Next Gen STEP AP242 Native-ish BREP Geometric Modeling Kernel
FRIC-B0.1: correct blind-hole fixture and matrix classification
Yuechen Li5bb47e351c66
diff --git a/docs/frictionlab/FRIC-B0-chimera-pressure-test.md b/docs/frictionlab/FRIC-B0-chimera-pressure-test.mdindex a2f498fb..a7566d87 100644--- a/docs/frictionlab/FRIC-B0-chimera-pressure-test.md+++ b/docs/frictionlab/FRIC-B0-chimera-pressure-test.md@@ -4,9 +4,9 @@ Date: 2026-04-19 (UTC)## Mission state-**Meaningful progression**.+**Success (FRIC-B0.1 corrective pass)**.-This pressure-test milestone intentionally prioritizes boundary extraction over feature completion. The run produced a high-density rejection map, and isolated a key upstream blocker: feature-graph gating currently prevents most mixed analytic+prismatic follow-on probes from reaching the `BrepBooleanBoxMixedThroughVoidBuilder` family.+FRIC-B0 established a boundary map; FRIC-B0.1 corrects one misclassified datapoint (`zone_b_blind_cyl`) that INV-B0 proved was a contained cavity fixture bug. The corrected fixture now models a true exterior-opening blind hole and updates only the affected matrix row.## Source-of-truth inspection (code + CLI)@@ -40,7 +40,7 @@ Intent: stress through vs blind, family kind spread, and mixed continuation atteZones:- `zone_a_through_cyl` (baseline through cylinder)-- `zone_b_blind_cyl`+- `zone_b_blind_cyl` (corrected in FRIC-B0.1 to explicit exterior-face blind-hole placement; prior variant was contained cavity)- `zone_c_cone_through`- `zone_d_cone_blind`- `zone_e_slot_through`@@ -84,13 +84,21 @@ Zones:- Produced per-zone success/failure evidence with exact diagnostics.4. `python3` aggregation over `artifacts/fric-b0/*.json`- Clustered diagnostics into blocker classes used below.+5. `dotnet run --project Aetheris.CLI -- build testdata/firmament/frictionlab/fric-b0/chimera_a_zone_b_blind_cyl.firmament --json` (pre-fix capture)+ - Confirmed old fixture behavior in INV-B0 context: rejected with `[FIRM-SCHEMA-0006]` enclosed-void diagnostic.+6. Updated `chimera_a_zone_b_blind_cyl.firmament` to use explicit `place.on_face: chimera_a_root.top_face` blind-hole placement.+ - Converted semantics from contained internal cavity to exterior-opening blind hole.+7. `dotnet run --project Aetheris.CLI -- build testdata/firmament/frictionlab/fric-b0/chimera_a_zone_b_blind_cyl.firmament --out artifacts/fric-b0.1/zone_b_blind_cyl_new.step --json`+ - Corrected case builds successfully under process `default`.+8. `dotnet run --project Aetheris.CLI -- analyze artifacts/fric-b0.1/zone_b_blind_cyl_new.step --json`+ - Confirms single-shell manifold body (no enclosed void shell), consistent with an exterior-opening blind hole.## Per-zone result matrix| Chimera | Zone | Operation attempted | Result | Exact diagnostic (source) | Blocker class | Recommendation ||---|---|---|---|---|---|---|| A | `zone_a_through_cyl` | `subtract(box, cylinder through)` | Pass | n/a | Supported baseline | Safe to generalize now (already in family) |-| A | `zone_b_blind_cyl` | `subtract(box, cylinder blind)` | Reject | `[FIRM-SCHEMA-0006] ... fully enclosed internal void(s) ... not allowed for process 'default'` (`firmament`) | Process/schema sealed-void guard | **Must remain rejected** (unless process semantics change) |+| A | `zone_b_blind_cyl` | `subtract(box, cylinder blind from exterior face)` | Pass | n/a | Supported one-sided blind-hole family (after fixture correction) | Keep accepted; this row is now valid evidence for exterior-opening blind hole behavior || A | `zone_c_cone_through` | `subtract(box, cone through)` | Pass | n/a | Supported baseline | Safe to generalize now (already in family) || A | `zone_d_cone_blind` | `subtract(box, cone blind)` | Reject | `... does not match the supported subtract span family ...` (`BrepBoolean.AnalyticHole.NotFullySpanning`) | Non-through analytic continuation boundary | Generalizable later with new bounded representation || A | `zone_e_slot_through` | `subtract(box, slot_cut through)` | Pass | n/a | Supported prismatic through-cut family | Safe to generalize now (already in family) |@@ -127,7 +135,7 @@ Zones:- Signature: `FIRM-SCHEMA-0006` fully enclosed internal voids disallowed in process `default`.- Effect: catches certain blind-hole outcomes before/alongside geometric family checks.-INV-B0 follow-up (2026-04-19): `zone_b_blind_cyl` is fixture-contained (no exterior-face placement), so this rejection is expected enclosed-cavity policy behavior rather than a blind-hole misclassification.+INV-B0 follow-up (2026-04-19): the previous `zone_b_blind_cyl` fixture revision was contained (no exterior-face placement), so that historical rejection was enclosed-cavity policy behavior rather than blind-hole misclassification. FRIC-B0.1 replaces that fixture with explicit top-face placement and the zone now passes as a true exterior-opening blind hole.## Required boundary classification synthesisdiff --git a/docs/frictionlab/INV-B0-blind-hole-enclosed-void-diagnosis.md b/docs/frictionlab/INV-B0-blind-hole-enclosed-void-diagnosis.mdindex 8d7219f2..367e2c70 100644--- a/docs/frictionlab/INV-B0-blind-hole-enclosed-void-diagnosis.md+++ b/docs/frictionlab/INV-B0-blind-hole-enclosed-void-diagnosis.md@@ -76,6 +76,6 @@ No enclosed-void checker defect was required to explain the result.## 6) Recommended follow-up1. Reclassify FRIC-B0 `zone_b_blind_cyl` from “blind-hole” to “contained cavity” in pressure-test reporting.-2. Add a true exterior-opening blind-hole fixture variant for FRIC-B0 using explicit `place.on_face` semantics.+2. ✅ Completed in FRIC-B0.1: `testdata/firmament/frictionlab/fric-b0/chimera_a_zone_b_blind_cyl.firmament` now uses explicit `place.on_face` semantics for a true exterior-opening blind hole.3. Keep `FIRM-SCHEMA-0006` expectation for the current fixture under `default` as a guardrail.4. Optional tooling follow-up: extend `aetheris analyze` importer path to accept `BREP_WITH_VOIDS` roots so enclosed-void artifacts can be inspected directly via CLI.diff --git a/testdata/firmament/frictionlab/fric-b0/chimera_a_zone_b_blind_cyl.firmament b/testdata/firmament/frictionlab/fric-b0/chimera_a_zone_b_blind_cyl.firmamentindex 690dca54..f59ed314 100644--- a/testdata/firmament/frictionlab/fric-b0/chimera_a_zone_b_blind_cyl.firmament+++ b/testdata/firmament/frictionlab/fric-b0/chimera_a_zone_b_blind_cyl.firmament@@ -10,6 +10,9 @@ ops[2]:op: boxid: chimera_a_rootsize[3]: [60, 40, 20]+ place:+ on: origin+ offset[3]: [0, 0, -5]-op: subtractid: zone_b_blind_cyl@@ -17,4 +20,7 @@ ops[2]:with:op: cylinderradius: 4- height: 8+ height: 10+ place:+ on_face: chimera_a_root.top_face+ offset[3]: [0, 0, -10]