Fara1.5 – A family of frontier computer use agent models
Add example_trajectory + expand webeval trajectory-format docs
corby7ea1e441c495
diff --git a/README.md b/README.mdindex 2fef204..87db8e9 100644--- a/README.md+++ b/README.md@@ -23,9 +23,8 @@Fara-7B Online-Mind2Web/Browserbase trajectories, ~2 reviewers each) and`internal` (154 trajectories from a heldout aurora-v2 task suite) —with per-judge UV-blind / UV-informed labels, Universal Verifier- outputs, and legacy verifier outputs side-by-side. See the new- [`cuaverifierbench/`](cuaverifierbench/) directory in this repo for- the build script.+ outputs, and legacy verifier outputs side-by-side. The build script+ that produced the dataset lives alongside the data on HuggingFace.* **2026-04-18** — Removed the `autogen-core` / `autogen-ext` dependencyfrom `webeval`; chat completion clients are now self-contained under`webeval/src/webeval/oai_clients/`. No more autogen submodule install@@ -195,7 +194,7 @@ Two splits ship today:| `fara7b_om2w_browserbase` | Fara-7B trajectories on Online-Mind2Web tasks executed via Browserbase | 106 | 215 (≈2 reviewers/task; UV-blind **and** UV-informed stages) || `internal` | Heldout aurora-v2 task suite scored with the same WebSurfer + verifier stack | 154 | 154 (1 reviewer/task; UV-blind only) |-Reviewer identities are anonymized as `Judge1` … `JudgeN` using a single shared map across both splits. The build script that produced the dataset (with full schema + provenance) lives at [`cuaverifierbench/build_dataset.py`](cuaverifierbench/build_dataset.py); see the [dataset README](https://huggingface.co/datasets/microsoft/CUAVerifierBench/blob/main/README.md) for the full column list.+Reviewer identities are anonymized as `Judge1` … `JudgeN` using a single shared map across both splits. The build script that produced the dataset (with full schema + provenance) ships alongside the data on HuggingFace at [`microsoft/CUAVerifierBench`](https://huggingface.co/datasets/microsoft/CUAVerifierBench); see the [dataset README](https://huggingface.co/datasets/microsoft/CUAVerifierBench/blob/main/README.md) for the full column list.```pythonfrom datasets import load_dataset@@ -413,7 +412,7 @@ export BROWSERBASE_PROJECT_ID=<your_browserbase_project_id># (rubric_is_success := rubric_score >= --rubric_score_threshold; a more# lenient gate, expect slightly higher numbers), or ``both``.python webtailbench.py \- --model_url /data/data/Fara/model_checkpoints \+ --model_url /path/to/Fara/model_checkpoints \--model_port 5000 \--device_id 0,1 \--eval_oai_config ../../endpoint_configs/judge_active/prod \@@ -421,24 +420,15 @@ python webtailbench.py \--judge_o4_eval_model o4-mini \--rubric_score_threshold 0.8 \--success outcome \- --out_url /data/data/Fara/eval \+ --out_url /path/to/Fara/eval \--processes 4 \--run_id 1 \--max_rounds 100 \--browserbase-python webtailbench.py \- --model_url /data/data/Fara/model_checkpoints \- --eval_oai_config ../../endpoint_configs/judge_active/prod \- --judge_eval_model gpt-5.2 --judge_o4_eval_model o4-mini \- --out_url /data/data/Fara/eval \- --split flights --subsample 0.1 \- --device_id 0,1 --processes 1 --run_id smoke --max_rounds 30 \- --browserbase-python verify_trajectories.py \- --input /data/data/Fara/eval/runs/.../<benchmark>/<run_id>/traj \- --task-data ../data/om2w/Online_Mind2Web_06042025.json \+ --input /path/to/Fara/eval/runs/.../<benchmark>/<run_id>/traj \+ --task-data ../path/to/om2w/Online_Mind2Web_06042025.json \--task-data-format om2w \--eval-config ../../endpoint_configs/judge_active/prod \--judge-model gpt-5.2 --o4mini-model o4-mini \@@ -452,7 +442,7 @@ Deploy [Fara-7B on Foundry endpoint(s)](https://ai.azure.com/explore/models/Fara```bashpython webvoyager.py --model_endpoint ../../endpoint_configs/ --eval_oai_config ../endpoint_configs_gpt4o/dev/ --out_url /path/to/save/eval/files --processes 1 --run_id 1_endpoint --max_rounds 100python om2w.py --model_endpoint ../../endpoint_configs/ --eval_oai_config ../endpoint_configs_o4/dev/ --eval_model o4-mini --out_url /path/to/save/eval/files --processes 1 --run_id 1_endpoint --max_rounds 100-python webtailbench.py --model_endpoint ../../endpoint_configs/ --eval_oai_config ../../endpoint_configs/judge_active/prod --judge_eval_model gpt-5.2 --judge_o4_eval_model o4-mini --out_url /data/data/Fara/eval --processes 1 --run_id 1_endpoint --max_rounds 100+python webtailbench.py --model_endpoint ../../endpoint_configs/ --eval_oai_config ../../endpoint_configs/judge_active/prod --judge_eval_model gpt-5.2 --judge_o4_eval_model o4-mini --out_url /path/to/Fara/eval --processes 1 --run_id 1_endpoint --max_rounds 100```### Notesdiff --git a/cuaverifierbench/README.md b/cuaverifierbench/README.mddeleted file mode 100644index 0199657..0000000--- a/cuaverifierbench/README.md+++ /dev/null@@ -1,187 +0,0 @@-----language:-- en-license: mit-size_categories:-- n<1K-pretty_name: CUAVerifierBench-tags:-- cua-- agent-evaluation-- verifier-- arxiv:2604.06240-task_categories:-- image-text-to-text-configs:-- config_name: trajectories- data_files:- - split: fara7b_om2w_browserbase- path: trajectories/fara7b_om2w_browserbase-*- - split: internal- path: trajectories/internal-*-- config_name: annotations- data_files:- - split: fara7b_om2w_browserbase- path: annotations/fara7b_om2w_browserbase-*- - split: internal- path: annotations/internal-*------# CUAVerifierBench: A Human-Annotated Benchmark for Computer-Using-Agent Verifiers--[](https://aka.ms/msaif/fara)-[](https://huggingface.co/microsoft/fara-7b)-[](https://github.com/microsoft/fara)--Universal Verifier paper: *The Art of Building Verifiers for Computer Use Agents*--## Dataset Summary--**CUAVerifierBench** is an evaluation benchmark for **verifiers** of computer-using agents (CUAs) — i.e. judges that read an agent's trajectory (screenshots + actions + final answer) and decide whether the task was completed correctly. Where benchmarks like WebTailBench measure *agents*, CUAVerifierBench measures the *judges that score those agents*.--Each row pairs a Fara-7B agent trajectory with one human reviewer's verdict, plus the verdicts produced by the **Universal Verifier (MMRubricAgent)** and several legacy verifiers. Researchers can use the dataset to:--- Compute verifier–human agreement (Cohen's κ, accuracy, F1) on a fixed corpus of trajectories-- Study disagreement between judges and how it changes when reviewers see the verifier's output (the "UV-informed" stage)-- Iterate on new verifier prompts/architectures against a frozen ground-truth set--## Splits--Both configs (`trajectories`, `annotations`) carry the same two splits:--| Split | Source | Trajectories | Annotation rows | Annotation stages |-|---|---|---|---|---|-| `fara7b_om2w_browserbase` | Fara-7B trajectories on the [Online-Mind2Web](https://huggingface.co/datasets/osunlp/Online-Mind2Web) tasks executed via the [Browserbase](https://www.browserbase.com/) remote browser | 106 | 215 (≈2 reviewers/task) | UV-blind **and** UV-informed |-| `internal` | Microsoft-internal task suite — heldout aurora-v2 task definitions evaluated with the same WebSurfer + verifier stack | 154 | 154 (1 reviewer/task) | UV-blind only |--The two splits share the same column schema. The `internal` split was annotated in a single UV-blind stage, so its `informed_*` fields and `human_process_score` are empty / null.--## Dataset Structure--The dataset is exposed as **two HuggingFace configs** that are joinable on `task_id`:--| Config | Granularity | Contents |-|---|---|---|-| `trajectories` | one row per task | The agent run — instruction, screenshots, web_surfer log, final answer, plus all verifier outputs and task-level human aggregates |-| `annotations` | one row per (task, judge) | Free-text and structured human judgments from one reviewer |--Reviewer identities are anonymized as `Judge1` … `JudgeN` using a single shared map across both splits — the same human always gets the same `Judge` ID.--Storing screenshots only in `trajectories` (rather than duplicating across judges) cuts the on-disk size roughly in half.--### Config: `trajectories`--| Field | Type | Description |-|---|---|---|-| `task_id` | string | **PK.** Online-Mind2Web task identifier (e.g. `Adidas--11857213`) |-| `instruction` | string | Natural-language task given to the agent |-| `init_url` | string | Starting URL |-| `start_timestamp`, `end_timestamp` | string | Wall-clock bounds of the run |-| `final_answer` | string | The agent's submitted answer (or `<no_answer>` if it never called `terminate`) |-| `is_aborted` | bool | Whether the run was aborted before completion |-| `web_surfer_log` | string | Full JSONL action/observation log from `web_surfer.log` |-| `screenshots` | sequence of `Image` | Inline PNG screenshots in chronological order, decoded to PIL automatically |-| `n_screenshots` | int32 | Length of the `screenshots` list |-| `gpt_eval_json` | string | Raw JSON of the original Online-Mind2Web GPT judge verdict |-| `uv_rubric_score` | float32 | **Universal Verifier (current)** rubric score in [0, 1] |-| `uv_outcome_success` | int32 | **Universal Verifier (current)** binary outcome verdict |-| `mm_is_success` | int32 | **Legacy (deprecated)** — verdict from the original WebTailBench multimodal grounded verifier (see note below) |-| `verifier_is_success` | int32 | **Legacy (deprecated)** — verdict from the original WebTailBench text-only task verifier (see note below) |-| `final_human_outcome_label` | int32 | Final adjudicated outcome label across all reviewers of this task |-| `final_human_process_label` | int32 | Final adjudicated process label across all reviewers of this task |-| `median_human_rubric_score_agnostic` | float32 | Median of UV-blind process scores across reviewers |-| `majority_human_outcome_vote` | int32 | Majority vote of UV-blind outcome labels |--> **About the legacy verifiers.** `mm_is_success` and `verifier_is_success` come from the **original WebTailBench verifier suite** used in the Fara-7B tech report (a 3-judge ensemble: text-only task verifier, multimodal grounded verifier, early rubric agent). The entire suite has since been **deprecated and replaced by the [Universal Verifier (MMRubricAgent)](https://github.com/microsoft/fara/blob/main/webeval/src/webeval/rubric_agent/mm_rubric_agent.py)** in [`microsoft/fara`](https://github.com/microsoft/fara). They are included only for backwards-compatible analysis against numbers from the original Fara-7B paper. **New work should use `uv_rubric_score` / `uv_outcome_success`.**--### Config: `annotations`--| Field | Type | Description |-|---|---|---|-| `task_id` | string | **FK** → `trajectories.task_id` |-| `annotator` | string | Anonymized reviewer (`Judge1` … `Judge6`) |-| `human_judgement_outcome` | string | UV-blind outcome label (`Correct` / `Incorrect` / etc.) |-| `human_judgement_process` | string | UV-blind process label |-| `human_process_score` | float32 | UV-blind continuous process score in [0, 1] |-| `outcome_comment` | string | UV-blind free-text justification for the outcome label |-| `process_comment` | string | UV-blind free-text justification for the process label |-| `informed_outcome_agreement` | string | UV-informed: agreement with the Universal Verifier's outcome verdict |-| `informed_process_agreement` | string | UV-informed: agreement with the Universal Verifier's process verdict |-| `informed_outcome_comment` | string | UV-informed free-text justification |-| `informed_process_comment` | string | UV-informed free-text justification |--**UV-blind vs. UV-informed.** Reviewers labeled each trajectory in two stages: first *without* seeing any verifier output (`human_*` and `*_comment` fields), then *after* being shown the Universal Verifier's verdict (`informed_*` fields).--## Loading--Each config is loaded separately and joined on `task_id`. Pass either `fara7b_om2w_browserbase` or `internal` as the split:--```python-from datasets import load_dataset--split = "fara7b_om2w_browserbase" # or "internal"-trajs = load_dataset("microsoft/CUAVerifierBench", "trajectories", split=split)-anns = load_dataset("microsoft/CUAVerifierBench", "annotations", split=split)--# Per-judge analysis: join in pandas-import pandas as pd-df = anns.to_pandas().merge(trajs.to_pandas(), on="task_id")--# Or look up trajectories on demand:-by_id = {r["task_id"]: r for r in trajs}-print(by_id[anns[0]["task_id"]]["screenshots"][0]) # PIL.Image-```--## Dataset Creation--### Source trajectories--Trajectories were generated by running [Fara-7B](https://huggingface.co/microsoft/fara-7b) on the public [Online-Mind2Web](https://huggingface.co/datasets/osunlp/Online-Mind2Web) task set, executed inside a [Browserbase](https://www.browserbase.com/)-hosted Chromium instance. Each trajectory contains the screenshots the model saw, the structured actions it issued, and the final answer it submitted.--### Annotation protocol--Each task was independently reviewed by ~2 human annotators in two stages:--1. **UV-blind (agnostic)** — Reviewers read the instruction and trajectory and assign outcome / process labels and a continuous process score, *without* seeing any verifier output.-2. **UV-informed** — Reviewers are then shown the Universal Verifier's verdict and asked whether they agree, with free-text justifications.--Reviewer identities are anonymized as `Judge1`…`Judge6`.--### Universal Verifier outputs--For each trajectory we also include the verdicts of the **MMRubricAgent** (the Universal Verifier shipped with Fara) and two legacy verifiers, so users can directly compute verifier–human agreement.--## Considerations for Using the Data--### Intended Use--- Evaluating CUA verifiers against human judgment-- Studying inter-annotator agreement and the effect of showing model verdicts to humans-- Developing new judge prompts / architectures for trajectory evaluation--### Limitations--- 106 tasks is a relatively small corpus; results should be reported with confidence intervals-- All trajectories come from a single agent (Fara-7B); verifier behavior on trajectories from other agents may differ-- Tasks inherit the temporal validity and domain biases of Online-Mind2Web--### Licensing--MIT License--### Citation--If you use CUAVerifierBench in your research, please cite the Universal Verifier paper:--```bibtex-@article{UniversalVerifier2026,- title={The Art of Building Verifiers for Computer Use Agents},- journal={arXiv preprint arXiv:2604.06240},- year={2026},- url={https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.06240v1}-}-```--### Contributions--Created by Microsoft Research AI Frontiers.diff --git a/cuaverifierbench/build_dataset.py b/cuaverifierbench/build_dataset.pydeleted file mode 100644index 9990a51..0000000--- a/cuaverifierbench/build_dataset.py+++ /dev/null@@ -1,446 +0,0 @@-"""Build the CUAVerifierBench HuggingFace dataset locally.--Emits two HF *configs* — ``trajectories`` and ``annotations`` — each with-two splits: ``fara7b_om2w_browserbase`` and ``internal``. Tables are-joinable on ``task_id``:--* ``trajectories`` — one row per task (instruction, screenshots,- web_surfer log, verifier outputs, task-level aggregates).-* ``annotations`` — one row per (task_id, annotator) human review.--Annotator names are anonymized to ``Judge1`` … ``JudgeN`` using a single-shared map across both splits, so the same human gets the same ID.--Run:- python build_dataset.py [--out OUT_DIR] [--push REPO_ID]-"""--from __future__ import annotations--import argparse-import collections-import csv-import json-import logging-import re-from pathlib import Path-from typing import Any, Dict, List, Optional--from datasets import Dataset, DatasetDict, Features, Image, Sequence, Value--logging.basicConfig(level=logging.INFO, format="%(asctime)s %(levelname)s %(message)s")-logger = logging.getLogger("build_cuaverifierbench")--# --- om2w_browserbase split --------------------------------------------------OM2W_ANN_TSV = Path(- "/mnt/users/wangzhe/code/agento/webeval_next/verify_verifiers/"- "trajectory_human_annotations/browserbase_om2w_v2/annotations_fixed.tsv"-)-OM2W_TRAJ_ROOT = Path("/data/data/Agento/eval/browserbase-om2w/traj")-OM2W_SCORE_FILE = "gpt_eval.json"--# --- internal split ----------------------------------------------------------INTERNAL_ANN_TSV = Path(- "/mnt/users/wangzhe/code/agento/webeval_next/verify_verifiers/"- "trajectory_human_annotations/"- "internal_combined_annotations.outcome_process.fixed.merged.tsv"-)-INTERNAL_TRAJ_ROOT = Path(- "/data/data/Agento/eval/verify_verifiers/human_annotated_traj/"- "internal_combined_traj/runs/"- "WebSurfer-orca_qwen25vl_aurorav2_solver_history-100-max_n_images-3/"- "models_dummy/corbyrosset/"- "HoldOut__data_data_Agento_eval_verify_verifiers_human_annotated_traj_"- "internal_combined_traj/"- "gpt5.2v4_MMv20_gpt5.2_scored_soft_outcome_verifier/traj"-)-INTERNAL_SCORE_FILE = "0.8-5-3.json"--SCREENSHOT_RE = re.compile(r"^screenshot(\d+)\.png$")---# ----------------------------------------------------------------------------# Trajectory loader-# ----------------------------------------------------------------------------def _load_trajectory(traj_dir: Path, score_filename: str) -> Dict[str, Any]:- out: Dict[str, Any] = {}-- td_path = traj_dir / "task_data.json"- task_data = json.loads(td_path.read_text()) if td_path.exists() else {}- out["instruction"] = task_data.get("task_proposal") or task_data.get("task_summary") or ""- out["init_url"] = task_data.get("init_url") or ""- out["start_timestamp"] = task_data.get("start_timestamp") or ""- out["end_timestamp"] = task_data.get("end_timestamp") or ""-- fa_files = list(traj_dir.glob("*_final_answer.json"))- if fa_files:- fa = json.loads(fa_files[0].read_text())- out["final_answer"] = fa.get("final_answer", "<no_answer>")- out["is_aborted"] = bool(fa.get("is_aborted", False))- else:- out["final_answer"] = "<no_answer>"- out["is_aborted"] = True-- wsl_path = traj_dir / "web_surfer.log"- out["web_surfer_log"] = wsl_path.read_text(encoding="utf-8") if wsl_path.exists() else ""-- score_path = traj_dir / "scores" / score_filename- out["gpt_eval_json"] = score_path.read_text(encoding="utf-8") if score_path.exists() else ""-- screenshots: List[tuple] = []- for fname in traj_dir.iterdir():- m = SCREENSHOT_RE.match(fname.name)- if m:- screenshots.append((int(m.group(1)), str(fname)))- screenshots.sort()- out["screenshots"] = [p for _, p in screenshots]- out["n_screenshots"] = len(screenshots)- return out---def _parse_uv_outcome_from_score_json(raw: str) -> Optional[int]:- """Extract rubric_outcome_verification.output_success (bool) → int."""- if not raw:- return None- try:- outer = json.loads(raw)- inner = json.loads(outer.get("gpt_response_text", "{}"))- ov = inner.get("rubric_outcome_verification") or {}- v = ov.get("output_success")- if v is None:- return None- return int(bool(v))- except (ValueError, TypeError, json.JSONDecodeError):- return None---# ----------------------------------------------------------------------------# Per-row helpers-# ----------------------------------------------------------------------------def _f(d: Dict[str, Any], name: str) -> str:- return (d.get(name) or "").strip()---def _floatish(d: Dict[str, Any], name: str) -> Optional[float]:- v = _f(d, name)- if v == "":- return None- try:- return float(v)- except ValueError:- return None---def _binint(d: Dict[str, Any], name: str) -> Optional[int]:- v = _f(d, name)- if v == "":- return None- s = v.lower()- if s in ("true", "1", "1.0", "yes", "correct"):- return 1- if s in ("false", "0", "0.0", "no", "incorrect"):- return 0- try:- return int(float(v))- except ValueError:- return None---def _normalize_outcome_label(raw: str) -> str:- """Map numeric ('1.0'/'0.0') and string variants to 'Correct'/'Incorrect'."""- s = raw.strip().lower()- if s in ("1", "1.0", "correct", "true", "yes"):- return "Correct"- if s in ("0", "0.0", "incorrect", "false", "no"):- return "Incorrect"- return raw # leave anything else (e.g. 'partial') as-is---# ----------------------------------------------------------------------------# Annotation TSV adapters: normalize each TSV's columns into a canonical dict-# ----------------------------------------------------------------------------def _read_om2w_annotations(path: Path) -> List[Dict[str, Any]]:- with open(path, encoding="utf-8") as f:- rows = list(csv.DictReader(f, delimiter="\t"))- logger.info(f"loaded {len(rows)} om2w_browserbase annotation rows from {path.name}")- return rows # already in canonical om2w schema---def _read_internal_annotations(path: Path) -> List[Dict[str, Any]]:- """Map internal TSV cols → same canonical keys used by the om2w loader.-- Internal TSV has no UV-informed stage and no continuous process score;- those fields are emitted as empty strings so downstream coercion → None.- """- with open(path, encoding="utf-8") as f:- # QUOTE_NONE: NOTES sometimes contains stray double-quotes- rows = list(csv.DictReader(f, delimiter="\t", quoting=csv.QUOTE_NONE))- # Strip surrounding quotes from column names (QUOTE_NONE keeps them literal).- rows = [{k.strip('"'): v for k, v in r.items()} for r in rows]- out: List[Dict[str, Any]] = []- for r in rows:- # Some internal files include a header artifact row; skip if Annotator literally is "Annotator".- if (r.get("Annotator") or "").strip() == "Annotator":- continue- if not (r.get("TASK") or "").strip():- continue- out.append({- "TASK": r.get("TASK", ""),- "VERIFIER": r.get("Annotator", ""),- "HUMAN JUDGEMENT OUTCOME": _normalize_outcome_label(r.get("HUMAN JUDGEMENT OUTCOME", "")),- "HUMAN JUDGEMENT PROCESS": _normalize_outcome_label(r.get("HUMAN JUDGEMENT PROCESS", "")),- "HUMAN PROCESS SCORE": "", # not in internal- "OUTCOME_COMMENT": r.get("NOTES", ""),- "PROCESS_COMMENT": "",- "INFORMED_OUTCOME_AGREEMENT": "",- "INFORMED_PROCESS_AGREEMENT": "",- "INFORMED_OUTCOME_COMMENT": "",- "INFORMED_PROCESS_COMMENT": "",- "rubric_score": r.get("rubric_score", ""),- "outcome_success": "", # parsed from score JSON instead- "mm_is_success": r.get('MM_verifier_response[""is_success""]', "")- or r.get('MM_verifier_response["is_success"]', ""),- "verifier_is_success": r.get("Verifier_bool", ""),- })- logger.info(f"loaded {len(out)} internal annotation rows from {path.name}")- return out---# ----------------------------------------------------------------------------# Schemas-# ----------------------------------------------------------------------------_TRAJ_FEATURES = Features({- "task_id": Value("string"),- "instruction": Value("string"),- "init_url": Value("string"),- "start_timestamp": Value("string"),- "end_timestamp": Value("string"),- "final_answer": Value("string"),- "is_aborted": Value("bool"),- "web_surfer_log": Value("string"),- "screenshots": Sequence(Image()),- "n_screenshots": Value("int32"),- "gpt_eval_json": Value("string"),- "uv_rubric_score": Value("float32"),- "uv_outcome_success": Value("int32"),- "mm_is_success": Value("int32"),- "verifier_is_success": Value("int32"),- "final_human_outcome_label": Value("int32"),- "final_human_process_label": Value("int32"),- "median_human_rubric_score_agnostic": Value("float32"),- "majority_human_outcome_vote": Value("int32"),-})--_ANN_FEATURES = Features({- "task_id": Value("string"),- "annotator": Value("string"),- "human_judgement_outcome": Value("string"),- "human_judgement_process": Value("string"),- "human_process_score": Value("float32"),- "outcome_comment": Value("string"),- "process_comment": Value("string"),- "informed_outcome_agreement": Value("string"),- "informed_process_agreement": Value("string"),- "informed_outcome_comment": Value("string"),- "informed_process_comment": Value("string"),-})---# ----------------------------------------------------------------------------# Row builders-# ----------------------------------------------------------------------------def _majority(values: List[Optional[int]]) -> Optional[int]:- vals = [v for v in values if v is not None]- if not vals:- return None- return collections.Counter(vals).most_common(1)[0][0]---def _trajectory_row(- task_id: str,- traj: Dict[str, Any],- anns: List[Dict[str, Any]],- *,- derive_aggregates: bool,- uv_outcome_from_score_json: bool,-) -> Dict[str, Any]:- head = anns[0]- if uv_outcome_from_score_json:- uv_out = _parse_uv_outcome_from_score_json(traj["gpt_eval_json"])- else:- uv_out = _binint(head, "outcome_success")-- if derive_aggregates:- outcome_votes = [_binint(a, "HUMAN JUDGEMENT OUTCOME") for a in anns]- process_votes = [_binint(a, "HUMAN JUDGEMENT PROCESS") for a in anns]- final_outcome = _majority(outcome_votes)- final_process = _majority(process_votes)- median_score = None- majority_outcome = final_outcome- else:- final_outcome = _binint(head, "final_human_outcome_label")- final_process = _binint(head, "final_human_process_label")- median_score = _floatish(head, "median_human_rubric_score_agnostic")- majority_outcome = _binint(head, "majority_human_outcome_vote")-- return {- "task_id": task_id,- "instruction": traj["instruction"],- "init_url": traj["init_url"],- "start_timestamp": traj["start_timestamp"],- "end_timestamp": traj["end_timestamp"],- "final_answer": traj["final_answer"],- "is_aborted": traj["is_aborted"],- "web_surfer_log": traj["web_surfer_log"],- "screenshots": traj["screenshots"],- "n_screenshots": traj["n_screenshots"],- "gpt_eval_json": traj["gpt_eval_json"],- "uv_rubric_score": _floatish(head, "rubric_score"),- "uv_outcome_success": uv_out,- "mm_is_success": _binint(head, "mm_is_success"),- "verifier_is_success": _binint(head, "verifier_is_success"),- "final_human_outcome_label": final_outcome,- "final_human_process_label": final_process,- "median_human_rubric_score_agnostic": median_score,- "majority_human_outcome_vote": majority_outcome,- }---def _annotation_row(task_id: str, annotator: str, ann: Dict[str, Any]) -> Dict[str, Any]:- return {- "task_id": task_id,- "annotator": annotator,- "human_judgement_outcome": _f(ann, "HUMAN JUDGEMENT OUTCOME"),- "human_judgement_process": _f(ann, "HUMAN JUDGEMENT PROCESS"),- "human_process_score": _floatish(ann, "HUMAN PROCESS SCORE"),- "outcome_comment": _f(ann, "OUTCOME_COMMENT"),- "process_comment": _f(ann, "PROCESS_COMMENT"),- "informed_outcome_agreement": _f(ann, "INFORMED_OUTCOME_AGREEMENT"),- "informed_process_agreement": _f(ann, "INFORMED_PROCESS_AGREEMENT"),- "informed_outcome_comment": _f(ann, "INFORMED_OUTCOME_COMMENT"),- "informed_process_comment": _f(ann, "INFORMED_PROCESS_COMMENT"),- }---# ----------------------------------------------------------------------------# Per-split build-# ----------------------------------------------------------------------------def _build_split(- *,- split_name: str,- annotations: List[Dict[str, Any]],- traj_root: Path,- score_filename: str,- alias_map: Dict[str, str],- derive_aggregates: bool,- uv_outcome_from_score_json: bool,-) -> Dict[str, Dataset]:- annotated_task_ids = sorted({(a.get("TASK") or "").strip() for a in annotations if a.get("TASK")})- have_traj = {tid for tid in annotated_task_ids if (traj_root / tid).is_dir()}- missing = sorted(set(annotated_task_ids) - have_traj)- if missing:- logger.warning(f"[{split_name}] {len(missing)} annotated task_ids have no trajectory dir: {missing[:5]}…")- logger.info(f"[{split_name}] task_ids w/ both annotation and trajectory: {len(have_traj)} / {len(annotated_task_ids)}")-- anns_by_task: Dict[str, List[Dict[str, Any]]] = {}- for ann in annotations:- tid = (ann.get("TASK") or "").strip()- if tid in have_traj:- anns_by_task.setdefault(tid, []).append(ann)-- traj_rows: List[Dict[str, Any]] = []- ann_rows: List[Dict[str, Any]] = []- for tid in sorted(have_traj):- traj = _load_trajectory(traj_root / tid, score_filename)- traj_rows.append(_trajectory_row(- tid, traj, anns_by_task[tid],- derive_aggregates=derive_aggregates,- uv_outcome_from_score_json=uv_outcome_from_score_json,- ))- for ann in anns_by_task[tid]:- judge = alias_map.get(_f(ann, "VERIFIER"), _f(ann, "VERIFIER"))- ann_rows.append(_annotation_row(tid, judge, ann))-- logger.info(f"[{split_name}] emitted {len(traj_rows)} trajectory rows, {len(ann_rows)} annotation rows")- return {- "trajectories": Dataset.from_list(traj_rows, features=_TRAJ_FEATURES),- "annotations": Dataset.from_list(ann_rows, features=_ANN_FEATURES),- }---def _build_alias_map(*ann_lists: List[Dict[str, Any]]) -> Dict[str, str]:- """Single shared map across all splits: same human → same JudgeN."""