Skip to content

armgit / cra

Public Imported from GitHub
0

The open-source Arc replacement for macOS. Spaces, pinned tabs, split view, Little Windows and Arc's shortcuts on Chromium, with your Arc sidebar imported in one go.

18.4 KB
Raw Blame

Arc parity sweep (Arc 1.172.1, 7 Nov 2026)

A full pass over Arc's menu bar, Settings window, Shortcuts list, right-click menus and Library, compared item by item with Cra on main (8dbd6d1). Arc was an offline copy on a fake home (docs/arc-reverse-engineering.md, "One space"), read through Accessibility and window captures. Arc's source file list (paths left in its binary) was used to find feature modules Cra has no counterpart for.

Status: missing = Cra has nothing; partial = Cra has some of it; done = built in this sweep (commit noted). Items marked skip are left out on purpose (cloud, account, AI partner, or Arc-only service), per CONTRIBUTING.md.

1. Whole features

Arc feature Where in Arc Cra Notes
Boosts (per-site CSS/JS, colours, fonts, Zap) URL bar ✎, Library ▸ Boosts, Settings ▸ Advanced "Enable Boosts" done New Boost (command bar), the editor (wheel, invert, contrast/brightness/saturation, 20 fonts, size, case, Zap, CSS/JS code), Library ▸ Boosts, Settings ▸ Advanced switch. The Code panel's eyedropper (selector picker: outlines the element and the ones like it, then Copy selector for this / for related, Zap all related elements), hammer (Show / Hide Developer Tools) and, for JS, Refresh this Page. The Boost Gallery and sharing are skip (arc.net). The colour wheel's recolouring is CSS filters, not Arc's own engine.
Easels File ▸ New Easel ⌃⇧E, Library ▸ Easels partial File ▸ New Easel (⌃⇧E): canvas, title, Pointer/Image/Text/Ellipse/Rectangle/Arrow/Freehand, pictures by file, paste or drop, saved per easel. Library ▸ Easels and Window ▸ View Easels… done. The canvas shows the window's backdrop under a 50 % veil as in Arc. The toolbar strip above it takes the same veil. The capture menu's New Easel done. The capture menu's Send To… done too. The pill's + and − and Aa (Arc's four looks: bold, serif, wide, mono, in macOS's designs) work, on the title too; Duplicate (the toolbar's eighth button) done; sharing is skip (cloud).
Notes File ▸ New Note ⌃⇧N, ⌃⌥N in split, Help ▸ Export Arc Notes skip Arc 1.172.1 no longer creates Notes: New Note is gone from the File menu and ⌃⇧N does nothing; only Help ▸ Export Arc Notes is left.
Library ▸ Media Window ▸ View Media…, Library rail done Off until Show Media; ⋯ picks the folders (Cra has no captures folder).
Essential Keyboard Shortcuts window Help ▸ Essential Keyboard Shortcuts, Settings ▸ Shortcuts done 475×462 floating dark panel, five rows of key caps, "View All ↗".
Website appearance View ▸ Appearance ▸ Automatic / Light / Dark ("Websites, Easels, and Notes will use:") done Forces prefers-color-scheme for pages.
Stay On Top Window ▸ Stay On Top done Floats the window above other apps.
Save Page As File ▸ Save Page As ⇧⌘S done
Capture Full Page / Portrait Mode File, URL-bar menu done Portrait: 390 × 844 pt at 3x.
Copy URL without trackers Copy URL ⇧⌘C ("Copy the current tab's URL without trackers") done utm_* and click ids dropped (CleanURL).
Copy URL as Quote Edit ▸ ⌃⇧⌘C, "Enable Shared Quotes when highlighting text" done Arc links to arc.net (cloud); Cra copies a text-fragment link.
AppleScript dictionary Arc.sdef, View ▸ Developer ▸ Allow JavaScript from Apple Events done Arc's terms and codes (resources/Cra.sdef); execute javascript only after View ▸ Developer ▸ Allow JavaScript from Apple Events (off by default, as in Arc).
Cast View ▸ Cast done Chrome's Cast bubble (IDC_ROUTE_MEDIA).
Find and Replace, Use Selection to Find, Jump to Selection Edit ▸ Find partial Use Selection to Find and Jump to Selection (⌘J) done; Find and Replace is for Arc's Notes/Easels text, which Cra doesn't have.
Sound effects Settings ▸ Advanced "Play Arc sound effects" done Settings ▸ Advanced ▸ Play Cra sound effects gates the capture shutter.
Theme data for websites Settings ▸ Advanced "Allow websites to get your theme data" done --arc-palette-* and --arc-background-* as #RRGGBBAA, from the space's theme (ArcThemeData; fitted to Arc's stored palette, checked live).
Window dragging from the top of webpages Settings ▸ Advanced done With the toolbar hidden, a drag from the top 56 pt of a page moves the window; a click there still reaches the page (PageTopDrag). Settings ▸ Advanced, on by default as in Arc.
Restore windows from previous session Settings ▸ Advanced done Settings ▸ Advanced; off keeps the window in use last.
Block Cookie Banners Settings ▸ General done Settings ▸ Privacy; hides the common consent managers' banners (CookieBanners), off by default as in Arc.
Archive Little Arcs after Settings ▸ Links (6 hours default) done Settings ▸ Tabs ▸ Links; a Little Window left alone that long closes into the archive.
Previews (Gmail, Calendar on Favorites) Settings ▸ General ▸ Previews Settings…, a Calendar favorite's menu ▸ Live Calendar done Gmail: the unread mail from Gmail's Atom feed (the space's own sign-in) in Arc's card, rows, + and motion, measured on Victor's signed-in Arc 8 Nov. Calendar: Arc's timeline card, gear menu, Live Calendar ▸ submenu, tile countdown and meeting link; events read through Google's Calendar embed (Arc's own fetch says "Failed to update" in 1.172.1). See "Previews, measured".
Join Meeting ⌃⌘J Shortcuts done The call on now, else the next one today, from a Live Calendar favorite.
Troubleshooting menu Help ▸ Troubleshooting: Record Trace, Open Task Manager, Reveal Arc Data, Copy Arc Info done Export Diagnostics…, Open Task Manager (Chrome's), Reveal Cra Data, Copy Cra Info; Record Trace is Arc-internal.
Help menu Getting Started, Release Notes, Contact the Team, Visit Help Center, Restore Data done Cra Help (Arc's Help Center and Getting Started guide), Release Notes, Report an Issue… (Contact the Team), Essential Keyboard Shortcuts, Troubleshooting ▸ Task Manager / Reveal Data / Copy Info. skip: Restore Data and Export Arc Notes (Arc's account and Notes), Record Trace (chrome://tracing is a developer tool).
Ad blocker upsell card, Sync, Account, Membership card, Share Arc, Sign Out, Send to Dia, Share Space skip Account/cloud.
Max: Instant Links, 5-Second Previews, ChatGPT in the Command Bar, New ChatGPT Message ⌥⌘G Settings ▸ Max skip AI partner (cloud). Tidy Tabs/Titles/Downloads already on-device.

