Next Gen STEP AP242 Native-ish BREP Geometric Modeling Kernel
FL2f rerun: reassess 4 friction cases with STEP semantic inspection
Yuechen Lif7cb746b2646
diff --git a/Aetheris.Firmament.FrictionLab/Cases/mounting-bracket-basic/review.toon b/Aetheris.Firmament.FrictionLab/Cases/mounting-bracket-basic/review.toonindex 3a9736f3..224030aa 100644--- a/Aetheris.Firmament.FrictionLab/Cases/mounting-bracket-basic/review.toon+++ b/Aetheris.Firmament.FrictionLab/Cases/mounting-bracket-basic/review.toon@@ -2,16 +2,17 @@ case_id: mounting-bracket-basicpossible: partialawkwardness: highpain_points[2]:- - "Bracket add root is still not recognized as a bounded orthogonal safe subtract root for follow-on subtract features."- - "Hole placement remains manual offset authoring with no semantic alignment helpers."+ - "Build/export now succeeds, but STEP inspection shows the base-hole intent is not preserved after additive-root continuation."+ - "Hole locations still require manual offsets with no semantic placement constraints."proposed_features[2]:- - "Broaden bounded additive-root recognition so valid bracket add/union results can re-enter safe subtract composition."- - "Face/axis placement primitives for hole positioning."-reviewer_verdict: "FL2e rerun is unchanged from FL2a: subtract continuation after bracket add still fails root recognition."+ - "Stabilize subtract continuation placement through additive roots so hole frames stay anchored to intended geometry."+ - "Add face/axis placement references for hole authoring."+reviewer_verdict: "FL2f rerun changed from FL2e: export now succeeds, but geometry is semantically wrong (base_hole is misplaced from intended base position)."previous_status: partialcurrent_status: partial-changed: no-improved: false-classification: unchanged_kernel_blocker-blocker_remaining: "Boolean feature 'base_hole' (subtract) cannot continue from 'bracket' because that prior add result is not a recognized bounded orthogonal safe subtract root."-comparison_to_fl2a: "No status change relative to FL2a; G2 did not unlock this case's subtract continuation path."+changed: yes+improved: true+classification: exported_but_semantically_wrong+blocker_remaining: "Exported STEP has two cylindrical cuts, but base_hole appears at x=11 instead of the intended base-centered x=-15 offset; this is a root-interpretation/placement mismatch rather than a pure export failure."+comparison_to_fl2e: "Compared with FL2e (no artifact), FL2f now emits STEP; however direct artifact inspection shows semantic mismatch in hole placement."+step_artifact_semantic_inspection: "Artifact contains two cylindrical surfaces (r=3.5) centered at (11,0,22) and (26,0,22); first center does not match intended base_hole offset, so result is topologically valid but semantically wrong."diff --git a/Aetheris.Firmament.FrictionLab/Cases/pocketed-plate/review.toon b/Aetheris.Firmament.FrictionLab/Cases/pocketed-plate/review.toonindex 0212cf41..3de4f7f2 100644--- a/Aetheris.Firmament.FrictionLab/Cases/pocketed-plate/review.toon+++ b/Aetheris.Firmament.FrictionLab/Cases/pocketed-plate/review.toon@@ -2,14 +2,17 @@ case_id: pocketed-platepossible: partialawkwardness: mediumpain_points[2]:- - "Region-removal relies on subtracting another box instead of declaring a pocket intent."- - "Pocket depth and top-face reference are not explicit first-class concepts."+ - "Pocket intent is still expressed as box subtraction and remains blocked by subtract rebuild representability."+ - "Top-face anchored pocket semantics are still absent from production authoring flow."proposed_features[2]:- - "Pocket primitive with profile + depth definition."- - "Feature references for top-face anchored cuts."-reviewer_verdict: "Plate pocket is expressible only as primitive abuse; semantics are missing."+ - "Support pocket-like subtract representability beyond single-box rebuild constraints."+ - "Add feature references for top-face anchored depth cuts."