Convert any text to a graph of knowledge. This can be used for Graph Augmented Generation or Knowledge Graph based QnA
HTML
text|source|page|chunk_id
"82Accelerating Global Health: Pathways to Health Equity for the G20
83Building a Resilient
Digital Health
Ecosystem in India
Lav Agarwal
Technology now permeates every facet of human existence. From
communication and transportation to healthcare and entertainment,
technology has redefined how we live, work, and interact. Its omnipresence
is reshaping societal norms, revolutionising various sectors, and propelling
us into the future.
Through improvements in diagnostics, treatment, and patient care,
technological advancements have had a profound impact on healthcare.
Medical devices, telemedicine, electronic health records, and artificial
intelligence (AI)-driven diagnostics have transformed healthcare delivery by
making it more precise, efficient, and accessible. Wearable devices and health
apps have empowered individuals to monitor and manage their well-being
proactively. Technology has also played a crucial role in advancing medical"|data/MedicalDocuments/India/BuildingResilientDigitalHealthIndia.pdf|0|13476c1867c9495c84d01303b9f5222a
"research, discovering new treatments, and improving overall healthcare
outcomes. In response to the COVID-19 pandemic, the world witnessed the
exponential growth of digital health."|data/MedicalDocuments/India/BuildingResilientDigitalHealthIndia.pdf|0|86113e13490f4002a68f873173662f9a
"83Building a Resilient Digital Health Ecosystem in India Digital Health Landscape in India
Given India’s massive population, providing equitable access to healthcare
services to all is an important agenda. By harnessing the power of
technology, digital health can effectively address these challenges and
ensure that healthcare services are accessible even in the remote regions.
Patients can use digital platforms for convenient access to care. Digital
platforms therefore bridge gaps and improve healthcare delivery across the
nation.
In line with the ‘Digital India’ initiative and the vision to create
interoperable and standardised electronic health records across the country,
the Indian government notified the Electronic Health Record1 standards in
2016. The National Health Policy2 (2017) envisages the creation of a digital
health technology ecosystem that serves the needs of all stakeholders and
improves efficiency, transparency, and citizens’ experiences across public"|data/MedicalDocuments/India/BuildingResilientDigitalHealthIndia.pdf|1|b179a090fb084d6ea17fee9439a110d1
"and private healthcare.
Over the recent years, India has made progress in digital healthcare
delivery, as demonstrated in national health programmes such as the
Hospital Management Information System, Online Registration System, the
national tuberculosis elimination (Ni-kshay) programme, Mother and Child
Tracking System, Mera Aspataal (My Hospital, a patient feedback system), the
Health Management Information System, the Integrated Health Information
Platform, and Non-Communicable Diseases screening application—which
have benefitted patients through the timely delivery of services and by
making government healthcare more affordable and accessible.3
The need for a future-ready digital health system has become even more
urgent with the announcement of the Ayushman Bharat Pradhan Mantri Jan
Arogya Yojana (AB-PMJAY)4 in 2018, India’s flagship programme that would
herald an infrastructural transformation of the nation’s health system. This
mission envisions the following:"|data/MedicalDocuments/India/BuildingResilientDigitalHealthIndia.pdf|1|bf384699b63a44e9a6429a506dfb961e
"mission envisions the following:
I. Operationalising 1.5 lakh health and wellness centres that offer preventive
and primary care, including telemedicine consultation services; and"|data/MedicalDocuments/India/BuildingResilientDigitalHealthIndia.pdf|1|2807f6f0a7dd43c0aff29de2279ae157
"84Accelerating Global Health: Pathways to Health Equity for the G20
85II. Providing financial protection of up to INR 500,000 per family annually
for secondary and tertiary care hospitalisation to the over 120 million
crore poor and vulnerable families that comprise the bottom 40 percent
of the Indian population.
These initiatives aim to scale up a wellness-oriented approach instead
of an illness-focused one—a key step towards achieving universal health
coverage (UHC) through patient data portability across primary, secondary,
and tertiary levels. This essentially translates into an environment where
all people can obtain health services anywhere in the country without
suffering financial hardship or excessive indirect costs.
Achieving such scale requires us to rethink the core technology backbone
of our system and leverage cutting-edge digital solutions to tackle the
challenge. However, it is also felt that all these efforts need to converge into"|data/MedicalDocuments/India/BuildingResilientDigitalHealthIndia.pdf|2|d75ac3dcfd744c7b963a9b4c90fbd9d9
"a single framework to achieve interoperability of data, which would benefit
both policymakers for decision-making and patients with effective services
at the time of need. In response, the government developed the National
Digital Health Blueprint as a framework for the efficient implementation of
digital health treatments.
