Skip to content

Garry's Opinionated OpenClaw/Hermes Agent Brain

TypeScript
12.0 KB
Raw Blame
{
  "decision_id": "p6-think-notes",
  "plan": "P6",
  "stage": "dev",
  "eligible_for_default": false,
  "eligibility_note": "Dev verdicts come from development data and never set a default. A held-out verdict comes from the custodian after a committed preregistration.",
  "verdict_type": "quality",
  "overall": "inconclusive",
  "decided_at": "2026-10-05T01:39:20.209Z",
  "sources": [
    {
      "source": "lme-s-dev-think",
      "verdict": "inconclusive",
      "arms": {
        "baseline": {
          "package": "gbrain",
          "declared_pin": "github:garrytan/gbrain#739e5cc89ca43b9b9351f0f203c7b12a7c0c571c",
          "declared_sha": "739e5cc89ca43b9b9351f0f203c7b12a7c0c571c",
          "version": "0.60.48.0",
          "package_sha256": "7c1796a95adc86aeb9c8b6f5b603b4b3943bd0b508d607a569d75e703590ebe0",
          "loaded_git_head": "0cba0ec9c35612d8652bcdaf55dbdb4f55d32c39"
        },
        "candidate": {
          "package": "gbrain",
          "declared_pin": "github:garrytan/gbrain#739e5cc89ca43b9b9351f0f203c7b12a7c0c571c",
          "declared_sha": "739e5cc89ca43b9b9351f0f203c7b12a7c0c571c",
          "version": "0.60.48.0",
          "package_sha256": "7c1796a95adc86aeb9c8b6f5b603b4b3943bd0b508d607a569d75e703590ebe0",
          "loaded_git_head": "0cba0ec9c35612d8652bcdaf55dbdb4f55d32c39"
        }
      },
      "family": {
        "family_id": "p6-think-notes:lme-s-dev-think",
        "verdict": "inconclusive",
        "reasons": [
          "qa-score: inconclusive"
        ],
        "alpha": 0.05,
        "holm_family": [
          "qa-score"
        ],
        "comparisons": [
          {
            "id": "qa-score",
            "metric": "qa_score",
            "gate": "superiority",
            "status": "inconclusive",
            "reasons": [
              "an improvement larger than 0 is not shown (Holm p = 0.7486 > 0.05); this is not evidence of a loss"
            ],
            "n_pairs": 150,
            "n_clusters": 150,
            "n_excluded": 0,
            "stats": {
              "n_pairs": 150,
              "n_clusters": 150,
              "mean_a": 0.8866666666666667,
              "mean_b": 0.88,
              "delta": -0.006666666666666667,
              "se_cluster": 0.014947085390483146,
              "se_iid": 0.014947085390483145,
              "design_effect": 1.0000000000000004,
              "effective_n": 149.99999999999994,
              "ci95": [
                -0.03333333333333333,
                0.02
              ],
              "p_two_sided": 1,
              "p_greater": 0.8164183581641836,
              "p_less": 0.5008499150084992,
              "p_method": "monte-carlo-sign-flip"
            },
            "mcnemar": {
              "losses": 3,
              "wins": 2,
              "both_pass": 130,
              "both_fail": 15,
              "discordant": 5,
              "p_two_sided": 1
            },
            "power": {
              "alpha": 0.05,
              "power": 0.8,
              "mde": 0.04187553349481874,
              "min_one_sided_discordant": 6,
              "note": "with 150 pairs in 150 clusters, a two-sided 0.05 test has 80% power for an absolute change of about 0.0419; the observed delta is below that size, so a null result here is not evidence of no effect; an exact McNemar test needs at least 6 wins with zero losses to reach 0.05"
            },
            "direction": "higher",
            "p_holm": 0.7486251374862514,
            "min_effect": 0,
            "p_superiority": 0.7486251374862514
          },
          {
            "id": "recall-all-5",
            "metric": "recall_all_at_5",
            "gate": "exploratory",
            "status": "report_only",
            "reasons": [],
            "n_pairs": 142,
            "n_clusters": 142,
            "n_excluded": 8,
            "stats": {
              "n_pairs": 142,
              "n_clusters": 142,
              "mean_a": 0.9436619718309859,
              "mean_b": 0.9436619718309859,