- raw = set()- for anns in ann_lists:- for a in anns:- name = (a.get("VERIFIER") or "").strip()- if name:- raw.add(name)- return {name: f"Judge{i + 1}" for i, name in enumerate(sorted(raw))}---def build_all() -> Dict[str, DatasetDict]:- """Returns {config_name: DatasetDict({split_name: Dataset})}."""- om2w_anns = _read_om2w_annotations(OM2W_ANN_TSV)- internal_anns = _read_internal_annotations(INTERNAL_ANN_TSV)-- alias_map = _build_alias_map(om2w_anns, internal_anns)- logger.info(f"anonymized {len(alias_map)} unique annotators → Judge1..Judge{len(alias_map)}")- logger.info(f" alias map: {alias_map}")-- om2w_split = _build_split(- split_name="fara7b_om2w_browserbase",- annotations=om2w_anns,- traj_root=OM2W_TRAJ_ROOT,- score_filename=OM2W_SCORE_FILE,- alias_map=alias_map,- derive_aggregates=False, # om2w TSV has pre-computed aggregates- uv_outcome_from_score_json=False, # om2w TSV has outcome_success column- )- internal_split = _build_split(- split_name="internal",- annotations=internal_anns,- traj_root=INTERNAL_TRAJ_ROOT,- score_filename=INTERNAL_SCORE_FILE,- alias_map=alias_map,- derive_aggregates=True, # compute majority votes from per-judge labels- uv_outcome_from_score_json=True, # parse from rubric_outcome_verification.output_success- )-- return {- "trajectories": DatasetDict({- "fara7b_om2w_browserbase": om2w_split["trajectories"],- "internal": internal_split["trajectories"],- }),- "annotations": DatasetDict({- "fara7b_om2w_browserbase": om2w_split["annotations"],- "internal": internal_split["annotations"],- }),- }---def main():- p = argparse.ArgumentParser()- p.add_argument("--out", default="/tmp/cuaverifierbench_local", help="Local save_to_disk root")- p.add_argument("--push", default=None, help="HF repo (e.g. microsoft/CUAVerifierBench)")- args = p.parse_args()-- configs = build_all()-- out_dir = Path(args.out)- out_dir.mkdir(parents=True, exist_ok=True)- for cfg_name, dd in configs.items():- local = out_dir / cfg_name- dd.save_to_disk(str(local))- for split_name, ds in dd.items():- logger.info(f" config={cfg_name!r} split={split_name!r} rows={len(ds)} → {local}")-- if args.push:- for cfg_name, dd in configs.items():- logger.info(f"push_to_hub({args.push!r}, config={cfg_name!r}) …")- dd.push_to_hub(args.push, config_name=cfg_name, private=True)- logger.info(f"pushed to https://huggingface.co/datasets/{args.push}")---if __name__ == "__main__":- main()diff --git a/webeval/README.md b/webeval/README.mdindex ebf341a..0986c01 100644--- a/webeval/README.md+++ b/webeval/README.md@@ -18,31 +18,50 @@ Every executed task lives in its own directory undere.g.:```-/data/data/Fara/eval/runs/WebSurfer-fara-100-max_n_images-3/+/path/to/Fara/eval/runs/WebSurfer-fara-100-max_n_images-3/fara-7b/<user>/WebTailBench_hf/<run_id>/traj/<task_id>/web_surfer.log # newline-delimited JSON action+observation log<task_id>_final_answer.json # FinalAnswer dump (final_answer, screenshots, token_usage)- screenshot0.png ... screenshotN.png- times.json # {start, end, duration} of the solver run+ screenshot_1.png ... screenshot_N.png+ times.json # {start_time, end_time, duration} of the solver runcore.log # webeval.core per-task log (Execution / Evaluation lifecycle)+ task_data.json # only present after the rubric verifier runs (see below)scores/<benchmark.eval_hash>.json # {score: float, gpt_response_text: str|json}```+A concrete example is checked in at+[`webeval/data/example_trajectory/`](data/example_trajectory/) — a+single WebTailBench AllTrails task (`alltrails_find_23`) with its+`web_surfer.log`, `alltrails_find_23_final_answer.json`,+`screenshot_{1..4}.png` frames, `times.json`, `core.log`,+`task_data.json` (written by the rubric verifier on re-eval), and the+`scores/mmrubric_0.8-5-3.json` rubric verdict (`score=1`). Point+`Trajectory.from_folder(...)` at that dir to see every field below+populated end-to-end.+### `web_surfer.log` (one JSON object per line)Written by the `LogHandler` in `webeval/utils.py`, attached to the`WebSurferLogger` inside `WebSurferSystem.get_answer()`. The handlerruns at `DEBUG` level so the `FaraAgent.{generate_model_call,execute_action}` methods (`src/fara/fara_agent.py`) — which emit at-`logger.debug(...)` — actually flow through. Each line is one of three-shapes:--| `type` | Source | Key fields |-|---------------------|------------------------------------------------|---|-| `OtherEvent` | `FaraAgent` thought/action prints + observation| `message` (free text — `Thought #N: ...\nAction #N: executing tool '<tool>' with arguments {...}` or `Observation#N: ...`), `timestamp` |-| `WebSurferEvent` | `FaraAgent.execute_action` | `source`, `message`, `url`, `action`, `arguments`, `timestamp` |-| `OrchestrationEvent` / `AgentEvent` | reserved for orchestrator-side messages | `source`, `message` |+`logger.debug(...)` — actually flow through. Every line carries a+top-level `type` field (`LogHandler.emit` in `webeval/utils.py:124`).+In the current `FaraAgent` pipeline only two of them are actually+produced:++| `type` | Source | Key fields |+|------------------|-------------------------------------------------|---|+| `WebSurferEvent` | `FaraAgent.execute_action` (`src/fara/fara_agent.py:467`) | `timestamp`, `source`, `message`, `url`, `action`, `arguments`. The structured action event — one per tool call, with `action=<tool>` and `arguments=<dict>`. |+| `OtherEvent` | `FaraAgent`'s raw `logger.debug(...)` strings (`fara_agent.py:403,415`) | `timestamp`, `type`, `message`. The `Thought #N: ...\nAction #N: executing tool '<tool>' with arguments {...}` and `Observation#N: ...` prints land here, because they're plain strings, not dataclasses, and `LogHandler.emit` falls through to its catch-all branch. |++Three more event dataclasses (`OrchestrationEvent`, `AgentEvent`,+`LLMCallEvent`) are declared in `webeval/systems/messages.py` /+`webeval/utils.py` and handled by `LogHandler.emit`, but have no+construction callsites in the current repo — they're reserved for+other solver systems / legacy trajectories and won't appear in a+fresh `FaraAgent` run.`Trajectory.__init__` reads every line and either:@@ -79,7 +98,7 @@ hits `max_rounds`. Field reference (`webeval/trajectory.py:FinalAnswer`):| `screenshots` | `List[str]` | Screenshot filenames captured during the run, **relative** to the trajectory dir if `is_rel_paths` is true (the default), else absolute. || `is_aborted` | `bool` | True if the trajectory was killed mid-execution by an environment error. Aborted trajectories are typically retried up to `--max_error_task_retries` (see `webeval/core.py`). || `is_rel_paths` | `bool` | Whether `screenshots` paths are relative to `trajectory.path`. New runs use `True`. |-| `token_usage` | `Dict[str, RequestUsage]` | Per-component LLM token usage (e.g. `{"FaraAgent": RequestUsage(prompt_tokens=…, completion_tokens=…)}`). Aggregated via `RequestUsage.__add__`. |+| `token_usage` | `Dict[str, RequestUsage]` | Per-component LLM token usage. The example uses `{"FaraAgent": {"prompt_tokens": 23383, "completion_tokens": 1920}}` — the key is whichever component name `WebSurferSystem.get_answer()` attributes the call to. Aggregated via `RequestUsage.__add__`. |Persisted via `FinalAnswer.save(path)`; loaded via `FinalAnswer.load(path)`.`Trajectory.__init__` calls `FinalAnswer.load(...)` on the single@@ -119,16 +138,37 @@ short-circuits with `verifier_reasoning='The last action must be`terminate` — those are guaranteed to have `final_answer =="<no_answer>"` and therefore nothing the rubric judge can grade.-`screenshot{i}.png` files keep accumulating regardless of how the+> **Auto-0 vs excluded**: two superficially similar cases are scored+> very differently.+>+> - **Over-budget** (`<no_answer>`, `is_aborted=False`): WebTailBench+> short-circuits to `score=0` without calling the rubric judge,+> writes it to `scores/<eval_hash>.json`, and **counts it as 0 in+> the mean**.+> - **Aborted / errored mid-run** (`is_aborted=True`, loader fails,+> or evaluator raises): returns `score=None`, no score file is+> written, and every aggregator filters on `score is not None` —+> so aborted trajectories are **excluded from all final metrics**+> rather than counted as 0.++`screenshot_{i}.png` files keep accumulating regardless of how thetrajectory ended, so screenshot count alone is **not** a proxy for"in budget" — always combine it with the `final_answer` check above.+Note: `trajectory.latest_screenshot` is a static convenience path+(`trajectory.path / "screenshot_scaled.png"`, see+`webeval/trajectory.py:131`) that may not exist on disk for every+run — the example directory, for instance, has only+`screenshot_1..4.png`.### `times.json`-`{"start": <iso8601>, "end": <iso8601>, "duration": <float-seconds>}`,-written around the solver call in `webeval/core.py:run_single_task`.-`evaluate_single_example` reads `duration` to populate-`EvalResult.duration`.+`{"start_time": <unix-float>, "end_time": <unix-float>, "duration":+<float-seconds>}`, written around the solver call in+`webeval/core.py:run_single_task` (`webeval/core.py:86-93`). Both+stamps are `time.time()` values (not ISO-8601); e.g. the example is+`{"start_time": 1762809276.0520103, "end_time": 1762809454.79363,+"duration": 178.74161958694458}`. `evaluate_single_example` reads+`duration` to populate `EvalResult.duration`.### `scores/<benchmark.eval_hash>.json`@@ -145,23 +185,58 @@ benchmark-specific verdict lives inside `gpt_response_text`.#### Where each benchmark's verdict livesThe score file is the **single source of truth for an evaluation-result** — neither `task_data.json` (does not exist for new fara-private-runs) nor `final_answer.json` get overwritten by the verifier.-Re-running the verifier (`--redo_eval` or `scripts/verify_trajectories.py`)-rewrites this file in place.+result**. `final_answer.json` is never overwritten by the verifier.+`task_data.json` is a separate dump the WebTailBench rubric verifier+writes alongside the score file (`benchmarks/webtailbench.py:346` →+`[Rubric] Saved rubric results to …/task_data.json`), so a fresh+solver-only run won't have one, but any trajectory that's been+re-scored — including the checked-in example — will. Re-running the+verifier (`--redo_eval` or `scripts/verify_trajectories.py`) rewrites+the score file in place and, for webtailbench, refreshes+`task_data.json` with the latest rubric payload.| Benchmark | Score file path under `traj/<task_id>/` | `gpt_response_text` payload ||---|---|---|| `webvoyager` | `scores/gpt_eval.json` | gpt-4o judge text — verdict is `"SUCCESS"` / `"NOT SUCCESS"` parsed back to `score ∈ {0.0, 1.0}` (`benchmarks/webvoyager/webvoyager.py`). || `om2w` | `scores/<eval_method>-<threshold>.json` (e.g. `WebJudge_Online_Mind2Web_eval-3.json`) | o4-mini judge text — verdict via `extract_predication(...)` from the OnlineMind2Web judge methods (`benchmarks/om2w/om2w.py`). |-| `webtailbench` | `scores/mmrubric_<rubric_threshold>-<max_imgs>-<keypt>.json` | JSON-encoded dict with `rubric_*` (per-criterion scoring), `outcome_*` (output_success / primary_intent / reasoning), `error_taxonomy.*` (first-point-of-failure, ambiguity / invalid-task verdicts). Top-level `score` is `int(outcome_success)`. |+| `webtailbench` | `scores/mmrubric_<rubric_threshold>-<max_imgs>-<keypt>.json` | JSON-encoded dict assembled in `benchmarks/webtailbench/webtailbench.py:355-442`: `is_success` (int 0/1), `success_criterion` (`outcome` / `process` / `both`), `final_answer`, `outcome_success` (bool), `outcome_reasoning`, `outcome_primary_intent`, `rubric_is_success` (int), the `rubric_*` family forwarded from MMRubricAgent (`rubric_items`, `rubric_total_earned_points`, `rubric_total_max_points`, `rubric_all_scores_list`, `rubric_all_rubric_dicts`, `rubric_intermediate_mm_rubric_steps`, `rubric_outcome_verification`, `rubric_majority_vote_metadata`), and the error-taxonomy fields nested inside the rubric payload (`first_point_of_failure`, `is_ambiguous` / `ambiguity_codes`, `is_invalid` / `invalid_task_codes` — `mm_rubric_agent.py:392-406`). Top-level `score` equals `is_success`, which is driven by `--success`: `outcome` → `int(outcome_success)`, `process` → `rubric_is_success`, `both` → both. || `verify_trajectories.py` (stand-alone) | same path + shape as `webtailbench` | same Universal Verifier output. |### `core.log`-Per-task log lines from `webeval.core.<task_id>` — `[Execution …]-Start/Completed/Error`, `[Evaluation …] Start/Completed/Error`. Useful-when a task hangs or errors and the rest of the pipeline keeps moving.+Per-task log lines from the `webeval.core.<task_id>` logger. Useful+when a task hangs or errors and the rest of the pipeline keeps+moving. A run's `core.log` typically mixes:++- `[Execution <task_id>] Start / Trajectory is not complete. Reexecuting... / Completed / Error`+- BrowserBase plumbing: `Initializing BrowserBase session...`,+ `Connected to BrowserBase session: <url>`, `Closing browser...`+- Every `WebSurferEvent` event re-emitted as its dataclass+ `repr(...)` (so the same step shows up both here and in+ `web_surfer.log`, just unparsed)+- `[Evaluation <task_id>] Start / Loading from: <path> / Completed: score=<n>, duration=<seconds> / Error`+- `[Rubric] Saved rubric results to <path>/task_data.json` when the+ WebTailBench rubric verifier runs++The example's `core.log` shows the full sequence for one solve on+2025-11-10 plus three separate rubric re-eval passes on 2026-03-26,+all against the same trajectory directory.++### `task_data.json` (optional, rubric-verifier output)++Only written by the WebTailBench rubric verifier+(`benchmarks/webtailbench/webtailbench.py:346`), so trajectories that+have never been re-scored won't have one. When present, it's a large+JSON dump of the task's rubric/outcome state — everything MMRubricAgent+produced plus the task metadata it loaded. In the example,+`task_data.json` has 76 keys, including `task_summary`, `task_type`,+`rubric_score`, `verifier_agent_response`, `verifier_rubric`,+`start_timestamp`, `end_timestamp`, `token_usage`, `plan_list`,+`facts_list`, `observations_list`, `actions`, `actions_summary`, and+the boolean error-taxonomy flags (`did_web_surfing_fail`,+`web_surfing_stalled`, `encountered_captcha`, …). Treat this file as+diagnostic detail; the authoritative score still lives in+`scores/<eval_hash>.json`.## `Trajectory` consumersdiff --git a/webeval/data/example_trajectory/alltrails_find_23_final_answer.json b/webeval/data/example_trajectory/alltrails_find_23_final_answer.jsonnew file mode 100644index 0000000..c1c3af4--- /dev/null+++ b/webeval/data/example_trajectory/alltrails_find_23_final_answer.json@@ -0,0 +1,19 @@+{+ "final_answer": "The two standout waterfalls to see while hiking in the Superstition Mountains are:\n- Massacre Falls: Reached from First Water Trailhead; an easier, well-marked hike suitable for most skill levels. It’s a seasonal waterfall that flows mainly in winter or after significant rains, and the trail offers great desert scenery and is dog-friendly.\n- Reavis Falls: A hidden gem deep in the Superstition Wilderness. This is a challenging hike (about 13 miles round‑trip, >3,000 ft elevation gain) but rewards you with a spectacular ~196‑foot waterfall and sweeping views, with beautiful scenery across seasons.",+ "env_state_json": "<no_answer>",+ "env_state_raw": "<no_answer>",+ "screenshots": [+ "screenshot_1.png",+ "screenshot_2.png",+ "screenshot_3.png",+ "screenshot_4.png"+ ],+ "is_aborted": false,+ "is_rel_paths": true,+ "token_usage": {+ "MultimodalWebSurferTaskSolving": {+ "prompt_tokens": 23383,+ "completion_tokens": 1920+ }+ }+}\ No newline at end of filediff --git a/webeval/data/example_trajectory/core.log b/webeval/data/example_trajectory/core.lognew file mode 100644index 0000000..715251f--- /dev/null+++ b/webeval/data/example_trajectory/core.log@@ -0,0 +1,29 @@+2025-11-10 13:14:35,184 [INFO] webeval.core.alltrails_find_23 - [Execution alltrails_find_23] Start+2025-11-10 13:14:35,280 [INFO] webeval.core.alltrails_find_23 - [Execution alltrails_find_23] Trajectory is not complete. Reexecuting...+2025-11-10 13:14:37,322 [INFO] webeval.core.alltrails_find_23 - Initializing BrowserBase session...+2025-11-10 13:14:39,959 [INFO] webeval.core.alltrails_find_23 - Connected to BrowserBase session: https://browserbase.com/sessions/c77a970e-1d06-4775-b7ec-bdb365475c70+2025-11-10 13:15:11,763 [INFO] webeval.core.alltrails_find_23 - WebSurferEvent(source='WebSurfer-SummarizedAction', message="Action 1: URL=https://www.bing.com/, input_text({'state_description': 'We are on the Bing home page with the search textbox focused.', 'reasoning': 'To find information on the best waterfalls in the Superstition Mountains, I will perform a web search using the Bing search bar.', 'input_field_id': 22, 'text_value': 'best waterfalls to see while hiking in the Superstition Mountains Arizona', 'press_enter': True, 'delete_existing_text': True})", url='https://www.bing.com/', action=None, arguments=None)+2025-11-10 13:15:12,358 [INFO] webeval.core.alltrails_find_23 - WebSurferEvent(source='WebSurfer', message='input_text( {"state_description": "We are on the Bing home page with the search textbox focused.", "reasoning": "To find information on the best waterfalls in the Superstition Mountains, I will perform a web search using the Bing search bar.", "input_field_id": 22, "text_value": "best waterfalls to see while hiking in the Superstition Mountains Arizona", "press_enter": true, "delete_existing_text": true} )', url='https://www.bing.com/', action='input_text', arguments={'state_description': 'We are on the Bing home page with the search textbox focused.', 'reasoning': 'To find information on the best waterfalls in the Superstition Mountains, I will perform a web search using the Bing search bar.', 'input_field_id': 22, 'text_value': 'best waterfalls to see while hiking in the Superstition Mountains Arizona', 'press_enter': True, 'delete_existing_text': True})+2025-11-10 13:16:02,391 [INFO] webeval.core.alltrails_find_23 - WebSurferEvent(source='WebSurfer-SummarizedAction', message='Action 2: URL=https://www.bing.com/search?q=best+waterfalls+to+see+while+hiking+in+the+Superstition+Mountains+Arizona&form=QBLH&sp=-1&ghc=1&lq=0&pq=best+waterfalls+to+see+while+hiking+in+the+superstition+mountains+arizon&sc=12-72&qs=n&sk=&cvid=4D2B7C22E0844E40995A7389B39B9F58, click({\'state_description\': "On the Bing SERP, there\'s an AI-generated summary box listing waterfalls in the Superstition Mountains, currently showing \'1. Massacre Falls\' with details and a \'Read more\' button to expand the summary.", \'reasoning\': \'Expanding the AI-generated summary will likely reveal additional waterfalls and details relevant to identifying the best waterfalls to see.\', \'target_id\': 47})', url='https://www.bing.com/search?q=best+waterfalls+to+see+while+hiking+in+the+Superstition+Mountains+Arizona&form=QBLH&sp=-1&ghc=1&lq=0&pq=best+waterfalls+to+see+while+hiking+in+the+superstition+mountains+arizon&sc=12-72&qs=n&sk=&cvid=4D2B7C22E0844E40995A7389B39B9F58', action=None, arguments=None)+2025-11-10 13:16:02,990 [INFO] webeval.core.alltrails_find_23 - WebSurferEvent(source='WebSurfer', message='click( {"state_description": "On the Bing SERP, there\'s an AI-generated summary box listing waterfalls in the Superstition Mountains, currently showing \'1. Massacre Falls\' with details and a \'Read more\' button to expand the summary.", "reasoning": "Expanding the AI-generated summary will likely reveal additional waterfalls and details relevant to identifying the best waterfalls to see.", "target_id": 47} )', url='https://www.bing.com/search?q=best+waterfalls+to+see+while+hiking+in+the+Superstition+Mountains+Arizona&form=QBLH&sp=-1&ghc=1&lq=0&pq=best+waterfalls+to+see+while+hiking+in+the+superstition+mountains+arizon&sc=12-72&qs=n&sk=&cvid=4D2B7C22E0844E40995A7389B39B9F58', action='click', arguments={'state_description': "On the Bing SERP, there's an AI-generated summary box listing waterfalls in the Superstition Mountains, currently showing '1. Massacre Falls' with details and a 'Read more' button to expand the summary.", 'reasoning': 'Expanding the AI-generated summary will likely reveal additional waterfalls and details relevant to identifying the best waterfalls to see.', 'target_id': 47})+2025-11-10 13:16:54,857 [INFO] webeval.core.alltrails_find_23 - WebSurferEvent(source='WebSurfer-SummarizedAction', message='Action 3: URL=https://www.bing.com/search?q=best+waterfalls+to+see+while+hiking+in+the+Superstition+Mountains+Arizona&form=QBLH&sp=-1&ghc=1&lq=0&pq=best+waterfalls+to+see+while+hiking+in+the+superstition+mountains+arizon&sc=12-72&qs=n&sk=&cvid=4D2B7C22E0844E40995A7389B39B9F58, pause_and_memorize_fact({\'state_description\': "On the Bing search results page for \'best waterfalls to see while hiking in the Superstition Mountains Arizona\', there is an AI-generated summary box listing two waterfalls with details: Massacre Falls and Reavis Falls, including trailheads, difficulty, and notable characteristics. It also shows sources such as \'jaceyoutwest.com\' and \'Only In Your State\'.", \'reasoning\': "These details provide the specific waterfalls and characteristics needed to answer the user\'s question. Memorizing them ensures we can give an accurate, concise recommendation.", \'fact\': \'Best waterfalls in the Superstition Mountains: 1) Massacre Falls — Trailhead: First Water Trailhead; Difficulty: Easy to moderate; Seasonal waterfall flowing mainly in winter or after significant rain; well-marked trail, family-friendly, scenic desert views, dog-friendly. 2) Reavis Falls — Trailhead: Reavis Falls Trail; Difficulty: Challenging; Distance: ~13 miles round-trip; Elevation gain: Over 3,000 feet; Hidden gem deep in Superstition Wilderness; features a stunning ~196-foot waterfall; less trafficked, beautiful scenery across seasons.