Convert any text to a graph of knowledge. This can be used for Graph Augmented Generation or Knowledge Graph based QnA
HTML
text|source|page|chunk_id
"147
147Mental Health as a
Pathway to Health
Equity
Pratima Murthy, Krishna Prasad Muliyala, and
Channaveerachari Naveen Kumar
Equity, diversity, and inclusiveness are the basic tenets of distributive
justice and are essential goals for development. The World Health
Organization (WHO) envisages that health equity can be achieved when
everyone attains their full potential for health and well-being. This includes
mental health. According to WHO’s definition, ‘mental health’ is a state of
mental well-being that enables people to cope with the stresses of life,
realise their abilities, learn well and work well, and contribute to their
community.1
Mental health is closely linked with many of the United Nations (UN)
Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs).2 It comprises people’s individual
and collective abilities to make decisions, build relationships, and shape the
world, and is more than the mere absence of mental illness. In its broadest
sense, mental health encompasses promotive and preventive aspects, while
mental disorders or illnesses (used interchangeably in this article) are more
focused on treatment and rehabilitative aspects. However, mental health
and well-being is equally important for persons with mental disorders, as
much as it is for those without such disorders."|data_input/OrfPathHealth/MentalHealthPathwayToEquity.pdf|0|422ffd0b9f1e43be891bfa4022ff0269
"148Accelerating Global Health: Pathways to Health Equity for the G20
149Integrating Mental Health into General Healthcare
The complex interaction of biological, psychological, and social determinants
shapes an individual’s mental health. There is evidence that poverty and
other adverse social circumstances are risk factors for poor mental health,
and for mental disorders. Biological vulnerability as well as psychosocial
distress predispose an individual to common mental disorders like
depression, substance use disorders, and behavioural addictions.3 They can
also be reasons for relapse for episodes of severe mental illness (SMI)
such as schizophrenia or bipolar mood disorder.
The relationship between social adversity, mental distress, mental and
physical illness is both interactive and complex. The presence of mental
illness, particularly SMI, can drive people to poverty and worsen mental
distress for both the individual and their family. Similarly, psychosocial
adversity is a recognised risk factor in conditions like diabetes and
tuberculosis and influences health outcomes.4,5 Socioeconomic, political,
cultural and place-based conditions all determine health outcomes, including
on mental health.
Multimorbidity—defined as the co-occurrence of more than one chronic
condition in an individual—can occur a decade earlier in those who are
experiencing socioeconomic vulnerabilities.6 When two or more conditions"|data_input/OrfPathHealth/MentalHealthPathwayToEquity.pdf|1|d8ac3a127087488cb1f605559cc9e21a
"condition in an individual—can occur a decade earlier in those who are
experiencing socioeconomic vulnerabilities.6 When two or more conditions
cluster together (both contributing and resulting in socioeconomic
inequalities), medical specialists use the term ‘syndemic’ to describe such
a situation. Therefore, the contextual determinants of health and disease
are paramount in the conceptual framework of syndemics. Moreover, the
two or more chronic conditions can interact and lead to adverse mutual
outcomes for the conditions. The imperative, therefore, is to shed a
dichotomous approach to mental and physical health and integrate them
both in healthcare service delivery.
The challenge is how to efficiently distribute healthcare resources to those
who most need them. In many regions of the world, while disadvantaged
populations need greater healthcare, they receive less.7 Some sections
of society (for example, those with mental illness) may warrant greater
allocations of resources, as much as equal treatment is required for similar
needs. Health economists and the World Health Organization (WHO) have"|data_input/OrfPathHealth/MentalHealthPathwayToEquity.pdf|1|3ce1c09aaca9419db0174ae024084f14
"149Mental Health as a Pathway to Health Equityargued that investing in mental health is important from the point of view
of improving population health and reducing social inequality, promoting
human rights, and improving economic efficiency.8 The economic implications
of mental and substance disorders can be enormous: for example, the
global economic loss due to common mental disorders is an estimated US$
1 trillion per year.9 Given the increasing prevalence of mental illness, the
costs are likely to only further mount. Investment in treatment of mental
illness can result in large economic productivity gains.10
The Burden of Mental Health, Substance Use Disorders and
Multimorbidity
Mental and substance-abuse disorders are leading contributors to premature
morbidity and mortality globally. In India, for example, the National Mental
Health Survey (NMHS), 2015-16, has reported a 13.6-percent lifetime
prevalence of any mental/substance-abuse disorder morbidity.11 The overall
number of Disability-Adjusted-Life-Years (DALYs) for mental disorders has
increased by more than 50 percent between 1990 and 2019.12 This growth
pattern is expected to continue, necessitating a proportionate response from
the health systems. Most of the mental and substance abuse disorders
are chronic and disabling conditions. The treatment gap for mental and
substance abuse disorders (defined as proportions of those needing care"|data_input/OrfPathHealth/MentalHealthPathwayToEquity.pdf|2|4b2a3063fa0c49049ee3978e8874a08e
"are chronic and disabling conditions. The treatment gap for mental and
substance abuse disorders (defined as proportions of those needing care
but not receiving) remains high (about 75 percent), contributing to the
high burden at various levels (individual, family and community). A vast
majority of the population cannot afford out-of-pocket (OOP) spending
for the treatment of mental and substance abuse disorders and psychiatric
rehabilitation.
Such out-of-pocket expenditure, in India, is dominated by medicines.13 In
more than half of the population, non-medical costs such as expenses
on travel and accommodation contribute to more than one-third of OOP
spending. The share of doctors’ fees and diagnostic charges in OOP
expenditure is high in private healthcare settings.14 Discrimination in the
coverage by health insurance toward mental illness significantly raises
the chances of catastrophic spending in such circumstances. Despite the
Insurance Regulatory and Development Authority of India (IRDAI) having
directed Indian insurance companies to cover mental illnesses as per the"|data_input/OrfPathHealth/MentalHealthPathwayToEquity.pdf|2|0e7eb893bc5f496cadc42399e6dcc1ce
"150Accelerating Global Health: Pathways to Health Equity for the G20
151Mental Health Care Act, 2017, there have been many reported violations of
the provision of the Act.15 The violations have included rejections of claims
for mental illness by insurance companies and discriminatory ceilings on
the sum of reimbursement for mental illness.
Worldwide, people with SMI have shortened life expectancy by 10-20
years, which is explained by the high rates of multimorbidity.16 Yet the
interventions to address the multimorbidity, primarily non-communicable
diseases (NCDs) and the associated risk factors such as tobacco and alcohol
use, physical inactivity, and poor diets—are insufficient for this group.
The existing national programs to address these chronic conditions seem
oriented vertically with poor horizontal integration across the programmes.
Homeless persons, women, persons with developmental disorders, and
elderly with mental illness experience even further inequities among the
unequal.
The living conditions of persons in India with SMI chronically and who
reside in psychiatric hospitals have been highlighted through public interest
litigations and addressed by the active intervention of the judiciary. The
National Human Rights Commission (NHRC), with the technical support
of the National Institute of Mental Health & Neuro Sciences (NIMHANS),
Bengaluru, has reviewed the rights violations of persons with SMI in these"|data_input/OrfPathHealth/MentalHealthPathwayToEquity.pdf|3|264356480e46446ca4ca7150f6fcc65a
"of the National Institute of Mental Health & Neuro Sciences (NIMHANS),
Bengaluru, has reviewed the rights violations of persons with SMI in these
hospitals and monitored the required systemic changes.17,18
Over the last two decades, there have been consistent efforts toward
developing a better systemic response in the care of persons with mental
illness.
Key Efforts in Improving Mental Healthcare in India
The NMHS, 2015-16, India, reported the current prevalence of any mental
morbidity to be 10.56 percent.19 Those with low education and lower
income, and are middle-aged were at the highest risk for mental illness.20
Only two out of every 10 individuals with mental illness received mental
healthcare.21 Lack of mental health resources (e.g., shortage of mental health
professionals), poor mental health literacy, stigma and discrimination,"|data_input/OrfPathHealth/MentalHealthPathwayToEquity.pdf|3|a8abadb5a3854419980fc641aaac297f
"151Mental Health as a Pathway to Health Equitysocial inequality, gender issues and lack of community participation may
be among the various factors that impede mental health equity in India.
To be sure, India has made strides toward improving mental healthcare
(summarised in Box 1). India was one of the first Asian countries to have
a National Program for Mental Health (NMHP; as early as 1982). The
District Mental Health Program (DMHP) today covers 700 districts across
the country. The DMHP is the implementation arm of the NMHP tasked
to ensure the availability and accessibility of minimum mental healthcare,
integration of mental health in general healthcare, and to promote
community participation in mental health development.
Box 1. Initiatives in India to Ensure Equitable Mental Healthcare
Programmes:
• Expansion of the National Mental Health Programme – District
Mental Health Programme (>700 districts) and Taluk Mental Health
programme (e.g., Karnataka)
• Ayushman Bharat-Pradhan Mantri Jan Arogya Yojna (PM-JAY) –
Universal Health Coverage, Health and Wellness Centres
• National Tele Mental Health Programme (Tele Mental Health Assistance
and Networking Across States: Tele-MANAS)
• Generic medicines – Jan Aushadhi Kendras
Policies:
• National Mental Health Policy (2014)
• National Health Policy (2017)
Legislations:
• Rights of Persons with Disability Act, 2016
• Mental Health Care Act, 2017"|data_input/OrfPathHealth/MentalHealthPathwayToEquity.pdf|4|9566a8be5ebc4470ba12c098589b03d5
"152Accelerating Global Health: Pathways to Health Equity for the G20
153Moreover, the availability of psychotropic medications in primary healthcare
has also improved. Screening and basic management of mental illness have
been incorporated into the services offered at Health and Wellness Centres
(HWC). India has a progressive Mental Health Policy (2014) based on equity,
justice, integrated and evidence-based care in a rights-based approach.22
The use of digital technology is being leveraged for training and expanding
human resources for mental health care in the country through digital
academies at NIMHANS as well as other institutions. The National Tobacco
Control Program has employed a mobile-based strategy called m-Cessation
and tobacco quit-lines to support those who wish to quit tobacco.23,24 The
Government of India launched the National Tele Mental Health Program
(Tele Mental Health Assistance and Networking Across States: Tele-MANAS)
initiative on World Mental Health Day, 2022, to provide 24/7 comprehensive
tele-mental health services that cater to remote and underserved areas.25
The Tele-MANAS initiative—a phone-based, counsellor-led service—aims to
address mental distress, identify mental illnesses and behaviours that need
specialist mental health referrals, and improve service networking in each
State/Union Territory. The examples of digital technology-based initiatives
in India for mental health are summarised in Box 2."|data_input/OrfPathHealth/MentalHealthPathwayToEquity.pdf|5|2b5c18bbd14945b4b6f701b520fd21d9
"State/Union Territory. The examples of digital technology-based initiatives
in India for mental health are summarised in Box 2.
Box 2. Technological Initiatives in India for Mental Health
◊ Telephone/mobile based: Quitline, m-cessation (tobacco), Nikshay Sampark
(TB helpline), Tele-MANAS (National Tele-mental health programme),
Kiran (mental health rehabilitation), COVID-19 psychosocial helpline, sui -
cide helplines, crisis helplines for elderly, women, children, farmers
◊ E-healthcare: eSanjeevani (National Telemedicine Service of India),
e-Manas Karnataka (Mental Healthcare Management System)
◊ Training: NIMHANS digital academy, Telemedicine Centre, NIMHANS, CIP
Digital Academy, LGBRIMH Digital Academy
◊ Telepsychiatry: NIMHANS ECHO model, PGIMER “Tele-enabling model”
◊ Potential uses: chatbots, telerehabilitation, self-help"|data_input/OrfPathHealth/MentalHealthPathwayToEquity.pdf|5|51847ea9e2ef427b9ce15eada66777c0
"153Mental Health as a Pathway to Health EquityThe Government of India’s flagship insurance scheme, Ayushman Bharat-
Pradhan Mantri Jan Arogya Yojna (PM-JAY), aims to achieve Universal
Health Care (UHC) in India.26 The scheme will cover most secondary and
tertiary hospitalisations for nearly 40 percent of the population. The annual
coverage of INR 500,000 per family is irrespective of family size. The
scheme does not, however, cover outpatient expenses. Generic medicines
have been made available in Jan Aushadhi Kendras.27 The availability of
generic medicines at cheaper rates than branded drugs will likely reduce
the economic burden for all sections of society, especially the poor and
marginalised. The second pillar of the PM-JAY is the provision of universal,
comprehensive healthcare in primary care through the 150,000 Health and
Wellness Centres (HWC). The HWC will act as the first point of contact
for comprehensive services, including screening and essential mental health
conditions management.
Two progressive legislations were enacted by the Government of India in
the backdrop of the United Nations Convention on the Rights of Persons
with Disability to address critical concerns of inequality and inequity in
mental healthcare. The Rights of Persons with Disability Act (RPWD),
2016 has provided a reservation of 1 percent for mental illness-related
disabilities in recruitment to government jobs or aided organisations.28"|data_input/OrfPathHealth/MentalHealthPathwayToEquity.pdf|6|5c43ba3a34074ab9b14580755e1c98ae
"2016 has provided a reservation of 1 percent for mental illness-related
disabilities in recruitment to government jobs or aided organisations.28
The Act guarantees reasonable accommodation in education and work in
government institutions for persons with disability. The Mental Health
Care Act (MHCA) 2017 provides the right to access mental healthcare and
treatment from mental health services run or funded by the appropriate
Government.29 The provision under the Act encompasses a range of services
for persons with mental illness, including psychiatric rehabilitation and
community reintegration. The Act also underscores the need for integrating
mental health services with general health services at all levels. The MHCA
2017 also directs parity for mental illness in health insurance as is available
for physical conditions. Appointing persons with mental illness, their family
members and NGOs in the Central and State Mental Health Authorities and
the Mental Health Review Boards is an affirmative step towards ensuring
checks and balances in the delivery of mental healthcare in an equitable
manner."|data_input/OrfPathHealth/MentalHealthPathwayToEquity.pdf|6|ef8b3b7c8544456db1b80edd381daa9e
"154Accelerating Global Health: Pathways to Health Equity for the G20
155Thus, there have been improvements in curative and preventive care domains
for mental and substance use disorders in the last decade. However, these
need to be translated on the ground. There is also still a lack of adequate
focus on rehabilitative care, which remains restricted to select tertiary care
mental health institutions.
The Way Forward
If the vision of the National Mental Health Policy 2014 must be truly
realised, its strategic directions and recommendations for action will need to
be implemented. The distinct mental health needs of vulnerable populations
such as children, the elderly, the homeless, require to be addressed. Macro-
environmental issues such as poverty, unemployment, displacement, and
emerging concerns such as the mental health impact of climate change
require particular focus. Leadership and governance at various levels must
be strengthened. Mental health systems should be strengthened at various
levels to provide decentralised care in smaller administrative units such as
the taluks /blocks.
Preventive and promotive aspects of mental health provide an opportunity
to integrate existing mainstream/biomedical as well as alternative/traditional
systems of care, including Yoga. Mental health should be effectively
addressed at the workplace. The mental health of children and adolescents
should take primacy and can be addressed in educational settings."|data_input/OrfPathHealth/MentalHealthPathwayToEquity.pdf|7|7cce2ea34f0249fe9a54a17d2c6bcb85
"addressed at the workplace. The mental health of children and adolescents
should take primacy and can be addressed in educational settings.
However, given that there may be a substantial group of out-of-school
children and adolescents, as well as a large proportion of the population
that works in the unorganised sector, there is a need to expand the reach
of access to mental healthcare. A life-span approach to mental healthcare,
extending from perinatal care to elderly care is recommended. Research in
public mental health aspects is another priority. Mental health indicators
need to be standardised and incorporated in governance regularly. The
comprehensive set of interrelated services has been deemed necessary
in the World Mental Health Report, 2022 – these cover the life cycle, from
maternal and child mental health, to the elderly.30"|data_input/OrfPathHealth/MentalHealthPathwayToEquity.pdf|7|fc7a5acb1a31446dbf751cd0606a6381
"155Mental Health as a Pathway to Health EquityInequity in mental healthcare needs to be systematically measured and
monitored in LMICs to identify gaps and to inform policies and programmes.
WHO has developed the Health Equity Assessment Toolkit (HEAT and HEAT
Plus) software to explore and compare within-country health inequalities
and across settings using disaggregated datasets.31 Simultaneously, there is
a need to learn from successful models developed in High-Income Countries
(HICs). For example, in the United Kingdom (UK), the National Health
Service (NHS) through the Five-Year Forward View for Mental Health has
prioritised addressing inequity.32 There have been debates in the public
health domain for “disparity interventions” that are specifically designed
for populations that face inequality.33 Most of the existing inequality
interventions in the mental health field from the HICs have focused on
racial disparities, age-related factors, and socioeconomic issues. While
developing, testing, and implementing the interventions, at each stage, all
stakeholders including the service users will have to get involved.
To ensure universal health coverage for mental health, specific efforts have
been conducted by WHO in six early adopter countries. Inadequate human
resource and inequitable distribution of specialists were reported to be the
crucial issues in the situational analysis.34 In India, for the PM-JAY to"|data_input/OrfPathHealth/MentalHealthPathwayToEquity.pdf|8|252f9895e28748adb6ebaa67d5dadb0f
"crucial issues in the situational analysis.34 In India, for the PM-JAY to
meet the goal of universal health coverage, service delivery needs to be
strengthened at all levels and systems to maintain continuity of care must
be created, an area that is particularly relevant for mental health.35 The
coverage for non-PM-JAY patients, specifically non-below poverty line but
belonging to lower/middle socioeconomic classes will have to be addressed
to reduce catastrophic spending.36 Mechanisms of surveillance and health
information must be further strengthened to encompass private healthcare
providers.
The national programmes for non-communicable diseases and chronic
communicable diseases such as Tuberculosis need to consider that
most patients with these conditions have multimorbidity and align the
programmes with the NMHP at various levels. Integration of care at the
primary care level and the HWC will have to be implemented as envisioned
in the PM-JAY, with an emphasis to improve patient reported outcomes,
besides clinical outcomes. There is sufficient evidence for self-management
and peer-based interventions for chronic conditions that have emerged
and have been successfully implemented in HICs.37,38 They must be adapted"|data_input/OrfPathHealth/MentalHealthPathwayToEquity.pdf|8|7456f0334e9840cba532ec95cc0fda8f
"156Accelerating Global Health: Pathways to Health Equity for the G20
157to the cultural settings of LMICs. The effectiveness of brief psychological
interventions delivered by lay counsellors for moderate to severe depressive
disorders and harmful drinking in primary care has been demonstrated in
India.39,40
These low-cost interventions may have important lessons for HIC as the
health systems in HICs are overwhelmed with long waiting periods for
psychological intervention. Low-intensity interventions such as WHO’s
Problem Management plus (PM+) can be used in low-human resource
settings for adults in distress due to exposure to adversity.41 Families
are an important resource for care provision in LMICs, specifically in the
context of mental health and the role and concerns of family caregivers
must be formally addressed. Indigenous interventions such as Yoga as well
as alternative forms of medicine have potential benefits for multimorbidity.
An evidence-based integration into the public health system may enhance
outcomes as they are culturally acceptable and may have a broad spectrum
of action.
Technology has been harnessed in healthcare in India as exemplified
by the Tele-MANAS programme. However, the metrics to monitor the
implementation of the programme should encompass inequities in the
delivery of virtual care. Methods to enhance digital literacy and adaptation
of the care so that even those with low digital literacy can comfortably"|data_input/OrfPathHealth/MentalHealthPathwayToEquity.pdf|9|5bde385272364d41863f4dd611d3ce69
"of the care so that even those with low digital literacy can comfortably
use the portals of care, need to be considered during implementation. As
primary healthcare is the locus of UHC, addressing the referral pathways
with monitoring of the referrals, robust information systems and integration
of mental and physical care are central to improving outcomes. The
successful translation of policies and programmes on the ground requires
governmental engagement as well as that of all stakeholders to ensure
equitable and quality healthcare.
Dr. Pratima Murthy, Director and Senior Professor of Psychiatry, NIMHANS, Bengaluru
Dr. Krishna Prasad Muliyala, A d d i t i o n a l P r o f e s s o r o f P s y c h i a t r y , N I M H A N S , B e n g a l u r u
Dr. Channaveerachari Naveen Kumar, Professor of Psychiatry and Head of Community
Psychiatry, NIMHANS, Bengaluru"|data_input/OrfPathHealth/MentalHealthPathwayToEquity.pdf|9|70c49596e8704f398fa071bad0daac8b
"39
39The COVID-19 pandemic took the world by surprise. In early 2020, no
one would have thought that in months to come, millions of people
would be in ‘lockdown’, trillions of dollars would be lost to the global
economy, and over 7 million people would die from the disease caused by
the novel coronavirus. For many years before 2020, scientists and medical
experts had been warning that the world was simply not ready for disease
‘X’; such a pandemic was almost inevitable, however, coming as it did
from a zoonotic virus for which no vaccines or drugs had been developed.
