Skip to content

Solution for long term memory for agent coding CLIs and to facilitate handoff between different agent vendors

Rust

docs(security): record the capture and proxy guards and their residuals

AkitaOnRails1638778aa958
diff --git a/CHANGELOG.md b/CHANGELOG.md
index caae4077..dc040f45 100644
--- a/CHANGELOG.md
+++ b/CHANGELOG.md
@@ -19,8 +19,18 @@ and this project adheres to [Semantic Versioning](https://semver.org/spec/v2.0.0
`list_directory` and the legacy `search_file_content` name are now search
tools, dropped under an active policy like `grep_search` and `glob`. A shell
command whose `**` glob could recurse into an ignored directory (zsh, or bash
- with `globstar`) is now dropped too. This applies to the native hook, the
- server, and the generated TypeScript integrations. (GHSA-gcpc-88hm-3xqr)
+ with `globstar`) is now dropped too. A `read_many_files` entry naming a
+ directory above an ignored path (`docs`, `.`), which Gemini reads
+ recursively, is dropped as well. GitHub Copilot CLI's `view`, `create` and
+ `str_replace_editor` are now file tools, checked against `ignore_paths` like
+ `Read` and `Write`. Under an active or invalid policy, tools that read back
+ output of an earlier command (Claude Code `BashOutput`/`TaskOutput`, Codex
+ `write_stdin`, Hermes and OpenClaw `process`, Copilot CLI `read_bash` and
+ `write_bash`) and shell commands using brace expansion or a bracket class
+ are now metadata-only, since the matcher cannot prove they miss an ignored
+ path; upgrade the server before the clients, because an older server drops
+ those events. This applies to the native hook, the server, and the
+ generated TypeScript integrations. (GHSA-gcpc-88hm-3xqr)
- Fixed a web page open in the operator's browser being able to act on an
unauthenticated server (the loopback default, no token), such as claiming a
project's pending handoff or starting admin jobs. With auth off, the machine
@@ -33,7 +43,9 @@ and this project adheres to [Semantic Versioning](https://semver.org/spec/v2.0.0
allowlist (a LAN address or name, or `host.docker.internal`), where browsers
do not send the request metadata the check relies on, the session-start
handoff fetch now also requires an `X-AI-Memory-Client` header that every
- ai-memory hook, CLI command and generated integration sends. Hooks on such a
+ ai-memory hook, CLI command and generated integration sends; the same holds
+ for a request that arrives through a forwarding proxy, even one that rewrites
+ the host to the loopback address. Hooks on such a
server must be re-staged with `ai-memory install-hooks` (or
`ai-memory upgrade`); loopback installs need nothing.
(GHSA-6mc4-46pr-w82w)
diff --git a/docs/security-boundaries.md b/docs/security-boundaries.md
index c067a1c9..44012b0a 100644
--- a/docs/security-boundaries.md
+++ b/docs/security-boundaries.md
@@ -66,7 +66,7 @@ means the boundary is not built yet.
| 10e | Reconcile-tombstone of a disk-deleted page is opt-in, soft, scope-bound, and false-positive-guarded (invariant #16, #929 delete-half) | `ai-memory-wiki/src/watcher.rs` — off by default (`[maintenance] reconcile_tombstones_deleted_pages`); a page is tombstoned only after its file is observed missing on two consecutive passes (streak resets if the path's `PageId` changed), re-verified against the live filesystem immediately before acting, with reserved/indexed-but-unwalked paths (`bootstrap.md`, `_meta.md`, `_pending/`, `sessions/*.md`) excluded and a circuit breaker that skips a whole scope when `> max(3, 50%)` of its pages look missing or a non-partial walk finds nothing; `ai-memory-store/src/ops.rs` `soft_delete_for_reconcile_if_latest` is a soft tombstone (`is_latest=0` + `superseded_at`, decay's shape) through the single writer actor in one transaction — never a filesystem write — scoped to the page's own `(workspace_id, project_id)` | `watcher.rs` `reconcile_delete_disabled_by_default_never_tombstones_a_missing_page`, `reconcile_delete_cross_project_isolation` (project A's deletion never tombstones project B's same-path page), `reconcile_tombstone_refuses_a_stale_latest_id`, `reconcile_tombstone_refuses_when_the_file_still_exists`, `reconcile_tombstone_never_touches_the_filesystem`; `ops.rs` `reconcile_tombstone_resurrects_instead_of_orphaning_on_recreate` | STRONG |
| 10f | Session-time repair is scope-bound (no cross-project timestamp rewrite) | `ai-memory-store/src/ops.rs` `repair_session_times` — every candidate is read back and updated with `WHERE id=? AND workspace_id=? AND project_id=?`; a row outside that 3-tuple is reported `NotFound` and untouched, same code path as an id that does not exist at all; `ai-memory-mcp/src/admin.rs` `handle_repair_session_times` passes the caller's `(workspace, project)` straight through, never the candidate's own | `ops.rs` `repair_session_times_does_not_touch_a_session_of_another_project` (control: sibling session in-scope repaired in the same batch); `admin_repair_session_times.rs` `cross_project_session_is_not_found_and_untouched`; both bite-checked by dropping the `project_id` filter | STRONG |
| 11a | Hook backpressure (202/429) + bounded fan-out (invariant #5) | `ai-memory-hooks/src/router.rs` semaphore→429, 202 immediately, `MAX_HOOK_BATCH_ITEMS`, bounded LRU limiter; batch acknowledgements retain only processed indices and classify terminal drops without consuming capacity | `router.rs` `handle_hook_returns_429_when_ingest_saturated`, `ingest_rate_limiter_is_bounded`; `router.rs` `handle_hook_batch_skips_rate_limited_first_item_and_accepts_later_source`, `handle_hook_batch_reports_failed_index_after_rate_limited_skip`, `handle_hook_batch_drops_subagent_events_before_capacity_check` (each asserts result indices and includes an accepted control) | STRONG |
