Skip to content

The cross-harness, self-improving memory layer for AI agents. Join our community: https://discord.com/invite/zdNChS2fBu

4.4 KB
Raw Blame
id: crontab-modification
version: 2
title: Crontab modified (user, system, or spool)
description: >
  A persistent-scheduling primitive was modified: the user crontab
  (crontab -e, crontab <file>, echo '...' | crontab -, crontab -r to
  remove), the system crontab (/etc/crontab), a drop-in under
  /etc/cron.d/ or /etc/cron.{hourly,daily,weekly,monthly}/, or a
  user's spool file under /var/spool/cron/. Adding a cron entry is a
  near-universal persistence primitive — once installed, the job runs
  on schedule even after the originating agent session ends. The rule
  is anchored on the command binary or the file path so a `crontab -l`
  list or a `cat /etc/crontab` read does not fire.
severity: high
status: experimental
posture: detect
taxonomy:
  beacon_category: risky-command
  owasp_llm: LLM06
  mitre_atlas: AML.T0011

match: >
  (e.event.action == "command.executed" && (
    e.command.command.matches("(?i)(^|[;&|]\\s*|\\bsudo\\s+)\\s*crontab\\b[^;&|]*(\\s-e\\b|\\s-[a-z]*r\\b|\\s-\\s+[a-zA-Z0-9_./-]+|\\s-\\s*$|\\b[^;&|]*\\|\\s*crontab\\b)") ||
    e.command.command.matches("(?i)(^|[;&|(]\\s*|\\bsudo\\s+)\\s*crontab(\\s+-u\\s*[^\\s;&|]+)?\\s+[a-zA-Z0-9_./~][a-zA-Z0-9_./~-]*\\s*($|[;&|)])")
  )) || (
    e.event.action in ["file.modified", "file.created", "file.edited"] && (
      e.file.path.matches("(?i)(^|/)etc/crontab$") ||
      e.file.path.matches("(?i)(^|/)etc/cron\\.d/[^/]+$") ||
      e.file.path.matches("(?i)(^|/)etc/cron\\.(hourly|daily|weekly|monthly)/[^/]+$") ||
      e.file.path.matches("(?i)(^|/)var/spool/cron/[^/]+$")
    )
  )

emit:
  reason: "Crontab modified (user crontab -e/-r, system /etc/cron.*, or spool) — persistence primitive"

tests:
  - name: crontab_edit
    verdict: match
    events:
      - event: { action: command.executed }
        command: { command: "crontab -e" }
        session: { id: s1 }
  - name: crontab_load_from_file
    verdict: match
    events:
      - event: { action: command.executed }
        command: { command: "crontab /tmp/payload.cron" }
        session: { id: s1 }
  - name: crontab_load_then_cleanup
    verdict: match
    events:
      - event: { action: command.executed }
        command: { command: "crontab /tmp/payload.cron && rm /tmp/payload.cron" }
        session: { id: s1 }
  - name: crontab_load_from_home
    verdict: match
    events:
      - event: { action: command.executed }
        command: { command: "crontab ~/jobs.cron" }
        session: { id: s1 }
  - name: crontab_list_then_command
    verdict: no_match
    events:
      - event: { action: command.executed }
        command: { command: "crontab -l && echo done" }
        session: { id: s1 }
  - name: crontab_backup_then_command
    verdict: no_match
    events:
      - event: { action: command.executed }
        command: { command: "crontab -l > ~/crontab.bak && echo saved" }
        session: { id: s1 }
  - name: pipe_into_crontab
    verdict: match
    events:
      - event: { action: command.executed }
        command: { command: "echo '* * * * * /tmp/x.sh' | crontab -" }
        session: { id: s1 }
  - name: crontab_remove
    verdict: match
    events:
      - event: { action: command.executed }
        command: { command: "crontab -r" }
        session: { id: s1 }
  - name: write_etc_cron_d
    verdict: match
    events:
      - event: { action: file.modified }
        file: { path: "/etc/cron.d/agent-persist" }
        session: { id: s1 }
  - name: write_etc_cron_hourly
    verdict: match
    events:
      - event: { action: file.modified }
        file: { path: "/etc/cron.hourly/rotate" }
        session: { id: s1 }
  - name: write_var_spool_cron
    verdict: match
    events:
      - event: { action: file.modified }
        file: { path: "/var/spool/cron/root" }
        session: { id: s1 }
  - name: crontab_list_only
    verdict: no_match
    events:
      - event: { action: command.executed }
        command: { command: "crontab -l" }
        session: { id: s1 }
  - name: read_etc_crontab
    verdict: no_match
    events:
      - event: { action: file.read }
        file: { path: "/etc/crontab" }
        session: { id: s1 }
  - name: ordinary_shell_command
    verdict: no_match
    events:
      - event: { action: command.executed }
        command: { command: "echo hello world" }
        session: { id: s1 }
  - name: write_etc_cron_d_created
    verdict: match
    events:
      - event: { action: file.created }
        file: { path: "/etc/cron.d/agent-persist" }
        session: { id: s1 }