Skip to content

Apple's open-source XNU kernel on Android phones: its own loader and drivers, Metal on the Adreno. Runs from RAM; a reboot gives the phone back to Android.

C

After the page arrives: no signature failure is announced, and a fourth shape of a lying instrument

vcvkkefa91c610657
diff --git a/README.md b/README.md
index d8bfdbb..083fcfb 100644
--- a/README.md
+++ b/README.md
@@ -1918,7 +1918,17 @@ appstored: task 0 COMPLETED status 200, 43713 байт, application/json, bag.
приложении: `ios-appstore.jetpack` — документ для JetEngine, а JetEngine здесь есть на томе
(`System/Library/PrivateFrameworks/JetEngine.framework`, рядом `_JetEngine_SwiftUI.framework`) и это
**фреймворк, а не демон** — пропавшего процесса, на который можно свалить, нет, приложение рисует само.
-Это и есть следующее расследование, и оно уже названо.
+Это и есть следующее расследование, и оно уже названо. Первые шаги в нём уже сделаны: **тот же документ
+в 177 786 байт скачивается дважды** — так ведёт себя то, что загрузили, отвергли и попробовали снова, —
+а подписанного провала JetEngine при этом не объявляет: за сеанс приложение рассылает 169–197
+уведомлений, и ни одного про jetpack, подпись, проверку или brotli (единственное от JetEngine вообще —
+`JetEngine.Unstable.Accounts.didChangeNotification`, то есть движок жив и работает). `JEBrotliDecoder`
+в процессе App Store есть (в `appstored` его нет) и отвечает на `-decoder` и
+`-decompressStreamWithAvailableIn:nextIn:availableOut:nextOut:`, перехват на него встал, и ни одной
+строки о распаковке так и не появилось. Похоже, что страницу скачивают и не распаковывают — но это
+**не доказано**: строка счётчика того же перехвата из отчёта тоже пропала, а пропавшая строка — ровно то,
+в чём эта ветка ошибалась пять раз. Следующий прогон должен печатать этот счётчик отдельно и рано, а не
+одной строкой в отчёте на шестьдесят строк.
Значит, работа всё-таки не в AMS: понять, почему `fairplayd.H2` выходит с `exit(0)` сразу, и удержать
его живым; подмена выше — опыт, показывающий, что это починит.
diff --git a/userland/src/inject_store.c b/userland/src/inject_store.c
index 14f6f9d..7011bc7 100644
--- a/userland/src/inject_store.c
+++ b/userland/src/inject_store.c
@@ -154,6 +154,7 @@ struct replacement {
};
static struct replacement replacements[];
static size_t replacement_count(void);
+static void image_added(const struct mach_header *header, intptr_t image_slide);
/*
* How many times each hook was entered: a count that survives a console that drops lines. The names
@@ -168,7 +169,8 @@ enum {
COUNT_dataTaskPromise, COUNT_dataTask, COUNT_addCookies, COUNT_addStorefrontHeader, COUNT_addAnisette,
COUNT_prepareRequest, COUNT_finishWithResult, COUNT_finishWithError, COUNT_finishFunnel,
COUNT_finishResultError, COUNT_thenWithBlock, COUNT_continueWithBlock, COUNT_bagValue,
- COUNT_resultBefore, COUNT_afterUpdating, COUNT_addCookies4, COUNT_fpDeviceType, COUNT_last
+ COUNT_resultBefore, COUNT_afterUpdating, COUNT_addCookies4, COUNT_fpDeviceType, COUNT_brotli,
+ COUNT_last
};
static const char *const counted[COUNT_last] = {
"-[ACAccount ams_storefront]", "-[AMSBagNetworkDataSource cachedStorefront]",
@@ -192,6 +194,7 @@ static const char *const counted[COUNT_last] = {
"-[ACAccountStore _ams_localiTunesAccountAfterUpdatingStorefront:]",
"ams_addCookiesForAccount:clientInfo:bag:cleanupGlobalCookies:",
"-[AMSUserAgent _sharedComponentFairPlayDeviceType]",
+ "-[JEBrotliDecoder decompressStreamWithAvailableIn:nextIn:availableOut:nextOut:]",
};
static unsigned long entered[COUNT_last];
/*
@@ -229,6 +232,21 @@ say(const char *format, ...)
if (console == -2) {
console = open("/dev/console", O_WRONLY | O_APPEND);
}
+ /*
+ * And say which process. Two of them carry this library and both write to the one console, so a
+ * report read by position belongs to whichever process happened to be writing -- the lines are
+ * interleaved, not grouped. Every line names its own program instead.