+reviewer_verdict: "FL2f rerun is unchanged from FL2a: pocket subtract still fails due to box-minus-box rebuild representability limits."previous_status: partialcurrent_status: partialchanged: no-blocker_class: unchanged_kernel_blocker-blocker_remaining: "Box-minus-box pocket result still cannot be represented in current subtract rebuild model."+improved: false+classification: unchanged_kernel_blocker+blocker_remaining: "Boolean feature 'pocket' (subtract): box subtraction result is not representable as a single box in M13."+comparison_to_fl2a: "No status change relative to FL2a; blocker remained BrepBoolean.RebuildResult."+step_artifact_semantic_inspection: "Not applicable: export did not succeed; no STEP artifact generated."diff --git a/Aetheris.Firmament.FrictionLab/Cases/shaft-keyway/review.toon b/Aetheris.Firmament.FrictionLab/Cases/shaft-keyway/review.toonindex 7e35d1b5..01c062b9 100644--- a/Aetheris.Firmament.FrictionLab/Cases/shaft-keyway/review.toon+++ b/Aetheris.Firmament.FrictionLab/Cases/shaft-keyway/review.toon@@ -2,16 +2,17 @@ case_id: shaft-keywaypossible: trueawkwardness: mediumpain_points[2]:- - "Keyway subtract is still outside the supported sequential safe subtract family on bounded cylinder roots."- - "Alignment intent remains offset-driven with no dedicated shaft/keyway semantic helper."+ - "Keyway subtract remains outside the supported sequential safe subtract family on cylinder roots."+ - "No semantic keyway primitive/reference exists; authoring remains offset-driven."proposed_features[2]:- - "Extend subtract family recognition for bounded cylinder-root slot/keyway geometry."- - "Reference constraints against cylindrical faces/axes."-reviewer_verdict: "FL2e rerun is unchanged from FL2a: keyway subtract remains unsupported by current safe composition rules."+ - "Extend subtract-family support for bounded cylinder-root slot/keyway cuts."+ - "Support cylindrical-face/axis anchoring for shaft features."+reviewer_verdict: "FL2f rerun is unchanged from FL2e/FL2a: keyway subtract still fails execution in BrepBoolean.RebuildResult."previous_status: failurecurrent_status: failurechanged: noimproved: falseclassification: unchanged_kernel_blocker-blocker_remaining: "Boolean feature 'keyway' (subtract): Boolean Subtract: sequential safe composition only supports subtracting supported analytic holes from the current bounded safe root family."-comparison_to_fl2a: "No status change relative to FL2a; G2 does not materially improve this shaft/keyway case."+blocker_remaining: "Boolean feature 'keyway' (subtract): sequential safe composition only supports subtracting supported analytic holes from the current bounded safe root family."+comparison_to_fl2e: "No status or diagnostic class change relative to FL2e."+step_artifact_semantic_inspection: "Not applicable: export did not succeed; no STEP artifact generated."diff --git a/Aetheris.Firmament.FrictionLab/Cases/simple-bracket/review.toon b/Aetheris.Firmament.FrictionLab/Cases/simple-bracket/review.toonindex 60880a6f..59d30bc1 100644--- a/Aetheris.Firmament.FrictionLab/Cases/simple-bracket/review.toon+++ b/Aetheris.Firmament.FrictionLab/Cases/simple-bracket/review.toon@@ -2,15 +2,16 @@ case_id: simple-bracketpossible: partialawkwardness: highpain_points[2]:- - "Second bracket add still hits M13 union rebuild constraints for non-single-box recognized roots."- - "Bracket intent is straightforward but expression remains blocked by limited add/union representability."+ - "Build/export now succeeds, but STEP inspection indicates the final solid collapses to a single box instead of the intended multi-add bracket."+ - "Add-chain intent remains fragile because semantic correctness cannot be inferred from export success alone."proposed_features[1]:- - "Expand boolean add execution beyond single recognized axis-aligned box rebuild constraints."-reviewer_verdict: "FL2e rerun remains blocked at the same second-add union step seen in FL2a."+ - "Preserve boolean-add semantics for chained bracket unions so resultant topology reflects intended profile."