2. Menu bar and shortcuts

Arc's actions (Settings ▸ Shortcuts, 106 rows) that Cra has no action for:

Arc action Arc shortcut Cra
Collapse Pinned Tabs (View) — done
Reveal Tab in Sidebar (Tabs) / Reveal Current Tab ⌃Space done
Reset all tabs in this Space (Tabs) — done
View Archive… / Clear Archive (Archive menu) — done
Collapse All Folders / Expand All Folders — done
Next Tab / Previous Tab, second binding ⌘} / ⌘{ done
Go Back / Go Forward, second binding ⌘← / ⌘→ done
Developer Tools, second binding F12 done
Go to last Sidebar Item ⌘9 done
Switch to Split View 1–4 ⌃⇧1…4 done
Expand Current Split — missing (Cra has Flip orientation)
Open Extensions ⌘E done
Show Little Arc "Open In" Menu ⇧⌘O done
Open Little Arc or Peek in… ⌘O partial (Window menu)
Network Inspector — skip (DevTools has it)
Exit ⎋ n/a

Naming differences (Cra → Arc): "Close Tab" → "Archive Tab" for ⌘W in Shortcuts; "Go to Space N" → the space's name ("Victor ⌃1"); "Hide Sidebar" → "Show/Hide Sidebar" in Shortcuts; Spaces menu "Edit Space…" → "Edit Theme…" and "Rename Space"; Tabs menu "New Folder" → "New Folder…"; File gains "New Profile".

