Skip to content

Anti-AI-slop design skill for Claude Code, Cursor, and Codex.

CSS

The catalog stops riding along on derived runs

Yousseffa09ddc24cda
diff --git a/README.md b/README.md
index 0f2531c..a6ca30c 100644
--- a/README.md
+++ b/README.md
@@ -2,7 +2,7 @@
**A design skill for Claude Code, Cursor, and Codex that refuses to look AI-generated.**
-[Live demo →](https://www.usehallmark.com)  ·  twenty-four themes  ·  five verbs  ·  press `T` to cycle.
+[Live demo →](https://www.usehallmark.com)  ·  a derived world per brief  ·  twenty-three themes  ·  five verbs  ·  press `T` to cycle.
Made by Together AI.
@@ -10,7 +10,7 @@ Made by Together AI.
<img src="site/OG-hallmark.png" alt="Hallmark, a design skill that refuses to look AI-generated" />
</p>
-Hallmark holds a hard floor and then gets out of the way. It dresses the brief in one of twenty-four themes, runs a fifty-eight-gate slop test plus a pre-emit self-critique, and refuses the on-distribution defaults every LLM was trained into.
+Hallmark holds a hard floor and then gets out of the way. It derives a visual world made-to-measure for each brief (an outside draw picks among grounded directions, so the model cannot repeat its favourite), keeps twenty-three named themes as a fast path, runs a fifty-eight-gate slop test plus a pre-emit self-critique, and refuses the on-distribution defaults every LLM was trained into.
Thirty-four of those gates are a **floor**: contrast, focus order, reduced motion, invented metrics, layout that breaks on a phone, and the eyebrow above the heading. Nothing ships through them. Eighteen are **reflex** gates, the defaults a language model falls into rather than laws, and a build with an argument can overrule one on the record, with the reason named in the CSS stamp and the guard re-derived by the checker. There is no cap on how many: a colour-field poster that wants a black stage, achromatic neutrals and one face doing everything is allowed to say so and ship. The last six are polish and bookkeeping and never block a ship.
@@ -94,7 +94,7 @@ In v1.2 the custom route runs a full art-direction ritual: it names and rejects
</tr>
</table>
-It stays a quiet branch; vanilla briefs never see it. The protocol lives in [`custom-theme.md`](skills/hallmark/references/custom-theme.md).
+It stays a quiet branch; vanilla briefs never see it. The protocol lives in [`direction.md`](skills/hallmark/references/direction.md).
---
diff --git a/ROADMAP.md b/ROADMAP.md
index 20428a8..ceeeb2f 100644
--- a/ROADMAP.md
+++ b/ROADMAP.md
@@ -1,6 +1,6 @@
# Roadmap
-What's next. (v1.2 shipped: four new themes with the image hook, spec files for all 24 themes, the edit-time lint hook, the Tier A conformance harness, variants v2 with progressive reveal + grafts + thumbnails + scoped injection and the corner dock, and the harness pivot - one core with per-harness adapters for Claude Code / Codex / OpenCode plus the multi-harness installer.)
+What's next. (v1.2 shipped: four new themes with the image hook, spec files for every theme, the edit-time lint hook, the Tier A conformance harness, variants v2 with progressive reveal + grafts + thumbnails + scoped injection and the corner dock, and the harness pivot - one core with per-harness adapters for Claude Code / Codex / OpenCode plus the multi-harness installer.)
**Since v1.2: the floor / library split.** The eyebrow is banned outright, in every geometry, with a DOM-shape detector behind it and twelve replacement openings in `section-entry.md`. The 58 gates gained tiers: 34 carry a Floor clause that nothing ships through, 18 are Reflex gates a build can waive on the record with a mechanically re-derived guard and no cap, 6 never block. `FAIL` and `REFLEX` are separate grades, so "0 FAIL" is a true claim about the floor even while a build still owes an argument above it. Themes were cut to a written contract and are material rather than page plans, which took them from 4,070 lines to 2,861. The catalogs stopped being a mandatory pick and became a place to look.
diff --git a/eval/briefs.json b/eval/briefs.json
index 286509d..e2da050 100644
--- a/eval/briefs.json
+++ b/eval/briefs.json
@@ -59,7 +59,7 @@
"brief": "--fast Build a landing page for a two-person bookbinding workshop that takes commissions.",
"expect": {
"scope": "page",
- "notes": "Route coverage for the catalog fast path after derivation became the default. --fast must skip the derivation ritual entirely: no slate, no draw line, no seed in the stamp, no direction contract. The stamp must name one of the 24 catalog themes rather than 'custom'. Its twin is b1, which names no theme and must therefore derive."
+ "notes": "Route coverage for the catalog fast path after derivation became the default. --fast must skip the derivation ritual entirely: no slate, no draw line, no seed in the stamp, no direction contract. The stamp must name one of the 23 catalog themes rather than 'custom'. Its twin is b1, which names no theme and must therefore derive."
}
}
]
diff --git a/eval/gen-cli.mjs b/eval/gen-cli.mjs
index 99eb3f7..8fafb3b 100644
--- a/eval/gen-cli.mjs
+++ b/eval/gen-cli.mjs
@@ -111,11 +111,11 @@ function analyzeTranscript(lines, runDir) {
return { cost, model, sessionInit, resultText, isError, refReads, filesWritten, earlyStop, usage, numTurns, stop };
}
-// Reference-read budget. Was 10, which predated derivation becoming the default:
-// a derived run reads direction.md AND theme-axes.md where a catalog run read one
-// theme file, so the floor moved up by one, and a measured clean derived build
-// lands at 12 (ritual, genre, hero-discipline, rejection table, then the eight
-// universal files). 14 leaves room for two legitimate conditionals and still
+// Reference-read budget. Was 10, which predated derivation becoming the default.
+// A derived run now reads direction.md only (the worn-coordinates digest lives
+// inside it; theme-axes.md is catalog-route-only), and a measured clean derived
+// build lands at 11 (ritual, genre, hero-discipline, then the eight
+// universal files). 14 leaves room for legitimate conditionals and still
// catches the failure this check exists for, which is defensive pre-loading of a
// forty-file reference tree.