-| 11b | Capture exclusions drop before storage | `ai-memory-hooks` `capture_policy.rs` `inspect`→`Drop` (before semaphore/spawn), including shell commands whose arguments name an ignored path (`match_command`; argv elements matched whole and tokenized); an invalid marker makes file and shell calls metadata-only, and the server admits a metadata-only shell body only under an invalid marker (`router.rs` `metadata_protocol_is_legal`); generated OpenCode/OMP/Pi/OpenClaw integrations mirror it in `render_shared.rs` `ts_capture_policy_v1` (`captureMatchCommand`). Candidate/argument flavor (`Flavor::Posix` vs `Flavor::Windows`, used to pick which `ignore_paths` patterns even apply) is derived from the **host** (the cwd), never from the candidate string alone — a POSIX-host candidate spelled with a leading `//` is collapsed to a single `/` before flavor detection (`normalize_candidate`; TS `captureNormalize`'s `windowsHost` parameter, sourced from `captureHostWindows(cwd)`), fixing GHSA-vh98 (a `//`-prefixed candidate used to self-classify as `Flavor::Windows` regardless of host, matching zero POSIX patterns and being captured instead of dropped); a genuine Windows/UNC host (cwd itself windows-flavored) is unaffected; `hook.rs` `--check-capture` preflight uses the same capture policy before any spool or spawn | `capture_policy.rs` per-agent `…honors_exclusions` tests, `shell_fixture_vectors` (shared `capture-policy.json` `shell` drop/keep vectors: tool aliases incl. OpenClaw/Devin `exec` and `PowerShell`, `workdir`, glob directories, Windows paths, and a POSIX-host leading-`//` command via `/{root}/docs/adr/x.md`), `shell_tool_shapes_of_every_adapter_honor_exclusions`, `claude_code_powershell_honors_ignored_paths_on_a_windows_host` (#1186: Windows-spelled and `-Param:value` paths drop, public-path and `git status` controls kept, invalid marker metadata-only), `gemini_cli_shell_and_read_many_files_honor_ignored_paths` (Gemini `run_shell_command` incl. `dir_path`/`directory`, and `read_many_files` globs via `match_globs`: excluded literal, mixed public+excluded, `docs/*`, recursive `**` and case-variant entries drop, an `exclude` list cannot rescue them, unsupported glob syntax and malformed lists are metadata-only, public entries kept, POSIX and Windows hosts) and `globstar_reaches_lets_double_star_span_any_depth`, `fixture_vectors` (incl. TS-adapter `bash`/`exec` vectors, and `normalization`'s leading-`//` POSIX vectors alongside the kept Windows-cwd UNC vectors as the no-regression control); `shell_matching_is_off_when_inactive_and_fails_closed_when_invalid_or_over_budget`; `router.rs` `capture_protocol_shell_decisions_survive_server_reinspection`, `capture_protocol_invalid_marker_shell_is_metadata_only` (active metadata-only shell refused, older client's invalid-marker keep stripped, commandless control kept), `capture_protocol_unparseable_marker_strips_shell_events` (server fallback for an unparseable marker), `capture_protocol_invalid_shell_metadata_claim_must_be_canonical` (a stripped shell claim with a path count or non-`extracted` state is refused); `capture_policy.rs` `invalid_marker_strips_shell_calls_with_unparseable_commands`, `long_bash_lc_script_in_argv_is_not_dropped_by_the_match_budget`, **`a_leading_double_slash_candidate_does_not_escape_posix_ignore_paths_via_flavor_mismatch`** (GHSA-vh98 adversarial: attempts the `//repo/secret/...` violation on a POSIX host, proves it now drops, with a plain-single-slash control and a Windows-hosted genuine-UNC control both still correct — fails on the pre-fix code); `hook.rs` `shell_command_reading_an_ignored_path_is_dropped_before_spool`, `gemini_cli_shell_and_read_many_files_exclusions_drop_before_spool` (pre- and post-tool events with an excluded path are never spooled; public controls spool with their family); `render_shared.rs` `generated_capture_policy_v1_node_runtime_evidence` (runs the same fixture sections, including the GHSA-vh98 and Gemini `read_many_files`/`run_shell_command` vectors, plus unsupported-glob, empty-list and recursive-`**` checks, against the emitted TypeScript; `#[ignore]` locally, run with `--ignored` under Node 24 by the Linux CI test job); `hook.rs` `check_capture_refuses_partial_scope_and_excluded_content` (ignored-path and partial-scope violations refused, complete public-path control passes), `check_capture_bounds_marker_hints_and_refuses_oversized_scope` (513-byte hints refused, 512-byte control passes; native routing preserved) | STRONG |
+| 11b | Capture exclusions drop before storage | `ai-memory-hooks` `capture_policy.rs` `inspect`→`Drop` (before semaphore/spawn), including shell commands whose arguments name an ignored path (`match_command`; argv elements matched whole and tokenized); an invalid marker makes file and shell calls metadata-only; an active one makes a shell call metadata-only when a word uses unquoted brace expansion or a bracket class (`has_unevaluated_expansion`), and either makes tools that read back an earlier command's output metadata-only (`reads_earlier_output`: `BashOutput`, `TaskOutput`, `write_stdin`, `process`, `read_bash`/`write_bash` and PowerShell twins); the server admits a metadata-only shell or unknown-family body only under an active or invalid marker, with no paths and an `extracted` state (`router.rs` `metadata_protocol_is_legal`), and its own re-inspection strips an older client's keep for either; a Gemini `read_many_files` literal entry is also read as `entry/**` (`glob_matches_below`), and Copilot CLI's runtime `view`/`create`/`str_replace_editor` are file tools for that agent only (`agent_family`); generated OpenCode/OMP/Pi/OpenClaw integrations mirror it in `render_shared.rs` `ts_capture_policy_v1` (`captureMatchCommand`, `captureUnevaluatedExpansion`, `captureGlobBelow`, the `reader` flag). Candidate/argument flavor (`Flavor::Posix` vs `Flavor::Windows`, used to pick which `ignore_paths` patterns even apply) is derived from the **host** (the cwd), never from the candidate string alone — a POSIX-host candidate spelled with a leading `//` is collapsed to a single `/` before flavor detection (`normalize_candidate`; TS `captureNormalize`'s `windowsHost` parameter, sourced from `captureHostWindows(cwd)`), fixing GHSA-vh98 (a `//`-prefixed candidate used to self-classify as `Flavor::Windows` regardless of host, matching zero POSIX patterns and being captured instead of dropped); a genuine Windows/UNC host (cwd itself windows-flavored) is unaffected; `hook.rs` `--check-capture` preflight uses the same capture policy before any spool or spawn | `capture_policy.rs` per-agent `…honors_exclusions` tests, `shell_fixture_vectors` (shared `capture-policy.json` `shell` drop/keep vectors: tool aliases incl. OpenClaw/Devin `exec` and `PowerShell`, `workdir`, glob directories, Windows paths, and a POSIX-host leading-`//` command via `/{root}/docs/adr/x.md`), `shell_tool_shapes_of_every_adapter_honor_exclusions`, `claude_code_powershell_honors_ignored_paths_on_a_windows_host` (#1186: Windows-spelled and `-Param:value` paths drop, public-path