Skip to content

Ears for coding agents: let AI hear, review and make sound. CPU-only, open source.

11.3 KB
Raw Blame
{
 "base": {
  "what": "control: the real Clawd soundtrack untouched",
  "models": false,
  "picture": false,
  "expect": [],
  "caught": [],
  "verdict": "close",
  "partial": [
   "realness",
   "music presence"
  ],
  "score": 0.871,
  "critical": 0,
  "major": 2,
  "flagged": [
   "crest_lu high (major)",
   "first_sound_s high (major)"
  ],
  "first_action": "nothing reaches body level until 0:01.01 (before that the sound sits around -42 LUFS, 27 LU under the body; refs 0.04 s .. 0.48 s): raise the opening or start the music at 0:00",
  "p_real": null,
  "seconds": 27.5
 },
 "quiet": {
  "what": "unmastered: 12 dB quieter",
  "models": false,
  "picture": false,
  "expect": [
   "lufs_i"
  ],
  "caught": [
   "lufs_i"
  ],
  "verdict": "needs work",
  "partial": [
   "realness",
   "music presence"
  ],
  "score": 0.774,
  "critical": 1,
  "major": 2,
  "flagged": [
   "lufs_i low (critical)",
   "crest_lu high (major)",
   "first_sound_s high (major)"
  ],
  "first_action": "raise the master by +13.0 dB to about -14 LUFS integrated (web) with a true-peak limiter (ceiling -1 dBTP); if the limiter works harder than ~3 dB, compress the music bus first (refs -22.2 LUFS .. -7.3 LUFS)",
  "p_real": null,
  "seconds": 9.0
 },
 "hot": {
  "what": "12 dB hotter, clipped by the 16-bit file",
  "models": false,
  "picture": false,
  "expect": [
   "lufs_i",
   "true_peak"
  ],
  "caught": [
   "lufs_i",
   "true_peak"
  ],
  "verdict": "needs work",
  "partial": [
   "realness",
   "music presence"
  ],
  "score": 0.774,
  "critical": 1,
  "major": 2,
  "flagged": [
   "lufs_i high (critical)",
   "true_peak high (major)",
   "first_sound_s high (major)"
  ],
  "first_action": "turn the master down by 7.8 dB to about -12 LUFS: above -9 LUFS normalising platforms turn it down anyway and the limiter flattens every hit (refs -22.2 LUFS .. -7.3 LUFS)",
  "p_real": null,
  "seconds": 8.8
 },
 "mono": {
  "what": "folded to mono",
  "models": false,
  "picture": false,
  "expect": [
   "side_to_mid_db"
  ],
  "caught": [
   "side_to_mid_db"
  ],
  "verdict": "close",
  "partial": [
   "realness",
   "music presence"
  ],
  "score": 0.767,
  "critical": 0,
  "major": 3,
  "flagged": [
   "lufs_i low (major)",
   "crest_lu high (major)",
   "first_sound_s high (major)",
   "side_to_mid_db low (minor)"
  ],
  "first_action": "nothing reaches body level until 0:01.01 (before that the sound sits around -43 LUFS, 26 LU under the body; refs 0.04 s .. 0.48 s): raise the opening or start the music at 0:00",
  "p_real": null,
  "seconds": 9.5
 },
 "muffled": {
  "what": "low-passed at 3 kHz (12 dB/oct)",
  "models": false,
  "picture": false,
  "expect": [
   "band_presence",
   "band_air"
  ],
  "caught": [
   "band_presence",
   "band_air"
  ],
  "verdict": "close",
  "partial": [
   "realness",
   "music presence"
  ],
  "score": 0.806,
  "critical": 0,
  "major": 2,
  "flagged": [
   "crest_lu high (major)",
   "first_sound_s high (major)",
   "band_presence low (minor)",
   "band_air low (minor)"
  ],
  "first_action": "nothing reaches body level until 0:00.94 (before that the sound sits around -44 LUFS, 29 LU under the body; refs 0.04 s .. 0.48 s): raise the opening or start the music at 0:00",
  "p_real": null,
  "seconds": 10.0
 },
 "late": {
  "what": "2.5 s of silence before the start",
  "models": false,
  "picture": false,
  "expect": [
   "first_sound_s"
  ],
  "caught": [
   "first_sound_s"
  ],
  "verdict": "close",
  "partial": [
   "realness",
   "music presence"
  ],
  "score": 0.806,
  "critical": 0,
  "major": 3,
  "flagged": [
   "crest_lu high (major)",
   "first_sound_s high (major)",
   "onset_rate low (major)"
  ],