const REF_BUDGET = 14;
diff --git a/site/_tests/all-themes.html b/site/_tests/all-themes.html
index 40080da..a7fdd02 100644
--- a/site/_tests/all-themes.html
+++ b/site/_tests/all-themes.html
@@ -1,12 +1,12 @@
<!doctype html>
-<!-- Internal review sheet: all 24 themes as live, scaled previews of the landing
+<!-- Internal review sheet: all 23 themes as live, scaled previews of the landing
(../index.html?theme=KEY). Click any card to open it full. Not linked from
the public site. -->
<html lang="en">
<head>
<meta charset="utf-8" />
<meta name="viewport" content="width=device-width, initial-scale=1" />
- <title>Hallmark - all 24 themes</title>
+ <title>Hallmark - all 23 themes</title>
<style>
:root {
--thumb-w: 460px;
@@ -78,7 +78,7 @@
</head>
<body>
<header class="top">
- <h1>Hallmark — all <b>24</b> themes</h1>
+ <h1>Hallmark — all <b>23</b> themes</h1>
<p class="sub">Live previews of the landing in each theme. Click any card to open it full in a new tab. Tags are my recommendation, not a decision — yours to make.</p>
<div class="legend">
<span><i class="dot dot--keep"></i> Keep — distinctive</span>
@@ -112,7 +112,6 @@
{ k:"lumen", n:"Lumen", v:"Keep", t:"keep" },
{ k:"hum", n:"Hum", v:"Default", t:"keep" },
{ k:"grid", n:"Grid", v:"v1.2", t:"keep" },
- { k:"field", n:"Field", v:"v1.2", t:"keep" },
{ k:"ledger", n:"Ledger", v:"v1.2", t:"keep" },
{ k:"arcade", n:"Arcade", v:"v1.2", t:"keep" }
];
diff --git a/site/js/main.js b/site/js/main.js
index 4ee7715..5b4be4b 100644
--- a/site/js/main.js
+++ b/site/js/main.js
@@ -61,7 +61,6 @@ const THEMES = {
lumen: "Lumen",
cobalt: "Cobalt",
grid: "Grid",
- field: "Field",
ledger: "Ledger",
arcade: "Arcade",
};
@@ -93,7 +92,6 @@ const ARCHETYPES = {
hum: { hero: "hum", footer: "colophon" },
cobalt: { hero: "cobalt", footer: "colophon" },
grid: { hero: "marquee", footer: "colophon" },
- field: { hero: "split", footer: "colophon" },
ledger: { hero: "stat-led", footer: "colophon" },
arcade: { hero: "marquee", footer: "colophon" },
};
@@ -131,7 +129,6 @@ const THEME_GENRES = {
// v1.2 themes
grid: "editorial", // the Swiss / grotesque exception in the editorial cluster
ledger: "modern-minimal", // the cluster's one dark option, next to light Coral / Cobalt
- field: "playful",
arcade: "playful",
};
@@ -241,7 +238,7 @@ const COPY = {
quote: "An almanac is a book that knows where to look.",
attrib: "Almanac, frontispiece",
salutation: "Reference note,",
- letterBody: "This page is a reference, not an argument. The numbers are the point: 21 macrostructures, 50 archetypes, 24 themes, 58 slop-test gates. Cross-referenced so the next page Hallmark builds is genuinely different from the last.",
+ letterBody: "This page is a reference, not an argument. The numbers are the point: 21 macrostructures, 50 archetypes, 23 themes, 58 slop-test gates. Cross-referenced so the next page Hallmark builds is genuinely different from the last.",
signoff: "— editor",
captionA: "Vol. III",
captionB: "Plate 12",
@@ -349,7 +346,7 @@ const COPY = {
studio: {
colophon: "Studio · 2026",
title: HERO_TITLE,
- lede: "We design and build distinctive products for ambitious teams. Hallmark is our typography opinion, codified — twenty-four themes, twenty-one shapes, no defaults.",
+ lede: "We design and build distinctive products for ambitious teams. Hallmark is our typography opinion, codified — twenty-three themes, twenty-one shapes, no defaults.",
ctaLabel: "Engage",
proofLabel: "Selected work",
proofA: "01 — A foundry rebrand",
@@ -473,7 +470,7 @@ const COPY = {
carnival: {
colophon: "NO TEMPLATES · NO DEFAULTS",
title: HERO_TITLE,
- lede: "24 themes that refuse to blend in. Pick one and the whole page changes — the bones, not the paint.",
+ lede: "23 themes that refuse to blend in. Pick one and the whole page changes — the bones, not the paint.",
ctaLabel: "Install",
proofLabel: "ON THE BILL",
proofA: "21 page-shapes, 50 archetypes",
@@ -485,7 +482,7 @@ const COPY = {
quote: "A PAGE THAT HEDGES IS A PAGE THAT FAILS.",
attrib: "CARNIVAL",
salutation: "WE PRINT POSTERS, NOT TEMPLATES.",
- letterBody: "Every model was trained on the same page. Carnival refuses it — loud type, duo-tone ink, ornaments that mean it. 24 themes in the catalog, and not one of them whispers.",
+ letterBody: "Every model was trained on the same page. Carnival refuses it — loud type, duo-tone ink, ornaments that mean it. 23 themes in the catalog, and not one of them whispers.",
signoff: "— CARNIVAL",
captionA: "BILL 01",
captionB: "OUT NOW",
@@ -493,7 +490,7 @@ const COPY = {
lumen: {
colophon: "00 · DESIGN SKILL",
title: HERO_TITLE,
- lede: "a design skill that refuses the defaults every model was trained on. twenty-four themes, twenty-one page-shapes, and one slop test that gates every build before it ships.",
+ lede: "a design skill that refuses the defaults every model was trained on. twenty-three themes, twenty-one page-shapes, and one slop test that gates every build before it ships.",
ctaLabel: "install",
proofLabel: "00 · SPEC",
proofA: "21 page-shapes · 50 archetypes",
@@ -505,7 +502,7 @@ const COPY = {
quote: "two briefs, two pages — not one template, recoloured.",
attrib: "lumen",
salutation: "built to refuse the default.",
- letterBody: "every model emits the same page. lumen is the part that refuses — lowercase classical serif, one accent verb, a hand-built apparatus where the orb used to be. twenty-four themes in the catalog, and the numbers hold under load.",
+ letterBody: "every model emits the same page. lumen is the part that refuses — lowercase classical serif, one accent verb, a hand-built apparatus where the orb used to be. twenty-three themes in the catalog, and the numbers hold under load.",
signoff: "— lumen",
captionA: "00 · spec",
captionB: "night foundry",
@@ -572,27 +569,6 @@ const COPY = {
captionA: "Grid",
captionB: "v1.2",
},
- field: {
- colophon: "Warm productivity",
- title: HERO_TITLE,
- lede: "The serious tool that feels hand-made. Cream paper, a Source Serif headline over humanist Public Sans, one marigold highlighter behind the phrase that matters, and hand-drawn ink where a diagram helps.",
- ctaLabel: "Start free",
- proofLabel: "Made, not generated",
- proofA: "Cream paper · Source Serif + Public Sans",
- proofB: "Marigold highlighter, one phrase",
- proofC: "Hand-drawn ink accents",
- cta: "See how it works",
- stat: "1",
- qualifier: "highlighter, on the phrase that matters.",
- mockStat: "1",
- quote: "Credible, warm, a little hand-made. Software that reads like a good notebook.",
- attrib: "Field note",
- salutation: "A plan, by the time you stand up.",
- letterBody: "Warm-productivity SaaS without the cute: a serif display for weight, a humanist sans for the work, one marigold band on the phrase that carries the promise, and ink doodles that behave like margin notes rather than decoration.",
- signoff: "Noted,",
- captionA: "Field",
- captionB: "v1.2",
- },
ledger: {
colophon: "Fintech terminal-lux",
title: HERO_TITLE,
diff --git a/skills/hallmark/SKILL.md b/skills/hallmark/SKILL.md
index 64e110a..3d38e4d 100644
--- a/skills/hallmark/SKILL.md
+++ b/skills/hallmark/SKILL.md
@@ -204,7 +204,7 @@ Two things the catalogs are not: a checklist you owe, and a rotation you must wa
**Rotation (the canonical block - every other file defers here):**
- **Structure:** the page's shape must differ from the last three Hallmark outputs for this project (read `.hallmark/log.json`, newest first; a CSS stamp counts when the log is missing). Whether you named a catalog shape or invented one, the log records what you built and the next run has to move.
-- **Theme:** two consecutive systems must differ on at least one of three axes: **paper band** (dark < 30% L · mid 30-85% · light > 85%), **display style**, **accent hue** (warm 10-60° · cool 200-300° · neutral · chromatic-other). A derived system declares its own triple ([`references/direction.md`](references/direction.md) § D) and must additionally clear all 24 catalog coordinates ([`references/theme-axes.md`](references/theme-axes.md) § The rejection reading). On the fast path, the 24-row table is also the lookup: two of three matching means pick a more distant theme.
+- **Theme:** two consecutive systems must differ on at least one of three axes: **paper band** (dark < 30% L · mid 30-85% · light > 85%), **display style**, **accent hue** (warm 10-60° · cool 200-300° · neutral · chromatic-other). A derived system declares its own triple ([`references/direction.md`](references/direction.md) § D) and must additionally clear the worn-coordinates digest carried in that same section; it never opens the catalog to do so. On the fast path, the table in [`references/theme-axes.md`](references/theme-axes.md) is the lookup: two of three matching means pick a more distant theme.
- **Chrome:** the nav and the footer must not be the same shape as the last three runs, across consecutive runs and across test builds of the same theme. This is the single most-violated rule. If you reach for the default nav, the stamp has to name it (gate 42) — the default is allowed, arriving at it by reflex is not.
- **Hero:** vary the hero's stance run to run. Nothing but the fold-fit floor (gate 44b) constrains how tall or how anchored it is.
- **Enrichment:** do not repeat the previous run's enrichment approach back-to-back.
@@ -232,18 +232,18 @@ The `axes` and `fingerprint` fields are how Rotation and gate 32 become checkabl
**Derive, unless one of the fast-path conditions holds.** Check them in order; the first match wins.
0. **A `study` diagnosis emitted earlier and the user says build with it** → route **studied-DNA**: the diagnosis's paper OKLCH, accent OKLCH, type roles, macrostructure, and archetypes become the locked system. Diversification is suspended. Stamp `theme: studied-DNA (source: <URL or image>)` with the values inline. The user pivoting ("use Newsprint instead", "ignore the DNA") re-enters the dispatch.