+reviewer_verdict: "FL2f rerun changed from FL2e: export now succeeds, but the produced geometry is semantically wrong (not the intended bracket form)."previous_status: partialcurrent_status: partial-changed: no-improved: false-classification: unchanged_kernel_blocker-blocker_remaining: "Boolean feature 'bracket' (add): Boolean Union: M13 only supports recognized axis-aligned boxes from BrepPrimitives.CreateBox(...)."-comparison_to_fl2a: "No change versus FL2a; G2 does not affect this add/union blocker path."+changed: yes+improved: true+classification: exported_but_semantically_wrong+blocker_remaining: "STEP has one manifold solid with only 6 advanced faces (rectangular prism-like), indicating wrong boolean/add result for the intended bracket shape."+comparison_to_fl2e: "Compared with FL2e (blocked at second add), FL2f now emits STEP; direct inspection shows topologically valid but semantically incorrect output."+step_artifact_semantic_inspection: "Artifact exports as MANIFOLD_SOLID_BREP, but no cylindrical features and only 6 ADVANCED_FACE entries are present, matching a simple box rather than the intended L/bracket composition."diff --git a/Aetheris.Firmament.FrictionLab/Reports/Artifacts/mounting-bracket-basic.step b/Aetheris.Firmament.FrictionLab/Reports/Artifacts/mounting-bracket-basic.stepnew file mode 100644index 00000000..b39c53a7--- /dev/null+++ b/Aetheris.Firmament.FrictionLab/Reports/Artifacts/mounting-bracket-basic.step@@ -0,0 +1,280 @@+ISO-10303-21;+HEADER;+FILE_DESCRIPTION(('Aetheris AP242 subset export'),'2;1');+FILE_NAME('aetheris_export.step','1970-01-01T00:00:00',('Aetheris'),('Aetheris'),'Aetheris.Kernel','Aetheris.Kernel','');+FILE_SCHEMA(('AP242_MANAGED_MODEL_BASED_3D_ENGINEERING_MIM_LF'));+ENDSEC;+DATA;+#1=CARTESIAN_POINT($,(26,0,22));+#2=DIRECTION($,(0,0,-1));+#3=DIRECTION($,(1,0,0));+#4=AXIS2_PLACEMENT_3D($,#1,#2,#3);+#5=PLANE($,#4);+#6=CARTESIAN_POINT($,(7,-15,22));+#7=VERTEX_POINT($,#6);+#8=CARTESIAN_POINT($,(67,-15,22));+#9=VERTEX_POINT($,#8);+#10=CARTESIAN_POINT($,(7,-15,22));+#11=DIRECTION($,(1,0,0));+#12=VECTOR($,#11,1);+#13=LINE($,#10,#12);+#14=EDGE_CURVE($,#7,#9,#13,.T.);+#15=ORIENTED_EDGE($,$,$,#14,.T.);+#16=CARTESIAN_POINT($,(67,15,22));+#17=VERTEX_POINT($,#16);+#18=CARTESIAN_POINT($,(67,-15,22));+#19=DIRECTION($,(0,1,0));+#20=VECTOR($,#19,1);+#21=LINE($,#18,#20);+#22=EDGE_CURVE($,#9,#17,#21,.T.);+#23=ORIENTED_EDGE($,$,$,#22,.T.);+#24=CARTESIAN_POINT($,(7,15,22));+#25=VERTEX_POINT($,#24);+#26=CARTESIAN_POINT($,(67,15,22));+#27=DIRECTION($,(-1,0,0));+#28=VECTOR($,#27,1);+#29=LINE($,#26,#28);+#30=EDGE_CURVE($,#17,#25,#29,.T.);+#31=ORIENTED_EDGE($,$,$,#30,.T.);+#32=CARTESIAN_POINT($,(7,15,22));+#33=DIRECTION($,(0,-1,0));+#34=VECTOR($,#33,1);+#35=LINE($,#32,#34);+#36=EDGE_CURVE($,#25,#7,#35,.T.);+#37=ORIENTED_EDGE($,$,$,#36,.T.);+#38=EDGE_LOOP($,(#15,#23,#31,#37));+#39=FACE_OUTER_BOUND('',#38,.T.);+#40=CARTESIAN_POINT($,(14.5,0,22));+#41=VERTEX_POINT($,#40);+#42=CARTESIAN_POINT($,(11,0,22));+#43=DIRECTION($,(0,0,1));+#44=DIRECTION($,(1,0,0));+#45=AXIS2_PLACEMENT_3D($,#42,#43,#44);+#46=CIRCLE($,#45,3.5);+#47=EDGE_CURVE($,#41,#41,#46,.T.);+#48=ORIENTED_EDGE($,$,$,#47,.F.);+#49=EDGE_LOOP($,(#48));+#50=FACE_BOUND('',#49,.T.);+#51=CARTESIAN_POINT($,(29.5,0,22));+#52=VERTEX_POINT($,#51);+#53=CARTESIAN_POINT($,(26,0,22));+#54=DIRECTION($,(0,0,1));+#55=DIRECTION($,(1,0,0));+#56=AXIS2_PLACEMENT_3D($,#53,#54,#55);+#57=CIRCLE($,#56,3.5);+#58=EDGE_CURVE($,#52,#52,#57,.T.);+#59=ORIENTED_EDGE($,$,$,#58,.F.);+#60=EDGE_LOOP($,(#59));+#61=FACE_BOUND('',#60,.T.);+#62=ADVANCED_FACE('',(#39,#50,#61),#5,.T.);+#63=CARTESIAN_POINT($,(26,0,62));+#64=DIRECTION($,(0,0,1));+#65=DIRECTION($,(1,0,0));+#66=AXIS2_PLACEMENT_3D($,#63,#64,#65);+#67=PLANE($,#66);+#68=CARTESIAN_POINT($,(7,-15,62));+#69=VERTEX_POINT($,#68);+#70=CARTESIAN_POINT($,(67,-15,62));+#71=VERTEX_POINT($,#70);+#72=CARTESIAN_POINT($,(7,-15,62));+#73=DIRECTION($,(1,0,0));+#74=VECTOR($,#73,1);+#75=LINE($,#72,#74);+#76=EDGE_CURVE($,#