Skip to content

Solution for long term memory for agent coding CLIs and to facilitate handoff between different agent vendors

Rust
4.7 KB
Raw Blame

Extension and plugin surfaces (research, 2026-10-08)

Can an ai-memory extension in each app's marketplace do what an installer cannot? Sourced from current official docs and, for Codex, its source. The resulting design proposal is RFC #1166; the implementation design, re-verified on 2026-10-13, is design-marketplace-plugins.md.

Claude (one plugin format, three surfaces)

Per https://claude.com/docs/plugins/platform-support, the same plugin folder installs everywhere but each surface loads a different subset:

Component Chat Cowork Claude Code (CLI, IDE, desktop Code tab)
Skills, commands Load (commands as skills) Load Load
Hooks Ignored Load Load
Remote MCP (fixed http/sse URL) Listed under the plugin's Connectors; works once connected Loads; connect from Connectors Loads
Local MCP (a command, incl. .mcpb) Ignored Loads when the Cowork session runs on your computer Loads
MCP using ${user_config.*} Ignored when the URL references it Ignored without a default; no prompt Loads; prompts
Top-level bin/ executables Can't be installed Can't be installed Loads

Chat and Cowork plugins are added from Customize > Plugins in claude.ai or the desktop app (one click, from the directory or an added GitHub/GitLab/ Bitbucket marketplace, or an uploaded zip), are attached to the account, and reach Claude Code as synced plugins. Claude Code installs per machine (/plugin, claude plugin install).

Consequences for ai-memory:

  • Cowork gains a capture path: a plugin's hooks load there, which ~/.claude/settings.json hooks are not documented to do. Unverified: on Linux Cowork runs in a VM, so a hook command or a loopback server URL that works on the host may not work inside it.
  • Chat still cannot capture: hooks and local MCP servers are ignored. Only skills and a remote MCP connector load, and a remote connector has to be reachable as configured (whether claude.ai brokers it from Anthropic's side, which would rule out a loopback server, was not verified here).
  • A plugin cannot install the ai-memory binary on Chat/Cowork (bin/ is refused there), so the server still has to be installed separately; hook scripts shipped as plugin files (like the POSIX bundle in hooks/) are not top-level executables.

Other apps

App Extension unit Can bundle hooks? Can bundle MCP? Install path Source
Codex (CLI + desktop) Plugin Yes, but only for manually installed plugins: a plugin with lifecycle hooks is not eligible for the public plugin directory Yes (the public directory requires a public HTTPS endpoint) Repo, personal or Git marketplace (.agents/plugins/marketplace.json); public directory only without hooks https://developers.openai.com/plugins/build/plugins; https://learn.chatgpt.com/docs/hooks; plugin hook trust in codex-rs/app-server/src/effective_plugin_change.rs
Cursor Cursor Plugin (.cursor-plugin/plugin.json + hooks/hooks.json) or Agent Plugin (root plugin.json) Cursor Plugin format only; an Agent Plugin carries skills and MCP, not hooks Yes Cursor Marketplace / Customize page; cursor:// deeplinks install an MCP config, not hooks https://cursor.com/docs/plugins; https://cursor.com/docs/reference/plugins
Antigravity Plugin Yes, CLI only per docs Yes (mcp_config.json plugin component) agy plugin install <name>@antigravity-plugins-official, a GitHub URL or local directory, or a folder in ~/.gemini/config/plugins/ / .agents/plugins/ https://antigravity.google/docs/plugins.md; https://antigravity.google/docs/hooks.md
Zed Extension No Yes, but MCP extensions are being deprecated in favor of the official MCP registry; remote servers belong in the native UI Extension registry (MCP registry for new servers) https://zed.dev/docs/extensions/mcp-extensions
ChatGPT (hosted chat) Plugin No Remote only, needs a reachable server Published directory with review https://developers.openai.com/plugins

Codex trusts plugin hooks automatically only for plugins a ChatGPT workspace lists for the signed-in account (trust_materialized_plugin_hooks); a plugin from any other source goes through the normal per-hook trust, so a plugin does not remove the silent "untrusted hook" failure. Whether Cursor plugin hooks need approval is not stated in its docs (the hooks page only says project hooks run in any trusted workspace). The #721 de-duplication of Cursor's copy of the Claude Code hooks needs Cursor's own ai-memory hooks, so only the Cursor Plugin format can provide it.