locked database) is not taken for team, so one bad read neither retires the review nor breaks its chain — the next run checks again.\n\nThe parser also takes a zone: `_parse_cadence_spec(spec, after, tz=UTC)` builds the wall-clock time in `tz` and only then converts to UTC, so a local schedule stays at the same local time across daylight-saving changes (a time the spring-forward gap skips fires once, just after the jump; a time the fall-back repeats fires at its first occurrence).\n\n### The principal's rhythm\n\nThe morning brief (`principal_brief_morning`, 08:00), end-of-day digest (`principal_brief_eod`, 18:00) and reflection (`executive_reflection`, 07:30) are seeded once per database by `seed_principal_briefs()` and each chains its next occurrence when it fires. In a solo workspace it also seeds the **weekly review** (`principal_weekly_review`, Friday 16:00 local by default), which runs the `weekly_review` workflow and is delivered like the briefs; its `PRINCIPAL_WEEKLY_REVIEW_TIME` takes a whole weekly spec (`weekly@fri@16:00`), read as UTC when valid, like the pinned times below, and it chains only while the workspace is still solo — and never when a weekly row is already pending, so a switch to solo while a review finishes cannot leave two. Their default times are local to the user's zone — `memory.workspace_settings.get_user_timezone()`: the zone set through `PUT /workspace`, else `USER_TIMEZONE`, else UTC — computed with the cadence parser above. An operator who pinned a valid `HH:MM` in `PRINCIPAL_BRIEF_MORNING_TIME` / `PRINCIPAL_BRIEF_EOD_TIME` / `PRINCIPAL_REFLECTION_TIME` keeps that time read as UTC, as before zones existed, so a pinned time never moves; a malformed value is logged and treated as unset. An install that set `USER_TIMEZONE` but pinned nothing does move to that zone, from each kind's first fire after the upgrade (a row seeded before it keeps its old UTC time once). When the zone in effect changes, `reschedule_principal_rhythm()` re-times each kind's pending, not-yet-due row **in place** — it only updates `run_at` (guarded on the row being unchanged since it was read), never inserts or cancels, so it cannot race a chain into a duplicate. The new time is the next occurrence in the new zone after `max(now, last fired run + 12h)`, so a kind never runs twice within 12 hours; and if that is more than 12 hours later than the row's current time — moving would skip a day, as when someone switches to Europe/London at 07:59 UTC with the 08:00 UTC brief a minute away — the row keeps its time once. A kind with no such row is left alone: a row that is running, one between being marked done and its chain insert, or a due row held by a pause or a missing company profile. Its chain times the next one in the new zone, and the chain itself starts from `max(now, fired run + 12h)`, so a zone change while a brief runs cannot put a second brief a few hours after it. The weekly review follows the same rules with a 3.5-day gap (`_min_gap`) in place of 12 hours, so a zone change can neither run it twice in a week nor skip one.\n\nUser-created (dynamic) workflows can carry the same cadence DSL. A cadence-enabled definition enqueues a `dynamic_workflow` action (`workflows.dynamic_cadence`); when due, the runner runs the stored `DynamicWorkflow`, DMs the definition's `cadence_person_id` what the run came to (`workflows/run_message`: a fast-model message written from the full report for its reader — what came of the run in their timezone, no tool or step names — or no message at all when the run found nothing and did nothing they need to hear about; the full report stays on the run), and re-chains the next occurrence. A workflow that reads its creator's own mail or calendar (`delegation.workflow_reads`) runs as theirs instead: the run is created with them as its owner (their history alone), its steps run as them, every audit row is theirs (`private_run`), and the artifact, a held-writes pause's eventual delivery and a failure card go to them whatever the cadence names. Saving/updating/deleting the definition reconciles its pending `dynamic_workflow` rows. A cadence definition may not contain an approval gate — a cron fire has no human to ask — with one exception, the **held-writes** pause: when an action step holds a write to a new target, the runner checkpoints the run (`checkpoint_gate`, the owner is DMed), still marks the row done and re-chains the cadence, and stamps `deliver_to_person_id` on the resume payload so the resumer sends that same message to the cadence recipient once the owner answers (or the 48 h timeout skips the held writes). Any other gate is still refused at execution: it calls `workflows.gate.ensure_workflow_event`, which raises on a gate so the run is recorded as failed. It previously ignored the gate and stored a completed run with `\"(no artifact)\"` as its body, which looked like a success every period.\n\n**Monthly tally.** On the first weekday of each month, in daytime (09:00–18:00 local), a tick hook beside the reminders (`_maybe_send_monthly_value` → `briefing.value_summary.maybe_send_monthly`, checked every 15 minutes) sends the owner last month's counted lines and a link to Pulse → Your month through `_deliver_to_principal`, in solo and team mode alike. It is claimed once per month (`briefing_narrative` scope `value_summary:YYYY-MM`, never released, so one try), skipped for an empty month, audited `value_summary_sent` / `value_summary_not_sent`, and off with `VALUE_SUMMARY_MONTHLY_ENABLED=false`. It is not a `scheduled_actions` row.