3. Right-click menus

Where Arc items Cra lacks
Today tab all done (Share ▸, Change Icon…, Open in Split View, Archive Tabs Below)
Pinned tab Edit Pinned Page ▸ (Cra lists them flat on purpose, PR #55), Remove Pin (Share ▸, Change Icon… and Add Split View done)
Space header / empty sidebar Share Space… (skip), New Folder, Manage Spaces…, Delete Space (check order)
Toolbar address Share ▸ (in the Site Control Center), Disable Shared Quotes (arc.net); the rest done
Library button Show media ▸ Documents, Desktop, Screenshots, Arc Captures, Downloads

4. Settings

Arc tab Rows Cra lacks
General (Previews: Gmail done, Tabs pane; Live Calendar in the Calendar favorite's menu, as in Arc; Block Cookie Banners done, under Privacy)
Profiles "New documents" app (Arc's Notes/Easels); Privacy, Passwords, Credit Cards and Notifications done
Links "Open Little Arc when clicking on links with ⌥⌘ held"; Archive Little Windows after done
Advanced Shared Quotes (arc.net) (the rest done)
Icon Cra has its own icon picker

5. Animations and styling

  • Command bar (⌘T / File ▸ New Tab…), 7 Nov 2026, 57 fps region recordings of both apps: Arc's bar is there complete from one frame to the next, no fade or scale; Cra's too. Matches.

  • Boost editor, 7 Nov 2026, 60 fps recordings of both apps (BoostEditorMotion): Arc draws the panel at 85 % on its first frame and grows it to full size in 0.28 s about the middle of its right edge, no fade; it closes from one frame to the next. Code widens it 183 → 480 pt in 0.35 s with the 480 pt layout centred and clipped on both sides meanwhile; Back narrows it in 0.13 s. Ease-out throughout. Cra matches after this sweep (it had no opening animation and resized with AppKit's default). Arc's code header is only Back and a centred CSS / JS switch; Cra had the boost's name and Undo there too.

  • Sidebar ⌘S, 8 Nov 2026, screencapture -V at 60 fps, four Arc runs and two of Cra each way (SidebarMotion): Arc's page edge covers about 43 / 72 / 89 / 97 % of its travel after frames 1–4 hiding and 30 / 69 / 89 / 97 % showing, done in 5 frames. Cra ran ahead (67 / 87 / 96 / 99 %, fitted to an ffmpeg recording that had dropped Arc's first frames); now 0.085 s on (0.3, 0.7, 0.5, 1), measured 23–48 / 60 / 83–85 / 96–98 % hiding and 30–47 / 65–76 / 86–92 / 96–98 % showing. ffmpeg's avfoundation capture misses window moves; screencapture -V doesn't.

  • Previews cards, 8 Nov 2026: see "Previews, measured".

Not re-measured in this sweep: earlier sessions measured the command bar, split view, Peek, Little Arc, PiP, folders, space dock, Library swipe, dialogs, toasts and toolbar against Arc (docs/arc-reverse-engineering.md). New surfaces built from this list are matched to captures taken in this sweep (Essential Shortcuts window, Library pages).