and `git status` controls kept, invalid marker metadata-only), `gemini_cli_shell_and_read_many_files_honor_ignored_paths` (Gemini `run_shell_command` incl. `dir_path`/`directory`, and `read_many_files` globs via `match_globs`: excluded literal, mixed public+excluded, `docs/*`, recursive `**` and case-variant entries drop, an `exclude` list cannot rescue them, unsupported glob syntax and malformed lists are metadata-only, public entries kept, POSIX and Windows hosts) and `globstar_reaches_lets_double_star_span_any_depth`, `fixture_vectors` (incl. TS-adapter `bash`/`exec` vectors, and `normalization`'s leading-`//` POSIX vectors alongside the kept Windows-cwd UNC vectors as the no-regression control); `shell_matching_is_off_when_inactive_and_fails_closed_when_invalid_or_over_budget`; `router.rs` `capture_protocol_shell_decisions_survive_server_reinspection`, `capture_protocol_invalid_marker_shell_is_metadata_only` (active metadata-only shell admitted for an unevaluated expansion, inactive refused, older client's invalid-marker keep stripped, commandless control kept), `capture_protocol_unparseable_marker_strips_shell_events` (server fallback for an unparseable marker), `capture_protocol_invalid_shell_metadata_claim_must_be_canonical` (a stripped shell claim with a path count or non-`extracted` state is refused); `capture_policy.rs` `invalid_marker_strips_shell_calls_with_unparseable_commands`, `long_bash_lc_script_in_argv_is_not_dropped_by_the_match_budget`, **`a_leading_double_slash_candidate_does_not_escape_posix_ignore_paths_via_flavor_mismatch`** (GHSA-vh98 adversarial: attempts the `//repo/secret/...` violation on a POSIX host, proves it now drops, with a plain-single-slash control and a Windows-hosted genuine-UNC control both still correct — fails on the pre-fix code); `hook.rs` `shell_command_reading_an_ignored_path_is_dropped_before_spool`, `gemini_cli_shell_and_read_many_files_exclusions_drop_before_spool` (pre- and post-tool events with an excluded path are never spooled; public controls spool with their family); `capture_policy.rs` `read_many_files_directory_entries_cannot_reach_ignored_paths` (shared `read_many_files_directories` vectors: `docs`, `.`, `./`, `docs/`, case and `..` variants drop; `src`, `README.md`, `docs/adrx` kept), `output_reader_tools_are_metadata_only_only_under_a_policy` (active and invalid strip, inactive and an unrelated unknown tool keep), `copilot_cli_runtime_file_tools_are_scoped_to_copilot`, `unevaluated_shell_expansions_respect_quoting`, the shell fixture's brace/class vectors (quoted, escaped, `${…}`, `{}`, `[ … ]`, `HEAD@{1}` controls kept); `router.rs` `capture_protocol_active_keep_of_unprovable_output_is_stripped`; `hook.rs` `excluded_content_cannot_reach_the_spool_through_unevaluated_tool_shapes` (directory entries and Copilot `view`/`create` never spool, readers and brace shells spool without content, public controls spool with it); `render_shared.rs` `generated_capture_policy_v1_node_runtime_evidence` (runs the same fixture sections, including the GHSA-vh98 and Gemini `read_many_files`/`run_shell_command` vectors, plus unsupported-glob, empty-list and recursive-`**` checks, against the emitted TypeScript; `#[ignore]` locally, run with `--ignored` under Node 24 by the Linux CI test job); `hook.rs` `check_capture_refuses_partial_scope_and_excluded_content` (ignored-path and partial-scope violations refused, complete public-path control passes), `check_capture_bounds_marker_hints_and_refuses_oversized_scope` (513-byte hints refused, 512-byte control passes; native routing preserved) | STRONG with listed residuals. Matching is lexical by design, so these stay open: shell variables (`$VAR`, `FILE=… sh -c 'cat $FILE'`) and command substitution, a `cd` inside the command, symlinks (paths are never resolved on disk), a recursive search of a parent directory (`grep -r x docs`, `rg x`) through a shell, and tools the matcher does not list, which keep their current unknown-tool behavior. Mitigation: allowlist capture mode (`install-hooks --capture-mode allowlist`) for sensitive projects |
| 11c | Capture hook ≤200ms budget (invariant #5) | `hooks/_lib.sh` capture path `curl --max-time 0.2` (context-fetch 1.0s and background drain 2.0s are separate, larger-budget paths) | none (shell-script timeout; hard to unit-test) — watch on any capture-path change | WATCH |
| 11d | Hook server-profile routing: a marker-selected server gets only its own capture and its own token (#992) | `ai-memory-cli/src/server_profiles.rs` `resolve` (validated `ProfileName`, strict `servers.toml` parse, `roots` required once two profiles exist, component-wise root match) and `marker.rs` `find_server_selection` (inherited down the tree, any value shape counts); `commands/hook.rs` `resolve_hook_route` drops a `Rejected` route before spool, handoff and backfill, and hands the drainer no live token for a profile route; `commands/hook_spool.rs` `static_retry_token` (a profile entry retries only with its own stored token), the loopback reroot skip, and chunk splitting on `profile`; generated TS `captureServerRouted` drops a routed repository and gates `fetchHandoff`; `hooks/_lib.sh` `ai_memory_server_routed` (flag refused by `ai_memory_post_hook`/`ai_memory_get_handoff`) and `hooks/lib/ai-memory-hook.ps1` `Test-AiMemoryServerRouted` drop it in the script hooks; `--check-capture` refuses a rejected server-profile selection without printing its token or URL | `hook.rs` `each_repository_spools_to_its_own_profile_with_its_own_token`, `a_selection_that_does_not_resolve_emits_nothing` (unknown / tokenless / outside roots / roots required / invalid name, plus a resolving control), `session_start_handoff_comes_from_the_profile_server_only`, `a_repository_without_a_server_key_keeps_the_install_default`; `hook_spool.rs` `a_profile_entry_is_never_retried_with_the_install_live_token` (server B accepts exactly the install's live token and must still not get it), `a_profile_entry_recovers_with_its_own_rotated_token` (control), `a_profile_entry_on_a_dead_loopback_port_is_not_rerouted_to_the_default`, `profile_and_default_entries_at_one_address_ride_separate_batches`; `server_profiles.rs` roots/registry/name tests; `marker.rs` `nested_markers_without_server_inherit_the_ancestor_selection`; `install_hooks.rs` `generated_integrations_fail_closed_on_a_server_profile_marker`, `openclaw_plugin.rs` `openclaw_plugin_fails_closed_on_a_server_profile_marker`, and