\n\n### Department authority & cancelling\n\nA department-scoped row passes the authority gate (`departments.authority.gate_action`, see Org) before it is dispatched: `auto_execute` dispatches; `propose_only` raises an approval card and marks the row done without dispatching (deferred to the approver's next availability window when they are outside it); `escalate` raises an urgent `[ESCALATION]` card (severity high) straight away — never deferred — and likewise does not dispatch, because approving the card is what sends it. As that card is the action's only trace it always lands: unrouted when there is no approver and no principal, and deduped on the whole action (kind, channel, recipient and intent) rather than the summary's first 60 characters, so another escalation sharing an opening — or the same text for someone else — cannot swallow it. An identical escalation folds into a still-open card and gets a fresh one once that card was handled, and a card that cannot be written retries the row with backoff and, once the retries are spent, marks it `failed` — never `done`. (It used to raise the card *and* dispatch.) The runner records which action each card holds (`alert_held_actions`, server-side only, never a tag a model could write): approving one (`POST /alerts/{id}/approve`) queues a copy of that exact action with no department, so it goes out on the next tick without meeting the gate again. A `dept_cadence` row is not gated at all — gating it turned every check-in on a propose-only department (all eight seeded ones) into a one-shot card, and the row never chained its next occurrence. Nudge-engine rows carry no department and bypass the gate.\n\nA `pending` row can be cancelled with `DELETE /scheduled/{id}` — the Pulse page's Cancel; the update only moves a row that is still `pending`, so one the scheduler has just claimed is never overwritten. Cancelling only stops work, so, like pause, any signed-in user may: the route accepts a signed-in caller through the UI proxy (its `x-caller-email`, trusted only alongside the `BACKEND_SHARED_SECRET` `x-api-key`), a matching `X-Admin-Token` (`SCHEDULED_ADMIN_TOKEN`, for scripts), or a loopback caller when no token is set — otherwise 401 (token set) or 503. Each cancel is audited as `scheduled_action_cancelled` with who did it.\n\n### Channel routing & nudges\n\nThe delivery channel lives on the `scheduled_actions` row (`channel` / `channel_ref`); the runner dispatches through whichever was set at enqueue time — `telegram`, `slack_dm`, `discord_dm`, `email`, or `__internal__` (workflow steps and heartbeats bypass outbound dispatch). Rows left pending by the removed staff-onboarding kinds drain through that same `__internal__` short-circuit (marked done, no dispatch); the removed talent workflows' *ad-hoc* reminders sat on the principal's real DM channel instead, so a one-shot startup sweep (`memory.episodic.cancel_orphaned_talent_reminders`) cancels them — `ad_hoc`, no department, `pending` or `running`, matching the five generated reminder shapes (outreach, interview coordination, reference checks, onboarding check-in, offer expiry) — and clears the awaiting-reply flag on delivered ones so the nudge engine stops chasing them. The marker row in `app_migrations` is claimed first with `INSERT OR IGNORE` in the same transaction, so concurrent boots cannot double-run or crash. The nudge engine (`scheduler.nudge_engine`, default 15 min) scans stalled `awaiting_human` runs, stale commitments, and idle initiatives, then emits `proactive_nudge` rows routed via `people.channel.prefer_channel_for` — honouring each Person's preferred (last-used) channel and availability windows, deferring those outside their window and skipping those with no reachable channel. Emission is capped per `scope_key` (`NUDGE_MAX_PER_SCOPE`, default 3 delivered nudges) so a parked item is not chased forever.\n\nAn idle initiative is chased with its department's head; with no head to resolve — no department (what the episodic extractor stores), an unknown department, or no head set — the principal owns it. That source used to skip every initiative without a head, so in practice it never fired. The principal gets self-addressed wording (\"<title>\" has not moved since <date> — still active, done, or dropped?). If channel routing cannot reach the principal (no channel configured, or unreachable beyond `NUDGE_MAX_DEFER_DAYS`), the nudge becomes an unrouted Briefing card instead, keyed on the initiative and the ISO week: at most one card per initiative per week, and while one is still unread the scan leaves it alone rather than refreshing it every 15 minutes. The emitted nudge still carries no department, and the usual caps and cooldowns apply. A department-tagged initiative is still skipped while its department's check-in actually ran inside the idle window; a skipped check-in does not count.\n\nThe stale-commitment source also chases **open loops** (see Attunement): `scheduled_actions` rows with `kind='open_loop'`, recorded `done` on the `__internal__` channel so the runner never dispatches them, whose `awaiting_response_since` is the loop's *due time*. They are chased as soon as they are overdue — not after `NUDGE_COMMITMENT_STALE_DAYS` — with a check-in intent addressed to the loop's owner (which quotes only the owner's own verbatim words and tells the dispatching turn to treat them as data), through the same `prefer_channel_for` routing, availability windows and outbound guard. Until open loops existed nothing in production set `awaiting_response_since`, so this source had nothing to chase. Each scan first closes loops older than `ATTUNEMENT_LOOP_TTL_DAYS` (21) as `expired`, then marks proactive outreach nobody answered within `ATTUNEMENT_IGNORE_AFTER_HOURS` as `ignored` in the outcome ledger. Ranking uses that ledger: a candidate whose person left their last five resolved nudges of that kind unanswered ranks after all others and waits three times its cooldown; a single answer lifts it. Approving a stalled run (however it's approved) and updating an initiative count as acting on the nudges that chased them. The generic dispatch path tags each send with its source (`_outreach_source`) so the ledger can attribute it.