Although it has been declared that the Public Health Emergency of
International Concern relating to COVID-19 is over, many countries,
especially low-income ones, still have a substantial number of COVID-19
cases and are without access to the vaccines and drugs they need. There is
the risk of becoming complacent again. There are hundreds of thousands
of bird and animal viruses that could get transmitted to humans, and
potentially onwards from human to human. A new infectious disease can
almost certainly strike. The question is when.
While not all disease outbreaks can be prevented, they can be arrested so
that they do not escalate into an epidemic or pandemic. Social inequalities Barbara StockingThe Urgent Need for
a Pandemic Accord"|data_input/OrfPathHealth/UrgentNeedForPandemicAccors.pdf|0|caf5d404de8c43a0b5d1a54ea9d40d97
"40Accelerating Global Health: Pathways to Health Equity for the G20
41can be reduced, and health systems strengthened, to better protect
populations against such outbreaks. The imperative is to understand what
went wrong, and what it would take to make things right.
Critical Failures
To prevent history from repeating itself, the global community would do
well to learn the lessons of COVID-19.
a. Countries were insufficiently prepared. Even those with strong healthcare
systems geared to tackle pandemics had not tested them through,
for instance, simulation exercises. Poorer countries did not have the
resources to run a fully functioning public health system. In almost
all countries, there was little understanding of the implications of a
lockdown—for livelihoods and the economy, trade, and social services
such as education .
b. Aside from public health experts, others had no understanding of how
fast an outbreak can develop into a pandemic. Initially, governments
took a ‘wait and see’ approach rather than precautionary action. February
2020 was a critical month when the opportunity to take control of the
virus was lost.
c. Countries did not comply with the International Health Regulations
(IHR) which have been in place since 2005, and often did not accept
evidence-based advice from the World Health Organization (WHO).
d. The wide inequities between countries and population groups were
exacerbated, and the consequences were dire in determining who had"|data_input/OrfPathHealth/UrgentNeedForPandemicAccors.pdf|1|9a5fb26f97944249bc2c6dbbee7bd4b5
"d. The wide inequities between countries and population groups were
exacerbated, and the consequences were dire in determining who had
access to vaccines and drugs and who did not.
A New Pandemic Treaty and Amendments to the IHR
Early on in the pandemic, calls were made for action including developing
a ‘pandemic treaty’ that would set out what countries need to do, and hold
them to account. At a special session of the World Health Assembly (WHA)"|data_input/OrfPathHealth/UrgentNeedForPandemicAccors.pdf|1|82925b5296d34fcbbd07c71e6285ea37
"41The Urgent Need for a Pandemic Accordin 2021, WHO’s 194 member states agreed to negotiate a new ‘Convention
Accord or other International Instrument’ on pandemic preparedness and
response (PPR) (referred to as the WHO CA+ or the Pandemic Accord).1
The work began with an Intergovernmental Negotiating Body (INB) being
established with a final proposal to be delivered to the WHA in May 2024.
In May 2022, it was also agreed that a Working Group on amendments to
the IHR should be established (WGIHR).2 Its report is due at the end of
2023. All member states are engaged in both negotiations.
From the beginning, the scope of the changes to the IHR has been
contentious. The resolution of the WHA was to keep it to a small number
of amendments, but some countries argued for a much wider scope. They
sought, for example, for ‘One Health’a prevention measures, and equity in
access to drugs and vaccines. It has led to 300 amendments to the IHR
being submitted to the WGIHR. Countries which might have preferred a
more limited approach also jumped in when it was clear that the scope
was to be broader. As a result, many proposed changes are similar to those
suggested in the Pandemic Accord.
Ultimately, there has to be coherence and compatibility between the Accord
and the IHR. It is likely that the Accord will have more of the overarching
principles and wider issues, with the IHR defining the technical requirements"|data_input/OrfPathHealth/UrgentNeedForPandemicAccors.pdf|2|0bea0cfd2ac34d51b9a07b5c004ddae3
"principles and wider issues, with the IHR defining the technical requirements
to deliver them. There is a long way to go but the member states guiding
the negotiations are meeting regularly to try to ensure coherence and avoid
conflicting recommendations.
Guiding Principles
The following are the key principles that should be at the heart of the
Pandemic Accord and the IHR:
a ‘One Health’ is a collaborative, multi-sectoral approach to health, which recognises the
interconnection between people, animals, plants and their shared environment."|data_input/OrfPathHealth/UrgentNeedForPandemicAccors.pdf|2|9b653d140720425c915c3f500ad365e4
"42Accelerating Global Health: Pathways to Health Equity for the G20
43• Solidarity.
Preventing outbreaks from turning into pandemics is a collective
responsibility and is in every country’s self-interest. Unhelpful campaigning
on social media and elsewhere has suggested that a new treaty could
challenge the sovereignty of a country. That is not the case; countries will
continue to take their own decisions. The Charter of the United Nations
affirms the sovereignty of States Parties in addressing their own public
health matters.3 However, it also sets out the obligation to ensure that
“activities within their own jurisdiction or control do not cause damage to
their peoples, other States Parties, and areas beyond the limits of national
jurisdiction”.
• Equity.
Morality and national self-interest demand equitable access to all tools,
including vaccines, diagnostics and treatments, and financing for these
resources. Equity includes a change of attitude in governance. There
needs to be equity in governance systems, for example, in financing for
preparedness and response to pandemics. It should not be just controlled
by donors.
Equity also means fairness in the assessment of what countries are capable
of. There are significant differences in each country’s ability to deliver
preparedness and response. Poorer countries simply do not have the same
level of resources as the developed ones.
• Transparency."|data_input/OrfPathHealth/UrgentNeedForPandemicAccors.pdf|3|93da291caa4f47eda2643c323f552507
"preparedness and response. Poorer countries simply do not have the same
level of resources as the developed ones.
• Transparency.
Transparency of data and genomic sequencing are vital to responding
quickly and effectively to the pandemic, and required for the development
of new drugs and vaccines. Transparency is what builds trust within and
between countries.
• Accountability.
The new Accord must set out greater accountability requirements than were
in place in the past. This is one of the key reasons for the Accord. Many"|data_input/OrfPathHealth/UrgentNeedForPandemicAccors.pdf|3|4db0ca6c5b2b432985da0bda23132499
"43The Urgent Need for a Pandemic Accordcivil society organisations have been sceptical about whether a new treaty
would make a difference, pointing out that compliance with the IHR is still
lacking. That challenge must be met.
Accountability should be to the people of each country through parliamentary
systems and civil society. It is also needed for mutual assurance between
countries. When governments require extraordinary actions from their
populations—for example, lockdowns and mask mandates—they need to be
confident that other countries are also taking appropriate action.
Building Consensus
Early in 2023 the ‘zero draft’ of the Accord was made available and
the real negotiations began. Taking into account all the discussions and
proposed texts from member states, a revised draft—the ‘first draft’—is
to be produced in the summer of 2023. The negotiations are undoubtedly
complex, but it is worth noting that a surprising amount seems to be
commonly agreed upon.
The purpose of the Accord and its principles seem widely accepted, including
the protection of the human rights of all people wherever and whoever they
may be. There is particular concern that the needs of the most vulnerable
people are taken into account in pandemics. There is commitment to the
development of public health and healthcare systems and to protect staff,
who are most at risk in epidemics and pandemics. There is a need to"|data_input/OrfPathHealth/UrgentNeedForPandemicAccors.pdf|4|0f7ab32f99de49388ec7f47d55f62bc0
"development of public health and healthcare systems and to protect staff,
who are most at risk in epidemics and pandemics. There is a need to
communicate well with the public and deal with misinformation. There is
commitment to a ‘whole-of-society’ approach for all plans and actions,
and recognition of the need for global coordination.
There appears to be conceptual agreement that preparedness plans should
involve all of government, and that there should be regular simulation
exercises. A ‘Universal Health and Preparedness Review’ is suggested as
a mechanism for review of each country’s preparedness. Both peer review
of the plans as well as independent assessment are being discussed.
Surprisingly, remarkably little is being said about public health response,
presumably because so much of it falls within the IHR."|data_input/OrfPathHealth/UrgentNeedForPandemicAccors.pdf|4|22cc304d163540089e2e574688718ab6
"44Accelerating Global Health: Pathways to Health Equity for the G20
45An area of work making encouraging process is prevention. This brings
together human and animal health, now often described as ‘one health’.
Because zoonosesb a r e t h e g r e a t e s t r i s k , a c t i o n s t o r e d u c e t r a n s m i s s i o n —
such as closure of wet markets or banning of exotic animal trade—are
being considered alongside work on the habitats of humans and animals.
However, it seems unlikely that a fully considered plan will be ready for the
Accord; a new protocol might be more appropriate. The Joint Plan of Action
is being developed by WHO, the Food and Agriculture Organization, the
World Organisation for Animal Health, and the United Nations Environment
Programme,4 m a k i n g u p t h e s o - c a l l e d ‘ q u a d r i p a r t i t e ’ .
Areas of Contention
The contentious issues are around equity, especially related to countries’
access to vaccines, drugs, and other medical equipment. Member states
might sign up to the principle, but there are great differences among them
on how this should be achieved. Developing countries are pressing for a
wider spread of manufacturing, particularly for vaccines, but not only for
them. Success in getting mRNA vaccine manufacturing underway in South
Africa is a good start, although manufacturing for the whole continent and
globally will require both financial investment and technology transfer. The"|data_input/OrfPathHealth/UrgentNeedForPandemicAccors.pdf|5|5aaf419340ed446388c170a975494f36
"globally will require both financial investment and technology transfer. The
extent to which the pharmaceutical industry would be prepared to engage
with technology transfer and the associated question of intellectual property
rights is unclear.
Various models have been proposed to achieve access. When wealthier
governments fund the research and development (R&D) of companies, for
example, they could persuade industry players to earmark a percentage of
vaccines for the poorer countries, or to sell these to them at cost. However,
that would still leave the poorest countries at their mercy. Meanwhile, the
pharmaceutical industry argues that without commercial pricing of new
drugs and vaccines, there is no incentive for innovation.
b These are infectious diseases which can be transferred from animals to humans, or vice
versa."|data_input/OrfPathHealth/UrgentNeedForPandemicAccors.pdf|5|7e4472e16355427eac7ca4ad2ad540a6
"45The Urgent Need for a Pandemic AccordSuch debates are not new. The World Trade Organization struggled to reach
an agreement on a Trade Related Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights
(TRIPS) waiver throughout the pandemic, with limited success.5 This was
despite an early agreement on TRIPS waivers for drugs in a public health
emergency, reached many years ago in 2001 during the Doha Trade Round.6
It is difficult to see how there can be a breakthrough, but developing
countries have made it clear they will not support a new Accord which
does not deal with equity of access.
Crucial Gaps
The Pandemic Accord and the IHR will fail if two areas are not attended
to: financing and accountability.
Financing : The G20 Independent High-Level Panel estimated that the
annual financing need for future preparedness and response to pandemics
was US$ 31 billion.7 Even considering domestic and international financing,
US$ 10 billion a year is required for PPR, which includes upgrading public
health systems, R&D, and overall preparedness. If the amount seems high,
it must be remembered that it is a tiny amount compared to the cost of
a pandemic.
The G20 report and another from the World Bank and WHO8 led to the
establishing of the Pandemic Fund at the World Bank. However, the
promised funding in the first year has been only US$ 1.6 billion, and there
are concerns about how funds can be raised in the longer term. This is"|data_input/OrfPathHealth/UrgentNeedForPandemicAccors.pdf|6|c7a99ed0afc64ddd846b914246743dd2
"promised funding in the first year has been only US$ 1.6 billion, and there
are concerns about how funds can be raised in the longer term. This is
the moment for the G20 to deliberate on how the necessary financing can
be found.
Accountability: For the Accord and the IHR to succeed, countries must
deliver on the obligations they have committed to. External accountability
mechanisms are also needed as safeguards to ensure that all parties are
answerable for these obligations. The Panel, which this author chairs,
firmly believes that there should be independent assessment of countries—
their preparedness plans, response, and other matters which might be
agreed upon in the Accord. WHO is a friend and supporter of countries,"|data_input/OrfPathHealth/UrgentNeedForPandemicAccors.pdf|6|7aa12dbfbe994dec81d06c120a98f78a
"46Accelerating Global Health: Pathways to Health Equity for the G20
47which makes it difficult for it to challenge them in the public space. The
Panel believes that the way forward is a small independent body for the
Accord and perhaps the IHR, too. The Accord will be hosted by WHO but
will have its own secretariat. An arms-length independent assessment body
could be housed within the Accord’s treaty structure. The International
Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) is one model being proposed, but because
WHO already has much of the monitoring information, the independent
assessment body need not be as large as the IAEA.
Assessments do not have to be about blaming and shaming. They need
to be public but supportive, especially of countries that do not have the
resources and are in need of financial and technical help. Pandemics create
huge risks to individuals and nations. The public has a right to know what
their governments and other governments are doing to protect them, and
that includes ensuring countries across the world have the resources to
deliver.
Dame Barbara Stocking, Chair, Panel for a Global Public Health Convention, is
responsible for opinions expressed in this article though they are informed by the
Panel’s discussions."|data_input/OrfPathHealth/UrgentNeedForPandemicAccors.pdf|7|a89658b132ad4547a1efc0cfad4cfcec
"19
1819There is an enormous sense of relief that the world has already
suffered the most acute stage of the COVID-19 pandemic—with
its heartbreaking death toll, devastating illness, and crushing social and
economic fallout. The job of hardening the world’s defences against future
disease outbreaks, however, has only begun. Indeed, COVID-19 is still with
us and will continue to smoulder for years to come, assuming it does
not flare up again. Moreover, the prospect of future, and potentially more
menacing, global infectious disease outbreaks remains in the horizon—
made more likely by factors like climate change, unabated encroachment
on the habitats of wild animals that carry dangerous pathogens, population
growth, and urbanisation.
Now is the time to take stock of the many lessons of COVID-19 and, more
importantly, to act on them. The emotional, physical, economic and social
scars that millions suffered are still fresh enough to feed the political will
as leaders need to make big, tough choices about investments in future Ensuring Equitable
Supply and Access
to Critical Vaccines
During Pandemics:
The Lessons of COV AX
Aurélia Nguyen"|data_input/OrfPathHealth/EnsuringEquitableSupplyOfVaccines.pdf|0|fabf903dfe89474ca6029b0a5e34f595
"19The Lessons of COVAX
19pandemic preparedness and response. If they fail to do so, the global
community will once again pay dearly—in lives lost and damaged and in
profound economic and social shocks.
The overarching and perhaps most obvious lesson of the pandemic was
that most countries, and the world collectively, were unprepared to defend
themselves against SARS-CoV-2, the virus that causes COVID-19.1 Nearly all
countries—even those whose health systems were presumed to be strong—
struggled not just to arrest the spread and blunt the devastating impacts
of the virus but also to continue delivering other vital health services.2
This was no surprise to the many global health experts who had long
warned about the world’s vulnerability to a crisis of such magnitude.
Yet, even those experts could not have fully anticipated exactly the ways
COVID-19 ultimately exploited the gaps in health security systems globally.
If there is anything meaningful that emerged from the pandemic, it is
the knowledge of where and how health systems struggled, where they
performed well, and what must be done to prepare for future pandemics.
This author speaks from experience as managing director of the Office of
the COVAX Facility from the fall of 2020 through mid-2022. The Access to
COVID-19 Tools Accelerator (or ACT-A) was a global collaboration focused
on accelerating the development, production, and access to vaccines. COVAX,"|data_input/OrfPathHealth/EnsuringEquitableSupplyOfVaccines.pdf|1|3ee93735b86a4c618f12653e0f3c4db0
"on accelerating the development, production, and access to vaccines. COVAX,
the vaccines pillar of ACT-A, had the remit of facilitating access to potential
COVID-19 vaccines to the most vulnerable everywhere, regardless of their
income;3 to date, it has delivered nearly 2 billion doses of COVID-19
vaccines to 146 countries across the world.4 It is a collaborative work of
the Coalition for Epidemic Preparedness Innovations (CEPI), the World
Health Organization (WHO), the United Nations Children’s Fund (UNICEF)
and Gavi, the Vaccine Alliance which co-managed COVAX.
COVAX accomplished a great deal, and according to estimates from Imperial
College London, the impact of COVID-19 vaccinations on COVAX AMC
participants included the prevention of an estimated 2.7 million deaths
worldwide.5 It could have made even greater impact had certain conditions
been met even before it was launched in 2020. To that end, one must heed
three categories of lessons that emerged while dealing with the pandemic"|data_input/OrfPathHealth/EnsuringEquitableSupplyOfVaccines.pdf|1|6d3b267a64e4447380d861e2af2085b7
"20Accelerating Global Health: Pathways to Health Equity for the G20
21puzzle—the procurement, distribution, and administration of COVID-19
vaccines across countries.
First, the world must be willing to take risks and make contingent
financing available to ramp up rapidly as health crises emerge. Before
the COVID-19 pandemic broke out, there was nothing in the world like
COVAX. It began without any funding and with virtually no personnel.
Unlike sovereign governments with sizeable spending power, global health
organisations and other international development agencies could not take
on the risk of paying billions of dollars in purchase orders for vaccines.6
It thus took COVAX several months to raise sufficient funds to secure
early-purchase agreements with vaccine makers. Meanwhile, vaccine
manufacturers gave priority to bilateral customers—typically, well-resourced
sovereign governments—even months before it was clear which, if any
of the vaccine candidates would earn regulatory approval.7 That, in turn,
left relatively few doses available early on for COVAX to procure. More
importantly, some countries imposed export bans on vaccines or vaccine
ingredients manufactured on their shores to ensure they would have enough
supply for their citizens.8
It is understandable that countries will do everything they can to place
the health needs of their citizens first in a crisis such as COVID-19. This"|data_input/OrfPathHealth/EnsuringEquitableSupplyOfVaccines.pdf|2|7bb65fb349424e1db705103fc033b0df
"the health needs of their citizens first in a crisis such as COVID-19. This
dynamic will not change. The question, therefore, is how the world can
navigate this geopolitical reality.
One way is to put in place now contingent funding that will be immediately
deployable as soon as another crisis strikes. That will help global health
agencies—like a future version of the COVAX Facility—mount an even more
effective global response.
Such funding must be flexible and agile. It will require mechanisms to
constantly update working assumptions regarding epidemiology, policy
recommendations, supply, demand, R&D, manufacturing, country-level
challenges, and other factors, and for making at-risk investments for
multiple scenarios. This funding should also include a proportion that could
be used with a high-risk appetite to secure vaccines that are at any R&D
stage, even with the risk of vaccine failure.9"|data_input/OrfPathHealth/EnsuringEquitableSupplyOfVaccines.pdf|2|b756f59ae9c846d4b8cd180fdab678a9
"21The Lessons of COVAXAnother lesson is related to the value of an innovative financing mechanism
that COVAX created, called the pandemic vaccine pool (PVP), which ensures
that there will be cash on hand to make rapid procurement of vaccines
available, especially to lower-income countries—even in a scenario such as
the one in 2020 where it was uncertain which of the vaccine candidates
would get approval. Likewise, COVAX pioneered other new innovations out
of the crisis—such as indemnification and liability agreements and a ‘no-
fault compensation scheme’ that would lower the risks for manufacturers—
which were also critical to removing bottlenecks and speeding up the
response-time during COVID-19. Mechanisms that allow fast response and
sharing of risk during an emergency are important features of any future
responses.