The Ayushman Bharat Digital Mission5
To implement the principles of the blueprint, the National Digital Health
Mission, now known as the Ayushman Bharat Digital Mission (ABDM), was
launched in six union territories in August 2020. It was proposed to be
carried out via six key components—i.e, the digital health ID card, Digi-
Doctor, Health Facility Registry, Personal Health Records, e-pharmacy, and
telemedicine. India launched the nationwide implementation the ABDM in
September 2021 . The ABDM intends to create the framework needed to
enable an integrated digital health infrastructure in India. Additionally, it"|data/MedicalDocuments/India/BuildingResilientDigitalHealthIndia.pdf|2|31edc3e999ac4bc8a24b5aed3c81d49d
"will bridge the existing gap amongst different stakeholders of the healthcare
ecosystem through digital highways.
Under the ABDM, every citizen will be provided a 14-digit Ayushman
Bharat Account (ABHA) number, which is a unique health identifier. With
the patient’s informed consent, the ABHAs will be used to identify and"|data/MedicalDocuments/India/BuildingResilientDigitalHealthIndia.pdf|2|4077d77275bc45b98606bbe4e77387d1
"85Building a Resilient Digital Health Ecosystem in India authenticate people’s health records across various systems and stakeholders.
As of July 2023, over 435 million ABHAa numbers have been created, and
214,396 health facilities and 207,274 doctors have been registered under
the ABDM ecosystem.
ABDM has accelerated the participation of various stakeholders of the
healthcare ecosystem and ensured deployment of patient-centric policies—
resulting in cashless care with improved access to ensure protection
for the poor. Given its federal and complex healthcare structure, India
demands agility, flexibility and evidence-based smart policymaking for
implementation of healthcare initiatives, driving all stakeholders towards
health-seeking behaviours with renewed energy.
Digital Health in COVID-19 Management
The COVID-19 pandemic has challenged health systems across the globe.
The India government not only focused on the management of the pandemic"|data/MedicalDocuments/India/BuildingResilientDigitalHealthIndia.pdf|3|563b45ecd7d447c089670da47fd6f9ec
"through various activities but also formulated innovative solutions to ensure
the continuity of health services across the spectrum. It has followed a
‘whole of government, whole of society’ approach to battle the pandemic
by engaging subnational and local governments, civil society organisations,
the private sector, and local communities in mitigation efforts.
Amid the pandemic, India recognised the need to ease access to digital
consultations, and issued the Telemedicine Practice Guidelines in March
2020. India also launched eSanjeevaniOPD,6 a first of its kind and the
world’s largest national telemedicine service to facilitate online health
facilities to patients in the confines of their home at no cost to ensure
continuum of care. The eSanjeevani initiative has been instrumental in
bridging the digital divide in India, particularly in rural areas where access
to healthcare is often limited. This initiative has completed 142 million"|data/MedicalDocuments/India/BuildingResilientDigitalHealthIndia.pdf|3|8022fb132d55422fa241f9aebc537158
"consultationsb in record time and is currently serving around 400,000
patients every day as of 27 July 2023.
a https://dashboard.abdm.gov.in/abdm/
b https://esanjeevani.mohfw.gov.in/#/"|data/MedicalDocuments/India/BuildingResilientDigitalHealthIndia.pdf|3|a864c6a3aa9e4714b6773022853020df
"86Accelerating Global Health: Pathways to Health Equity for the G20
87India developed another state-of-the-art digital health system, CoWIN,7 a
digital platform that helped more than a billion beneficiaries book COVID-19
vaccinations in less than three months. In less than 18 months, CoWIN
had helped administer two billion COVID-19 vaccination doses, immunising
over 90 percent of all eligible adults.
The establishment of digitally-enabled COVID-19 ‘war rooms’ at the central
and state levels allowed key stakeholders to undertake data-driven decisions
towards infrastructure gap analysis, case projection and management, and
to identify problem areas that required specific state-centre coordination.