  "first_action": "nothing reaches body level until 0:03.51 (before that the sound sits around -46 LUFS, 32 LU under the body; refs 0.04 s .. 0.48 s): raise the opening or start the music at 0:00",
  "p_real": null,
  "seconds": 13.8
 },
 "deadair": {
  "what": "4 s of silence after the end",
  "models": false,
  "picture": false,
  "expect": [
   "end_silence_s"
  ],
  "caught": [
   "end_silence_s"
  ],
  "verdict": "close",
  "partial": [
   "realness",
   "music presence"
  ],
  "score": 0.806,
  "critical": 0,
  "major": 3,
  "flagged": [
   "crest_lu high (major)",
   "first_sound_s high (major)",
   "end_silence_s high (major)"
  ],
  "first_action": "4.1 s of dead air after the sound ends at 0:59.93: trim the picture or let the final sting ring out over the end card (refs 0.02 s .. 1.90 s)",
  "p_real": null,
  "seconds": 14.4
 },
 "fadeout": {
  "what": "12 s fade-out",
  "models": false,
  "picture": false,
  "expect": [
   "fade_s",
   "final_lu",
   "end_lu"
  ],
  "caught": [
   "fade_s",
   "final_lu"
  ],
  "verdict": "close",
  "partial": [
   "realness",
   "music presence"
  ],
  "score": 0.774,
  "critical": 0,
  "major": 3,
  "flagged": [
   "crest_lu high (major)",
   "first_sound_s high (major)",
   "final_lu low (major)",
   "fade_s high (minor)"
  ],
  "first_action": "the final moment sits 11.9 LU below the body: end on a logo sting / hit instead of fading away (refs -2.2 LU .. 5.6 LU)",
  "p_real": null,
  "seconds": 12.6
 },
 "hole": {
  "what": "2.5 s muted mid-film",
  "models": false,
  "picture": false,
  "expect": [
   "max_gap_s"
  ],
  "caught": [
   "max_gap_s"
  ],
  "verdict": "needs work",
  "partial": [
   "realness",
   "music presence"
  ],
  "score": 0.742,
  "critical": 0,
  "major": 4,
  "flagged": [
   "crest_lu high (major)",
   "first_sound_s high (major)",
   "max_gap_s high (major)",
   "onset_rate low (major)"
  ],
  "first_action": "nothing reaches body level until 0:01.01 (before that the sound sits around -42 LUFS, 27 LU under the body; refs 0.04 s .. 0.48 s): raise the opening or start the music at 0:00",
  "p_real": null,
  "seconds": 13.2
 },
 "squashed": {
  "what": "over-compressed: 20:1 from -36 dB + limiter",
  "models": false,
  "picture": false,
  "expect": [
   "lra",
   "crest_lu"
  ],
  "caught": [],
  "verdict": "launch-grade",
  "partial": [
   "realness",
   "music presence"
  ],
  "score": 0.903,
  "critical": 0,
  "major": 1,
  "flagged": [
   "true_peak high (major)",
   "side_to_mid_db high (minor)"
  ],
  "first_action": "true peak +0.3 dBTP: end the master chain with a true-peak limiter, ceiling -1.0 dBTP, then re-encode",
  "p_real": null,
  "seconds": 14.6
 },
 "sfx_only": {
  "what": "the SFX stem alone, with the picture",
  "models": true,
  "picture": true,
  "expect": [
   "music_frac"
  ],
  "caught": [
   "music_frac"
  ],
  "verdict": "needs work",
  "partial": [],
  "score": 0.769,
  "critical": 2,
  "major": 0,
  "flagged": [
   "lufs_i low (critical)",
   "music_frac low (critical)",
   "band_sub low (minor)",
   "band_low low (minor)",
   "band_mid high (minor)"
  ],
  "first_action": "raise the master by +13.6 dB to about -14 LUFS integrated (web) with a true-peak limiter (ceiling -1 dBTP); if the limiter works harder than ~3 dB, compress the music bus first (refs -22.2 LUFS .. -7.3 LUFS)",
  "p_real": 0.787,
  "seconds": 194.8
 },
 "amb_only": {
  "what": "the ambience stem alone",
  "models": true,
  "picture": false,
  "expect": [
   "music_frac",
   "onset_rate",
   "hit_rate"
  ],
  "caught": [
   "music_frac"
  ],
  "verdict": "needs work",
  "partial": [],
  "score": 0.676,
  "critical": 2,
  "major": 1,
  "flagged": [
   "lufs_i low (critical)",
   "music_frac low (critical)",
   "crest_lu high (major)",
   "band_sub low (minor)",
   "band_low low (minor)",
   "band_mid high (minor)",
   "band_presence high (minor)"
  ],