Moreover, multinational trade-facilitation measures must be strengthened
to allow for the free flow of vaccines, manufacturing supplies, and other
life-saving equipment during health emergencies. There should be in place,
for example, exemptions and waivers that allow agencies involved in the
global health response to ship life-saving medical countermeasures and
materials to low- and middle-income countries as well as into humanitarian
situations exempt from any trade barriers.10
Second, it is now known that turning vaccines i n t o vaccinations depends
upon strong, reliable health systems. That is, getting shots in people’s"|data_input/OrfPathHealth/EnsuringEquitableSupplyOfVaccines.pdf|3|71ad7c0227f24ca38c4803f7f8cf8f8e
"upon strong, reliable health systems. That is, getting shots in people’s
arms requires complete end-to-end solutions at the country level, backed
by investments—from early R&D; scaling-up manufacturing; securing deals;
consistent policy guidance; and setting up operational, logistical, regulatory,
and legal frameworks further along the value chain. This applies not just
to the vaccines themselves but also ancillary supplies, such as cold chain
and safe injection equipment, international freight and logistics as well as
in-country delivery requirements, including personal protective equipment
for healthcare workers.11
Many countries that lacked this infrastructure strained to get doses
to the people who needed them. To be sure, the challenge was less
pronounced—though still serious—in many countries where organisations
like Gavi and WHO had already provided significant resources over many
years to help strengthen health systems (particularly primary health care),"|data_input/OrfPathHealth/EnsuringEquitableSupplyOfVaccines.pdf|3|2067070d62214af186e8acbe3592ef65
"22Accelerating Global Health: Pathways to Health Equity for the G20
23build cold chains that facilitated the widespread delivery of vaccines, and
establish relations with all the many stakeholders who make immunisation
programmes work.
At Gavi, which has supported the improvement of lower-income countries’
routine immunisation programmes since 2000, the concern was that
those efforts to vaccinate mostly children would flag significantly under
the extra burden of delivering COVID-19 vaccines to other populations. It
was unexpected, therefore, when many showed relatively little decline in
routine immunisation. To be sure, their systems were pushed to the limit.
Vaccinators, doctors and nurses were burned out. However, considering that
while responding to the pandemic and having to deliver three times the
number of vaccines compared with previous years, immunisation in Gavi-
implementing countries suffered declines of only 4 percent in 2020 and
1 percent in 2021 and a near return to pre-COVID levels by the end of
2022—there was a lot more resilience than expected.12
Those many years of health system strengthening investments apparently
paid off. But these countries will need more, especially when it comes to
building out primary healthcare services, cold chain, vaccine track-and-
trace, human resources and data monitoring systems13 that reach all their
citizens, especially those with the least access to healthcare."|data_input/OrfPathHealth/EnsuringEquitableSupplyOfVaccines.pdf|4|ce903a70fac544b9beac7468f519c9eb
"trace, human resources and data monitoring systems13 that reach all their
citizens, especially those with the least access to healthcare.
One step in that direction, for example, is the COVID-19 vaccine Delivery
Support (CDS) which was time-sensitive funding based on country’s
requirements across various areas, including service delivery, data and
monitoring, and supply chain systems that Gavi helped put in place
to deal with funding gaps for delivery and improve countries’ capacity
to rapidly scale up COVID-19 vaccinations. In addition to that goal, in
many countries the programme has also contributed to health system
strengthening, including upscaled cold chain infrastructure, digitisation of
health data, improved outreach capabilities, combined COVID-19 and routine
immunisation deliveries, and expanded vaccine supply chain capacity.
Somalia, for example, where targeted CDS investment saw the digitisation
of its health systems, strengthening of the country’s cold chain capacity,
and the training of health workers at the front of community engagement
and support of risk communications for both COVID-19 vaccination and"|data_input/OrfPathHealth/EnsuringEquitableSupplyOfVaccines.pdf|4|54286a988fb7490d9a86d8da96b43249
"23The Lessons of COVAXroutine immunisation helped increase primary COVID-19 vaccine coverage
from 5 percent at the beginning of 2022 to 41 percent by the end of the
year.14 Gavi invested approximately US$1.3 billion in health systems in
Gavi-implementing countries from 2021 to 2022.15
Moreover, it must be ensured that every country puts in place regulatory
readiness, harmonisation, and policy development for pandemic preparedness.
They must build access for the most vulnerable people—especially those
who are chronically hard to reach—into the pandemic architecture. This
should acknowledge that, despite best efforts, there will be disparities in
countries’ readiness levels, infrastructure, and capacity in the event of
another pandemic.16 The global community cannot shirk from the challenge
of closing those gaps, as much as possible.
Third, it is important to lower barriers to the equitable supply of vaccines—
such as vaccine nationalism, hoarding, and export bans. The very idea of
the COVAX Facility emerged from a desire to prevent a replay of what took
place in 2009 during the H1N1 pandemic when better-resourced countries
dominated nearly all the global supply of vaccines.17 Countries with little
financial resources and without their own vaccine production capacity were
left largely empty-handed.18
To solve that problem, COVAX sought to pool demand for COVID-19 vaccines
from lower-income economies as well as from wealthier nations. With"|data_input/OrfPathHealth/EnsuringEquitableSupplyOfVaccines.pdf|5|89bc1967110149bbbeeab91bd2716113
"To solve that problem, COVAX sought to pool demand for COVID-19 vaccines
from lower-income economies as well as from wealthier nations. With
pooled demand and funding, COVAX would ideally be in a better position
to make large-scale investments. It could build a diverse portfolio of what
was eventually 11 vaccine-candidates across four technology platforms (10 of
which received regulatory approval for use). This was the largest portfolio
secured by any buyer, making more than 4 billion doses available to 191
countries that were part of COVAX.19
In other words, COVAX would be able to compete with better-resourced
countries for what would surely be a finite supply of vaccine doses. Dose
domination by relatively few countries would not follow the pattern of the
H1N1 vaccine."|data_input/OrfPathHealth/EnsuringEquitableSupplyOfVaccines.pdf|5|81a04b1247ef4f6586112345ee3284c6
"24Accelerating Global Health: Pathways to Health Equity for the G20
25The experience during COVID-19 and previous pandemics cries out for
increased and geographically diversified vaccine manufacturing, particularly
across the African continent. Africa has an eighth of the world’s population
but only about 0.1 percent of the vaccine manufacturing capacity.20 There is
much work that must and can be done to help those regions establish this
essential infrastructure, not just for emergencies but for the production of
routine vaccines during non-crisis times. To help regional production take
root and grow, there must be support for technology transfer as well as
demand-side financing to promote a sustainable diversified manufacturing
base.21
With this goal in mind, Gavi and the African Union Commission entered
into a Memorandum of Understanding in May 2023 (with the cooperation
of the Africa Center for Disease Control)22 to work together to stimulate,
among other health advances, sustainable regional vaccine manufacturing in
the continent. The endeavour includes 10 commitments to increase political,
financial, and technical investments in immunisation programmes.23
Another one of the biggest lessons was that critical to an effective global
response is putting models in place that can ensure, long before the
occurrence of a pandemic, that lower-income countries receive volumes of
vaccine doses at the same time and in the same levels that high-income"|data_input/OrfPathHealth/EnsuringEquitableSupplyOfVaccines.pdf|6|b6c2a98b763a48c2aae8cda39b29ffaa
"occurrence of a pandemic, that lower-income countries receive volumes of
vaccine doses at the same time and in the same levels that high-income
countries do to stop the spread of variants. This will require increased
standards for manufacturers’ transparency about their order books so
that it is possible to determine—and correct— the supply inequities among
countries. This will also require that contingent financing continues to be
readily available to allow response to unexpected trends in the trajectory
of the pandemic. Discussions on the use of available COVAX AMC funding
is currently ongoing, with consideration on using part of the available PVP
funding channelled to the procurement of new products, including variant-
containing vaccine boosters, based on country requirements.
Discussions also focus on the implementation of the 2024–25 COVID-19
programme approved by the Gavi board in June 2023.24 Equally important
considerations include using these funds to prepare for other health
emergencies, catching up from the effects of the pandemic, accelerating
diversified manufacturing—all of which will be discussed further at the
December board meeting of Gavi."|data_input/OrfPathHealth/EnsuringEquitableSupplyOfVaccines.pdf|6|3692203dde53471fb79f6b9dd7bf58aa
"25The Lessons of COVAXThe global community is relieved to have moved past the worst of the
biggest and most devastating global health crisis in more than a century.
However, such sense of relief—and perhaps the understandable weariness
after three years of searing crisis—must not turn into complacency or
neglect. The future depends on learning from what the world lived through
and to make the big, smart changes that are required.
Aurélia Nguyen is the chief programme strategy officer at Gavi, the Vaccine Alliance.
She served as managing director of the Office of the COVAX Facility for the first two and
a half years of the pandemic and, previously, as Gavi’s managing director for vaccines
and sustainability."|data_input/OrfPathHealth/EnsuringEquitableSupplyOfVaccines.pdf|7|347f88a5870b41f185abcb1de7d74b12
"13Among the most important lessons the world should learn from
the COVID-19 pandemic is that being prepared—being ready to act
urgently with the right technology, know-how and resources—can give the
world a crucial head start in tackling a newly-emerging infectious disease
outbreak.
With COVID-19, many countries and regions of the world were seriously
deficient on many important epidemic and pandemic preparedness measures,
putting them way behind the line. However, in one key aspect of the race
against the novel viral threat—vaccine development—the world had put
itself a few critical steps ahead by the time the SARS-CoV-2 coronavirus
emerged in 2020.
This was in large part a result of many years of studying other similar
viruses, whereby scientists had the chance to develop and hone techniques
to facilitate new vaccine designs. Research initially on respiratory syncytial
virus (RSV)—a virus first identified in 1956 that can cause respiratory
tract infections—and subsequently on the SARS coronavirus that emerged
in China in 2003, then on the MERS coronavirus that was first reported a
12Richard Hatchett and Kate KellandA Global Vaccine
Library:
Giving Humanity a Head Start Against
Pandemic Threats"|data_input/OrfPathHealth/GlobalVaccineLibrary.pdf|0|abf14dd14f25491dbf10495484afc8aa
"13A Global Vaccine Librarydecade later in Saudi Arabia, meant scientists had well-developed insights
into these types of viruses and knew how to go about designing effective
vaccines against them.
Those decades of work allowed scientists to understand, for example, the
importance of the spike protein of the coronavirus for the production of
neutralising antibodies. They had also developed and refined techniques
for manipulating the spike protein to make it more visible to the immune
system and therefore more able to illicit a potent immune response.
In early 2020 when the novel coronavirus SARS-CoV-2 emerged, drug
developers were able to create new candidate vaccines at record speed.
They pulled off the shelf previous research, data and knowledge on RSV,
SARS and MERS virology, vaccinology and immunology, and tweaked it to
figure out how to best tackle the novel threat. Therefore, despite never
before having seen the COVID-19-causing virus, they were not reinventing
the wheel in developing COVID-19 vaccines. Humanity had a head start.
Consider also the case of Mpox. Formerly known as monkeypox, Mpox
is a contagious disease caused by a virus from a family called the
orthopoxviruses—a viral family that also counts smallpox, cowpox and
many other pox viruses among its members. When Mpox began to spread
in 2022 in a far larger outbreak that reached more geographies, humanity
had again put itself a few critical steps ahead. It was in the late 1800s"|data_input/OrfPathHealth/GlobalVaccineLibrary.pdf|1|eac4fb2d0ec3485093755074f08e0cb4
"in 2022 in a far larger outbreak that reached more geographies, humanity
had again put itself a few critical steps ahead. It was in the late 1800s
when vaccines against the highly deadly smallpox were developed, before
being refined and ultimately deployed to greatest effect in the 1970s and
1980s when smallpox became the first—and so far only—human disease
to be eradicated. After this success, however, many governments remained
highly concerned about the potential for the smallpox virus to be used one
day as a weapon of bioterrorism. This led national and international health
security bodies to decide to maintain stockpiles of smallpox vaccines.
Fortunately, those smallpox vaccines also offer broad protection against
other viruses in the orthopoxvirus family, including Mpox. When Mpox case
numbers ballooned into an epidemic of international emergency proportions
in 2022, the bank of knowledge, data and vaccines that could help public
health authorities curb the outbreak was significant. Again, humanity had
a head start."|data_input/OrfPathHealth/GlobalVaccineLibrary.pdf|1|ac169d2f7ba94e499cac064424d51111
"14Accelerating Global Health: Pathways to Health Equity for the G20
15What if humanity could get itself a similar head start against any viral
threat—known or unknown, novel or re-emerging? What if we could get
ahead of any infectious pathogen with the potential to cause a serious
and deadly epidemic? Doing that would give us a far better chance of
winning the containment race against an emerging virus and of controlling
a nascent pandemic before it is able to spread across the world.
A Proposed ‘One World Vaccine Library’
At the Coalition for Epidemic Preparedness Innovations (CEPI), of which
the authors of this essay are part, we have a concept for how the world
could do just this—by creating and stocking a library of knowledge, data
and prototype vaccines against every one of the viral families we already
know have the potential to cause human disease outbreaks. CEPI calls this
the ‘One World Vaccine Library’—a vaccine library for the whole world that
will help the global community achieve greater health security by being
better prepared to beat the next pandemic threat, wherever it emerges, and
whatever form it takes.
Vaccines are among the most potent tools against pandemic threats and
will be critical to any future response to dangerous and deadly outbreaks
of infectious disease. The faster an effective vaccine can be developed and
deployed, the faster it can be used to mitigate and potentially contain an"|data_input/OrfPathHealth/GlobalVaccineLibrary.pdf|2|45c5d935196b4e8ab17e7b96fcbf2818
"deployed, the faster it can be used to mitigate and potentially contain an
incipient pandemic. This is why we need to work on getting those head
starts against as many as possible of our potential opponents.
Getting ahead of any potential viral threat, known or unknown, can at first
sound like an impossible task. There are between 250 and 300 viruses
from around 25 viral families that are already known to have the ability
to infect people, and the world’s scientists cannot create new vaccines
against every one of them, just on a chance that they might one day pose
a deadly threat.
Yet the beauty of a One World Vaccine Library is that we do not need to.
As those several hundred viruses all come from just 25 families, scientists
can take a viral-family-based prototype vaccine approach to preparing
the world’s defences against them. They can gather knowledge, scientific"|data_input/OrfPathHealth/GlobalVaccineLibrary.pdf|2|d44f7d2a0db640ff9c3ff89ee5b3668c
"15A Global Vaccine Libraryinsights and research data on a selection of representative viruses from
each family and create vaccines that target their most common threatening
features. That way, the world will have a bank of detailed fundamental
knowledge about the threats posed by these virus families.
As things currently stand, scientists have already made meaningful
progress—proven safe and effective vaccines are available against scores of
viruses that come from and represent at least 15 of the 25 virus families.
For the One World Vaccine Library to be able to help the world respond
at speed to a newly emerging threat, however, those vaccines will need to
be transferred onto so-called rapid response platforms—technologies like
mRNA platforms or viral vector platforms that can be rapidly scaled up to
allow for hundreds of millions of doses to be produced within months if
needed.
Beyond that, the library will need to be stocked with data and research and
potential vaccine candidates against viruses that represent all the remaining
families, and its sections on the most threatening virus families must be
filled with as much preparatory work as possible. That way, new vaccine
development will be faster and more efficient, saving precious time, and
potentially lives, that would otherwise be at risk if new vaccines had to be
started from scratch each time a pandemic threat looms.
Take the paramyxoviruses, for example. The paramyxovirus family includes"|data_input/OrfPathHealth/GlobalVaccineLibrary.pdf|3|ec6c0366c902440a8d382c1a5bfe0978
"started from scratch each time a pandemic threat looms.
Take the paramyxoviruses, for example. The paramyxovirus family includes
a number of well-known human disease threats, including measles and
mumps, as well as several less well-known ones, such as Hendra and
Nipah.
If the aim is to make similarly fast—indeed, ideally, faster—progress
against a future emerging novel paramyxovirus threat as was made in 2020
with the novel coronavirus, the One World Vaccine Library’s paramyxovirus
section should be stocked with as much research, data and technical
knowledge about how to design and make effective vaccines against the
known and closely related viruses in that family.
In other words, the library will collate scientific knowledge and prototype
rapid-response vaccine candidates for measles, mumps, Nipah, Hendra and"|data_input/OrfPathHealth/GlobalVaccineLibrary.pdf|3|b0476594560848e5a8e36df2397bc0ea
"16Accelerating Global Health: Pathways to Health Equity for the G20
17other known paramyxoviruses. If and when a novel paramyxovirus emerges
and begins to infect people in a fast-spreading outbreak, the library can
be accessed for knowledge that can help rapidly create vaccines or other
medical countermeasures to prevent that spread as much and as soon as
possible.
An Ambitious Yet Achievable Global Endeavour
Building a One World Vaccine Library and stocking it to its fullest possible
capacity is a substantial task and will require sustained investment of time,
effort and money. Such a Library, however, will mean the fruits of human
ingenuity—the benefits of scientific progress—can potentially be made
available to all, whenever and wherever they are needed. It will mean that
when the next viral pandemic threat emerges—whether it is a known virus
or a novel one—humanity will have the knowledge and the technology to
develop vaccines and other medical defences far more swiftly than it has
ever done before.
Researchers assessing a new outbreak and the virus causing it, wherever
and whenever it occurs, will be able within days and weeks to sequence
its genome, match it against related viruses and select prototype vaccines
from the library to develop and deploy new vaccines against the epidemic
or pandemic threat.
CEPI’s current work includes prioritising the development and stocking
of sections of the One World Vaccine Library for the virus families that"|data_input/OrfPathHealth/GlobalVaccineLibrary.pdf|4|752aaba01d014b229677ddfa9be7e095
"CEPI’s current work includes prioritising the development and stocking
of sections of the One World Vaccine Library for the virus families that
pose the greatest and most urgent threats to global health security. CEPI
is engaging virus experts to systematically rank each family to assess
its potential to spawn the next Disease X. For each family selected,
the aim is to create vaccine candidates for at least one and potentially
several different viruses, depending on the family’s complexity and genetic
diversity. Vaccines in the library will be taken through preclinical and
early-stage clinical testing to build vital knowledge about the safety and
immunogenicity of both the platform and the antigens they target. The
larger goal is to establish clinical proof of concept for the lead candidates
in multiple families over the next five years."|data_input/OrfPathHealth/GlobalVaccineLibrary.pdf|4|2b40e9b8f0d24ea9bf8b24f342c9a7d1
"17A Global Vaccine LibraryThe ‘100 Days Mission’ and the Need for Speed
Creating and stocking a One World Vaccine Library is a critical enabler of
CEPI’s 100 Days Mission, embraced by the G7 and the G20, to compress
the development timeline for new vaccines against emerging disease threats
to 100 days. Coupled with improved surveillance providing earlier detection
and warning of potential viral disease threats, and with swift and effective
use of non-pharmaceutical interventions such as testing, contact tracing
and social distancing to suppress disease transmission, delivering an
effective new vaccine within 100 days would give the world a real chance
to extinguish the existential threat posed by a future Disease X pandemic
virus.
The head starts in these viral races—and there are sure to be ever more
frequent ones in this era of novel epidemic threats—will come from having
a One World Vaccine Library that is comprehensive and extensive and,
crucially, immediately accessible to all nations and regions whenever they
need it. As the bank of knowledge builds up in the library, so too, does
the potential for scientists to significantly accelerate vaccine development
against a wide and growing range of virus families over time.
Like the 100 Days Mission, the ambition of creating a One World Vaccine
Library is a bold one. It is also an essentially equitable one that seeks
to help people across the world bolster their defences against the ever-"|data_input/OrfPathHealth/GlobalVaccineLibrary.pdf|5|866dcc7ae951407e81247418bfc9ded3
"Library is a bold one. It is also an essentially equitable one that seeks
to help people across the world bolster their defences against the ever-
increasing risk of viral infectious diseases.
Building and stocking the library will take the combined resources, will,
and ingenuity of the world’s best scientific minds, political leaders and
health security experts. In return, the library’s evolving knowledge and
increasingly sophisticated contents will be a living gift from generation
to generation: the prospect of a future free from the deadly threat of
pandemics.
Dr. Richard Hatchett is Chief Executive Officer of the Coalition for Epidemic
Preparedness Innovations (CEPI).