Built in this sweep

  • Window ▸ Stay On Top; File ▸ Capture Full Page and Save Page As (⇧⌘S, single file or HTML only); Edit ▸ Copy URL as Quote (⌃⇧⌘C, a text-fragment link instead of Arc's arc.net card).
  • Copy URL, Copy URL as Markdown and the sidebar's Copy Link leave out utm_* and click ids (CleanURL).
  • View ▸ Collapse/Expand Pinned Tabs; View ▸ Appearance (Automatic / Light / Dark for websites).
  • Tabs ▸ Reveal Tab in Sidebar (⌃Space) and Reset all tabs in this Space; Archive ▸ View Archive… and Clear Archive; Collapse All Folders / Expand All Folders; Open Extensions (⌘E); Switch to Split View 1–4 (⌃⇧1…4); Next/Previous Tab on ⌘} / ⌘{ too; Developer Tools on F12 too; ⌘9 = last tab.
  • Today tab menu: Archive Tabs Below.
  • Help ▸ Essential Keyboard Shortcuts (Arc's card, checked side by side at 2x); Help ▸ Troubleshooting with Export Diagnostics…, Reveal Cra Data, Copy Cra Info.
  • Settings ▸ Advanced ▸ Play Cra sound effects.
  • Library ▸ Media and Window ▸ View Media…; File ▸ Capture in Portrait Mode; the toolbar address menu's Capture…, Capture Full Page, Manage Extensions… and Hide Toolbar.
  • Settings ▸ Tabs ▸ Archive Little Windows after (1 hour, 6 hours, 12 hours); Settings ▸ Profiles ▸ Your Data and Settings (Chromium's privacy, passwords, cards and notifications pages per profile).
  • Sidebar tab menu: Add Split View on the open tab, Open in Split View on any other.
  • View ▸ Cast… and Help ▸ Troubleshooting ▸ Open Task Manager, Chrome's own (ExecuteChromeCommand).
  • Sidebar tab menu: Change Icon… and Share ▸.
  • Settings ▸ Advanced ▸ "When opening Cra, restore windows from previous session".
  • Show Little Window "Open In" Menu (⇧⌘O): the Little Window's list of spaces.
  • Settings ▸ Advanced ▸ "Allow websites to get your theme data": Arc's --arc-palette-* variables, measured live in Arc (names, #RRGGBBAA format, no trace in the page's markup) and fitted to the semantic palette Arc stores per space.
  • Edit ▸ Find ▸ Use Selection to Find and Jump to Selection (⌘J).
  • Previews for a Gmail favorite: unread mail in Arc's card on hover (Settings ▸ Tabs); 8 Nov: Arc's full card (sender, age, subject, two lines, scrolling past 270 pt, + for a new mail, rows open the mail) and its motion.
  • Live Calendar on a Google Calendar favorite (8 Nov, Victor's choice: a working version, as Arc's no longer reads): today's timeline on hover, the gear's Last fetch / Refresh / Disable Live Calendar, the favorite's Live Calendar ▸ submenu (Show Hover Preview, Show Time to Next Meeting, Show Next Meeting Link ▸ Never … Ten Minutes Before), the tile's countdown, a Join card from two minutes before a call, and Join Meeting ⌃⌘J.
  • Boosts: New Boost, the editor, Zap, CSS/JS code, Library ▸ Boosts, Window ▸ View Boosts…, the Advanced switch.
  • Window dragging from the top of webpages (Victor's choice, 7 Nov: on, as in Arc).
  • AppleScript, Arc's dictionary (Victor's choice, 7 Nov: like Arc, JavaScript off by default).
  • Settings ▸ Privacy ▸ Block cookie banners (Arc's "Block Cookie Banners", off by default).
  • Easels, first version: File ▸ New Easel (⌃⇧E) opens a canvas in the tab (EaselBrowser, a page engine of its own like WebKitBrowser, so sidebar.json is unchanged: the tab's address is easel://, the drawing Easels/.json); Library ▸ Easels and Window ▸ View Easels….