-1. **The catalog fast path**, on any one of four conditions and no others: the user **names a theme**; `--fast` was passed; a `design.md` or a real brand already exists (Step 0 caught it, and that branch never reached here); or the scope is a **single component**. Then pick per Rotation from Specimen, Atelier, Brutal, Newsprint, Studio, Manifesto, Terminal, Midnight, Almanac, Garden, Riso, Sport, Bloom, Coral, Cobalt, Aurora, Editorial, Carnival, Lumen, Hum, Grid, Ledger, Arcade, and load that theme's file.
+1. **The catalog fast path**, on any one of four conditions and no others: the user **names a theme**; `--fast` was passed; a `design.md` or a real brand already exists (Step 0 caught it, and that branch never reached here); or the scope is a **single component**. Then pick per Rotation from the catalog (the lookup table in [`references/theme-axes.md`](references/theme-axes.md) lists every theme with its axes and arbitrates distance) and load that one theme's file from `references/themes/`. Do not enumerate or browse the catalog on any other route.
2. **Everything else derives.** Load [`references/direction.md`](references/direction.md) and run the ritual: reflex check → spent defaults → slate → draw → scene sentence → colour posture → direction contract → build → finish review. Tuned keeps Hallmark's structures; bespoke (the structure itself is the ask) designs from first principles. Do not ask which route; do not mention the catalog.
A derived system is complete (palette + pairing + axes), never a colour swap; its diversification axes are recorded exactly like a catalog theme's. All 58 slop-test gates fire unchanged, at their usual tiers, and the Step 5 Picks block surfaces everything before code.
-**Two consequences, stated once.** Every derived run stamps `posture:`, so gate 23 reads its posture-aware branch as the normal path rather than the occasional one; nothing about the gate changed. And the 23 themes stay fully employed even when nothing picks them: [`references/theme-axes.md`](references/theme-axes.md) § The rejection reading turns them into the coordinates a derived system must not land on.
+**Two consequences, stated once.** Every derived run stamps `posture:`, so gate 23 reads its posture-aware branch as the normal path rather than the occasional one; nothing about the gate changed. And a derived triple still has somewhere it may not land: the worn-coordinates digest in [`references/direction.md`](references/direction.md) § D lists the axis triples Hallmark has already worn out, with no theme names attached.
### 3. Load the visual ruleset
**Do:** load exactly what this build needs; over-eager loading is the largest avoidable cost of running Hallmark.
-**Always (2-3 files):** the genre file from Step 1; [`references/enrichment/hero-discipline.md`](references/enrichment/hero-discipline.md) (the hero rules bind on every page hero, enriched or not); plus, **on the catalog fast path only**, `references/themes/<theme>.md` for the picked theme (all 24 have one). A derived run loads [`references/direction.md`](references/direction.md) instead, and reads [`references/theme-axes.md`](references/theme-axes.md) § The rejection reading rather than the whole file.
+**Always (2-3 files):** the genre file from Step 1; [`references/enrichment/hero-discipline.md`](references/enrichment/hero-discipline.md) (the hero rules bind on every page hero, enriched or not); plus, **on the catalog fast path only**, `references/themes/<theme>.md` for the picked theme (every theme has one). A derived run loads [`references/direction.md`](references/direction.md) instead and touches nothing under the catalog.
**Index-then-pick (only when you are taking a named starting point; skip entirely when you are not):**
- [`references/macrostructures.md`](references/macrostructures.md) → one file from `references/macrostructures/`.
@@ -255,7 +255,7 @@ A derived system is complete (palette + pairing + axes), never a colour swap; it
Two of those carry sections you should skip rather than read whole: `typography.md` § The font catalog is dead weight when a catalog theme has already named the faces, and `copy.md` § Voice samples per tone is seven blocks of which six are not your tone. Skipping both saves roughly 200 lines a build.
-**Conditionally (be honest, no defensive pre-loads):** [`references/microinteractions.md`](references/microinteractions.md) when anything is interactive (most pages); [`references/interaction-and-states.md`](references/interaction-and-states.md) for stateful UI; [`references/responsive.md`](references/responsive.md) when mobile is in scope; [`references/structure.md`](references/structure.md) only when deviating from a named macrostructure; [`references/assets.md`](references/assets.md) only when an enrichment needs an external asset; [`references/texture.md`](references/texture.md) only when the picked theme earns texture (Riso, Carnival, Arcade, faint Newsprint) or a custom draw has print lineage; [`references/scroll-choreography.md`](references/scroll-choreography.md) only when the brief asks for scroll story / cinematic pacing or the macro is Feature-stack / Narrative Workflow; [`references/dark-mode.md`](references/dark-mode.md) only when the user asks for both modes; [`references/data-viz.md`](references/data-viz.md) when the brief involves charts / data / dashboards or the macro is Stat-Led / Workbench; [`references/brand-truth.md`](references/brand-truth.md) when the brief names a real brand or company to build for; [`references/theme-axes.md`](references/theme-axes.md) § The rejection reading on every derived run, and in full only when picking from the catalog; [`references/comp.md`](references/comp.md) only when signal 9 fired, at Step 5.5, never earlier; [`references/design-md.md`](references/design-md.md) only when the user asks to lock the system; [`references/preview-examples.md`](references/preview-examples.md) only if the Step 5 spec is not scaffolding enough.
+**Conditionally (be honest, no defensive pre-loads):** [`references/microinteractions.md`](references/microinteractions.md) when anything is interactive (most pages); [`references/interaction-and-states.md`](references/interaction-and-states.md) for stateful UI; [`references/responsive.md`](references/responsive.md) when mobile is in scope; [`references/structure.md`](references/structure.md) only when deviating from a named macrostructure; [`references/assets.md`](references/assets.md) only when an enrichment needs an external asset; [`references/texture.md`](references/texture.md) only when the picked theme earns texture (Riso, Carnival, Arcade, faint Newsprint) or a custom draw has print lineage; [`references/scroll-choreography.md`](references/scroll-choreography.md) only when the brief asks for scroll story / cinematic pacing or the macro is Feature-stack / Narrative Workflow; [`references/dark-mode.md`](references/dark-mode.md) only when the user asks for both modes; [`references/data-viz.md`](references/data-viz.md) when the brief involves charts / data / dashboards or the macro is Stat-Led / Workbench; [`references/brand-truth.md`](references/brand-truth.md) when the brief names a real brand or company to build for; [`references/theme-axes.md`](references/theme-axes.md) only when picking from the catalog, never on a derived run; [`references/comp.md`](references/comp.md) only when signal 9 fired, at Step 5.5, never earlier; [`references/design-md.md`](references/design-md.md) only when the user asks to lock the system; [`references/preview-examples.md`](references/preview-examples.md) only if the Step 5 spec is not scaffolding enough.
**At the end only:** [`references/slop-test.md`](references/slop-test.md) strictly at Step 7 (pre-loading it costs thousands of tokens for nothing; `anti-patterns.md` is the pre-emit list); [`references/contract.md`](references/contract.md) at handoff; [`references/export-formats.md`](references/export-formats.md) only on `design.md` projects.
@@ -279,8 +279,8 @@ Then run the image-need table at [`references/hero-enrichment.md` § Image-need
**Hallmark · v1.2.0**
- **Structure** · Workbench (last 3: Bento, Long Document, Manifesto) — genre modern-minimal
-- **Direction** · Line-printer output (draw 4/7, wildcard no) · posture committed
-- **System** · pale greenbar paper · rust accent ~35 · Syne over IBM Plex Mono (clears Ledger on paper band, Grid on display face, Terminal on display class)
+- **Direction** · Line-printer output (draw 4/7 · challengers declined · raise: tabular state discipline from the dealt instrument) · posture committed
+- **System** · pale greenbar paper · rust accent ~35 · Syne over IBM Plex Mono (worn coordinates clear; nearest occupied triple differs on display class)
- **Chrome** · nav N13 (prev N5) · footer: a single justified colophon line
- **Hero** · Stage/H2 (prev Settled)
- **Section entry** · a hairline rule, repeated, plus one change of paper
@@ -290,7 +290,7 @@ Then run the image-need table at [`references/hero-enrichment.md` § Image-need
- **Slop test** · Floor 34/34 ✓ · Reflex 18 · Finish clean (run after Build)
```
-Name a catalog code where you took one, plain words where you designed it. **Direction** carries the draw; **System** carries the derived palette and pairing plus which catalog coordinates it cleared. SaaS deck runs add `**Deck** · -logos +worked-example`. Any page may add `**Signature** · <the one move>`.