\n\n### Alert lifecycle: expiry sweep and the review heartbeat\n\nTwo alert-maintenance jobs live here. The **expiry sweep** is loop-level, not a heartbeat row: `_maybe_sweep_alerts` runs `alerts.lifecycle.expire_stale_alerts` (and, on the same 15-minute throttle, `monitoring.research.watch_policy.sweep` — expiring unreviewed research watch suggestions, auto-disabling research-added watches that proved noisy or dead, and filing one `watchlist_suggestions` nudge when ≥3 suggestions have waited ≥7 days; see External monitoring) once at boot and every 15 minutes at the top of the tick — before the company-profile and rotation gates, so an old backlog expires even before onboarding completes, flipping `unread` alerts past their category TTL to `expired` and auditing `alert_sweep`. Pure DB hygiene, no model call, reversible via `POST /alerts/{id}/reopen`. The same throttled call also deletes Always in the loop notes past their expiry (`memory.history.sweep_expired`; reads already skip them, and it never raises). Each tick also calls `_maybe_remind_notes` → `memory.history_reminders.maybe_remind` (its own 15-minute throttle, 09:00–18:00 local, one task at a time): a person whose notes say something they promised by email is due today gets one message saying how many, through `deliver_to_person` — the brief's own channel order for any Person, never a shared channel (`delivery_order` now skips a Telegram group id, for the briefs too); a message `_send_on_plan` sends into a Telegram chat or Slack or Discord DM is saved into that chat's current conversation (`integrations.conversations.record_delivery`, see Integrations), so a reply to a brief, digest or report has it in view, with the senders' audit rows private to that person. A hook rather than a `scheduled_actions` row, which `/scheduled` would show to everyone (see Memory).\n\nThe **Executive alert review** is a real heartbeat — kind `alert_review_scan`, `__internal__` channel, bootstrapped idempotently at startup when `ALERT_REVIEW_ENABLED` and chained every `ALERT_REVIEW_INTERVAL_HOURS` (6) with the same crash-resilient run → mark-done → chain shape as `nudge_scan`. `_run_principal_brief` also runs a `pre_brief` pass right before the morning brief (a review failure never blocks the brief). Each pass re-examines open alerts with evidence and, within department authority and the privacy rule, routes, nudges, escalates, drafts, merges or resolves them — see the Today section for the policy. The moves go through the real handlers (`message_person`, `draft_artifact`), so the outbound anti-spam guard applies, and `ALERT_REVIEW_MAX_MOVES_PER_SCAN` bounds side effects per pass.\n\nThe /today **\"What's going on\" header** is kept current from the tick too, so it is fresh before anyone opens the page. `_maybe_refresh_narrative` is a throttled call inside the loop, like the alert sweep — no `scheduled_actions` row. It runs after the pause, company-profile and rotation gates, every `BRIEFING_NARRATIVE_REFRESH_MINUTES` (10; 0 turns it off) and only between `BRIEFING_NARRATIVE_REFRESH_START_HOUR` and `_END_HOUR` (06–22) in the user's zone. It starts `today.refresh_principal_narrative` as its own task, so a slow model call never holds the tick, and never starts a second while one runs. That refreshes the cached calendar read (`live_signals.refresh_calendar`, at most once per 15 minutes) and rewrites the principal's header only when its key moved — new mail, a held reply, a proposal, the hour — with the route's own per-scope lock, so a page view and the tick never write the same header twice (see Today).\n\nAct as me's **reminders** are loop-level too: `_maybe_send_reminders` starts `delegation.reminders.maybe_send` at most once a minute, which claims each due `delegation_reminders` row once (due times are stored in UTC, so they compare in order) (compare-and-set on `claimed_at`) and sends its stored text, prefixed \"Reminder you set on <date>:\", to the person who set it alone through `deliver_to_person`. No model and no tool run; a reminder missed by more than two days is dropped rather than sent late, and one due in the person's quiet hours or leave waits, unclaimed, until they end; audit rows are private to the person. They are not `scheduled_actions` rows for the same reason as the scan below: that list is everyone's, and its rows run an Executive turn when they fire.\n\n**Held messages** are loop-level as well: `_maybe_release_held` starts `people.held_messages.maybe_release` at most once a minute, which sends each person whatever is due to them — messages held for their quiet hours once those end, and brief-held messages made due when the briefs run — as one *While you were away* message through `deliver_to_person`, claims each row first so a brief can't send it too, marks them sent only once that went, postpones a person back in quiet hours, on leave or outside their windows to when that ends, backs off 2, 4, 8 … minutes (at most an hour) after any other failure, and audits every drop (too old, over the cap) privately as a count, and writes audit rows private to the person. The principal-brief handler appends the principal's brief-held messages to the morning brief or end-of-day digest it delivers (`_with_held_messages`; the stored run artifact is unchanged), claims them, marks them sent only when the brief went (otherwise frees the claim), then makes everyone else's due (`_release_others_digests`). The `proactive_nudge` re-check calls `prefer_channel_for` / `next_available_window` with `quiet_hours=True` (urgent for a `nudge:stalled:` scope key), so a nudge due in the person's quiet hours is deferred to their end like one outside an availability window. A dispatch whose message was held is audited `held`, not `delivered`. See Org for the notification settings.