Skip to content

armgit / moss

Public Imported from GitHub
0

MOSS: a small, mostly 3D-printed litter-picking rover. Cleaner streets, one maker at a time.

Python

docs: itemize prototype and experimental Pi build budgets

metrox09720e9e0fd9
diff --git a/NOTICE b/NOTICE
index 038126c..4388ca0 100644
--- a/NOTICE
+++ b/NOTICE
@@ -7,3 +7,7 @@ Hardware design files and documentation (docs/, hardware/, media/): CC BY 4.0.
moss_dimos/gamepad.py is derived from vector-dimos (https://github.com/metrox-eth/vector-dimos),
Copyright 2026 Laurent Genoud, Apache-2.0, itself an external blueprint for dimOS
(https://github.com/dimensionalOS/dimos), Copyright 2025 Dimensional Inc., Apache-2.0.
+
+Third-party photographs and trademarks appearing in the 21 September 2026
+BOM comparison video are excluded from the above CC BY 4.0 grant.
+See media/MOSS_cost_comparison_20260921_credits.md for attribution.
diff --git a/README.md b/README.md
index 3306474..da6fb68 100644
--- a/README.md
+++ b/README.md
@@ -2,7 +2,7 @@
Cleaner streets, one maker at a time.
-MOSS is a small litter-picking rover you can print and build yourself: a tracked base, a bin, and an arm derived from the SO-101 with a parallel gripper. About 500 to 700 USD in parts, plus a Jetson. It is being built in public, from a living room in Hua Hin, Thailand. Nothing here is finished; everything here is real.
+MOSS is a small litter-picking rover you can print and build yourself: a tracked base, a bin, and an arm derived from the SO-101 with a parallel gripper. About $1,700 in parts as built, with a Jetson and a RealSense; a Raspberry Pi version around $820 is the next experiment. It is being built in public, from a living room in Hua Hin, Thailand. Nothing here is finished; everything here is real.
![MOSS exploded view, turntable](media/images/moss_exploded_turntable.gif)
@@ -20,6 +20,16 @@ All 113 printed parts are on the bench, with the shafts, bearings and screws to
Every step is written down when it is real, good or bad. The [build log](docs/build_log.md) has the dates and the numbers, the [assembly feedback](docs/assembly_feedback.md) has what did not fit, the [roadmap](docs/roadmap.md) has what comes next, without dates.
+## What does it cost?
+
+| Build | Parts estimate |
+|---|---:|
+| As built: Jetson Orin Nano Super, RealSense D455, 2 TB SSD | about $1,680 |
+| Next experiment: Raspberry Pi 5, Mighty Camera | $820 |
+| Next experiment: Raspberry Pi 5, ST 3D time-of-flight | $821 |
+
+Replacement-cost estimates for every part, not receipts. The Pi builds keep the same chassis, arm and drivetrain, and have not been tested yet. Every line, assumption and source is in the [itemized budget](docs/bom-costs.md); the [45-second comparison](media/video/MOSS_cost_comparison_20260921.mp4) tells it in pictures.
+
## Try the demo
Jev, TypeSafe AI's decision model, choosing every step of a pickup (approach, align, grasp, lift, carry, release) on physics recorded once in MuJoCo, replayed in 3D in your browser. Three missions with real Jev decisions, plus the earlier target-choice scenarios: https://www.showrobotics.ai/moss-jev/
diff --git a/docs/bom-costs.md b/docs/bom-costs.md
new file mode 100644
index 0000000..64f9adb
--- /dev/null
+++ b/docs/bom-costs.md
@@ -0,0 +1,114 @@
+# MOSS parts budget — prototype and Raspberry Pi experiments
+
+**21 September 2026 · USD · hardware prototype V0.3**
+
+This comparison replaces the initial $500–700 target excluding the Jetson. It values reused hardware at replacement cost so that a new builder can see the scope. It is not the prototype's actual cash expenditure, a supplier quote, or a validated kit BOM. The [current hardware inventory](bom.md) and [113-piece print inventory](printed_parts.md) remain separate references.