the `server-routed-*` checks in `generated_capture_policy_v1_node_runtime_evidence`; `hook.rs` `an_event_without_a_payload_cwd_routes_by_the_process_cwd`, `a_refused_route_prints_nothing_for_kimi_user_prompts`; `hook_spool.rs` `a_profile_entry_is_not_retried_with_a_token_issued_for_a_new_url`; `server_profiles.rs` `changing_the_url_without_a_token_discards_the_old_token`, `omitted_roots_keep_the_registered_ones`; `marker.rs` `outside_home_the_walk_reaches_a_marker_above_the_checkout_root`, `encoding_noise_cannot_hide_a_server_key`, `an_unreadable_marker_is_a_refused_selection`; `backfill.rs` `a_spawned_backfill_authenticates_like_the_hook_that_spawned_it`; `tests/hooks/test_lib.sh` "server profiles (#992)" section; `hook.rs` `a_mixed_spool_drains_each_event_only_to_its_own_server` (two token-gated servers, one spool, one drain: each server receives exactly its own event with exactly its own bearer); `tests/suite/server_profiles.rs` (the built binary: `server add` → `hook` spools to the profile with its token, unknown profile spools nothing, `uninstall` removes the tokens; `two_real_servers_each_receive_only_their_own_repository` runs two real `ai-memory serve` children with different root tokens and checks on each server which repository landed there); `ai-memory-hooks` `powershell_server_routed.rs` `server_routed_guard_mirrors_the_native_walk` (runs `Test-AiMemoryServerRouted` under real PowerShell: inherited, BOM, look-alike keys, the `$HOME` boundary with its control, past a checkout root outside home, current directory); `hook.rs` `a_selection_that_does_not_resolve_emits_nothing` (rejected routes refuse preflight; resolved profile control passes); `tests/hooks/test_lib.sh` and `powershell_home.rs` `a_trailing_separator_on_home_keeps_the_walk_boundary` (a `$HOME` ending in `/` or `\` keeps both script walks at home: a `server` marker above it routes nothing, with a root-home control that does) | STRONG for native hooks, generated TS, `.sh` and `.ps1` hooks. Known gap: an older binary draining a shared spool ignores `profile` |
| 11e | Native self-upgrade archive confinement (#1025) | `ai-memory-cli/src/commands/upgrade.rs` normalizes every tar/zip path, rejects links and special entries, extracts only the binary and `hooks/`, accepts only the exact non-runtime support layout emitted by `release.yml`, and caps both entry count and declared expanded bytes before writing | `upgrade.rs` `release_workflow_support_assets_are_exact_and_ignored` (shipped support paths admitted, near-miss docs/packaging/template paths refused), `extracts_archive_built_like_release_yml` and `extracts_zip_happy_path_with_hooks` (real workflow-shaped archives succeed but support assets are not written), `validate_rejects_path_traversal`, `zip_extract_rejects_path_traversal`, `tar_extract_rejects_declared_expansion_past_limit`, with binary/hooks extraction as the legitimate control | STRONG |
@@ -76,7 +76,7 @@ means the boundary is not built yet.
| 11i | OpenCode executable probing and generated-config cleanup (#1097) | `ai-memory-cli/src/config.rs` captures the full process environment once in typed `RuntimeEnv`; `run.rs` overlays explicit `run --env` values with platform key semantics and uses that same effective environment for executable resolution, probing, and launch without rereading process environment; `opencode_dialect.rs` invokes only direct argv `--version`, caps output and time, and rejects malformed/future majors. Automatic launch skips only OpenCode on probe failure; explicit OpenCode fails. `install_hooks.rs` quarantines the incompatible sibling before reading its exact ownership markers, restores unowned content with an atomic no-replace link, and never deletes or overwrites a concurrent replacement; `install_mcp.rs` owns the shared dual-schema endpoint/token inference used by both installers, rejects conflicting generated V1/V2 entries before mutation, and migrates an alternate-major entry only when endpoint, generated shape, and absent-or-Authorization-only headers match, preserving custom headers and ambiguous entries; auto-wire migrates MCP before hooks infer from that exact config path and skips hook mutation when transition preflight fails | `run.rs` `automatic_opencode_probe_failure_keeps_another_harness_available`, `opencode_executable_probe_selects_v2_for_launch_and_autowire`, effective-child-environment PATH casing controls, fake V1/V2/env-derived-major/malformed/future/timeout executable tests, `setup-agent` V1/V2 no-probe integration controls; `install_hooks.rs` `opencode_plugin_cleanup_removes_only_exact_owned_incompatible_sibling`, `opencode_plugin_cleanup_preserves_a_concurrent_user_replacement`, `opencode_plugin_restore_moves_quarantine_when_destination_is_free`, `opencode_plugin_restore_preserves_an_existing_replacement`, `opencode_plugin_restore_does_not_replace_a_file_created_at_restore_window`, `opencode_plugin_cleanup_does_not_escape_custom_target_directory`; `install_mcp.rs` `opencode_install_reuses_owned_endpoint_and_token_across_major_transitions`, `opencode_install_refuses_conflicting_owned_transition_entries`, `opencode_install_does_not_infer_from_a_user_owned_transition_entry`, `opencode_mcp_migration_moves_only_owned_alternate_shape`, `opencode_mcp_migration_preserves_ambiguous_user_entry`, `opencode_mcp_migration_preserves_custom_headers`, `opencode_mcp_migration_accepts_only_historical_generated_headers` | STRONG for Unix process probes and platform-neutral ownership gates; exact Windows executable resolution remains covered by `run.rs` resolver tests and requires the PR `windows` label |
| 12 | Network/auth posture | `config.rs` loopback `DEFAULT_BIND`; `serve.rs` `validate_http_exposure`, `require_allowed_host`; `auth.rs` `require_bearer`; `serve.rs` mounts `/identity` inside the host and machine-auth gates even with web disabled; `nix/nixos-module.nix` treats only literal `127.0.0.1`/`::1` as loopback, requires exactly one secret environment source for other binds, keeps secret auth and `llm_headers` values out of the Nix store, and brackets IPv6 in `ExecStart` | `serve.rs` host-guard (missing→400 / forged→403), non-loopback-requires-token; `auth.rs` wrong-token 401; `serve.rs` `machine_identity_remains_authenticated_with_web_disabled_and_expired_keys` (wrong and expired keys refused, valid machine key accepted, web remains disabled); `flake.nix` `nixos-module-eval` refuses `localhost` and `0.0.0.0` without a secret source, refuses two secret sources, `settings.auth` secrets, and `settings.llm_headers`, with literal IPv4/IPv6 loopback and one-source controls | STRONG |