Various other digital health initiatives that have enhanced India’s efforts
against the COVID-19 crisis are outlined in the following points:
i. the COVID-19 India Portal developed for disease tracking by geography,"|data/MedicalDocuments/India/BuildingResilientDigitalHealthIndia.pdf|4|60df57d856f447b7950656fe9dbe5ae5
"inventory tracking of essential items, and predicting demands at the
national, state, and district levels based on case-loads;
ii. the Aarogya Setu, a mobile tracking app which uses the smartphone's
GPS and Bluetooth features to track the coronavirus infection through
contact tracing, syndromic mapping, and self-assessment in addition to
essential risk communication for our citizens;
iii. the RT-PCR app, a hand-held tool for country-wide sample collection;
and
iv. a COVID-19 facility app which allows health system stakeholders up to
the district level to track the state and management of patients.
Institutionalising Pandemic Learnings: National Public Health
Observatory (NPHO)
India has established the National Public Health Observatory (NPHO) and
the Health Emergency Operations Centre (HEOC) for real-time monitoring
and analysis of various data points for informed decision-making. The
NPHO will ensure comprehensive monitoring of health systems, including"|data/MedicalDocuments/India/BuildingResilientDigitalHealthIndia.pdf|4|506570cee97045fdbbd6f6fa40148423
"overall healthcare service delivery, integration of healthcare programmes,
and transformation of the healthcare situation in the country."|data/MedicalDocuments/India/BuildingResilientDigitalHealthIndia.pdf|4|3ace18959abf4e81a8cb3d616aa96327
"87Building a Resilient Digital Health Ecosystem in India Leveraging AI for Improved Healthcare
Across the world, AI is being used in healthcare to support doctors and
healthcare workers, improve customer service and patient management, and
monitor diseases. The Indian government has established three centres of
excellence for AI—at the All India Institutes of Medical Sciences in Delhi
and Rishikesh, and at the Post Graduate Institute of Medical Education &
Research in Chandigarh—to leverage and identify potential areas for the
use of AI in the health sector. The centres are already working on several
solutions for healthcare which leverage generative AI, including:
i. a clinical decision support system, a multilingual solution to provide
diagnostic and triaging support to doctors;
ii. event-based disease surveillance to scan large volumes of digital media
in English as well as 10 Indian languages to monitor events that signal
an impending disease outbreak; and"|data/MedicalDocuments/India/BuildingResilientDigitalHealthIndia.pdf|5|eaa37a93bd1b4a7a9713e4186e935786
"an impending disease outbreak; and
iii. an AI assistant for frontline workers in 11 Indian languages to enable
and empower healthcare workers to ask questions and receive responses
to enhance their work.
Stimulating Advanced Knowledge for Sustainable Health
Management (SAKSHAM) Portal
The inclusive capacity building of health professionals is an important
component to ensure the efficient delivery of healthcare services across
the country. Tele-education has benefitted all fields of education including
medical education, especially for students in remote areas with limited access
to schools and qualified teachers. Online platforms, video conferencing,
and pre-recorded lectures have facilitated learning for students who were
previously deprived of quality education due to their geographical location.
Keeping this vision in mind, the government has developed a unified and
dedicated online learning and training platform, SAKSHAM,8 to enable"|data/MedicalDocuments/India/BuildingResilientDigitalHealthIndia.pdf|5|aa8d6614bfc94397897f73b56ab9c6ca
"health professionals to receive advanced training without any disruption in
their regular jobs. The portal hosts more than 200 courses on public health
and 150 on clinical practices."|data/MedicalDocuments/India/BuildingResilientDigitalHealthIndia.pdf|5|f473348c6cf242d3aa0a855283ed2af7
"88Accelerating Global Health: Pathways to Health Equity for the G20
89With such developments in digital health, India has leapfrogged in terms
of the adoption of digital health in the public sector. This will arguably
lead to the creation of a national digital health ecosystem through wide-
scale adoption of digital tools across the continuum of care, both in the
private and public sectors.
Promoting the Digital Health Agenda Globally
India has emerged as a frontrunner in championing digital health and
in positioning it as a critical agenda at the global level. Recognising
the transformative potential of technology in healthcare, India has
taken proactive steps to harness digital innovations, promote healthcare
accessibility, and drive advancements in the field globally.
India tabled the Digital Health Resolution in the 71st World Health
Assembly in May 2018 at Geneva, which was unanimously adopted by all"|data/MedicalDocuments/India/BuildingResilientDigitalHealthIndia.pdf|6|8b7151d4c540461bbb6c6d1cc46ca27c
"the member states of the World Health Organization (WHO). The resolution
highlighted global attention to the potential challenges and opportunities
related to digital health technology and need for close collaboration on the
issue globally. As a follow-up action, WHO has prioritised digital health
agenda by establishing the Department for Digital Health and Innovation in
April 2019 and published the Global Strategy on Digital Health 2020-2025 to
promote healthy lives and well-being for all.