\n\nAct as me's **inbox watcher** is loop-level the same way: `_maybe_scan_inbox`, after the same gates, starts the due scans (`delegation.inbox.maybe_scan`) as one task and never a second while one runs. A person is due every `DELEGATION_INBOX_POLL_MINUTES` (default 5) once their **Draft replies to my inbox** switch is on, unless a Gmail failure set a back-off; nobody is scanned while a client slot is active. It is deliberately not a `scheduled_actions` row: those are listed on `/scheduled` for everyone and anyone may cancel them, and a scan reads the owner's own mail. Every row a scan writes is private to the principal (see Act as Me).\n\nThe **contact keeper** is loop-level too: `_maybe_keep_contacts`, right after the inbox watcher, calls `people.contact_keeper.maybe_run`, which starts one pass at most every 6 hours (an in-process start time plus the stored `last_run_at`, so a restart doesn't re-run it) and never a second while one runs. Like the scans it is not a `scheduled_actions` row, because it reads the principal's own mail. See Org.\n\n### Principal briefs\n\nThe `principal_brief_morning` / `principal_brief_eod` / `principal_weekly_review` rows (and the client-rotation digest) are delivered by `_deliver_to_principal`, not through a row channel. The principal's `preferred_channel` (`slack` / `discord` / `telegram` / `email` / `any`, where `any` means the chat app they last talked in) is tried first, then the other chat channels they have an id for (Slack → Discord → Telegram), by `people.reach.reach_order`. Email goes through the active MCP gateway: first when the preference is `email`, and otherwise last, as the backup after every chat channel. Before planning, the delivery asks the gateway supervisor for a start if the gateway is down (`runner.ensure_email_ready` → `mcp_gateway.ensure_active_gateway`, the lazy re-check), and a row action resolves the gateway at execution time rather than from what boot had, so a gateway that failed at boot and came up on a retry carries the brief. The outcome names what happened: `gateway_down` when email is set up but the gateway is not running (the Executive's fault, with the start failure, never `no_channel`, which blamed the owner's setup), and a `send_failed` detail that quotes each channel's own error (`email: invalid_grant …`, `slack_dm: channel_not_found`), stored with the outcome (`brief_state.record_delivery_outcome(detail=…)`) and shown on the Briefing notice and the Setup page's *Daily brief* light, whose fix says to reconnect when the detail shows a dead grant. Delivery stops at the first channel that sends, so an owner linked by email at setup keeps their Slack delivery without extra email, and gets the brief by email only when Slack is missing or fails. The email is formatted HTML (`utils.markdown_email`: raw HTML and images off, unsafe link schemes dropped) with a subject dated in the user's zone (\"Morning Brief — Fri 25 Sep\"). Email counts as ready only when the MCP gateway runs the Google Workspace server. Every run's outcome — delivered, no owner, nowhere to send it, every send failed, or the brief couldn't be written at all (the workflow failed or produced nothing) — is recorded with the channel's name (never an address) under `brief_state`, for the Briefing's notice and the Setup status \"Daily brief\" light (the weekly review's outcome too — `brief_state.DELIVERY_KINDS` — so a weekly review that wasn't sent is reported the same way). The light also turns amber when a brief got through only on a backup channel, naming the one that failed. `_run_principal_brief` sets `morning_brief.PRINCIPAL_DELIVERY` for the run, because it goes to the principal alone: only then (or on the principal's own verified chat turn) does the morning brief read what is private to them. When the workflow reports `private_to_principal` on its `result` event — it did read such a row — the run history keeps `persistence.PRIVATE_RUN_ARTIFACT` in place of the text (`stored_artifact`), since `/workflows/runs` is readable by everyone signed in; the principal gets the full text where it is delivered. When no channel can deliver at all (a web-only principal, or email with no gateway), the brief is still generated and stored as a run with its artifact — a web-only principal reads it on the Artifacts page — it is just not delivered, and the next occurrence is chained; see Workflows.\n\n## Client rotation claim pause\n\nThe `client_rotation` kind (multi-client practice mode, opt-in via `CLIENT_ROTATION_ENABLED`) adds one loop-level behavior: while a rotation's `.rotation_in_progress` marker exists, the scheduler **skips claiming entirely** for that tick. Rotation switches the live company context between parked clients; claiming during the window would fire the just-activated client's overdue outbound follow-ups from a context nobody is watching. Everything due fires on the first tick after the original client is restored. Stale markers (crash mid-rotation) are reconciled at scheduler startup, and the rotation row is idempotently re-seeded both at boot and after every slot activation (scheduled rows swap with the client). See the Client Companies section for the rotation's full design.