| 12b | Managed-workstream provenance privacy, stable replay identity and server event namespace | `ai-memory-core/src/workstream.rs` `scrub_workstream_provenance`; `ai-memory-hooks/src/workstream.rs` `finish_run` reserved client-id check and `sanitize_events` before immutable segments, with `sanitize_events` and `append_boundary_events` scrubbing event/checkpoint/losses content *before* the 64 KiB cap so a cap-straddling secret is never cut into an unmatchable prefix (#1113); `ai-memory-store/src/workstream.rs` `finish_run` stable identity check and `stored_event`, scrubbing content with the explicitly supplied configured sanitizer before its 16 KiB store-boundary bound; no changes to the typed observation boundary | `store/tests/suite/workstream_provenance.rs` `workstream_provenance_is_bounded_scrubbed_and_idempotent_before_storage` (hostile and oversized source ids, unknown metadata, legitimate correlation, retry and distinct event ids), `workstream_provenance_legacy_reads_strip_secrets_and_unknown_metadata` (search and tail, malformed/oversized legacy JSON), `workstream_provenance_reused_event_id_retains_data_and_refuses_identity_change` (first indexed version retained, identity refusal and batch rollback), `workstream_provenance_replay_survives_sanitizer_changes` (new extra patterns and removal of a built-in-pattern allowlist exemption, with identity-refusal control), `workstream_provenance_replay_preserves_legacy_rows_above_bounds`, `workstream_provenance_finished_run_ignores_late_events`, `workstream_provenance_retry_with_marker_matching_pattern_is_idempotent`, `workstream_content_is_scrubbed_before_the_store_cap` (a credential straddling the 16 KiB store cap is redacted, not persisted as an unmatchable prefix; benign control verbatim; #1113); `hooks` `workstream_provenance_finish_scrubs_before_raw_segment_and_search` (custom sanitizer, immutable segment, SQL recovery and finished-run no-op), `workstream_provenance_client_cannot_use_server_event_ids` (reserved ids refused before raw writes, normal client event and server-generated checkpoint/loss controls), `finish_run_scrubs_event_content_before_the_byte_cap` and `finish_run_scrubs_boundary_events_before_the_byte_cap` (a credential straddling the 64 KiB event cap is redacted in the raw segment and never reaches the index; checkpoint/losses and benign controls; #1113); `cli/tests/suite/workstream_provenance.rs` (text/JSON and old server DTOs) | STRONG: privacy, stable-identity and reserved-namespace regressions fail with their guards bypassed; an isolated allowlist bypass fails on the unknown key, and bypassing the raw-id search authorization returns 200 where its test requires 403. No provenance is emitted in startup packets, and old raw segments are not rewritten |
-| 12c | Browser cross-origin writes refused on an unauthenticated server (a foreign page in the operator's browser, DNS rebinding, and a LAN host where browsers send no fetch metadata) | `serve.rs` `refuse_cross_origin_browser_requests` / `is_cross_origin_browser_request`, layered on the machine (`/mcp`, `/hook*`, `/handoff`, `/workstream/*`, `/identity`) and admin (`/admin/*`) routes when auth is off: `Sec-Fetch-Site` other than `same-origin`/`none` → 403, or, without fetch metadata, an `Origin` whose authority is not the `Host` → 403; and `is_non_script_browser_request`: any `Sec-Fetch-Dest` other than `empty` (case-insensitive; non-UTF-8 refused) → 403 whatever `Sec-Fetch-Site` says, so links, images, navigations, iframes and form posts are refused even as `same-origin` or `none`. Browsers send fetch metadata over plain HTTP only to a potentially trustworthy host, so on any other `Host` (a LAN address or name in the allowlist, `0.0.0.0`, `host.docker.internal`; `is_loopback_host` admits only `localhost`, `*.localhost`, `127.0.0.0/8` and `[::1]`) `handoff_fetch_lacks_client_marker` also refuses `GET`/`HEAD /handoff` without a non-empty `X-AI-Memory-Client` header (`ai_memory_hooks::CLIENT_MARKER_HEADER`) → 403 whose body names both remedies (re-stage hooks, or set a bearer token). A page cannot add that header without a preflight these routes never answer. `/handoff` is the one state-changing `GET` on these routes; the other `GET`s are reads a foreign page cannot see the answer to, and every cross-origin `POST` carries `Origin`. Every first-party client sends the marker: the native hook (`hook_capture.rs` `post_hook`/`post_batch`/`get_handoff`), CLI subcommands (`http_client.rs` `ServerEndpoint::authenticate`), every curl in `hooks/_lib.sh`, both header tables in `hooks/lib/ai-memory-hook.ps1`, and the generated TypeScript integrations (`render_shared.rs` `ts_auth_headers_fn` plus the spool drain). Loopback hosts keep accepting a fetch without it, so hooks staged before the header existed still work on a default install. Hooks, the CLI and MCP clients send none of these headers; the web UI's same-origin `/admin/pending-writes` calls are `fetch()` (`Sec-Fetch-Dest: empty`) and pass. Behind it, axum `Json` and rmcp's `Content-Type: application/json` check refuse the preflight-free content types (`text/plain`, form-urlencoded, multipart) with 415; `require_allowed_host` (and rmcp `allowed_hosts` on `/mcp`) refuses a rebinding `Host`; machine/admin routes carry no CORS layer, so a preflight never comes back permissive. A stored wiki page viewed in the built-in web UI could otherwise turn the guard's same-origin allowance into a claim: `ai-memory-web/src/markdown.rs` `safe_image_url` / `is_safe_image_target` render as `#` any image target that is root-relative, a network path, carries a `..