Kate Kelland is CEPI’s Chief Scientific Writer."|data_input/OrfPathHealth/GlobalVaccineLibrary.pdf|5|a6893ff6377a470b8c4d24061e062736
"161
160161Investing in the Public
Health Workforce:
Reflections for the G20
Wenzhen Zuo, Huan Xu, Lizzie Tecson, Bettina Borisch, Sadaf Lynnes,
Laura Magaña, Priscilla Robinson, Duncan Selbie, and Jim Campbell
Public health workers are the backbone of the public health system
and a determining factor in the capacity for emergency preparedness
and response. The COVID-19 pandemic tested and exposed the weaknesses
in core public health capacities around the world,1,2 which are often the
result of decades of underfunding and lack of political commitment to
public health.3,4 Alongside the number of confirmed deaths from COVID-19,
there was increased mortality and morbidity due to the severe disruptions
in essential health services, including preventive care such as routine
immunisation.5,6 The inadequate preparedness of many health systems to
respond to disease outbreaks partly explains these outcomes.7 However, the
limited availability of the health workforce was the critical bottleneck.8,9
This was largely due to longstanding workforce shortages that were
exacerbated by COVID-19 infections and deaths among health workers; the
burden placed upon them, which resulted in mental health issues, including
burnout; and poor working conditions.10,11
The world is also burdened with other public health emergencies,
including protracted conflicts and a global increase in climate-related and"|data_input/OrfPathHealth/InvestingInPublicHealthWorkforce.pdf|0|11488b72ecf34335b62473afa88f1450
"The world is also burdened with other public health emergencies,
including protracted conflicts and a global increase in climate-related and
humanitarian disasters. These have collectively contributed to a public health
crisis, with reversals in life expectancy and Sustainable Development Goals"|data_input/OrfPathHealth/InvestingInPublicHealthWorkforce.pdf|0|b82e440ece464069a77bf88f9e5ada99
"161Investing in the Public Health Workforce
161targets.12,13 These reversals and the increasing likelihood of multi-hazards
and future emergencies stress the imperative for strengthening national
health systems through investment in the 12 Essential Public Health
Functiona (EPHF) through an all-hazards emergency risk management
approach.14 Strengthening the quantity and quality of the national public
health workforce capacity to deliver these EPHFs is essential15 and requires
political leadership as well as global investment
There was the emergence of a global consensus to strengthen public health
during the pandemic, as evident in the political and technical consensus
within the G7 and G20 intergovernmental processes from 2021 to 2023.16
This contributed to an iterative process coordinated by the World Health
Organization (WHO) along with a global partnership of associations,
institutions, and schools of public health (as represented by their national,
regional, and global bodies)b to jointly develop and endorse a WHO Roadmap
to strengthen national public health and emergency workforces.17
The G20’s and G7’s Role in Strengthening Public Health
and Emergency Workforces
Both the G20 and the G7 processes have historically incorporated public
health within their intergovernmental deliberations, aiming to address
pressing global health challenges and foster international cooperation
amongst member and partner countries. This was reinforced during the"|data_input/OrfPathHealth/InvestingInPublicHealthWorkforce.pdf|1|62d9f40cfb654006a0859c0ef5ed39ee
"pressing global health challenges and foster international cooperation
amongst member and partner countries. This was reinforced during the
COVID-19 pandemic, where both the G20 and the G7 platforms tabled
agenda items on public health for consideration in the Health Ministers
and Heads of State meetings.
a The EPHFs are a set of interconnected activities both within and beyond the health sector
that are required to ensure effective public health action to prevent disease and promote and
protect health and well-being.
b Including the World Federation of Public Health Associations (WFPHA), International
Association of National Public Health Institutions (IANPHI) and Global Network Academic
Schools of Public Health (GNASPH)."|data_input/OrfPathHealth/InvestingInPublicHealthWorkforce.pdf|1|1be624b611cc491db7d1687100ae5d34
"162Accelerating Global Health: Pathways to Health Equity for the G20
163G20 and G7 Deliberations on Public Health (2021–2023)
G20 Italy, 2021
In May 2021, the G20 and invited leaders, heads of international and
regional organisations, and representatives of global health bodies gathered
in Rome for the Global Health Summit that culminated in the Rome
Declaration.18 This political declaration recognised the impacts of the
pandemic, the reversal of public health gains, and the sacrifices from
the health and care workforce. The Rome Declaration set out a global
consensus which subsequently informed the G20 Italia Declaration of
Health Ministers in September 2021,19 where investment in health systems
and public health workforce strengthening was identified as a prerequisite
for countries to improve future pandemic preparedness and response. The
declaration affirmed the role of political consensus in strengthening the
health workforce. It highlighted the need to protect workers and invest
in their education, employment, and retention, including to strengthen
multidisciplinary teams to better respond to future emergencies and deliver
the essential functions in “health care system and preventive care”.20
G7 United Kingdom, 2021
In June 2021, the Carbis Bay Health Declaration21 was signed at the G7
Summit in Cornwall, United Kingdom. The primary objective of the G7
Summit 2021 was to bring the world’s leading democracies together to fight"|data_input/OrfPathHealth/InvestingInPublicHealthWorkforce.pdf|2|17c2b5995f3d4131bd1c7f8cd1aea347
"Summit in Cornwall, United Kingdom. The primary objective of the G7
Summit 2021 was to bring the world’s leading democracies together to fight
COVID-19 and build a greener, more prosperous future. The G7 summit
recognised the contributions and commitment of health and care workers
and highlighted the importance of maintaining a health workforce that
can adapt to changing circumstances. Training, supporting, and protecting
health and care workers were important aspects of the discussion.
G7 Germany, 2022
Germany’s presidency of the G7 built upon Italy’s legacy on essential public
health functions by diving deeper into pandemic preparedness and response.
On 19 May 2022, the G7 ministers met in Berlin and launched the G7 Pact
for Pandemic Readiness,22,23 which focuses on strengthening collaborative
surveillance in low- and lower-middle income countries (LMICs) and"|data_input/OrfPathHealth/InvestingInPublicHealthWorkforce.pdf|2|680110c39c674b5695eef6dc5c29a063
"163Investing in the Public Health Workforcepredictable rapid “regional and global surge readiness groups”.24 This focus
on pandemic preparedness and response demonstrated alignment with
similar deliberations among WHO member states in Strengthening the Global
Architecture for Health Emergency Preparedness and Response (HEPR).25 The
HEPR structures a new global health architecture around health emergency
governance,c systems, and financing, applying the principles of EPHFs at a
global level. Supporting the global health architecture, the G7’s Roadmap
for Practical Cooperation to Advance the G7 Pact26 committed to help 100
countries strengthen their International Health Regulation (IHR 2005) core
capacities.d
G20 Indonesia, 2022
G20 in Indonesia continued to advance the global health architecture for
emergency preparedness and response by launching the Pandemic Fund.27
The fund aims to strengthen countries’ pandemic prevention, preparedness,
and response (PPR) capacities by addressing capacity and capability gaps.
The Pandemic Fund further aims to catalyse investment in critical health
workforce capacities and in health systems to strengthen synergies between
the health system and pandemic PPR capacity at country and local levels
in core domains of the IHR 2005 and the World Organisation for Animal
Health’s (WOAH) international standards. It is estimated that there is
a need for US$10 billion per year of international funding to cover the"|data_input/OrfPathHealth/InvestingInPublicHealthWorkforce.pdf|3|5ffa8a052fda4a48832954cb28fccad6
"Health’s (WOAH) international standards. It is estimated that there is
a need for US$10 billion per year of international funding to cover the
catalytic funding for systemic preparedness required in LMICs.e
c Under the governance part of HEPR, it contains the ongoing Intergovernmental Negotiating
Body on new WHO convention, agreement, or other international instrument on PPR (WHO
CA+) and International Health Regulation amendments.
d IHR core capacities: described in IHR 2005’s Annex 1, the core capacities for surveillance and
responses require public health capacities ranging from the local community and primary
public health level all up until the national public health leadership level. In the voluntary
Joint External Evaluation tool to assess the IHR 2005 capacities, the highest scores for IHR
capacities as human resources are given to countries who have a national multisectoral
skilled and competent health personnel for sustainable and functional public health
surveillance and response at all levels of the health system.
e Worth noting that the Pandemic Fund, as of May 2023, had received a pledge of just 10% of
the annual amount needed from donors and foreign aid from the main G20 countries."|data_input/OrfPathHealth/InvestingInPublicHealthWorkforce.pdf|3|87486127dc55458db953d30ad3b03b4d
"164Accelerating Global Health: Pathways to Health Equity for the G20
165G7 Japan, 2023
The G7 in Japan further reaffirmed the prevailing health consensus to
strengthen the national Public Health and Emergency Workforce in the
G7 Global Plan for UHC Action Agenda.28 Action area 8 of the UHC Action
Agenda specifically addresses UHC and health security by strengthening all
EPHFs and to “support well-trained workforce to deliver the EPHF in line
with WHO Roadmap”.29 The Action Agenda also advocates for investing,
protecting, educating, and employing the entire health and care workforce
while also recognising the importance of strengthening the public health
workforce.
The G7 leaders supported the development of global network of experts,
including their trainings, and committed to work together to implement IHR
core capacities in 100 LMICs until 2027, echoing the 2022 commitment at
G7 Germany. To achieve UHC and health security, G7 Japan also announced
the launch of the Impact Investment Initiative for Global Health,30 in
time for the United Nations’ three High-Level Meetings (HLM) on UHC,
tuberculosis, and pandemic preparedness and response. This initiative
prioritises investment in impactful initiatives and capacity building in the
Global South for non-communicable and communicable diseases, PPR, and
to “restore of essential health services to better than pre-pandemic level”.31
Emerging Consensus for WHO and Partners’ Roadmap for
Public Health Workforce"|data_input/OrfPathHealth/InvestingInPublicHealthWorkforce.pdf|4|529770bb53184afba32ffa3ad3fa81f1
"Emerging Consensus for WHO and Partners’ Roadmap for
Public Health Workforce
The public health momentum from the G20 and the G7 processes enabled
renewed dialogue on public health, the 12 essential public health functions
that are typically prevalent across all countries, and the public health
workforce required to deliver these functions. Building on the political call
for action during Italy’s G20 presidency and resolutions adopted in the
World Health Assembly,32,33,34,35 WHO convened and worked with its partners
to jointly develop and launch a roadmap and an action plan36 on national
public health workforce capacity to deliver all EPHFs, including emergency
preparedness and response. The public health workforce encompasses core
public health personnel and professionals, health and care workers who
perform at least one of the essential public health functions, and all"|data_input/OrfPathHealth/InvestingInPublicHealthWorkforce.pdf|4|54fad894a7294d1c9d84ce0c7cc9d868
"165Investing in the Public Health Workforceoccupations outside of the health sector that contribute to public health
(e.g., water, sanitation, social determinants).37,38
Global partners on the roadmap and action plan have jointly developed
reference documents and tools for countries of all income classifications to
assess their public health workforce against the standard EPHF and their
individual public health priorities.39 T h e a s s e s s m e n t i s u n d e r p i n n e d b y a
whole-of-government and whole-of-society approach that involves national
stakeholders and existing national and global networks of partners of the
roadmap, including associations, institutions, and schools of public health.
This country-based assessment will ultimately guide policy improvement
and address gaps in national public health workforce planning, delivery,
and competency-based education curricula in order to bolster national
workforce capacity and readiness for all current and future public health
needs.
The above tools are timely additions to support national assessments and
benchmarking. The G20 support to invest in preparedness and national
capacity contributed to the launch of the World Bank’s Pandemic Fund in
November 2022. In its first call for submissions, strengthening human
resources to help countries prevent, prepare for, and respond to health
emergencies was highlighted as a priority.40 This indicates an opportunity"|data_input/OrfPathHealth/InvestingInPublicHealthWorkforce.pdf|5|d0f37eee53de40eb86a850883db49084
"resources to help countries prevent, prepare for, and respond to health
emergencies was highlighted as a priority.40 This indicates an opportunity
to prioritise sustainable public health workforce capacity in LMICs.
The roadmap also assists in alignment with the ongoing governance
processes of IHR 2005 amendments and negotiations on a global pandemic
accord, the Intergovernmental Negotiating Body (INB) on a new WHO
convention, agreement, or other international instruments on PPR (WHO
CA+).f
f Under the governance part of HEPR, it contains the ongoing Intergovernmental Negotiating
Body on new WHO convention, agreement, or other international instrument on PPR (WHO
CA+) and International Health Regulation amendments."|data_input/OrfPathHealth/InvestingInPublicHealthWorkforce.pdf|5|5b43a574fd4f40b5a10d4d9081c9448a
"166Accelerating Global Health: Pathways to Health Equity for the G20
167The Role of India’s G20 Presidency
The intergovernmental consensus and commitment for public health
strengthening has evolved over the last three years, and in mid-2023,
there was a window of opportunity to convert consensus into national
actions that address public health workforce needs. The G20 in India has
signalled the development cooperation for SDGs and the global health
architecture for PPR as important priorities for the Indian presidency.41,42 It
also presents an opportunity for India to amplify public health workforce
strengthening from the perspective of developing countries, ensuring that
multilateral investment is leveraged to strengthen public health workforce
across LMICs. This might present an attractive legacy agenda in 2024 when
Brazil assumes the G20 and would likely resonate with Italy’s G7.
Elements for reflection might therefore include the role of G20 stakeholders
and partners to:
• Expand domestic financing to strengthen national health system capacity
and the respective public health workforce to deliver all essential
health services and public health functions, including health emergency
preparedness and response.
• Expand international financing to support the LMICs in national public
health and health system strengthening, as committed by the G7
Germany in the Roadmap to PPR in 2022 and G7 Japan."|data_input/OrfPathHealth/InvestingInPublicHealthWorkforce.pdf|6|1674d91ad4154cee9c2bfc7bbc26a5cd
"health and health system strengthening, as committed by the G7
Germany in the Roadmap to PPR in 2022 and G7 Japan.
• Capitalise and leverage the proposed Impact Investment Initiative for
Global Health and the Pandemic Fund to meet demand.
• Strengthen and position the G20 consensus language on protecting and
investing in the public health workforce, consistent with the Italy G20
language and recommendations from the 5th Global Forum on Human
Resources for Health.
• Strengthen and position the G20 consensus language in the preparations
and outcomes for the UN HLM for PPR in New York and the member
state deliberations on the IHR amendments and WHO CA+ in Geneva."|data_input/OrfPathHealth/InvestingInPublicHealthWorkforce.pdf|6|7a6b19e8970147368367270706392a50
"167Investing in the Public Health Workforce• Strengthen and position gender inequality as a systemic issue to
contribute to an enabling environment for women’s economic and social
rights by gender-equitable policy for the health sector and beyond.43
Wenzhen (Jen) Zuo , Family Physician - Hospitalist / Glob al Health Consultant, World
Health Organization.
Huan Xu, Technical Officer, Health Workforce Department, World Health Organization;
Lead, General coordination of the Public health and emergency workforce roadmap.
Lizzie Tecson, Programme Officer at the Health Workforce Department, World Health
Organization; Co-lead, General coordination of Public health and emergency workforce
roadmap.
Bettina Borisch, Professor at the University of Geneva and Executive Director of the
World Federation of Public Health Associations(WFPHA).
Sadaf Lynes, Director of Collaborative Surveillance workforce and health
emergencies, International Association of National Public Health Institutes (IANPHI).
Laura Magaña, President & CEO of the Association of Schools and Programs of Public
Health (ASPPH); co-chair, Competency b ased education, Public health and emergency
workforce roadmap.
Priscilla Robinson, Adjunct Associate Professor at LaT robe University; co-chair,
Competency based education, Public health and emergency workforce roadmap.
Duncan Selbie, President, International Association of National Public Health Institutes
(IANPHI)."|data_input/OrfPathHealth/InvestingInPublicHealthWorkforce.pdf|7|2ab4e315dc444a4ea4484a0a2bcaccdb
"Duncan Selbie, President, International Association of National Public Health Institutes
(IANPHI).
Jim Campbell, Director, Health Workforce Department, World Health Organization."|data_input/OrfPathHealth/InvestingInPublicHealthWorkforce.pdf|7|5fa3147f3d21436e88b0f3e51e257757
"49
4849Soumya Swaminathan and Priyadarshini RajamaniBridging the Divide:
Advancing ‘One Health’ for a
Better World
Human health is interconnected with the ecosystem that consists
of animals, plants, and the environment. As such, any health
intervention should be integrative of these connecting factors. ‘One Health’
(OH) is a holistic approach that considers all the determinants of health,
designed for disease prevention and control. It is a transdisciplinary
approach that allows multisectoral collaboration and deals with antimicrobial
resistance and the prevention and control of zoonoses and vector-, food-
and water-borne diseases.
Since 2022, the Quadripartite collaboration between the World Health
Organization, Food and Agriculture Organization, United Nations Environment
Programme, and World Organisation for Animal Health has been responsible
for OH operations, guiding countries in planning and adapting strategies
for addressing global health challenges. Implementing OH will enhance
pandemic prevention, preparedness, and response, and will also enable the
strengthening of domestic health systems, including in India."|data_input/OrfPathHealth/BridgingTheDivide.pdf|0|8cb396872001467fa610927f2b7ca3b1
"49Advancing ‘One Health’ for a Better World
49Deconstructing ‘One Health’
The World Health Organization (WHO) defines ‘One Health’ (OH) as
“an integrated, unifying approach that aims to sustainably balance and
optimize the health of people, animals, and ecosystems.”1 In addition to an
individual’s characteristics and behavioural patterns, social, economic and
physical environments are important determinants of health, and include
a variety of factors such as water, air, animals, plants, housing, and
jobs. Animal trade, agriculture, livestock farming, urbanisation, extractive
industries, climate change, habitat fragmentation, and encroachment into
wild areas are some of the factors that can impact human health. It is
essential to consider the possible interactions of these factors with an
individual’s health to achieve optimal health outcomes. Therefore, no health
intervention can be designed and implemented with the consideration of the
health sector alone. There should be multisectoral inclusivity in addressing
any health-related issues. For example, antimicrobial resistance (AMR)
cannot be addressed only through medical intervention and also requires
the checking of antibacterial content in food and water.
The OH concept encourages a collaborative, multisectoral, and
transdisciplinary approach at the local, regional, national, and global levels.
It recognises the interconnection between people, animals, plants, and their"|data_input/OrfPathHealth/BridgingTheDivide.pdf|1|f907599a09644db7ae6534847f11b19a
"It recognises the interconnection between people, animals, plants, and their
shared environment to achieve optimal health outcomes, and it encourages
experts from multiple sectors to work together. Under the OH concept,
policy, advocacy, financing, organisational development, data, evidence, and
knowledge are focused on providing sustainable and long-lasting results at
all levels.
The OH concept identifies a range of priority health issues that need the
world’s urgent attention:
Antimicrobial Resistance (AMR)
AMR is one of the greatest threats to human health, food security, and
development. WHO has declared AMR as one of the top 10 global public
health threats that need coordinated and concerted global action.2 By 2050,
there could be nearly 10 million deaths due to AMR each year, and it could
cost the global economy between US$11–444 million.3"|data_input/OrfPathHealth/BridgingTheDivide.pdf|1|dcccb60ee13a48b49d3e99676789581c
"50Accelerating Global Health: Pathways to Health Equity for the G20
51Medicines become ineffective when pathogens undergo structural changes
as a result of increased drug exposure. Misuse or overuse of antimicrobials,
multiplication of pathogens due to unhygienic water and poor sanitation
processes, and inadequate infection prevention and control measures in
hospitals and healthcare settings are some of the other factors that cause
AMR. It also arises due to the use of antibiotics in the farming, livestock,
and fisheries sectors, which enables pathogens infecting these animals to
develop resistance. Close contact with these animals and the contamination
of soil and water with these microbes exposes humans to these bugs.
AMR makes treating infections difficult, leaving patients with limited
treatment options, if at all. In such cases, managing serious infections in
children and adults alongside any surgical intervention becomes a challenge.
Indeed, the global health system is already exposed to drug-resistant
Tuberculosis, HIV infections, and specific AMRs such as artemisinin-based
combination therapy-resistance in malaria treatment, and antileprotic drug
resistance.
Zoonotic diseases
Over the past three decades, around 30 pathogens have been detected, with
75 percent of them originating from animals, causing zoonotic diseases and
contributing to about 60 percent of emerging infectious diseases globally.4"|data_input/OrfPathHealth/BridgingTheDivide.pdf|2|dbd06533e0f8426bb5c48add38e4a7af
"contributing to about 60 percent of emerging infectious diseases globally.4
These diseases can be spread directly through the saliva, blood, urine,
mucous, faeces, or body fluids of infected animals, or indirectly through
contact with areas where animals live and roam as well as through
contaminated objects or surfaces.
Urbanisation and the destruction of the natural habitats of animals, illegal
trade in wildlife, and wet markets increase the chances of interaction
between animals, animal products and humans, thereby increasing the risk
of zoonotic disease and contributing to zoonotic spillover. Recent disease
outbreaks such as SARS, MERS, Ebola, Nipah, and avian influenza are
examples of zoonotic infections being established in humans. It is important
to ensure the hygienic and appropriate care of animals in the agriculture
sector, and the safe handling of meat, eggs, dairy, and vegetables to avoid
contamination to prevent outbreaks of food-borne zoonotic diseases."|data_input/OrfPathHealth/BridgingTheDivide.pdf|2|2f884a037acc49378eeae7a7fb414b1e
"51Advancing ‘One Health’ for a Better WorldAddressing zoonotic infectious diseases through an OH approach includes
multiple actions:
• Raising awareness at all levels of society on prevention and risk-
reduction strategies.
