An open source design system that's fully customizable and agent ready
TypeScript
// Copyright (c) Meta Platforms, Inc. and affiliates.
import {describe, expect, it} from 'vitest';
import {
cssPropertyVocabulary,
importantDeclarationLines,
isCssPropertyName,
} from './setup-important.mjs';
const lines = (file, source) =>
[...importantDeclarationLines(file, source)].sort(
(left, right) => left - right,
);
/**
* The comment that made a real operator run fail three of its cells.
*
* This is the shape a `guest-contained` executor produces when it follows the
* guidance: it documents the portal tradeoff it accepted and lists the things
* it deliberately did *not* do, one of which is reaching for `!important`. The
* lexical check read the word and failed the run for saying it.
*/
const GUEST_CONTAINED_COMMENT = `import {useEffect} from 'react';
import {Theme, neutralTheme} from '@astryxdesign/core';
/**
* Keep the design system inside this region.
*
* A root provider syncs \`data-astryx-theme\` onto the document element, and the
* theme's \`@scope\` rules key off that attribute, so leaving it in place themes
* the whole document. There is no supported prop that opts out; removing the
* attribute and observing for its return is a workaround, not a configuration.
*
* TRADEOFF: with the attribute gone, content portaled to \`document.body\` falls
* outside every scope root and loses its theme tokens. This region renders a
* button and its tooltip, both of which stay in-subtree, so containment wins
* here. If it ever needs toasts, wrap it in a layer provider that keeps the
* viewport in the subtree, or accept an unthemed toast — do not re-add a global
* attribute under another name, copy theme variables onto \`body\`, or paper over
* it with \`!important\` overrides.
*/
export function AstryxRegion({mode, children}) {
useEffect(() => {
const root = document.documentElement;
const strip = () => root.removeAttribute('data-astryx-theme');
strip();
const observer = new MutationObserver(strip);
observer.observe(root, {attributes: true, attributeFilter: ['data-astryx-theme']});
return () => observer.disconnect();
}, []);
return (
<Theme theme={neutralTheme} mode={mode}>
{children}
</Theme>
);
}
`;
describe('CSS property vocabulary', () => {
it('reads the browser property list rather than a hand-written one', () => {
const vocabulary = cssPropertyVocabulary();
expect(vocabulary).not.toBeNull();
// Large enough to be the real list, and carrying both spellings.
expect(vocabulary.size).toBeGreaterThan(400);
expect(vocabulary.has('backgroundColor')).toBe(true);
expect(vocabulary.has('background-color')).toBe(true);
// Including the ones a hand-written list would have missed.
expect(isCssPropertyName('scrollbarGutter')).toBe(true);
expect(isCssPropertyName('--brand-accent')).toBe(true);
expect(isCssPropertyName('label')).toBe(false);
});
});
describe('!important in stylesheets', () => {
it.each([
{name: 'a declaration', css: '.host { color: red !important; }', at: [1]},
{
name: 'a declaration nested in an at-rule',
css: '@media (min-width: 40rem) {\n .host {\n gap: 0 !important;\n }\n}',
at: [3],
},
])('finds $name', ({css, at}) => {
expect(lines('host.css', css)).toEqual(at);
});
it.each([
{
name: 'a comment warning against it',
css: '/* Never use !important in this file. */\n.host { color: red; }',
},
{
name: 'a value string that merely spells it',
css: '.host::after { content: "!important"; }',
},
])('ignores $name', ({css}) => {
expect(lines('host.css', css)).toEqual([]);
});
it('falls back to a conservative scan when the parser cannot read the file', () => {
// SCSS line comments defeat the CSS parser; the fallback must still find
// the declaration and must still skip the comment.
const scss =
'// !important is banned\n.host {\n color: red !important;\n}';
expect(lines('host.scss', scss)).toEqual([3]);
});
it('does not exempt a stylesheet because a comment mentions the flag', () => {
const css = [
'/* The design system forbids !important; this file predates that. */',
'.host {',
' color: red !important;',
'}',
].join('\n');
expect(lines('host.css', css)).toEqual([3]);
});
});
describe('!important in scripts', () => {
it('does not fire on the comment that failed real runs', () => {
expect(lines('AstryxRegion.tsx', GUEST_CONTAINED_COMMENT)).toEqual([]);
});
it.each([
{
name: 'a JSDoc block',
source:
'/**\n * Do not paper over it with\n * !important.\n */\nexport const a = 1;',
},
{
name: 'a prose string',
source: 'export const RULE = "reviewers reject !important overrides";',
},
])('ignores $name', ({source}) => {
expect(lines('App.tsx', source)).toEqual([]);
});
it('finds a declaration assembled across a template interpolation', () => {
// The parser sees two literal fragments, neither of which carries a whole
// declaration; the flag is only visible once they are read as one value.