` segment (also percent-encoded), or, for a UI mounted at the base-path root, starts with a server route segment | `cli/tests/suite/cross_origin_e2e.rs` `browser_cross_origin_requests_cannot_write_to_an_unauthenticated_loopback_server`, against the shipped `serve`: every write route (`/hook`, `/hook/batch`, MCP `memory_write_page`/`memory_delete_page`/`memory_message_send`/`memory_handoff_accept`, `/admin/write-page`/`delete-page`/`purge-project`/`messages/send`, `/workstream/runs`) × each simple content type × modern, Origin-only and fetch-metadata-only browser shapes → 4xx; body-less `GET /handoff` (which claims the single-use baton), `POST /admin/profile/rebuild` and `POST /admin/backup` → 403; a rebinding `Host` → 403; preflights answer no `Access-Control-Allow-*`; `GET /handoff` as a same-origin `document` or `image` and as a `Sec-Fetch-Site: none` `document` → 403 with the baton still open. Then a canary scan of the whole data dir, page/project/handoff survival, and legitimate controls (JSON MCP calls, a JSON hook → 202, the web UI's same-origin `/admin/pending-writes` list and approve reach their handlers, the anonymous active-project pointer is unmoved after the refused `/handoff` fetches while the closing hook-style fetch claims the baton and moves it). `serve.rs` `cross_origin_browser_request_detection` and `non_script_browser_request_detection` (header tables) and `cross_origin_browser_guard_applies_only_without_auth` (same-origin `image` and `none` `document` refused, same-origin `empty` passes, both pass with auth on); `ai-memory-web` `markdown.rs` `neutralises_images_that_reach_server_routes` (`/handoff?…`, `/admin/backup`, `//host/…`, `../` and `%2e%2e/` traversal, root-mounted route names refused) with `preserves_relative_images` as the legitimate control. `cross_origin_e2e.rs` `handoff_fetch_on_a_lan_host_requires_the_client_marker`, against a `serve` that allowlists a LAN name and address: `GET` and `HEAD /handoff` through either without the marker, and with an empty one → 403 carrying the remedy text, with the baton still open and the active-project pointer unmoved; controls: a marked fetch through the LAN name claims the baton, and a marker-less fetch through `127.0.0.1` (a hook staged before the marker) claims the next one. `serve.rs` `loopback_host_detection`, `handoff_fetch_client_marker_decision` and `handoff_client_marker_guard_on_lan_hosts_and_under_a_base_path` (also under a `--base-path` nest; inactive with auth on). Front-door parity: `hook_capture.rs` `every_native_hook_request_carries_the_client_marker` (handoff GET, hook POST, batch POST), `http_client.rs` `authenticate_no_token_sets_only_the_client_marker`, the client-marker block of `tests/hooks/test_lib.sh` (every curl branch of the GET, the POST and the drain, plus a static check that every PowerShell header table carries it and every `Invoke-WebRequest` passes one), `render_shared.rs` `assert_every_ts_request_carries_client_marker` run for OpenCode, OpenCode 2, OMP, Pi and OpenClaw, `external_capture_ts.rs` (the rendered OpenCode plugin under Node sends no unmarked request) and `external_capture_powershell.rs` `every_request_carries_the_client_marker` (Windows leg) | STRONG with listed residuals. Bite checks: with the marker check disabled, the LAN e2e marker-less `GET /handoff` returns 200 and the unit layer test fails; dropping the marker from the native handoff GET, the shell token-drain curl, a PowerShell header table or the TypeScript spool drain fails the matching front-door test. With the guard removed, the cross-origin `GET /handoff` returns 200, consumes the baton and moves the active-project pointer (the pre-fix behaviour); with the guard treating `same-origin` as foreign, the web UI control gets 403; with the `Sec-Fetch-Dest` check removed, the same-origin `document` `GET /handoff` returns 200 and the unit guard test lets a same-origin image through; with the host layer removed, a rebound `/hook` returns 202; a permissive `CorsLayer` fails the preflight assertion; reverting `is_safe_image_target` to the pre-fix rule fails the markdown test on `/handoff?…`, dropping the percent-decoding fails it on `%2e%2e/`, and emptying the route list fails it on a root-mounted `handoff`. To reproduce the bite on the 415 layer, remove the guard and make `/hook` read a raw body instead of `Json`: a `text/plain` hook then returns 202 and the test fails. Residual, closed by setting a bearer token: a browser that sends no fetch metadata even to a loopback host (Safari before 16.4) sends no `Sec-Fetch-*` header and no `Origin` on an image `GET` or a link click, so such a request to a loopback host still reaches `/handoff` (loopback keeps accepting marker-less legacy hooks) and the other, read-only `GET` routes. On a non-loopback host the marker requirement closes `/handoff` for every browser. Browsers that send fetch metadata no longer have the earlier link residuals: a link opened from another app (`Sec-Fetch-Site: none`) and a link clicked in a stored page (`same-origin` navigation) both carry a non-`empty` destination and are refused. With auth on, the bearer token and the session CSRF token are the gate and this layer is a no-op |
+| 12c | Browser cross-origin writes refused on an unauthenticated server (a foreign page in the operator's browser, DNS rebinding, and a LAN host where browsers send no fetch metadata) | `serve.rs` `refuse_cross_origin_browser_requests` / `is_cross_origin_browser_request`, layered on the machine (`/mcp`, `/hook*`, `/handoff`, `/workstream/*`, `/identity`) and admin (`/admin/*`) routes when auth is off: `Sec-Fetch-Site` other than `same-origin`/`none` → 403, or, without fetch metadata, an `Origin` whose authority is not the `Host` → 403; and `is_non_script_browser_request`: any `Sec-Fetch-Dest` other than `empty` (case-insensitive; non-UTF-8 refused) → 403 whatever `Sec-Fetch-Site` says, so links, images, navigations, iframes and form posts are refused even as `same-origin` or `none`. Browsers send fetch metadata over plain HTTP only to a potentially trustworthy host, so on any other `Host` (a LAN address or name in the allowlist, `0.0.0.0`, `host.docker.internal`; `is_loopback_host` admits only `localhost`, `*.localhost`, `127.0.0.0/8` and `[::1]`) `handoff_fetch_lacks_client_marker` also refuses `GET`/`HEAD /handoff` without a non-empty `X-AI-Memory-Client` header (`ai_memory_hooks::CLIENT_MARKER_HEADER`) → 403 whose body names both remedies (re-stage hooks, or set a bearer token). A page cannot add that header without a preflight these routes never answer. `/handoff` is the one state-changing `GET` on these routes; the other `GET`s are reads a foreign page cannot see the answer to, and every cross-origin `POST` carries `Origin`. Every first-party client sends the marker: the native hook (`hook_capture.rs` `post_hook`/`post_batch`/`get_handoff`), CLI subcommands (`http_client.rs` `ServerEndpoint::authenticate`), every curl in `hooks/_lib.sh`, both header tables in `hooks/lib/ai-memory-hook.ps1`, and the generated TypeScript integrations (`render_shared.rs` `ts_auth_headers_fn` plus the spool drain). Loopback hosts keep accepting a fetch without it, so hooks staged before the header existed still work on a default install, except that a request carrying any proxy forwarding header (`Forwarded`, `X-Forwarded-For`, `X-Forwarded-Host`, `X-Real-IP`, `Via`; `PROXY_HEADERS`) counts as non-loopback, since a plain-HTTP proxy can rewrite `Host` to loopback while the browser behind it sent no fetch metadata. No first-party client sends those headers. Hooks, the CLI and MCP clients send none of these headers; the web UI's same-origin `/admin/pending-writes` calls are `fetch()` (`Sec-Fetch-Dest: empty`) and pass. Behind it, axum `Json` and rmcp's `Content-Type: application/json` check refuse the preflight-free content types (`text/plain`, form-urlencoded, multipart) with 415; `require_allowed_host` (and rmcp `allowed_hosts` on `/mcp`) refuses a rebinding `Host`; machine/admin routes carry no CORS layer, so a preflight never comes back permissive. A stored wiki page viewed in the built-in web UI could otherwise turn the guard's same-origin allowance into a claim: `ai-memory-web/src/markdown.rs` `safe_image_url` / `is_safe_image_target` render as `#` any image target that is root-relative, a network path, carries a `..` segment (also percent-encoded), or, for a UI mounted at the base-path root, starts with a server route segment | `cli/tests/suite/cross_origin_e2e.rs` `browser_cross_origin_requests_cannot_write_to_an_unauthenticated_loopback_server`, against the shipped `serve`: every write route (`/hook`, `/hook/batch`, MCP `memory_write_page`/`memory_delete_page`/`memory_message_send`/`memory_handoff_accept`, `/admin/write-page`/`delete-page`/`purge-project`/`messages/send`, `/workstream/runs`) × each simple content type × modern, Origin-only and fetch-metadata-only browser shapes → 4xx; body-less `GET /handoff` (which claims the single-use baton), `POST /admin/profile/rebuild` and `POST /admin/backup` → 403; a rebinding `Host` → 403; preflights answer no `Access-Control-Allow-*`; `GET /handoff` as a same-origin `document` or `image` and as a `Sec-Fetch-Site: none` `document` → 403 with the baton still open. Then a canary scan of the whole data dir, page/project/handoff survival, and legitimate controls (JSON MCP calls, a JSON hook → 202, the web UI's same-origin `/admin/pending-writes` list and approve reach their handlers, the anonymous active-project pointer is unmoved after the refused `/handoff` fetches while the closing hook-style fetch claims the baton and moves it). `serve.rs` `cross_origin_browser_request_detection` and `non_script_browser_request_detection` (header tables) and `cross_origin_browser_guard_applies_only_without_auth` (same-origin `image` and `none` `document` refused, same-origin `empty` passes, both pass with auth on); `ai-memory-web` `markdown.rs` `neutralises_images_that_reach_server_routes` (`/handoff?…`, `/admin/backup`, `//host/…`, `../` and `%2e%2e/` traversal, root-mounted route names refused) with `preserves_relative_images` as the legitimate control. `cross_origin_e2e.rs` `handoff_fetch_on_a_lan_host_requires_the_client_marker`, against a `serve` that allowlists a LAN name and address: `GET` and `HEAD /handoff` through either without the marker, and with an empty one → 403 carrying the remedy text, with the baton still open and the active-project pointer unmoved; controls: a marked fetch through the LAN name claims the baton, and a marker-less fetch through `127.0.0.1` (a hook staged before the marker) claims the next one; then a `127.0.0.1` fetch carrying each proxy forwarding header and no marker → 403 with the baton still open, and the same fetch with the marker claims it. `serve.rs` `loopback_host_detection`, `handoff_fetch_client_marker_decision` (incl. a loopback `Host` with each proxy header, refused without the marker and admitted with it) and `handoff_client_marker_guard_on_lan_hosts_and_under_a_base_path` (also under a `--base-path` nest; inactive with auth on). Front-door parity: `hook_capture.rs` `every_native_hook_request_carries_the_client_marker` (handoff GET, hook POST, batch POST), `http_client.rs` `authenticate_no_token_sets_only_the_client_marker`, the client-marker block of `tests/hooks/test_lib.sh` (every curl branch of the GET, the POST and the drain, plus a static check that every PowerShell header table carries it and every `Invoke-WebRequest` passes one), `render_shared.rs` `assert_every_ts_request_carries_client_marker` run for OpenCode, OpenCode 2, OMP, Pi and OpenClaw, `external_capture_ts.rs` (the rendered OpenCode plugin under Node sends no unmarked request) and `external_capture_powershell.rs` `every_request_carries_the_client_marker` (Windows leg) | STRONG with listed residuals. Bite checks: with the marker check disabled, the LAN e2e marker-less `GET /handoff` returns 200 and the unit layer test fails; with the proxy-header rule disabled, the proxied loopback e2e fetch claims the baton and the unit decision test fails; dropping the marker from the native handoff GET, the shell token-drain curl, a PowerShell header table or the TypeScript spool drain fails the matching front-door test. With the guard removed, the cross-origin `GET /handoff` returns 200, consumes the baton and moves the active-project pointer (the pre-fix behaviour); with the guard treating `same-origin` as foreign, the web UI control gets 403; with the `Sec-Fetch-Dest` check removed, the same-origin `document` `GET /handoff` returns 200 and the unit guard test lets a same-origin image through; with the host layer removed, a rebound `/hook` returns 202; a permissive `CorsLayer` fails the preflight assertion; reverting `is_safe_image_target` to the pre-fix rule fails the markdown test on `/handoff?…`, dropping the percent-decoding fails it on `%2e%2e/`, and emptying the route list fails it on a root-mounted `handoff`. To reproduce the bite on the 415 layer, remove the guard and make `/hook` read a raw body instead of `Json`: a `text/plain` hook then returns 202 and the test fails. Residual, closed by setting a bearer token: a browser that sends no fetch metadata even to a loopback host (Safari before 16.4) sends no `Sec-Fetch-*` header and no `Origin` on an image `GET` or a link click, so such a request to a loopback host still reaches `/handoff` (loopback keeps accepting marker-less legacy hooks) and the other, read-only `GET` routes. On a non-loopback host the marker requirement closes `/handoff` for every browser. Browsers that send fetch metadata no longer have the earlier link residuals: a link opened from another app (`Sec-Fetch-Site: none`) and a link clicked in a stored page (`same-origin` navigation) both carry a non-`empty` destination and are refused. With auth on, the bearer token and the session CSRF token are the gate and this layer is a no-op |