69,#71,#75,.T.);+#77=ORIENTED_EDGE($,$,$,#76,.T.);+#78=CARTESIAN_POINT($,(67,15,62));+#79=VERTEX_POINT($,#78);+#80=CARTESIAN_POINT($,(67,-15,62));+#81=DIRECTION($,(0,1,0));+#82=VECTOR($,#81,1);+#83=LINE($,#80,#82);+#84=EDGE_CURVE($,#71,#79,#83,.T.);+#85=ORIENTED_EDGE($,$,$,#84,.T.);+#86=CARTESIAN_POINT($,(7,15,62));+#87=VERTEX_POINT($,#86);+#88=CARTESIAN_POINT($,(67,15,62));+#89=DIRECTION($,(-1,0,0));+#90=VECTOR($,#89,1);+#91=LINE($,#88,#90);+#92=EDGE_CURVE($,#79,#87,#91,.T.);+#93=ORIENTED_EDGE($,$,$,#92,.T.);+#94=CARTESIAN_POINT($,(7,15,62));+#95=DIRECTION($,(0,-1,0));+#96=VECTOR($,#95,1);+#97=LINE($,#94,#96);+#98=EDGE_CURVE($,#87,#69,#97,.T.);+#99=ORIENTED_EDGE($,$,$,#98,.T.);+#100=EDGE_LOOP($,(#77,#85,#93,#99));+#101=FACE_OUTER_BOUND('',#100,.T.);+#102=ADVANCED_FACE('',(#101),#67,.T.);+#103=CARTESIAN_POINT($,(26,-15,18));+#104=DIRECTION($,(0,-1,0));+#105=DIRECTION($,(1,0,0));+#106=AXIS2_PLACEMENT_3D($,#103,#104,#105);+#107=PLANE($,#106);+#108=ORIENTED_EDGE($,$,$,#14,.T.);+#109=CARTESIAN_POINT($,(67,-15,22));+#110=DIRECTION($,(0,0,1));+#111=VECTOR($,#110,1);+#112=LINE($,#109,#111);+#113=EDGE_CURVE($,#9,#71,#112,.T.);+#114=ORIENTED_EDGE($,$,$,#113,.T.);+#115=ORIENTED_EDGE($,$,$,#76,.F.);+#116=CARTESIAN_POINT($,(7,-15,22));+#117=DIRECTION($,(0,0,1));+#118=VECTOR($,#117,1);+#119=LINE($,#116,#118);+#120=EDGE_CURVE($,#7,#69,#119,.T.);+#121=ORIENTED_EDGE($,$,$,#120,.F.);+#122=EDGE_LOOP($,(#108,#114,#115,#121));+#123=FACE_OUTER_BOUND('',#122,.T.);+#124=ADVANCED_FACE('',(#123),#107,.T.);+#125=CARTESIAN_POINT($,(67,0,18));+#126=DIRECTION($,(1,0,0));+#127=DIRECTION($,(0,1,0));+#128=AXIS2_PLACEMENT_3D($,#125,#126,#127);+#129=PLANE($,#128);+#130=ORIENTED_EDGE($,$,$,#22,.T.);+#131=CARTESIAN_POINT($,(67,15,22));+#132=DIRECTION($,(0,0,1));+#133=VECTOR($,#132,1);+#134=LINE($,#131,#133);+#135=EDGE_CURVE($,#17,#79,#134,.T.);+#136=ORIENTED_EDGE($,$,$,#135,.T.);+#137=ORIENTED_EDGE($,$,$,#84,.F.);+#138=ORIENTED_EDGE($,$,$,#113,.F.);+#139=EDGE_LOOP($,(#130,#136,#137,#138));+#140=FACE_OUTER_BOUND('',#139,.T.);+#141=ADVANCED_FACE('',(#140),#129,.T.);+#142=CARTESIAN_POINT($,(26,15,18));+#143=DIRECTION($,(0,1,0));+#144=DIRECTION($,(-1,0,0));+#145=AXIS2_PLACEMENT_3D($,#142,#143,#144);+#146=PLANE($,#145);+#147=ORIENTED_EDGE($,$,$,#30,.T.);+#148=CARTESIAN_POINT($,(7,15,22));+#149=DIRECTION($,(0,0,1));+#150=VECTOR($,#149,1);+#151=LINE($,#148,#150);+#152=EDGE_CURVE($,#25,#87,#151,.T.);+#153=ORIENTED_EDGE($,$,$,#152,.T.);+#154=ORIENTED_EDGE($,$,$,#92,.F.);+#155=ORIENTED_EDGE($,$,$,#135,.F.);+#156=EDGE_LOOP($,(#147,#153,#154,#155));+#157=FACE_OUTER_BOUND('',#156,.T.);+#158=ADVANCED_FACE('',(#157),#146,.T.);+#159=CARTESIAN_POINT($,(7,0,18));+#160=DIRECTION($,(-1,0,0));+#161=DIRECTION($,(0,1,0));+#162=AXIS2_PLACEMENT_3D($,#159,#160,#161);+#163=PLANE($,#162);+#164=ORIENTED_EDGE($,$,$,#36,.T.);+#165=ORIENTED_EDGE($,$,$,#120,.T.);+#166=ORIENTED_EDGE($,$,$,#98,.F.);+#167=ORIENTED_EDGE($,$,$,#152,.F.);+#168=EDGE_LOOP($,(#164,#165,#166,#167));+#169=FACE_OUTER_BOUND('',#168,.T.);+#170=ADVANCED_FACE('',(#169),#163,.T.);+#171=CARTESIAN_POINT($,(11,0,22));+#172=DIRECTION($,(0,0,1));+#173=DIRECTION($,(1,0,0));+#174=AXIS2_PLACEMENT_3D($,#171,#172,#173);+#175=CYLINDRICAL_SURFACE($,#174,3.5);+#176=CARTESIAN_POINT($,(14.5,0,28));+#177=VERTEX_POINT($,#176);+#178=CARTESIAN_POINT($,(14.5,0,22));+#179=VERTEX_POINT($,#178);+#180=CARTESIAN_POINT($,(14.5,0,28));+#181=DIRECTION($,(0,0,-1));+#182=VECTOR($,#181,1);+#183=LINE($,#180,#182);+#184=EDGE_CURVE($,#177,#179,#183,.T.);+#185=ORIENTED_EDGE($,$,$,#184,.T.);+#186=CARTESIAN_POINT($,(14.5,0,28));+#187=VERTEX_POINT($,#186);+#188=CARTESIAN_POINT($,(11,0,28));+#189=DIRECTION($,(0,0,1));+#190=DIRECTION($,(1,0,0));+#191=AXIS2_PLACEMENT_3D($,#188,#189,#190);+#192=CIRCLE($,#191,3.5);+#193=EDGE_CURVE($,#187,#187,#192,.T.);+#194=ORIENTED_EDGE($,$,$,#193,.F.);+#195=ORIENTED_EDGE($,$,$,#184,.F.);+#196=ORIENTED_EDGE($,$,$,#47,.T.);+#197=EDGE_LOOP($,(#185,#194,#195,#196));+#198=FACE_OUTER_BOUND('',#197,.T.);+#199=ADVANCED_FACE('',(#198),#175