India served as Chair of the Global Digital Health Partnership (GDHP,
between 2019 and 2021), which is the world’s largest intergovernmental
and multilateral forum on the issue of digital health. Under India’s
leadership, the GDHP’s membership grew from 14 to 33, including three
international organisations (WHO, Organisation for Economic Co-operation
and Development, and the International Digital Health and AI Research
Collaborative)."|data/MedicalDocuments/India/BuildingResilientDigitalHealthIndia.pdf|6|c8b5be8cbd904b85993063c806f35357
"Collaborative).
India’s G20 Leadership Catalysing Global Health Initiatives
India’s G20 presidency set ambitious goals to address the 21st century’s
greatest challenges such as climate change, food insecurity, the threat of"|data/MedicalDocuments/India/BuildingResilientDigitalHealthIndia.pdf|6|1084281ae25042bcabd574e63cb93cf0
"89Building a Resilient Digital Health Ecosystem in India future pandemics, and other health emergencies by building international
co-operation and strengthening global systems. The pandemic experience
has taught us that preventing and preparing for a health emergency must
always be a top priority at a global level, because when it comes to health,
“no one is safe until everyone is safe.”
Drawing from the lessons from the pandemic, the G20 Health Working
Group set out to catalyse and enervate global health initiatives. Through
four meetings, culminating in the health ministers’ meeting, three main
priorities were discussed:
i. prevention, preparedness, and response to health emergencies with
focus on anti-microbial resistance and ‘One Health’;
ii. strengthening cooperation in the pharmaceutical sector with focus on
availability and access to safe, effective, quality, and affordable medical
countermeasures, namely vaccines, therapeutics, and diagnostics; and"|data/MedicalDocuments/India/BuildingResilientDigitalHealthIndia.pdf|7|3a2b7bba4b20447bba50b43246d52bb9
"iii. digital health innovations and solutions to aid universal health coverage
and improve healthcare services delivery.
Digital health, the third priority under India’s G20 presidency aims to
leverage the country’s acumen and achievements along with other global
initiatives in the digital health space, and develop innovative digital health
solutions that can be applied across the world. A number of programmes
and projects seeking to develop digital health products are being initiated
independently. These projects are cumulatively spending billions of dollars
while working on similar aspects.
India’s G20 presidency has aimed to bring them all under the umbrella
of the Global Initiative on Digital Health (GIDH), a network managed by
WHO. The GIDH is an opportunity to create a globally connected digital
health ecosystem, converging worldwide efforts in scaling up commitments
and investments of relevant stakeholders and promotion of digital health"|data/MedicalDocuments/India/BuildingResilientDigitalHealthIndia.pdf|7|0409b3edab974d9abac6a39e22368ef3
"solutions as digital public goods. This will be achieved through coordinated
engagements and implementation aligned with WHO norms, standards, and"|data/MedicalDocuments/India/BuildingResilientDigitalHealthIndia.pdf|7|ed875ee5493d4896b733fb1ae7b9af2a
"90Accelerating Global Health: Pathways to Health Equity for the G20
91guidelines, while increasing transparency of resources being allocated to
digital transformation and identifying important gaps in support.
Conclusion
Adopting digital health is no longer a choice. The pandemic has undoubtedly
paved the way for the quick adoption of digital health. Digital health is
propelling the world towards more integrated health systems that are
focused on delivering patient-centred care, improving health outcomes, and
making the best use of healthcare resources. India’s digital health initiatives
such as the ABDM, CoWIN, and eSanjeevani have provided a stimulus to
act in conformity with a globally progressive commitment to health equity.
They have also enabled the country to work towards creating a movement
to enable integration of technology-informed models for universal health
coverage."|data/MedicalDocuments/India/BuildingResilientDigitalHealthIndia.pdf|8|cefde7e5f720409c906b7a789099ba0c
"coverage.