+ */
+ if (strncmp(line, "redwood: store: ", 16) == 0) {
+ char named[sizeof(line) + 32];
+
+ n = snprintf(named, sizeof(named), "redwood: %s: %s", who, line + 16);
+ if (n > (int)sizeof(named) - 1) {
+ n = sizeof(named) - 1;
+ }
+ write(console >= 0 ? console : 2, named, (size_t)n);
+ return;
+ }
write(console >= 0 ? console : 2, line, (size_t)n);
}
@@ -341,6 +359,112 @@ dump_tasks(void)
}
}
+/*
+ * WHAT HAPPENS TO THE PAGE AFTER IT ARRIVES. The front page comes down whole and nothing draws it,
+ * and the report that showed that also showed something nobody was looking for: THE SAME 177 786
+ * BYTES WERE FETCHED TWICE. A document that parsed would not be fetched again, so the likeliest
+ * story is loaded, rejected, tried again.
+ * JetEngine says how it would reject one. It carries jetpackSignatureVerificationDidFailNotification
+ * -- a signature is verified and there is a named way of announcing that it was not liked -- and a
+ * JEBrotliDecoder, so the body is compressed before any of that; JetPackSigningPolicy,
+ * JetpackSignatureVerifierP, JetPackageFormatParser and JetpackErrorDomain are all in the same
+ * library. Every one of those rejects AFTER the bytes are on disk, which is the shape measured.
+ * Rather than guess the notification's string (a name is one of the ways an instrument lies -- see
+ * below), every notification posted in the process is watched and the ones whose name speaks of
+ * jetpacks, signatures, verification or brotli are printed.
+ * WHAT IT SAYS SO FAR. No signature-failure notification is ever posted: 169 to 197 notifications in
+ * a session of the app and not one about a jetpack, a signature, verification or brotli -- the only
+ * JetEngine notification seen at all is JetEngine.Unstable.Accounts.didChangeNotification, so the
+ * engine is alive and posting. JEBrotliDecoder is in the App Store's process and not in appstored,
+ * it answers to -decoder and -decompressStreamWithAvailableIn:nextIn:availableOut:nextOut:, the
+ * app's NOT TAKEN list does not name it, and no BROTLI line is ever printed. That points at a page
+ * that is fetched and never decompressed -- but it is NOT settled, because the counter line for that
+ * hook is missing from the report as well, and a line that is missing is the thing this branch has
+ * been wrong about five times. The next run should print the brotli counter on its own, early, not
+ * as one line of a sixty-line report.
+ *
+ * THE THREE SHAPES OF AN INSTRUMENT THAT LIES, all of them met on this branch, all of them making a
+ * thing that happened look like a thing that did not:
+ * the wrong channel -- the library was inside AppStore.app and said nothing, because an app
+ * started by SpringBoard has no console on standard error (say() writes to /dev/console now);
+ * the wrong name -- a hook on ams_addCookiesForAccount:clientInfo:bag: never fired for a whole
+ * evening because the cookies go through the four-argument ...:cleanupGlobalCookies: instead;
+ * the wrong moment -- one report at 150 s, while the App Store starts when it is tapped at 95 s
+ * and its report fell past the end of the run (every minute now);
+ * the wrong order -- the hook on JEBrotliDecoder was NOT TAKEN although the class is plainly in
+ * the process (the report's own selector dump lists its methods): the table is tried when dyld
+ * adds an image, and a Swift framework's classes are registered after that callback runs, so
+ * the one moment it was looked for was the one moment it was not there. The table is tried
+ * again every minute now, which costs nothing and cannot miss a late arrival.
+ * The fifth shape belongs in this list when it is found.