,.T.);+#200=CARTESIAN_POINT($,(26,0,22));+#201=DIRECTION($,(0,0,1));+#202=DIRECTION($,(1,0,0));+#203=AXIS2_PLACEMENT_3D($,#200,#201,#202);+#204=CYLINDRICAL_SURFACE($,#203,3.5);+#205=CARTESIAN_POINT($,(29.5,0,28));+#206=VERTEX_POINT($,#205);+#207=CARTESIAN_POINT($,(29.5,0,22));+#208=VERTEX_POINT($,#207);+#209=CARTESIAN_POINT($,(29.5,0,28));+#210=DIRECTION($,(0,0,-1));+#211=VECTOR($,#210,1);+#212=LINE($,#209,#211);+#213=EDGE_CURVE($,#206,#208,#212,.T.);+#214=ORIENTED_EDGE($,$,$,#213,.T.);+#215=CARTESIAN_POINT($,(29.5,0,28));+#216=VERTEX_POINT($,#215);+#217=CARTESIAN_POINT($,(26,0,28));+#218=DIRECTION($,(0,0,1));+#219=DIRECTION($,(1,0,0));+#220=AXIS2_PLACEMENT_3D($,#217,#218,#219);+#221=CIRCLE($,#220,3.5);+#222=EDGE_CURVE($,#216,#216,#221,.T.);+#223=ORIENTED_EDGE($,$,$,#222,.F.);+#224=ORIENTED_EDGE($,$,$,#213,.F.);+#225=ORIENTED_EDGE($,$,$,#58,.T.);+#226=EDGE_LOOP($,(#214,#223,#224,#225));+#227=FACE_OUTER_BOUND('',#226,.T.);+#228=ADVANCED_FACE('',(#227),#204,.T.);+#229=CARTESIAN_POINT($,(11,0,28));+#230=DIRECTION($,(-0,-0,-1));+#231=DIRECTION($,(1,0,0));+#232=AXIS2_PLACEMENT_3D($,#229,#230,#231);+#233=PLANE($,#232);+#234=ORIENTED_EDGE($,$,$,#193,.T.);+#235=EDGE_LOOP($,(#234));+#236=FACE_OUTER_BOUND('',#235,.T.);+#237=ADVANCED_FACE('',(#236),#233,.T.);+#238=CARTESIAN_POINT($,(26,0,28));+#239=DIRECTION($,(-0,-0,-1));+#240=DIRECTION($,(1,0,0));+#241=AXIS2_PLACEMENT_3D($,#238,#239,#240);+#242=PLANE($,#241);+#243=ORIENTED_EDGE($,$,$,#222,.T.);+#244=EDGE_LOOP($,(#243));+#245=FACE_OUTER_BOUND('',#244,.T.);+#246=ADVANCED_FACE('',(#245),#242,.T.);+#247=CLOSED_SHELL($,(#62,#102,#124,#141,#158,#170,#199,#228,#237,#246));+#248=MANIFOLD_SOLID_BREP('AetherisBody',#247);+#249=APPLICATION_CONTEXT('mechanical design');+#250=PRODUCT_CONTEXT('',#249,'mechanical');+#251=PRODUCT('AETHERIS','AetherisBody','',(#250));+#252=PRODUCT_DEFINITION_FORMATION('','',#251);+#253=PRODUCT_DEFINITION_CONTEXT('design',#249,'design');+#254=PRODUCT_DEFINITION('','',#252,#253);+#255=PRODUCT_DEFINITION_SHAPE('','',#254);+#256=(LENGTH_UNIT()NAMED_UNIT(*)SI_UNIT(.MILLI.,.METRE.));+#257=(NAMED_UNIT(*)PLANE_ANGLE_UNIT()SI_UNIT($,.RADIAN.));+#258=(NAMED_UNIT(*)SI_UNIT($,.STERADIAN.)SOLID_ANGLE_UNIT());+#259=(GEOMETRIC_REPRESENTATION_CONTEXT(3)GLOBAL_UNIT_ASSIGNED_CONTEXT((#256,#257,#258))REPRESENTATION_CONTEXT('3','3D'));+#260=SHAPE_ASPECT('firmament-feature:base_hole','supported cylinder through-hole feature',#255,.FALSE.);+#261=PROPERTY_DEFINITION('diameter:base_hole','auto-derived semantic PMI diameter',#260);+#262=MEASURE_REPRESENTATION_ITEM('diameter',7,#256);+#263=SHAPE_DIMENSION_REPRESENTATION('diameter:base_hole',(#262),#259);+#264=PROPERTY_DEFINITION_REPRESENTATION(#261,#263);+#265=SHAPE_ASPECT('firmament-feature:upright_hole','supported cylinder through-hole feature',#255,.FALSE.);+#266=PROPERTY_DEFINITION('diameter:upright_hole','auto-derived semantic PMI diameter',#265);+#267=MEASURE_REPRESENTATION_ITEM('diameter',7,#256);+#268=SHAPE_DIMENSION_REPRESENTATION('diameter:upright_hole',(#267),#259);+#269=PROPERTY_DEFINITION_REPRESENTATION(#266,#268);+#270=SHAPE_REPRESENTATION('AetherisBody',(#248),#259);+#271=SHAPE_DEFINITION_REPRESENTATION(#255,#270);+ENDSEC;+END-ISO-10303-21;diff --git a/Aetheris.Firmament.FrictionLab/Reports/Artifacts/simple-bracket.step b/Aetheris.Firmament.FrictionLab/Reports/Artifacts/simple-bracket.stepnew file mode 100644index 00000000..76898f7a--- /dev/null+++ b/Aetheris.Firmament.FrictionLab/Reports/Artifacts/simple-bracket.step@@ -0,0 +1,172 @@+ISO-10303-21;+HEADER;+FILE_DESCRIPTION(('Aetheris AP242 subset