\n\nAn optional `notion_sync_scan` heartbeat (`NOTION_SYNC_ENABLED`, off by default) incrementally re-indexes Notion pages the workspace integration can see into the isolated `notion_wiki` collection (not COMPANY), reconciles un-shared pages, then chains the next tick. An optional `drive_sync_scan` heartbeat (`DRIVE_SYNC_ENABLED`, off by default, bootstrapped in the lifespan beside it) does the same for the configured Google Drive folders, into the isolated `drive_docs` collection (see RAG). An optional `onedrive_sync_scan` heartbeat (`ONEDRIVE_SYNC_ENABLED`, off by default) does the same for the configured OneDrive folders, into `onedrive_docs`. An optional `confluence_sync_scan` heartbeat (`CONFLUENCE_SYNC_ENABLED`, off by default, bootstrapped in the lifespan the same way) re-indexes the changed pages of the configured Confluence spaces into the isolated `confluence_wiki` collection, leaving out restricted pages, and purges pages that were deleted, moved out or restricted.\n\n**Take the lead wakes.** With Take the lead as the Executive on, a turn from a channel (mail, Slack, Discord, Telegram, Google Chat) calls `take_the_lead.wake`, which inserts one `take_the_lead_wake` `__internal__` action five minutes out. It does nothing while one is pending or running, and nothing within 30 minutes of the last wake. The runner's `_run_take_the_lead_wake` runs the same reflection as the daily rhythm (`_reflect`, shared with `_run_executive_reflection`), only if the switch is still on, and never chains. The pause holds it like every claim.\n\n**Conversation reviews.** A kept chat turn (`memory.chat_review.record_turn`) makes sure one `chat_review` `__internal__` action is waiting for that conversation (`channel_ref` = session id), 30 minutes (`CHAT_REVIEW_QUIET_MINUTES`) out. `_run_chat_review` marks it done, then `chat_review.run_scheduled` either schedules a fresh one for 30 minutes after the newest turn (the chat is still going) or reviews the turns not yet reviewed. It never chains, and the pause holds it like every claim.\n\n**Replay of the misses.** The `chat_replay` kind (`memory.replay`) is seeded with the briefs by `seed_principal_briefs()` and chains its next occurrence like the reflection (`_run_chat_replay`; `CHAT_REPLAY_TIME`, 03:30 in the user's zone, pinned as UTC when set). It replays the turns the conversation review graded a miss with the lessons and facts in force today, in a dry run, judges each, and records the night (`chat_review_replay_runs`) whether or not anything was due; a failed night still marks done and chains. The pause holds it like every claim.",
"mermaid": "flowchart TD\n Loop[\"run_scheduler<br/>poll every 30s\"]\n Pause{\"is_paused()?<br/>(executive_control)\"}\n Claim[\"claim_due_actions<br/>(status=pending, by kind)\"]\n Table[(\"scheduled_actions\")]\n Dispatch[\"dispatch via row channel<br/>(ad_hoc / proactive_nudge)\"]\n Dept[\"dept_cadence →<br/>department_check_in<br/>(skipped when nothing is new)\"]\n Solo[\"solo workspace →<br/>cancelled, no chain\"]\n Nudge[\"nudge_scan →<br/>nudge_engine scan\"]\n Brief[\"principal_brief_morning / _eod →<br/>morning_brief / end_of_day_digest<br/>(user's local time)\"]\n Weekly[\"principal_weekly_review (solo) →<br/>weekly_review, Fri 16:00 local\"]\n Reflect[\"executive_reflection →<br/>reflection (artifact only)\"]\n ExtMon[\"external_monitor_scan →<br/>monitoring pipeline\"]\n Research[\"watchlist_research_scan →<br/>executive_research (skip-if-unchanged)\"]\n Notion[\"notion_sync_scan →<br/>isolated wiki ingest\"]\n Drive[\"drive_sync_scan →<br/>isolated Drive folder ingest\"]\n Confluence[\"confluence_sync_scan →<br/>isolated Confluence space ingest\"]\n Chain[\"enqueue_next<br/>(re-arm recurring tick)\"]\n Prefer[\"prefer_channel_for<br/>(availability + last-used)\"]\n Channels[\"Slack / Discord<br/>Telegram / Email\"]\n Principal[\"DM or email principal\"]\n Alerts[\"alerts pipeline → /today\"]\n Loop --> Pause\n Pause -- \"paused: hold, sleep\" --> Loop\n Pause -- \"running\" --> Claim\n Claim -- \"claim due rows\" --> Table\n Claim -- \"ad_hoc / proactive_nudge\" --> Dispatch\n Claim -- \"dept_cadence\" --> Dept\n Claim -- \"dept_cadence (solo)\" --> Solo\n Claim -- \"nudge_scan\" --> Nudge\n Claim -- \"principal_brief_*\" --> Brief\n Claim -- \"principal_weekly_review\" --> Weekly\n Claim -- \"executive_reflection\" --> Reflect\n Claim -- \"external_monitor_scan\" --> ExtMon\n Claim -- \"watchlist_research_scan\" --> Research\n Claim -- \"notion_sync_scan\" --> Notion\n Claim -- \"drive_sync_scan\" --> Drive\n Claim -- \"confluence_sync_scan\" --> Confluence\n Nudge -- \"prefer_channel_for\" --> Prefer\n Prefer -- \"emits proactive_nudge\" --> Table\n Dispatch --> Channels\n Brief --> Principal\n Weekly --> Principal\n ExtMon --> Alerts\n Dept --> Chain\n Nudge --> Chain\n Brief --> Chain\n Weekly -- \"while solo\" --> Chain\n Reflect --> Chain\n ExtMon --> Chain\n Research --> Chain\n Notion --> Chain\n Drive --> Chain\n Confluence --> Chain\n Chain --> Table\n class Loop entry\n class Claim compute\n class Table storage\n class Dispatch compute\n class Dept compute\n class Solo compute\n class Nudge compute\n class Brief compute\n class Weekly compute\n class Reflect compute\n class ExtMon compute\n class Research compute\n class Notion compute\n class Drive compute\n class Confluence compute\n class Chain compute\n class Prefer compute\n class Channels external\n class Principal external\n class Alerts hot",
- "generated_at": "2026-10-23T12:46:17Z"
+ "generated_at": "2026-10-26T13:22:39.813606+00:00"
}
diff --git a/packages/core/openexecutive/integrations/conversations.py b/packages/core/openexecutive/integrations/conversations.py
index 4ff1d0e7..b59f8738 100644
--- a/packages/core/openexecutive/integrations/conversations.py
+++ b/packages/core/openexecutive/integrations/conversations.py
@@ -4,13 +4,16 @@ Each adapter computes its stream's base id as before, then asks
``conversation_for`` which conversation a message belongs to, answers
``/new`` with ``start_fresh``, and calls ``title_after_turn`` once a turn is
saved so a conversation's first exchange gives it a title, as a web chat's
-does.