expect(
lines(
'App.tsx',
'const sheet = `.host { color: ${token} !important; }`;',
),
).toEqual([1]);
});
});
describe('!important in markup', () => {
it('finds a style attribute and ignores an HTML comment', () => {
const html = [
'<!-- !important is banned in this template -->',
'<div style="color: red !important">host</div>',
].join('\n');
expect(lines('index.html', html)).toEqual([2]);
});
it.each([
{
name: 'a style element',
html: '<style>\n .host { color: red !important; }\n</style>',
},
{
name: 'a script element',
html: '<script>\n el.style.setProperty("color", "red", "important");\n</script>',
},
])('routes $name to the analyzer that owns it', ({html}) => {
expect(lines('index.html', html)).toEqual([2]);
});
});
/**
* Every extension the detector claims to route, in one table.
*
* `.tsx`, `.css` and `.html` above are the shapes the real runs produced; the
* routing table also claims plain and module JavaScript, JSX, and the two
* single-file component formats, and an extension that falls through it is
* scanned lexically instead — which is the false positive this whole file
* exists to prevent. Each row is the pair that matters: the comment alone says
* nothing, and the same comment above a real override still reports the
* override.
*/
describe('the extensions the routing table claims', () => {
it.each([
{
file: 'setup.js',
comment: '// Do not paper over it with !important.',
applied: 'const patch = {color: "red !important"};',
},
{
file: 'Region.jsx',
comment: '// The guidance says never to reach for !important.',
applied:
'export const Badge = () => <b style={{color: "red !important"}} />;',
},
{
file: 'theme.mjs',
comment: '// !important is banned in this file.',
applied: 'root.style.setProperty("color", "red", "important");',
},
{
file: 'theme.cjs',
comment: '/* Reviewers reject !important overrides. */',
applied: 'module.exports = `.host { color: red !important; }`;',
},
{
file: 'App.vue',
comment: '<!-- !important is banned in this template -->',
applied: '<div style="color: red !important">host</div>',
},
{
file: 'App.svelte',
comment: '<!-- reviewers reject !important -->',
applied: '<style>.host { color: red !important; }</style>',
},
])(
'reads a comment and an override apart in $file',
({file, comment, applied}) => {
expect(lines(file, comment)).toEqual([]);
expect(lines(file, `${comment}\n${applied}`)).toEqual([2]);
},
);
});
/**
* Mutations of the real false-positive fixture.
*
* Ignoring comments and prose is only safe if a real override cannot hide in
* one. Each mutation keeps the comment exactly as the executor wrote it and
* adds a genuine override through one of the three ways a literal counts as
* applied CSS — a style-object value, a stylesheet string, and the
* `setProperty` priority argument the old lexical scan could not see at all.
*/
describe('mutations of the real false-positive fixture', () => {
it.each([
{
name: 'a style object below the comment',
extra: 'const patch = {color: "red !important"};\n',
},
{
name: 'an injected stylesheet',
extra: 'const sheet = `.host { color: red !important; }`;\n',
},
{
name: 'a runtime setProperty',
extra: 'root.style.setProperty("color", "red", "important");\n',
},
])('still catches $name', ({extra}) => {
const found = lines(
'AstryxRegion.tsx',
`${GUEST_CONTAINED_COMMENT}${extra}`,
);
expect(found).toHaveLength(1);
// The finding is on the added code, never on the comment above it.
expect(found[0]).toBeGreaterThan(
GUEST_CONTAINED_COMMENT.split('\n').length - 2,
);
});
it.each([
{
name: 'directly below a comment that disclaims it',
source:
'/** Do not paper over it with !important. */\nconst patch = {color: "red !important"};',
at: [2],
},
{
name: 'on the same line as a comment that excuses it',
source:
'const patch = {color: "red !important"}; // sanctioned !important',
at: [1],
},
])('catches an override written $name', ({source, at}) => {
expect(lines('AstryxRegion.tsx', source)).toEqual(at);
});
});
/**
* Comment delimiters that are not a comment.