export'),'2;1');+FILE_NAME('aetheris_export.step','1970-01-01T00:00:00',('Aetheris'),('Aetheris'),'Aetheris.Kernel','Aetheris.Kernel','');+FILE_SCHEMA(('AP242_MANAGED_MODEL_BASED_3D_ENGINEERING_MIM_LF'));+ENDSEC;+DATA;+#1=CARTESIAN_POINT($,(0,0,3));+#2=DIRECTION($,(0,0,-1));+#3=DIRECTION($,(1,0,0));+#4=AXIS2_PLACEMENT_3D($,#1,#2,#3);+#5=PLANE($,#4);+#6=CARTESIAN_POINT($,(-20,-5,3));+#7=VERTEX_POINT($,#6);+#8=CARTESIAN_POINT($,(20,-5,3));+#9=VERTEX_POINT($,#8);+#10=CARTESIAN_POINT($,(-20,-5,3));+#11=DIRECTION($,(1,0,0));+#12=VECTOR($,#11,1);+#13=LINE($,#10,#12);+#14=EDGE_CURVE($,#7,#9,#13,.T.);+#15=ORIENTED_EDGE($,$,$,#14,.T.);+#16=CARTESIAN_POINT($,(20,5,3));+#17=VERTEX_POINT($,#16);+#18=CARTESIAN_POINT($,(20,-5,3));+#19=DIRECTION($,(0,1,0));+#20=VECTOR($,#19,1);+#21=LINE($,#18,#20);+#22=EDGE_CURVE($,#9,#17,#21,.T.);+#23=ORIENTED_EDGE($,$,$,#22,.T.);+#24=CARTESIAN_POINT($,(-20,5,3));+#25=VERTEX_POINT($,#24);+#26=CARTESIAN_POINT($,(20,5,3));+#27=DIRECTION($,(-1,0,0));+#28=VECTOR($,#27,1);+#29=LINE($,#26,#28);+#30=EDGE_CURVE($,#17,#25,#29,.T.);+#31=ORIENTED_EDGE($,$,$,#30,.T.);+#32=CARTESIAN_POINT($,(-20,5,3));+#33=DIRECTION($,(0,-1,0));+#34=VECTOR($,#33,1);+#35=LINE($,#32,#34);+#36=EDGE_CURVE($,#25,#7,#35,.T.);+#37=ORIENTED_EDGE($,$,$,#36,.T.);+#38=EDGE_LOOP($,(#15,#23,#31,#37));+#39=FACE_OUTER_BOUND('',#38,.T.);+#40=ADVANCED_FACE('',(#39),#5,.T.);+#41=CARTESIAN_POINT($,(0,0,30));+#42=DIRECTION($,(0,0,1));+#43=DIRECTION($,(1,0,0));+#44=AXIS2_PLACEMENT_3D($,#41,#42,#43);+#45=PLANE($,#44);+#46=CARTESIAN_POINT($,(-20,-5,30));+#47=VERTEX_POINT($,#46);+#48=CARTESIAN_POINT($,(20,-5,30));+#49=VERTEX_POINT($,#48);+#50=CARTESIAN_POINT($,(-20,-5,30));+#51=DIRECTION($,(1,0,0));+#52=VECTOR($,#51,1);+#53=LINE($,#50,#52);+#54=EDGE_CURVE($,#47,#49,#53,.T.);+#55=ORIENTED_EDGE($,$,$,#54,.T.);+#56=CARTESIAN_POINT($,(20,5,30));+#57=VERTEX_POINT($,#56);+#58=CARTESIAN_POINT($,(20,-5,30));+#59=DIRECTION($,(0,1,0));+#60=VECTOR($,#59,1);+#61=LINE($,#58,#60);+#62=EDGE_CURVE($,#49,#57,#61,.T.);+#63=ORIENTED_EDGE($,$,$,#62,.T.);+#64=CARTESIAN_POINT($,(-20,5,30));+#65=VERTEX_POINT($,#64);+#66=CARTESIAN_POINT($,(20,5,30));+#67=DIRECTION($,(-1,0,0));+#68=VECTOR($,#67,1);+#69=LINE($,#66,#68);+#70=EDGE_CURVE($,#57,#65,#69,.T.);+#71=ORIENTED_EDGE($,$,$,#70,.T.);+#72=CARTESIAN_POINT($,(-20,5,30));+#73=DIRECTION($,(0,-1,0));+#74=VECTOR($,#73,1);+#75=LINE($,#72,#74);+#76=EDGE_CURVE($,#65,#47,#75,.T.);+#77=ORIENTED_EDGE($,$,$,#76,.T.);+#78=EDGE_LOOP($,(#55,#63,#71,#77));+#79=FACE_OUTER_BOUND('',#78,.T.);+#80=ADVANCED_FACE('',(#79),#45,.T.);+#81=CARTESIAN_POINT($,(0,-5,16.5));+#82=DIRECTION($,(0,-1,0));+#83=DIRECTION($,(1,0,0));+#84=AXIS2_PLACEMENT_3D($,#81,#82,#83);+#85=PLANE($,#84);+#86=ORIENTED_EDGE($,$,$,#14,.T.);+#87=CARTESIAN_POINT($,(20,-5,3));+#88=DIRECTION($,(0,0,1));+#89=VECTOR($,#88,1);+#90=LINE($,#87,#89);+#91=EDGE_CURVE($,#9,#49,#90,.T.);+#92=ORIENTED_EDGE($,$,$,#91,.T.);+#93=ORIENTED_EDGE($,$,$,#54,.F.);+#94=CARTESIAN_POINT($,(-20,-5,3));+#95=DIRECTION($,(0,0,1));+#96=VECTOR($,#95,1);+#97=LINE($,#94,#96);+#98=EDGE_CURVE($,#7,#47,#97,.T.);+#99=ORIENTED_EDGE($,$,$,#98,.F.);+#100=EDGE_LOOP($,(#86,#92,#93,#99));+#101=FACE_OUTER_BOUND('',#100,.T.);+#102=ADVANCED_FACE('',(#101),#85,.T.);+#103=CARTESIAN_POINT($,(20,0,16.5));+#104=DIRECTION($,(1,0,0));+#105=DIRECTION($,(0,1,0));+#106=AXIS2_PLACEMENT_3D($,#103,#104,#105);+#107=PLANE($,#106);+#108=ORIENTED_EDGE($,$,$,#22,.T.);+#109=CARTESIAN_POINT($,(20,5,3));+#110=DIRECTION($,(0,0,1));+#111=VECTOR($,#110,1);+#112=LINE($,#109,#111);+#113=EDGE_CURVE($,#17,#57,#112,.T.);+#114=ORIENTED_EDGE($,$,$,#113,.T.);+#115=ORIENTED_EDGE($,$,$,#62,.F.);+#116=ORIENTED_EDGE($,$,$,#91,.F.);+#117=EDGE_LOOP($,(#108,#114,#115,#116));+#118=FACE_OUTER_BOUND('',#117,.T.);+#119=ADVANCED_FACE('',(#118),#107,.T.);+#120=CARTESIAN_POINT($,(0,5,16.5));+#121=DIRECTION($,(0,1,0));+#122=DIRECTION($,(-1,0,0));+#123=AXIS2_PLACEMENT_3D($,#120,#121,#122);+#124=PLANE($,#123);+#125=ORIENTED_EDGE($,$,$,#30,.T.);+#126=CARTESIAN_POINT($,(-20,5,3));+#127=DIRECTION($,(0,0,1));+#128=VECTOR($,#127,1);+#129=LINE($,#126,#128);+#130=EDGE_CURVE($,#25,#65,#129,.T.);+#131=ORIENTED_EDGE($,$,$,#130,.T.);+#132=ORIENTED_EDGE($,$,$,#70,.F.);+#133=ORIENTED_EDGE($,$,$,#113,.F.);+#134=EDGE_LOOP($,(#125,#131,#132,#133));+#135=FACE_OUTER_BOUND('',#134,.T.);+#136=ADVANCED_FACE('',(#135),#124,.T.);+#137=CARTESIAN_POINT($,(-20,0,16.5));+#138=DIRECTION($,(-1,0,0));+#139=DIRECTION($,(0,1,0));+#140=AXIS2_PLACEMENT_3D($,#137,#138,#139);+#141=PLANE($,#140);+#142=ORIENTED_EDGE($,$,$,#36,.T.);+#143=ORIENTED_EDGE($,$,$,#98,.T.);+#144=ORIENTED_EDGE($,$,$,#76,.F.);+#145=ORIENTED_EDGE($,$,$,#130,.F.);+#146=EDGE_LOOP($,(#142,#143,#144,#145));+#147=FACE_OUTER_BOUND('',#146,.T.);+#148=ADVANCED_FACE('',(#147),#141,.T.);+#149=CLOSED_SHELL($,(#40,#80,#102,#119,#136,#148));+#150=MANIFOLD_SOLID_BREP('AetherisBody',#149);+#151=APPLICATION_CONTEXT('mechanical