+Name a catalog code where you took one, plain words where you designed it. **Direction** carries the draw plus the challenger verdicts and any raise; **System** carries the derived palette and pairing plus confirmation that the worn coordinates were cleared. SaaS deck runs add `**Deck** · -logos +worked-example`. Any page may add `**Signature** · <the one move>`.
**On the catalog fast path**, the two rows collapse into one, because the theme name already says the system: `- **Theme** · Coral (near-white paper · quiet neutrals · coral accent; differs from Newsprint on paper band + display style)`.
diff --git a/skills/hallmark/references/direction.md b/skills/hallmark/references/direction.md
index 20a6338..2f5704e 100644
--- a/skills/hallmark/references/direction.md
+++ b/skills/hallmark/references/direction.md
@@ -8,14 +8,14 @@ Derivation is the default because **the model's own taste is an attractor**. Lef
## The catalog fast path
-The 24 named themes are still here, and they are the right answer four times:
+The 23 named themes are still here, and they are the right answer four times:
1. **The user names one.** "Use Newsprint", "give me that Ledger feel" is an instruction.
2. **`--fast`.** Speed is the ask; the catalog is the pre-built answer.
3. **A `design.md` or a real brand already exists.** Pre-flight found the system; inherit it. That branch never reaches this file.
4. **Component scope.** One button does not need a derived world.
-Anything else derives. Do not ask which; do not mention the catalog. A brief that says nothing gets a world of its own, and the 24 coordinates it must not land on are in [`theme-axes.md`](theme-axes.md) § The rejection reading.
+Anything else derives. Do not ask which; do not mention the catalog. A brief that says nothing gets a world of its own, and the coordinates it must not land on are in § D § The worn coordinates below; the catalog itself stays shut on a derived run.
---
@@ -30,7 +30,7 @@ Name the category's obvious aesthetic AND the second-order trap, then reject bot
- First order: the aesthetic anyone would guess. Tea brand: sage, cream, forest green. Fintech: navy and emerald trust palette. AI tool: near-black with a glowing gradient.
- Second order: the "tasteful" fallback a design-literate model reaches for after dodging the first. Tea: editorial serif on bone paper. Fintech: monochrome Swiss restraint. AI tool: mono type and terminal green.
-Format: *"Reflex check: rejecting <first-order> (the category default) and <second-order> (the tasteful fallback)."* Landing on either after writing this line means the self-check failed; redirect before continuing.
+Format: *"Reflex check: rejecting <first-order> (the category default) and <second-order> (the tasteful fallback)."* Landing on either after writing this line means the self-check failed; redirect before continuing. The default and its predictable opposite are both the rut: dodging navy fintech by shipping anti-navy fintech is still steering by the default, just in reverse.
Third altitude, **the mirror**: if the slate you are about to write would fit the category's OTHER products unchanged, it is category gravity wearing a slate's clothes. Sharpen entries until at least three are only defensible for THIS product.
@@ -64,7 +64,7 @@ The spent look can still be *earned* if the draw lands on a direction that genui
A pinned world pins the world, not its softest rendition: the pinned world's full material range stays in play, and a rendition that matches what any model ships for that world failed at execution, not selection.
-Note that the catalog's own twenty-four coordinates are spent too, on every derived run. [`theme-axes.md`](theme-axes.md) § The rejection reading carries that list and the tolerance that defines a collision.
+Note that the axis triples Hallmark's own catalog occupies are spent too, on every derived run. § D § The worn coordinates carries that list and the tolerance that defines a collision; the catalog files themselves are never opened for this.
### R.3 · The slate
@@ -76,19 +76,25 @@ Two questions that pull the list away from the obvious: what would this thing lo
**Spread across material families.** If more than three of the seven share one material family (all paper goods, all screens, all signage), the derivation stopped at the subject's most obvious artifact. Dig until the list spans at least three families.
-### R.4 · The draw
+**The literal metaphor gets one seat.** The brief's own noun is allowed at most one slate entry: a coffee brand may seat one coffee-bag direction, not three. The audience's world is larger than the product's object.
+
+### R.4 · The draw, and the challengers
The model never hand-picks from its own slate; its favourite is deterministic, and refusing that argmax is the whole point. An outside pick decides:
```
-node <skill-dir>/scripts/seed.mjs "<brief-slug>" --n 7 --wild 2
+node <skill-dir>/scripts/seed.mjs "<brief-slug>" --n 7
```
-The script prints a reproducible line: `draw: n/7 (seed <slug>·<date>·r0) · wildcards: <name>, <name>`. Paste it into the Picks block. Re-roll (only when the user asks): rerun with `--reroll 1`, `--reroll 2`, and so on; it usually lands elsewhere (there is no exclusion; roll again if it repeats), and the seed key keeps every roll reproducible.
+The script prints a reproducible line: `draw: n/7 (seed <slug>·<date>·r0) · challengers: <name> · <name> · <name>`. Paste it into the Picks block. Re-roll (only when the user asks): rerun with `--reroll 1`, `--reroll 2`, and so on; it usually lands elsewhere (there is no exclusion; roll again if it repeats), and the seed key keeps every roll reproducible.
+
+**Challengers.** The three dealt entries come from [`direction-atlas.json`](direction-atlas.json), a curated deck of complete design systems from real lineages, one from each tier: a **graphic system**, an **instrument language**, an **atmosphere world**. Each arrives with a five-line system grammar and one named browser technique. Judge each against the drawn slate entry on exactly two axes, **audience identification** and **product clarity**, in one written line per challenger with the verdict at the end: **wins** (it replaces the drawn entry), **competitive** (loses, but narrowly), **declined**. Challengers exist to break category gravity, never to win by novelty.
+
+**Fusion, not costume.** A winning challenger supplies the form and its system grammar; the product supplies every fact, name, number, and claim; clarity wins every conflict. The page is the product wearing the challenger's system, never the challenger with the product's logo pasted on.
-**Wildcards.** The two dealt entries come from [`direction-atlas.json`](direction-atlas.json), a curated deck of real design-history lineages. A wildcard **replaces the drawn slate entry only if it beats it on both axes: audience identification and product clarity.** Weigh in one written line each; discard losers without ceremony. Wildcards exist to break category gravity, not to win by novelty.
+**The raise.** A challenger that loses does not just vanish: the strongest loser donates the one discipline of its system grammar the drawn direction lacks (a state language, a navigation topology, a material rule), named in one line: *"raise: the meter bridge's stepped state ladder for the pricing tiers."* Every derived run ships either a winning challenger or one named raise; a run with neither treated the deal as ceremony.
-**Script-less fallback** (no Node, no shell): N = (letter count of the brief, spaces and punctuation excluded) mod 7, pick slate entry N + 1; each re-roll adds 3 (mod 7). Print the arithmetic so the pick is reproducible: *"draw fallback: 142 letters mod 7 = 2, entry 3."* Skip wildcards, and stamp the seed as `seed: fallback-<letters>·<date>·r<n>`.
+**Script-less fallback** (no Node, no shell): N = (letter count of the brief, spaces and punctuation excluded) mod 7, pick slate entry N + 1; each re-roll adds 3 (mod 7). Print the arithmetic so the pick is reproducible: *"draw fallback: 142 letters mod 7 = 2, entry 3."* Skip challengers, and stamp the seed as `seed: fallback-<letters>·<date>·r<n>`.
### R.5 · The scene sentence
@@ -130,11 +136,12 @@ The base stamp and the base log entry are specified in [`SKILL.md`](../SKILL.md)
* theme: custom · direction: "<drawn direction>" · vibe: "<4-8 words>"
* paper: oklch(<L>% <C> <H>) · accent: oklch(<L>% <C> <H>) · display: <font> · body: <font>
* axes: <paper-band> / <display-style> / <accent-hue> · posture: <posture>
- * seed: <slug>·<date>·r<n> · contract: kept (5/5) · studied: no · v1.2.0
+ * seed: <slug>·<date>·r<n> · challenger: <name> (<wins | raise: one line | declined>)
+ * contract: kept (5/5) · studied: no · v1.2.0
*/
```
-`contract: kept (5/5)` is written only after the finish review below confirms it. The log entry adds the same values as fields: `"theme": "custom"`, `"direction"`, `"posture"`, `"seed"`, `"wildcard"`, `"vibe"`, and the `"axes"` triple (one key, the same one a catalog entry uses; Rotation reads it either way).