Easels, measured (Arc 1.172.1, offline copy, 7 Nov 2026)

  • File ▸ New Easel (⌃⇧E) adds an "Untitled Easel" row to Today (AX EaselCellView, an easel glyph) and opens it in the page area; the toolbar's address shows its name.
  • The page area is a native canvas (easelCanvasView), as wide as the page and 2436 pt tall, scrolling. A title text box 894 pt wide sits centred 52 pt below the top, selected on creation (blue outline with round corner handles), "Untitled Easel" in bold white about 22 pt; beside it a black pill with +, Aa and − (text size).
  • Bottom left, 16 pt in: a toolbar of 36 pt buttons 38 pt apart on #100D00 (the palette's dark backgroundExtra): Pointer, Image, Text, Ellipse, Rectangle, Arrow, Freehand, then captures. The picked tool sits on #716328 with 8 pt corners; glyphs in #FAEEC2 (foregroundPrimary). Bottom right: a 36 pt share button (person.badge.plus), cloud sharing in Arc.

Boosts, measured (Arc 1.172.1, Victor's Arc, 7 Nov 2026)

  • The command bar's "New Boost" opens the editor for the open site: a 183 × 588 pt floating panel 10 pt in from the window's right edge and 215 pt down (AX boostsEditor). Header 40 pt: Done (grey ✕), "My Boost ⌄" (Rename this Boost…, Shuffle, Reset all Edits, Delete this Boost, All Boosts…), Undo. A 147 pt colour wheel in a brushed grey frame with two handles; Invert lightness, Advanced color controls (a popover: Contrast, Brightness, Original Saturation sliders) and Reset to original colors, 42 × 38 each; a white card of 20 "Aa" fonts (5 × 4, 26 pt cells); Size and Case (69 × 38); Zap ⚡ and Code {} (147 × 38). Code widens the panel to 480 pt: Back, a CSS / JS switch, a dark editor (479 pt; in 1.172.1 an arc:// page that only says "Internal debugging pages are currently disabled"), and a 69 pt strip with 38 pt tools 15 pt in. From Arc's binary: the eyedropper is "Show / Hide Selector Picker" (ARC_BoostsEditor.bundle's SelectorPicker.js ranks selectors for the element under the pointer; after a click, "Copy selector for this", "Copy selector for related", "Zap all related elements"), the hammer "Show / Hide Developer Tools", and an arrow.clockwise "Refresh this Page" (Cra shows it for JS, which runs on load). Delete asks "Delete this Boost?" in Arc's dialog. Reference captures: docs/screenshots/arc-boost-*.png.

Previews, measured (Arc 1.172.1, Victor's signed-in Arc, 8 Nov 2026)

  • Hovering a favorite that isn't the open tab shows the card about 0.25 s after the tile lights up (once the content is in hand; the first Gmail fetch took ~0.85 s); it grows from about 80 % and fades in over some 4 frames at 60 fps (opacity .21/.47/.76/.95/1). The pointer can move onto the card; once it has left tile and card, the card waits ~0.17 s and fades out, shrinking a little, over ~4 frames. Cra measured the same way: 0.28 s, .14/.29/.82/.97/1, 0.15 s (CraCore FavoritePreviewMotion).
  • Gmail: 238 pt wide, at most 270 pt (the fourth row peeks), rows 84 pt with 1 pt lines, 11 pt insets; sender semibold 13 and its age ("50s", "1m", "3h"), subject 13, two grey lines 12; the pointer's row a lighter card 3 pt in; a 32 pt + 9.5 pt from the bottom right. The card refreshes in place when mail arrives.
  • Calendar: 238 × 255 pt, an hour 42 pt with "8 AM" (English, whatever the Mac's clock) at the top left, the current hour's line 13 pt under the top, a cream now line with a dot from 42 pt in, a filled gear and a + at the bottom right. Gear: "Last fetch: Just now" (dimmed), Refresh, Disable Live Calendar. The favorite's menu starts with Live Calendar ▸: status, Refresh, ✓Show Hover Preview, ✓Show Time to Next Meeting, Show Next Meeting Link ▸ Never / On Start / ✓Two Minutes Before / Five / Ten. Arc's LiveCalendarClient (a hidden browser) says "Failed to update" for a calendar with events, so its event blocks, countdown and meeting link couldn't be seen: Cra's are its own, in the card's style. Cra reads the primary calendar the way Google's Calendar embed does (a hidden calendar/u/<n>/embed page asks the Calendar API through the page's own signed-in client), every 5 minutes and on hover when older than a minute.

Left for later, and why