\'})', url='https://www.bing.com/search?q=best+waterfalls+to+see+while+hiking+in+the+Superstition+Mountains+Arizona&form=QBLH&sp=-1&ghc=1&lq=0&pq=best+waterfalls+to+see+while+hiking+in+the+superstition+mountains+arizon&sc=12-72&qs=n&sk=&cvid=4D2B7C22E0844E40995A7389B39B9F58', action=None, arguments=None)+2025-11-10 13:16:55,466 [INFO] webeval.core.alltrails_find_23 - WebSurferEvent(source='WebSurfer', message='pause_and_memorize_fact( {"state_description": "On the Bing search results page for \'best waterfalls to see while hiking in the Superstition Mountains Arizona\', there is an AI-generated summary box listing two waterfalls with details: Massacre Falls and Reavis Falls, including trailheads, difficulty, and notable characteristics. It also shows sources such as \'jaceyoutwest.com\' and \'Only In Your State\'.", "reasoning": "These details provide the specific waterfalls and characteristics needed to answer the user\'s question. Memorizing them ensures we can give an accurate, concise recommendation.", "fact": "Best waterfalls in the Superstition Mountains: 1) Massacre Falls \\u2014 Trailhead: First Water Trailhead; Difficulty: Easy to moderate; Seasonal waterfall flowing mainly in winter or after significant rain; well-marked trail, family-friendly, scenic desert views, dog-friendly. 2) Reavis Falls \\u2014 Trailhead: Reavis Falls Trail; Difficulty: Challenging; Distance: ~13 miles round-trip; Elevation gain: Over 3,000 feet; Hidden gem deep in Superstition Wilderness; features a stunning ~196-foot waterfall; less trafficked, beautiful scenery across seasons."} )', url='https://www.bing.com/search?q=best+waterfalls+to+see+while+hiking+in+the+Superstition+Mountains+Arizona&form=QBLH&sp=-1&ghc=1&lq=0&pq=best+waterfalls+to+see+while+hiking+in+the+superstition+mountains+arizon&sc=12-72&qs=n&sk=&cvid=4D2B7C22E0844E40995A7389B39B9F58', action='pause_and_memorize_fact', arguments={'state_description': "On the Bing search results page for 'best waterfalls to see while hiking in the Superstition Mountains Arizona', there is an AI-generated summary box listing two waterfalls with details: Massacre Falls and Reavis Falls, including trailheads, difficulty, and notable characteristics. It also shows sources such as 'jaceyoutwest.com' and 'Only In Your State'.", 'reasoning': "These details provide the specific waterfalls and characteristics needed to answer the user's question. Memorizing them ensures we can give an accurate, concise recommendation.", 'fact': 'Best waterfalls in the Superstition Mountains: 1) Massacre Falls — Trailhead: First Water Trailhead; Difficulty: Easy to moderate; Seasonal waterfall flowing mainly in winter or after significant rain; well-marked trail, family-friendly, scenic desert views, dog-friendly. 2) Reavis Falls — Trailhead: Reavis Falls Trail; Difficulty: Challenging; Distance: ~13 miles round-trip; Elevation gain: Over 3,000 feet; Hidden gem deep in Superstition Wilderness; features a stunning ~196-foot waterfall; less trafficked, beautiful scenery across seasons.'})+2025-11-10 13:17:26,374 [INFO] webeval.core.alltrails_find_23 - WebSurferEvent(source='WebSurfer-SummarizedAction', message="Action 4: URL=https://www.bing.com/search?q=best+waterfalls+to+see+while+hiking+in+the+Superstition+Mountains+Arizona&form=QBLH&sp=-1&ghc=1&lq=0&pq=best+waterfalls+to+see+while+hiking+in+the+superstition+mountains+arizon&sc=12-72&qs=n&sk=&cvid=4D2B7C22E0844E40995A7389B39B9F58, stop_and_answer_question({'state_description': 'On the Bing search results page for “best waterfalls to see while hiking in the Superstition Mountains Arizona,” an AI-generated summary lists two waterfalls with details: Massacre Falls (First Water Trailhead; easy to moderate; seasonal flow mainly in winter or after rains; family-friendly, dog-friendly; scenic desert views) and Reavis Falls (Reavis Falls Trail; challenging; ~13 miles round trip; >3,000 ft gain; hidden gem deep in the wilderness; ~196‑foot waterfall; beautiful scenery year-round). The summary also cites sources like jaceyoutwest.com and Only In Your State.', 'reasoning': 'The page’s summary explicitly identifies the notable waterfalls in the Superstition Mountains along with key hiking details, which is sufficient to answer the user’s question accurately.', 'answer': 'The two standout waterfalls to see while hiking in the Superstition Mountains are:\\n- Massacre Falls: Reached from First Water Trailhead; an easier, well-marked hike suitable for most skill levels. It’s a seasonal waterfall that flows mainly in winter or after significant rains, and the trail offers great desert scenery and is dog-friendly.\\n- Reavis Falls: A hidden gem deep in the Superstition Wilderness. This is a challenging hike (about 13 miles round‑trip, >3,000 ft elevation gain) but rewards you with a spectacular ~196‑foot waterfall and sweeping views, with beautiful scenery across seasons.'})", url='https://www.bing.com/search?q=best+waterfalls+to+see+while+hiking+in+the+Superstition+Mountains+Arizona&form=QBLH&sp=-1&ghc=1&lq=0&pq=best+waterfalls+to+see+while+hiking+in+the+superstition+mountains+arizon&sc=12-72&qs=n&sk=&cvid=4D2B7C22E0844E40995A7389B39B9F58', action=None, arguments=None)+2025-11-10 13:17:26,971 [INFO] webeval.core.alltrails_find_23 - WebSurferEvent(source='WebSurfer', message='stop_and_answer_question( {"state_description": "On the Bing search results page for \\u201cbest waterfalls to see while hiking in the Superstition Mountains Arizona,\\u201d an AI-generated summary lists two waterfalls with details: Massacre Falls (First Water Trailhead; easy to moderate; seasonal flow mainly in winter or after rains; family-friendly, dog-friendly; scenic desert views) and Reavis Falls (Reavis Falls Trail; challenging; ~13 miles round trip; >3,000 ft gain; hidden gem deep in the wilderness; ~196\\u2011foot waterfall; beautiful scenery year-round). The summary also cites sources like jaceyoutwest.com and Only In Your State.", "reasoning": "The page\\u2019s summary explicitly identifies the notable waterfalls in the Superstition Mountains along with key hiking details, which is sufficient to answer the user\\u2019s question accurately.", "answer": "The two standout waterfalls to see while hiking in the Superstition Mountains are:\\n- Massacre Falls: Reached from First Water Trailhead; an easier, well-marked hike suitable for most skill levels. It\\u2019s a seasonal waterfall that flows mainly in winter or after significant rains, and the trail offers great desert scenery and is dog-friendly.\\n- Reavis Falls: A hidden gem deep in the Superstition Wilderness. This is a challenging hike (about 13 miles round\\u2011trip, >3,000 ft elevation gain) but rewards you with a spectacular ~196\\u2011foot waterfall and sweeping views, with beautiful scenery across seasons."} )', url='https://www.bing.com/search?q=best+waterfalls+to+see+while+hiking+in+the+Superstition+Mountains+Arizona&form=QBLH&sp=-1&ghc=1&lq=0&pq=best+waterfalls+to+see+while+hiking+in+the+superstition+mountains+arizon&sc=12-72&qs=n&sk=&cvid=4D2B7C22E0844E40995A7389B39B9F58', action='stop_and_answer_question', arguments={'state_description': 'On the Bing search results page for “best waterfalls to see while hiking in the Superstition Mountains Arizona,” an AI-generated summary lists two waterfalls with details: Massacre Falls (First Water Trailhead; easy to moderate; seasonal flow mainly in winter or after rains; family-friendly, dog-friendly; scenic desert views) and Reavis Falls (Reavis Falls Trail; challenging; ~13 miles round trip; >3,000 ft gain; hidden gem deep in the wilderness; ~196‑foot waterfall; beautiful scenery year-round). The summary also cites sources like jaceyoutwest.com and Only In Your State.', 'reasoning': 'The page’s summary explicitly identifies the notable waterfalls in the Superstition Mountains along with key hiking details, which is sufficient to answer the user’s question accurately.', 'answer': 'The two standout waterfalls to see while hiking in the Superstition Mountains are:\n- Massacre Falls: Reached from First Water Trailhead; an easier, well-marked hike suitable for most skill levels. It’s a seasonal waterfall that flows mainly in winter or after significant rains, and the trail offers great desert scenery and is dog-friendly.\n- Reavis Falls: A hidden gem deep in the Superstition Wilderness. This is a challenging hike (about 13 miles round‑trip, >3,000 ft elevation gain) but rewards you with a spectacular ~196‑foot waterfall and sweeping views, with beautiful scenery across seasons.'})+2025-11-10 13:17:33,852 [INFO] webeval.core.alltrails_find_23 - WebSurferEvent(source='WebSurfer', message='Web surfing done. Final target: The two standout waterfalls to see while hiking in the Superstition Mountains are:\n- Massacre Falls: Reached from First Water Trailhead; an easier, well-marked hike suitable for most skill levels. It’s a seasonal waterfall that flows mainly in winter or after significant rains, and the trail offers great desert scenery and is dog-friendly.\n- Reavis Falls: A hidden gem deep in the Superstition Wilderness. This is a challenging hike (about 13 miles round‑trip, >3,000 ft elevation gain) but rewards you with a spectacular ~196‑foot waterfall and sweeping views, with beautiful scenery across seasons.', url='https://www.bing.com/search?q=best+waterfalls+to+see+while+hiking+in+the+Superstition+Mountains+Arizona&form=QBLH&sp=-1&ghc=1&lq=0&pq=best+waterfalls+to+see+while+hiking+in+the+superstition+mountains+arizon&sc=12-72&qs=n&sk=&cvid=4D2B7C22E0844E40995A7389B39B9F58', action=None, arguments=None)+2025-11-10 13:17:34,113 [INFO] webeval.core.alltrails_find_23 - Closing browser...+2025-11-10 13:17:34,950 [INFO] webeval.core.alltrails_find_23 - [Execution alltrails_find_23] Completed+2025-11-10 13:17:35,097 [INFO] webeval.core.alltrails_find_23 - [Evaluation alltrails_find_23] Start+2025-11-10 13:19:12,957 [INFO] webeval.core.alltrails_find_23 - [Evaluation alltrails_find_23] Completed: score=1, duration=178.74161958694458+2026-03-26 15:47:15,749 [INFO] webeval.core.alltrails_find_23 - [Evaluation alltrails_find_23] Start+2026-03-26 15:47:15,749 [INFO] webeval.core.alltrails_find_23 - [Evaluation alltrails_find_23] Loading from: /data/corbyrosset/eval/webtailbench/runs/WebSurfer-gpt_solver-100-max_n_images-3/gpt-5/corbyrosset/HoldOut__data_corbyrosset_eval_webtailbench/step_budget_scales_max100steps_Nov10/traj/alltrails_find_23+2026-03-26 15:53:30,116 [INFO] webeval.core.alltrails_find_23 - [Rubric] Saved rubric results to /data/corbyrosset/eval/webtailbench/runs/WebSurfer-gpt_solver-100-max_n_images-3/gpt-5/corbyrosset/HoldOut__data_corbyrosset_eval_webtailbench/step_budget_scales_max100steps_Nov10/traj/alltrails_find_23/task_data.json+2026-03-26 15:53:30,118 [INFO] webeval.core.alltrails_find_23 - [Evaluation alltrails_find_23] Completed: score=1, duration=178.74161958694458+2026-03-26 16:14:42,819 [INFO] webeval.core.alltrails_find_23 - [Evaluation alltrails_find_23] Start+2026-03-26 16:14:42,819 [INFO] webeval.core.alltrails_find_23 - [Evaluation alltrails_find_23] Loading from: /data/corbyrosset/eval/webtailbench/runs/WebSurfer-gpt_solver-100-max_n_images-3/gpt-5/corbyrosset/HoldOut__data_corbyrosset_eval_webtailbench/step_budget_scales_max100steps_Nov10/traj/alltrails_find_23+2026-03-26 16:17:12,393 [INFO] webeval.core.alltrails_find_23 - [Rubric] Saved rubric results to /data/corbyrosset/eval/webtailbench/runs/WebSurfer-gpt_solver-100-max_n_images-3/gpt-5/corbyrosset/HoldOut__data_corbyrosset_eval_webtailbench/step_budget_scales_max100steps_Nov10/traj/alltrails_find_23/task_data.json+2026-03-26 16:17:12,396 [INFO] webeval.core.alltrails_find_23 - [Evaluation alltrails_find_23] Completed: score=1, duration=178.74161958694458+2026-03-26 16:57:30,478 [INFO] webeval.core.alltrails_find_23 - [Evaluation alltrails_find_23] Start+2026-03-26 16:57:30,478 [INFO] webeval.core.alltrails_find_23 - [Evaluation alltrails_find_23] Loading from: /data/corbyrosset/eval/webtailbench/runs/WebSurfer-gpt_solver-100-max_n_images-3/gpt-5/corbyrosset/HoldOut__data_corbyrosset_eval_webtailbench/step_budget_scales_max100steps_Nov10/traj/alltrails_find_23+2026-03-26 16:59:19,491 [INFO] webeval.core.alltrails_find_23 - [Rubric] Saved rubric results to /data/corbyrosset/eval/webtailbench/runs/WebSurfer-gpt_solver-100-max_n_images-3/gpt-5/corbyrosset/HoldOut__data_corbyrosset_eval_webtailbench/step_budget_scales_max100steps_Nov10/traj/alltrails_find_23/task_data.json+2026-03-26 16:59:19,494 [INFO] webeval.core.alltrails_find_23 - [Evaluation alltrails_find_23] Completed: score=1, duration=178.74161958694458diff --git a/webeval/data/example_trajectory/scores/mmrubric_0.8-5-3.json b/webeval/data/example_trajectory/scores/mmrubric_0.8-5-3.jsonnew file mode 100644index 0000000..64eea87--- /dev/null+++ b/webeval/data/example_trajectory/scores/mmrubric_0.8-5-3.json@@ -0,0 +1 @@+{"score": 1, "gpt_response_text": "{\"rubric_is_success\": 1, \"outcome_success\": true, \"outcome_reasoning\": \"\", \"outcome_primary_intent\": \"The user wanted recommendations for the best waterfalls that can be seen via hiking routes in the Superstition Mountains, Arizona. A reasonable user would be flexible on exact ranking/wording and whether the falls are seasonal, but not on the results actually being real waterfall hike destinations in/strongly associated with the Superstitions.\", \"rubric_items\": [{\"criterion\": \"Identify waterfalls to see while hiking in the Superstition Mountains\", \"description\": \"Provide recommendations of waterfalls (including seasonal/ephemeral falls) that can be visited as part of hikes in the Superstition Mountains, Arizona, or that are directly adjacent/commonly paired with Superstition hiking routes. Full credit if the agent identifies multiple (more than one) relevant waterfall destinations and/or clearly explains if true in-range options are limited and includes the closest reasonable hike-accessible alternatives that preserve the user\\u2019s intent. Partial credit if only one relevant waterfall is identified or if some suggestions are only loosely connected. No credit if recommendations are not waterfalls/cascades or are not in the Superstition/adjacent hiking context.\", \"max_points\": 6, \"justification\": \"The agent identified two distinct waterfalls\\u2014Massacre Falls and Reavis Falls\\u2014both accessible via hikes within the Superstition Mountains and provided relevant trailhead information, difficulty levels, and context. This satisfies the requirement to recommend multiple in-range waterfall destinations.\", \"earned_points\": 6, \"reality_notes\": \"Screenshots show a Bing \\u201cCopilot Search\\u201d summary explicitly naming two Superstition Mountains waterfall hike destinations: Massacre Falls and Reavis Falls. The page provides hiking context (trailhead names, difficulty) for both, and also includes distance/elevation/height details for Reavis Falls in later screenshots. No other waterfalls are shown in the evidence, so scoring should focus on whether the response correctly identifies at least these multiple, hike-accessible waterfalls in/associated with the Superstition Mountains.\", \"applicable_evidence\": \"Latest evidence is Screenshot 4 (also supported by Screenshot 3): Bing Copilot summary explicitly lists two Superstition Mountains waterfall hikes\\u20141) Massacre Falls and 2) Reavis Falls\\u2014with trailheads and hiking context. Screenshot 4 shows Massacre Falls (First Water Trailhead; easy-moderate; seasonal) and Reavis Falls (Reavis Falls Trail; challenging; ~13 mi RT; >3,000 ft gain; 196-ft waterfall).\", \"post_image_justification\": \"The agent output identifies multiple relevant waterfalls in the Superstition Mountains hiking context (Massacre Falls and Reavis Falls). This matches the on-screen list and satisfies the requirement to recommend more than one in-range, hike-accessible waterfall.\", \"post_image_earned_points\": 6.0}, {\"criterion\": \"Best/most suitable waterfall choices\", \"description\": \"Make clear which waterfalls are top picks (highlights rather than an arbitrary list) and give non-speculative, hiking-relevant reasons (e.g., scenery, typical popularity, relative accessibility, route pairing). Full credit if the agent provides grounded selection rationale and appropriately caveats external/variable factors beyond its control (e.g., seasonal flow, recent rainfall, closures). Partial credit if the agent lists highlights with minimal or generic rationale. No credit if it asserts 'best' based on invented specifics or substantially incorrect claims when better-known relevant options exist.\", \"max_points\": 4, \"justification\": \"The agent clearly labeled Massacre Falls and Reavis Falls as standout picks, explaining their relative accessibility, difficulty, seasonal flow considerations, and scenic highlights. It provided grounded, non-speculative reasons and caveated seasonal variability.\", \"earned_points\": 4, \"reality_notes\": \"The on-screen Copilot summary frames Massacre Falls and Reavis Falls as notable/highlight waterfalls (\\u201cstunning waterfalls like\\u2026\\u201d). It provides concrete, hiking-relevant rationale: Massacre Falls is \\u201ceasy to moderate\\u201d from First Water Trailhead and is seasonal (winter/after rainfall), described as well-marked/family-friendly; Reavis Falls is \\u201cchallenging,\\u201d ~13 miles round-trip, >3,000 ft gain, and features a ~196-foot waterfall and a more remote/less-trafficked character. A \\u201cdog owners\\u201d/dog-friendly angle for Massacre Falls is supported in the visible details in at least one screenshot, but any additional \\u2018best\\u2019 claims beyond these shown attributes aren\\u2019t evidenced here.\", \"applicable_evidence\": \"Latest evidence is Screenshot 4 (also Screenshot 3): provides grounded reasons to treat these as highlights\\u2014Massacre Falls is easier and seasonal; Reavis Falls is a challenging, remote 'hidden gem' with quantified distance/elevation and a 196-ft drop. Screenshot 3 additionally supports 'less trafficked' and Massacre Falls being suitable for a broad range of hikers (and indicates it\\u2019s good for dog owners).\", \"post_image_justification\": \"The agent clearly frames the two as standout/best picks and provides hiking-relevant, non-speculative justification consistent with the screenshots (accessibility + seasonality for Massacre Falls; strenuous stats + large waterfall for Reavis Falls). The seasonality caveat is appropriately included, and the 'dog-friendly' note is supported in the evidence.\", \"post_image_earned_points\": 4.0}], \"rubric_total_max_points\": 10.0, \"rubric_outcome_verification\": {\"primary_intent\": \"The user wanted recommendations for the best waterfalls that can be seen via hiking routes in the Superstition Mountains, Arizona. A reasonable user would be flexible on exact ranking/wording and whether the falls are seasonal, but not on the results actually being real waterfall hike destinations in/strongly associated with the Superstitions.\", \"reasoning\": \"Nitpicks: The answer only lists two waterfalls (could have included more options or nearby alternates), and some descriptive phrasing like \\u201csweeping views/beautiful scenery across seasons\\u201d is somewhat generic. These do not materially reduce usefulness. \\nCritical issues: None supported by the evidence. The screenshots (especially 3 and 4) explicitly list Massacre Falls and Reavis Falls as Superstition Mountains waterfalls with hike access and provide the same key hiking details the agent reported (trailheads, difficulty; for Reavis Falls ~13 miles round-trip, >3,000 ft gain, ~196-foot waterfall; for Massacre Falls seasonality and access from First Water Trailhead, plus dog-friendly language). \\nOutcome: The agent successfully identified and highlighted two relevant, hike-accessible waterfall destinations in the Superstition Mountains and gave hiking-relevant reasons/caveats (difficulty, seasonality, distance/elevation). This satisfies the user\\u2019s primary intent to identify the best waterfalls to see while hiking in the area.\", \"output_success\": true}, \"rubric_total_earned_points\": 10.0, \"rubric_intermediate_mm_rubric_steps\": {\"step1_num_screenshots\": 4, \"step2_relevance_scores\": {\"screenshot_0\": {\"0\": 0, \"1\": 0, \"screenshot_idx\": 0}, \"screenshot_1\": {\"0\": 9, \"1\": 7, \"screenshot_idx\": 1}, \"screenshot_2\": {\"0\": 9, \"1\": 8, \"screenshot_idx\": 2}, \"screenshot_3\": {\"0\": 9, \"1\": 8, \"screenshot_idx\": 3}}, \"step3_grouped_screenshots\": {\"0\": [3, 2, 1, 0], \"1\": [3, 2, 1, 0]}, \"step4_evidence_by_criterion\": {\"0\": [{\"screenshot_evidence\": \"The screenshot shows a Microsoft Bing results page with a \\u201cCopilot Search\\u201d summary. The headline reads: \\u201cThe Superstition Mountains offer stunning waterfalls like Massacre Falls and Reavis Falls, accessible via scenic hiking trails that cater to various skill levels.\\u201d Below it, two numbered entries are visible:\\n1. \\u201cMassacre Falls\\u201d with bullets including \\u201cTrailhead: First Water Trailhead\\u201d, \\u201cDifficulty: Easy to moderate\\u201d, and a \\u201cDetails:\\u201d paragraph noting it is \\u201ca seasonal waterfall that flows primarily during the winter months or after significant rainfall\\u2026\\u201d\\n2. \\u201cReavis Falls\\u201d with bullets including \\u201cTrailhead: Reavis Falls Trail\\u201d, \\u201cDifficulty: Challenging\\u201d, \\u201cDistance: Approximately 13 miles round-trip\\u201d, \\u201cElevation Gain: Over 3,000 feet\\u201d, and a \\u201cDetails:\\u201d paragraph mentioning a \\u201cstunning 196-foot waterfall.\\u201d\", \"criterion_analysis\": \"Meets the criterion. The screenshot clearly identifies multiple relevant waterfall hikes in the Superstition Mountains area (Massacre Falls and Reavis Falls) and includes hiking context (trailheads, difficulty, distance/elevation, and seasonal flow). The agent\\u2019s predicted output aligns with these two waterfall recommendations.\", \"discrepancies\": \"No substantive mismatch. The agent output lists the same two waterfalls and matches key visible details (First Water Trailhead; Reavis Falls Trail; seasonal flow; ~13 miles RT; >3,000 ft gain; ~196-foot waterfall).\", \"environment_issues_confirmed\": false, \"screenshot_idx\": 3}, {\"screenshot_evidence\": \"The screenshot shows a Microsoft Bing results page with a \\u201cCopilot Search\\u201d summary. The headline text reads: \\u201cThe Superstition Mountains offer stunning waterfalls like Massacre Falls and Reavis Falls, accessible via scenic hiking trails that cater to various skill levels.\\u201d Below it, two numbered entries are visible: \\u201c1. Massacre Falls\\u201d (with bullets including \\u201cTrailhead: First Water Trailhead\\u201d and \\u201cDifficulty: Easy to moderate\\u201d and a details paragraph describing it as a seasonal waterfall) and \\u201c2. Reavis Falls\\u201d (with bullets including \\u201cTrailhead: Reavis Falls Trail,\\u201d \\u201cDifficulty: Challenging,\\u201d \\u201cDistance: Approximately 13 miles round-trip,\\u201d \\u201cElevation Gain: Over 3,000 feet,\\u201d plus a details paragraph noting a \\u201c196-foot waterfall\\u201d).\", \"criterion_analysis\": \"The screenshot directly supports identifying multiple waterfalls to see while hiking in the Superstition Mountains: Massacre Falls and Reavis Falls. Because the page explicitly lists these as Superstition Mountains waterfalls with hike access/trailheads, this satisfies the requirement to identify more than one relevant waterfall destination.\", \"discrepancies\": \"No substantive mismatch: the agent\\u2019s predicted output lists Massacre Falls and Reavis Falls with the same trailheads/difficulty and generally matching hike context shown in the screenshot.\", \"environment_issues_confirmed\": false, \"screenshot_idx\": 2}, {\"screenshot_evidence\": \"The screenshot shows a Microsoft Bing results page with a \\u201cCopilot Search\\u201d summary. The visible headline text reads: \\u201cThe Superstition Mountains offer stunning waterfalls like Massacre Falls and Reavis Falls, accessible via scenic hiking trails that cater to various skill levels.\\u201d Below that, item \\u201c1. Massacre Falls\\u201d is expanded with bullets: \\u201cTrailhead: First Water Trailhead\\u201d, \\u201cDifficulty: Easy to moderate\\u201d, and a \\u201cDetails:\\u201d paragraph stating it is \\u201ca seasonal waterfall that flows primarily during the winter months or after significant rainfall\\u2026\\u201d. A \\u201cRead more\\u201d button is visible below the paragraph. Reavis Falls is mentioned in the headline sentence, but its detailed section is not visible in this screenshot.