Lav Agarwal i s A d d i t i o n a l S e c r e t a r y f o r eHealth, International Health & Collaboration,
Public Health, and G20 at the Ministry of Health and Family Welfare, Government of
India."|data/MedicalDocuments/India/BuildingResilientDigitalHealthIndia.pdf|8|c5acb60e6fe04d2485554b4c5362cfc4
"93
9293Lessons from
India’s Digital Public
Infrastructure
Transformation
Sameer Kanwar and Varun Kumar
In today's rapidly evolving digital landscape, many countries are
striving to establish and strengthen digital public infrastructure (DPI)
to harness the transformative power of technology to benefit citizens. India
has emerged as a noteworthy example by successfully using technological
advancements to create robust DPI. It has implemented various initiatives
that mobilise technology for inclusive growth, economic development, and
improved governance. Countries around the world can learn from India’s
experience and achievements to initiate similar digital transformations.
Through the Digital India programme, India is seeking to digitally equip
citizens with access to all government services by improving internet
connectivity and developing online infrastructure. This encompasses three
key areas: (a) establishing a secure digital infrastructure; (b) successfully"|data/MedicalDocuments/India/LessonsIndiaDigitalHealthTfn.pdf|0|1b372b2c96bf4cf5be87c9ecf6535941
"delivering digital services; and (c) ensuring that every citizen has access
to the internet. India has also seen an increase in the number of digital
technology users, with an estimated 750 million smartphone users, and a
projected one billion users by 2025.1 This increase has generated demand
for a centralised digital architecture that functions as a single enterprise."|data/MedicalDocuments/India/LessonsIndiaDigitalHealthTfn.pdf|0|6fc85b4fdeef43289abba22a98b48bd1
"93Lessons from India’s Digital Public Infrastructure Transformation
93In 2018, the Ministry of Electronics and Information Technology (MeitY)
created the India Enterprise Architecture (IndEA) framework1 for the adoption
of a whole-of-government enterprise architecture by central ministries,
state departments, and public sector enterprises. Built with a focus on
performance, IndEA offers open standards to promote interoperability
and supports decentralisation. At the same time, it supports both new
(greenfield) and legacy (brownfield) e-governance initiatives. The emphasis
of the IndEA initiative is to enable “One Government – a government
that is least visible but is effective” by implementing the concept of
“virtualisation of departments” to activate synergy.2
Growing digitalisation will lead to the increased generation of data,
and consequently, data protection and ownership must be addressed at
the outset. The Data Empowerment and Protection Architecture (DEPA)"|data/MedicalDocuments/India/LessonsIndiaDigitalHealthTfn.pdf|1|bcba5a5d25d8471aafa6da4a13cbd5f0
"framework, introduced in 2020, seeks to ensure user control over data.
DEPA suggests measures for consent-governed and secure data-sharing
with third-party institutions. Controlled by consent managers, only relevant
user data is plugged in to any private ecosystem and there is no need
to set up bilateral databases.3 This empowers citizens with ownership and
control over their own data and how it is shared.
While DEPA has been flexibly applied in multiple sectors, it has been
particularly well-used as a techno-legal solution in the finance sector.
Since DEPA empowers individuals to securely share their financial data
with banks, insurers, investors, and other stakeholders, its first immediate
benefit has been to encourage competition among private players.
Individuals and small businesses are now able to get loans, insurance, and
other financial products at competitive rates, just by using their digital"|data/MedicalDocuments/India/LessonsIndiaDigitalHealthTfn.pdf|1|ad7832db5516440d84c6cfd72e7cd917
"footprint. In practice, DEPA works closely with the many layers of India
Stack4—Aadhaar-based e-KYC, Unified Payments Interface (UPI) for cashless
payments, and Aadhaar-based eSign) and uses the Open Credit Enablement
Network to facilitate lending. India Stack has enabled the country to build
its digital infrastructure, especially in establishing a design to improve
private sector service delivery, and has served as India’s digital library,
housing several digital global goods and offering learnings to the world.
Over the last decade, India has taken landmark steps to set in motion its
vision of becoming an inclusive digital economy. This includes establishing"|data/MedicalDocuments/India/LessonsIndiaDigitalHealthTfn.pdf|1|d5bb32aab9d64c40b61624e114470f5d
"94Accelerating Global Health: Pathways to Health Equity for the G20
95robust DPI and the facilitation of digital governance by streamlining
roles, accountability, and change management. This encompasses various
components, including digital identification systems, digital payments
systems, and digital service delivery platforms.