• Investing in interdisciplinary approaches including OH perspectives.
• Initiating research to explore the complex social, economic, and ecological
dimensions of diseases; to assess risks and effective interventions; and
to conduct cost-benefit analyses.
• Regularly monitoring food systems, from farm to fork, and improving
sanitary measures.
• Implementing biosecurity and zoonoses-control measures for both
industrial and disadvantaged smallholder farmers and herders.
• Supporting agricultural and wildlife habitats by managing landscapes
and seascapes collectively.
• Promoting agro-ecological methods of food production, mitigating waste
and pollution, reducing further destruction of wildlife and habitat loss,
and maintaining ecological connectivity.
• Being mindful of biodiversity during government and private-sector
planning, decision-making, and capacity building.5
WHO, the Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO), and the World
Organisation for Animal Health (WOAH) have already established the
Global Early Warning and Response System for Major Animal Diseases to
combat zoonoses to coordinate risk assessment and assist in early warning,
prevention, and control of disease threats.6
Vector-borne diseases"|data_input/OrfPathHealth/BridgingTheDivide.pdf|3|cde4a7c94f2f4ca8bd465e9272856a9b
"combat zoonoses to coordinate risk assessment and assist in early warning,
prevention, and control of disease threats.6
Vector-borne diseases
The determining demographic, environmental, and social factors of the
distribution of vector-borne diseases are often complex, such as global
travel, trade, and unplanned urbanisation. WHO’s Global Vector Control
Response (GVCR) 2017–2030 provides strategic guidance to countries for
strengthening vector-control programmes.7"|data_input/OrfPathHealth/BridgingTheDivide.pdf|3|ff8f20fb0aac4191b052993d77f15999
"52Accelerating Global Health: Pathways to Health Equity for the G20
53Water-borne diseases
Drinking or coming in contact with contaminated water causes water-borne
diseases. Faecal-contaminated water is consumed by two billion people
globally, which causes diseases such as cholera, dysentery, typhoid and
polio. These diseases are responsible for around 485,000 deaths every year.8
Food-borne diseases
Over 200 diseases, ranging from diarrhoea to cancers, are caused by
eating or drinking food contaminated with animal or human faecal matter,
chemical substances such as unpasteurised (raw) milk, undercooked meat
or eggs, and raw fruits and vegetables. Globally, 600 million people are
affected by food-borne diseases, in which 420,000 die each year, resulting
in 33 million healthy life years lost. Access to adequate safe and nutritious
food is key to sustaining life and promoting good health.9
Operationalising ‘One Health’
In April 2022, WHO, FAO, United Nations Environment Programme (UNEP),
and WOAH signed a memorandum of understanding for joint work on OH,
forming the ‘Quadripartite Collaboration for One Health’. The Quadripartite
is a strategic coordination mechanism that aims to work towards “a world
capable of preventing, detecting, containing, eliminating, and responding to animal
and public health risks attributable to zoonoses and animal diseases with an impact
on food security through multi-sectoral cooperation and strong partnerships”.10 The"|data_input/OrfPathHealth/BridgingTheDivide.pdf|4|c28f27b2026346d8b1c25d3ac4fb35f1
"on food security through multi-sectoral cooperation and strong partnerships”.10 The
One Health High-Level Expert Panel comprising 26 key international experts
serves as the advisory group to the Quadripartite. In late 2022, the group
launched the first One Health Joint Plan of Action (2022-2026) to combat
health risks at the human–animal–environment interface.11
The Quadripartite has urged all countries to translate the OH approach
into policy actions by promoting and increasing investment in intersectoral
health governance. Countries are encouraged to adopt national OH policies,
and create and exchange research on OH. Research institutions can be
encouraged to work on improved genomic surveillance and data-sharing
practices. Academic courses on OH can help train and equip a workforce."|data_input/OrfPathHealth/BridgingTheDivide.pdf|4|3eb3f6d6d48542a68f240d92f26cae0b
"53Advancing ‘One Health’ for a Better WorldSince the OH approach is similar to pandemic prevention and preparedness,
resources allocated for the latter can also be utilised for operationalising
OH. For instance, the World Bank’s US$10-billion fund for pandemic
prevention can be used to implement the OH approach. Additionally,
the UN’s high-level meeting on pandemic prevention, preparedness, and
response (scheduled for September 2023) is an opportunity to integrate the
OH agenda into the pandemic action plan.
According to the World Bank, between US$10.3-11.5 billion is needed
annually to implement OH at a global scale.12 But the lack of centralised
OH funding is a challenge, leaving relevant ministries in each country to
assume the responsibility for implementing necessary actions and activities.
This hinders the development of effective global OH strategies.
WHO has identified several other existing gaps in the implementation of
the OH approach.13 These gaps are evident in the following areas:
• Databases and knowledge-sharing resources for effective information
exchange.
• Showcasing best practice examples to encourage successful OH initiatives.
• Mapping and generating an OH workforce to strengthen capacity.
• Developing a model for an integrated OH surveillance system.
• Establishing routine and emergency coordination mechanisms with
stakeholders.
• Creating a standardised framework for addressing zoonotic spillover"|data_input/OrfPathHealth/BridgingTheDivide.pdf|5|acb5a4d42cd747a5bb0bf5035f6a2d56
"stakeholders.
• Creating a standardised framework for addressing zoonotic spillover
risks related to animal trade, agriculture, and livestock farming.
• Addressing issues related to urbanisation and habitat fragmentation.
• Identifying spillover risks and disease spread in ways that minimise
trade-offs and maximise co-benefits.
‘One Health’ in the G20 countries14
The G20 countries can play a key role in improving global health, for
various reasons—the member countries are among the world’s largest
economies, they are home to roughly two-thirds of the global population"|data_input/OrfPathHealth/BridgingTheDivide.pdf|5|54b6a818f27a4747bc848ce2b3fca069
"54Accelerating Global Health: Pathways to Health Equity for the G20
55(including the majority of the ageing population), they house 78 percent
of the world’s pharmaceutical companies, see a high prevalence of non-
communicable diseases (and account for nearly 70 percent of proportional
mortality from such diseases), and contribute 72 percent of all CO2
emissions.15 T h e G 2 0 c o u n t r i e s a g r e e d t o a d o p t O H a t t h e 2 0 2 2 S u m m i t .16
India has already made headway on this front.
One Health approach in India17
The Indian government initiated the OH approach under the office of
the Principal Scientific Adviser (PSA) with the aim to increase pandemic
preparedness and integrated disease control against priority diseases in
both human and animal sectors. A supplementary goal includes establishing
an early warning system built on an integrated surveillance system and
response-readiness for endemic and emerging epidemic or pandemic threats.
The country has also sought to implement integrated disease surveillance,
build environmental surveillance systems, and develop robust outbreak
investigation mechanisms. The OH mission will also focus on:
•Targeted R&D to develop critical tools such as vaccines, diagnostics,
therapeutics, and other prevention tools, and to invest in developing
novel disease surveillance and control methodologies.
•Data and database integration for better information sharing across"|data_input/OrfPathHealth/BridgingTheDivide.pdf|6|11443940fbd24182af4b70641327ab56
"novel disease surveillance and control methodologies.
•Data and database integration for better information sharing across
different departments, and investing in analytics for better tracking of
national-level progress and implementation at the local level.
•Streamlining regulatory and approval processes for enabling OH research
and for rapid decision-making.
•Building a governance model for integrating OH into existing
programmes for system strengthening, sustainability and resource
allocation for maximising outcomes.
India has also established a One Health Centre at the National Institute
of Animal Biotechnology, Hyderabad, for intersectoral collaboration among
veterinary, medical, agriculture, environmental, forestry, meteorological and"|data_input/OrfPathHealth/BridgingTheDivide.pdf|6|b0b09c253eda45308d9818f8747a02a8
"55Advancing ‘One Health’ for a Better Worldother areas to detect, prevent and control zoonoses and transboundary
animal diseases.18
In 2008, an attempt to operationalise the OH approach for zoonotic
disease control and prevention identified the barriers preventing effective
cross-sectoral collaboration on disease control.19 These included a lack
of supportive policies, conflicting departmental priorities and limited
institutional capacities. A review of zoonotic policy documents revealed
there is a lack of specific mechanisms or strategies to safeguard livestock
health, and a lack of guidelines for promoting cross-sectoral action. It also
revealed a lack of clarity and inadequate information regarding engagement
in the animal and forest sectors. This study found that implementing the
OH approach in India requires contextual adaptation based on the underlying
sociopolitical, institutional, and cultural contexts.20
Given India’s diverse context, the way forward involves developing strategies
that focus on fostering existing informal interpersonal relationships and
collaborations between different sectors to successfully adopt the OH
approach. It also requires intersectoral coordination at all levels, including
the veterinary workforce, academic institutions, and the local or grassroots
population. For instance, to conduct the SARS-CoV2 vaccine trial, the Tamil
Nadu Veterinary and Animal Sciences University signed a pact with the"|data_input/OrfPathHealth/BridgingTheDivide.pdf|7|95e9919de1de4544bc48124bd30a8a42
"population. For instance, to conduct the SARS-CoV2 vaccine trial, the Tamil
Nadu Veterinary and Animal Sciences University signed a pact with the
Tamil Nadu Dr MGR Medical University for conducting joint academic and
research activities. Similarly, during an outbreak investigation in Punjab,
community health workers, non-government organisations, auxiliary nursing
midwives, accredited social health activists (or ASHAs) and village leaders
actively participated in efforts to address vaccine hesitancy.21
Conclusion
Implementing the OH approach will enhance pandemic prevention,
preparedness, and response. It will also strengthen systems and cross-
sectoral capacities, allowing for the co-design and implementation of
inclusive and equitable multi-level workplans and strategies in line with
OH principles. It is essential to develop, disseminate, and utilise improved
and harmonised OH tools, technologies, and practices that integrate data
and knowledge to prevention of future pandemics, reduce the spread"|data_input/OrfPathHealth/BridgingTheDivide.pdf|7|ba6d12617e9d4d3da1a5a071f7087ae7
"56Accelerating Global Health: Pathways to Health Equity for the G20
57of infectious diseases through better surveillance systems, and boost
collaboration between different organisations.
India’s G20 theme of ‘One Earth, One Family, One Future’ highlights that
global collaboration and solidarity is needed to live harmoniously with
nature and to ensure health and well-being for all people, everywhere.
Dr Soumya Swaminathan is Chairperson, MS Swaminathan Research Foundation and
Former Chief Scientist, World Health Organization.
Dr Priyadarshini Rajamani is a consultant with the MS Swaminathan Research
Foundation."|data_input/OrfPathHealth/BridgingTheDivide.pdf|8|763c7ccbb18c440fae959857c92fe260
"82Accelerating Global Health: Pathways to Health Equity for the G20
83Building a Resilient
Digital Health
Ecosystem in India
Lav Agarwal
Technology now permeates every facet of human existence. From
communication and transportation to healthcare and entertainment,
technology has redefined how we live, work, and interact. Its omnipresence
is reshaping societal norms, revolutionising various sectors, and propelling
us into the future.
Through improvements in diagnostics, treatment, and patient care,
technological advancements have had a profound impact on healthcare.
Medical devices, telemedicine, electronic health records, and artificial
intelligence (AI)-driven diagnostics have transformed healthcare delivery by
making it more precise, efficient, and accessible. Wearable devices and health
apps have empowered individuals to monitor and manage their well-being
proactively. Technology has also played a crucial role in advancing medical
research, discovering new treatments, and improving overall healthcare
outcomes. In response to the COVID-19 pandemic, the world witnessed the
exponential growth of digital health."|data_input/OrfPathHealth/BuildingResilientDigitalHealthIndia.pdf|0|d2a4917ce8cf48d69608d55e8bdeefd7
"83Building a Resilient Digital Health Ecosystem in India Digital Health Landscape in India
Given India’s massive population, providing equitable access to healthcare
services to all is an important agenda. By harnessing the power of
technology, digital health can effectively address these challenges and
ensure that healthcare services are accessible even in the remote regions.
Patients can use digital platforms for convenient access to care. Digital
platforms therefore bridge gaps and improve healthcare delivery across the
nation.
In line with the ‘Digital India’ initiative and the vision to create
interoperable and standardised electronic health records across the country,
the Indian government notified the Electronic Health Record1 standards in
2016. The National Health Policy2 (2017) envisages the creation of a digital
health technology ecosystem that serves the needs of all stakeholders and
improves efficiency, transparency, and citizens’ experiences across public
and private healthcare.
Over the recent years, India has made progress in digital healthcare
delivery, as demonstrated in national health programmes such as the
Hospital Management Information System, Online Registration System, the
national tuberculosis elimination (Ni-kshay) programme, Mother and Child
Tracking System, Mera Aspataal (My Hospital, a patient feedback system), the
Health Management Information System, the Integrated Health Information"|data_input/OrfPathHealth/BuildingResilientDigitalHealthIndia.pdf|1|e645ea793f2148328e415470d8fad8f1
"Health Management Information System, the Integrated Health Information
Platform, and Non-Communicable Diseases screening application—which
have benefitted patients through the timely delivery of services and by
making government healthcare more affordable and accessible.3
The need for a future-ready digital health system has become even more
urgent with the announcement of the Ayushman Bharat Pradhan Mantri Jan
Arogya Yojana (AB-PMJAY)4 in 2018, India’s flagship programme that would
herald an infrastructural transformation of the nation’s health system. This
mission envisions the following:
I. Operationalising 1.5 lakh health and wellness centres that offer preventive
and primary care, including telemedicine consultation services; and"|data_input/OrfPathHealth/BuildingResilientDigitalHealthIndia.pdf|1|4e39f83a77424bd29d01a053be2e9e24
"84Accelerating Global Health: Pathways to Health Equity for the G20
85II. Providing financial protection of up to INR 500,000 per family annually
for secondary and tertiary care hospitalisation to the over 120 million
crore poor and vulnerable families that comprise the bottom 40 percent
of the Indian population.
These initiatives aim to scale up a wellness-oriented approach instead
of an illness-focused one—a key step towards achieving universal health
coverage (UHC) through patient data portability across primary, secondary,
and tertiary levels. This essentially translates into an environment where
all people can obtain health services anywhere in the country without
suffering financial hardship or excessive indirect costs.
Achieving such scale requires us to rethink the core technology backbone
of our system and leverage cutting-edge digital solutions to tackle the
challenge. However, it is also felt that all these efforts need to converge into
a single framework to achieve interoperability of data, which would benefit
both policymakers for decision-making and patients with effective services
at the time of need. In response, the government developed the National
Digital Health Blueprint as a framework for the efficient implementation of
digital health treatments.
The Ayushman Bharat Digital Mission5
To implement the principles of the blueprint, the National Digital Health
Mission, now known as the Ayushman Bharat Digital Mission (ABDM), was"|data_input/OrfPathHealth/BuildingResilientDigitalHealthIndia.pdf|2|89b3b356103448bfa7a2ae333c705bc5
"To implement the principles of the blueprint, the National Digital Health
Mission, now known as the Ayushman Bharat Digital Mission (ABDM), was
launched in six union territories in August 2020. It was proposed to be
carried out via six key components—i.e, the digital health ID card, Digi-
Doctor, Health Facility Registry, Personal Health Records, e-pharmacy, and
telemedicine. India launched the nationwide implementation the ABDM in
September 2021 . The ABDM intends to create the framework needed to
enable an integrated digital health infrastructure in India. Additionally, it
will bridge the existing gap amongst different stakeholders of the healthcare
ecosystem through digital highways.
Under the ABDM, every citizen will be provided a 14-digit Ayushman
Bharat Account (ABHA) number, which is a unique health identifier. With
the patient’s informed consent, the ABHAs will be used to identify and"|data_input/OrfPathHealth/BuildingResilientDigitalHealthIndia.pdf|2|728cd64802bb4f528a5671ab9a58f407
"85Building a Resilient Digital Health Ecosystem in India authenticate people’s health records across various systems and stakeholders.
As of July 2023, over 435 million ABHAa numbers have been created, and
214,396 health facilities and 207,274 doctors have been registered under
the ABDM ecosystem.
ABDM has accelerated the participation of various stakeholders of the
healthcare ecosystem and ensured deployment of patient-centric policies—
resulting in cashless care with improved access to ensure protection
for the poor. Given its federal and complex healthcare structure, India
demands agility, flexibility and evidence-based smart policymaking for
implementation of healthcare initiatives, driving all stakeholders towards
health-seeking behaviours with renewed energy.
Digital Health in COVID-19 Management
The COVID-19 pandemic has challenged health systems across the globe.
The India government not only focused on the management of the pandemic
through various activities but also formulated innovative solutions to ensure
the continuity of health services across the spectrum. It has followed a
‘whole of government, whole of society’ approach to battle the pandemic
by engaging subnational and local governments, civil society organisations,
the private sector, and local communities in mitigation efforts.
Amid the pandemic, India recognised the need to ease access to digital
consultations, and issued the Telemedicine Practice Guidelines in March"|data_input/OrfPathHealth/BuildingResilientDigitalHealthIndia.pdf|3|658d7809791142b1bfd0ba47c57bfbbd
"Amid the pandemic, India recognised the need to ease access to digital
consultations, and issued the Telemedicine Practice Guidelines in March
2020. India also launched eSanjeevaniOPD,6 a first of its kind and the
world’s largest national telemedicine service to facilitate online health
facilities to patients in the confines of their home at no cost to ensure
continuum of care. The eSanjeevani initiative has been instrumental in
bridging the digital divide in India, particularly in rural areas where access
to healthcare is often limited. This initiative has completed 142 million
consultationsb in record time and is currently serving around 400,000
patients every day as of 27 July 2023.
a https://dashboard.abdm.gov.in/abdm/
b https://esanjeevani.mohfw.gov.in/#/"|data_input/OrfPathHealth/BuildingResilientDigitalHealthIndia.pdf|3|e7422980e3274bdd888d03252996f332
"86Accelerating Global Health: Pathways to Health Equity for the G20
87India developed another state-of-the-art digital health system, CoWIN,7 a
digital platform that helped more than a billion beneficiaries book COVID-19
vaccinations in less than three months. In less than 18 months, CoWIN
had helped administer two billion COVID-19 vaccination doses, immunising
over 90 percent of all eligible adults.
The establishment of digitally-enabled COVID-19 ‘war rooms’ at the central
and state levels allowed key stakeholders to undertake data-driven decisions
towards infrastructure gap analysis, case projection and management, and
to identify problem areas that required specific state-centre coordination.
Various other digital health initiatives that have enhanced India’s efforts
against the COVID-19 crisis are outlined in the following points:
i. the COVID-19 India Portal developed for disease tracking by geography,
inventory tracking of essential items, and predicting demands at the
national, state, and district levels based on case-loads;
ii. the Aarogya Setu, a mobile tracking app which uses the smartphone's
GPS and Bluetooth features to track the coronavirus infection through
contact tracing, syndromic mapping, and self-assessment in addition to
essential risk communication for our citizens;
iii. the RT-PCR app, a hand-held tool for country-wide sample collection;
and
iv. a COVID-19 facility app which allows health system stakeholders up to"|data_input/OrfPathHealth/BuildingResilientDigitalHealthIndia.pdf|4|77ee5dafaf88492baeedba46dc96add6
"and
iv. a COVID-19 facility app which allows health system stakeholders up to
the district level to track the state and management of patients.
Institutionalising Pandemic Learnings: National Public Health
Observatory (NPHO)
India has established the National Public Health Observatory (NPHO) and
the Health Emergency Operations Centre (HEOC) for real-time monitoring
and analysis of various data points for informed decision-making. The
NPHO will ensure comprehensive monitoring of health systems, including
overall healthcare service delivery, integration of healthcare programmes,
and transformation of the healthcare situation in the country."|data_input/OrfPathHealth/BuildingResilientDigitalHealthIndia.pdf|4|bc7f62f18fed4b8a97382c0aec77ea70
"87Building a Resilient Digital Health Ecosystem in India Leveraging AI for Improved Healthcare
Across the world, AI is being used in healthcare to support doctors and
healthcare workers, improve customer service and patient management, and
monitor diseases. The Indian government has established three centres of
excellence for AI—at the All India Institutes of Medical Sciences in Delhi
and Rishikesh, and at the Post Graduate Institute of Medical Education &
Research in Chandigarh—to leverage and identify potential areas for the
use of AI in the health sector. The centres are already working on several
solutions for healthcare which leverage generative AI, including:
i. a clinical decision support system, a multilingual solution to provide
diagnostic and triaging support to doctors;
ii. event-based disease surveillance to scan large volumes of digital media
in English as well as 10 Indian languages to monitor events that signal
an impending disease outbreak; and
iii. an AI assistant for frontline workers in 11 Indian languages to enable
and empower healthcare workers to ask questions and receive responses
to enhance their work.