+`contract: kept (5/5)` is written only after the finish review below confirms it. The log entry adds the same values as fields: `"theme": "custom"`, `"direction"`, `"posture"`, `"seed"`, `"challenger"` (name plus verdict, and the raise when one was taken), `"vibe"`, and the `"axes"` triple (one key, the same one a catalog entry uses; Rotation reads it either way).
---
@@ -231,7 +238,23 @@ A derived system declares its diversification values explicitly so the Rotation
- **Accent hue band:** warm 10-60° · cool 200-300° · neutral (chroma < 0.05) · chromatic-other (sub-tag the anchor: `chromatic-moss ~140°`).
- **Posture** (fourth logged value): restrained · committed · full-palette · drenched.
-Before the triple is final, check it against the rejection table in [`theme-axes.md`](theme-axes.md) § The rejection reading: the catalog's twenty-four coordinates, live on every derived run. A triple that survives it is the thing the route was built to produce.
+Before the triple is final, check it against the digest below. A triple that survives it is the thing the route was built to produce.
+
+### The worn coordinates
+
+The axis triples Hallmark's own catalog already occupies, deduplicated, with no theme names attached. **A constructed system that lands within tolerance of one has failed the reflex check** - not "is unoriginal", not "should be reconsidered": failed, the same way R.1 fails when the slate lands on the category default. **Within tolerance** means all three at once: same paper band; same display class at this digest's grain (`grotesk-sans` and `grotesk-heavy` are different classes, and `roman-serif`, `high-contrast-serif` and `slab-serif` are three); same accent band, or hues within **20°** of each other for two `chromatic-other` entries. Matching two of three is fine and common; it is the full triple that means you re-derived something that already exists.
+
+Occupied triples, grouped by paper band:
+
+- **Light** (the most worn band by far; a derived light-paper system has the least room, which is itself a nudge): high-contrast-serif / warm · roman-serif / warm · roman-serif / chromatic-green ~140 · slab-serif / warm · display-heavy / warm · display-heavy / chromatic-amber ~95 · display-condensed / warm · geometric-sans / warm · grotesk-sans / warm · grotesk-sans / cool · grotesk-heavy / warm and cool ~264 and chromatic-yellow ~95 · rounded-sans / chromatic-amber ~95
+- **Mid**: grotesk-sans / cool · grotesk-heavy / cool
+- **Dark**: display-condensed-bold / warm · mono / chromatic-phosphor ~138 · geometric-sans / cool · geometric-sans / chromatic-teal ~172 · classical-serif / warm · grotesk-sans / chromatic-teal ~185 · pixel-display / every neon it has worn
+
+**When you land there.** Move one axis, and prefer the one the brief cares least about - usually accent hue, occasionally paper band, rarely display class (the display carries the direction and is the most expensive thing to trade away). Then say it happened in one line: *"Landed on an occupied triple (light / grotesk-sans / cool); moved accent to chromatic-moss ~145."* Silence here is the failure mode, not the collision.
+
+**Two exceptions, both narrow.** The user asking for a named theme's look is the catalog fast path, not a collision. And the draw can earn a coordinate: a direction that genuinely demands it (a line-printer draw wanting dark paper and a mono display) may keep it, with the same one-line argument R.2 requires for landing on a spent default; a draw that "happens to" land on an occupied triple twice in one project is not a draw, it is a preference.
+
+This is not as tight a constraint as it looks: three paper bands times a display class times an accent band leaves a derived system nearly the whole space, minus the couple dozen places Hallmark has already been. Maintenance: this digest is edited by hand whenever a theme enters or leaves `references/themes/`; the reminder lives in [`themes/README.md`](themes/README.md).
---
diff --git a/skills/hallmark/references/genres/atmospheric.md b/skills/hallmark/references/genres/atmospheric.md
index a2d6442..89aa442 100644
--- a/skills/hallmark/references/genres/atmospheric.md
+++ b/skills/hallmark/references/genres/atmospheric.md
@@ -6,11 +6,6 @@ For the AI-creative product page. Dark canvas with warm radial blooms, confident
Brief mentions any of: *AI tool, generative, music, video, image, voice, late-night, atmospheric, dark mode, expressive, creative tool, model playground, vibe-coded, dreamlike, nocturnal*. Also pick when the user names a *mood* that requires darkness (e.g. "moody", "cinematic", "after hours").
-## Themes that belong
-
-`Bloom` (canonical light-paper), `Midnight`, `Terminal`, `Aurora`, `Lumen`. Five themes; the rotation walks them when atmospheric is active.
-
-`Lumen` is the premium AI-tool register — Modal / Anthropic / Together / ElevenLabs / Cluely / Adept / Granola. One focal CSS artefact and a classical serif headline set upright and all-lowercase (Lumen ships no italic anywhere). **Two palette drops** (Night Foundry — dark amber-gold, emits; Day Foundry — light indigo, refracts). The only atmospheric theme with a serif display and the only one whose canvas treatment is one *built* artefact rather than two diffuse blooms.
## Voice
diff --git a/skills/hallmark/references/genres/editorial.md b/skills/hallmark/references/genres/editorial.md
index 38aa0b4..ee8e468 100644
--- a/skills/hallmark/references/genres/editorial.md
+++ b/skills/hallmark/references/genres/editorial.md
@@ -8,11 +8,6 @@ This is what Hallmark looks like when no other genre signal fires. It is the sil
Default. Pick editorial when the brief does not name a specialised aesthetic — when the user said "a landing page for X" without telling you whether X is enterprise, atmospheric, or playful. Most briefs land here.
-## Themes that belong
-
-`Specimen`, `Newsprint`, `Atelier`, `Garden`, `Almanac`, `Studio`, `Riso`, `Sport`, `Brutal`, `Manifesto`, `Editorial`, `Carnival`, `Grid`. Thirteen themes - plenty of variety inside the genre. `Grid` is the Swiss / neo-grotesque exception here: rational, exposed-grid, near-monochrome with one signal ink spent on geometry, where the rest are serif-led.
-
-`Carnival` is the loud-maximalist editorial register — Dropout TV / Fly.io / Stones Throw / Third Man Records. Duo-tone accent system (mustard + oxblood), chunky variable display, decorative ornaments, hard-offset shadows. The loud sibling to Riso / Manifesto / Brutal.
## Voice
diff --git a/skills/hallmark/references/genres/modern-minimal.md b/skills/hallmark/references/genres/modern-minimal.md
index fb61fd9..7f2b5df 100644
--- a/skills/hallmark/references/genres/modern-minimal.md
+++ b/skills/hallmark/references/genres/modern-minimal.md
@@ -6,13 +6,6 @@ For the polished enterprise / dev-tool / API page. Stripe / Linear / ElevenLabs
Brief mentions any of: *SaaS, enterprise, API, platform, developer tool, infra, B2B, dashboard, billing, Stripe-like, Linear-like, ElevenLabs-like, dev experience, ship fast*. Also pick when the user names a brand colour but the rest of the brief is restrained.
-## Themes that belong
-
-`Coral` (canonical) — warm-grey paper, single warm coral accent, Geist throughout, soft pill CTAs. The "Stripe-not-Linear" warmth.
-
-`Cobalt` — the cool dev-tool / API / docs register (the GitBook + Firecrawl school, executed **cobalt-on-light, not orange**). Cool engineered near-white paper, one electric cobalt signal accent, Space Grotesk display + Inter body + JetBrains Mono code, ruler-drawn hairlines, tight 6 px radii, a bordered ⌘K nav, and a live code/API request–response hero. The technical, instrument-panel sibling to Coral's warmth — the rotation walks Coral ⇄ Cobalt when modern-minimal is active.
-
-The two differ on every axis a glance registers: Coral is warm-grey + coral + Geist + pills; Cobalt is cool-white + electric blue + Space Grotesk/mono + tight-radius bordered controls. `Ledger` joins as the cluster's one dark option: a ruled navy account book (banded, columnar, or journal), Instrument Sans over tabular IBM Plex Mono, and two inks with one job each - teal for credits and matched rows, brass for debits and pending ones, never red. Totals close under a double rule and every figure states its as-of. Data-as-hero, the same restraint executed dark, which also gives the rotation a dark-vs-light lever inside the genre. It is a book, not a dashboard: no KPI card grids. Future themes can join too - anything monochrome or near-monochrome with an Inter-class sans display and a single restrained accent.