+
+## Three configurations
+
+| Budget category | Prototype: Jetson + D455 | Pi 5 + Mighty | Pi 5 + ST ToF |
+|---|---:|---:|---:|
+| Shared mechanics, arm/gripper, drive, control and power | $480 | $480 | $480 |
+| Computer, cooling and computer-specific power | $480 | $203 | $203 |
+| Storage | $250: 2 TB SSD allowance | $15: 128 GB microSD | $15: 128 GB microSD |
+| Sensors and dedicated connections | $466 | $122 | $123 |
+| **Estimated total** | **$1,676** | **$820** | **$821** |
+| Optional Hailo AI HAT+ | — | +$70 | +$70 |
+
+The video rounds the prototype to **about $1,680**. The two Pi columns are alternatives, not a combined sensor stack. Neither contains a Jetson, RealSense or 2D lidar. Both retain a colour camera for litter detection. The prototype retains its 2 TB SSD; the Pi budgets use microSD only.
+
+**The $250 SSD amount is an unverified allowance**, not a confirmed model or paid price. Change it dollar-for-dollar when the actual value is available. Of the $856 difference between prototype and Pi/Mighty, $235 comes from changing storage. With a $15 storage allowance on both sides, the difference would be $621. No equivalent navigation or inference performance has been demonstrated.
+
+## Shared parts — $480
+
+All amounts below are estimates or rounded budget allowances. Quantities are planning quantities; confirm them against the final assembly before purchasing. The CF35-12 allowance rounds a $49.99 supplier listing. Servo gearing and motor specifications still need exact purchasable references.
+
+| Item | Quantity | Unit / lot USD | Line USD |
+|---|---:|---:|---:|
+| Espressif ESP32-S3-DevKitC-1 | 1 | 13 | 13 |
+| Waveshare Bus Servo Adapter (A) V1.1 | 1 | 5 | 5 |
+| Cytron MD10C R3 motor driver | 2 | 18 | 36 |
+| 12 V geared DC motor with quadrature encoder | 2 | 15 | 30 |
+| ST3215 12 V arm joint servo | 5 | 22 | 110 |
+| CF35-12 constant-force gripper servo | 1 | 50 | 50 |
+| Assembled 3S battery with BMS, replacement allowance | 1 | 35 | 35 |
+| Compatible 12.6 V CC/CV charger | 1 | 12 | 12 |
+| Accessible motor/servo power cut, fuse holders, fuses and distribution | 1 lot | 18 | 18 |
+| Power/signal wiring, XT60, ferrules, terminals and heat-shrink | 1 lot | 15 | 15 |
+| USB control cables for ESP32 and servo adapter | 1 lot | 10 | 10 |
+| INA219 battery-voltage monitor | 1 | 5 | 5 |
+| Bearings: 12 × 625, 4 × 608, 4 × 626 | 20; lot budget | 12 | 12 |
+| Shaft collars: 12 × Ø5, 4 × Ø8, 2 × Ø6 mm | 18; lot budget | 18 | 18 |
+| Shaft stock: Ø5 × 500, Ø6 × 250, Ø8 × 250 mm | 1 of each; lot | 8 | 8 |
+| Rigid Ø6–Ø6 mm couplings, Ø14 × 22 mm envelope | 2 | 2.5 | 5 |
+| Compatible metal hex wheel hubs | 2 | 1.5 | 3 |
+| Screws, nuts, washers, inserts and small spacers | 1 lot | 15 | 15 |
+| Black PETG filament | 2 kg | 18 | 36 |
+| PLA filament | 1 kg | 14 | 14 |
+| TPU 95A filament | 1 kg | 25 | 25 |
+| Enclosure ventilation, fan/filter/grille | 1 lot | 5 | 5 |
+| **Shared total** | | | **480** |
+
+- The arm budget is **five ST3215 joint servos plus one CF35-12 for the MOSS gripper**. It is not the standard SO-101 servo set.
+- Battery and charger are replacement allowances. The prototype uses a reused pack; this table does not establish its capacity, BMS thresholds or runtime. A future pack design needs its own qualification.
+- The INA219 line budgets voltage monitoring. The prototype's R100 shunt is bypassed by motor current; this is not a main-rail current measurement design.
+- The power/distribution allowance does not specify a final whole-robot fuse rating. The existing 5 A bench-test rating is not a completed rover rating.
+- Filament amounts budget whole spools, not measured part masses. Use the print inventory for each part's material; buying lots of fasteners or bearings may cost more than the consumed quantities shown here.
+- Shaft stock, hub fits and fasteners must be checked against the assembled revision. These budget lines do not replace cutting drawings. Remove the hub allowance if hubs are included with the motors. The prototype's earlier hardware order is already represented by these lines; do not add its entire order total again.
+
+Shared category subtotals used in the video: arm/gripper $160; motors/drivers $66; mechanics/filament $136; control/power/wiring/ventilation $118.