+does. ``record_delivery`` saves what the Executive sent on its own (a brief,
+a digest, a workflow's report) into the conversation, so a reply to it has
+it in view.
"""
from __future__ import annotations
import asyncio
import logging
import re
+from pathlib import Path
from openexecutive.memory.conversation_ids import base_session_id, is_rolling
@@ -44,6 +47,52 @@ def conversation_for(base_id: str) -> str:
return base_id
+def record_delivery(
+ base_id: str,
+ text: str,
+ *,
+ owner_person_id: int | None,
+ title: str,
+ db_path: Path | None = None,
+) -> str | None:
+ """Save ``text``, which the Executive just sent into ``base_id``'s stream
+ on its own, as its message in the conversation a reply would join.
+
+ Without it the reply's turn has nothing before it: "can you fix it?"
+ after the evening digest reads as a question out of nowhere, and when the
+ stream was quiet for a while the reply even starts a new conversation.
+ Saving it also counts as activity, so the reply lands in this same
+ conversation. ``title`` names a conversation this message starts; an
+ existing one keeps its name. Returns the conversation's id, or None when
+ it couldn't be saved. Sync (SQLite); never raises.
+ """
+ if not is_rolling(base_id) or not (text or "").strip():
+ return None
+ from datetime import UTC, datetime
+
+ from openexecutive.memory import episodic
+ from openexecutive.memory.conversations import current_conversation
+ from openexecutive.memory.session_store import (
+ create_session,
+ save_message,
+ update_session_timestamp,
+ )
+
+ path = db_path or episodic.DB_PATH
+ try:
+ session_id = current_conversation(base_session_id(base_id), db_path=path)
+ create_session(
+ session_id, title, datetime.now(UTC).isoformat(),
+ caller_person_id=owner_person_id, db_path=path,
+ )
+ save_message(session_id, "assistant", text, db_path=path)
+ update_session_timestamp(session_id, db_path=path)
+ except Exception:
+ logger.exception("conversations: couldn't save a delivery into %s", base_id)
+ return None
+ return session_id
+
+
def start_fresh(base_id: str, owner_person_id: int | None) -> str:
"""Start a new conversation in ``base_id``'s stream and return the reply
to send. Sync (SQLite)."""
diff --git a/packages/core/openexecutive/orchestrator/session.py b/packages/core/openexecutive/orchestrator/session.py
index 2f498b49..e4a876e4 100644
--- a/packages/core/openexecutive/orchestrator/session.py
+++ b/packages/core/openexecutive/orchestrator/session.py
@@ -6,6 +6,7 @@ from datetime import datetime
from typing import TYPE_CHECKING, Any
from openexecutive.memory.company_profile import CompanyProfile
+from openexecutive.memory.conversation_ids import is_rolling
if TYPE_CHECKING:
from openexecutive.memory.workspace_settings import PrincipalRole
@@ -22,6 +23,10 @@ def history_window_start(total: int, max_turns: int = 20, step_turns: int = 10)
return ((total - keep) // step) * step
+# The user turn put before history that opens with the Executive's message.
+CONTINUED_PLACEHOLDER = "(Continuing our chat.)"
+
+
@dataclass
class Session:
session_id: str = field(default_factory=lambda: str(uuid.uuid4()))
@@ -276,8 +281,15 @@ class Session:
"""
start = history_window_start(len(self.conversation_history), max_turns, step_turns)
history = self.conversation_history[start:]
- # Anthropic requires messages to start with a user turn.
- # Drop a leading assistant message if history length is odd (can happen on error recovery).
+ # Anthropic requires messages to start with a user turn. A chat-app
+ # conversation can open with the Executive's own message (a brief or
+ # digest it sent, ``integrations.conversations.record_delivery``).