              "delta": 0,
              "se_cluster": 0,
              "se_iid": 0,
              "design_effect": null,
              "effective_n": null,
              "ci95": [
                0,
                0
              ],
              "p_two_sided": 1,
              "p_greater": 1,
              "p_less": 1,
              "p_method": "degenerate"
            },
            "mcnemar": {
              "losses": 0,
              "wins": 0,
              "both_pass": 134,
              "both_fail": 8,
              "discordant": 0,
              "p_two_sided": 1
            },
            "power": {
              "alpha": 0.05,
              "power": 0.8,
              "mde": null,
              "min_one_sided_discordant": 6,
              "note": "no paired variation was observed, so the detectable effect cannot be estimated from this data; an exact McNemar test needs at least 6 wins with zero losses to reach 0.05"
            },
            "direction": "higher"
          },
          {
            "id": "qa-input-tokens",
            "metric": "qa_input_tokens",
            "gate": "exploratory",
            "status": "report_only",
            "reasons": [],
            "n_pairs": 150,
            "n_clusters": 150,
            "n_excluded": 0,
            "stats": {
              "n_pairs": 150,
              "n_clusters": 150,
              "mean_a": 23.213333333333335,
              "mean_b": 23.213333333333335,
              "delta": 0,
              "se_cluster": 0,
              "se_iid": 0,
              "design_effect": null,
              "effective_n": null,
              "ci95": [
                0,
                0
              ],
              "p_two_sided": 1,
              "p_greater": 1,
              "p_less": 1,
              "p_method": "degenerate"
            },
            "power": {
              "alpha": 0.05,
              "power": 0.8,
              "mde": null,
              "min_one_sided_discordant": null,
              "note": "no paired variation was observed, so the detectable effect cannot be estimated from this data"
            },
            "direction": "lower"
          }
        ]
      }
    },
    {
      "source": "locomo-dev-think",
      "verdict": "inconclusive",
      "arms": {
        "baseline": {
          "package": "gbrain",
          "declared_pin": "github:garrytan/gbrain#739e5cc89ca43b9b9351f0f203c7b12a7c0c571c",
          "declared_sha": "739e5cc89ca43b9b9351f0f203c7b12a7c0c571c",
          "version": "0.60.48.0",
          "package_sha256": "7c1796a95adc86aeb9c8b6f5b603b4b3943bd0b508d607a569d75e703590ebe0",
          "loaded_git_head": "0cba0ec9c35612d8652bcdaf55dbdb4f55d32c39"
        },
        "candidate": {
          "package": "gbrain",
          "declared_pin": "github:garrytan/gbrain#739e5cc89ca43b9b9351f0f203c7b12a7c0c571c",
          "declared_sha": "739e5cc89ca43b9b9351f0f203c7b12a7c0c571c",
          "version": "0.60.48.0",
          "package_sha256": "7c1796a95adc86aeb9c8b6f5b603b4b3943bd0b508d607a569d75e703590ebe0",
          "loaded_git_head": "0cba0ec9c35612d8652bcdaf55dbdb4f55d32c39"
        }
      },
      "family": {
        "family_id": "p6-think-notes:locomo-dev-think",
        "verdict": "inconclusive",
        "reasons": [
          "qa-score: inconclusive"
        ],
        "alpha": 0.05,
        "holm_family": [
          "qa-score"
        ],
        "comparisons": [
          {
            "id": "qa-score",
            "metric": "qa_score",
            "gate": "superiority",
            "status": "inconclusive",
            "reasons": [
              "McNemar treats items as independent; the clustered sign-flip p-value is the primary test here",
              "an improvement larger than 0 is not shown (Holm p = 1.0000 > 0.05); this is not evidence of a loss"
            ],
            "n_pairs": 587,
            "n_clusters": 3,
            "n_excluded": 0,
            "stats": {
              "n_pairs": 587,
              "n_clusters": 3,
              "mean_a": 0.8943781942078365,
              "mean_b": 0.879045996592845,