## Voice
diff --git a/skills/hallmark/references/genres/playful.md b/skills/hallmark/references/genres/playful.md
index aa1e5cb..c300cf4 100644
--- a/skills/hallmark/references/genres/playful.md
+++ b/skills/hallmark/references/genres/playful.md
@@ -6,15 +6,6 @@ For the consumer / friendly / onboarding-led page. Soft surfaces, mild colour, m
Brief mentions any of: *fun, consumer, casual, family, kids, friendly, approachable, onboarding-heavy, community, social, tactile-but-soft, post-Linear-soft*. Pick playful sparingly — most consumer briefs still belong to editorial (warm-paper, hand-set) unless the user explicitly asks for *softer* and *friendlier*.
-## Themes that belong
-
-`Hum` (vibrant, alive) is the genre's canonical theme — the post-Brilliant-alive register: multi-accent cream + pear + cyan + coral, mandatory motion, a single character moment. Pick it when the brief wants "feels alive in the room with you." For the quieter, more restrained end of friendly — "friendly but soft" rather than "alive" — reach instead for modern-minimal (Coral): a single low-chroma accent on warm paper, smooth easings, motion optional.
-
-`Arcade` joins the cluster as the retro-nostalgia end: an aubergine-black sheet under a real CRT stack (aperture grille, scanline, vignette, tight phosphor bloom), marquee lettering over a readable Chivo body, an ember + acid duo, and pixel type kept to the HUD. Playful and loud, but the re-drawn-chrome ban still holds (no fake OS windows, title bars, or monitor bezels; the retro comes from the screen texture and the lettering, not from furniture). Every Arcade page also carries one deliberately quiet, unbloomed instruction card, which is what makes the loud parts land. The two give the genre range: alive (Hum) and retro-loud (Arcade).
-
-For a warm, credible, friendly-but-quiet brief, reach for modern-minimal (Coral) or editorial (Garden, Almanac) rather than stretching playful to cover it.
-
-`Hum` is the catalog's only **rounded-sans-multi-accent** theme — it relaxes several playful defaults: bouncy spring easings are allowed (and canonical) on its primary CTA, accent chroma goes higher than 0.16, and motion is mandatory not optional. It answers a specific brief: a learning platform for curious adults, a daily-curiosity app, a habit tracker with character — products that should feel warm and alive, not merely tidy.
## Voice
diff --git a/skills/hallmark/references/hero-enrichment.md b/skills/hallmark/references/hero-enrichment.md
index 6e8fc93..48bfe2c 100644
--- a/skills/hallmark/references/hero-enrichment.md
+++ b/skills/hallmark/references/hero-enrichment.md
@@ -68,7 +68,7 @@ If the brief contains explicit visual cues, pick from this map:
• "bakery", "kitchen", "café", "atelier" + craft brief → E5 custom illustration (Tier B SVG)
• "agency", "studio", "portfolio" → E8 photography or no enrichment
• "manifesto", "essay", "book", "letter" → no enrichment (typography only)
- • Coral theme picked → no enrichment (the theme IS restraint)
+ • a restraint-led system (quiet-minimal direction/theme) → no enrichment (the restraint IS the design)
Else if the brief is genuinely ambiguous, ask one question:
"Want me to add a demo video, an illustration, or keep it
diff --git a/skills/hallmark/references/microinteractions.md b/skills/hallmark/references/microinteractions.md
index 1e0fb62..bb55eca 100644
--- a/skills/hallmark/references/microinteractions.md
+++ b/skills/hallmark/references/microinteractions.md
@@ -193,7 +193,7 @@ Trigger: ⌘K or `/`. Open: instant, no animation. Arrow-keys move selection —
### Page-load reveals
-One orchestrated entrance. Stagger by DOM index, capped at ~500ms total. Use `IntersectionObserver`, never scroll listeners. After first reveal, no more on-scroll animations — let the page just *be there*. Theme-specific themes (Atelier, Newsprint) skip reveals entirely; that is correct, not a bug.
+One orchestrated entrance. Stagger by DOM index, capped at ~500ms total. Use `IntersectionObserver`, never scroll listeners. After first reveal, no more on-scroll animations — let the page just *be there*. A system whose motion character is **still** skips reveals entirely; that is correct, not a bug.
## The named tells (what AI defaults produce)
@@ -220,24 +220,18 @@ These are the microinteraction signatures of generated code. The slop test in [`
19. **Toasts that move existing content.** New toast pushes the page down; dismissed toast lets it spring back. Stack toasts; don't shift layout.
20. **Hover delays on touch.** A `:hover` state that the touch user can never reach because there's no equivalent focus / tap behaviour.
-## Theme-aware microinteractions
+## Motion character
-Microinteractions adapt to the theme. The same button press is louder in Brutal than in Atelier. Apply a multiplier per theme:
+Microinteractions adapt to the system's declared **motion character**. Every system declares exactly one: a catalog theme in its file, a derived direction in its contract (the character should be audible in the FORM block). The same button press is louder in a severe system than in a calm one.
-| Theme | Duration scale | Easing flavour | Notes |
+| Character | Duration scale | Easing flavour | Feels like |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
-| Specimen | 1.0× | `--ease-out` | Default. Restrained. |
-| Midnight | 0.9× | `--ease-out` | Snappy, technical. |
-| Brutal | 0.75× | `--ease-out` (sharper) | Fast, decisive. No spring. |
-| Garden | 1.2× | `--ease-out` | Calm. Springs welcome. |
-| Atelier | 1.3× | `--ease-out` (very gentle) | Generous; almost no movement. |
-| Newsprint | 0× | none | Static. Print metaphor. |
-| Terminal | 0× | none, except caret blink *inside* a typed command (N8 nav, install code) | Print + monospace metaphor. **No standalone blinking cursor** — see the Caret blink row above. The caret only blinks where the user would type. |
-| Manifesto | 0.7× | `--ease-out` (sharp) | Snap into place. |
-| Almanac | 0.85× | `--ease-out` | Functional, like a reference book. |
-| Sport | 0.7× | `--ease-out` (sharp) | Quick, italic-energy. |
-
-If the theme has duration scale `0×`, you do not animate. The page does not move. That is a deliberate design choice; it is not broken.
+| **still** | 0× | none | Print. The page does not move. Exception: a caret may blink *inside* a typed command where the user would type; never standalone (see the Caret blink row above). |
+| **severe** | 0.7-0.75× | `--ease-out` (sharp) | Fast, decisive, snaps into place. No spring anywhere. |
+| **brisk** | 0.85-0.9× | `--ease-out` | Snappy, technical, functional; a reference book or an instrument panel. |
+| **calm** | 1.0-1.3× | `--ease-out` (gentle at the high end) | Restrained through generous; springs only where the genre allows them. |
+
+If the character is **still**, you do not animate. The page does not move. That is a deliberate design choice; it is not broken.
## Accessibility ground truth
diff --git a/skills/hallmark/references/preview-examples.md b/skills/hallmark/references/preview-examples.md
index 982270c..119c4ab 100644
--- a/skills/hallmark/references/preview-examples.md
+++ b/skills/hallmark/references/preview-examples.md
@@ -38,7 +38,7 @@ Four sample Step 5 Picks blocks for the model to imitate, varied across page typ
> **Hallmark · v1.2.0**
>
> - **Structure** · Long Document
-> - **Direction** · the postal frank (draw 6/7, wildcard no)
+> - **Direction** · the postal frank (draw 6/7 · challengers declined · raise: the timetable's column discipline)
> - **Posture** · Full palette (kraft field · frank red · ink · airmail-blue seal)
> - **Theme** · custom (vibe: "archival warmth, hand-set, no varnish" · paper oklch(95% 0.015 80) · accent oklch(55% 0.17 30) frank-red · Bricolage Grotesque display + Literata body, both roman)
> - **Enrichment** · pure-CSS frank mark (craft tier-a)
diff --git a/skills/hallmark/references/theme-axes.md b/skills/hallmark/references/theme-axes.md
index f92689c..9987d7a 100644
--- a/skills/hallmark/references/theme-axes.md
+++ b/skills/hallmark/references/theme-axes.md
@@ -1,11 +1,8 @@
-# Theme axes - the Rotation lookup, and the rejection table
+# Theme axes - the catalog Rotation lookup
-The three diversification axes for every catalog theme, derived from the canonical token values. This table is read two ways depending on the route, and both readings are live:
+The three diversification axes for every catalog theme, derived from the canonical token values. **This file is read on the catalog fast path only.** The Rotation block in [`SKILL.md`](../SKILL.md) reads it to pick the next theme: two consecutive themes must differ on at least one axis, and two candidates matching on two of three means pick a more distant one.