Pillars of Digital Public Infrastructure in India
The foundation: Aadhaar5
India's Aadhaar programme, a biometric and face authentication-based
digital identification system, has revolutionised identity verification
and service delivery in the country. Aadhaar has provided a unique
identification number to over 1.3 billion residents of India, enabling access
to essential services such as government subsidies, bank accounts, and
mobile connections. It has enabled the government to streamline service
delivery and eliminate duplication by providing a single digital identity
across multiple sectors. The world can learn from India's approach in"|data/MedicalDocuments/India/LessonsIndiaDigitalHealthTfn.pdf|2|0ffd7ae1eed043cbb84efab7d4513c47
"implementing a centralised, secure, and inclusive identification system, that
has facilitated interoperability across service delivery platforms, both public
and private.
Driving financial inclusion: Unified Payments Interface6
India's push to digitise payments has transformed the way financial
transactions are conducted in the country. The implementation of UPI has
created a platform that enables instant money transfers between bank
accounts. It offers a smartphone-based interface to support seamless,
interoperable, and real-time payments, available on the go. UPI has not only
transformed the way individuals transact but has also provided a significant
boost to the growth of the digital economy. Countries can gather important
lessons from India's experience in fostering a competitive and interoperable
payment ecosystem, which has led to increased financial inclusion, reduced
reliance on cash, and enhanced transparency in transactions."|data/MedicalDocuments/India/LessonsIndiaDigitalHealthTfn.pdf|2|323abf2e2dd640b68025a5e6b9346734
"The number of digital transactions increased by more than three times
from 3 billion in November 2019 to 10 billion by January 2023.7 A 2019"|data/MedicalDocuments/India/LessonsIndiaDigitalHealthTfn.pdf|2|2ed578303b5e4434844b6472c6c1a2a2
"95Lessons from India’s Digital Public Infrastructure Transformation MeitY study noted that under a ‘business as usual’ scenario, India’s
digital economy will grow to US$500 billion by 2025, with the potential
to increase to US$1 trillion.8 In 2021, India had 48.6 billion real-time
payments, as compared to 18.5 billion in China and 8.7 billion in Brazil.9
This is indicative of the ease with which the Indian population has adopted
digital platforms for making payments even if the average value of such
payments may be rather low.
Efficient welfare delivery: Direct Benefit Transfer10
India's Direct Benefit Transfer (DBT) programme is aimed at eliminating
potential leakages in the physical delivery of financial benefits and ensuring
an efficient transfer of welfare to the right beneficiaries. By leveraging
digital payment systems, benefits are directly credited to the beneficiaries’
bank accounts, reducing corruption, eliminating middlemen, and improving"|data/MedicalDocuments/India/LessonsIndiaDigitalHealthTfn.pdf|3|b9fc627dc58a4940915aefe392262ca3
"transparency in the transfer of subsidies.11 The enablers for DBT in India
are the Pradhan Mantri Jan-Dhan Yojana, the Jan Dhan-Aadhaar-Mobile
Yojana, and nearly 312 other schemes from 53 ministries across all states
and union territories. More than INR 24,800 billion has been transferred
through the DBT programme since 2013, with INR 6,300 billion transferred
in FY 2021-22 alone. On average, more than 9 million DBT payments were
processed daily in FY 2021-22.12
Citizen-centric services: E-governance13
India has leveraged technology to enhance governance and service delivery
through initiatives like Digital India and other e-governance platforms. The
use of digital platforms (or information and communication technologies)
has facilitated efficient and transparent administration, improved the
accessibility of government services, and reduced bureaucratic inefficiencies."|data/MedicalDocuments/India/LessonsIndiaDigitalHealthTfn.pdf|3|8045b63702f14e20aeecdab5e9d55069
"The MyGov platform14 h a s b e e n a c r u c i a l c o n t r i b u t o r t o t r a n s f o r m i n g c i t i z e n -
government interactions. India's approach to digital governance emphasises
citizen-centricity, where technology acts as an enabler to bridge the gap
between the government and its citizens. By adopting similar approaches,
countries can enhance government services, promote transparency, and
strengthen democratic participation."|data/MedicalDocuments/India/LessonsIndiaDigitalHealthTfn.pdf|3|5a6b176e0ea544508b33ab20d77ece86
"96Accelerating Global Health: Pathways to Health Equity for the G20
97Creating a digital ecosystem: Technology access and innovation
India has created a vibrant digital ecosystem that fosters innovation
and entrepreneurship. Initiatives like Startup India15 a n d M a k e i n I n d i a16
have encouraged the growth of technology start-ups and attracted global
investments. India has nurtured a conducive environment for technology
and innovation through policy reforms, access to funding, and incubation