\", \"criterion_analysis\": \"The screenshot supports identifying at least two relevant waterfall destinations in the Superstition Mountains hiking context (Massacre Falls and Reavis Falls). Even though only Massacre Falls details are displayed, the page explicitly names both waterfalls as examples. This meets the \\u201cmultiple waterfalls\\u201d requirement, though the screenshot provides full on-screen detail for only one of them.\", \"discrepancies\": \"The agent\\u2019s predicted output provides detailed stats for Reavis Falls (e.g., ~13 miles round-trip, >3,000 ft gain, ~196-foot waterfall). Those specific Reavis Falls details are not visible anywhere in this screenshot; only the name \\u201cReavis Falls\\u201d appears in the headline sentence. The Massacre Falls details (First Water Trailhead; easy to moderate; seasonal winter/after rain) are consistent with visible text.\", \"environment_issues_confirmed\": false, \"screenshot_idx\": 1}], \"1\": [{\"screenshot_evidence\": \"The Copilot summary frames the items as notable choices: \\u201coffer stunning waterfalls like Massacre Falls and Reavis Falls,\\u201d and provides hiking-relevant reasons/details. For Massacre Falls it states \\u201cDifficulty: Easy to moderate\\u201d and describes it as \\u201cseasonal\\u2026 primarily during the winter months or after significant rainfall,\\u201d and \\u201cfamily-friendly.\\u201d For Reavis Falls it states \\u201cDifficulty: Challenging,\\u201d \\u201cDistance: Approximately 13 miles round-trip,\\u201d \\u201cElevation Gain: Over 3,000 feet,\\u201d and describes it as a \\u201chidden gem\\u2026 deep within the Superstition Wilderness\\u201d with a \\u201cstunning 196-foot waterfall.\\u201d\", \"criterion_analysis\": \"Largely satisfies the criterion. The agent highlights two \\u201cstandout\\u201d waterfalls and gives grounded, hike-relevant rationale consistent with the screenshot: accessibility/ease and seasonal flow for Massacre Falls; strenuous stats and major waterfall height/remote character for Reavis Falls. The agent output also appropriately notes seasonality (winter/after rains) matching the on-screen text.\", \"discrepancies\": \"Minor wording differences only (agent says \\u201cdog-friendly,\\u201d which is visible in the Massacre Falls details paragraph in the screenshot: \\u201cgreat for dog owners.\\u201d). Otherwise consistent with on-screen rationale and stats.\", \"environment_issues_confirmed\": false, \"screenshot_idx\": 3}, {\"screenshot_evidence\": \"The Copilot summary positions the waterfalls as highlights, stating the area offers \\u201cstunning waterfalls like Massacre Falls and Reavis Falls.\\u201d For Massacre Falls it shows \\u201cDifficulty: Easy to moderate\\u201d and the details say it is \\u201ca seasonal waterfall that flows primarily during the winter months or after significant rainfall,\\u201d and that the trail is \\u201cwell-marked and suitable for hikers of all skill levels.\\u201d For Reavis Falls it shows \\u201cDifficulty: Challenging,\\u201d \\u201cDistance: Approximately 13 miles round-trip,\\u201d \\u201cElevation Gain: Over 3,000 feet,\\u201d and the details mention a \\u201cstunning 196-foot waterfall\\u201d and that the trail is \\u201cless trafficked.\\u201d\", \"criterion_analysis\": \"The agent\\u2019s output presents the two waterfalls as the \\u201ctwo standout waterfalls\\u201d and gives hiking-relevant reasons that align with what\\u2019s visible: accessibility/ease and seasonal flow for Massacre Falls, and longer/challenging hike with large waterfall and remoteness for Reavis Falls. The seasonal/rainfall caveat is grounded in the screenshot for Massacre Falls; the output\\u2019s framing of \\u201cstandout\\u201d is consistent with the summary highlighting these two.\", \"discrepancies\": \"Minor: the agent output adds \\u201cdog-friendly\\u201d for Massacre Falls. The screenshot\\u2019s Massacre Falls details paragraph includes \\u201cgreat for dog owners,\\u201d which supports that. Otherwise, the output matches the visible difficulty/distance/elevation gain/196-foot claim for Reavis Falls.\", \"environment_issues_confirmed\": false, \"screenshot_idx\": 2}, {\"screenshot_evidence\": \"The Copilot summary frames the waterfalls as \\u201cstunning\\u201d and \\u201caccessible via scenic hiking trails that cater to various skill levels.\\u201d For Massacre Falls, the screenshot shows hiking-relevant reasons/attributes: \\u201cTrailhead: First Water Trailhead,\\u201d \\u201cDifficulty: Easy to moderate,\\u201d and that it is \\u201ca seasonal waterfall\\u201d flowing \\u201cprimarily during the winter months or after significant rainfall.\\u201d No comparable rationale/details for Reavis Falls are visible in the screenshot (only its name appears in the introductory sentence).\", \"criterion_analysis\": \"The agent\\u2019s output presents Massacre Falls and Reavis Falls as \\u201ctwo standout waterfalls,\\u201d which is generally supported by the Copilot header naming them as notable examples. The screenshot provides grounded, non-speculative rationale for Massacre Falls (access point, difficulty, and seasonality), which aligns with the agent\\u2019s claims about it being easier and seasonal. However, the agent\\u2019s stronger \\u201cbest\\u201d rationale for Reavis Falls (distance, elevation gain, and waterfall height) is not corroborated by this screenshot, so the justification for it being a top pick is not fully supported by the visible evidence here.\", \"discrepancies\": \"The agent adds claims not shown in the screenshot: that Massacre Falls is \\u201cdog-friendly\\u201d and that Reavis Falls is \\u201cchallenging\\u201d with \\u201cabout 13 miles round-trip,\\u201d \\u201c>3,000 ft elevation gain,\\u201d and a \\u201c~196-foot waterfall,\\u201d plus \\u201csweeping views\\u201d and \\u201cbeautiful scenery across seasons.\\u201d None of these Reavis Falls specifics, nor the \\u201cdog-friendly\\u201d note, are visible in the screenshot. The seasonality caveat for Massacre Falls does match visible text.\", \"environment_issues_confirmed\": false, \"screenshot_idx\": 1}]}, \"step5_reality_check\": {\"0\": \"Screenshots show a Bing \\u201cCopilot Search\\u201d summary explicitly naming two Superstition Mountains waterfall hike destinations: Massacre Falls and Reavis Falls. The page provides hiking context (trailhead names, difficulty) for both, and also includes distance/elevation/height details for Reavis Falls in later screenshots. No other waterfalls are shown in the evidence, so scoring should focus on whether the response correctly identifies at least these multiple, hike-accessible waterfalls in/associated with the Superstition Mountains.\", \"1\": \"The on-screen Copilot summary frames Massacre Falls and Reavis Falls as notable/highlight waterfalls (\\u201cstunning waterfalls like\\u2026\\u201d). It provides concrete, hiking-relevant rationale: Massacre Falls is \\u201ceasy to moderate\\u201d from First Water Trailhead and is seasonal (winter/after rainfall), described as well-marked/family-friendly; Reavis Falls is \\u201cchallenging,\\u201d ~13 miles round-trip, >3,000 ft gain, and features a ~196-foot waterfall and a more remote/less-trafficked character. A \\u201cdog owners\\u201d/dog-friendly angle for Massacre Falls is supported in the visible details in at least one screenshot, but any additional \\u2018best\\u2019 claims beyond these shown attributes aren\\u2019t evidenced here.\"}, \"step6_rescoring_summary\": [{\"criterion\": \"Identify waterfalls to see while hiking in the Superstition Mountains\", \"earned_points\": 6, \"post_image_earned_points\": 6.0, \"max_points\": 6, \"applicable_evidence\": \"Latest evidence is Screenshot 4 (also supported by Screenshot 3): Bing Copilot summary explicitly lists two Superstition Mountains waterfall hikes\\u20141) Massacre Falls and 2) Reavis Falls\\u2014with trailheads and hiking context. Screenshot 4 shows Massacre Falls (First Water Trailhead; easy-moderate; seasonal) and Reavis Falls (Reavis Falls Trail; challenging; ~13 mi RT; >3,000 ft gain; 196-ft waterfall).\", \"post_image_justification\": \"The agent output identifies multiple relevant waterfalls in the Superstition Mountains hiking context (Massacre Falls and Reavis Falls). This matches the on-screen list and satisfies the requirement to recommend more than one in-range, hike-accessible waterfall.\", \"reality_notes\": \"Screenshots show a Bing \\u201cCopilot Search\\u201d summary explicitly naming two Superstition Mountains waterfall hike destinations: Massacre Falls and Reavis Falls. The page provides hiking context (trailhead names, difficulty) for both, and also includes distance/elevation/height details for Reavis Falls in later screenshots. No other waterfalls are shown in the evidence, so scoring should focus on whether the response correctly identifies at least these multiple, hike-accessible waterfalls in/associated with the Superstition Mountains.\"}, {\"criterion\": \"Best/most suitable waterfall choices\", \"earned_points\": 4, \"post_image_earned_points\": 4.0, \"max_points\": 4, \"applicable_evidence\": \"Latest evidence is Screenshot 4 (also Screenshot 3): provides grounded reasons to treat these as highlights\\u2014Massacre Falls is easier and seasonal; Reavis Falls is a challenging, remote 'hidden gem' with quantified distance/elevation and a 196-ft drop. Screenshot 3 additionally supports 'less trafficked' and Massacre Falls being suitable for a broad range of hikers (and indicates it\\u2019s good for dog owners).\", \"post_image_justification\": \"The agent clearly frames the two as standout/best picks and provides hiking-relevant, non-speculative justification consistent with the screenshots (accessibility + seasonality for Massacre Falls; strenuous stats + large waterfall for Reavis Falls). The seasonality caveat is appropriately included, and the 'dog-friendly' note is supported in the evidence.\", \"reality_notes\": \"The on-screen Copilot summary frames Massacre Falls and Reavis Falls as notable/highlight waterfalls (\\u201cstunning waterfalls like\\u2026\\u201d). It provides concrete, hiking-relevant rationale: Massacre Falls is \\u201ceasy to moderate\\u201d from First Water Trailhead and is seasonal (winter/after rainfall), described as well-marked/family-friendly; Reavis Falls is \\u201cchallenging,\\u201d ~13 miles round-trip, >3,000 ft gain, and features a ~196-foot waterfall and a more remote/less-trafficked character. A \\u201cdog owners\\u201d/dog-friendly angle for Massacre Falls is supported in the visible details in at least one screenshot, but any additional \\u2018best\\u2019 claims beyond these shown attributes aren\\u2019t evidenced here.\"}], \"step7_penalty_criteria\": [], \"step7_reasoning\": \"The task was to identify the best waterfalls to see while hiking in the Superstition Mountains, AZ. The agent\\u2019s actions consisted of: opening Bing, entering the query, expanding/reading the AI summary box, and then providing the answer. These are all directly in service of the requested information-gathering task. There were no actions with lasting/material side effects (no purchases, cart additions, sign-ups, subscriptions, form submissions, or personal data entry). The only click was to expand/read more on the search results summary, which is normal exploratory behavior and not extraneous. The scored rubric summary already gives full credit and there is no unpenalized wrong substitution or side-effectful action to address. Therefore no new penalty criterion is warranted.\", \"step7_requires_penalty\": false, \"majority_vote_steps67\": {\"all_scores\": [1.0], \"median_instance_idx\": 0, \"all_instances\": [{\"instance_idx\": 0, \"score\": 1.0, \"total_earned_points\": 10.0, \"total_max_points\": 10.0, \"step6_rescoring_summary\": [{\"criterion\": \"Identify waterfalls to see while hiking in the Superstition Mountains\", \"earned_points\": 6, \"post_image_earned_points\": 6.0, \"max_points\": 6, \"applicable_evidence\": \"Latest evidence is Screenshot 4 (also supported by Screenshot 3): Bing Copilot summary explicitly lists two Superstition Mountains waterfall hikes\\u20141) Massacre Falls and 2) Reavis Falls\\u2014with trailheads and hiking context. Screenshot 4 shows Massacre Falls (First Water Trailhead; easy-moderate; seasonal) and Reavis Falls (Reavis Falls Trail; challenging; ~13 mi RT; >3,000 ft gain; 196-ft waterfall).\", \"post_image_justification\": \"The agent output identifies multiple relevant waterfalls in the Superstition Mountains hiking context (Massacre Falls and Reavis Falls). This matches the on-screen list and satisfies the requirement to recommend more than one in-range, hike-accessible waterfall.\", \"reality_notes\": \"Screenshots show a Bing \\u201cCopilot Search\\u201d summary explicitly naming two Superstition Mountains waterfall hike destinations: Massacre Falls and Reavis Falls. The page provides hiking context (trailhead names, difficulty) for both, and also includes distance/elevation/height details for Reavis Falls in later screenshots. No other waterfalls are shown in the evidence, so scoring should focus on whether the response correctly identifies at least these multiple, hike-accessible waterfalls in/associated with the Superstition Mountains.\"}, {\"criterion\": \"Best/most suitable waterfall choices\", \"earned_points\": 4, \"post_image_earned_points\": 4.0, \"max_points\": 4, \"applicable_evidence\": \"Latest evidence is Screenshot 4 (also Screenshot 3): provides grounded reasons to treat these as highlights\\u2014Massacre Falls is easier and seasonal; Reavis Falls is a challenging, remote 'hidden gem' with quantified distance/elevation and a 196-ft drop. Screenshot 3 additionally supports 'less trafficked' and Massacre Falls being suitable for a broad range of hikers (and indicates it\\u2019s good for dog owners).\", \"post_image_justification\": \"The agent clearly frames the two as standout/best picks and provides hiking-relevant, non-speculative justification consistent with the screenshots (accessibility + seasonality for Massacre Falls; strenuous stats + large waterfall for Reavis Falls). The seasonality caveat is appropriately included, and the 'dog-friendly' note is supported in the evidence.\", \"reality_notes\": \"The on-screen Copilot summary frames Massacre Falls and Reavis Falls as notable/highlight waterfalls (\\u201cstunning waterfalls like\\u2026\\u201d). It provides concrete, hiking-relevant rationale: Massacre Falls is \\u201ceasy to moderate\\u201d from First Water Trailhead and is seasonal (winter/after rainfall), described as well-marked/family-friendly; Reavis Falls is \\u201cchallenging,\\u201d ~13 miles round-trip, >3,000 ft gain, and features a ~196-foot waterfall and a more remote/less-trafficked character. A \\u201cdog owners\\u201d/dog-friendly angle for Massacre Falls is supported in the visible details in at least one screenshot, but any additional \\u2018best\\u2019 claims beyond these shown attributes aren\\u2019t evidenced here.\"}], \"step7_requires_penalty\": false, \"step7_reasoning\": \"The task was to identify the best waterfalls to see while hiking in the Superstition Mountains, AZ. The agent\\u2019s actions consisted of: opening Bing, entering the query, expanding/reading the AI summary box, and then providing the answer. These are all directly in service of the requested information-gathering task. There were no actions with lasting/material side effects (no purchases, cart additions, sign-ups, subscriptions, form submissions, or personal data entry). The only click was to expand/read more on the search results summary, which is normal exploratory behavior and not extraneous. The scored rubric summary already gives full credit and there is no unpenalized wrong substitution or side-effectful action to address. Therefore no new penalty criterion is warranted.\", \"step7_penalty_criteria\": []}]}, \"step8_outcome_verification\": {\"primary_intent\": \"The user wanted recommendations for the best waterfalls that can be seen via hiking routes in the Superstition Mountains, Arizona. A reasonable user would be flexible on exact ranking/wording and whether the falls are seasonal, but not on the results actually being real waterfall hike destinations in/strongly associated with the Superstitions.\", \"reasoning\": \"Nitpicks: The answer only lists two waterfalls (could have included more options or nearby alternates), and some descriptive phrasing like \\u201csweeping views/beautiful scenery across seasons\\u201d is somewhat generic. These do not materially reduce usefulness. \\nCritical issues: None supported by the evidence. The screenshots (especially 3 and 4) explicitly list Massacre Falls and Reavis Falls as Superstition Mountains waterfalls with hike access and provide the same key hiking details the agent reported (trailheads, difficulty; for Reavis Falls ~13 miles round-trip, >3,000 ft gain, ~196-foot waterfall; for Massacre Falls seasonality and access from First Water Trailhead, plus dog-friendly language). \\nOutcome: The agent successfully identified and highlighted two relevant, hike-accessible waterfall destinations in the Superstition Mountains and gave hiking-relevant reasons/caveats (difficulty, seasonality, distance/elevation). This satisfies the user\\u2019s primary intent to identify the best waterfalls to see while hiking in the area.\", \"output_success\": true}, \"majority_vote_step8\": {\"all_votes\": [true], \"majority_output_success\": true, \"all_results\": [{\"primary_intent\": \"The user wanted recommendations for the best waterfalls that can be seen via hiking routes in the Superstition Mountains, Arizona. A reasonable user would be flexible on exact ranking/wording and whether the falls are seasonal, but not on the results actually being real waterfall hike destinations in/strongly associated with the Superstitions.\", \"reasoning\": \"Nitpicks: The answer only lists two waterfalls (could have included more options or nearby alternates), and some descriptive phrasing like \\u201csweeping views/beautiful scenery across seasons\\u201d is somewhat generic. These do not materially reduce usefulness. \\nCritical issues: None supported by the evidence. The screenshots (especially 3 and 4) explicitly list Massacre Falls and Reavis Falls as Superstition Mountains waterfalls with hike access and provide the same key hiking details the agent reported (trailheads, difficulty; for Reavis Falls ~13 miles round-trip, >3,000 ft gain, ~196-foot waterfall; for Massacre Falls seasonality and access from First Water Trailhead, plus dog-friendly language). \\nOutcome: The agent successfully identified and highlighted two relevant, hike-accessible waterfall destinations in the Superstition Mountains and gave hiking-relevant reasons/caveats (difficulty, seasonality, distance/elevation). This satisfies the user\\u2019s primary intent to identify the best waterfalls to see while hiking in the area.\", \"output_success\": true}]}}, \"rubric_majority_vote_metadata\": {\"n_instances\": 1, \"median_instance_idx\": 0, \"all_scores\": [1.0], \"median_score\": 1.0, \"outcome_votes\": [true], \"majority_output_success\": true}, \"rubric_all_rubric_dicts\": [{\"items\": [{\"criterion\": \"Identify waterfalls to see while hiking in the Superstition Mountains\", \"description\": \"Provide recommendations of waterfalls (including seasonal/ephemeral falls) that can be visited as part of hikes in the Superstition Mountains, Arizona, or that are directly adjacent/commonly paired with Superstition hiking routes. Full credit if the agent identifies multiple (more than one) relevant waterfall destinations and/or clearly explains if true in-range options are limited and includes the closest reasonable hike-accessible alternatives that preserve the user\\u2019s intent. Partial credit if only one relevant waterfall is identified or if some suggestions are only loosely connected. No credit if recommendations are not waterfalls/cascades or are not in the Superstition/adjacent hiking context.\", \"max_points\": 6, \"justification\": \"The agent identified two distinct waterfalls\\u2014Massacre Falls and Reavis Falls\\u2014both accessible via hikes within the Superstition Mountains and provided relevant trailhead information, difficulty levels, and context. This satisfies the requirement to recommend multiple in-range waterfall destinations.\", \"earned_points\": 6, \"reality_notes\": \"Screenshots show a Bing \\u201cCopilot Search\\u201d summary explicitly naming two Superstition Mountains waterfall hike destinations: Massacre Falls and Reavis Falls. The page provides hiking context (trailhead names, difficulty) for both, and also includes distance/elevation/height details for Reavis Falls in later screenshots. No other waterfalls are shown in the evidence, so scoring should focus on whether the response correctly identifies at least these multiple, hike-accessible waterfalls in/associated with the Superstition Mountains.\", \"applicable_evidence\": \"Latest evidence is Screenshot 4 (also supported by Screenshot 3): Bing Copilot summary explicitly lists two Superstition Mountains waterfall hikes\\u20141) Massacre Falls and 2) Reavis Falls\\u2014with trailheads and hiking context. Screenshot 4 shows Massacre Falls (First Water Trailhead; easy-moderate; seasonal) and Reavis Falls (Reavis Falls Trail; challenging; ~13 mi RT; >3,000 ft gain; 196-ft waterfall).\", \"post_image_justification\": \"The agent output identifies multiple relevant waterfalls in the Superstition Mountains hiking context (Massacre Falls and Reavis Falls). This matches the on-screen list and satisfies the requirement to recommend more than one in-range, hike-accessible waterfall.\", \"post_image_earned_points\": 6.0}, {\"criterion\": \"Best/most suitable waterfall choices\", \"description\": \"Make clear which waterfalls are top picks (highlights rather than an arbitrary list) and give non-speculative, hiking-relevant reasons (e.g., scenery, typical popularity, relative accessibility, route pairing). Full credit if the agent provides grounded selection rationale and appropriately caveats external/variable factors beyond its control (e.g., seasonal flow, recent rainfall, closures). Partial credit if the agent lists highlights with minimal or generic rationale. No credit if it asserts 'best' based on invented specifics or substantially incorrect claims when better-known relevant options exist.\", \"max_points\": 4, \"justification\": \"The agent clearly labeled Massacre Falls and Reavis Falls as standout picks, explaining their relative accessibility, difficulty, seasonal flow considerations, and scenic highlights. It provided grounded, non-speculative reasons and caveated seasonal variability.\", \"earned_points\": 4, \"reality_notes\": \"The on-screen Copilot summary frames Massacre Falls and Reavis Falls as notable/highlight waterfalls (\\u201cstunning waterfalls like\\u2026\\u201d). It provides concrete, hiking-relevant rationale: Massacre Falls is \\u201ceasy to moderate\\u201d from First Water Trailhead and is seasonal (winter/after rainfall), described as well-marked/family-friendly; Reavis Falls is \\u201cchallenging,\\u201d ~13 miles round-trip, >3,000 ft gain, and features a ~196-foot waterfall and a more remote/less-trafficked character. A \\u201cdog owners\\u201d/dog-friendly angle for Massacre Falls is supported in the visible details in at least one screenshot, but any additional \\u2018best\\u2019 claims beyond these shown attributes aren\\u2019t evidenced here.\", \"applicable_evidence\": \"Latest evidence is Screenshot 4 (also Screenshot 3): provides grounded reasons to treat these as highlights\\u2014Massacre Falls is easier and seasonal; Reavis Falls is a challenging, remote 'hidden gem' with quantified distance/elevation and a 196-ft drop. Screenshot 3 additionally supports 'less trafficked' and Massacre Falls being suitable for a broad range of hikers (and indicates it\\u2019s good for dog owners).\", \"post_image_justification\": \"The agent clearly frames the two as standout/best picks and provides hiking-relevant, non-speculative justification consistent with the screenshots (accessibility + seasonality for Massacre Falls; strenuous stats + large waterfall for Reavis Falls). The seasonality caveat is appropriately included, and the 'dog-friendly' note is supported in the evidence.\", \"post_image_earned_points\": 4.0}], \"total_max_points\": 10.0, \"outcome_verification\": {\"primary_intent\": \"The user wanted recommendations for the best waterfalls that can be seen via hiking routes in the Superstition Mountains, Arizona. A reasonable user would be flexible on exact ranking/wording and whether the falls are seasonal, but not on the results actually being real waterfall hike destinations in/strongly associated with the Superstitions.