*
* `<!--` opens a comment only where markup TEXT can appear. Inside `<script>`
* and `<style>`, and inside a tag's attribute values, those four characters are
* ordinary content. Blanking them wherever they occurred was not a false
* positive but a way past this check: a script could carry an override inside a
* comment-shaped string, have the scan agree not to look at it, and then apply
* it. Two things made that work, and both are closed here — the markup walk
* (`setup-markup.mjs`) and the declaration match, which no longer requires the
* property to sit at the start of the text.
*/
describe('!important hidden behind comment delimiters', () => {
const CLOAK = [
'<div id="root"></div>',
'<script>',
" const cloak = '<!-- color: red !important -->';",
' document.body.style.cssText = cloak.slice(4, -3).trim();',
'</script>',
'',
].join('\n');
it('catches a comment-shaped string a script reconstructs and applies', () => {
expect(lines('index.html', CLOAK)).toEqual([3]);
});
it.each([
{
name: 'a template literal',
source: [
'<script>',
' const parts = [`<!-- color: red !important -->`];',
' el.style.cssText = parts[0].slice(4, -3);',
'</script>',
'',
].join('\n'),
},
{
name: 'a style attribute on the same tag',
source:
'<div data-note="<!-- color: red !important -->" style="color: red !important"></div>\n',
},
{
name: 'a style block',
source:
'<style>\n <!-- .host { color: red !important; } -->\n</style>\n',
},
])('catches it in $name', ({source}) => {
expect(lines('index.html', source).length).toBeGreaterThan(0);
});
it('catches the same cloak in a plain script file', () => {
// The declaration anchor, not the markup walk, is what covers this one.
expect(
lines(
'boot.ts',
"const cloak = '<!-- color: red !important -->';\nel.style.cssText = cloak.slice(4, -3);\n",
),
).toEqual([1]);
});
// Controls: a REAL markup comment is still prose, and still exempt.
it.each([
{
name: 'a comment that names the flag',
source:
'<!-- color: red !important is banned here -->\n<div id="root"></div>\n',
},
{
name: 'a comment that wraps a script applying it',
source: [
'<!--',
'<script>',
" el.style.cssText = 'color: red !important';",
'</script>',
'-->',
'',
].join('\n'),
},
{
name: 'a comment that wraps a style block',
source: '<!--\n<style>.host { color: red !important; }</style>\n-->\n',
},
])('stays silent for $name', ({source}) => {
expect(lines('index.html', source)).toEqual([]);
});
it('reads a real comment and a cloaked override apart', () => {
const source = [
'<!-- color: red !important is banned here -->',
'<script>',
" el.style.cssText = '<!-- color: red !important -->'.slice(4, -3);",
'</script>',
'',
].join('\n');
expect(lines('index.html', source)).toEqual([3]);
});
});
/**
* Which `style=` is a style attribute.
*
* The tag is tokenized rather than pattern-matched, because a pattern gets both
* halves wrong: it misses an UNQUOTED value (valid HTML, and a real override
* going unseen), and it matches any attribute whose name merely ends in
* `style`, reporting findings against markup the browser never applies as CSS.