support. Managed by the Department for Promotion of Industry and Internal
Trade under the commerce ministry, the Startup India initiative has helped
introduce various programmes that support entrepreneurs and create a
healthy start-up ecosystem. Similarly, the ‘Make in India’ initiative has
incentivised the development, manufacture, and assembly of products in the
country, and has thus boosted partnerships, investments, and innovations."|data/MedicalDocuments/India/LessonsIndiaDigitalHealthTfn.pdf|4|11dbcb29edd24ce9bdc983d9f6ef4703
"Growing digital literacy and inclusion in harnessing the benefits of
technology has also been crucial achievements for the country. India's
experience underscores the importance of widespread access to affordable
internet connectivity, digital skills training, and tailored initiatives for
marginalised communities. Initiatives like BharatNet,17 which aims to
connect over 250,000 local rural bodies with high-speed internet, and the
Common Service Centers,18 which provide access to government services in
remote areas, have been instrumental in extending the benefits of India’s
digital infrastructure to rural communities. In addition to the digital
training programmes offered through government-supported bodies like
the National Skills Development Centre19 and the National Institute for
Entrepreneurship and Small Business Development,20 other private training
institutes and online platforms have significantly contributed to digital skill"|data/MedicalDocuments/India/LessonsIndiaDigitalHealthTfn.pdf|4|b806fb3d2fe445c49eabb633e9c94715
"building among citizens, both in urban and rural settings. By prioritising
digital literacy and inclusion, countries can bridge the digital divide and
empower their citizens to participate fully in the digital age.
Key Drivers of India’s Digital Transformation
India’s achievements in implementing DPI demonstrate the transformative
power of technology when combined with inclusivity, scalability, regulation,
and collaboration. The key factors that equipped the country to achieve this
digital revolution include:"|data/MedicalDocuments/India/LessonsIndiaDigitalHealthTfn.pdf|4|4346c415761a400bbd13738d2880dc1d
"97Lessons from India’s Digital Public Infrastructure Transformation Ecosystem collaboration
India's success in digital service delivery can be attributed to strong
collaboration between government agencies, industry leaders, startups,
academia, and civil society organisations. This collaborative approach
has fostered innovation, shared expertise, and effective implementation.
India’s G20 presidency has further drawn attention to the importance
of collaboration, with initiatives like the Global DPI Summit21 allowing
a close agreement between partners (and non-partners alike) on the
common principles and design aspects of DPIs. By bringing together all the
stakeholders, the Indian government has created a collaborative environment
for developing and implementing digital public infrastructure projects.
Industry players have contributed their expertise, resources, and technological
innovations to build and maintain the required infrastructure. Similarly,"|data/MedicalDocuments/India/LessonsIndiaDigitalHealthTfn.pdf|5|72341765203b43498a676b032bedf44c
"collaborations with academic institutions and research organisations have
aided innovation and helped address technical and policy challenges. Public-
private partnerships and international collaborations have further supported
knowledge exchange, best practice sharing, and access to resources and
funding.
The Indian government has been able to promote such an ecosystem
collaboration by establishing platforms (such as, India Stack), forums (for
example, India Stack Knowledge Exchange Forum, 202222), and regulatory
frameworks (IndEA and DEPA) that encourage active participation,
information sharing, and coordination between different stakeholders.
These collaborations prioritise interoperability, data privacy, security, and
scalability to build a robust and sustainable DPI in the country.
Scalability and inclusion
India's experience in scaling up its DPI demonstrates the significance
of inclusivity, with the most successful case being that of its digital"|data/MedicalDocuments/India/LessonsIndiaDigitalHealthTfn.pdf|5|53c1745ea8864bdcb280f11902de0be2
"identification system. MeitY, in response to an unstarred question in the
upper house of Parliament (in July 2022), said that out of the approximate
projected population of 1.37 billion, around 1.27 billion held a live Aadhaar
number.23 By ensuring accessibility and ease of enrollment for all citizens,"|data/MedicalDocuments/India/LessonsIndiaDigitalHealthTfn.pdf|5|0c64ee48cf0246289234f29befd7b34e
"98Accelerating Global Health: Pathways to Health Equity for the G20
99including marginalised communities, India has achieved a notable level of
inclusivity. While there are gaps in digital inclusion across demographic
locations (55 percent share of urban telephone subscribers, as of December
202224) and gender (11 percent gender gap in mobile ownership, 202325),
the country is consistently invested in closing this difference.