\", \"reasoning\": \"Nitpicks: The answer only lists two waterfalls (could have included more options or nearby alternates), and some descriptive phrasing like \\u201csweeping views/beautiful scenery across seasons\\u201d is somewhat generic. These do not materially reduce usefulness. \\nCritical issues: None supported by the evidence. The screenshots (especially 3 and 4) explicitly list Massacre Falls and Reavis Falls as Superstition Mountains waterfalls with hike access and provide the same key hiking details the agent reported (trailheads, difficulty; for Reavis Falls ~13 miles round-trip, >3,000 ft gain, ~196-foot waterfall; for Massacre Falls seasonality and access from First Water Trailhead, plus dog-friendly language). \\nOutcome: The agent successfully identified and highlighted two relevant, hike-accessible waterfall destinations in the Superstition Mountains and gave hiking-relevant reasons/caveats (difficulty, seasonality, distance/elevation). This satisfies the user\\u2019s primary intent to identify the best waterfalls to see while hiking in the area.\", \"output_success\": true}, \"total_earned_points\": 10.0}], \"rubric_all_scores_list\": [1.0], \"is_success\": 1}"}\ No newline at end of filediff --git a/webeval/data/example_trajectory/screenshot_1.png b/webeval/data/example_trajectory/screenshot_1.pngnew file mode 100644index 0000000..582836cBinary files /dev/null and b/webeval/data/example_trajectory/screenshot_1.png differdiff --git a/webeval/data/example_trajectory/screenshot_2.png b/webeval/data/example_trajectory/screenshot_2.pngnew file mode 100644index 0000000..b2c608eBinary files /dev/null and b/webeval/data/example_trajectory/screenshot_2.png differdiff --git a/webeval/data/example_trajectory/screenshot_3.png b/webeval/data/example_trajectory/screenshot_3.pngnew file mode 100644index 0000000..ee8e3c5Binary files /dev/null and b/webeval/data/example_trajectory/screenshot_3.png differdiff --git a/webeval/data/example_trajectory/screenshot_4.png b/webeval/data/example_trajectory/screenshot_4.pngnew file mode 100644index 0000000..ee8e3c5Binary files /dev/null and b/webeval/data/example_trajectory/screenshot_4.png differdiff --git a/webeval/data/example_trajectory/task_data.json b/webeval/data/example_trajectory/task_data.jsonnew file mode 100644index 0000000..dc62dbf--- /dev/null+++ b/webeval/data/example_trajectory/task_data.json@@ -0,0 +1,512 @@+{+ "environment": "browser",+ "init_url": "",+ "start_timestamp": "2025-11-10T13:15:12.358963",+ "end_timestamp": "2025-11-10T13:17:26.971700",+ "viewport_width": null,+ "viewport_height": null,+ "url_unreachable": null,+ "url_language": "",+ "url_category": "",+ "is_url_NSFW": null,+ "is_likely_illegal": null,+ "is_PII": null,+ "required_clarification_questions": [],+ "clarification_questions_answered": [],+ "url_interactiveness_rating": null,+ "coherence_rating": null,+ "task_complexity": "",+ "task_ideas": [],+ "initial_task_proposal": "Identify the best waterfalls to see while hiking in the Superstition Mountains, Arizona",+ "task_proposal": "Identify the best waterfalls to see while hiking in the Superstition Mountains, Arizona",+ "plan_list": [],+ "facts_list": [],+ "solver_ledger": [],+ "did_web_surfing_fail": false,+ "web_surfing_stalled": 0,+ "web_surfing_stalled_and_replanned": 0,+ "web_surfing_memorized_fact": 0,+ "web_surfing_identified_target": 0,+ "web_surfing_forgot_to_identify_target": 0,+ "did_failed_after_attempting_to_fix": false,+ "attempted_error_fix": 0,+ "retroactively_identified_target": null,+ "rollback_premature_stop_action": 0,+ "web_surfer_forced_into_endstate": 0,+ "web_surfing_at_critical_point": false,+ "is_web_surfing_done": true,+ "output_target": null,+ "solver_predicted_output": "The two standout waterfalls to see while hiking in the Superstition Mountains are:\n- Massacre Falls: Reached from First Water Trailhead; an easier, well-marked hike suitable for most skill levels. It\u2019s a seasonal waterfall that flows mainly in winter or after significant rains, and the trail offers great desert scenery and is dog-friendly.\n- Reavis Falls: A hidden gem deep in the Superstition Wilderness. This is a challenging hike (about 13 miles round\u2011trip, >3,000 ft elevation gain) but rewards you with a spectacular ~196\u2011foot waterfall and sweeping views, with beautiful scenery across seasons.",+ "web_sufing_steps_exceeded": null,+ "replanning_exceeded": null,+ "web_surfing_timed_out": null,+ "encountered_captcha": false,+ "failed_to_solve_captcha": false,+ "openai_bad_request_error": false,+ "preliminary_successful": null,+ "task_summary": "Identify the best waterfalls to see while hiking in the Superstition Mountains, Arizona",+ "summary_abstract": "",+ "erasable_domain_specific_prompt": "",+ "task_proposal_specificity": null,+ "verifier_agent_response": null,+ "task_type": "",+ "task_difficulty": "",+ "verifier_bool": null,+ "did_agent_access_relevant_information": null,+ "crossed_critical_point": null,+ "verifier_rubric": null,+ "rubric_score": null,+ "precomputed_rubric": {+ "items": [+ {+ "criterion": "Identify waterfalls to see while hiking in the Superstition Mountains",+ "description": "Provide recommendations of waterfalls (including seasonal/ephemeral falls) that can be visited as part of hikes in the Superstition Mountains, Arizona, or that are directly adjacent/commonly paired with Superstition hiking routes. Full credit if the agent identifies multiple (more than one) relevant waterfall destinations and/or clearly explains if true in-range options are limited and includes the closest reasonable hike-accessible alternatives that preserve the user\u2019s intent. Partial credit if only one relevant waterfall is identified or if some suggestions are only loosely connected. No credit if recommendations are not waterfalls/cascades or are not in the Superstition/adjacent hiking context.",+ "max_points": 6,+ "justification": "The agent identified two distinct waterfalls\u2014Massacre Falls and Reavis Falls\u2014both accessible via hikes within the Superstition Mountains and provided relevant trailhead information, difficulty levels, and context. This satisfies the requirement to recommend multiple in-range waterfall destinations.",+ "earned_points": 6,+ "reality_notes": "Screenshots show a Bing \u201cCopilot Search\u201d summary explicitly naming two Superstition Mountains waterfall hike destinations: Massacre Falls and Reavis Falls. The page provides hiking context (trailhead names, difficulty) for both, and also includes distance/elevation/height details for Reavis Falls in later screenshots. No other waterfalls are shown in the evidence, so scoring should focus on whether the response correctly identifies at least these multiple, hike-accessible waterfalls in/associated with the Superstition Mountains.",+ "applicable_evidence": "Latest evidence is Screenshot 4 (also supported by Screenshot 3): Bing Copilot summary explicitly lists two Superstition Mountains waterfall hikes\u20141) Massacre Falls and 2) Reavis Falls\u2014with trailheads and hiking context. Screenshot 4 shows Massacre Falls (First Water Trailhead; easy-moderate; seasonal) and Reavis Falls (Reavis Falls Trail; challenging; ~13 mi RT; >3,000 ft gain; 196-ft waterfall).",+ "post_image_justification": "The agent output identifies multiple relevant waterfalls in the Superstition Mountains hiking context (Massacre Falls and Reavis Falls). This matches the on-screen list and satisfies the requirement to recommend more than one in-range, hike-accessible waterfall.",+ "post_image_earned_points": 6.0+ },+ {+ "criterion": "Best/most suitable waterfall choices",+ "description": "Make clear which waterfalls are top picks (highlights rather than an arbitrary list) and give non-speculative, hiking-relevant reasons (e.g., scenery, typical popularity, relative accessibility, route pairing). Full credit if the agent provides grounded selection rationale and appropriately caveats external/variable factors beyond its control (e.g., seasonal flow, recent rainfall, closures). Partial credit if the agent lists highlights with minimal or generic rationale. No credit if it asserts 'best' based on invented specifics or substantially incorrect claims when better-known relevant options exist.",+ "max_points": 4,+ "justification": "The agent clearly labeled Massacre Falls and Reavis Falls as standout picks, explaining their relative accessibility, difficulty, seasonal flow considerations, and scenic highlights. It provided grounded, non-speculative reasons and caveated seasonal variability.",+ "earned_points": 4,+ "reality_notes": "The on-screen Copilot summary frames Massacre Falls and Reavis Falls as notable/highlight waterfalls (\u201cstunning waterfalls like\u2026\u201d). It provides concrete, hiking-relevant rationale: Massacre Falls is \u201ceasy to moderate\u201d from First Water Trailhead and is seasonal (winter/after rainfall), described as well-marked/family-friendly; Reavis Falls is \u201cchallenging,\u201d ~13 miles round-trip, >3,000 ft gain, and features a ~196-foot waterfall and a more remote/less-trafficked character. A \u201cdog owners\u201d/dog-friendly angle for Massacre Falls is supported in the visible details in at least one screenshot, but any additional \u2018best\u2019 claims beyond these shown attributes aren\u2019t evidenced here.",+ "applicable_evidence": "Latest evidence is Screenshot 4 (also Screenshot 3): provides grounded reasons to treat these as highlights\u2014Massacre Falls is easier and seasonal; Reavis Falls is a challenging, remote 'hidden gem' with quantified distance/elevation and a 196-ft drop. Screenshot 3 additionally supports 'less trafficked' and Massacre Falls being suitable for a broad range of hikers (and indicates it\u2019s good for dog owners).",+ "post_image_justification": "The agent clearly frames the two as standout/best picks and provides hiking-relevant, non-speculative justification consistent with the screenshots (accessibility + seasonality for Massacre Falls; strenuous stats + large waterfall for Reavis Falls). The seasonality caveat is appropriately included, and the 'dog-friendly' note is supported in the evidence.",+ "post_image_earned_points": 4.0+ }+ ],+ "total_max_points": 10.0,+ "outcome_verification": {+ "primary_intent": "The user wanted recommendations for the best waterfalls that can be seen via hiking routes in the Superstition Mountains, Arizona. A reasonable user would be flexible on exact ranking/wording and whether the falls are seasonal, but not on the results actually being real waterfall hike destinations in/strongly associated with the Superstitions.",+ "reasoning": "Nitpicks: The answer only lists two waterfalls (could have included more options or nearby alternates), and some descriptive phrasing like \u201csweeping views/beautiful scenery across seasons\u201d is somewhat generic. These do not materially reduce usefulness. \nCritical issues: None supported by the evidence. The screenshots (especially 3 and 4) explicitly list Massacre Falls and Reavis Falls as Superstition Mountains waterfalls with hike access and provide the same key hiking details the agent reported (trailheads, difficulty; for Reavis Falls ~13 miles round-trip, >3,000 ft gain, ~196-foot waterfall; for Massacre Falls seasonality and access from First Water Trailhead, plus dog-friendly language). \nOutcome: The agent successfully identified and highlighted two relevant, hike-accessible waterfall destinations in the Superstition Mountains and gave hiking-relevant reasons/caveats (difficulty, seasonality, distance/elevation). This satisfies the user\u2019s primary intent to identify the best waterfalls to see while hiking in the area.",+ "output_success": true+ },+ "total_earned_points": 10.0+ },+ "intermediate_mm_rubric_steps": {+ "step1_num_screenshots": 4,+ "step2_relevance_scores": {+ "screenshot_0": {+ "0": 0,+ "1": 0,+ "screenshot_idx": 0+ },+ "screenshot_1": {+ "0": 9,+ "1": 7,+ "screenshot_idx": 1+ },+ "screenshot_2": {+ "0": 9,+ "1": 8,+ "screenshot_idx": 2+ },+ "screenshot_3": {+ "0": 9,+ "1": 8,+ "screenshot_idx": 3+ }+ },+ "step3_grouped_screenshots": {+ "0": [+ 3,+ 2,+ 1,+ 0+ ],+ "1": [+ 3,+ 2,+ 1,+ 0+ ]+ },+ "step4_evidence_by_criterion": {+ "0": [+ {+ "screenshot_evidence": "The screenshot shows a Microsoft Bing results page with a \u201cCopilot Search\u201d summary. The headline reads: \u201cThe Superstition Mountains offer stunning waterfalls like Massacre Falls and Reavis Falls, accessible via scenic hiking trails that cater to various skill levels.\u201d Below it, two numbered entries are visible:\n1. \u201cMassacre Falls\u201d with bullets including \u201cTrailhead: First Water Trailhead\u201d, \u201cDifficulty: Easy to moderate\u201d, and a \u201cDetails:\u201d paragraph noting it is \u201ca seasonal waterfall that flows primarily during the winter months or after significant rainfall\u2026\u201d\n2. \u201cReavis Falls\u201d with bullets including \u201cTrailhead: Reavis Falls Trail\u201d, \u201cDifficulty: Challenging\u201d, \u201cDistance: Approximately 13 miles round-trip\u201d, \u201cElevation Gain: Over 3,000 feet\u201d, and a \u201cDetails:\u201d paragraph mentioning a \u201cstunning 196-foot waterfall.\u201d",+ "criterion_analysis": "Meets the criterion. The screenshot clearly identifies multiple relevant waterfall hikes in the Superstition Mountains area (Massacre Falls and Reavis Falls) and includes hiking context (trailheads, difficulty, distance/elevation, and seasonal flow). The agent\u2019s predicted output aligns with these two waterfall recommendations.",+ "discrepancies": "No substantive mismatch. The agent output lists the same two waterfalls and matches key visible details (First Water Trailhead; Reavis Falls Trail; seasonal flow; ~13 miles RT; >3,000 ft gain; ~196-foot waterfall).",+ "environment_issues_confirmed": false,+ "screenshot_idx": 3+ },+ {+ "screenshot_evidence": "The screenshot shows a Microsoft Bing results page with a \u201cCopilot Search\u201d summary. The headline text reads: \u201cThe Superstition Mountains offer stunning waterfalls like Massacre Falls and Reavis Falls, accessible via scenic hiking trails that cater to various skill levels.\u201d Below it, two numbered entries are visible: \u201c1. Massacre Falls\u201d (with bullets including \u201cTrailhead: First Water Trailhead\u201d and \u201cDifficulty: Easy to moderate\u201d and a details paragraph describing it as a seasonal waterfall) and \u201c2. Reavis Falls\u201d (with bullets including \u201cTrailhead: Reavis Falls Trail,\u201d \u201cDifficulty: Challenging,\u201d \u201cDistance: Approximately 13 miles round-trip,\u201d \u201cElevation Gain: Over 3,000 feet,\u201d plus a details paragraph noting a \u201c196-foot waterfall\u201d).",+ "criterion_analysis": "The screenshot directly supports identifying multiple waterfalls to see while hiking in the Superstition Mountains: Massacre Falls and Reavis Falls. Because the page explicitly lists these as Superstition Mountains waterfalls with hike access/trailheads, this satisfies the requirement to identify more than one relevant waterfall destination.",+ "discrepancies": "No substantive mismatch: the agent\u2019s predicted output lists Massacre Falls and Reavis Falls with the same trailheads/difficulty and generally matching hike context shown in the screenshot.",+ "environment_issues_confirmed": false,+ "screenshot_idx": 2+ },+ {+ "screenshot_evidence": "The screenshot shows a Microsoft Bing results page with a \u201cCopilot Search\u201d summary. The visible headline text reads: \u201cThe Superstition Mountains offer stunning waterfalls like Massacre Falls and Reavis Falls, accessible via scenic hiking trails that cater to various skill levels.\u201d Below that, item \u201c1. Massacre Falls\u201d is expanded with bullets: \u201cTrailhead: First Water Trailhead\u201d, \u201cDifficulty: Easy to moderate\u201d, and a \u201cDetails:\u201d paragraph stating it is \u201ca seasonal waterfall that flows primarily during the winter months or after significant rainfall\u2026\u201d. A \u201cRead more\u201d button is visible below the paragraph. Reavis Falls is mentioned in the headline sentence, but its detailed section is not visible in this screenshot.",+ "criterion_analysis": "The screenshot supports identifying at least two relevant waterfall destinations in the Superstition Mountains hiking context (Massacre Falls and Reavis Falls). Even though only Massacre Falls details are displayed, the page explicitly names both waterfalls as examples. This meets the \u201cmultiple waterfalls\u201d requirement, though the screenshot provides full on-screen detail for only one of them.",+ "discrepancies": "The agent\u2019s predicted output provides detailed stats for Reavis Falls (e.g., ~13 miles round-trip, >3,000 ft gain, ~196-foot waterfall). Those specific Reavis Falls details are not visible anywhere in this screenshot; only the name \u201cReavis Falls\u201d appears in the headline sentence. The Massacre Falls details (First Water Trailhead; easy to moderate; seasonal winter/after rain) are consistent with visible text.",+ "environment_issues_confirmed": false,+ "screenshot_idx": 1+ }+ ],+ "1": [+ {+ "screenshot_evidence": "The Copilot summary frames the items as notable choices: \u201coffer stunning waterfalls like Massacre Falls and Reavis Falls,\u201d and provides hiking-relevant reasons/details. For Massacre Falls it states \u201cDifficulty: Easy to moderate\u201d and describes it as \u201cseasonal\u2026 primarily during the winter months or after significant rainfall,\u201d and \u201cfamily-friendly.\u201d For Reavis Falls it states \u201cDifficulty: Challenging,\u201d \u201cDistance: Approximately 13 miles round-trip,\u201d \u201cElevation Gain: Over 3,000 feet,\u201d and describes it as a \u201chidden gem\u2026 deep within the Superstition Wilderness\u201d with a \u201cstunning 196-foot waterfall.\u201d",+ "criterion_analysis": "Largely satisfies the criterion. The agent highlights two \u201cstandout\u201d waterfalls and gives grounded, hike-relevant rationale consistent with the screenshot: accessibility/ease and seasonal flow for Massacre Falls; strenuous stats and major waterfall height/remote character for Reavis Falls. The agent output also appropriately notes seasonality (winter/after rains) matching the on-screen text.",+ "discrepancies": "Minor wording differences only (agent says \u201cdog-friendly,\u201d which is visible in the Massacre Falls details paragraph in the screenshot: \u201cgreat for dog owners.\u201d). Otherwise consistent with on-screen rationale and stats.",+ "environment_issues_confirmed": false,+ "screenshot_idx": 3+ },+ {+ "screenshot_evidence": "The Copilot summary positions the waterfalls as highlights, stating the area offers \u201cstunning waterfalls like Massacre Falls and Reavis Falls.\u201d For Massacre Falls it shows \u201cDifficulty: Easy to moderate\u201d and the details say it is \u201ca seasonal waterfall that flows primarily during the winter months or after significant rainfall,\u201d and that the trail is \u201cwell-marked and suitable for hikers of all skill levels.\u201d For Reavis Falls it shows \u201cDifficulty: Challenging,\u201d \u201cDistance: Approximately 13 miles round-trip,\u201d \u201cElevation Gain: Over 3,000 feet,\u201d and the details mention a \u201cstunning 196-foot waterfall\u201d and that the trail is \u201cless trafficked.\u201d",+ "criterion_analysis": "The agent\u2019s output presents the two waterfalls as the \u201ctwo standout waterfalls\u201d and gives hiking-relevant reasons that align with what\u2019s visible: accessibility/ease and seasonal flow for Massacre Falls, and longer/challenging hike with large waterfall and remoteness for Reavis Falls. The seasonal/rainfall caveat is grounded in the screenshot for Massacre Falls; the output\u2019s framing of \u201cstandout\u201d is consistent with the summary highlighting these two.",+ "discrepancies": "Minor: the agent output adds \u201cdog-friendly\u201d for Massacre Falls. The screenshot\u2019s Massacre Falls details paragraph includes \u201cgreat for dog owners,\u201d which supports that. Otherwise, the output matches the visible difficulty/distance/elevation gain/196-foot claim for Reavis Falls.",+ "environment_issues_confirmed": false,+ "screenshot_idx": 2+ },+ {+ "screenshot_evidence": "The Copilot summary frames the waterfalls as \u201cstunning\u201d and \u201caccessible via scenic hiking trails that cater to various skill levels.\u201d For Massacre Falls, the screenshot shows hiking-relevant reasons/attributes: \u201cTrailhead: First Water Trailhead,\u201d \u201cDifficulty: Easy to moderate,\u201d and that it is \u201ca seasonal waterfall\u201d flowing \u201cprimarily during the winter months or after significant rainfall.\u201d No comparable rationale/details for Reavis Falls are visible in the screenshot (only its name appears in the introductory sentence).",+ "criterion_analysis": "The agent\u2019s output presents Massacre Falls and Reavis Falls as \u201ctwo standout waterfalls,\u201d which is generally supported by the Copilot header naming them as notable examples. The screenshot provides grounded, non-speculative rationale for Massacre Falls (access point, difficulty, and seasonality), which aligns with the agent\u2019s claims about it being easier and seasonal. However, the agent\u2019s stronger \u201cbest\u201d rationale for Reavis Falls (distance, elevation gain, and waterfall height) is not corroborated by this screenshot, so the justification for it being a top pick is not fully supported by the visible evidence here.",+ "discrepancies": "The agent adds claims not shown in the screenshot: that Massacre Falls is \u201cdog-friendly\u201d and that Reavis Falls is \u201cchallenging\u201d with \u201cabout 13 miles round-trip,\u201d \u201c>3,000 ft elevation gain,\u201d and a \u201c~196-foot waterfall,\u201d plus \u201csweeping views\u201d and \u201cbeautiful scenery across seasons.\u201d None of these Reavis Falls specifics, nor the \u201cdog-friendly\u201d note, are visible in the screenshot. The seasonality caveat for Massacre Falls does match visible text.",+ "environment_issues_confirmed": false,+ "screenshot_idx": 1+ }+ ]+ },+ "step5_reality_check": {+ "0": "Screenshots show a Bing \u201cCopilot Search\u201d summary explicitly naming two Superstition Mountains waterfall hike destinations: Massacre Falls and Reavis Falls. The page provides hiking context (trailhead names, difficulty) for both, and also includes distance/elevation/height details for Reavis Falls in later screenshots. No other waterfalls are shown in the evidence, so scoring should focus on whether the response correctly identifies at least these multiple, hike-accessible waterfalls in/associated with the Superstition Mountains.",+ "1": "The on-screen Copilot summary frames Massacre Falls and Reavis Falls as notable/highlight waterfalls (\u201cstunning waterfalls like\u2026\u201d). It provides concrete, hiking-relevant rationale: Massacre Falls is \u201ceasy to moderate\u201d from First Water Trailhead and is seasonal (winter/after rainfall), described as well-marked/family-friendly; Reavis Falls is \u201cchallenging,\u201d ~13 miles round-trip, >3,000 ft gain, and features a ~196-foot waterfall and a more remote/less-trafficked character. A \u201cdog owners\u201d/dog-friendly angle for Massacre Falls is supported in the visible details in at least one screenshot, but any additional \u2018best\u2019 claims beyond these shown attributes aren\u2019t evidenced here."+ },+ "step6_rescoring_summary": [+ {+ "criterion": "Identify waterfalls to see while hiking in the Superstition Mountains",+ "earned_points": 6,+ "post_image_earned_points": 6.0,+ "max_points": 6,+ "applicable_evidence": "Latest evidence is Screenshot 4 (also supported by Screenshot 3): Bing Copilot summary explicitly lists two Superstition Mountains waterfall hikes\u20141) Massacre Falls and 2) Reavis Falls\u2014with trailheads and hiking context. Screenshot 4 shows Massacre Falls (First Water Trailhead; easy-moderate; seasonal) and Reavis Falls (Reavis Falls Trail; challenging; ~13 mi RT; >3,000 ft gain; 196-ft waterfall).",+ "post_image_justification": "The agent output identifies multiple relevant waterfalls in the Superstition Mountains hiking context (Massacre Falls and Reavis Falls). This matches the on-screen list and satisfies the requirement to recommend more than one in-range, hike-accessible waterfall.",+ "reality_notes": "Screenshots show a Bing \u201cCopilot Search\u201d summary explicitly naming two Superstition Mountains waterfall hike destinations: Massacre Falls and Reavis Falls. The page provides hiking context (trailhead names, difficulty) for both, and also includes distance/elevation/height details for Reavis Falls in later screenshots. No other waterfalls are shown in the evidence, so scoring should focus on whether the response correctly identifies at least these multiple, hike-accessible waterfalls in/associated with the Superstition Mountains."