+ # Dropping that would hide what the person is answering, so there a
+ # placeholder turn goes first; anywhere else a leading assistant
+ # message (left by error recovery) is dropped.
if history and history[0]["role"] != "user":
- history = history[1:]
+ if is_rolling(self.session_id):
+ history = [{"role": "user", "content": CONTINUED_PLACEHOLDER}, *history]
+ else:
+ history = history[1:]
return history
diff --git a/packages/core/openexecutive/scheduler/runner.py b/packages/core/openexecutive/scheduler/runner.py
index 00349378..2bc56ba6 100644
--- a/packages/core/openexecutive/scheduler/runner.py
+++ b/packages/core/openexecutive/scheduler/runner.py
@@ -2371,6 +2371,7 @@ async def _send_on_plan(
"user_id": principal.slack_user_id, "text": text,
})
if _delivered_ok(result):
+ await _remember_in_chat(result, f"slack:dm:{principal.slack_user_id}", principal, text, label)
return _sent(channel, principal.slack_user_id)
failures.append(f"{channel}: {_error_line(result)}")
elif channel == "discord_dm" and principal.discord_user_id:
@@ -2379,6 +2380,7 @@ async def _send_on_plan(
"discord_user_id": principal.discord_user_id, "text": text,
})
if _delivered_ok(result):
+ await _remember_in_chat(result, f"discord:dm:{principal.discord_user_id}", principal, text, label)
return _sent(channel, principal.discord_user_id)
failures.append(f"{channel}: {_error_line(result)}")
elif channel == "telegram" and principal.telegram_chat_id:
@@ -2389,6 +2391,7 @@ async def _send_on_plan(
"chat_id": int(principal.telegram_chat_id), "text": text,
})
if _delivered_ok(result):
+ await _remember_in_chat(result, f"telegram:{principal.telegram_chat_id}", principal, text, label)
return _sent(channel, principal.telegram_chat_id)
failures.append(f"{channel}: {_error_line(result)}")
elif channel == "email":
@@ -2407,6 +2410,28 @@ async def _send_on_plan(
)
+async def _remember_in_chat(
+ result_json: str, base_id: str, person: Person, text: str, label: str
+) -> None:
+ """Save a message just sent into a chat app into that chat's conversation
+ (``integrations.conversations.record_delivery``), so the person's reply
+ to it has it in view. Only once it was sent: a held one is saved when
+ ``people.held_messages`` releases it, which sends through
+ ``deliver_to_person`` and so through here. Never raises."""
+ import json as _json
+
+ try:
+ if _json.loads(result_json).get("status") != "sent":
+ return
+ from openexecutive.integrations.conversations import record_delivery
+
+ await asyncio.to_thread(
+ record_delivery, base_id, text, owner_person_id=person.id, title=label,
+ )
+ except Exception:
+ logger.exception("scheduler: couldn't save the delivery into %s", base_id)
+
+
def _sent(channel: str, to: str | None) -> PrincipalDelivery:
return PrincipalDelivery(True, f"{channel} → {to}", "delivered", channel)
diff --git a/packages/core/tests/unit/test_chat_deliveries_in_history.py b/packages/core/tests/unit/test_chat_deliveries_in_history.py
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..34af07d7
--- /dev/null
+++ b/packages/core/tests/unit/test_chat_deliveries_in_history.py
@@ -0,0 +1,152 @@
+"""What the Executive sends into a chat app on its own is part of the chat.
+
+A brief, the evening digest or a workflow's report used to go out without
+being saved, so the person's reply ("can you fix it?") reached a turn with
+nothing before it, and after a quiet stretch it even opened a new
+conversation. ``record_delivery`` saves it where the reply will land.
+"""
+from __future__ import annotations
+
+import asyncio
+import json
+from datetime import UTC, datetime, timedelta
+from pathlib import Path
+from typing import Any
+
+import pytest
+
+from openexecutive.integrations.conversations import record_delivery
+from openexecutive.memory import conversations, session_store
+from openexecutive.memory.episodic import _get_conn, initialize_db
+from openexecutive.orchestrator import schedule_tools
+from openexecutive.orchestrator.session import CONTINUED_PLACEHOLDER, Session
+from openexecutive.people.models import Person
+from openexecutive.scheduler import runner
+
+OWNER = 7
+BASE = "telegram:4242"
+DIGEST = "Done for you\n\n- Your Monday prep came back empty."
+
+
+def db(tmp_path: Path) -> Path:
+ path = tmp_path / "test.db"
+ initialize_db(path)
+ return path
+
+
+def _turn(db: Path, sid: str, at: datetime) -> None:
+ session_store.create_session(sid, "Telegram Dana", at.isoformat(), caller_person_id=OWNER, db_path=db)
+ with _get_conn(db) as conn:
+ for role, text in (("user", "Q"), ("assistant", "A")):
+ conn.execute(
+ "INSERT INTO chat_messages (session_id, role, content, created_at) VALUES (?, ?, ?, ?)",
+ (sid, role, text, at.isoformat()),
+ )
+ conn.execute("UPDATE sessions SET updated_at = ? WHERE session_id = ?", (at.isoformat(), sid))
+
+
+def _roles(db: Path, sid: str) -> list[tuple[str, str]]:
+ return [(m["role"], m["content"]) for m in session_store.load_messages(sid, db_path=db)]
+
+
+def test_a_delivery_joins_the_open_conversation(db: Path) -> None:
+ _turn(db, BASE, datetime.now(UTC) - timedelta(minutes=30))
+ sid = record_delivery(BASE, DIGEST, owner_person_id=OWNER, title="Evening digest", db_path=db)
+ assert sid == BASE
+ assert _roles(db, BASE)[-1] == ("assistant", DIGEST)
+ # A reply now lands in the same conversation, after the digest.