Stimulating Advanced Knowledge for Sustainable Health
Management (SAKSHAM) Portal
The inclusive capacity building of health professionals is an important
component to ensure the efficient delivery of healthcare services across
the country. Tele-education has benefitted all fields of education including"|data_input/OrfPathHealth/BuildingResilientDigitalHealthIndia.pdf|5|2daf7051ab3742f9b7751844dc2a9e37
"the country. Tele-education has benefitted all fields of education including
medical education, especially for students in remote areas with limited access
to schools and qualified teachers. Online platforms, video conferencing,
and pre-recorded lectures have facilitated learning for students who were
previously deprived of quality education due to their geographical location.
Keeping this vision in mind, the government has developed a unified and
dedicated online learning and training platform, SAKSHAM,8 to enable
health professionals to receive advanced training without any disruption in
their regular jobs. The portal hosts more than 200 courses on public health
and 150 on clinical practices."|data_input/OrfPathHealth/BuildingResilientDigitalHealthIndia.pdf|5|2aba8c3477ef41a690f6b92cb7aa831d
"88Accelerating Global Health: Pathways to Health Equity for the G20
89With such developments in digital health, India has leapfrogged in terms
of the adoption of digital health in the public sector. This will arguably
lead to the creation of a national digital health ecosystem through wide-
scale adoption of digital tools across the continuum of care, both in the
private and public sectors.
Promoting the Digital Health Agenda Globally
India has emerged as a frontrunner in championing digital health and
in positioning it as a critical agenda at the global level. Recognising
the transformative potential of technology in healthcare, India has
taken proactive steps to harness digital innovations, promote healthcare
accessibility, and drive advancements in the field globally.
India tabled the Digital Health Resolution in the 71st World Health
Assembly in May 2018 at Geneva, which was unanimously adopted by all
the member states of the World Health Organization (WHO). The resolution
highlighted global attention to the potential challenges and opportunities
related to digital health technology and need for close collaboration on the
issue globally. As a follow-up action, WHO has prioritised digital health
agenda by establishing the Department for Digital Health and Innovation in
April 2019 and published the Global Strategy on Digital Health 2020-2025 to
promote healthy lives and well-being for all."|data_input/OrfPathHealth/BuildingResilientDigitalHealthIndia.pdf|6|b38388979c9e43c88e5a5d68a1d37391
"April 2019 and published the Global Strategy on Digital Health 2020-2025 to
promote healthy lives and well-being for all.
India served as Chair of the Global Digital Health Partnership (GDHP,
between 2019 and 2021), which is the world’s largest intergovernmental
and multilateral forum on the issue of digital health. Under India’s
leadership, the GDHP’s membership grew from 14 to 33, including three
international organisations (WHO, Organisation for Economic Co-operation
and Development, and the International Digital Health and AI Research
Collaborative).
India’s G20 Leadership Catalysing Global Health Initiatives
India’s G20 presidency set ambitious goals to address the 21st century’s
greatest challenges such as climate change, food insecurity, the threat of"|data_input/OrfPathHealth/BuildingResilientDigitalHealthIndia.pdf|6|484e082ae5c04d178affe983e61dfcc6
"89Building a Resilient Digital Health Ecosystem in India future pandemics, and other health emergencies by building international
co-operation and strengthening global systems. The pandemic experience
has taught us that preventing and preparing for a health emergency must
always be a top priority at a global level, because when it comes to health,
“no one is safe until everyone is safe.”
Drawing from the lessons from the pandemic, the G20 Health Working
Group set out to catalyse and enervate global health initiatives. Through
four meetings, culminating in the health ministers’ meeting, three main
priorities were discussed:
i. prevention, preparedness, and response to health emergencies with
focus on anti-microbial resistance and ‘One Health’;
ii. strengthening cooperation in the pharmaceutical sector with focus on
availability and access to safe, effective, quality, and affordable medical
countermeasures, namely vaccines, therapeutics, and diagnostics; and
iii. digital health innovations and solutions to aid universal health coverage
and improve healthcare services delivery.
Digital health, the third priority under India’s G20 presidency aims to
leverage the country’s acumen and achievements along with other global
initiatives in the digital health space, and develop innovative digital health
solutions that can be applied across the world. A number of programmes
and projects seeking to develop digital health products are being initiated"|data_input/OrfPathHealth/BuildingResilientDigitalHealthIndia.pdf|7|b51b0fd9a2f14d859d03e650b46b801e
"solutions that can be applied across the world. A number of programmes
and projects seeking to develop digital health products are being initiated
independently. These projects are cumulatively spending billions of dollars
while working on similar aspects.
India’s G20 presidency has aimed to bring them all under the umbrella
of the Global Initiative on Digital Health (GIDH), a network managed by
WHO. The GIDH is an opportunity to create a globally connected digital
health ecosystem, converging worldwide efforts in scaling up commitments
and investments of relevant stakeholders and promotion of digital health
solutions as digital public goods. This will be achieved through coordinated
engagements and implementation aligned with WHO norms, standards, and"|data_input/OrfPathHealth/BuildingResilientDigitalHealthIndia.pdf|7|f59eb11a1aac414eb8c4fd10a67fc2e5
"90Accelerating Global Health: Pathways to Health Equity for the G20
91guidelines, while increasing transparency of resources being allocated to
digital transformation and identifying important gaps in support.
Conclusion
Adopting digital health is no longer a choice. The pandemic has undoubtedly
paved the way for the quick adoption of digital health. Digital health is
propelling the world towards more integrated health systems that are
focused on delivering patient-centred care, improving health outcomes, and
making the best use of healthcare resources. India’s digital health initiatives
such as the ABDM, CoWIN, and eSanjeevani have provided a stimulus to
act in conformity with a globally progressive commitment to health equity.
They have also enabled the country to work towards creating a movement
to enable integration of technology-informed models for universal health
coverage.
Lav Agarwal i s A d d i t i o n a l S e c r e t a r y f o r eHealth, International Health & Collaboration,
Public Health, and G20 at the Ministry of Health and Family Welfare, Government of
India."|data_input/OrfPathHealth/BuildingResilientDigitalHealthIndia.pdf|8|3e8b619797c14053812ade71b8f1d710
"93
9293Lessons from
India’s Digital Public
Infrastructure
Transformation
Sameer Kanwar and Varun Kumar
In today's rapidly evolving digital landscape, many countries are
striving to establish and strengthen digital public infrastructure (DPI)
to harness the transformative power of technology to benefit citizens. India
has emerged as a noteworthy example by successfully using technological
advancements to create robust DPI. It has implemented various initiatives
that mobilise technology for inclusive growth, economic development, and
improved governance. Countries around the world can learn from India’s
experience and achievements to initiate similar digital transformations.
Through the Digital India programme, India is seeking to digitally equip
citizens with access to all government services by improving internet
connectivity and developing online infrastructure. This encompasses three
key areas: (a) establishing a secure digital infrastructure; (b) successfully
delivering digital services; and (c) ensuring that every citizen has access
to the internet. India has also seen an increase in the number of digital
technology users, with an estimated 750 million smartphone users, and a
projected one billion users by 2025.1 This increase has generated demand
for a centralised digital architecture that functions as a single enterprise."|data_input/OrfPathHealth/LessonsIndiaDigitalHealthTfn.pdf|0|f1acb3a152d842edb93b59c44e1a1a29
"93Lessons from India’s Digital Public Infrastructure Transformation
93In 2018, the Ministry of Electronics and Information Technology (MeitY)
created the India Enterprise Architecture (IndEA) framework1 for the adoption
of a whole-of-government enterprise architecture by central ministries,
state departments, and public sector enterprises. Built with a focus on
performance, IndEA offers open standards to promote interoperability
and supports decentralisation. At the same time, it supports both new
(greenfield) and legacy (brownfield) e-governance initiatives. The emphasis
of the IndEA initiative is to enable “One Government – a government
that is least visible but is effective” by implementing the concept of
“virtualisation of departments” to activate synergy.2
Growing digitalisation will lead to the increased generation of data,
and consequently, data protection and ownership must be addressed at
the outset. The Data Empowerment and Protection Architecture (DEPA)
framework, introduced in 2020, seeks to ensure user control over data.
DEPA suggests measures for consent-governed and secure data-sharing
with third-party institutions. Controlled by consent managers, only relevant
user data is plugged in to any private ecosystem and there is no need
to set up bilateral databases.3 This empowers citizens with ownership and
control over their own data and how it is shared.
While DEPA has been flexibly applied in multiple sectors, it has been"|data_input/OrfPathHealth/LessonsIndiaDigitalHealthTfn.pdf|1|844ace5971524f39856818d72304f7c9
"control over their own data and how it is shared.
While DEPA has been flexibly applied in multiple sectors, it has been
particularly well-used as a techno-legal solution in the finance sector.
Since DEPA empowers individuals to securely share their financial data
with banks, insurers, investors, and other stakeholders, its first immediate
benefit has been to encourage competition among private players.
Individuals and small businesses are now able to get loans, insurance, and
other financial products at competitive rates, just by using their digital
footprint. In practice, DEPA works closely with the many layers of India
Stack4—Aadhaar-based e-KYC, Unified Payments Interface (UPI) for cashless
payments, and Aadhaar-based eSign) and uses the Open Credit Enablement
Network to facilitate lending. India Stack has enabled the country to build
its digital infrastructure, especially in establishing a design to improve
private sector service delivery, and has served as India’s digital library,
housing several digital global goods and offering learnings to the world.
Over the last decade, India has taken landmark steps to set in motion its
vision of becoming an inclusive digital economy. This includes establishing"|data_input/OrfPathHealth/LessonsIndiaDigitalHealthTfn.pdf|1|2744d84fd22b428182e2ad368b01f58e
"94Accelerating Global Health: Pathways to Health Equity for the G20
95robust DPI and the facilitation of digital governance by streamlining
roles, accountability, and change management. This encompasses various
components, including digital identification systems, digital payments
systems, and digital service delivery platforms.
Pillars of Digital Public Infrastructure in India
The foundation: Aadhaar5
India's Aadhaar programme, a biometric and face authentication-based
digital identification system, has revolutionised identity verification
and service delivery in the country. Aadhaar has provided a unique
identification number to over 1.3 billion residents of India, enabling access
to essential services such as government subsidies, bank accounts, and
mobile connections. It has enabled the government to streamline service
delivery and eliminate duplication by providing a single digital identity
across multiple sectors. The world can learn from India's approach in
implementing a centralised, secure, and inclusive identification system, that
has facilitated interoperability across service delivery platforms, both public
and private.
Driving financial inclusion: Unified Payments Interface6
India's push to digitise payments has transformed the way financial
transactions are conducted in the country. The implementation of UPI has
created a platform that enables instant money transfers between bank"|data_input/OrfPathHealth/LessonsIndiaDigitalHealthTfn.pdf|2|8507704c71af4046b36f3348692ead0d
"transactions are conducted in the country. The implementation of UPI has
created a platform that enables instant money transfers between bank
accounts. It offers a smartphone-based interface to support seamless,
interoperable, and real-time payments, available on the go. UPI has not only
transformed the way individuals transact but has also provided a significant
boost to the growth of the digital economy. Countries can gather important
lessons from India's experience in fostering a competitive and interoperable
payment ecosystem, which has led to increased financial inclusion, reduced
reliance on cash, and enhanced transparency in transactions.
The number of digital transactions increased by more than three times
from 3 billion in November 2019 to 10 billion by January 2023.7 A 2019"|data_input/OrfPathHealth/LessonsIndiaDigitalHealthTfn.pdf|2|a16a8630ec2e4e6fba026e3265f13a86
"95Lessons from India’s Digital Public Infrastructure Transformation MeitY study noted that under a ‘business as usual’ scenario, India’s
digital economy will grow to US$500 billion by 2025, with the potential
to increase to US$1 trillion.8 In 2021, India had 48.6 billion real-time
payments, as compared to 18.5 billion in China and 8.7 billion in Brazil.9
This is indicative of the ease with which the Indian population has adopted
digital platforms for making payments even if the average value of such
payments may be rather low.
Efficient welfare delivery: Direct Benefit Transfer10
India's Direct Benefit Transfer (DBT) programme is aimed at eliminating
potential leakages in the physical delivery of financial benefits and ensuring
an efficient transfer of welfare to the right beneficiaries. By leveraging
digital payment systems, benefits are directly credited to the beneficiaries’
bank accounts, reducing corruption, eliminating middlemen, and improving
transparency in the transfer of subsidies.11 The enablers for DBT in India
are the Pradhan Mantri Jan-Dhan Yojana, the Jan Dhan-Aadhaar-Mobile
Yojana, and nearly 312 other schemes from 53 ministries across all states
and union territories. More than INR 24,800 billion has been transferred
through the DBT programme since 2013, with INR 6,300 billion transferred
in FY 2021-22 alone. On average, more than 9 million DBT payments were
processed daily in FY 2021-22.12
Citizen-centric services: E-governance13"|data_input/OrfPathHealth/LessonsIndiaDigitalHealthTfn.pdf|3|2df59a2c23fd4299aa5289516d7fe4ca
"in FY 2021-22 alone. On average, more than 9 million DBT payments were
processed daily in FY 2021-22.12
Citizen-centric services: E-governance13
India has leveraged technology to enhance governance and service delivery
through initiatives like Digital India and other e-governance platforms. The
use of digital platforms (or information and communication technologies)
has facilitated efficient and transparent administration, improved the
accessibility of government services, and reduced bureaucratic inefficiencies.
The MyGov platform14 h a s b e e n a c r u c i a l c o n t r i b u t o r t o t r a n s f o r m i n g c i t i z e n -
government interactions. India's approach to digital governance emphasises
citizen-centricity, where technology acts as an enabler to bridge the gap
between the government and its citizens. By adopting similar approaches,
countries can enhance government services, promote transparency, and
strengthen democratic participation."|data_input/OrfPathHealth/LessonsIndiaDigitalHealthTfn.pdf|3|2290c2d7dd6e4fb4bd1dd3b017722e68
"96Accelerating Global Health: Pathways to Health Equity for the G20
97Creating a digital ecosystem: Technology access and innovation
India has created a vibrant digital ecosystem that fosters innovation
and entrepreneurship. Initiatives like Startup India15 a n d M a k e i n I n d i a16
have encouraged the growth of technology start-ups and attracted global
investments. India has nurtured a conducive environment for technology
and innovation through policy reforms, access to funding, and incubation
support. Managed by the Department for Promotion of Industry and Internal
Trade under the commerce ministry, the Startup India initiative has helped
introduce various programmes that support entrepreneurs and create a
healthy start-up ecosystem. Similarly, the ‘Make in India’ initiative has
incentivised the development, manufacture, and assembly of products in the
country, and has thus boosted partnerships, investments, and innovations.
Growing digital literacy and inclusion in harnessing the benefits of
technology has also been crucial achievements for the country. India's
experience underscores the importance of widespread access to affordable
internet connectivity, digital skills training, and tailored initiatives for
marginalised communities. Initiatives like BharatNet,17 which aims to
connect over 250,000 local rural bodies with high-speed internet, and the
Common Service Centers,18 which provide access to government services in"|data_input/OrfPathHealth/LessonsIndiaDigitalHealthTfn.pdf|4|014f9ea7e74046c3a199e084f6657655
"connect over 250,000 local rural bodies with high-speed internet, and the
Common Service Centers,18 which provide access to government services in
remote areas, have been instrumental in extending the benefits of India’s
digital infrastructure to rural communities. In addition to the digital
training programmes offered through government-supported bodies like
the National Skills Development Centre19 and the National Institute for
Entrepreneurship and Small Business Development,20 other private training
institutes and online platforms have significantly contributed to digital skill
building among citizens, both in urban and rural settings. By prioritising
digital literacy and inclusion, countries can bridge the digital divide and
empower their citizens to participate fully in the digital age.
Key Drivers of India’s Digital Transformation
India’s achievements in implementing DPI demonstrate the transformative
power of technology when combined with inclusivity, scalability, regulation,
and collaboration. The key factors that equipped the country to achieve this
digital revolution include:"|data_input/OrfPathHealth/LessonsIndiaDigitalHealthTfn.pdf|4|06adff272cad490cace25f6dfee1652d
"97Lessons from India’s Digital Public Infrastructure Transformation Ecosystem collaboration
India's success in digital service delivery can be attributed to strong
collaboration between government agencies, industry leaders, startups,
academia, and civil society organisations. This collaborative approach
has fostered innovation, shared expertise, and effective implementation.
India’s G20 presidency has further drawn attention to the importance
of collaboration, with initiatives like the Global DPI Summit21 allowing
a close agreement between partners (and non-partners alike) on the
common principles and design aspects of DPIs. By bringing together all the
stakeholders, the Indian government has created a collaborative environment
for developing and implementing digital public infrastructure projects.
Industry players have contributed their expertise, resources, and technological
innovations to build and maintain the required infrastructure. Similarly,
collaborations with academic institutions and research organisations have
aided innovation and helped address technical and policy challenges. Public-
private partnerships and international collaborations have further supported
knowledge exchange, best practice sharing, and access to resources and
funding.
The Indian government has been able to promote such an ecosystem
collaboration by establishing platforms (such as, India Stack), forums (for"|data_input/OrfPathHealth/LessonsIndiaDigitalHealthTfn.pdf|5|3d69704c07bc45b798128faaee87c3c6
"The Indian government has been able to promote such an ecosystem
collaboration by establishing platforms (such as, India Stack), forums (for
example, India Stack Knowledge Exchange Forum, 202222), and regulatory
frameworks (IndEA and DEPA) that encourage active participation,
information sharing, and coordination between different stakeholders.
These collaborations prioritise interoperability, data privacy, security, and
scalability to build a robust and sustainable DPI in the country.
Scalability and inclusion
India's experience in scaling up its DPI demonstrates the significance
of inclusivity, with the most successful case being that of its digital
identification system. MeitY, in response to an unstarred question in the
upper house of Parliament (in July 2022), said that out of the approximate
projected population of 1.37 billion, around 1.27 billion held a live Aadhaar
number.23 By ensuring accessibility and ease of enrollment for all citizens,"|data_input/OrfPathHealth/LessonsIndiaDigitalHealthTfn.pdf|5|a3bb7b5785614744bfc93dc4ac04eaf8
"98Accelerating Global Health: Pathways to Health Equity for the G20
99including marginalised communities, India has achieved a notable level of
inclusivity. While there are gaps in digital inclusion across demographic
locations (55 percent share of urban telephone subscribers, as of December
202224) and gender (11 percent gender gap in mobile ownership, 202325),
the country is consistently invested in closing this difference.
India’s digital infrastructure has been created keeping in mind future
needs and potential growth. With a quantum increase in users connected
to the internet, the emergence of multiple types of intermediaries (digital
media, e-commerce, and others), and the possible use of connectivity to
cause harm or commit crimes cannot be ignored. Comprehensive measures
need to be taken to prepare for the future. To check a potential DPI’s
scalability even before introduction, significant emphasis has been placed
on considerations like robust technology frameworks, interoperability, open
Application Programming Interfaces, data management, and addressing
infrastructure gaps.
India’s journey is an example of how scalability and inclusion work
together in building a resilient and equitable digital public infrastructure.
Key strategies that have helped the country’s efforts to establish its
infrastructure at scale are ensuring accessibility, promoting digital literacy
and skill development, focus on last-mile connectivity, multilingual support"|data_input/OrfPathHealth/LessonsIndiaDigitalHealthTfn.pdf|6|bee39e9c57284375ab9ef3286387d6f7
"and skill development, focus on last-mile connectivity, multilingual support
in technological solutions, participatory implementation, and regulations to
ensure affordability.
Balancing regulation and innovation
India's digital payments ecosystem demonstrates the need to strike a
balance between regulation and innovation. While fostering competition and
innovation, the country has implemented robust regulatory measures to
ensure the security and integrity of transactions.