+
+## Compute and storage
+
+| Item | Prototype | Each Pi option | Price basis |
+|---|---:|---:|---|
+| Jetson Orin Nano Super 8 GB kit, cooling included | $480 | — | Current sourcing reference reported by the builder |
+| Raspberry Pi 5 8 GB | — | $175 | Selected budget reference; PiShop listing |
+| Active Pi cooler | — | $8 | Estimate |
+| Battery-to-Pi regulated supply, target 5.1 V / 5 A continuous | — | $20 | Estimate; module and interface not qualified |
+| 2 TB SSD | $250 | — | Allowance; model and paid price unconfirmed |
+| 128 GB A2 microSD | — | $15 | Estimate |
+| **Compute, cooling, specific power and storage** | **$730** | **$218** | |
+
+The Jetson boots from the prototype battery in the reported assembly. No extra Pi-specific converter is charged to that column. The Pi needs a suitable power path for both board and peripherals; verify voltage, current capability and USB-C current recognition where applicable. The $20 allowance is not approval of an arbitrary buck converter.
+
+## Sensor options
+
+| Item | Prototype | Pi + Mighty | Pi + ST | Price basis |
+|---|---:|---:|---:|---|
+| RealSense D455, RGB and IMU included | $466 | — | — | Builder's paid price |
+| Mighty Camera, onboard IMU | — | $92 | — | Paid price; ordered 21 September |
+| STEVAL-VL53L9 evaluation board | — | — | $80 | Paid price; ordered 21 September |
+| Fixed colour USB UVC camera | — | $25 | $25 | Estimate |
+| Separate compatible IMU | — | — | $8 | Estimate |
+| Dedicated sensor connection / adaptation | — | $5 | $10 | Estimate; ST adapter not yet identified |
+| **Sensor subtotal** | **$466** | **$122** | **$123** | |
+
+**Mighty:** onboard visual-inertial pose estimation, with a monochrome tracking camera and IMU. Its loop-closure feature is documented as beta and disabled by default; it should not be treated as a proven persistent map. Obstacle mapping and integration with dimOS on the Pi remain to be tested. The separate RGB camera is for colour litter detection.
+
+**ST:** the VL53L9CX evaluation board provides 3D ToF depth, with 2.3K zones and a manufacturer-stated range up to 9 m under suitable conditions. It is a forward depth sensor, not a 360° 2D scanner or a complete SLAM system. Localisation would combine encoders, an IMU and geometric/visual correction. Pi driver, MIPI/I3C connection, acquisition, power and RGB/depth calibration remain to be qualified. The supplier estimates one unit in stock on **28 October 2026**; that is not a guaranteed delivery date.
+
+Both sensors were ordered; neither alternative navigation configuration has been validated on MOSS. dimOS is the intended software stack for the experiments. Test detection rate, tracking drift, low obstacles, outdoor behaviour, RAM use and thermal limits before describing either as a reproducible navigation build.
+
+## Optional accelerator and exclusions
+
+A **Raspberry Pi AI HAT+ 13 TOPS (Hailo-8L)** adds a $70 budget reference: **$890 / $891** with Mighty / ST. It is optional. It needs a compatible detector and software stack; it does not automatically accelerate mapping or replace CUDA across the application.
+
+A wrist camera, gamepad, tools, printer, labour, development computer, electricity and API/service usage are not included in any column. Additional shipping, import costs and taxes are not added; reported paid prices may already contain some charges that are not itemised. Most lines are estimates, so allow a separate contingency before buying. This is a component budget, not a selling price.
+
+## Sources and price provenance
+
+Accessed for the 21 September comparison; prices and availability vary by location.
+
+- [Raspberry Pi 5 8 GB — PiShop](https://www.pishop.us/product/raspberry-pi-5-8gb/): $175 budget reference retained for both Pi builds.
+- [Raspberry Pi AI HAT+](https://www.raspberrypi.com/products/ai-hat/): optional 13 TOPS board.
+- [Mighty documentation](https://mightycamera.com/docs), [SDK](https://mightycamera.com/docs/sdk) and [development history](https://mightycamera.com/story).
+- [STEVAL-VL53L9 — STMicroelectronics](https://www.st.com/en/evaluation-tools/steval-vl53l9.html): evaluation board specifications and interfaces.
+- [CF35-12 — Waveshare](https://www.waveshare.com/product/robotics/motors-servos/servos/cf35-12.htm): rounded $50 allowance.
+- [Waveshare Bus Servo Adapter (A)](https://docs.waveshare.com/Bus_Servo_Adapter_A): interface reference.