  "first_action": "raise the master by +25.5 dB to about -14 LUFS integrated (web) with a true-peak limiter (ceiling -1 dBTP); if the limiter works harder than ~3 dB, compress the music bus first (refs -22.2 LUFS .. -7.3 LUFS)",
  "p_real": 0.882,
  "seconds": 90.6
 },
 "synth_bed": {
  "what": "the retired code-synthesized music bed",
  "models": true,
  "picture": false,
  "expect": [
   "p_real"
  ],
  "caught": [
   "p_real"
  ],
  "verdict": "not launch-grade",
  "partial": [],
  "score": 0.486,
  "critical": 3,
  "major": 3,
  "flagged": [
   "lufs_i low (critical)",
   "p_real low (critical)",
   "music_frac low (critical)",
   "crest_lu high (major)",
   "first_sound_s high (major)",
   "onset_rate low (major)",
   "band_sub low (minor)",
   "band_low low (minor)",
   "band_mid high (minor)",
   "side_to_mid_db high (minor)"
  ],
  "first_action": "realness: likely code-synthesized (p_real 0.10, at or below the model's 0.40 threshold); 4 s windows at or below the window threshold 0.17 (code-synthesized): 0:08.00-0:12.00 (0.01), 0:12.00-0:16.00 (0.03), 0:16.00-0:20.00 (0.01), 0:28.00-0:32.00 (0.04), 0:52.00-0:56.00 (0.02), 0:56.00-1:00.00 (0.02) (+6 more): replace oscillator / noise layers with real recordings and produced music (skills/real-sound has the sourcing and licence workflow); judge each stem with `earshot realness stem.wav` (a finished mix is harder to judge than its sources)",
  "p_real": 0.095,
  "seconds": 43.7
 },
 "sine": {
  "what": "30 s 440 Hz sine",
  "models": true,
  "picture": false,
  "expect": [
   "p_real",
   "music_frac",
   "onset_rate"
  ],
  "caught": [
   "p_real",
   "music_frac",
   "onset_rate"
  ],
  "verdict": "not launch-grade",
  "partial": [],
  "score": 0.351,
  "critical": 3,
  "major": 4,
  "flagged": [
   "lufs_i low (critical)",
   "p_real low (critical)",
   "music_frac low (critical)",
   "lra low (major)",
   "crest_lu low (major)",
   "onset_rate low (major)",
   "hit_rate low (major)",
   "band_sub low (minor)",
   "band_low low (minor)",
   "band_lowmid high (minor)",
   "band_mid low (minor)",
   "band_presence low (minor)",
   "band_air low (minor)",
   "side_to_mid_db low (minor)"
  ],
  "first_action": "realness: likely code-synthesized (p_real 0.03, at or below the model's 0.40 threshold); 4 s windows at or below the window threshold 0.17 (code-synthesized): 0:00.00-0:04.00 (0.03), 0:04.00-0:08.00 (0.03), 0:08.00-0:12.00 (0.03), 0:12.00-0:16.00 (0.03), 0:16.00-0:20.00 (0.03), 0:20.00-0:24.00 (0.03) (+2 more): replace oscillator / noise layers with real recordings and produced music (skills/real-sound has the sourcing and licence workflow); judge each stem with `earshot realness stem.wav` (a finished mix is harder to judge than its sources)",
  "p_real": 0.03,
  "seconds": 47.5
 },
 "pink": {
  "what": "30 s pink noise",
  "models": true,
  "picture": false,
  "expect": [
   "p_real",
   "music_frac",
   "onset_rate"
  ],
  "caught": [
   "p_real",
   "music_frac",
   "onset_rate"
  ],
  "verdict": "not launch-grade",
  "partial": [],
  "score": 0.459,
  "critical": 3,
  "major": 4,
  "flagged": [
   "lufs_i low (critical)",
   "p_real low (critical)",
   "music_frac low (critical)",
   "lra low (major)",
   "crest_lu low (major)",
   "onset_rate low (major)",
   "hit_rate low (major)",
   "band_mid high (minor)",
   "band_presence high (minor)",
   "side_to_mid_db low (minor)"
  ],
  "first_action": "realness: likely code-synthesized (p_real 0.16, at or below the model's 0.40 threshold); 4 s windows at or below the window threshold 0.17 (code-synthesized): 0:00.00-0:04.00 (0.12), 0:08.00-0:12.00 (0.16), 0:12.00-0:16.00 (0.15), 0:20.00-0:24.00 (0.17), 0:24.00-0:28.00 (0.11), 0:26.00-0:30.00 (0.15): replace oscillator / noise layers with real recordings and produced music (skills/real-sound has the sourcing and licence workflow); judge each stem with `earshot realness stem.wav` (a finished mix is harder to judge than its sources)",
  "p_real": 0.158,
  "seconds": 22.7
 }
}