              "delta": -0.015332197614991482,
              "se_cluster": 0.011104515918088198,
              "se_iid": 0.009774154610923767,
              "design_effect": 1.2907461931830273,
              "effective_n": 454.7756972673586,
              "ci95": [
                -0.03347280334728033,
                0
              ],
              "p_two_sided": 0.5,
              "p_greater": 1,
              "p_less": 0.25,
              "p_method": "exact-sign-flip"
            },
            "mcnemar": {
              "losses": 21,
              "wins": 12,
              "both_pass": 504,
              "both_fail": 50,
              "discordant": 33,
              "p_two_sided": 0.16275565745308995
            },
            "power": {
              "alpha": 0.05,
              "power": 0.8,
              "mde": 0.03111024765856505,
              "min_one_sided_discordant": 6,
              "note": "with 587 pairs in 3 clusters, a two-sided 0.05 test has 80% power for an absolute change of about 0.0311; the observed delta is below that size, so a null result here is not evidence of no effect; an exact McNemar test needs at least 6 wins with zero losses to reach 0.05; clustering inflates variance by 1.29x (effective n about 454.8 of 587)"
            },
            "direction": "higher",
            "p_holm": 1,
            "min_effect": 0,
            "p_superiority": 1
          },
          {
            "id": "recall-all-5",
            "metric": "recall_all_at_5",
            "gate": "exploratory",
            "status": "report_only",
            "reasons": [
              "McNemar treats items as independent; the clustered sign-flip p-value is the primary test here"
            ],
            "n_pairs": 464,
            "n_clusters": 3,
            "n_excluded": 123,
            "stats": {
              "n_pairs": 464,
              "n_clusters": 3,
              "mean_a": 0.7564655172413793,
              "mean_b": 0.7564655172413793,
              "delta": 0,
              "se_cluster": 0,
              "se_iid": 0,
              "design_effect": null,
              "effective_n": null,
              "ci95": [
                0,
                0
              ],
              "p_two_sided": 1,
              "p_greater": 1,
              "p_less": 1,
              "p_method": "degenerate"
            },
            "mcnemar": {
              "losses": 0,
              "wins": 0,
              "both_pass": 351,
              "both_fail": 113,
              "discordant": 0,
              "p_two_sided": 1
            },
            "power": {
              "alpha": 0.05,
              "power": 0.8,
              "mde": null,
              "min_one_sided_discordant": 6,
              "note": "no paired variation was observed, so the detectable effect cannot be estimated from this data; an exact McNemar test needs at least 6 wins with zero losses to reach 0.05"
            },
            "direction": "higher"
          },
          {
            "id": "qa-input-tokens",
            "metric": "qa_input_tokens",
            "gate": "exploratory",
            "status": "report_only",
            "reasons": [],
            "n_pairs": 587,
            "n_clusters": 3,
            "n_excluded": 0,
            "stats": {
              "n_pairs": 587,
              "n_clusters": 3,
              "mean_a": 15,
              "mean_b": 15,
              "delta": 0,
              "se_cluster": 0,
              "se_iid": 0,
              "design_effect": null,
              "effective_n": null,
              "ci95": [
                0,
                0
              ],
              "p_two_sided": 1,
              "p_greater": 1,
              "p_less": 1,
              "p_method": "degenerate"
            },
            "power": {
              "alpha": 0.05,
              "power": 0.8,
              "mde": null,
              "min_one_sided_discordant": null,
              "note": "no paired variation was observed, so the detectable effect cannot be estimated from this data"
            },
            "direction": "lower"
          }
        ]
      }
    }
  ]
}