+ assert conversations.current_conversation(BASE, db_path=db) == BASE
+
+
+def test_after_a_quiet_stretch_the_delivery_opens_the_conversation_the_reply_joins(db: Path) -> None:
+ _turn(db, BASE, datetime.now(UTC) - timedelta(hours=5))
+ sid = record_delivery(BASE, DIGEST, owner_person_id=OWNER, title="Evening digest", db_path=db)
+ assert sid == "telegram:4242~2"
+ assert _roles(db, sid) == [("assistant", DIGEST)]
+ meta = session_store.get_session_metadata(sid, db_path=db)
+ assert meta is not None and meta["title"] == "Evening digest"
+ # An hour later the reply is still within the gap of the digest.
+ later = datetime.now(UTC) + timedelta(hours=1)
+ assert conversations.current_conversation(BASE, now=later, db_path=db) == sid
+
+
+def test_the_reply_sees_a_conversation_that_opens_with_the_delivery() -> None:
+ session = Session(session_id="telegram:4242~2")
+ session.conversation_history = [
+ {"role": "assistant", "content": DIGEST},
+ {"role": "user", "content": "Can you fix it?"},
+ {"role": "assistant", "content": "Yes."},
+ ]
+ history = session.get_recent_history()
+ assert history[0] == {"role": "user", "content": CONTINUED_PLACEHOLDER}
+ assert history[1]["content"] == DIGEST
+
+
+def test_a_web_chat_still_drops_a_leading_reply() -> None:
+ session = Session(session_id="4f1c2a")
+ session.conversation_history = [
+ {"role": "assistant", "content": "orphan"},
+ {"role": "user", "content": "Hi"},
+ ]
+ assert session.get_recent_history() == [{"role": "user", "content": "Hi"}]
+
+
+def test_only_chat_app_streams_and_real_text_are_saved(db: Path) -> None:
+ assert record_delivery("4f1c2a", DIGEST, owner_person_id=OWNER, title="x", db_path=db) is None
+ assert record_delivery(BASE, " ", owner_person_id=OWNER, title="x", db_path=db) is None
+
+
+def _principal() -> Person:
+ return Person(id=OWNER, full_name="Dana", is_principal=True, telegram_chat_id="4242")
+
+
+def _run_send(monkeypatch: pytest.MonkeyPatch, result: dict[str, Any]) -> list[tuple[Any, ...]]:
+ saved: list[tuple[Any, ...]] = []
+
+ async def fake_send(_input: dict[str, Any]) -> str:
+ return json.dumps(result)
+
+ def fake_record(base_id: str, text: str, **kw: Any) -> str:
+ saved.append((base_id, text, kw["owner_person_id"], kw["title"]))
+ return base_id
+
+ monkeypatch.setattr(schedule_tools, "handle_send_telegram_message", fake_send)
+ monkeypatch.setattr("openexecutive.integrations.conversations.record_delivery", fake_record)
+ delivery = asyncio.run(runner._send_on_plan(_principal(), ["telegram"], DIGEST, label="Evening digest"))
+ assert delivery.ok
+ return saved
+
+
+def test_a_brief_sent_to_telegram_is_saved_into_the_chat(monkeypatch: pytest.MonkeyPatch) -> None:
+ saved = _run_send(monkeypatch, {"status": "sent", "chat_id": 4242})
+ assert saved == [(BASE, DIGEST, OWNER, "Evening digest")]
+
+
+def test_a_held_message_is_saved_only_when_it_goes_out(monkeypatch: pytest.MonkeyPatch) -> None:
+ assert _run_send(monkeypatch, {"status": "held"}) == []
+
+
+def test_a_held_message_is_saved_when_its_release_sends_it(monkeypatch: pytest.MonkeyPatch) -> None:
+ # people.held_messages releases through deliver_to_person, which sends on
+ # the same plan, so the released block is saved into the chat then.
+ saved: list[tuple[Any, ...]] = []
+
+ async def fake_send(_input: dict[str, Any]) -> str:
+ return json.dumps({"status": "sent", "chat_id": 4242})
+
+ async def no_email() -> bool:
+ return False
+
+ def fake_record(base_id: str, text: str, **kw: Any) -> str:
+ saved.append((base_id, text, kw["title"]))
+ return base_id
+
+ monkeypatch.setattr(schedule_tools, "handle_send_telegram_message", fake_send)
+ monkeypatch.setattr(runner, "ensure_email_ready", no_email)
+ monkeypatch.setattr("openexecutive.integrations.conversations.record_delivery", fake_record)
+ from openexecutive.people.held_messages import HEADING
+
+ delivery = asyncio.run(runner.deliver_to_person(_principal(), "While you were away: ...", label=HEADING))
+ assert delivery.ok and delivery.channel == "telegram"
+ assert saved == [(BASE, "While you were away: ...", HEADING)]