-- **As a lookup (catalog route).** The Rotation block in [`SKILL.md`](../SKILL.md) reads it to pick the next theme; two consecutive themes must differ on at least one axis.
-- **As a rejection table (custom route).** A constructed system declares its own axes per [`direction.md`](direction.md) § D, and this table is the list of triples it must not land on. See § The rejection reading below.
-
-The second reading is what the 23 themes are *for* on a derived run, where nothing picks a catalog theme. They stop being destinations and become the twenty-three most-worn coordinates in Hallmark's own space: precisely what [`direction.md`](direction.md) § R.2 means by house defaults, with values attached.
+A derived run never opens this file. The anonymous digest of these coordinates lives in [`direction.md`](direction.md) § D § The worn coordinates; the two are maintained together by hand whenever a theme enters or leaves the catalog.
Bands: paper **dark** < 30% L · **mid** 30-85% · **light** > 85%. Accent: **warm** 10-60° · **cool** 200-300° · **neutral** chroma < 0.05 · **chromatic-other** anything else (sub-tag the hue).
@@ -39,29 +36,4 @@ When two candidate themes match on two of the three axes, pick a more distant on
---
-## The rejection reading
-
-**A constructed system that lands within tolerance of a catalog row has failed the reflex check.** Not "is unoriginal", not "should be reconsidered": failed, the same way R.1 fails when the slate lands on the category default. The whole point of the custom route is that it goes somewhere the catalog does not already stand.
-
-**Within tolerance** means all three of these at once:
-
-1. **Same paper band** (dark / mid / light), and
-2. **Same display class** at the table's grain - `grotesk-sans` and `grotesk-heavy` are different classes, and `roman-serif`, `high-contrast-serif` and `slab-serif` are three, and
-3. **Same accent band**, or for two `chromatic-other` entries, hues within **20°** of each other.
-
-Matching two of the three is fine and common: a light paper with a roman serif and a teal accent collides with nothing. It is the full triple that means you re-derived a theme that already exists.
-
-**When you land there.** Move one axis, and prefer the one the brief cares least about - usually accent hue, occasionally paper band, rarely display class (the display carries the direction and is the most expensive thing to trade away). Then say it happened in one line: *"Landed on Cobalt's triple (light / grotesk-sans / cool ~250); moved accent to chromatic-moss ~145."* Silence here is the failure mode, not the collision.
-
-**Two exceptions, both narrow.**
-
-- **The user asked for it.** "Make it look like Terminal", "we want that Ledger feel" is an instruction, not a reflex. Build it, and record `axes: <triple> (Terminal, by request)` in the stamp so a later audit does not read it as drift.
-- **The draw earned it.** A direction from R.4 that genuinely demands the coordinate - a line-printer draw wanting a dark paper with a mono display - may keep it, but only with the same one-line argument R.2 requires for landing on a spent default. A draw that "happens to" land on a catalog triple twice in a project is not a draw, it is a preference.
-
-**This is not as tight a constraint as it looks.** Three paper bands times a display class times an accent band leaves a derived system nearly the whole space, minus the two dozen places Hallmark has already been.
-
----
-
----
-
The rules governing what a theme *file* may and may not carry live in [`themes/README.md`](themes/README.md). Read that only when writing or editing a theme, never when building a page.
diff --git a/skills/hallmark/references/themes/README.md b/skills/hallmark/references/themes/README.md
index a67d413..048a5c2 100644
--- a/skills/hallmark/references/themes/README.md
+++ b/skills/hallmark/references/themes/README.md
@@ -25,4 +25,6 @@ A theme file **may not** carry:
- an eyebrow, in any form (gate 54)
- counts that fix a layout ("always three cells, never two, never four")
+**When a theme enters or leaves this directory**, two lookups are edited by hand in the same change: the axes table in [`../theme-axes.md`](../theme-axes.md) (the catalog Rotation lookup) and the worn-coordinates digest in [`../direction.md`](../direction.md) § D (the anonymous triples a derived run must clear). Neither updates itself.
+
Where a theme genuinely invented something structural worth keeping, it belongs in the Library as an **optional** entry any brief can reach for, never as a thing this theme's builds must contain. The `## Build hint` block in each file is a token sketch, not a page: `:root` values and the two or three face rules that make the theme recognisable, and nothing that names a page part.
diff --git a/skills/hallmark/references/themes/almanac.md b/skills/hallmark/references/themes/almanac.md
index fef335d..ae2f643 100644
--- a/skills/hallmark/references/themes/almanac.md
+++ b/skills/hallmark/references/themes/almanac.md
@@ -50,7 +50,7 @@ Three families.
## Motion
-Functional and sparse, like turning a reference page. Section reveals fade and rise ~8px at `0.85×` ease-out, functional rather than showy. Number-tick counters run `0 → final` once on reveal for stats, dates, and prices, then hold. **No bounce, no parallax, no autoplay, no marquee.** Everything gates behind `prefers-reduced-motion: no-preference`; reduced-motion ships static, counters at final value, fully visible.
+**Motion character: brisk (0.85×).** Functional and sparse, like turning a reference page. Section reveals fade and rise ~8px at `0.85×` ease-out, functional rather than showy. Number-tick counters run `0 → final` once on reveal for stats, dates, and prices, then hold. **No bounce, no parallax, no autoplay, no marquee.** Everything gates behind `prefers-reduced-motion: no-preference`; reduced-motion ships static, counters at final value, fully visible.
## Voice range
diff --git a/skills/hallmark/references/themes/atelier.md b/skills/hallmark/references/themes/atelier.md
index bc20e91..1922583 100644
--- a/skills/hallmark/references/themes/atelier.md
+++ b/skills/hallmark/references/themes/atelier.md
@@ -48,7 +48,7 @@ The triad - bold humanist-serif display, neutral grotesk body, wide mono labels
## Motion
-Quiet and orchestrated. One entrance: a masked curtain-wipe (`clip-path`) or a plain fade on the display line, then static. Section reveals fade and rise ~10px, ease-out ~600ms, via a single `IntersectionObserver`. An amber underline grows on link hover. **No bounce, no parallax, no autoplay, no marquee.** Everything gates behind `prefers-reduced-motion: no-preference`; reduced-motion ships static and fully visible.
+**Motion character: calm (1.3×, very gentle).** Quiet and orchestrated. One entrance: a masked curtain-wipe (`clip-path`) or a plain fade on the display line, then static. Section reveals fade and rise ~10px, ease-out ~600ms, via a single `IntersectionObserver`. An amber underline grows on link hover. **No bounce, no parallax, no autoplay, no marquee.** Everything gates behind `prefers-reduced-motion: no-preference`; reduced-motion ships static and fully visible.
## Voice range
diff --git a/skills/hallmark/references/themes/brutal.md b/skills/hallmark/references/themes/brutal.md
index 3e557d0..8aa9858 100644
--- a/skills/hallmark/references/themes/brutal.md
+++ b/skills/hallmark/references/themes/brutal.md
@@ -45,7 +45,7 @@ All-sans. No serif anywhere.
## Motion
-Mechanical and abrupt. Reveals snap or step (a hard `opacity` cut, or a 1-step translate over ~120ms), they do not ease-glide. Hover flips state instantly: a block inverts to `--color-ink` (or `--color-accent`) with paper text, a border thickens to red. No bounce, no parallax, no blur transition, no autoplay. Everything gates behind `prefers-reduced-motion: no-preference`; reduced-motion ships static and fully visible.
+**Motion character: severe (0.75×).** Mechanical and abrupt. Reveals snap or step (a hard `opacity` cut, or a 1-step translate over ~120ms), they do not ease-glide. Hover flips state instantly: a block inverts to `--color-ink` (or `--color-accent`) with paper text, a border thickens to red. No bounce, no parallax, no blur transition, no autoplay. Everything gates behind `prefers-reduced-motion: no-preference`; reduced-motion ships static and fully visible.