+ */
+/*
+ * And the decompression, since no signature-failure notification is ever posted (169 to 197
+ * notifications in a session of the app, not one of them about a jetpack, a signature, verification
+ * or brotli). JEBrotliDecoder is in the App Store's process and not in appstored, and it answers to
+ * -decoder and -decompressStreamWithAvailableIn:nextIn:availableOut:nextOut:. The result is an
+ * integer status, so it is printed as one: a decode that never runs and a decode that fails are the
+ * same silence otherwise.
+ */
+static long (*old_brotli)(id, SEL, void *, void *, void *, void *);
+static long
+new_brotli(id self, SEL cmd, void *a, void *b, void *c, void *d)
+{
+ long result;
+
+ entered[COUNT_brotli]++;
+ result = old_brotli(self, cmd, a, b, c, d);
+ returned[COUNT_brotli]++;
+ if (returned[COUNT_brotli] <= 4 || result != 1) {
+ say("redwood: store: BROTLI decompressStream -> %ld (call %lu)\n", result, returned[COUNT_brotli]);
+ }
+ return result;
+}
+
+static unsigned long notifications;
+
+static bool
+interesting_name(const char *name)
+{
+ static const char *const words[] = { "jet", "Jet", "ignature", "erif", "rotli", "JE", "Pack" };
+
+ for (unsigned i = 0; i < sizeof(words) / sizeof(words[0]); i++) {
+ if (strstr(name, words[i]) != NULL) {
+ return true;
+ }
+ }
+ return false;
+}
+
+static id (*old_postName)(id, SEL, id, id, id);
+static id
+new_postName(id self, SEL cmd, id name, id object, id info)
+{
+ char buffer[160];
+ const char *text = text_of(name, buffer, sizeof(buffer));
+
+ notifications++;
+ if (interesting_name(text)) {
+ say("redwood: store: NOTIFICATION %s\n", text);
+ }
+ return old_postName(self, cmd, name, object, info);
+}
+
+static id (*old_postNotification)(id, SEL, id);
+static id
+new_postNotification(id self, SEL cmd, id note)
+{
+ char buffer[160];
+ id name = ((id (*)(id, SEL))objc_msgSend)(note, sel_registerName("name"));
+ const char *text = text_of(name, buffer, sizeof(buffer));
+
+ notifications++;
+ if (interesting_name(text)) {
+ say("redwood: store: NOTIFICATION (object) %s\n", text);
+ }
+ return old_postNotification(self, cmd, note);
+}
+
/*
* A GRAPH OF PROMISES, not a list of calls. One promise in seventeen is ever finished here, and
* naming the next deadlock by hand would take a slot each: what is wanted is the root -- a promise
@@ -749,6 +873,7 @@ static void
one_report(unsigned seconds)
{
say("redwood: store(%s): report at %u s\n", who, seconds);
+ image_added(NULL, 0); /* and try again for anything whose class has turned up since */
for (size_t i = 0; i < replacement_count(); i++) {
if (!replacements[i].done) {
@@ -772,6 +897,8 @@ one_report(unsigned seconds)
dump_tasks();
dump_threads();
dump_selectors("AMSURLSession", "equest");
+ dump_selectors("JEBrotliDecoder", NULL);
+ say("redwood: store: %lu notifications posted\n", notifications);
}
/*
@@ -1133,6 +1260,12 @@ static struct replacement replacements[] = {
(IMP *)&old_afterUpdating, false },
{ "NSMutableURLRequest", "ams_addCookiesForAccount:clientInfo:bag:cleanupGlobalCookies:", false,
(IMP)new_addCookies4, (IMP *)&old_addCookies4, false },
+ { "JEBrotliDecoder", "decompressStreamWithAvailableIn:nextIn:availableOut:nextOut:", false, (IMP)new_brotli,
+ (IMP *)&old_brotli, false },
+ { "NSNotificationCenter", "postNotificationName:object:userInfo:", false, (IMP)new_postName,
+ (IMP *)&old_postName, false },
+ { "NSNotificationCenter", "postNotification:", false, (IMP)new_postNotification,
+ (IMP *)&old_postNotification, false },
{ "AMSUserAgent", "_sharedComponentFairPlayDeviceType", false, (IMP)new_fpDeviceType,
(IMP *)&old_fpDeviceType, false },
{ "AMSUserAgent", "_sharedComponentFairPlayDeviceType", true, (IMP)new_fpDeviceType,