design');+#152=PRODUCT_CONTEXT('',#151,'mechanical');+#153=PRODUCT('AETHERIS','AetherisBody','',(#152));+#154=PRODUCT_DEFINITION_FORMATION('','',#153);+#155=PRODUCT_DEFINITION_CONTEXT('design',#151,'design');+#156=PRODUCT_DEFINITION('','',#154,#155);+#157=PRODUCT_DEFINITION_SHAPE('','',#156);+#158=(LENGTH_UNIT()NAMED_UNIT(*)SI_UNIT(.MILLI.,.METRE.));+#159=(NAMED_UNIT(*)PLANE_ANGLE_UNIT()SI_UNIT($,.RADIAN.));+#160=(NAMED_UNIT(*)SI_UNIT($,.STERADIAN.)SOLID_ANGLE_UNIT());+#161=(GEOMETRIC_REPRESENTATION_CONTEXT(3)GLOBAL_UNIT_ASSIGNED_CONTEXT((#158,#159,#160))REPRESENTATION_CONTEXT('3','3D'));+#162=SHAPE_REPRESENTATION('AetherisBody',(#150),#161);+#163=SHAPE_DEFINITION_REPRESENTATION(#157,#162);+ENDSEC;+END-ISO-10303-21;diff --git a/Aetheris.Firmament.FrictionLab/Reports/fl2f-run.json b/Aetheris.Firmament.FrictionLab/Reports/fl2f-run.jsonnew file mode 100644index 00000000..e550ccd1--- /dev/null+++ b/Aetheris.Firmament.FrictionLab/Reports/fl2f-run.json@@ -0,0 +1,71 @@+{+ "totalCases": 4,+ "successCount": 0,+ "partialCount": 3,+ "failureCount": 1,+ "caseResults": [+ {+ "caseId": "mounting-bracket-basic",+ "buildStatus": "partial",+ "artifactPresent": true,+ "stepArtifactPath": "Aetheris.Firmament.FrictionLab/Reports/Artifacts/mounting-bracket-basic.step",+ "possible": "partial",+ "awkwardness": "high",+ "diagnostics": []+ },+ {+ "caseId": "simple-bracket",+ "buildStatus": "partial",+ "artifactPresent": true,+ "stepArtifactPath": "Aetheris.Firmament.FrictionLab/Reports/Artifacts/simple-bracket.step",+ "possible": "partial",+ "awkwardness": "high",+ "diagnostics": []+ },+ {+ "caseId": "shaft-keyway",+ "buildStatus": "failure",+ "artifactPresent": false,+ "stepArtifactPath": null,+ "possible": "true",+ "awkwardness": "medium",+ "diagnostics": [+ {+ "code": "NotImplemented",+ "severity": "Error",+ "message": "Requested boolean feature \u0027keyway\u0027 (subtract) could not be executed.",+ "source": "firmament"+ },+ {+ "code": "NotImplemented",+ "severity": "Error",+ "message": "Boolean feature \u0027keyway\u0027 (subtract): Boolean Subtract: sequential safe composition only supports subtracting supported analytic holes from the current bounded safe root family.",+ "source": "BrepBoolean.RebuildResult"+ }+ ]+ },+ {+ "caseId": "pocketed-plate",+ "buildStatus": "partial",+ "artifactPresent": false,+ "stepArtifactPath": null,+ "possible": "partial",+ "awkwardness": "medium",+ "diagnostics": [+ {+ "code": "NotImplemented",+ "severity": "Error",+ "message": "Requested boolean feature \u0027pocket\u0027 (subtract) could not be executed.",+ "source": "firmament"+ },+ {+ "code": "NotImplemented",+ "severity": "Error",+ "message": "Boolean feature \u0027pocket\u0027 (subtract): Boolean Subtract: box subtraction result is not representable as a single box in M13.",+ "source": "BrepBoolean.RebuildResult"+ }+ ]+ }+ ],+ "summaryPath": "Aetheris.Firmament.FrictionLab/Reports/fl2f-run.json"+}\ No newline at end of filediff --git a/Aetheris.Firmament.FrictionLab/Reports/fl2f-summary.json b/Aetheris.Firmament.FrictionLab/Reports/fl2f-summary.jsonnew file mode 100644index 00000000..c3544676--- /dev/null+++ b/Aetheris.Firmament.FrictionLab/Reports/fl2f-summary.json@@ -0,0 +1,124 @@+{+ "milestone": "FL2f",+ "description": "Targeted friction rerun with direct STEP artifact semantic inspection after G8 additive-root and multi-hole continuation changes.",+ "rerun_case_count": 4,+ "source_previous_summaries": [+ "Aetheris.Firmament.FrictionLab/Reports/fl2e-summary.json",+ "Aetheris.Firmament.FrictionLab/Reports/fl2a-summary.json"+ ],+ "source_current_run": "Aetheris.Firmament.FrictionLab/Reports/fl2f-run.json",+ "cases": [+ {+ "case_id": "mounting-bracket-basic",+ "previous_status": "partial",+ "current_status": "partial",+ "changed": "yes",+ "improved": true,+ "classification": "exported_but_semantically_wrong",+ "artifact_present": true,+ "step_artifact_path": "Aetheris.Firmament.FrictionLab/Reports/Artifacts/mounting-bracket-basic.step",+ "possible": "partial",+ "awkwardness": "high",+ "remaining_blocker": "Additive-root continuation now exports, but base_hole placement is semantically wrong (root interpretation / feature placement mismatch).",+ "step_semantic_inspection": {+ "inspected": true,+ "expected_feature_geometry_present": true,+ "semantically_correct": false,+ "mismatch_kind": "wrong root interpretation",+ "inspection_notes": "Two cylindrical cuts exist (r=3.5), but centers are at (11,0,22) and (26,0,22); base_hole intent from offset -15 on base is not preserved."+ }+ },+ {+ "case_id": "simple-bracket",+ "previous_status": "partial",+ "current_status": "partial",+ "changed": "yes",+ "improved": true,+ "classification": "exported_but_semantically_wrong",+ "artifact_present": true,+ "step_artifact_path": "Aetheris.Firmament.FrictionLab/Reports/Artifacts/simple-bracket.step",+ "possible": "partial",+ "awkwardness": "high",+ "remaining_blocker": "Boolean add chain exports but semantic bracket shape is not preserved (result degenerates to simple box-like solid).",+ "step_semantic_inspection": {+ "inspected": true,+ "expected_feature_geometry_present": false,+ "semantically_correct": false,+ "mismatch_kind": "topologically valid but semantically wrong",+ "inspection_notes": "Artifact is a valid manifold solid but contains only 6 ADVANCED_FACE entries, indicating box-like output rather than intended bracket composition."+ }+ },+ {+ "case_id": "shaft-keyway",+ "previous_status": "failure",+ "current_status": "failure",+ "changed": "no",+ "improved": false,+ "classification": "unchanged_kernel_blocker",+ "artifact_present": false,+ "step_artifact_path": null,+ "possible": "true",+ "awkwardness": "medium",+ "remaining_blocker": "Boolean Subtract safe composition still only supports supported analytic holes on bounded safe roots.",+ "step_semantic_inspection": {+ "inspected": false,+ "expected_feature_geometry_present": false,+ "semantically_correct": false,+ "mismatch_kind": "other",+ "inspection_notes": "No STEP artifact: execution stops with BrepBoolean.RebuildResult NotImplemented diagnostic."+ }+ },+ {+ "case_id": "pocketed-plate",+ "previous_status": "partial",+ "current_status": "partial",+ "changed": "no",+ "improved": false,+ "classification": "unchanged_kernel_blocker",+ "artifact_present": false,+ "step_artifact_path": null,+ "possible": "partial",+ "awkwardness": "medium",+ "remaining_blocker": "Box-minus-box pocket subtract remains unrepresentable as a single-box rebuild in current M13 path.",+ "step_semantic_inspection": {+ "inspected": false,+ "expected_feature_geometry_present": false,+ "semantically_correct": false,+ "mismatch_kind": "other",+ "inspection_notes": "No STEP artifact: execution stops with BrepBoolean.RebuildResult representability diagnostic."+ }+ }+ ],+ "step_artifact_case_count": 2,+ "improved_cases": [+ "mounting-bracket-basic",+ "simple-bracket"+ ],+ "top_repeated_remaining_blockers": [+ {+ "blocker": "BrepBoolean.RebuildResult",+ "count": 2+ },+ {+ "blocker": "semantic-mismatch-after-export",+ "count": 2+ }+ ],+ "top_repeated_remaining_blocker_classes": [+ {+ "classification": "exported_but_semantically_wrong",+ "count": 2+ },+ {+ "classification": "unchanged_kernel_blocker",+ "count": 2+ }+ ],+ "next_blocker_after_g8": "Export-level success without semantic fidelity (especially additive-root continuation placement/shape correctness) is now the highest-priority blocker class.",+ "deterministic_case_order": [+ "mounting-bracket-basic",+ "simple-bracket",+ "shaft-keyway",+ "pocketed-plate"+ ]+}