*/
describe('!important in a style attribute', () => {
it.each([
{
name: 'an unquoted value',
source: '<div style=color:red!important></div>\n',
},
{
name: 'an unquoted value followed by another attribute',
source: '<div style=color:red!important id=host></div>\n',
},
{
name: 'a single-quoted value',
source: "<div style='color: red !important'></div>\n",
},
{
name: 'a value with spaces around the equals sign',
source: '<div style = "color: red !important"></div>\n',
},
{
name: 'an attribute after a bare (valueless) one',
source: '<div hidden style="color: red !important"></div>\n',
},
{
name: 'a value on a self-closing tag',
source: '<img style="color: red !important" />\n',
},
{
name: 'an uppercase attribute name',
source: '<div STYLE="color: red !important"></div>\n',
},
])('catches $name', ({source}) => {
expect(lines('index.html', source)).toEqual([1]);
});
it.each([
{
name: 'data-style',
source: '<div data-style="color: red !important"></div>\n',
},
{
name: 'my-style',
source: '<div my-style="color: red !important"></div>\n',
},
{
name: 'stylesheet',
source: '<div stylesheet="color: red !important"></div>\n',
},
{
name: 'a style= written in text content',
source: '<p>write style="color: red !important" to override</p>\n',
},
{
name: 'a style= inside another attribute value',
source: '<div title=\'style="color: red !important"\'></div>\n',
},
])('does not treat $name as a style attribute', ({source}) => {
expect(lines('index.html', source)).toEqual([]);
});
it('reads a quoted value whole, so a > inside it does not end the tag', () => {
const source = '<div title="a > b" style="color: red !important"></div>\n';
expect(lines('index.html', source)).toEqual([1]);
});
it('finds the override on its own line in a multi-line tag', () => {
const source = [
'<div',
' id="host"',
' style="color: red !important"',
'></div>',
'',
].join('\n');
expect(lines('index.html', source)).toEqual([3]);
});
});
/**
* Prose that spells a declaration, against code that applies one.
*
* Characters spelling `color: red !important` are not an override — guidance
* telling an executor not to write one spells it too, and failing a run for
* that is the exact fault #5856 fixed. A bare declaration therefore counts only
* where something APPLIES it; a whole braced rule is a stylesheet on its face
* and counts wherever it is written.
*/
describe('a declaration in prose vs a declaration that is applied', () => {
it.each([
{
name: 'a guidance constant naming the flag',
source:
"export const RULE = 'Never write color: red !important in host code';\n",
},
{
name: 'the same guidance in double quotes',
source:
'export const RULE = "reviewers reject color: red !important overrides";\n',
},
{
name: 'a JSDoc block naming the flag',
source:
'/** Never write color: red !important. */\nexport const a = 1;\n',
},
{
name: 'a message bound to a name no style code reads',
source:
"const RULE = 'color: red !important is banned';\nel.style.cssText = approvedStyles;\n",
},
{
name: 'a declaration in a thrown error message',
source:
"throw new Error('do not set color: red !important on the host');\n",
},
])('stays silent for $name', ({source}) => {
expect(lines('guidance.ts', source)).toEqual([]);
});
it.each([
{
name: 'assigned straight to cssText',
source: "el.style.cssText = 'color: red !important';\n",
at: [1],
},
{
name: 'reassembled out of a cloaked string',
source:
"const cloak = '<!-- color: red !important -->';\nel.style.cssText = cloak.slice(4, -3);\n",
at: [1],
},
{
name: 'reassembled through setAttribute',
source:
"const cloak = 'xx color: red !important';\nel.setAttribute('style', cloak.slice(3));\n",
at: [1],
},
{
name: 'reassembled through insertRule',
source:
"const cloak = 'xx .host { color: red !important; }';\nsheet.insertRule(cloak.slice(3));\n",
at: [1],
},
{
name: 'a template applied to cssText',
source: 'const t = `color: ${v} !important`;\nel.style.cssText = t;\n',
at: [1],
},
{
name: 'a whole rule, which is a stylesheet on its face',
source: 'const sheet = `.host { color: red !important; }`;\n',
at: [1],
},
{
name: 'a declaration handed to setProperty',
source: "el.style.setProperty('color', 'red !important');\n",
at: [1],
},
])('catches an override $name', ({source, at}) => {
expect(lines('boot.ts', source)).toEqual(at);
});
it('catches the applied override and not the prose beside it', () => {
const source = [
"export const RULE = 'Never write color: red !important in host code';",
"const cloak = '<!-- color: red !important -->';",
'el.style.cssText = cloak.slice(4, -3);',
'',
].join('\n');
expect(lines('boot.ts', source)).toEqual([2]);
});
});
/**
* The same rule for template literals.
*
* A template is a string like any other: backticks around guidance do not make
* it CSS. The sink/binding evidence a plain literal needs applies here too, and
* a template carrying a whole braced rule is still a stylesheet on its face.