+- Jetson $480: builder-reported current price. RealSense $466, Mighty $92 and ST $80: builder-reported paid prices, not guaranteed retail offers. A separately reported Thai Jetson quote of 19,600 THB is not treated as equivalent to $480.
+- All other amounts, including the $250 SSD, are allowances rather than verified purchase prices.
+
+## Media
+
+[45-second video](../media/video/MOSS_cost_comparison_20260921.mp4) · [Poster](../media/images/MOSS_cost_comparison_20260921.jpg) · [Media credits](../media/MOSS_cost_comparison_20260921_credits.md)
diff --git a/docs/bom.md b/docs/bom.md
index e78c85a..21bfb3c 100644
--- a/docs/bom.md
+++ b/docs/bom.md
@@ -1,6 +1,8 @@
# Bill of materials (work in progress)
-Target: 500 to 700 USD in parts plus a Jetson, before tax and shipping. Prices are not listed yet; they will be once the first unit is complete and the list is stable.
+The initial $500–700 target excluding the Jetson has been superseded by an [itemized comparison dated 21 September 2026](bom-costs.md): approximately **$1,680 for the Jetson / RealSense prototype configuration**, including an estimated $250 for its 2 TB SSD, and **$820 / $821 for experimental Pi 5 configurations** using Mighty Camera / ST 3D ToF and microSD storage.
+
+These are planning budgets using replacement values for reused hardware, not a receipt total. Additional tax and shipping are not added. The Pi configurations are not yet navigation-tested; the hardware inventory below continues to describe the V0.3 prototype.
## Printed parts
@@ -27,8 +29,9 @@ The authoritative list is the [printed-parts inventory](printed_parts.md) (113 p
Not printed: metal HEX12 hubs, bearings, shaft collars, motor–shaft couplings, servo horns, fasteners.
## Electronics (as selected on 20 September 2026, after the first harness bench tests)
-- Jetson Orin Nano 8 GB (brain), in its original plastic base; Wi-Fi on the Jetson side
-- Intel RealSense depth camera (the IMU comes from it)
+- Jetson Orin Nano Super 8 GB (brain), retaining its original plastic base; Wi-Fi on the Jetson side
+- 2 TB SSD
+- Intel RealSense D455 depth camera (RGB and IMU included)
- Espressif ESP32-S3-DevKitC-1 V1.1: motor controller (PWM/DIR for both drivers, both quadrature encoders, I²C to the INA219); see [`firmware/`](../firmware/README.md) for the wiring map
- 2 × Cytron MD10C R3 motor drivers
- 2 × geared DC motors with quadrature encoders
@@ -49,7 +52,8 @@ Cabling: same wire for the main runs and the driver branches, runs of 25–30 cm
- Fasteners M3 and M4
## Arm
-- SO-101 derived arm (6 DoF)
-- NormaCore parallel gripper
+- SO-101-derived arm: five ST3215 12 V joint servos
+- NormaCore-derived parallel gripper: one CF35-12 constant-force servo
+- This is the MOSS servo configuration, not the unmodified six-servo SO-101 kit BOM.
![Mechanical hardware](../media/images/build_05_hardware_ordered_20260917.jpg)
diff --git a/docs/build_log.md b/docs/build_log.md
index d2213f9..6bdc634 100644
--- a/docs/build_log.md
+++ b/docs/build_log.md
@@ -86,3 +86,11 @@ First assembly of the electronics inside the printed chassis: motors, drivers, E
First reality checks: some components ended up elsewhere than planned in CAD. The differences go into [assembly_feedback.md](assembly_feedback.md) as they are measured, and into the next hardware revision. No drive test yet.
+
+## 2026-09-21 — cost comparison and alternative sensors ordered
+
+Mighty Camera ($92 paid) and a STEVAL-VL53L9 evaluation board ($80 paid) were ordered to explore lower-cost navigation. The proposed computer is a Raspberry Pi 5 8 GB, budgeted at $175, with microSD storage. These are two alternative configurations, each retaining the tracked base and the MOSS arm and gripper. Navigation and detection on the Pi still need to be tested with dimOS.
+
+The [new itemized budget](bom-costs.md) is $820 with Mighty or $821 with ST, compared with $1,676 for the Jetson / RealSense prototype configuration including a $250 allowance for its 2 TB SSD. These are replacement-cost planning figures, not actual expenditure. They supersede the initial $500–700 excluding Jetson target recorded on 15 September; that entry remains as history.