## Voice range
diff --git a/skills/hallmark/references/themes/garden.md b/skills/hallmark/references/themes/garden.md
index 74d4958..36c156c 100644
--- a/skills/hallmark/references/themes/garden.md
+++ b/skills/hallmark/references/themes/garden.md
@@ -46,7 +46,7 @@ Every neutral carries a green cast (hue 90-152); no pure grey anywhere. Leaf-gre
## Motion
-Quiet and seasonal. One orchestrated entrance: staggered reveal (fade plus <=10px rise, `--i` stagger, <=500ms, reveal-once). An optional single hover behaviour on a piece of craft (a jar-fill rise). Transform and opacity only: no bounce, no parallax, no autoplay. Everything gates behind `prefers-reduced-motion: no-preference`; reduced-motion ships static and fully visible.
+**Motion character: calm (1.2×).** Quiet and seasonal. One orchestrated entrance: staggered reveal (fade plus <=10px rise, `--i` stagger, <=500ms, reveal-once). An optional single hover behaviour on a piece of craft (a jar-fill rise). Transform and opacity only: no bounce, no parallax, no autoplay. Everything gates behind `prefers-reduced-motion: no-preference`; reduced-motion ships static and fully visible.
## Do-nots (this theme's own failure modes)
diff --git a/skills/hallmark/references/themes/manifesto.md b/skills/hallmark/references/themes/manifesto.md
index 315dffc..7fd9850 100644
--- a/skills/hallmark/references/themes/manifesto.md
+++ b/skills/hallmark/references/themes/manifesto.md
@@ -48,7 +48,7 @@ The whole drama is scale contrast: the gap between `9rem` caps and `1rem` grotes
## Motion
-Hard and staccato, not soft. Display blocks clip-reveal upward once (a `clip-path: inset()` mask, not a soft fade and drift) via one `IntersectionObserver`, on a snappy cubic-bezier, playing once. Lines can enter one after another with the same snap. No bounce, no parallax, no autoplay, no red pulsing. Everything gates behind `prefers-reduced-motion: no-preference`; reduced-motion ships static and fully visible.
+**Motion character: severe (0.7×).** Hard and staccato, not soft. Display blocks clip-reveal upward once (a `clip-path: inset()` mask, not a soft fade and drift) via one `IntersectionObserver`, on a snappy cubic-bezier, playing once. Lines can enter one after another with the same snap. No bounce, no parallax, no autoplay, no red pulsing. Everything gates behind `prefers-reduced-motion: no-preference`; reduced-motion ships static and fully visible.
## Voice range
diff --git a/skills/hallmark/references/themes/midnight.md b/skills/hallmark/references/themes/midnight.md
index 1ad524a..b99983c 100644
--- a/skills/hallmark/references/themes/midnight.md
+++ b/skills/hallmark/references/themes/midnight.md
@@ -47,7 +47,7 @@ Accent stays under 5% of any viewport: a link hover, the one primary button, foc
## Motion
-Fade only, composed and slow. Reveals fade and rise ~10px, once. Hover: an azure underline-grow on links, a 1px border shift to `--color-accent` on focusable surfaces. No slide, no bounce, no parallax, no autoplay; the atmosphere carries it. Everything gates behind `prefers-reduced-motion: no-preference`; reduced-motion ships static and fully visible.
+**Motion character: brisk (0.9×).** Fade only, composed and slow. Reveals fade and rise ~10px, once. Hover: an azure underline-grow on links, a 1px border shift to `--color-accent` on focusable surfaces. No slide, no bounce, no parallax, no autoplay; the atmosphere carries it. Everything gates behind `prefers-reduced-motion: no-preference`; reduced-motion ships static and fully visible.
## Do-nots (this theme's own failure modes)
diff --git a/skills/hallmark/references/themes/newsprint.md b/skills/hallmark/references/themes/newsprint.md
index 92ae757..dce9f00 100644
--- a/skills/hallmark/references/themes/newsprint.md
+++ b/skills/hallmark/references/themes/newsprint.md
@@ -47,7 +47,7 @@ Every value is warm (hue 25-50); no neutral grey anywhere. Brick stays under 5%
## Motion
-Quiet and singular. One orchestrated reveal (fade plus ~10px rise) as sections enter. Hover: a brick underline-grow on links. **No parallax, no type-in, no counters, no autoplay.** Everything gates behind `prefers-reduced-motion: no-preference`; reduced-motion ships static and fully visible.
+**Motion character: calm (1.2×); one reveal and link underlines, nothing else moves.** Quiet and singular. One orchestrated reveal (fade plus ~10px rise) as sections enter. Hover: a brick underline-grow on links. **No parallax, no type-in, no counters, no autoplay.** Everything gates behind `prefers-reduced-motion: no-preference`; reduced-motion ships static and fully visible.
## Do-nots (this theme's own failure modes)
diff --git a/skills/hallmark/references/themes/specimen.md b/skills/hallmark/references/themes/specimen.md
index 7a41779..2e214db 100644
--- a/skills/hallmark/references/themes/specimen.md
+++ b/skills/hallmark/references/themes/specimen.md
@@ -45,7 +45,7 @@ Everything is tinted warm (hue 60-80). Orange stays under 5% of any viewport: a
## Motion
-Quiet and composed. One orchestrated entrance: reveals fade and rise (`--ease-out`, ~600ms). Optionally one weight or optical ladder that settles once, then holds static. Hover: an orange underline-grow on links, a 1px rule shift toward accent on focusable surfaces. No bounce, no parallax, no autoplay. Everything gates behind `prefers-reduced-motion: no-preference`; reduced-motion ships static and fully visible.
+**Motion character: calm (1.0×).** Quiet and composed. One orchestrated entrance: reveals fade and rise (`--ease-out`, ~600ms). Optionally one weight or optical ladder that settles once, then holds static. Hover: an orange underline-grow on links, a 1px rule shift toward accent on focusable surfaces. No bounce, no parallax, no autoplay. Everything gates behind `prefers-reduced-motion: no-preference`; reduced-motion ships static and fully visible.
## Do-nots (this theme's own failure modes)
diff --git a/skills/hallmark/references/themes/sport.md b/skills/hallmark/references/themes/sport.md
index 797d203..69529b3 100644
--- a/skills/hallmark/references/themes/sport.md
+++ b/skills/hallmark/references/themes/sport.md
@@ -49,7 +49,7 @@ All-sans. No serif anywhere.
## Motion
-Kinetic but disciplined. Section reveals fade and rise ~10px, ease-out ~600ms, from one `IntersectionObserver`. Numerals count up once on reveal (the scoreboard flip) and then hold. Hover: an orange underline grows on links, a 2px border shifts to orange on focusable rows. No parallax, no autoplay, no bounce. Everything gates behind `prefers-reduced-motion: no-preference`; reduced-motion ships final numbers, full visibility, static.
+**Motion character: severe (0.7×, quick).** Kinetic but disciplined. Section reveals fade and rise ~10px, ease-out ~600ms, from one `IntersectionObserver`. Numerals count up once on reveal (the scoreboard flip) and then hold. Hover: an orange underline grows on links, a 2px border shifts to orange on focusable rows. No parallax, no autoplay, no bounce. Everything gates behind `prefers-reduced-motion: no-preference`; reduced-motion ships final numbers, full visibility, static.
## Voice range
diff --git a/skills/hallmark/references/themes/terminal.md b/skills/hallmark/references/themes/terminal.md
index ea28bfd..c82999f 100644
--- a/skills/hallmark/references/themes/terminal.md
+++ b/skills/hallmark/references/themes/terminal.md
@@ -47,7 +47,7 @@ Numerals run tabular wherever a figure appears. Labels are uppercase mono for ca
## Motion
-A live command types itself in once, then the block cursor blinks on a steady 1s `step-end` loop. Section reveals **fade only**, ~500ms, no rise: the screen does not slide its content in. An optional one-time boot flicker on load is allowed. No parallax, no bounce, no autoplay. Everything gates behind `prefers-reduced-motion: no-preference`; reduced-motion ships static, cursor solid, scanlines still or absent.
+**Motion character: brisk (0.9×), fade-only; the only loop is the caret.** A live command types itself in once, then the block cursor blinks on a steady 1s `step-end` loop. Section reveals **fade only**, ~500ms, no rise: the screen does not slide its content in. An optional one-time boot flicker on load is allowed. No parallax, no bounce, no autoplay. Everything gates behind `prefers-reduced-motion: no-preference`; reduced-motion ships static, cursor solid, scanlines still or absent.
## Voice range