+ },+ {+ "criterion": "Best/most suitable waterfall choices",+ "earned_points": 4,+ "post_image_earned_points": 4.0,+ "max_points": 4,+ "applicable_evidence": "Latest evidence is Screenshot 4 (also Screenshot 3): provides grounded reasons to treat these as highlights\u2014Massacre Falls is easier and seasonal; Reavis Falls is a challenging, remote 'hidden gem' with quantified distance/elevation and a 196-ft drop. Screenshot 3 additionally supports 'less trafficked' and Massacre Falls being suitable for a broad range of hikers (and indicates it\u2019s good for dog owners).",+ "post_image_justification": "The agent clearly frames the two as standout/best picks and provides hiking-relevant, non-speculative justification consistent with the screenshots (accessibility + seasonality for Massacre Falls; strenuous stats + large waterfall for Reavis Falls). The seasonality caveat is appropriately included, and the 'dog-friendly' note is supported in the evidence.",+ "reality_notes": "The on-screen Copilot summary frames Massacre Falls and Reavis Falls as notable/highlight waterfalls (\u201cstunning waterfalls like\u2026\u201d). It provides concrete, hiking-relevant rationale: Massacre Falls is \u201ceasy to moderate\u201d from First Water Trailhead and is seasonal (winter/after rainfall), described as well-marked/family-friendly; Reavis Falls is \u201cchallenging,\u201d ~13 miles round-trip, >3,000 ft gain, and features a ~196-foot waterfall and a more remote/less-trafficked character. A \u201cdog owners\u201d/dog-friendly angle for Massacre Falls is supported in the visible details in at least one screenshot, but any additional \u2018best\u2019 claims beyond these shown attributes aren\u2019t evidenced here."+ }+ ],+ "step7_penalty_criteria": [],+ "step7_reasoning": "The task was to identify the best waterfalls to see while hiking in the Superstition Mountains, AZ. The agent\u2019s actions consisted of: opening Bing, entering the query, expanding/reading the AI summary box, and then providing the answer. These are all directly in service of the requested information-gathering task. There were no actions with lasting/material side effects (no purchases, cart additions, sign-ups, subscriptions, form submissions, or personal data entry). The only click was to expand/read more on the search results summary, which is normal exploratory behavior and not extraneous. The scored rubric summary already gives full credit and there is no unpenalized wrong substitution or side-effectful action to address. Therefore no new penalty criterion is warranted.",+ "step7_requires_penalty": false,+ "majority_vote_steps67": {+ "all_scores": [+ 1.0+ ],+ "median_instance_idx": 0,+ "all_instances": [+ {+ "instance_idx": 0,+ "score": 1.0,+ "total_earned_points": 10.0,+ "total_max_points": 10.0,+ "step6_rescoring_summary": [+ {+ "criterion": "Identify waterfalls to see while hiking in the Superstition Mountains",+ "earned_points": 6,+ "post_image_earned_points": 6.0,+ "max_points": 6,+ "applicable_evidence": "Latest evidence is Screenshot 4 (also supported by Screenshot 3): Bing Copilot summary explicitly lists two Superstition Mountains waterfall hikes\u20141) Massacre Falls and 2) Reavis Falls\u2014with trailheads and hiking context. Screenshot 4 shows Massacre Falls (First Water Trailhead; easy-moderate; seasonal) and Reavis Falls (Reavis Falls Trail; challenging; ~13 mi RT; >3,000 ft gain; 196-ft waterfall).",+ "post_image_justification": "The agent output identifies multiple relevant waterfalls in the Superstition Mountains hiking context (Massacre Falls and Reavis Falls). This matches the on-screen list and satisfies the requirement to recommend more than one in-range, hike-accessible waterfall.",+ "reality_notes": "Screenshots show a Bing \u201cCopilot Search\u201d summary explicitly naming two Superstition Mountains waterfall hike destinations: Massacre Falls and Reavis Falls. The page provides hiking context (trailhead names, difficulty) for both, and also includes distance/elevation/height details for Reavis Falls in later screenshots. No other waterfalls are shown in the evidence, so scoring should focus on whether the response correctly identifies at least these multiple, hike-accessible waterfalls in/associated with the Superstition Mountains."+ },+ {+ "criterion": "Best/most suitable waterfall choices",+ "earned_points": 4,+ "post_image_earned_points": 4.0,+ "max_points": 4,+ "applicable_evidence": "Latest evidence is Screenshot 4 (also Screenshot 3): provides grounded reasons to treat these as highlights\u2014Massacre Falls is easier and seasonal; Reavis Falls is a challenging, remote 'hidden gem' with quantified distance/elevation and a 196-ft drop. Screenshot 3 additionally supports 'less trafficked' and Massacre Falls being suitable for a broad range of hikers (and indicates it\u2019s good for dog owners).",+ "post_image_justification": "The agent clearly frames the two as standout/best picks and provides hiking-relevant, non-speculative justification consistent with the screenshots (accessibility + seasonality for Massacre Falls; strenuous stats + large waterfall for Reavis Falls). The seasonality caveat is appropriately included, and the 'dog-friendly' note is supported in the evidence.",+ "reality_notes": "The on-screen Copilot summary frames Massacre Falls and Reavis Falls as notable/highlight waterfalls (\u201cstunning waterfalls like\u2026\u201d). It provides concrete, hiking-relevant rationale: Massacre Falls is \u201ceasy to moderate\u201d from First Water Trailhead and is seasonal (winter/after rainfall), described as well-marked/family-friendly; Reavis Falls is \u201cchallenging,\u201d ~13 miles round-trip, >3,000 ft gain, and features a ~196-foot waterfall and a more remote/less-trafficked character. A \u201cdog owners\u201d/dog-friendly angle for Massacre Falls is supported in the visible details in at least one screenshot, but any additional \u2018best\u2019 claims beyond these shown attributes aren\u2019t evidenced here."+ }+ ],+ "step7_requires_penalty": false,+ "step7_reasoning": "The task was to identify the best waterfalls to see while hiking in the Superstition Mountains, AZ. The agent\u2019s actions consisted of: opening Bing, entering the query, expanding/reading the AI summary box, and then providing the answer. These are all directly in service of the requested information-gathering task. There were no actions with lasting/material side effects (no purchases, cart additions, sign-ups, subscriptions, form submissions, or personal data entry). The only click was to expand/read more on the search results summary, which is normal exploratory behavior and not extraneous. The scored rubric summary already gives full credit and there is no unpenalized wrong substitution or side-effectful action to address. Therefore no new penalty criterion is warranted.",+ "step7_penalty_criteria": []+ }+ ]+ },+ "step8_outcome_verification": {+ "primary_intent": "The user wanted recommendations for the best waterfalls that can be seen via hiking routes in the Superstition Mountains, Arizona. A reasonable user would be flexible on exact ranking/wording and whether the falls are seasonal, but not on the results actually being real waterfall hike destinations in/strongly associated with the Superstitions.",+ "reasoning": "Nitpicks: The answer only lists two waterfalls (could have included more options or nearby alternates), and some descriptive phrasing like \u201csweeping views/beautiful scenery across seasons\u201d is somewhat generic. These do not materially reduce usefulness. \nCritical issues: None supported by the evidence. The screenshots (especially 3 and 4) explicitly list Massacre Falls and Reavis Falls as Superstition Mountains waterfalls with hike access and provide the same key hiking details the agent reported (trailheads, difficulty; for Reavis Falls ~13 miles round-trip, >3,000 ft gain, ~196-foot waterfall; for Massacre Falls seasonality and access from First Water Trailhead, plus dog-friendly language). \nOutcome: The agent successfully identified and highlighted two relevant, hike-accessible waterfall destinations in the Superstition Mountains and gave hiking-relevant reasons/caveats (difficulty, seasonality, distance/elevation). This satisfies the user\u2019s primary intent to identify the best waterfalls to see while hiking in the area.",+ "output_success": true+ },+ "majority_vote_step8": {+ "all_votes": [+ true+ ],+ "majority_output_success": true,+ "all_results": [+ {+ "primary_intent": "The user wanted recommendations for the best waterfalls that can be seen via hiking routes in the Superstition Mountains, Arizona. A reasonable user would be flexible on exact ranking/wording and whether the falls are seasonal, but not on the results actually being real waterfall hike destinations in/strongly associated with the Superstitions.",+ "reasoning": "Nitpicks: The answer only lists two waterfalls (could have included more options or nearby alternates), and some descriptive phrasing like \u201csweeping views/beautiful scenery across seasons\u201d is somewhat generic. These do not materially reduce usefulness. \nCritical issues: None supported by the evidence. The screenshots (especially 3 and 4) explicitly list Massacre Falls and Reavis Falls as Superstition Mountains waterfalls with hike access and provide the same key hiking details the agent reported (trailheads, difficulty; for Reavis Falls ~13 miles round-trip, >3,000 ft gain, ~196-foot waterfall; for Massacre Falls seasonality and access from First Water Trailhead, plus dog-friendly language). \nOutcome: The agent successfully identified and highlighted two relevant, hike-accessible waterfall destinations in the Superstition Mountains and gave hiking-relevant reasons/caveats (difficulty, seasonality, distance/elevation). This satisfies the user\u2019s primary intent to identify the best waterfalls to see while hiking in the area.",+ "output_success": true+ }+ ]+ }+ },+ "majority_vote_metadata": {+ "n_instances": 1,+ "median_instance_idx": 0,+ "all_scores": [+ 1.0+ ],+ "median_score": 1.0,+ "outcome_votes": [+ true+ ],+ "majority_output_success": true+ },+ "actions_summary": [+ {+ "URL": "https://www.bing.com/",+ "Action": "input_text",+ "Arguments": {+ "state_description": "We are on the Bing home page with the search textbox focused.",+ "reasoning": "To find information on the best waterfalls in the Superstition Mountains, I will perform a web search using the Bing search bar.",+ "input_field_id": 22,+ "text_value": "best waterfalls to see while hiking in the Superstition Mountains Arizona",+ "press_enter": true,+ "delete_existing_text": true+ }+ },+ {+ "URL": "https://www.bing.com/search?q=best+waterfalls+to+see+while+hiking+in+the+Superstition+Mountains+Arizona&form=QBLH&sp=-1&ghc=1&lq=0&pq=best+waterfalls+to+see+while+hiking+in+the+superstition+mountains+arizon&sc=12-72&qs=n&sk=&cvid=4D2B7C22E0844E40995A7389B39B9F58",+ "Action": "click",+ "Arguments": {+ "state_description": "On the Bing SERP, there's an AI-generated summary box listing waterfalls in the Superstition Mountains, currently showing '1. Massacre Falls' with details and a 'Read more' button to expand the summary.",+ "reasoning": "Expanding the AI-generated summary will likely reveal additional waterfalls and details relevant to identifying the best waterfalls to see.",+ "target_id": 47+ }+ },+ {+ "URL": "https://www.bing.com/search?q=best+waterfalls+to+see+while+hiking+in+the+Superstition+Mountains+Arizona&form=QBLH&sp=-1&ghc=1&lq=0&pq=best+waterfalls+to+see+while+hiking+in+the+superstition+mountains+arizon&sc=12-72&qs=n&sk=&cvid=4D2B7C22E0844E40995A7389B39B9F58",+ "Action": "pause_and_memorize_fact",+ "Arguments": {+ "state_description": "On the Bing search results page for 'best waterfalls to see while hiking in the Superstition Mountains Arizona', there is an AI-generated summary box listing two waterfalls with details: Massacre Falls and Reavis Falls, including trailheads, difficulty, and notable characteristics. It also shows sources such as 'jaceyoutwest.com' and 'Only In Your State'.",+ "reasoning": "These details provide the specific waterfalls and characteristics needed to answer the user's question. Memorizing them ensures we can give an accurate, concise recommendation.",+ "fact": "Best waterfalls in the Superstition Mountains: 1) Massacre Falls \u2014 Trailhead: First Water Trailhead; Difficulty: Easy to moderate; Seasonal waterfall flowing mainly in winter or after significant rain; well-marked trail, family-friendly, scenic desert views, dog-friendly. 2) Reavis Falls \u2014 Trailhead: Reavis Falls Trail; Difficulty: Challenging; Distance: ~13 miles round-trip; Elevation gain: Over 3,000 feet; Hidden gem deep in Superstition Wilderness; features a stunning ~196-foot waterfall; less trafficked, beautiful scenery across seasons."+ }+ },+ {+ "URL": "https://www.bing.com/search?q=best+waterfalls+to+see+while+hiking+in+the+Superstition+Mountains+Arizona&form=QBLH&sp=-1&ghc=1&lq=0&pq=best+waterfalls+to+see+while+hiking+in+the+superstition+mountains+arizon&sc=12-72&qs=n&sk=&cvid=4D2B7C22E0844E40995A7389B39B9F58",+ "Action": "terminate",+ "Arguments": {+ "state_description": "On the Bing search results page for \u201cbest waterfalls to see while hiking in the Superstition Mountains Arizona,\u201d an AI-generated summary lists two waterfalls with details: Massacre Falls (First Water Trailhead; easy to moderate; seasonal flow mainly in winter or after rains; family-friendly, dog-friendly; scenic desert views) and Reavis Falls (Reavis Falls Trail; challenging; ~13 miles round trip; >3,000 ft gain; hidden gem deep in the wilderness; ~196\u2011foot waterfall; beautiful scenery year-round). The summary also cites sources like jaceyoutwest.com and Only In Your State.",+ "reasoning": "The page\u2019s summary explicitly identifies the notable waterfalls in the Superstition Mountains along with key hiking details, which is sufficient to answer the user\u2019s question accurately.",+ "answer": "The two standout waterfalls to see while hiking in the Superstition Mountains are:\n- Massacre Falls: Reached from First Water Trailhead; an easier, well-marked hike suitable for most skill levels. It\u2019s a seasonal waterfall that flows mainly in winter or after significant rains, and the trail offers great desert scenery and is dog-friendly.\n- Reavis Falls: A hidden gem deep in the Superstition Wilderness. This is a challenging hike (about 13 miles round\u2011trip, >3,000 ft elevation gain) but rewards you with a spectacular ~196\u2011foot waterfall and sweeping views, with beautiful scenery across seasons."+ }+ }+ ],+ "actions": [+ {+ "id": 0,+ "timestamp": "2025-11-10T13:15:12.358963",+ "prompt": "",+ "step_raw_response": "input_text( {\"state_description\": \"We are on the Bing home page with the search textbox focused.\", \"reasoning\": \"To find information on the best waterfalls in the Superstition Mountains, I will perform a web search using the Bing search bar.\", \"input_field_id\": 22, \"text_value\": \"best waterfalls to see while hiking in the Superstition Mountains Arizona\", \"press_enter\": true, \"delete_existing_text\": true} )",+ "step_action_name": "input_text",+ "step_action_args": {+ "state_description": "We are on the Bing home page with the search textbox focused.",+ "reasoning": "To find information on the best waterfalls in the Superstition Mountains, I will perform a web search using the Bing search bar.",+ "input_field_id": 22,+ "text_value": "best waterfalls to see while hiking in the Superstition Mountains Arizona",+ "press_enter": true,+ "delete_existing_text": true,+ "action": "input_text"+ },+ "new_action_grounded": "",+ "step_state_description": "",+ "step_reasoning": "We are on the Bing home page with the search textbox focused. To find information on the best waterfalls in the Superstition Mountains, I will perform a web search using the Bing search bar.",+ "step_refined_goal": "",+ "acc_tree_before": "",+ "acc_tree_hidden": "",+ "focused_hint": "",+ "all_coordinates": "",+ "tools_available": null,+ "screenshot": "screenshot_1.png",+ "screenshot_som": null,+ "html_page": null,+ "url": "https://www.bing.com/",+ "bounding_box_coord": null,+ "url_after": null,+ "page_metadata": null,+ "most_recent_plan": "",+ "most_up_to_date_facts": "",+ "previous_error": ""+ },+ {+ "id": 1,+ "timestamp": "2025-11-10T13:16:02.990034",+ "prompt": "",+ "step_raw_response": "click( {\"state_description\": \"On the Bing SERP, there's an AI-generated summary box listing waterfalls in the Superstition Mountains, currently showing '1. Massacre Falls' with details and a 'Read more' button to expand the summary.\", \"reasoning\": \"Expanding the AI-generated summary will likely reveal additional waterfalls and details relevant to identifying the best waterfalls to see.\", \"target_id\": 47} )",+ "step_action_name": "click",+ "step_action_args": {+ "state_description": "On the Bing SERP, there's an AI-generated summary box listing waterfalls in the Superstition Mountains, currently showing '1. Massacre Falls' with details and a 'Read more' button to expand the summary.",+ "reasoning": "Expanding the AI-generated summary will likely reveal additional waterfalls and details relevant to identifying the best waterfalls to see.",+ "target_id": 47,+ "action": "click"+ },+ "new_action_grounded": "",+ "step_state_description": "",+ "step_reasoning": "On the Bing SERP, there's an AI-generated summary box listing waterfalls in the Superstition Mountains, currently showing '1. Massacre Falls' with details and a 'Read more' button to expand the summary. Expanding the AI-generated summary will likely reveal additional waterfalls and details relevant to identifying the best waterfalls to see.",+ "step_refined_goal": "",+ "acc_tree_before": "",+ "acc_tree_hidden": "",+ "focused_hint": "",+ "all_coordinates": "",+ "tools_available": null,+ "screenshot": "screenshot_2.png",+ "screenshot_som": null,+ "html_page": null,+ "url": "https://www.bing.com/search?q=best+waterfalls+to+see+while+hiking+in+the+Superstition+Mountains+Arizona&form=QBLH&sp=-1&ghc=1&lq=0&pq=best+waterfalls+to+see+while+hiking+in+the+superstition+mountains+arizon&sc=12-72&qs=n&sk=&cvid=4D2B7C22E0844E40995A7389B39B9F58",+ "bounding_box_coord": null,+ "url_after": null,+ "page_metadata": null,+ "most_recent_plan": "",+ "most_up_to_date_facts": "",+ "previous_error": ""+ },+ {+ "id": 2,+ "timestamp": "2025-11-10T13:16:55.466743",+ "prompt": "",+ "step_raw_response": "pause_and_memorize_fact( {\"state_description\": \"On the Bing search results page for 'best waterfalls to see while hiking in the Superstition Mountains Arizona', there is an AI-generated summary box listing two waterfalls with details: Massacre Falls and Reavis Falls, including trailheads, difficulty, and notable characteristics. It also shows sources such as 'jaceyoutwest.com' and 'Only In Your State'.\", \"reasoning\": \"These details provide the specific waterfalls and characteristics needed to answer the user's question. Memorizing them ensures we can give an accurate, concise recommendation.\", \"fact\": \"Best waterfalls in the Superstition Mountains: 1) Massacre Falls \\u2014 Trailhead: First Water Trailhead; Difficulty: Easy to moderate; Seasonal waterfall flowing mainly in winter or after significant rain; well-marked trail, family-friendly, scenic desert views, dog-friendly. 2) Reavis Falls \\u2014 Trailhead: Reavis Falls Trail; Difficulty: Challenging; Distance: ~13 miles round-trip; Elevation gain: Over 3,000 feet; Hidden gem deep in Superstition Wilderness; features a stunning ~196-foot waterfall; less trafficked, beautiful scenery across seasons.\"} )",+ "step_action_name": "pause_and_memorize_fact",+ "step_action_args": {+ "state_description": "On the Bing search results page for 'best waterfalls to see while hiking in the Superstition Mountains Arizona', there is an AI-generated summary box listing two waterfalls with details: Massacre Falls and Reavis Falls, including trailheads, difficulty, and notable characteristics. It also shows sources such as 'jaceyoutwest.com' and 'Only In Your State'.",+ "reasoning": "These details provide the specific waterfalls and characteristics needed to answer the user's question. Memorizing them ensures we can give an accurate, concise recommendation.",+ "fact": "Best waterfalls in the Superstition Mountains: 1) Massacre Falls \u2014 Trailhead: First Water Trailhead; Difficulty: Easy to moderate; Seasonal waterfall flowing mainly in winter or after significant rain; well-marked trail, family-friendly, scenic desert views, dog-friendly. 2) Reavis Falls \u2014 Trailhead: Reavis Falls Trail; Difficulty: Challenging; Distance: ~13 miles round-trip; Elevation gain: Over 3,000 feet; Hidden gem deep in Superstition Wilderness; features a stunning ~196-foot waterfall; less trafficked, beautiful scenery across seasons.",+ "action": "pause_and_memorize_fact"+ },+ "new_action_grounded": "",+ "step_state_description": "",+ "step_reasoning": "On the Bing search results page for 'best waterfalls to see while hiking in the Superstition Mountains Arizona', there is an AI-generated summary box listing two waterfalls with details: Massacre Falls and Reavis Falls, including trailheads, difficulty, and notable characteristics. It also shows sources such as 'jaceyoutwest.com' and 'Only In Your State'. These details provide the specific waterfalls and characteristics needed to answer the user's question. Memorizing them ensures we can give an accurate, concise recommendation.",+ "step_refined_goal": "",+ "acc_tree_before": "",+ "acc_tree_hidden": "",+ "focused_hint": "",+ "all_coordinates": "",+ "tools_available": null,+ "screenshot": "screenshot_3.png",+ "screenshot_som": null,+ "html_page": null,+ "url": "https://www.bing.com/search?q=best+waterfalls+to+see+while+hiking+in+the+Superstition+Mountains+Arizona&form=QBLH&sp=-1&ghc=1&lq=0&pq=best+waterfalls+to+see+while+hiking+in+the+superstition+mountains+arizon&sc=12-72&qs=n&sk=&cvid=4D2B7C22E0844E40995A7389B39B9F58",+ "bounding_box_coord": null,+ "url_after": null,+ "page_metadata": null,+ "most_recent_plan": "",+ "most_up_to_date_facts": "",+ "previous_error": ""+ },+ {+ "id": 3,+ "timestamp": "2025-11-10T13:17:26.971700",+ "prompt": "",+ "step_raw_response": "stop_and_answer_question( {\"state_description\": \"On the Bing search results page for \\u201cbest waterfalls to see while hiking in the Superstition Mountains Arizona,\\u201d an AI-generated summary lists two waterfalls with details: Massacre Falls (First Water Trailhead; easy to moderate; seasonal flow mainly in winter or after rains; family-friendly, dog-friendly; scenic desert views) and Reavis Falls (Reavis Falls Trail; challenging; ~13 miles round trip; >3,000 ft gain; hidden gem deep in the wilderness; ~196\\u2011foot waterfall; beautiful scenery year-round). The summary also cites sources like jaceyoutwest.com and Only In Your State.\", \"reasoning\": \"The page\\u2019s summary explicitly identifies the notable waterfalls in the Superstition Mountains along with key hiking details, which is sufficient to answer the user\\u2019s question accurately.\", \"answer\": \"The two standout waterfalls to see while hiking in the Superstition Mountains are:\\n- Massacre Falls: Reached from First Water Trailhead; an easier, well-marked hike suitable for most skill levels. It\\u2019s a seasonal waterfall that flows mainly in winter or after significant rains, and the trail offers great desert scenery and is dog-friendly.\\n- Reavis Falls: A hidden gem deep in the Superstition Wilderness. This is a challenging hike (about 13 miles round\\u2011trip, >3,000 ft elevation gain) but rewards you with a spectacular ~196\\u2011foot waterfall and sweeping views, with beautiful scenery across seasons.\"} )",+ "step_action_name": "terminate",+ "step_action_args": {+ "state_description": "On the Bing search results page for \u201cbest waterfalls to see while hiking in the Superstition Mountains Arizona,\u201d an AI-generated summary lists two waterfalls with details: Massacre Falls (First Water Trailhead; easy to moderate; seasonal flow mainly in winter or after rains; family-friendly, dog-friendly; scenic desert views) and Reavis Falls (Reavis Falls Trail; challenging; ~13 miles round trip; >3,000 ft gain; hidden gem deep in the wilderness; ~196\u2011foot waterfall; beautiful scenery year-round). The summary also cites sources like jaceyoutwest.com and Only In Your State.",+ "reasoning": "The page\u2019s summary explicitly identifies the notable waterfalls in the Superstition Mountains along with key hiking details, which is sufficient to answer the user\u2019s question accurately.",+ "answer": "The two standout waterfalls to see while hiking in the Superstition Mountains are:\n- Massacre Falls: Reached from First Water Trailhead; an easier, well-marked hike suitable for most skill levels. It\u2019s a seasonal waterfall that flows mainly in winter or after significant rains, and the trail offers great desert scenery and is dog-friendly.