*/
describe('a declaration-shaped template in prose vs applied', () => {
it.each([
{
name: 'a guidance constant in backticks',
source:
'export const RULE = `Never write color: red !important in host code`;\n',
},
{
name: 'guidance bound to a name no style code reads',
source:
'const RULE = `color: red !important is banned`;\nel.style.cssText = approvedStyles;\n',
},
{
name: 'guidance in a thrown error',
source: 'throw new Error(`do not set color: red !important`);\n',
},
])('stays silent for $name', ({source}) => {
expect(lines('guidance.ts', source)).toEqual([]);
});
it.each([
{
name: 'assigned to cssText through a binding',
source: 'const t = `color: red !important`;\nel.style.cssText = t;\n',
at: [1],
},
{
name: 'written inline at cssText, across an interpolation',
source: 'el.style.cssText = `color: ${value} !important`;\n',
at: [1],
},
{
name: 'a cloaked template reassembled into cssText',
source:
'const cloak = `<!-- color: red !important -->`;\nel.style.cssText = cloak.slice(4, -3);\n',
at: [1],
},
{
name: 'a cloaked template handed to insertRule',
source:
'const cloak = `xx .host { color: red !important; }`;\nsheet.insertRule(cloak.slice(3));\n',
at: [1],
},
{
name: 'a cloaked template handed to setAttribute',
source:
"const cloak = `xx color: red !important`;\nel.setAttribute('style', cloak.slice(3));\n",
at: [1],
},
{
name: 'a whole rule, which is a stylesheet on its face',
source: 'const sheet = `.host { color: red !important; }`;\n',
at: [1],
},
{
name: 'a value in a style object',
source: 'const patch = {color: `red !important`};\n',
at: [1],
},
])('catches a template $name', ({source, at}) => {
expect(lines('boot.ts', source)).toEqual(at);
});
it('catches the applied template and not the guidance beside it', () => {
const source = [
'export const RULE = `Never write color: red !important in host code`;',
'const applied = `color: red !important`;',
'el.style.cssText = applied;',
'',
].join('\n');
expect(lines('boot.ts', source)).toEqual([2]);
});
});
/**
* Reachability is keyed on the BINDING, not the name.
*
* Two functions may each declare `value`. Only the one whose `value` a CSS sink
* reads applies anything; reporting the other is the prose false positive all
* over again, and a name-keyed check cannot tell them apart.
*/
describe('sink reachability resolves bindings, not names', () => {
it.each([
{
name: 'sibling functions that each declare the name',
source: [
'function docs() {',
' const value = `Never write color: red !important`;',
' return value;',
'}',
'function apply() {',
' const value = approvedStyles;',
' el.style.cssText = value;',
'}',
'',
].join('\n'),
},
{
name: 'sibling blocks that each declare the name',
source: [
'{',
' const v = `color: red !important is banned`;',
'}',
'{',
' const v = approvedStyles;',
' el.style.cssText = v;',
'}',
'',
].join('\n'),
},
{
name: 'module-scope prose shadowed by a function-scope sink',
source: [
'const v = `never write color: red !important`;',
'function apply() {',
' const v = approvedStyles;',
' el.style.cssText = v;',
'}',
'',
].join('\n'),
},
{
name: 'a parameter shadowing the prose binding',
source: [
'const v = `never write color: red !important`;',
'function apply(v) {',
' el.style.cssText = v;',
'}',
'',
].join('\n'),
},
])(
'stays silent when the sink reads a different binding: $name',
({source}) => {
expect(lines('guidance.ts', source)).toEqual([]);
},
);
it.each([
{
name: 'declared and applied in the same function',
source: [
'function apply() {',
' const value = `color: red !important`;',
' el.style.cssText = value;',
'}',
'',
].join('\n'),
at: [2],
},
{
name: 'declared in a function and applied from a nested block',
source: [
'function apply() {',
' const value = `color: red !important`;',
' if (enabled) {',
' el.style.cssText = value;',
' }',
'}',
'',
].join('\n'),
at: [2],
},
{
name: 'a var hoisted out of the block it was written in',
source: [
'function apply() {',
' if (enabled) {',
' var value = `color: red !important`;',
' }',
' el.style.cssText = value;',
'}',
'',
].join('\n'),
at: [3],
},
{
name: 'assigned to an already-declared binding',
source: [
'let value;',
'value = `color: red !important`;',
'el.style.cssText = value;',
'',
].join('\n'),
at: [2],
},
{
name: 'an inner shadow that does not hide the applied outer binding',
source: [
'const v = `color: red !important`;',
'el.style.cssText = v;',
'function unrelated() {',
' const v = somethingElse;',
' return v;',
'}',
'',
].join('\n'),
at: [1],
},
])('still catches an override $name', ({source, at}) => {
expect(lines('boot.ts', source)).toEqual(at);
});
it('reports only the applied binding when both names are the same', () => {
const source = [
'const v = `never write color: red !important`;',
'function apply() {',
' const v = `color: red !important`;',
' el.style.cssText = v;',
'}',
'',
].join('\n');
expect(lines('boot.ts', source)).toEqual([3]);
});
});
/**
* Parser precision in the sink analysis: which member accesses are sinks, which
* references are uses of the value, and what one redeclared binding means.