+
+[Comparison video, 45 seconds](../media/video/MOSS_cost_comparison_20260921.mp4).
diff --git a/docs/concept.md b/docs/concept.md
index 00947d4..478fedf 100644
--- a/docs/concept.md
+++ b/docs/concept.md
@@ -9,7 +9,7 @@ MOSS is a litter-picking rover for sidewalks, roadsides and parks: small enough
- Tracked base (two motors with encoders, differential drive), printed tracks in TPU.
- Collection bin on top, emptied by hand at the end of a run.
- Arm derived from the SO-101 (6 DoF, open source) with a NormaCore parallel gripper.
-- Brain: Jetson Orin Nano 8 GB, mounted in a printed cartridge. The cartridge is the modular part: print a different one and a Raspberry Pi takes the Jetson's place for a teleop-only build (MOSS Lite). Perception: an Intel RealSense depth camera.
+- Current compute and perception: Jetson Orin Nano Super 8 GB, 2 TB SSD and RealSense D455. The intended compute cartridge is modular; the first prototype placement has changed during assembly. A lower-cost Raspberry Pi 5 build with alternative navigation sensors is being explored, starting with teleop and then testing dimOS navigation. [Budget and integration work](bom-costs.md).
- Software: dimOS for navigation and teleop, LeRobot for data and policies.
The criterion we use for success: pick up more litter with less technology. Every added part has to earn its place against a person with a bag.
diff --git a/docs/roadmap.md b/docs/roadmap.md
index 7d02f28..5d7581f 100644
--- a/docs/roadmap.md
+++ b/docs/roadmap.md
@@ -6,4 +6,4 @@
- **Later**: first policy; first autonomous pick on video; kits so the first hundred builders do not have to source parts themselves.
No dates. Each step is posted when it is real.
-- **MOSS Lite**: the same base with a Raspberry Pi in the compute cartridge instead of the Jetson, teleop and data collection only, for builders without a Jetson.
+- **Lower-cost Pi build (experimental)**: Raspberry Pi 5 8 GB with either Mighty Camera or STEVAL-VL53L9 3D ToF, plus a colour camera. Start with teleop and data collection, then evaluate navigation and detection with dimOS on the Pi. Next: mount and test both sensors with dimOS, teleop and data collection first, then navigation and detection. Nothing is validated until it runs on the rover.
diff --git a/media/MOSS_cost_comparison_20260921_credits.md b/media/MOSS_cost_comparison_20260921_credits.md
new file mode 100644
index 0000000..023cd3c
--- /dev/null
+++ b/media/MOSS_cost_comparison_20260921_credits.md
@@ -0,0 +1,12 @@
+# MOSS hardware cost comparison — 21 September 2026
+
+Video: `video/MOSS_cost_comparison_20260921.mp4` (45 seconds, 1920 × 1080, 30 fps). Poster: `images/MOSS_cost_comparison_20260921.jpg`.
+
+MOSS prototype footage and CAD animation: Show Robotics / Laurent Genoud. Music: newly synthesised instrumental, with no third-party samples or original camera audio. Typography: Space Grotesk. Budget figures and assumptions: [itemized BOM](../docs/bom-costs.md).
+
+Product photography shown for identification and comparison:
+
+- Mighty Camera: [manufacturer story](https://mightycamera.com/story), [source photograph](https://mightycamera.com/logs-media/2067991167195857008-1-2067805782247440384.jpg).
+- STMicroelectronics STEVAL-VL53L9: [manufacturer product page](https://www.st.com/en/evaluation-tools/steval-vl53l9.html); photograph retrieved from [publicly shared product image](https://pbs.twimg.com/media/HLroGirXQAAHw0V.jpg).
+
+Third-party product photographs and trademarks retain their respective owners' rights and are not offered under the repository's CC BY 4.0 licence. No separate permission or open licence for those photographs has been established. Original phone footage and standalone manufacturer image files are not part of this update.
diff --git a/media/images/MOSS_cost_comparison_20260921.jpg b/media/images/MOSS_cost_comparison_20260921.jpg
new file mode 100644
index 0000000..17c795e
Binary files /dev/null and b/media/images/MOSS_cost_comparison_20260921.jpg differ
diff --git a/media/video/MOSS_cost_comparison_20260921.mp4 b/media/video/MOSS_cost_comparison_20260921.mp4
new file mode 100644
index 0000000..780ab83
Binary files /dev/null and b/media/video/MOSS_cost_comparison_20260921.mp4 differ