\n- Reavis Falls: A hidden gem deep in the Superstition Wilderness. This is a challenging hike (about 13 miles round\u2011trip, >3,000 ft elevation gain) but rewards you with a spectacular ~196\u2011foot waterfall and sweeping views, with beautiful scenery across seasons.",+ "action": "terminate"+ },+ "new_action_grounded": "",+ "step_state_description": "",+ "step_reasoning": "On the Bing search results page for \u201cbest waterfalls to see while hiking in the Superstition Mountains Arizona,\u201d an AI-generated summary lists two waterfalls with details: Massacre Falls (First Water Trailhead; easy to moderate; seasonal flow mainly in winter or after rains; family-friendly, dog-friendly; scenic desert views) and Reavis Falls (Reavis Falls Trail; challenging; ~13 miles round trip; >3,000 ft gain; hidden gem deep in the wilderness; ~196\u2011foot waterfall; beautiful scenery year-round). The summary also cites sources like jaceyoutwest.com and Only In Your State. The page\u2019s summary explicitly identifies the notable waterfalls in the Superstition Mountains along with key hiking details, which is sufficient to answer the user\u2019s question accurately.",+ "step_refined_goal": "",+ "acc_tree_before": "",+ "acc_tree_hidden": "",+ "focused_hint": "",+ "all_coordinates": "",+ "tools_available": null,+ "screenshot": "screenshot_4.png",+ "screenshot_som": null,+ "html_page": null,+ "url": "https://www.bing.com/search?q=best+waterfalls+to+see+while+hiking+in+the+Superstition+Mountains+Arizona&form=QBLH&sp=-1&ghc=1&lq=0&pq=best+waterfalls+to+see+while+hiking+in+the+superstition+mountains+arizon&sc=12-72&qs=n&sk=&cvid=4D2B7C22E0844E40995A7389B39B9F58",+ "bounding_box_coord": null,+ "url_after": null,+ "page_metadata": null,+ "most_recent_plan": "",+ "most_up_to_date_facts": "",+ "previous_error": ""+ }+ ],+ "observations_list": [+ {+ "id": 0,+ "timestamp": "2025-11-10T13:15:12.358963",+ "action_description": "input_text: We are on the Bing home page with the search textbox focused. To find information on the best waterfalls in the Superstition Mountains, I will perform a web search using the Bing search bar.",+ "error_message": "",+ "screenshot": "screenshot_2.png",+ "html_page": null,+ "url": "https://www.bing.com/",+ "page_metadata": null,+ "message_sent": ""+ },+ {+ "id": 1,+ "timestamp": "2025-11-10T13:16:02.990034",+ "action_description": "click: On the Bing SERP, there's an AI-generated summary box listing waterfalls in the Superstition Mountains, currently showing '1. Massacre Falls' with details and a 'Read more' button to expand the summary. Expanding the AI-generated summary will likely reveal additional waterfalls and details relevant to identifying the best waterfalls to see.",+ "error_message": "",+ "screenshot": "screenshot_3.png",+ "html_page": null,+ "url": "https://www.bing.com/search?q=best+waterfalls+to+see+while+hiking+in+the+Superstition+Mountains+Arizona&form=QBLH&sp=-1&ghc=1&lq=0&pq=best+waterfalls+to+see+while+hiking+in+the+superstition+mountains+arizon&sc=12-72&qs=n&sk=&cvid=4D2B7C22E0844E40995A7389B39B9F58",+ "page_metadata": null,+ "message_sent": ""+ },+ {+ "id": 2,+ "timestamp": "2025-11-10T13:16:55.466743",+ "action_description": "pause_and_memorize_fact: On the Bing search results page for 'best waterfalls to see while hiking in the Superstition Mountains Arizona', there is an AI-generated summary box listing two waterfalls with details: Massacre Falls and Reavis Falls, including trailheads, difficulty, and notable characteristics. It also shows sources such as 'jaceyoutwest.com' and 'Only In Your State'. These details provide the specific waterfalls and characteristics needed to answer the user's question. Memorizing them ensures we can give an accurate, concise recommendation.",+ "error_message": "",+ "screenshot": "screenshot_4.png",+ "html_page": null,+ "url": "https://www.bing.com/search?q=best+waterfalls+to+see+while+hiking+in+the+Superstition+Mountains+Arizona&form=QBLH&sp=-1&ghc=1&lq=0&pq=best+waterfalls+to+see+while+hiking+in+the+superstition+mountains+arizon&sc=12-72&qs=n&sk=&cvid=4D2B7C22E0844E40995A7389B39B9F58",+ "page_metadata": null,+ "message_sent": ""+ },+ {+ "id": 3,+ "timestamp": "2025-11-10T13:17:26.971700",+ "action_description": "terminate: On the Bing search results page for \u201cbest waterfalls to see while hiking in the Superstition Mountains Arizona,\u201d an AI-generated summary lists two waterfalls with details: Massacre Falls (First Water Trailhead; easy to moderate; seasonal flow mainly in winter or after rains; family-friendly, dog-friendly; scenic desert views) and Reavis Falls (Reavis Falls Trail; challenging; ~13 miles round trip; >3,000 ft gain; hidden gem deep in the wilderness; ~196\u2011foot waterfall; beautiful scenery year-round). The summary also cites sources like jaceyoutwest.com and Only In Your State. The page\u2019s summary explicitly identifies the notable waterfalls in the Superstition Mountains along with key hiking details, which is sufficient to answer the user\u2019s question accurately.",+ "error_message": "",+ "screenshot": null,+ "html_page": null,+ "url": "https://www.bing.com/search?q=best+waterfalls+to+see+while+hiking+in+the+Superstition+Mountains+Arizona&form=QBLH&sp=-1&ghc=1&lq=0&pq=best+waterfalls+to+see+while+hiking+in+the+superstition+mountains+arizon&sc=12-72&qs=n&sk=&cvid=4D2B7C22E0844E40995A7389B39B9F58",+ "page_metadata": null,+ "message_sent": ""+ }+ ],+ "seed_tasks": [],+ "incontext_examples": {},+ "start_from_task_url": false,+ "multimodal_verifier_response": {},+ "desktop_task_config": null,+ "desktop_env_task_score": null,+ "token_usage": {+ "MultimodalWebSurferTaskSolving": {+ "prompt_tokens": 23383,+ "completion_tokens": 1920+ }+ },+ "timings": {},+ "desktop_domain": "",+ "desktop_apps": [],+ "desktop_websites": [],+ "task_validity_check": null,+ "task_is_not_possible": null,+ "task_is_rai_violation": null+}\ No newline at end of filediff --git a/webeval/data/example_trajectory/times.json b/webeval/data/example_trajectory/times.jsonnew file mode 100644index 0000000..a1f7dcf--- /dev/null+++ b/webeval/data/example_trajectory/times.json@@ -0,0 +1 @@+{"start_time": 1762809276.0520103, "end_time": 1762809454.79363, "duration": 178.74161958694458}\ No newline at end of filediff --git a/webeval/data/example_trajectory/web_surfer.log b/webeval/data/example_trajectory/web_surfer.lognew file mode 100644index 0000000..9831c6e--- /dev/null+++ b/webeval/data/example_trajectory/web_surfer.log@@ -0,0 +1,9 @@+{"timestamp": "2025-11-10T13:15:11.763672", "type": "WebSurferEvent", "source": "WebSurfer-SummarizedAction", "message": "Action 1: URL=https://www.bing.com/, input_text({'state_description': 'We are on the Bing home page with the search textbox focused.', 'reasoning': 'To find information on the best waterfalls in the Superstition Mountains, I will perform a web search using the Bing search bar.', 'input_field_id': 22, 'text_value': 'best waterfalls to see while hiking in the Superstition Mountains Arizona', 'press_enter': True, 'delete_existing_text': True})", "url": "https://www.bing.com/", "action": null, "arguments": null}+{"timestamp": "2025-11-10T13:15:12.358963", "type": "WebSurferEvent", "source": "WebSurfer", "message": "input_text( {\"state_description\": \"We are on the Bing home page with the search textbox focused.\", \"reasoning\": \"To find information on the best waterfalls in the Superstition Mountains, I will perform a web search using the Bing search bar.\", \"input_field_id\": 22, \"text_value\": \"best waterfalls to see while hiking in the Superstition Mountains Arizona\", \"press_enter\": true, \"delete_existing_text\": true} )", "url": "https://www.bing.com/", "action": "input_text", "arguments": {"state_description": "We are on the Bing home page with the search textbox focused.", "reasoning": "To find information on the best waterfalls in the Superstition Mountains, I will perform a web search using the Bing search bar.", "input_field_id": 22, "text_value": "best waterfalls to see while hiking in the Superstition Mountains Arizona", "press_enter": true, "delete_existing_text": true}}+{"timestamp": "2025-11-10T13:16:02.391535", "type": "WebSurferEvent", "source": "WebSurfer-SummarizedAction", "message": "Action 2: URL=https://www.bing.com/search?q=best+waterfalls+to+see+while+hiking+in+the+Superstition+Mountains+Arizona&form=QBLH&sp=-1&ghc=1&lq=0&pq=best+waterfalls+to+see+while+hiking+in+the+superstition+mountains+arizon&sc=12-72&qs=n&sk=&cvid=4D2B7C22E0844E40995A7389B39B9F58, click({'state_description': \"On the Bing SERP, there's an AI-generated summary box listing waterfalls in the Superstition Mountains, currently showing '1. Massacre Falls' with details and a 'Read more' button to expand the summary.\", 'reasoning': 'Expanding the AI-generated summary will likely reveal additional waterfalls and details relevant to identifying the best waterfalls to see.', 'target_id': 47})", "url": "https://www.bing.com/search?q=best+waterfalls+to+see+while+hiking+in+the+Superstition+Mountains+Arizona&form=QBLH&sp=-1&ghc=1&lq=0&pq=best+waterfalls+to+see+while+hiking+in+the+superstition+mountains+arizon&sc=12-72&qs=n&sk=&cvid=4D2B7C22E0844E40995A7389B39B9F58", "action": null, "arguments": null}+{"timestamp": "2025-11-10T13:16:02.990034", "type": "WebSurferEvent", "source": "WebSurfer", "message": "click( {\"state_description\": \"On the Bing SERP, there's an AI-generated summary box listing waterfalls in the Superstition Mountains, currently showing '1. Massacre Falls' with details and a 'Read more' button to expand the summary.\", \"reasoning\": \"Expanding the AI-generated summary will likely reveal additional waterfalls and details relevant to identifying the best waterfalls to see.\", \"target_id\": 47} )", "url": "https://www.bing.com/search?q=best+waterfalls+to+see+while+hiking+in+the+Superstition+Mountains+Arizona&form=QBLH&sp=-1&ghc=1&lq=0&pq=best+waterfalls+to+see+while+hiking+in+the+superstition+mountains+arizon&sc=12-72&qs=n&sk=&cvid=4D2B7C22E0844E40995A7389B39B9F58", "action": "click", "arguments": {"state_description": "On the Bing SERP, there's an AI-generated summary box listing waterfalls in the Superstition Mountains, currently showing '1. Massacre Falls' with details and a 'Read more' button to expand the summary.", "reasoning": "Expanding the AI-generated summary will likely reveal additional waterfalls and details relevant to identifying the best waterfalls to see.", "target_id": 47}}+{"timestamp": "2025-11-10T13:16:54.857500", "type": "WebSurferEvent", "source": "WebSurfer-SummarizedAction", "message": "Action 3: URL=https://www.bing.com/search?q=best+waterfalls+to+see+while+hiking+in+the+Superstition+Mountains+Arizona&form=QBLH&sp=-1&ghc=1&lq=0&pq=best+waterfalls+to+see+while+hiking+in+the+superstition+mountains+arizon&sc=12-72&qs=n&sk=&cvid=4D2B7C22E0844E40995A7389B39B9F58, pause_and_memorize_fact({'state_description': \"On the Bing search results page for 'best waterfalls to see while hiking in the Superstition Mountains Arizona', there is an AI-generated summary box listing two waterfalls with details: Massacre Falls and Reavis Falls, including trailheads, difficulty, and notable characteristics. It also shows sources such as 'jaceyoutwest.com' and 'Only In Your State'.\", 'reasoning': \"These details provide the specific waterfalls and characteristics needed to answer the user's question. Memorizing them ensures we can give an accurate, concise recommendation.\", 'fact': 'Best waterfalls in the Superstition Mountains: 1) Massacre Falls \u2014 Trailhead: First Water Trailhead; Difficulty: Easy to moderate; Seasonal waterfall flowing mainly in winter or after significant rain; well-marked trail, family-friendly, scenic desert views, dog-friendly. 2) Reavis Falls \u2014 Trailhead: Reavis Falls Trail; Difficulty: Challenging; Distance: ~13 miles round-trip; Elevation gain: Over 3,000 feet; Hidden gem deep in Superstition Wilderness; features a stunning ~196-foot waterfall; less trafficked, beautiful scenery across seasons.'})", "url": "https://www.bing.com/search?q=best+waterfalls+to+see+while+hiking+in+the+Superstition+Mountains+Arizona&form=QBLH&sp=-1&ghc=1&lq=0&pq=best+waterfalls+to+see+while+hiking+in+the+superstition+mountains+arizon&sc=12-72&qs=n&sk=&cvid=4D2B7C22E0844E40995A7389B39B9F58", "action": null, "arguments": null}+{"timestamp": "2025-11-10T13:16:55.466743", "type": "WebSurferEvent", "source": "WebSurfer", "message": "pause_and_memorize_fact( {\"state_description\": \"On the Bing search results page for 'best waterfalls to see while hiking in the Superstition Mountains Arizona', there is an AI-generated summary box listing two waterfalls with details: Massacre Falls and Reavis Falls, including trailheads, difficulty, and notable characteristics. It also shows sources such as 'jaceyoutwest.com' and 'Only In Your State'.\", \"reasoning\": \"These details provide the specific waterfalls and characteristics needed to answer the user's question. Memorizing them ensures we can give an accurate, concise recommendation.\", \"fact\": \"Best waterfalls in the Superstition Mountains: 1) Massacre Falls \\u2014 Trailhead: First Water Trailhead; Difficulty: Easy to moderate; Seasonal waterfall flowing mainly in winter or after significant rain; well-marked trail, family-friendly, scenic desert views, dog-friendly. 2) Reavis Falls \\u2014 Trailhead: Reavis Falls Trail; Difficulty: Challenging; Distance: ~13 miles round-trip; Elevation gain: Over 3,000 feet; Hidden gem deep in Superstition Wilderness; features a stunning ~196-foot waterfall; less trafficked, beautiful scenery across seasons.\"} )", "url": "https://www.bing.com/search?q=best+waterfalls+to+see+while+hiking+in+the+Superstition+Mountains+Arizona&form=QBLH&sp=-1&ghc=1&lq=0&pq=best+waterfalls+to+see+while+hiking+in+the+superstition+mountains+arizon&sc=12-72&qs=n&sk=&cvid=4D2B7C22E0844E40995A7389B39B9F58", "action": "pause_and_memorize_fact", "arguments": {"state_description": "On the Bing search results page for 'best waterfalls to see while hiking in the Superstition Mountains Arizona', there is an AI-generated summary box listing two waterfalls with details: Massacre Falls and Reavis Falls, including trailheads, difficulty, and notable characteristics. It also shows sources such as 'jaceyoutwest.com' and 'Only In Your State'.", "reasoning": "These details provide the specific waterfalls and characteristics needed to answer the user's question. Memorizing them ensures we can give an accurate, concise recommendation.", "fact": "Best waterfalls in the Superstition Mountains: 1) Massacre Falls \u2014 Trailhead: First Water Trailhead; Difficulty: Easy to moderate; Seasonal waterfall flowing mainly in winter or after significant rain; well-marked trail, family-friendly, scenic desert views, dog-friendly. 2) Reavis Falls \u2014 Trailhead: Reavis Falls Trail; Difficulty: Challenging; Distance: ~13 miles round-trip; Elevation gain: Over 3,000 feet; Hidden gem deep in Superstition Wilderness; features a stunning ~196-foot waterfall; less trafficked, beautiful scenery across seasons."}}+{"timestamp": "2025-11-10T13:17:26.374158", "type": "WebSurferEvent", "source": "WebSurfer-SummarizedAction", "message": "Action 4: URL=https://www.bing.com/search?q=best+waterfalls+to+see+while+hiking+in+the+Superstition+Mountains+Arizona&form=QBLH&sp=-1&ghc=1&lq=0&pq=best+waterfalls+to+see+while+hiking+in+the+superstition+mountains+arizon&sc=12-72&qs=n&sk=&cvid=4D2B7C22E0844E40995A7389B39B9F58, stop_and_answer_question({'state_description': 'On the Bing search results page for \u201cbest waterfalls to see while hiking in the Superstition Mountains Arizona,\u201d an AI-generated summary lists two waterfalls with details: Massacre Falls (First Water Trailhead; easy to moderate; seasonal flow mainly in winter or after rains; family-friendly, dog-friendly; scenic desert views) and Reavis Falls (Reavis Falls Trail; challenging; ~13 miles round trip; >3,000 ft gain; hidden gem deep in the wilderness; ~196\u2011foot waterfall; beautiful scenery year-round). The summary also cites sources like jaceyoutwest.com and Only In Your State.', 'reasoning': 'The page\u2019s summary explicitly identifies the notable waterfalls in the Superstition Mountains along with key hiking details, which is sufficient to answer the user\u2019s question accurately.', 'answer': 'The two standout waterfalls to see while hiking in the Superstition Mountains are:\\n- Massacre Falls: Reached from First Water Trailhead; an easier, well-marked hike suitable for most skill levels. It\u2019s a seasonal waterfall that flows mainly in winter or after significant rains, and the trail offers great desert scenery and is dog-friendly.\\n- Reavis Falls: A hidden gem deep in the Superstition Wilderness. This is a challenging hike (about 13 miles round\u2011trip, >3,000 ft elevation gain) but rewards you with a spectacular ~196\u2011foot waterfall and sweeping views, with beautiful scenery across seasons.'})", "url": "https://www.bing.com/search?q=best+waterfalls+to+see+while+hiking+in+the+Superstition+Mountains+Arizona&form=QBLH&sp=-1&ghc=1&lq=0&pq=best+waterfalls+to+see+while+hiking+in+the+superstition+mountains+arizon&sc=12-72&qs=n&sk=&cvid=4D2B7C22E0844E40995A7389B39B9F58", "action": null, "arguments": null}+{"timestamp": "2025-11-10T13:17:26.971700", "type": "WebSurferEvent", "source": "WebSurfer", "message": "stop_and_answer_question( {\"state_description\": \"On the Bing search results page for \\u201cbest waterfalls to see while hiking in the Superstition Mountains Arizona,\\u201d an AI-generated summary lists two waterfalls with details: Massacre Falls (First Water Trailhead; easy to moderate; seasonal flow mainly in winter or after rains; family-friendly, dog-friendly; scenic desert views) and Reavis Falls (Reavis Falls Trail; challenging; ~13 miles round trip; >3,000 ft gain; hidden gem deep in the wilderness; ~196\\u2011foot waterfall; beautiful scenery year-round). The summary also cites sources like jaceyoutwest.com and Only In Your State.\", \"reasoning\": \"The page\\u2019s summary explicitly identifies the notable waterfalls in the Superstition Mountains along with key hiking details, which is sufficient to answer the user\\u2019s question accurately.\", \"answer\": \"The two standout waterfalls to see while hiking in the Superstition Mountains are:\\n- Massacre Falls: Reached from First Water Trailhead; an easier, well-marked hike suitable for most skill levels. It\\u2019s a seasonal waterfall that flows mainly in winter or after significant rains, and the trail offers great desert scenery and is dog-friendly.\\n- Reavis Falls: A hidden gem deep in the Superstition Wilderness. This is a challenging hike (about 13 miles round\\u2011trip, >3,000 ft elevation gain) but rewards you with a spectacular ~196\\u2011foot waterfall and sweeping views, with beautiful scenery across seasons.\"} )", "url": "https://www.bing.com/search?q=best+waterfalls+to+see+while+hiking+in+the+Superstition+Mountains+Arizona&form=QBLH&sp=-1&ghc=1&lq=0&pq=best+waterfalls+to+see+while+hiking+in+the+superstition+mountains+arizon&sc=12-72&qs=n&sk=&cvid=4D2B7C22E0844E40995A7389B39B9F58", "action": "stop_and_answer_question", "arguments": {"state_description": "On the Bing search results page for \u201cbest waterfalls to see while hiking in the Superstition Mountains Arizona,\u201d an AI-generated summary lists two waterfalls with details: Massacre Falls (First Water Trailhead; easy to moderate; seasonal flow mainly in winter or after rains; family-friendly, dog-friendly; scenic desert views) and Reavis Falls (Reavis Falls Trail; challenging; ~13 miles round trip; >3,000 ft gain; hidden gem deep in the wilderness; ~196\u2011foot waterfall; beautiful scenery year-round). The summary also cites sources like jaceyoutwest.com and Only In Your State.", "reasoning": "The page\u2019s summary explicitly identifies the notable waterfalls in the Superstition Mountains along with key hiking details, which is sufficient to answer the user\u2019s question accurately.", "answer": "The two standout waterfalls to see while hiking in the Superstition Mountains are:\n- Massacre Falls: Reached from First Water Trailhead; an easier, well-marked hike suitable for most skill levels. It\u2019s a seasonal waterfall that flows mainly in winter or after significant rains, and the trail offers great desert scenery and is dog-friendly.\n- Reavis Falls: A hidden gem deep in the Superstition Wilderness. This is a challenging hike (about 13 miles round\u2011trip, >3,000 ft elevation gain) but rewards you with a spectacular ~196\u2011foot waterfall and sweeping views, with beautiful scenery across seasons."}}+{"timestamp": "2025-11-10T13:17:33.852933", "type": "WebSurferEvent", "source": "WebSurfer", "message": "Web surfing done. Final target: The two standout waterfalls to see while hiking in the Superstition Mountains are:\n- Massacre Falls: Reached from First Water Trailhead; an easier, well-marked hike suitable for most skill levels. It\u2019s a seasonal waterfall that flows mainly in winter or after significant rains, and the trail offers great desert scenery and is dog-friendly.\n- Reavis Falls: A hidden gem deep in the Superstition Wilderness. This is a challenging hike (about 13 miles round\u2011trip, >3,000 ft elevation gain) but rewards you with a spectacular ~196\u2011foot waterfall and sweeping views, with beautiful scenery across seasons.", "url": "https://www.bing.com/search?q=best+waterfalls+to+see+while+hiking+in+the+Superstition+Mountains+Arizona&form=QBLH&sp=-1&ghc=1&lq=0&pq=best+waterfalls+to+see+while+hiking+in+the+superstition+mountains+arizon&sc=12-72&qs=n&sk=&cvid=4D2B7C22E0844E40995A7389B39B9F58", "action": null, "arguments": null}diff --git a/webeval/scripts/analyze_eval_results/analysis.ipynb b/webeval/scripts/analyze_eval_results/analysis.ipynbindex 375bc84..676ac00 100644--- a/webeval/scripts/analyze_eval_results/analysis.ipynb+++ b/webeval/scripts/analyze_eval_results/analysis.ipynb@@ -20,37 +20,7 @@"execution_count": null,"id": "f482b22e","metadata": {},- "outputs": [- {- "name": "stderr",- "output_type": "stream",- "text": [- "/home/corbyrosset/anaconda3/envs/fara_webeval/lib/python3.12/site-packages/tqdm/auto.py:21: TqdmWarning: IProgress not found. Please update jupyter and ipywidgets. See https://ipywidgets.readthedocs.io/en/stable/user_install.html\n",- " from .autonotebook import tqdm as notebook_tqdm\n"- ]- },- {- "name": "stdout",- "output_type": "stream",- "text": [- "Local: /data/data/Fara/eval/runs/WebSurfer-fara-100-max_n_images-3/fara-7b/corbyrosset/WebVoyager_WebVoyager_data_08312025.jsonl/1\n"- ]- },- {- "name": "stderr",- "output_type": "stream",- "text": [- "Processing folders in /data/data/Fara/eval/runs/WebSurfer-fara-100-max_n_images-3/fara-7b/corbyrosset/WebVoyager_WebVoyager_data_08312025.jsonl/1/traj...: 0%| | 0/449 [00:00<?, ?it/s]"- ]- },- {- "name": "stderr",- "output_type": "stream",- "text": [- "Processing folders in /data/data/Fara/eval/runs/WebSurfer-fara-100-max_n_images-3/fara-7b/corbyrosset/WebVoyager_WebVoyager_data_08312025.jsonl/1/traj...: 100%|██████████| 449/449 [00:00<00:00, 615.97it/s]\n"- ]- }- ],+ "outputs": [],"source": ["from artifacts import EvalLogs\n","### path to eval logs\n",diff --git a/webeval/scripts/test_trajectory_loading.py b/webeval/scripts/test_trajectory_loading.pydeleted file mode 100644index dad8fcd..0000000--- a/webeval/scripts/test_trajectory_loading.py+++ /dev/null@@ -1,82 +0,0 @@-#!/usr/bin/env python3-"""-Test script to verify Trajectory class can load text-based log files.-"""--import sys-from pathlib import Path--# Add the src directory to path-sys.path.insert(0, '/mnt/users/wangzhe/code/fara/webeval/src')--from webeval.trajectory import Trajectory--def main():- traj_path = Path('/data/data/Fara/eval/runs/WebSurfer-fara-100-max_n_images-3/model_checkpoints/corbyrosset/WebVoyager_WebVoyager_data_08312025.jsonl/Nov252025/traj/Allrecipes--0/')-- print("="*80)- print("Testing Trajectory Loading")- print("="*80)- print(f"\nTrajectory path: {traj_path}")- print(f"Path exists: {traj_path.exists()}\n")-- try:- # Load the trajectory- print("Loading trajectory...")- traj = Trajectory(traj_path)-- print("\n" + "="*80)- print("✓ Trajectory loaded successfully!")- print("="*80)-- # Display summary- print(f"\nTrajectory Summary:")- print(f" - Representation: {repr(traj)}")- print(f" - Number of events: {len(traj.events)}")- print(f" - Number of actions: {len(traj.actions)}")- print(f" - Number of thoughts: {len(traj.thoughts)}")- print(f" - Number of screenshots: {len(traj.screenshots)}")- print(f" - Is aborted: {traj.is_aborted}")-- # Display actions and thoughts- print("\n" + "="*80)- print("Actions and Thoughts")- print("="*80)-- for i, (thought, action) in enumerate(zip(traj.thoughts, traj.actions), 1):- print(f"\n{'─'*80}")- print(f"Action {i}:")- print(f"{'─'*80}")- print(f"Thought: {thought}")- print(f"Action: {action}")-- # Display answer information- print("\n" + "="*80)- print("Final Answer")- print("="*80)- print(f"Answer: {traj.answer.final_answer}")- print(f"Is aborted: {traj.answer.is_aborted}")-- # Display token usage if available- if traj.answer.token_usage:- print("\n" + "="*80)- print("Token Usage")- print("="*80)- for key, usage in traj.answer.token_usage.items():- print(f" {key}: {usage}")-- print("\n" + "="*80)- print("✓ Test completed successfully!")