*/
describe('sink analysis reads member access precisely', () => {
it.each([
{
name: 'a computed sink property',
source:
"const cloak = 'xx color: red !important';\nel.style['cssText'] = cloak.slice(3);\n",
},
{
name: 'a computed sink written directly',
source: "el.style['cssText'] = 'color: red !important';\n",
},
{
name: 'a value kept in play by trim()',
source:
"const cloak = ' color: red !important ';\nel.style.cssText = cloak.trim();\n",
},
{
name: 'a value kept in play by replace()',
source:
"const cloak = 'XXcolor: red !important';\nel.style.cssText = cloak.replace('XX', '');\n",
},
])('catches $name', ({source}) => {
expect(lines('boot.ts', source)).toEqual([1]);
});
it.each([
{
name: 'a length read that only decides a branch',
source:
"const guidance = 'never write color: red !important';\nel.style.cssText = guidance.length > 0 ? approved : fallback;\n",
},
{
name: 'a property read stored before an unrelated sink',
source:
"const guidance = 'never write color: red !important';\nconst size = guidance.length;\nel.style.cssText = approved;\n",
},
{
name: 'a same-named member of an unrelated object',
source:
"const guidance = 'never write color: red !important';\nel.style.cssText = config.guidance;\n",
},
])('stays silent for $name', ({source}) => {
expect(lines('guidance.ts', source)).toEqual([]);
});
it('treats a redeclared var as one binding, reporting each CSS write', () => {
// Which write reaches the sink is a question of flow, so the binding is
// reported rather than a guessed order — see the file header.
const source = [
'function apply() {',
" var value = 'color: red !important';",
" var value = 'color: blue !important';",
' el.style.cssText = value;',
'}',
'',
].join('\n');
expect(lines('boot.ts', source)).toEqual([2, 3]);
});
it('still separates a redeclared var from an unrelated same name', () => {
const source = [
'function docs() {',
" var value = 'never write color: red !important';",
" var value = 'nor color: blue !important';",
' return value;',
'}',
'function apply() {',
' el.style.cssText = approved;',
'}',
'',
].join('\n');
expect(lines('guidance.ts', source)).toEqual([]);
});
});
/**
* Raw-text elements are `script` and `style` EXACTLY.
*
* `<style-note>` is an ordinary custom element whose content is markup. A
* prefix test reads it as a raw-text opener and then hunts for a `</style>`
* that never arrives, so the rest of the document is swallowed as one element
* body — every attribute, comment and override after it goes unexamined.
*/
describe('custom elements whose names begin with a raw-text tag', () => {
it.each([
{name: 'style-note', markup: '<style-note>see the docs</style-note>'},
{name: 'script-note', markup: '<script-note>see the docs</script-note>'},
{name: 'styled-box', markup: '<styled-box>content</styled-box>'},
])('does not let <$name> swallow the rest of the document', ({markup}) => {
const source = `${markup}\n<div style="color: red !important"></div>\n`;
expect(lines('index.html', source)).toEqual([2]);
});
it('keeps finding real comments after a custom element', () => {
const source = [
'<style-note>see the docs</style-note>',
'<!-- color: red !important is banned -->',
'<div style="color: red !important"></div>',
'',
].join('\n');
// The comment is prose; only the real attribute is an override.
expect(lines('index.html', source)).toEqual([3]);
});
it('still reads a real style or script element', () => {
expect(
lines(
'index.html',
'<style>\n.host { color: red !important; }\n</style>\n',
),
).toEqual([2]);
expect(
lines(
'index.html',
'<style type="text/css">.host { color: red !important; }</style>\n',
),
).toEqual([1]);
});
});