| 13 | Managed-run transcript attribution (concurrent launches in one checkout, invariant #16) | `ai-memory-store/src/workstream.rs` `link_native_session` stamps `native_session_linked_at` on its own run only, both `finish` updates drop the stamp when the session changes, `run_status` reports it; `ai-memory-cli/src/commands/run.rs` `resolve_native_session_after_run` takes a linked session only when `ai-memory-workstream` `native_session_in_checkout` holds it for this checkout (OpenCode by recorded directory), never falls back to a link it set aside, and turns an `AmbiguousNativeSession` into a warning with nothing imported; for Claude it moves the run's own session to a background session only when `ai-memory-workstream` `claude_continued_session` finds a `sessionKind: "bg"` record that names that exact session as its attached client and this checkout as `cwd` (#1050), and to a `/clear`ed session only when that session's own transcript records the `/clear` command and names the run's session as its launch `session_id` from this checkout or below it; `ai-memory-workstream/src/transcript.rs` `discover_crush` claims only the one top-level session created (or, with `--continue`, touched) during the run, and in a data directory outside the project only one that edited a file in it | `multi_session.rs` `a_session_linked_by_one_managed_run_is_not_another_runs`; `run.rs` `a_session_linked_during_the_run_wins_over_discovery` (concurrent newer session, another checkout's link refused, no fallback to it, unlinked control); `transcript.rs` `claude_continued_session_follows_only_this_checkouts_bg_records` (a concurrent launch's background session, another checkout's, and a non-background record refused; own attachment control); `transcript.rs` `claude_continued_session_follows_only_this_launchs_clear` (an uncleared transcript, a quoted `/clear`, another checkout's clear, a concurrent launch's clear, a subagent file, and a pre-run clear refused; own clear and the newest of two as controls); `run.rs` `a_claude_run_that_attached_to_a_background_session_follows_it`, `a_claude_run_that_was_cleared_follows_the_new_session`; `transcript.rs` `native_session_in_checkout_checks_the_opencode_directory`; `store/src/lib.rs` `managed_run_status_reports_a_link_made_during_the_run`; `run.rs` `ambiguous_crush_discovery_keeps_the_run`; `transcript.rs` `crush_discovery_claims_only_the_session_the_run_created`, `crush_discovery_in_a_shared_store_claims_only_an_edit_here` | PARTIAL: a run whose child links nothing still falls back to discovering the newest session in the checkout; Crush, which has no hooks, relies on that discovery alone and claims nothing when it is ambiguous |
| 13a | Managed Codex stale-daemon run recovery (#987; concurrent launches, project/worktree isolation, operator isolation) | `managed_runs.owner_user` (V71) uses the topology-aware `IdentityKey` owner stamp; `router.rs` resolves and authorizes the SessionStart repository before handling the untrusted run id; store `link_or_adopt_native_session` selects and links in one writer transaction and admits only the sole live, undelivered, never-linked Codex run in the exact workspace/project/checkout-cwd/owner bucket. An active supplied id must itself match every boundary; another harness, an ambiguity, or a second native session is refused | `multi_session.rs` `stale_codex_run_recovery_cannot_cross_project_owner_or_session_boundaries` (foreign owner, foreign checkout, and cross-project candidates refused; project-local controls and racing rebind), `stale_codex_run_recovery_fails_closed_on_ambiguity_and_active_mismatch` (two candidates and active foreign id refused, exact control); `workstream.rs` `prepare_stamps_the_operator_bucket_used_by_session_start_recovery` (HTTP actor stamp with foreign and legitimate controls); `router.rs` `managed_session_start_delivers_ledger_and_pending_handoff` supplies a finished stale id and proves the new run is linked and delivered | STRONG for SessionStart recovery. No candidate is selected from a run id's stale scope, another checkout, or another operator bucket; ambiguity deliberately falls back to no managed packet |
| 13b | Managed-run lease exclusivity and explicit recovery (one active run per workstream, invariant #16) | `ai-memory-store/src/workstream.rs` `prepare_run` expires lapsed leases and otherwise refuses an `active` run inside the writer transaction (`StoreError::WorkstreamBusy`). The explicit `force_unlock` path may expire and replace that row in the same transaction only when its durable `owner_user` equals the incoming actor's attribution; different operators remain isolated. `heartbeat` renews only `active` rows. `ai-memory-cli/src/commands/run.rs` normally uses `wait_out_held_lease`; `--force-unlock` instead asks once and fails immediately when refused. Neither path treats the informational `lease_owner` label as authority | `multi_session.rs` `force_unlock_replaces_only_the_same_operators_active_run` (foreign operator refused with live control, same operator succeeds, old run loses heartbeat, unattributed single-user control); hooks `workstream.rs` `force_unlock_cannot_evict_another_operator` exercises the HTTP actor boundary; CLI `run.rs` `force_unlock_asks_once_instead_of_waiting_out_the_lease`; existing controls `managed_workstream_batches_are_idempotent_and_release_the_lease`, `a_renewed_lease_is_reported_as_a_live_owner_not_taken_over`, `interactive_launch_waits_out_a_lapsing_lease_then_proceeds`, and `ctrl_c_aborts_the_held_lease_wait_immediately` | STRONG for exclusivity. The `lease_owner` label (`host:pid`) is informational only and not unique inside ai-jail (every jailed launcher reports `ai-sandbox:<ns-pid>`), so it must never become an ownership key. A shared unattributed/root context is intentionally one operator bucket; deployments needing person-level refusal must authenticate DB users |