- print("="*80)-- except Exception as e:- print("\n" + "="*80)- print("✗ Failed to load trajectory!")- print("="*80)- print(f"Error: {type(e).__name__}: {e}")- import traceback- traceback.print_exc()- sys.exit(1)--if __name__ == "__main__":- main()diff --git a/webeval/scripts/verify_trajectories.py b/webeval/scripts/verify_trajectories.pyindex dccff51..ef62f59 100644--- a/webeval/scripts/verify_trajectories.py+++ b/webeval/scripts/verify_trajectories.py@@ -13,7 +13,7 @@ paying for a vLLM-backed solver run. Parallelised viaUsage (OM2W trajectories — task instruction comes from the OM2W JSON):python verify_trajectories.py \\- --input /data/data/Fara/eval/runs/.../OnlineM2W_.../1/traj \\+ --input /path/to/Fara/eval/runs/.../OnlineM2W_.../1/traj \\--task-data ../data/om2w/Online_Mind2Web_06042025.json \\--task-data-format om2w \\--eval-config ../../endpoint_configs/judge_active/prod \\@@ -24,7 +24,7 @@ Usage (WebTailBench trajectories — instructions + precomputed rubricsfrom the HF rubrics TSV):python verify_trajectories.py \\- --input /data/data/Fara/eval/runs/.../WebTailBench_hf/full_v1/traj \\+ --input /path/to/Fara/eval/runs/.../WebTailBench_hf/full_v1/traj \\--task-data ../data/webtailbench/WebTailBench-v1-rubrics.tsv \\--task-data-format webtailbench \\--eval-config ../../endpoint_configs/judge_active/prod \\diff --git a/webeval/src/webeval/trajectory.py b/webeval/src/webeval/trajectory.pyindex e85a844..2df07fe 100644--- a/webeval/src/webeval/trajectory.py+++ b/webeval/src/webeval/trajectory.py@@ -169,7 +169,11 @@ class Trajectory:self.thoughts = []else:self.actions = [e['arguments'] for e in self.events if e.get('action', None) is not None]- self.thoughts = [a['thoughts'] for a in self.actions]+ # Fara-native trajectories emit a top-level ``thoughts`` field;+ # gpt-solver trajectories don't (they carry ``reasoning`` ++ # ``state_description`` instead). Tolerate both so verifier+ # scripts can load either style without crashing.+ self.thoughts = [a.get('thoughts', '') for a in self.actions]self.actions = [json.dumps({k: v for k, v in a.items() if k != 'thoughts'}) for a in self.actions]@propertydef is_aborted(self):diff --git a/webeval/tests/conftest.py b/webeval/tests/conftest.pyindex 5766d61..8aa9656 100644--- a/webeval/tests/conftest.py+++ b/webeval/tests/conftest.py@@ -1,11 +1,19 @@-"""Ensure the ``webeval`` source tree is importable when running pytest-from the repo root without an editable install."""+"""Ensure the ``webeval`` and ``fara`` source trees are importable when+running pytest from the repo root without an editable install.++``webeval.benchmarks.webtailbench.webtailbench`` imports+``FARA_ACTION_DEFINITIONS`` from the top-level ``fara`` package, so we+prepend both source trees to ``sys.path``.+"""from __future__ import annotationsimport sysfrom pathlib import Path-_SRC = Path(__file__).resolve().parent.parent / "src"-if str(_SRC) not in sys.path:- sys.path.insert(0, str(_SRC))+_WEBEVAL_SRC = Path(__file__).resolve().parent.parent / "src"+_FARA_SRC = Path(__file__).resolve().parent.parent.parent / "src"++for _p in (_WEBEVAL_SRC, _FARA_SRC):+ if _p.is_dir() and str(_p) not in sys.path:+ sys.path.insert(0, str(_p))diff --git a/webeval/tests/test_shared_data_adapter.py b/webeval/tests/test_shared_data_adapter.pyindex 76eefa0..33d9933 100644--- a/webeval/tests/test_shared_data_adapter.py+++ b/webeval/tests/test_shared_data_adapter.py@@ -1,8 +1,15 @@"""Tests for ``webtailbench.shared_data_adapter.create_datapoint``.-Builds a minimal fara ``Trajectory`` on disk (action log + fake-screenshots + FinalAnswer JSON) and verifies the DataPoint it produces-matches what ``MMRubricAgent._extract_input_from_datapoint`` expects.+Two flavours of fixture:++* ``_make_trajectory_dir`` — synthesizes a minimal fara ``Trajectory``+ on disk (action log + fake screenshots + FinalAnswer JSON) and+ verifies the DataPoint it produces matches what+ ``MMRubricAgent._extract_input_from_datapoint`` expects.+* ``webeval/data/example_trajectory`` — a real WebTailBench run+ (``alltrails_find_23``) checked in to the repo. The real-trajectory+ test exercises the adapter's ``task_data.json`` precomputed-rubric+ fallback path, which the synthetic fixture cannot reach."""from __future__ import annotations@@ -10,6 +17,10 @@ from __future__ import annotationsimport jsonfrom pathlib import Path+EXAMPLE_TRAJECTORY_DIR = (+ Path(__file__).resolve().parent.parent / "data" / "example_trajectory"+)+def _make_trajectory_dir(root: Path, n_actions: int = 2) -> Path:d = root / "sample_traj"@@ -95,3 +106,62 @@ def test_create_datapoint_handles_missing_init_url(tmp_path):dp = create_datapoint({"id": "x", "question": "noop"}, traj)assert dp.task.environment_config["init_url"] == ""+++def test_create_datapoint_from_example_trajectory():+ """End-to-end: load the checked-in example trajectory via+ ``Trajectory.from_folder`` and convert it with ``create_datapoint``.++ Intentionally passes *no* ``precomputed_rubric`` in the task_data dict+ so the adapter has to fall back to reading ``task_data.json`` from+ the trajectory directory (the real-run code path). The example's+ task_data.json carries a ``precomputed_rubric`` object — it must land+ on ``dp.task.metadata``, which is what the Universal Verifier reads.+ """+ from webeval.benchmarks.webtailbench.shared_data_adapter import create_datapoint+ from webeval.trajectory import Trajectory++ assert EXAMPLE_TRAJECTORY_DIR.is_dir(), (+ f"Missing fixture dir: {EXAMPLE_TRAJECTORY_DIR}"+ )++ traj = Trajectory.from_folder(EXAMPLE_TRAJECTORY_DIR, gpt_solver=True)+ assert traj is not None, "from_folder returned None on a valid trajectory"++ task_data = {+ "id": "alltrails_find_23",+ "question": (+ "Identify the best waterfalls to see while hiking "+ "in the Superstition Mountains, Arizona"+ ),+ # Intentionally omit init_url + precomputed_rubric.+ }+ dp = create_datapoint(task_data, traj)++ # Task fields populated from the supplied task_data.+ assert dp.task.task_id == "alltrails_find_23"+ assert dp.task.instruction.startswith("Identify the best waterfalls")+ # Missing init_url defaults to "".+ assert dp.task.environment_config["init_url"] == ""++ # Adapter must have fallen back to task_data.json on disk for the rubric.+ rubric = dp.task.metadata.get("precomputed_rubric")+ assert isinstance(rubric, dict), (+ f"expected precomputed_rubric dict from task_data.json, got {type(rubric)}"+ )+ assert "items" in rubric and rubric.get("total_max_points"), (+ f"rubric missing expected fields: {list(rubric.keys())}"+ )++ # Step summaries: 4 actions, normalized screenshot filenames, terminal+ # action rewritten stop_and_answer_question → terminate.+ summaries = dp.solver_log.get_step_summaries()+ assert len(summaries) == 4+ for i, s in enumerate(summaries, start=1):+ assert s.index == i+ assert s.screenshot_path.endswith(f"screenshot_{i}.png")+ assert summaries[-1].action_name == "terminate"++ # Outcome passthrough of the final answer.+ assert dp.solver_log.outcome is not None+ assert dp.solver_log.outcome.answer.startswith("The two standout waterfalls")diff --git a/webeval/tests/test_trajectory_loading.py b/webeval/tests/test_trajectory_loading.pynew file mode 100644index 0000000..a041a43--- /dev/null+++ b/webeval/tests/test_trajectory_loading.py@@ -0,0 +1,120 @@+"""Tests for ``webeval.trajectory.Trajectory`` against the bundled+example trajectory at ``webeval/data/example_trajectory``.++The example is a real WebTailBench run (``alltrails_find_23``) checked+into the repo so the loader has a stable fixture — no network access,+no LLM calls, no hard-coded absolute paths.+"""++from __future__ import annotations++from pathlib import Path++import pytest+++EXAMPLE_TRAJECTORY_DIR = (+ Path(__file__).resolve().parent.parent / "data" / "example_trajectory"+)++[email protected](scope="module")+def example_traj_path() -> Path:+ assert EXAMPLE_TRAJECTORY_DIR.is_dir(), (+ f"Missing fixture dir: {EXAMPLE_TRAJECTORY_DIR}"+ )+ return EXAMPLE_TRAJECTORY_DIR+++def test_required_trajectory_files_present(example_traj_path: Path):+ """The fixture dir must contain the file set the current webeval+ pipeline produces — ``verify_trajectories.find_trajectory_dirs``+ keys off ``web_surfer.log`` + ``*_final_answer.json``.+ """+ assert (example_traj_path / "web_surfer.log").exists()+ assert (example_traj_path / "core.log").exists()+ assert (example_traj_path / "times.json").exists()+ assert (example_traj_path / "task_data.json").exists()++ answer_files = list(example_traj_path.glob("*_final_answer.json"))+ assert len(answer_files) == 1, f"expected 1 final-answer file, got {answer_files}"++ screenshots = sorted(example_traj_path.glob("screenshot_*.png"))+ assert len(screenshots) >= 1++ scores = list((example_traj_path / "scores").glob("*.json"))+ assert len(scores) >= 1+++def test_from_folder_returns_none_on_missing_log(tmp_path: Path):+ """``Trajectory.from_folder`` swallows exceptions and returns None;+ an empty dir has no web_surfer.log, so the call must not raise."""+ from webeval.trajectory import Trajectory++ assert Trajectory.from_folder(tmp_path) is None+++def test_from_folder_loads_example_trajectory(example_traj_path: Path):+ """Real trajectory must load, parse events, and resolve screenshot+ paths relative to the trajectory directory."""+ from webeval.trajectory import Trajectory++ traj = Trajectory.from_folder(example_traj_path, gpt_solver=True)+ assert traj is not None, "from_folder returned None on a valid trajectory"++ # web_surfer.log has interleaved SummarizedAction (action=null) and+ # WebSurfer (actual action) rows. With gpt_solver=True the loader+ # filters to source==WebSurfer AND action!=null → exactly one event+ # per taken step. The example has 4 steps.+ assert len(traj.events) == 4+ action_names = [e.get("action") for e in traj.events]+ assert action_names == [+ "input_text",+ "click",+ "pause_and_memorize_fact",+ "stop_and_answer_question",+ ]++ # FinalAnswer was loaded from the *_final_answer.json file.+ assert traj.answer is not None+ assert traj.answer.final_answer.startswith("The two standout waterfalls")+ assert not traj.is_aborted++ # Screenshots listed in the answer JSON are resolved to abs paths+ # rooted at the trajectory dir (is_rel_paths=True → joined in __init__).+ assert len(traj.screenshots) == 4+ for s in traj.screenshots:+ p = Path(s)+ assert p.is_absolute(), f"screenshot path should be absolute: {s}"+ assert p.parent == example_traj_path+ assert p.name.startswith("screenshot_") and p.name.endswith(".png")+ assert p.exists(), f"screenshot file missing: {p}"+++def test_repr_describes_screenshots_and_actions(example_traj_path: Path):+ """``repr(Trajectory)`` reports the counts debugging scripts rely on."""+ from webeval.trajectory import Trajectory++ traj = Trajectory.from_folder(example_traj_path, gpt_solver=True)+ assert traj is not None+ r = repr(traj)+ assert "4 screenshots" in r+ # gpt_solver=True short-circuits actions/thoughts construction, so+ # the "actions" count in repr is 0 in this mode — verify stable.+ assert "0 actions" in r+++if __name__ == "__main__":+ # Keep the old ad-hoc behaviour: running this file directly prints a+ # human-readable summary of the example trajectory. Useful for+ # eyeballing parse output without pytest.+ import sys++ sys.path.insert(0, str(Path(__file__).resolve().parent.parent / "src"))+ from webeval.trajectory import Trajectory++ traj = Trajectory(EXAMPLE_TRAJECTORY_DIR, gpt_solver=True)+ print(repr(traj))+ print(f"events: {len(traj.events)}")+ print(f"screenshots: {len(traj.screenshots)}")+ print(f"answer: {traj.answer.final_answer[:120]}...")diff --git a/webeval/tests/test_verify_trajectories.py b/webeval/tests/test_verify_trajectories.pynew file mode 100644index 0000000..e61de87--- /dev/null+++ b/webeval/tests/test_verify_trajectories.py@@ -0,0 +1,391 @@+"""Smoke tests for ``webeval/scripts/verify_trajectories.py``.++The script is the Universal Verifier's stand-alone runner. It can't be+imported as a normal module (lives under ``scripts/``, not ``src/``), so+we load it via :mod:`importlib.util`. Three layers of coverage:++1. **Pure helpers** — ``find_trajectory_dirs`` and+ ``load_webtailbench_tasks`` don't need the LLM stack and are tested+ directly.+2. **End-to-end with a stub agent** — ``_run_one`` is exercised against+ the checked-in example trajectory with ``_GLOBAL_AGENT`` monkey-+ patched to a fake. This verifies the data-prep pipeline+ (Trajectory → DataPoint → input_dict) and the score-file writer+ without incurring any LLM cost.+3. **Live LLM** — a skipped-by-default variant that hits the real+ verifier. Gate via ``FARA_VERIFY_LIVE_TEST=1`` and a valid+ ``--eval-config`` env (``FARA_VERIFY_EVAL_CONFIG=/path/to/configs``).+"""++from __future__ import annotations++import csv+import importlib.util+import json+import os+import shutil+import sys+import types+from pathlib import Path+from typing import Any, Dict++import pytest+++REPO_ROOT = Path(__file__).resolve().parent.parent.parent+SCRIPT_PATH = REPO_ROOT / "webeval" / "scripts" / "verify_trajectories.py"+EXAMPLE_TRAJECTORY_DIR = (+ Path(__file__).resolve().parent.parent / "data" / "example_trajectory"+)+EXAMPLE_TASK_ID = "alltrails_find_23"+++# ---------------------------------------------------------------------------+# Module loader — ``verify_trajectories.py`` lives under ``scripts/`` and+# isn't on any package path. Load it once per test session.+# ---------------------------------------------------------------------------+[email protected](scope="module")+def verify_mod() -> types.ModuleType:+ assert SCRIPT_PATH.is_file(), f"Missing script: {SCRIPT_PATH}"+ spec = importlib.util.spec_from_file_location(+ "verify_trajectories_under_test", SCRIPT_PATH+ )+ assert spec is not None and spec.loader is not None+ mod = importlib.util.module_from_spec(spec)+ # Ensure sibling packages (webeval, fara) are importable — the script+ # does its own sys.path tweaking at import time, so nothing extra is+ # required here, but conftest.py already covers local dev usage too.+ sys.modules["verify_trajectories_under_test"] = mod+ spec.loader.exec_module(mod)+ return mod+++# ---------------------------------------------------------------------------+# Pure helpers+# ---------------------------------------------------------------------------++def test_find_trajectory_dirs_picks_up_example(tmp_path: Path, verify_mod):+ """The example trajectory satisfies the discovery predicate+ (``web_surfer.log`` + ``*_final_answer.json``)."""+ parent = tmp_path / "traj"+ parent.mkdir()+ shutil.copytree(EXAMPLE_TRAJECTORY_DIR, parent / EXAMPLE_TASK_ID)++ # A sibling dir without a web_surfer.log must be ignored.+ (parent / "not_a_trajectory").mkdir()+ (parent / "not_a_trajectory" / "README.txt").write_text("ignore me")++ found = verify_mod.find_trajectory_dirs(parent)+ assert [d.name for d in found] == [EXAMPLE_TASK_ID]+++def test_load_webtailbench_tasks_parses_rubric(tmp_path: Path, verify_mod):+ """The WebTailBench TSV loader must pull ``id``, ``task_summary``,+ ``init_url``, and JSON-decode ``precomputed_rubric``."""+ tsv = tmp_path / "WebTailBench-v1-rubrics.tsv"+ rubric = {+ "items": [{"criterion": "sample", "max_points": 1}],+ "total_max_points": 1,+ }+ with open(tsv, "w", newline="", encoding="utf-8") as f:+ w = csv.DictWriter(+ f,+ fieldnames=[+ "benchmark",+ "id",+ "task_summary",+ "init_url",+ "precomputed_rubric",+ ],+ delimiter="\t",+ )+ w.writeheader()+ w.writerow(+ {+ "benchmark": "things_to_do",+ "id": EXAMPLE_TASK_ID,+ "task_summary": (+ "Identify the best waterfalls to see while hiking in the "+ "Superstition Mountains, Arizona"+ ),+ "init_url": "",+ "precomputed_rubric": json.dumps(rubric),+ }+ )++ tasks = verify_mod.load_webtailbench_tasks(tsv)+ assert EXAMPLE_TASK_ID in tasks+ task = tasks[EXAMPLE_TASK_ID]+ assert task["question"].startswith("Identify the best waterfalls")+ assert task["category"] == "things_to_do"+ assert task["precomputed_rubric"] == rubric+++# ---------------------------------------------------------------------------+# End-to-end _run_one against the example trajectory (no LLM)+# ---------------------------------------------------------------------------++class _StubAgent:+ """Minimal stand-in for ``MMRubricAgent`` used by ``_run_one``.++ Returns a fixed rubric+outcome verdict so we can exercise the full+ data-prep pipeline (Trajectory → DataPoint → input_dict) and the+ score-file writer without hitting an LLM.+ """++ async def _generate_reply(self, input_dict: Dict[str, Any]) -> Dict[str, Any]:+ # Record the input so the test can assert on it.+ self.last_input = input_dict+ return {+ "items": [{"criterion": "stubbed", "earned_points": 1, "max_points": 1}],+ "total_max_points": 1,+ "total_earned_points": 1,+ "outcome_verification": {+ "output_success": True,+ "reasoning": "stubbed",+ "primary_intent": "stubbed intent",+ },+ "intermediate_mm_rubric_steps": {+ "step9_first_point_of_failure": {+ "has_failure": False,+ "first_failure_step": None,+ },+ "step9b_task_verification_with_trajectory": {+ "is_ambiguous": False,+ "ambiguity_codes": [],+ "is_invalid": False,+ "invalid_task_codes": [],+ },+ "step10_task_verification": {+ "is_ambiguous": False,+ "ambiguity_codes": [],+ "is_invalid": False,+ "invalid_task_codes": [],+ },+ },+ "majority_vote_metadata": {},+ }++ def _wrap_result(self, result):+ from webeval.rubric_agent.data_point import (+ MajorityVoteMetadata,+ MMRubricOutcomeResult,+ MMRubricResult,+ )++ rubric_vr = MMRubricResult(+ score=1.0,+ reasoning="stubbed",+ verifier_name="mm_rubric",+ total_max_points=result["total_max_points"],+ total_earned_points=result["total_earned_points"],+ rubric_is_success=True,+ intermediate_mm_rubric_steps=result["intermediate_mm_rubric_steps"],+ majority_vote_metadata=MajorityVoteMetadata(),+ )+ outcome_vr = MMRubricOutcomeResult(+ score=1.0,+ reasoning="stubbed",+ verifier_name="mm_rubric_outcome",+ output_success=True,+ primary_intent="stubbed intent",+ )+ return [rubric_vr, outcome_vr]+++def test_run_one_end_to_end_with_stubbed_agent(tmp_path: Path, verify_mod):+ """``_run_one`` against a copy of the example trajectory must:++ * Find the task in ``_GLOBAL_TASKS``.+ * Load the Trajectory + convert to DataPoint + build the+ MMRubricAgent input dict (stubbed agent records the dict).+ * Write ``scores/mmrubric_<threshold>-<max_imgs>-<keypt>.json``.+ * Return a result row with ``status == "ok"`` plus success fields.+ """+ # Work on a copy so we don't pollute the checked-in fixture with new+ # score files the verifier writes.+ traj_dir = tmp_path / EXAMPLE_TASK_ID+ shutil.copytree(EXAMPLE_TRAJECTORY_DIR, traj_dir)++ stub = _StubAgent()+ verify_mod._GLOBAL_AGENT = stub+ verify_mod._GLOBAL_TASKS = {+ EXAMPLE_TASK_ID: {+ "id": EXAMPLE_TASK_ID,+ "question": (+ "Identify the best waterfalls to see while hiking in the "+ "Superstition Mountains, Arizona"+ ),+ "init_url": "",+ "category": "things_to_do",+ }+ }+ verify_mod._GLOBAL_ARGS = {+ "rubric_threshold": 0.8,+ "max_images_per_criterion": 5,+ "mm_keypoint_score_threshold": 3,+ "redo_eval": True,+ "success_criterion": "outcome",+ }++ out = verify_mod._run_one(str(traj_dir))++ # Top-line status+ assert out["status"] == "ok", out+ assert out["task_id"] == EXAMPLE_TASK_ID+ assert out["rubric_is_success"] is True+ assert out["outcome_success"] is True+ assert out["n_actions"] == 4++ # Score file is written under scores/mmrubric_*.json with the naming+ # convention the dashboard / post_eval_analysis expects.+ score_path = Path(out["score_path"])+ assert score_path.exists()+ assert score_path.name == "mmrubric_0.8-5-3.json"+ payload = json.loads(score_path.read_text())+ assert payload["score"] == 1 # outcome criterion+ gpt_payload = json.loads(payload["gpt_response_text"])+ assert gpt_payload["outcome_success"] is True+ assert gpt_payload["rubric_is_success"] == 1+ assert gpt_payload["success_criterion"] == "outcome"+ assert "error_taxonomy" in gpt_payload++ # The stub captured the input dict the real agent would have seen —+ # this is the contract the verifier relies on.+ inp = stub.last_input+ assert inp["task"].startswith("Identify the best waterfalls")+ assert inp["predicted_output"].startswith("The two standout waterfalls")+ assert inp["screenshots_dir"] == str(traj_dir)+ assert len(inp["actions_list"]) == 4+ assert len(inp["step_actions"]) == 4+ # The adapter reads the precomputed_rubric from task_data.json on+ # disk when task_data dict omits it — verify that propagated.+ assert isinstance(inp["precomputed_rubric"], dict)+ assert inp["precomputed_rubric"].get("total_max_points")+++def test_run_one_reports_no_task_data(tmp_path: Path, verify_mod):+ """If the trajectory id isn't in ``_GLOBAL_TASKS`` the runner must+ fail soft with ``status='no_task_data'``, not raise."""+ traj_dir = tmp_path / EXAMPLE_TASK_ID+ shutil.copytree(EXAMPLE_TRAJECTORY_DIR, traj_dir)++ verify_mod._GLOBAL_AGENT = _StubAgent()+ verify_mod._GLOBAL_TASKS = {} # empty+ verify_mod._GLOBAL_ARGS = {+ "rubric_threshold": 0.8,+ "max_images_per_criterion": 5,+ "mm_keypoint_score_threshold": 3,+ "redo_eval": True,+ "success_criterion": "outcome",+ }++ out = verify_mod._run_one(str(traj_dir))+ assert out["status"] == "no_task_data"+++# ---------------------------------------------------------------------------+# Live LLM — gated, expensive; not run in CI.+# ---------------------------------------------------------------------------++def _resolve_live_eval_config(dst: Path) -> Path | None:+ """Resolve the ``--eval-config`` dir for the live test from env vars.++ ``GracefulRetryClient.from_path`` lists ``*.json`` directly under its+ ``--eval-config`` argument (non-recursive) and filters by the+ ``eval_model`` field, so the script needs a single flat dir+ containing BOTH the judge (gpt-5) and action-judge (o4-mini)+ endpoint configs.++ Supported env-var shapes:++ * ``FARA_VERIFY_EVAL_CONFIG`` — a single dir already containing+ both sets of configs. Used as-is.+ * ``FARA_VERIFY_JUDGE_CONFIG`` + ``FARA_VERIFY_O4MINI_CONFIG`` — two+ separate dirs; we symlink all ``*.json`` from each into ``dst``+ and return that merged dir.++ Returns ``None`` if no env vars are set (caller should skip the+ live test).+ """+ flat = os.environ.get("FARA_VERIFY_EVAL_CONFIG")+ if flat:+ p = Path(flat)+ return p if p.is_dir() else None++ judge_dir = os.environ.get("FARA_VERIFY_JUDGE_CONFIG")+ o4mini_dir = os.environ.get("FARA_VERIFY_O4MINI_CONFIG")+ if not (judge_dir and o4mini_dir):+ return None++ dst.mkdir(parents=True, exist_ok=True)+ for src_str in (judge_dir, o4mini_dir):+ src = Path(src_str)+ if not src.is_dir():+ return None+ for cfg in src.glob("*.json"):+ link = dst / cfg.name+ if not link.exists():+ link.symlink_to(cfg)+ return dst+++ os.environ.get("FARA_VERIFY_LIVE_TEST") != "1",+ reason="Set FARA_VERIFY_LIVE_TEST=1 to run the live verifier (hits real LLM endpoints)",+)+def test_verify_trajectories_live_llm(tmp_path: Path, verify_mod):+ """Actually call the real MMRubricAgent against the example+ trajectory. Skips unless env vars below are set:++ * ``FARA_VERIFY_LIVE_TEST=1`` (opt-in gate)+ * ``FARA_VERIFY_EVAL_CONFIG`` — flat dir with judge endpoint JSONs, OR+ * ``FARA_VERIFY_JUDGE_CONFIG`` + ``FARA_VERIFY_O4MINI_CONFIG`` —+ per-model dirs (merged via symlink into tmp_path).++ Optional overrides: ``FARA_VERIFY_JUDGE_MODEL`` (default ``gpt-5``),+ ``FARA_VERIFY_O4MINI_MODEL`` (default ``o4-mini``).+ """+ merged_eval_config = _resolve_live_eval_config(tmp_path / "eval_config")+ if merged_eval_config is None:+ pytest.skip(+ "Live verifier needs endpoint configs — set FARA_VERIFY_EVAL_CONFIG "+ "or FARA_VERIFY_JUDGE_CONFIG + FARA_VERIFY_O4MINI_CONFIG"+ )++ traj_dir = tmp_path / EXAMPLE_TASK_ID+ shutil.copytree(EXAMPLE_TRAJECTORY_DIR, traj_dir)++ args_dict = {+ "eval_config": str(merged_eval_config),+ "judge_model": os.environ.get("FARA_VERIFY_JUDGE_MODEL", "gpt-5"),+ "o4mini_model": os.environ.get("FARA_VERIFY_O4MINI_MODEL", "o4-mini"),+ "rubric_threshold": 0.8,+ "max_images_per_criterion": 5,+ "mm_keypoint_score_threshold": 3,+ "majority_vote_instances": 1,+ "redo_eval": True,+ "success_criterion": "outcome",+ }+ tasks = {+ EXAMPLE_TASK_ID: {+ "id": EXAMPLE_TASK_ID,+ "question": (+ "Identify the best waterfalls to see while hiking in the "+ "Superstition Mountains, Arizona"+ ),+ "init_url": "",+ }+ }+ verify_mod._pool_init(args_dict, tasks)+ out = verify_mod._run_one(str(traj_dir))+ assert out["status"] == "ok", out+ assert out["outcome_success"] is True, (+ "Expected live LLM to verify this trajectory succeeds — it "+ "correctly answers the waterfalls question."+ )+ score_path = Path(out["score_path"])+ assert score_path.exists()+ payload = json.loads(score_path.read_text())+ assert payload["score"] in (0, 1) # hard gate: score file parseable