Putting in place provisions like regulatory sandboxes, which provide a
controlled environment for testing innovative technologies and business
models, has allowed experimentation and innovation, while ensuring
consumer protection and risk mitigation. At the same time, taking a"|data_input/OrfPathHealth/LessonsIndiaDigitalHealthTfn.pdf|6|f948ffcd6aba4bcbad96bb62772f6c2e
"99Lessons from India’s Digital Public Infrastructure Transformation collaborative approach by establishing forums and platforms for stakeholders
to engage in policy discussions and regulatory consultations has helped
in understanding their needs and concerns, thus informing the adoption
of balanced regulatory policies. Recognising the fast-paced nature of the
digital landscape, Indian regulators have also shown agility in updating and
adapting regulations. Recent policy measures like the introduction of the
Digital Personal Data Protection Bill 2022,26 which restricts the processing
of personal data until after the individual’s consent has been recorded, and
the presentation of the Digital India Act 2023,27 to set up global standard
cyber laws, have demonstrated a willingness to understand and respond to
consumer needs, emerging technologies, and market trends.
While India has made strides in regulation and innovation, challenges
remain. Striking the right balance between the two requires continuous
monitoring, assessment, and adaptation of regulatory frameworks to keep
pace with evolving technologies and market dynamics. Employing these
efforts at the desired scale in the country would require infrastructure,
investment, and a strong commitment. Ongoing collaboration between
regulators, industry players, and other stakeholders will be crucial to
maintaining an innovation-friendly environment while upholding consumer"|data_input/OrfPathHealth/LessonsIndiaDigitalHealthTfn.pdf|7|636a089b8c704526b9f5f9786744cf50
"regulators, industry players, and other stakeholders will be crucial to
maintaining an innovation-friendly environment while upholding consumer
protection and addressing emerging risks.
Conclusion
India's DPI provides valuable lessons on the advantages of harnessing
technology for inclusive growth, economic development, and improved
governance. Through initiatives like Aadhaar, UPI, digital health
infrastructure, DBT, e-governance, regulatory frameworks, and creating an
enabling digital ecosystem, India has been able to unlock the transformative
potential of DPI. By focusing on the key lessons from India's experience,
other countries can implement similar DPIs to address their unique
challenges and leverage the potential of technology for the benefit of their
citizens."|data_input/OrfPathHealth/LessonsIndiaDigitalHealthTfn.pdf|7|120159ef4cf6481e8226770a5ca66127
"100Accelerating Global Health: Pathways to Health Equity for the G20
101These countries must consider their contextual differences based on
population size, level of technological development, political priorities, and
policy outlooks to customise their learnings to suit their specific needs and
challenges. As the world embraces the digital era, India's DPI experience
can serve as inspiration and guide for building robust digital systems that
could foster inclusive societies and drive sustainable development in the
21st century.
Sameer Kanwar is Director, Digital Health, India and South Asia Hub, PATH .
Varun Kumar is Senior Program Officer, PATH."|data_input/OrfPathHealth/LessonsIndiaDigitalHealthTfn.pdf|8|a2bea37a1e0a4958aa622859959f8dd7
"29
2829Antibiotics have revolutionised modern medicine by reducing
morbidity and mortality caused by bacterial infections. However,
the overuse and misuse of antibiotics has accelerated the development of
antibiotic resistance, making once-treatable infections increasingly difficult
to manage.1 Antimicrobial resistance (AMR) is a grave global health crisis,
posing significant challenges to achieving health equity on a global scale.
In 2019 alone, bacterial AMR was directly responsible for 1.27 million
deaths worldwide.2 If left unchecked, this is predicted to cause a staggering
10 million deaths by 2050,3,4,5 u n d e r l i n i n g t h e u r g e n t n e e d f o r a c t i o n .
An increase in AMR will significantly impact the global economy and is
expected to push an additional 24 million people into extreme poverty by
2030.6 Although reliable estimates from developing nations remain limited,
perhaps due to inadequate surveillance, the burden of AMR is suspected
to be highest in low-income countries. Unless suitable interventions are
implemented, certain susceptible bacterial pathogens will eventually become
resistant to antimicrobials, thereby rendering treatments ineffective.7 This
essay explores the multifaceted nature of AMR and its impact on healthcare
systems and patient outcomes. The focus is on accelerating efforts to
combat AMR, with the recognition that addressing this issue is crucial for"|data_input/OrfPathHealth/TheBattleAgainstAntimicrobialResistance.pdf|0|56cb31ef42a4491684ce3bb3afc86948
"systems and patient outcomes. The focus is on accelerating efforts to
combat AMR, with the recognition that addressing this issue is crucial for
ensuring health equity for all. Ranga Reddy Burri, Robert Skov, Bulagonda Eswarappa Pradeep,
and Ralf SudbrakThe Battle Against
Antimicrobial
Resistance"|data_input/OrfPathHealth/TheBattleAgainstAntimicrobialResistance.pdf|0|5f7f2e3a81c34f3e8350a17a564371bb
"29The Battle Against Antimicrobial Resistance
29Understanding Antimicrobial Resistance
The emergence of AMR impedes the prevention and/or treatment of
persistent infectious diseases. Although a number of measures have been
initiated at the global, national, and regional levels, AMR persists.8 To
effectively combat AMR, it is essential to comprehend its fundamental
aspects. AMR refers to the ability of microorganisms, such as bacteria,
viruses, fungi, and parasites, to withstand the effects of antimicrobial drugs.
The development of resistance is part of the natural biological evolution as
this is part of the defence system of microorganisms. Resistance can be
inherent (i.e. no target for the antibiotic) or it can arise through various
mechanisms, including genetic mutations, horizontal transfer of resistance
genes between microorganisms, target modification, membrane permeability
alteration, drug modification, and antibiotic efflux. Exposure to antimicrobials
accelerates the generation of resistance by increasing rates of mutation
and exchange of genetic resistance mechanisms as well as the killing of
susceptible microorganisms (including many bacteria of the normal flora),
thereby giving resistant microorganisms a competitive advantage (also
known as ‘selection’). Resistance affects all types of antimicrobial agents,
including antibiotics, antivirals, antifungals, and antiparasitic drugs. There"|data_input/OrfPathHealth/TheBattleAgainstAntimicrobialResistance.pdf|1|4c09cfa7a92c4c6f91015c4bc12ca169
"including antibiotics, antivirals, antifungals, and antiparasitic drugs. There
are five key factors that contribute to the rise of AMR (see Figure 1).
Figure 1: Factors Contributing to the Rise of AMR
Source: Authors’ ownInadequate
infection
prevention
and controlPoor
diagnostic
capacityDrying
antimicrobial
development and
production
pipelineAbuse/
Inappropriate
use of
antibiotics"|data_input/OrfPathHealth/TheBattleAgainstAntimicrobialResistance.pdf|1|33f75b1bdb184c6a8d92a9f94c8e12aa
"30Accelerating Global Health: Pathways to Health Equity for the G20
31a) Inadequate infection prevention and control: The spread of AMR is
closely linked to the ability of bacteria and other microorganisms to
rapidly multiply and spread their population through various vectors/hosts.
Poor hand hygiene, improper disinfection and sterilisation practices, and
inadequate sanitation can lead to the rapid spread of these drug-resistant
pathogens. Strict adherence to infection control measures can lower the
occurrence of hospital-acquired infections.9 Therefore, appropriate measures
need to be taken to enhance the existing infection prevention framework and
reduce the risk of the spread of AMR. A significant hurdle in implementing
infection prevention and control (IPC) practices, especially in low- and
middle-income countries (LMICs), is the presence of adequately-trained
human resources. To address this, institutions such as the World Health
Organization (WHO) and US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention
have developed training modules, while the Infection Control Academy
of India (IFCAI) has developed a diploma course to build the capacity of
infection preventionists.
b) Abuse/inappropriate use of antibiotics : In addition to the selection
pressure on microbes due to the use of antimicrobial drugs, social and
administrative factors also contribute to, and exacerbate the emergence of"|data_input/OrfPathHealth/TheBattleAgainstAntimicrobialResistance.pdf|2|f264cfbdf5374cb18f41be2df1db4bc9
"pressure on microbes due to the use of antimicrobial drugs, social and
administrative factors also contribute to, and exacerbate the emergence of
AMR. One of the contributing factors is the availability, in many countries,
of antimicrobials through over-the-counter (OTC) sales without requiring
prescriptions. Furthermore, the inappropriate prescription of antibiotics by
physicians contribute to the overuse of antibiotics. A study conducted by
WHO highlighted that a significant proportion of antimicrobials prescribed
in outpatient departments of various hospitals were unnecessary or
inappropriate.10 Rampant use of antibiotics in the livestock sector, pressure
from patients to be prescribed an antibiotic for immediate relief from
symptoms, self-medication, and the discontinuation of antibiotic course
after relief from symptoms—all worsen drug resistance in pathogens.11,12
New legislation and the enforcement of existing regulations to prevent the
OTC sale of antimicrobials is crucial, as are stricter antibiotic prescription
and consumption measures.
c) Drying antimicrobial development and production pipeline: The complete
antimicrobial drug development process, from discovery to market entry, takes
an average of eight to 12 years. Although advancements in computational"|data_input/OrfPathHealth/TheBattleAgainstAntimicrobialResistance.pdf|2|b25025b426a4481fb8034389f7d5521c
"31The Battle Against Antimicrobial Resistancechemistry and artificial intelligence (AI) have aided in drastically cutting
down the timelines for the discovery of new antimicrobials, the in vitro
and in vivo trials take time. Even after such laborious efforts, bacteria
swiftly develop resistance to these antibiotics. Quicker and more efficient
antibiotic testing and approval pipelines need to be established to combat
AMR.13
Recent advances in antimicrobial discovery—including the repurposing
of existing drugs, exploration of natural products, employing alternate
treatment strategies, the use of computational approaches for drug design,
interdisciplinary collaborations, and the integration of new technologies may
help in accelerating the discovery process14 a n d i n t h e m i t i g a t i o n o f A M R .
Despite the recent advantages, investment in antibiotic research and
development remains limited, resulting in a clinical antibacterial pipeline
that is insufficient to address the emergence and spread of AMR infections.
In 2021,15 there were only 77 antibacterials in the clinical pipeline that target
WHO priority pathogens (Enterobacteriaceae, Acinetobacter and P s e u d o m o n a s )
including tuberculosis.16 Of these, 45 are traditional antibacterial agents and
32 are non-traditional. Of the 45 traditional antibiotics, 27 are reported
to be active against the WHO bacterial priority pathogens, 13 against"|data_input/OrfPathHealth/TheBattleAgainstAntimicrobialResistance.pdf|3|d6a0fa9223a74b6bb573ddaa0d4a0b34
"32 are non-traditional. Of the 45 traditional antibiotics, 27 are reported
to be active against the WHO bacterial priority pathogens, 13 against
Mycobacterium tuberculosis, and five exclusively against Clostridium difficile.
Only six of the 27 antibacterials targeting the priority pathogens fulfil at
least one of WHO’s four innovation criteria (i.e., absence of known cross-
resistance, new class of drug, new target site, and new mode of action).17
However, a robust pipeline of novel antibiotics is critical to tackling the
increasing emergence and spread of AMR. The Global AMR R&D Hub
and WHO18 reported on the progress and challenges for incentivising the
development of new antibacterial treatments to tackle the emerging threat
of AMR. The return on investment for new antibiotics fails to cover the
costs of their development, manufacturing, and distribution.19 As a result, big
pharmaceutical companies have exited the antibiotic market, and companies
remaining in the space (often small or micro biotech firms) face challenges
to sustain their operations given the cost and time for drugs to reach the
market. Novel reimbursement models addressing the market failures are
needed to make antibiotic development more economically sustainable."|data_input/OrfPathHealth/TheBattleAgainstAntimicrobialResistance.pdf|3|fa2e98764d92497a96afded036f69b3c
"32Accelerating Global Health: Pathways to Health Equity for the G20
33Innovative financing mechanisms play a crucial role in addressing the
lack of financial incentives for the private sector to develop, test, and roll
out new antimicrobials. One potential solution is the implementation of
advance market commitment–type investments, such as those undertaken
by organisations like DNDi (Drugs for Neglected Diseases Initiative), CEPI
(Coalition for Epidemic Preparedness Innovations), and Gavi (Global Alliance
for Vaccines and Immunization).
Under this model, governments pool funding to support manufacturers
and the private sector in creating antibiotics, thereby reducing innovation
risks and ensuring equitable pricing and access. This approach incentivises
private-sector investment, overcomes financial barriers, and contributes to
the fight against AMR, securing effective treatments for all.
d) Poor diagnostic capacity: Accurate and timely diagnostics are critical for
identifying and managing infectious diseases effectively. Poor diagnostic
capacity can lead to delayed or inappropriate treatment, increased morbidity,
mortality, and spread of infectious diseases, including outbreaks. Poor
diagnostics encompass several aspects, including limited access to diagnostic
technologies, inadequate laboratory supplies and equipment, poor quality of
chemicals and equipment, absence of reliable quality assurance systems,"|data_input/OrfPathHealth/TheBattleAgainstAntimicrobialResistance.pdf|4|a6e0c242b2ce4ecabcca7b5e2a13432e
"technologies, inadequate laboratory supplies and equipment, poor quality of
chemicals and equipment, absence of reliable quality assurance systems,
limited access to reference laboratories, inadequate infrastructure, lack of
trained personnel, and delays in obtaining test results.20 Poor diagnostic
capacity is one of the biggest challenges of the health sector in developing
countries.21 Lack of timely diagnostics is also a challenge in vulnerable
populations in high-income countries (HIC). Therefore, improving diagnostic
capacity is essential, especially in LMICs, as is ensuring equitable access to
diagnostics for vulnerable populations to enhance the quality and efficiency
of healthcare delivery and for achieving the global health goals of reducing
the burden of communicable and non-communicable diseases.22
Innovations Related to AMR
a) Exploration of alternative therapies: Alternate ways of treatment
like “bacteriophages,23 a n t i m i c r o b i a l p e p t i d e s ( A M P s ) o r b a c t e r i o c i n s ,24
antimicrobial adjuvants, faecal microbiota transplant (FMT) and competitive
exclusion of pathogens through genetically modified probiotics and"|data_input/OrfPathHealth/TheBattleAgainstAntimicrobialResistance.pdf|4|ae9f62f143fa4583888a5169b9b70f5f
"33The Battle Against Antimicrobial Resistancepostbiotics”25 rather than antibacterial agents alone, could be an alternate
way to reduce the use of antimicrobials.
b) Streamlined approval of new antimicrobials: Efficient and streamlined
clinical trial processes are crucial for expediting the development timeline
of new antimicrobials, including regulatory processes and innovative
trial designs, such as adaptive dose-ranging studies and seamless phase
transitions. This calls for better collaboration between regulatory agencies,
researchers, and industry stakeholders to establish harmonised protocols,
reduce administrative burden, and expedite patient recruitment, leading to
faster completion of clinical trials.26
c) Repurposing of existing drugs: Drug repurposing, or identifying new
therapeutic applications for existing drugs offers another strategy to
expedite antibacterial production. By leveraging the extensive knowledge
and safety profiles of approved drugs, researchers could bypass certain
preclinical and early clinical development stages, significantly reducing the
overall timeline. Repurposing can be achieved through in-silico analyses,
high-throughput screening, and exploring drug libraries, aiming to identify
existing drugs with potential antibacterial activity.27
d) Harnessing the power of AI: Machine learning (ML) and AI offer
possibilities to accelerate drug repurposing in several ways, including the"|data_input/OrfPathHealth/TheBattleAgainstAntimicrobialResistance.pdf|5|eef5aa9b8739411b810009a682c605ea
"d) Harnessing the power of AI: Machine learning (ML) and AI offer
possibilities to accelerate drug repurposing in several ways, including the
detection of the relationships among various biological components (such as
genes, proteins, diseases, and drugs) and through the analysis of molecular
fingerprints of compounds. Furthermore, neural network-based approaches
can be trained to learn the patterns and properties of fingerprints, enabling
prediction of drug activities and identifying potential drug candidates.28
AI can also be harnessed to streamline the diagnostic process. An academic–
industry collaboration in India (between Sri Sathya Sai Institute of Higher
Learning, IFCAI and SCIINV Biosciences Private Limited) has developed
AMRx™ , an AI/ML-based culture-free prediction system in the context of
urinary tract infections. It is a clinical decision support system to improve
empirical antibiotic prescriptions and to reduce unnecessary laboratory
testing of samples."|data_input/OrfPathHealth/TheBattleAgainstAntimicrobialResistance.pdf|5|191122a7c9ca424eb5b629f64b84501e
"34Accelerating Global Health: Pathways to Health Equity for the G20
35e) Collaborative research and funding initiatives: Global efforts are urgently
needed to address the complex elements of AMR. These include coordinated
leadership at the global, regional, and national level, involving diverse
government agencies, academia, practitioners, and industry.29,30 Recognising
the spread of AMR, WHO, the Food and Agriculture Organization, the United
Nations Environment Programme, and the World Organisation for Animal
Health have formed the Quadripartite to promote a ‘One Health’ approach31
that aims to align actions across the human, animal, and environmental
sectors. Several initiatives are ongoing, and 170 countries have developed
national action plans (NAPs). However, only 10 percent of these plans are
fully costed. Converting the NAPs to concrete AMR mitigation actions has
proved to be difficult, including in the LMICs.
In response, Denmark initiated the establishment of the International Centre
for Antimicrobial Resistance Solutions (ICARS) to support these countries
with funding and expertise to develop evidence-based, context-specific
and cost-effective solutions that can be scaled to establish sustainable
AMR mitigation. The AMR Multi-Partner Trust Fund (MPTF) was launched
in 2019 by the Quadripartite members to catalyse the implementation of
One Health NAPs and to provide effective leadership and coordination of"|data_input/OrfPathHealth/TheBattleAgainstAntimicrobialResistance.pdf|6|8c316bb5722c4d8d86175a03d060beff
"in 2019 by the Quadripartite members to catalyse the implementation of
One Health NAPs and to provide effective leadership and coordination of
multisectoral One Health response to AMR. Additionally, the Global AMR
R&D Hub in Berlin is promoting collaboration and coordination of research
and development on AMR, and is cataloguing the present funding in AMR
R&D to provide the landscape of present funding for future prioritisation.
Organisations such as CARB-X, Global Antibiotic Research & Development
Partnership (GARDP), and the AMR Action Fund work to stimulate drug
discovery and equitable access. To solve the market failure for antimicrobials,
new models for financing the development of novel antimicrobials, where
countries pay for the accessibility of drugs, are currently being explored.32
f) Rapid Diagnostic Tests and Point-of-Care Technologies in AMR: Absolute,
concrete, and timely diagnosis detection, and management of infection-
causing pathogens will significantly decline morbidity, mortality, and the
cost burden. Rapid diagnostic tests (RDTs)33 and point-of-care technologies
(POC) are tools that can be employed in achieving timely diagnostics.
The integration of RDTs and POC technologies, such as polymerase chain
reaction-based tests, genotypic assays, and phenotypic assays, in AMR"|data_input/OrfPathHealth/TheBattleAgainstAntimicrobialResistance.pdf|6|11ba021f8b0941128d23e1635a7534dc
"35The Battle Against Antimicrobial Resistancemanagement can potentially transform clinical practice and public health
interventions.34
Accelerating Efforts to Combat AMR
Combating AMR requires a multipronged approach the comprises all critical
components—from policy to implementation. Development of new antibiotics and alternative treatments in the era
of Antimicrobial ResistanceOvercoming difficulties in finding new drugsAntibiotic repurposingDevelopment of alternate therapies like BacteriophagesImproving infection prevention and control practicesOptimising antimicrobial useStrengthening surveillance and data collectionIntegrated One Health approach to unify and integrate multiple
sectorsIncorporating AMR into national and global health plansEngaging stakeholders and raising awareness about AMRMobilising political will and fostering multi-sectoral collaboration"|data_input/OrfPathHealth/TheBattleAgainstAntimicrobialResistance.pdf|7|8d5be2c00a594be49855a53b8f10793b
"36Accelerating Global Health: Pathways to Health Equity for the G20
37Conclusion
AMR is an ongoing and evolving pandemic that impacts LMICs and
vulnerable populations in HICs the hardest. This is aggravated by a drying
pipeline of antimicrobials and the industry leaving the field of antimicrobial
drug discovery due to lack of economic sustainability. The consequences of
the AMR pandemic are already severe, but will become even more dire if
not reversed. There is an urgent need for increased and focused action. Due
to the complex nature of AMR, this effort needs to be multifaceted, both
in reducing the circulation and spread of existing resistant microorganisms
and in slowing the increase of novel resistance mechanisms. Key to this
is lowering the overall use of antimicrobials (i.e. infection prevention),
antimicrobial stewardship (including accessibility of affordable and timely
diagnostics), and strengthening IPC and biosecurity procedures, all of which
need to be carried out through the ‘One Health’ approach. This needs
involvement at all levels and of all stakeholders, including civil society.