India’s digital infrastructure has been created keeping in mind future
needs and potential growth. With a quantum increase in users connected
to the internet, the emergence of multiple types of intermediaries (digital
media, e-commerce, and others), and the possible use of connectivity to
cause harm or commit crimes cannot be ignored. Comprehensive measures
need to be taken to prepare for the future. To check a potential DPI’s
scalability even before introduction, significant emphasis has been placed"|data/MedicalDocuments/India/LessonsIndiaDigitalHealthTfn.pdf|6|c4df77774a1644f7854fce36f38dd1c9
"on considerations like robust technology frameworks, interoperability, open
Application Programming Interfaces, data management, and addressing
infrastructure gaps.
India’s journey is an example of how scalability and inclusion work
together in building a resilient and equitable digital public infrastructure.
Key strategies that have helped the country’s efforts to establish its
infrastructure at scale are ensuring accessibility, promoting digital literacy
and skill development, focus on last-mile connectivity, multilingual support
in technological solutions, participatory implementation, and regulations to
ensure affordability.
Balancing regulation and innovation
India's digital payments ecosystem demonstrates the need to strike a
balance between regulation and innovation. While fostering competition and
innovation, the country has implemented robust regulatory measures to
ensure the security and integrity of transactions."|data/MedicalDocuments/India/LessonsIndiaDigitalHealthTfn.pdf|6|8b202115529b413e805052339024fb38
"Putting in place provisions like regulatory sandboxes, which provide a
controlled environment for testing innovative technologies and business
models, has allowed experimentation and innovation, while ensuring
consumer protection and risk mitigation. At the same time, taking a"|data/MedicalDocuments/India/LessonsIndiaDigitalHealthTfn.pdf|6|095821a0ae1b48d4bc4127dd272e8e30
"99Lessons from India’s Digital Public Infrastructure Transformation collaborative approach by establishing forums and platforms for stakeholders
to engage in policy discussions and regulatory consultations has helped
in understanding their needs and concerns, thus informing the adoption
of balanced regulatory policies. Recognising the fast-paced nature of the
digital landscape, Indian regulators have also shown agility in updating and
adapting regulations. Recent policy measures like the introduction of the
Digital Personal Data Protection Bill 2022,26 which restricts the processing
of personal data until after the individual’s consent has been recorded, and
the presentation of the Digital India Act 2023,27 to set up global standard
cyber laws, have demonstrated a willingness to understand and respond to
consumer needs, emerging technologies, and market trends.
While India has made strides in regulation and innovation, challenges"|data/MedicalDocuments/India/LessonsIndiaDigitalHealthTfn.pdf|7|450a40f14b1e45e48521b712958e128a
"remain. Striking the right balance between the two requires continuous
monitoring, assessment, and adaptation of regulatory frameworks to keep
pace with evolving technologies and market dynamics. Employing these
efforts at the desired scale in the country would require infrastructure,
investment, and a strong commitment. Ongoing collaboration between
regulators, industry players, and other stakeholders will be crucial to
maintaining an innovation-friendly environment while upholding consumer
protection and addressing emerging risks.
Conclusion
India's DPI provides valuable lessons on the advantages of harnessing
technology for inclusive growth, economic development, and improved
governance. Through initiatives like Aadhaar, UPI, digital health
infrastructure, DBT, e-governance, regulatory frameworks, and creating an
enabling digital ecosystem, India has been able to unlock the transformative
potential of DPI. By focusing on the key lessons from India's experience,"|data/MedicalDocuments/India/LessonsIndiaDigitalHealthTfn.pdf|7|8efb3d0a66f64a69b8b91f270d852d52
"other countries can implement similar DPIs to address their unique
challenges and leverage the potential of technology for the benefit of their
citizens."|data/MedicalDocuments/India/LessonsIndiaDigitalHealthTfn.pdf|7|9ea22e2775f04d79a52b48481a4704fb
"100Accelerating Global Health: Pathways to Health Equity for the G20
101These countries must consider their contextual differences based on
population size, level of technological development, political priorities, and
policy outlooks to customise their learnings to suit their specific needs and
challenges. As the world embraces the digital era, India's DPI experience
can serve as inspiration and guide for building robust digital systems that
could foster inclusive societies and drive sustainable development in the
21st century.
Sameer Kanwar is Director, Digital Health, India and South Asia Hub, PATH .
Varun Kumar is Senior Program Officer, PATH."|data/MedicalDocuments/India/LessonsIndiaDigitalHealthTfn.pdf|8|ee322f1af7c94acd8e538b65f908692d