Skip to content

Python tool for aircraft Doppler audio geolocation using historical ADS-B flight data (Source-available)

Record indoor scanner review follow-up (#3)

Cinna Davis2203b5d3ef43
diff --git a/benchmarks/youtube-expanded-scan-20261103.csv b/benchmarks/youtube-expanded-scan-20261103.csv
index 6064ac5..3a6b8bd 100644
--- a/benchmarks/youtube-expanded-scan-20261103.csv
+++ b/benchmarks/youtube-expanded-scan-20261103.csv
@@ -151,7 +151,7 @@ UZ_RrLxMrEg,https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UZ_RrLxMrEg,CONSTRUCTION SITE SOUND
V5mSVhz3Ry8,https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=V5mSVhz3Ry8,Spotting at LAX - In-N-Out on Sepulveda,site_named_aircraft,scanned,no_proposals,0,180.0135,0e87537b6d91815d91d170a6a514183f5ebfa7a3dfa46d0fc71f3b78fe010eeb,1,dopplergeist-w5-youtube-survey-20261103,scanned,
V9bgJTzGdTI,https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=V9bgJTzGdTI,I Tried Crossing the Atlantic on Tiny Propeller Planes,aircraft_targeted,scanned,proposals,9,180.0135,26b7f4129c445d66df889a234b1df3250dc7dda9b0090c28a5cffb4d87f005c9,2,dopplergeist-audio-corpus-20261103|dopplergeist-audio-corpus-retry-20261103,download_failed|scanned,ambiguous
VWdRetL4rpI,https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VWdRetL4rpI,Airplane Fly Over Landing At Runway Sounds,aircraft_targeted,scanned,proposals,8,180.0135,17ab08b9718d7aa6fb2a379f639ac081ad9e32a7cec73963095d4db3e760b743,1,dopplergeist-audio-corpus-20261103,scanned,ambiguous
-Vg1mpD1BICI,https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Vg1mpD1BICI,Open Window New York City Soundscape at Night (Midtown Manhattan City Sounds) 4k,indoor,scanned,proposals,1,180.0135,0660aabba5d783fdfefb4989e10523ea15872d5bc682d56eefb97030361d586b,1,dopplergeist-youtube-unified-retry-20261103,scanned,ambiguous
+Vg1mpD1BICI,https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Vg1mpD1BICI,Open Window New York City Soundscape at Night (Midtown Manhattan City Sounds) 4k,indoor,scanned,proposals,1,180.0135,0660aabba5d783fdfefb4989e10523ea15872d5bc682d56eefb97030361d586b,1,dopplergeist-youtube-unified-retry-20261103,scanned,ambiguous|ambiguous
VrO4s47Pd6s,https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VrO4s47Pd6s,"1-HOUR STUDY WITH ME in New York | study with sunset, no music, real sounds, study asmr [with timer]",indoor,scanned,no_proposals,0,180.0135,769a0b820b12f69feaecf0f6efbf88e6505b5fcc44d065197dde1e7dc4b45d26,2,dopplergeist-audio-corpus-20261103|dopplergeist-youtube-retry-20261103,download_failed|scanned,
WTu0StC2CjE,https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WTu0StC2CjE,Walking in the Rain to Lake Union in Downtown Seattle 4K Binaural Audio,outdoor_walk,scanned,no_proposals,0,180.0135,0e4e008ab39504f34aa0381f174f6618fc7cf997a5d6459483964d6389b270a8,2,dopplergeist-audio-corpus-20261103|dopplergeist-audio-corpus-retry-20261103,download_failed|scanned,
WpJP2qHeE94,https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WpJP2qHeE94,4K Virtual Walking Tour | Nature's sound | Boston View | Relaxing Walk,outdoor_walk,scanned,no_proposals,0|0,180.0135|180.0135,db9023cc880050c02bd603f4c08408a230d474cdff386b36c9365b2e2b99bc18|db9023cc880050c02bd603f4c08408a230d474cdff386b36c9365b2e2b99bc18,3,dopplergeist-audio-corpus-20261103|dopplergeist-youtube-retry-20261103|dopplergeist-audio-corpus-retry-20261103,download_failed|scanned|scanned,
diff --git a/benchmarks/youtube-expanded-scan-20261103.md b/benchmarks/youtube-expanded-scan-20261103.md
index 9080f6a..c732746 100644
--- a/benchmarks/youtube-expanded-scan-20261103.md
+++ b/benchmarks/youtube-expanded-scan-20261103.md
@@ -25,12 +25,16 @@ All 47 proposal-bearing videos received a quick single-reviewer spectrogram
inspection: five were labeled plausible Doppler-like, five plausible but with
visible changes or repetition consistent with edits or reused audio, and 37
ambiguous. These labels do not confirm aircraft identity or event independence.
-The [remaining 26 case notes](youtube-expanded-visual-review-20261103.csv)
-record individual reasons from 0–1000 Hz contact sheets; the previous 21 reviews are retained in the case
-table and local review receipts. None of the three proposals from indoor
-searches has an established indoor aircraft source; all three were visually
-ambiguous. These results do not show whether indoor recording, a phone, or poor
-audio quality succeeds or fails.
+The [visual-review notes](youtube-expanded-visual-review-20261103.csv) now
+contain 27 entries, including one follow-up on an indoor clip; earlier review
+receipts remain in the case table and local storage. None of the three proposals
+from indoor searches has an established indoor aircraft source; all three were
+visually ambiguous. A closer review of the Midtown Manhattan open-window scan
+([Vg1mpD1BICI](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Vg1mpD1BICI)) found one scanner
+ridge descending from 110.8 to 94.3 Hz over 64–77 s, alongside a persistent
+band near 100 Hz and no clearly co-moving harmonic family. It remains ambiguous;
+urban tonal sources are plausible. These results do not show whether indoor
+recording, a phone, or poor audio quality succeeds or fails.
The ten plausible leads in the first review came from aircraft-targeted or
site-named queries. A focused re-review adds one candidate from the outdoor-walk
diff --git a/benchmarks/youtube-expanded-visual-review-20261103.csv b/benchmarks/youtube-expanded-visual-review-20261103.csv
index 90b2ebc..4cb7a10 100644
--- a/benchmarks/youtube-expanded-visual-review-20261103.csv
+++ b/benchmarks/youtube-expanded-visual-review-20261103.csv
@@ -9,6 +9,7 @@ NphNZg6A32E,candidate_doppler_like_edited,Descending bands around 75–90 s; abr
Odi-wWuIW9Q,ambiguous,Short low-frequency trace amid wind/transient noise; source unclear.,sheet-02.png
QGOrWlx0HX0,ambiguous,Abrupt silent gap and faint near-horizontal traces; moving recorder and source unclear.,sheet-03.png
V9bgJTzGdTI,ambiguous,Speech and abrupt transitions; aircraft and recorder motion not established.,sheet-03.png
+Vg1mpD1BICI,ambiguous,"Follow-up: the single scanner ridge falls 110.8->94.3 Hz over 64-77 s, but a persistent ~100 Hz band and no clearly co-moving harmonic family keep the proposal ambiguous.",local follow-up spectrogram
VWdRetL4rpI,ambiguous,Strong repeated similar features suggest a reused sound effect; independent passes unverified.,sheet-03.png
XQiArX10mJo,ambiguous,Faint low-frequency trace amid rain and street noise; source unclear.,sheet-03.png
XWP9tkBS1nk,candidate_doppler_like,Prominent descending multi-band feature near 100–120 s in aircraft-labeled source; identity unverified.,sheet-04.png