Exploring alternative therapies such as bacteriophage therapy, repurposing
existing drugs, harnessing the power of AI, and fostering collaborative
research initiatives are key strategies in tackling AMR. These innovative
approaches provide hope for the future, where a robust antibacterial
pipeline can meet the challenges posed by evolving bacterial infections and"|data_input/OrfPathHealth/TheBattleAgainstAntimicrobialResistance.pdf|8|4232b39e033a479aa1395dd385b860ea
"approaches provide hope for the future, where a robust antibacterial
pipeline can meet the challenges posed by evolving bacterial infections and
ensure effective treatment options for patients worldwide.
Dr. Ranga Reddy Burri is President, Infection Control Academy of India and Honorary
Professor, at the University of Hyderabad, India.
Dr. Robert Skov is Scientific Director at the International Centre for Antimicrobial
Resistance Solutions (ICARS, Copenhagen, Denmark); President-Elect & Secretary General,
European Society of Clinical Microbiology and Infectious Diseases (ESCMID).
Dr. Bulagonda Eswarappa Pradeep is Associate Professor, Department of Biosciences,
Sri Sathya Sai Institute of Higher Learning, India.
Dr. Ralf Sudbrak i s D e p u t y D i r e c t o r a t t h e G l o b a l A M R R & D H u b , B e r l i n , G e r m a n y ."|data_input/OrfPathHealth/TheBattleAgainstAntimicrobialResistance.pdf|8|610fda1279b74010ba8f39d1ab0137fb
"59
59Janice Tan and Jeremy LimEnsuring Access
to Affordable
Healthcare for All:
The Role of Health Finance in G20
Countries
The G20 countries, individually and collectively, have made strides
in improving human health since the group's inception in 1999.
Average life expectancy across the member states has shown remarkable
progress, increasing from 73 years to 78 years over the past two decades,
well above the global average of 67 years.1
Figure 1: Average Life Expectancy in G20 Countries
Source: WHO dataAverage life expectancy (yrs)
100
50
0
ARG FRA JPN ZAF AUS DEU KOR TUR BRA IND MEX UK CAN IDN RUS US CHI ITA KSA74
79
70
79
71
79
78
62
66
79
81
75
73
66
72
59
71
77
7777
83
75
82
78
83
81
71
71
84
84
83
74
73
77
66
78
81
79
1999 2019"|data_input/OrfPathHealth/EnsuringAccessToAffordableHealth.pdf|0|dbcde4cff59545b39575aae24e1af0de
"60Accelerating Global Health: Pathways to Health Equity for the G20
61This achievement demonstrates the potential of the G20’s collective
commitment towards enhancing public health outcomes and underscores
the importance of continued efforts to prioritise health equity between
countries. There is still much to be done: within the group, there is an
18.2-year difference in life expectancy between the highest and lowest
achieving members. Imagine the life and health gains if all G20 countries
levelled up.
The improvements in human health have been accompanied by an increase
in healthcare spending in absolute terms. With the exception of India and
Turkey, G20 nations saw a rise in the average healthcare expenditure as
percent of GDP, from 6.8 percent to 8.5 percent between 2000 and 2019,
or just above US$3,000 per capita.
Figure 2: Healthcare Expenditure as % of GDP for G20 countries
Source: WHO data2Healthcare Expenditure (% of GDP)
20
15
10
5
0ARG FRA JPN ZAF AUS DEU KOR TUR BRA IND MEX UK CAN IDN RUS US CHI ITA8.2
7.6
8.3
8.3
4.5
9.6
9.9
4.0
1.9
7.6
7.0
3.9
8.1
5.5
7.3
4.6
7.2
12.59.5
10.2
9.6
11.0
5.4
11.1
11.7
2.9
2.9
8.7
10.8
4.5
5.0
5.7
8.2
4.4
9.9
16.7
2000 2019"|data_input/OrfPathHealth/EnsuringAccessToAffordableHealth.pdf|1|678afd7b052b4476bcb6202f9c92ca9a
"61The Role of Health Finance in G20 Countries Figure 3: Higher % GDP Spending in Healthcare and Increase in
UHC Coverage
Source: WHO Data3
There is recognition that investments in healthcare, overall, runs parallel
to expansion in coverage of Universal Health Care (see Fig. 3). However,
this coupling between healthcare spending and health outcomes is a topic
of intense interest when discussing health finance in G20 countries. While
increased healthcare expenditure often leads to improved health outcomes,
this is not always the case and it is crucial to ensure that investments
are directed effectively and efficiently. By adopting innovative financing
mechanisms, G20 countries can optimise the impact of healthcare spending
and achieve desired health outcomes for their populations.
Persisting Out-of-Pocket Expenses
Despite progress, the issue of high out-of-pocket (OOP) expenses remains
a significant concern in many G20 countries. OOP expenses often place
a disproportionate burden on vulnerable populations, leading to financial
hardships and limited access to healthcare.4 Embedded in the advocacy for
health equity is the recognition that health disparities exist among different
populations due to various factors such as socioeconomic status, race,
ethnicity, gender, geographic location and access to healthcare services.5
Thus, achieving health equity requires interventions and policies targeted"|data_input/OrfPathHealth/EnsuringAccessToAffordableHealth.pdf|2|1e2aba6274514421a8926919f8f7e96e
"Thus, achieving health equity requires interventions and policies targeted
towards those who are most disadvantaged and have the greatest needs.
This may involve redistributing resources, implementing targeted healthcare
programs, improving access to quality healthcare services, addressing social
and economic inequalities, and promoting health education and prevention UHC
Global average : 67
India
IndonesiaTurkiyeChinaSingapore South KoreaNetherlands
UKCanada
United StatesGermany
FranceJapan
Spain
Brazil
ArgentinaSouth AfricaRussiaAustralia
Mexico
% GDP100
80
60
40
20
0
0 5 10 15 20Italy"|data_input/OrfPathHealth/EnsuringAccessToAffordableHealth.pdf|2|283bcf2fc99c4e389f33ff7f69352c7a
"62Accelerating Global Health: Pathways to Health Equity for the G20
63initiatives. As the COVID-19 pandemic has illustrated, no one is safe until
everyone is, and even if primarily motivated by self-interest, there is an
economic case (if not for reasons of equity) for uplifting the most vulnerable
populations.
The efficiency of healthcare systems also varies greatly among G20 countries.
While some economies have successfully implemented efficient and effective
healthcare models, others continue to face challenges in delivering equitable
care. The authors of this article examine the relationship between universal
healthcare service coverage (UHC) and Out-Of-Pocket Expenses (OOPE) as a
proportion of Current Health Expenditure for G20 countries (Fig. 4), reflecting
targets 3.8.1 and 3.8.2 of the UN Sustainable Development Goals for Universal
Health Care.
UHC measures coverage of essential health services that include reproductive,
maternal, newborn and child health, infectious diseases, non-communicable
diseases and service capacity and access among the general and the most
disadvantaged populations. Meanwhile, 3.8.2 highlights catastrophic OOP
healthcare spending, usually defined as populations with household expenditure
on health >10 percent or 25 percent of total household expenditure. The
authors used data from previous decade to sift out which countries of the
G20 had shown the most recent improvements, and also included Spain and"|data_input/OrfPathHealth/EnsuringAccessToAffordableHealth.pdf|3|a95553e2bd244b7d942444cfa3c4669e
"authors used data from previous decade to sift out which countries of the
G20 had shown the most recent improvements, and also included Spain and
Singapore to the analysis as both these countries are permanent or recurring
guest nations to the G20 dialogues and could offer lessons to emulate.
Figure 4: Changes in UHC Service Coverage with OOPE in the
Past Decade for G20 Countries
Source: WHO data6UHC
AUS
90
80
70
60
50
40More health service coverage is betterIdeal
Situation
Lower Out of Pocket Expenditure as a% of Current Health Expenditure is betterOOPE70 60 50 40 30 20 10Global average : 67Global average : 312019
2009
ZAFTURTUR
KSA KSAFRA
FRA
USAUSAJPN
JPNDEU
AUSSPN
SPNITA
ITA
BRABRAKOR
CHI
CHIRUS
RUSMEX
MEX
IDN
IDNIND
INDKOR
SGP
SGPCAN
CAN
UKUK
DEU
ARG ARG
ZAF"|data_input/OrfPathHealth/EnsuringAccessToAffordableHealth.pdf|3|d2e918234f264142973787e721a6225a
"63The Role of Health Finance in G20 Countries From the chart, directional movement to the upper left quadrant or
North-West direction would be ideal as it highlights increased UHC
with lower OOPE, i.e. better coverage at greater affordability. The most
significant improvements are highlighted in green (China, India, Indonesia,
Singapore). This article discusses efforts in Indonesia and Singapore that
have contributed to these remarkable achievements. By examining diverse
strategies, readers can gain insights into potential pathways towards
achieving health equity within different national contexts, be they in
developing or developed nations.
Best Practices
Indonesia
Indonesia’s journey to UHC is a textbook case of adherence to expanding
health insurance coverage and implementing social protection mechanisms.
The landmark JKN National Health Insurance was implemented in 2014
to provide access to healthcare for its population and today covers
approximately 250M people.7 The JKN program covers all Indonesian
citizens, including formal and informal sector workers, and those
categorised as poor and near-poor, ensuring that everyone has access to
essential healthcare services. It consolidates more than 300 risk pools and
operates under a single-payer system, managed by the Social Security
Agency for Health ( Badan Penyelenggara Jaminan Sosial Kesehatan o r B P J S ) .
BPJS collects contributions, manages the insurance fund, and coordinates"|data_input/OrfPathHealth/EnsuringAccessToAffordableHealth.pdf|4|b4062701b5d347ce83cad737fb176357
"BPJS collects contributions, manages the insurance fund, and coordinates
with healthcare providers. Participation for all eligible individuals is
mandatory, and contributions are based on income and employment status,
with the government subsidising the premium for the poor and near-
poor. The insurance scheme entitles every Indonesian to the same medical
benefit package, decreasing OOPE from 47 percent to 34 percent in just
four years.8
Within this OOP spending, in LMICs (low- and medium-income countries)
such as Indonesia, medicines typically account for 20-60 percent of total
healthcare expenditure with nearly 90 percent of the population purchasing
medicines through OOP payments.9 Managing drug pricing and procurement
is thus a key lever for further managing costs and affordability. Indonesia"|data_input/OrfPathHealth/EnsuringAccessToAffordableHealth.pdf|4|b320f07f7cc04cf196f3f634b4508f39
"64Accelerating Global Health: Pathways to Health Equity for the G20
65has implemented a generic medicine pricing policy where the retail price
of generics cannot exceed the maximum retail price set by the MOH.
A 2010 study across nine public hospitals, 64 private pharmacies, and nine
NGO hospitals in four provinces in Indonesia, showed that the prices of
Lowest Price Generic (LPG) and Innovator Brand (IB) medicines was lower
in 2010 than in 2004, with declines ranging from 40 percent to 2200
percent.10 This showed that generic medicine pricing policies have succeeded
in lowering the price of medicines. Despite this success, however, there
is wide variation in implementation as exemplified by the excess paid by
patients compared to MOH set prices varying widely from 2 percent to
600 percent. Even within countries, there is substantial opportunity to
narrow the differences. More recently, the government has also embarked
on working through state-owned enterprises (SOEs) to centralise drug
procurement and leverage purchasing power, negotiating lower prices to
further ensure availability of medications across facilities.
On the demand side, Indonesia has promoted the use of generics with
public awareness campaigns to educate the public about their benefits.
These campaigns aim to dispel misconceptions and increase confidence
in the quality and efficacy of generic medications. Additionally, the"|data_input/OrfPathHealth/EnsuringAccessToAffordableHealth.pdf|5|6b7e7f21c99641d885aaabdde592722a
"These campaigns aim to dispel misconceptions and increase confidence
in the quality and efficacy of generic medications. Additionally, the
government has provided incentives for healthcare professionals to prescribe
and dispense generic medications. These incentives may include financial
incentives or recognition for healthcare providers who prioritise generic
prescribing. Again, implementation has been varied. In an observational
study at Kalisat District Hospital, doctor’s compliance in prescribing generic
drugs reached 68 percent while the national standard in April 2013 reached
90 percent.11
Overall, in Indonesia, BPJS and various national policies have forged
significant steps in achieving UHC. However, as highlighted above, uniform
and consistent implementation remains a challenge. Beyond these, there
are also additional efforts that Indonesia can undertake to improve UHC
further. Whilst JKN has an extensive network of healthcare providers,
including public and private hospitals, clinics and facilities, challenges
exist due to disparities in healthcare infrastructure across the vast island
archipelago, and despite co-payments by beneficiaries, the JKN also faces a"|data_input/OrfPathHealth/EnsuringAccessToAffordableHealth.pdf|5|839005dd18fd40a48a9e23aa520baa58
"65The Role of Health Finance in G20 Countries significant deficit. To raise funds, Indonesia has room to raise Public Health
Expenditure and contribution compliance. At the same time, Indonesia can
also improve primary care and manage spending and governance.12
Singapore
Whilst Indonesia is rightly lauded as having the fastest growing insurance
program in the world (with BPJS covering close to 91 percent of its
population in less than 10 years),13 Singapore has had its 3M approach
(Medisave - a compulsory health savings account, Medishield – catastrophic
illness insurance and MediFund – a social security net for the indigent)
initiated 30 years prior, in 1984. What has Singapore done in the past
decade to continue to move the needle in improving UHC and affordability?
Expanding capacity has been a priority. In 2009, there were approximately
8,000 acute hospital and 9,000 nursing home beds in Singapore. Today,
those numbers have grown to 12,000 and 17,000 beds, respectively, or
a combined 70-percent increase in institutional places. With healthy
economic and GDP growth, the Singapore government has been assiduously
increasing healthcare infrastructure, particularly in the eldercare sector as
it prepares to become the 2nd fastest aging economy in Asia outside of
Japan. By 2030, one in every four Singaporeans will be above 65, and along
with changing societal and family patterns, will require massive capacity"|data_input/OrfPathHealth/EnsuringAccessToAffordableHealth.pdf|6|cab8dbe7057d4de7995e3e7a9a909ac8
"with changing societal and family patterns, will require massive capacity
to cater to the elderly who mostly live independently and require support
with their daily activities. Singapore has tried to keep costs manageable for
the eldercare sector by footing high land and building costs of residential
nursing homes and then offering concessions through competitive bids for
operators. Eligible seniors are means tested and substantial subsidies of up
to 80 percent of monthly fees are extended.
Widening coverage to become truly universal has been a highlight of
the last decade. In 2015, MediShield was replaced by MediShield Life, a
more comprehensive and universal health insurance scheme that extended
coverage to all Singaporeans, including those with pre-existing conditions
and older individuals who were previously excluded or had difficulty
obtaining coverage. All citizens and permanent residents were automatically
enrolled in the scheme with lifetime coverage. Whilst MediShield Life helps"|data_input/OrfPathHealth/EnsuringAccessToAffordableHealth.pdf|6|9b26e7c5228846a0ab6f8df2c92bd605
"66Accelerating Global Health: Pathways to Health Equity for the G20
67to pay for large hospital bills and selected costly outpatient treatments such
as dialysis and chemotherapy, Singaporeans also have access to CareShield
Life, which is a long-term insurance targeted at severe disability, providing
cash payouts for long-term care costs for life (and applicable towards
nursing home fees). Both MediShield and CareShield premiums can be paid
using Medisave, with needier beneficiaries able to benefit from top-ups by
family members or occasionally, one-off government disbursements.
Prudent and rational use of limited funds is a priority in Singapore,
especially with increased investment. The visible, frontline expansion of
services aside, the Ministry of Health has also been actively shoring up
decision-making and support services for better health economics. The
Agency for Care Effectiveness (ACE) was set up in 2015—subsuming the
prior Pharmacoeconomic and Drug Utilization Unit (PEDU)—as an expanded
health technology assessment (HTA) unit to support the MOH’s Drug
Advisory Committee in making evidence-based recommendations for the
public funding of drugs. Standardised HTA methods and processes have
been developed in line with international best practices and since ACE’s
establishment, subsidised medications are provided earlier within a drug’s
life cycle and value-based pricing has led to more cost-effective prices"|data_input/OrfPathHealth/EnsuringAccessToAffordableHealth.pdf|7|a4d3d1ede1bc4c0e9856c1391ebee239
"establishment, subsidised medications are provided earlier within a drug’s
life cycle and value-based pricing has led to more cost-effective prices
being negotiated with pharma.14 However, bandwidth limitations and lack of
skilled HTA practitioners impact ACE’s capacity to achieve greater impact.
The cost positioning for Singapore was further improved when the public
healthcare clusters banded together in 2018 to centralise procurement
through the setting up of ALPS Healthcare. Touted as a supply chain
partner, ALPS consolidates, negotiates and manages logistics for supplies
for all public healthcare players—from primary to quarternary care and
including the eldercare sector. ALPS’s coverage goes beyond pharmaceuticals
to include consumables and even support services such as housekeeping
and laundry. This is especially important given the small size of the
domestic Singapore market and consolidation improves efficiency and more
cost-effective procurement.
Despite these cost-saving measures, Singapore has not escaped the
worldwide dilemma of rising healthcare costs. ‘Healthier SG’, set to
go live in July 2023, advocates the signing up of every citizen with"|data_input/OrfPathHealth/EnsuringAccessToAffordableHealth.pdf|7|4bdc5d18372e44b4bcb75a0fa1439031
"67The Role of Health Finance in G20 Countries a dedicated GP/family physician. The GP then serves as continuing and
continuous partner in managing each individual’s healthcare needs more
holistically—from simple needs to acute referrals to chronic diseases. The
focus will progressively shift from a hospital-centric healthcare system
to a preventive model and right-siting care to the most appropriate (and
cost-effective) modalities, which translates to more care within community
settings and providing care that is most appropriate for the individual and
not necessarily just what is most advanced medically.
As this article highlights the examples of Indonesia and Singapore, broad
themes emerge in the approaches used in achieving universal health
care. Expanding financial coverage is critical and with this, widening
service accessibility, especially in primary care and judicious purchasing
and effective procurement. Implementation is paramount and there is
opportunity here for countries to learn and work better together.
Particularly in Southeast Asia, where government procurement is
significant and yet not entirely efficient, the region lacks cross-country
learning opportunities. In the vein of RESYST (Resilient and Responsive
Health Systems) and SPARC (Strategic Purchasing for Africa Resource
Centre), international consortia focused on strategic purchasing, the
South East Asia Regional Collaborative for Health (SEARCH)15 hosted"|data_input/OrfPathHealth/EnsuringAccessToAffordableHealth.pdf|8|48fd8bec90ea48a6b74230bf7c87b411
"Centre), international consortia focused on strategic purchasing, the
South East Asia Regional Collaborative for Health (SEARCH)15 hosted
by the National University of Singapore aims to review existing health
purchasing mechanisms of all ASEAN countries and provide national and
regional-level policy recommendations. This will be a meaningful step to
educate policymakers and help countries overcome roadblocks to strategic
purchasing.
Beyond risk pooling, pricing and procurement, more efforts can be poured
into strengthening primary care provision; there are additional opportunities
from technology and digital modalities. Telehealth and insurtech, if devised
and regulated appropriately, could allow the next step-change in improving
access to healthcare, both within a dense urban city state like Singapore
or a dispersed island nation such as Indonesia. The COVID-19 pandemic
has shown the need and case for such services, and particularly for a
developing nation like Indonesia, the vast proliferation of mobile services
could pave the way for micro-insurance and insurtech to further improve
affordability of healthcare services."|data_input/OrfPathHealth/EnsuringAccessToAffordableHealth.pdf|8|723242056cf44a109c21c203e36c671c
"68Accelerating Global Health: Pathways to Health Equity for the G20
69The journey to UHC and improving health equity is an ongoing endeavour.
While G20 countries have made remarkable progress in improving human
health and increasing healthcare spending, more can be done to ensure
access to affordable healthcare for all. By prioritising health equity and
implementing innovative approaches to health finance, G20 countries can
accelerate progress in transforming public health systems. It is hoped that
some of the learnings shared in this chapter may inform and support
continued commitment to addressing the complex and interconnected public
health challenges faced by societies worldwide.
Associate Professor J e r e m y L i m , MBBS, MPH, is director of global health at the National
University of Singapore’s Saw Swee Hock School of Public Health.
Janice Tan is an experienced healthcare management executive who holds a wealth
of experience spanning diverse landscapes, including both public and private sector
hospitals as well as nursing homes, across both Singapore and Malaysia."|data_input/OrfPathHealth/EnsuringAccessToAffordableHealth.pdf|9|cc94bf6a09304213bad5280b33257311