Skip to content

armgit / mso

Public Imported from GitHub
0

Browser-based graphical shell and control plane for a Linux server you own — real terminal, file manager, live metrics and BYOK AI in one mobile-first workspace. Next.js 16 · React 19 · node-pty · Tailwind v4 · shadcn/ui. Public alpha, self-hosted.

docs(comparison): use explicit SEO-friendly ratings

Rahman72f0e8baa095
diff --git a/README.md b/README.md
index d1939071..9fe569d9 100644
--- a/README.md
+++ b/README.md
@@ -283,20 +283,20 @@ Deep dive: [docs/ARCHITECTURE.md](./docs/ARCHITECTURE.md).
<!-- comparison:start -->
**Positioning:** MSO is designed to be the most complete mobile-first, AI-native private Linux workspace for an owner or small trusted team. It does not claim to replace specialist products at their strongest specialty.
-● strong · ◐ partial/scope-limited · — not a product surface
+Strong = a first-class product strength · Partial = available with scope limitations · Not offered = not a core product surface
-| Product | Best fit | Workspace | Host ops | Delivery | Observability | Delegation | AI / MCP |
+| Product | Best fit | Browser workspace | Linux host administration | Application delivery | Monitoring and observability | Roles and delegation | Built-in AI and MCP |
|---|---|:---:|:---:|:---:|:---:|:---:|:---:|
-| **MSO** | Mobile-first private Linux workspace | ● | ◐ | ◐ | ◐ | ◐ | ● |
-| **Cockpit** | Deep graphical Linux administration | ◐ | ● | ◐ | ◐ | ● | — |
-| **Coolify** | Self-hosted Git/PaaS delivery | ◐ | ◐ | ● | ◐ | ● | — |
-| **Portainer** | Container and stack operations | ◐ | ◐ | ● | ◐ | ◐ | — |
-| **Netdata** | High-resolution observability and RCA | ◐ | — | — | ● | ◐ | ◐ |
-| **Tailscale SSH** | Identity-aware private remote access | — | ◐ | — | — | ● | — |
-| **File Browser** | Focused web file management | ◐ | — | — | — | ◐ | — |
-| **ttyd** | Small, focused web terminal | ◐ | — | — | — | ◐ | — |
-| **CasaOS** | Friendly personal-cloud home server | ◐ | ◐ | ◐ | ◐ | — | — |
-| **Runtipi** | Curated one-click self-hosted apps | ◐ | — | ● | ◐ | — | — |
+| **MSO** | Mobile-first private Linux workspace | Strong | Partial | Partial | Partial | Partial | Strong |
+| **Cockpit** | Deep graphical Linux administration | Partial | Strong | Partial | Partial | Strong | Not offered |
+| **Coolify** | Self-hosted Git/PaaS delivery | Partial | Partial | Strong | Partial | Strong | Not offered |
+| **Portainer** | Container and stack operations | Partial | Partial | Strong | Partial | Partial | Not offered |
+| **Netdata** | High-resolution observability and RCA | Partial | Not offered | Not offered | Strong | Partial | Partial |
+| **Tailscale SSH** | Identity-aware private remote access | Not offered | Partial | Not offered | Not offered | Strong | Not offered |
+| **File Browser** | Focused web file management | Partial | Not offered | Not offered | Not offered | Partial | Not offered |
+| **ttyd** | Small, focused web terminal | Partial | Not offered | Not offered | Not offered | Partial | Not offered |
+| **CasaOS** | Friendly personal-cloud home server | Partial | Partial | Partial | Partial | Not offered | Not offered |
+| **Runtipi** | Curated one-click self-hosted apps | Partial | Not offered | Strong | Partial | Not offered | Not offered |
Reviewed against official product documentation on **2026-08-29**. Ratings describe product scope, not benchmark scores. See [methodology, evidence, and per-cell notes](docs/COMPARISON.md) and the [execution roadmap](docs/COMPETITIVE-ROADMAP.md).
<!-- comparison:end -->
diff --git a/docs/COMPARISON.md b/docs/COMPARISON.md
index 07610312..b30eb70f 100644
--- a/docs/COMPARISON.md
+++ b/docs/COMPARISON.md
@@ -8,51 +8,51 @@ MSO is designed to be the most complete mobile-first, AI-native private Linux wo
## Method
- Ratings describe the documented product surface, not speed, popularity, or a universal winner.
-- `●` means a first-class strength, `◐` means partial or deliberately narrow scope, and `—` means it is not a meaningful product surface.
+- `Strong` means a first-class product strength, `Partial` means available with deliberate scope limitations, and `Not offered` means it is not a core product surface.
- MSO cells must point to repository evidence that exists at build time.
- Competitor claims use official project documentation only and must be manually re-reviewed before the freshness window expires.
- Edition-dependent or adjacent capabilities are marked partial unless they are consistently core to the product.
## Criteria
-### Workspace
+### Browser workspace
A unified browser workspace with mobile-aware navigation across files, terminal, editors, apps, and host views.
-### Host ops
+### Linux host administration
General Linux host operations such as services, logs, package visibility, network, storage, users, and system configuration.
-### Delivery
+### Application delivery
Application/container deployment, Git integration, previews, lifecycle, backups, and rollback.
-### Observability
+### Monitoring and observability
Metrics, history, alerting, anomaly detection, correlations, and incident analysis.
-### Delegation
+### Roles and delegation
Least-privilege roles, multiple identities/devices, auditability, and SSO or policy integration.
-### AI / MCP
+### Built-in AI and MCP
Built-in AI assistance plus structured remote tool/API control of the workspace.
## Matrix
-| Product | Best fit | Workspace | Host ops | Delivery | Observability | Delegation | AI / MCP |
+| Product | Best fit | Browser workspace | Linux host administration | Application delivery | Monitoring and observability | Roles and delegation | Built-in AI and MCP |
|---|---|:---:|:---:|:---:|:---:|:---:|:---:|
-| **MSO** | Mobile-first private Linux workspace | ● | ◐ | ◐ | ◐ | ◐ | ● |
-| **Cockpit** | Deep graphical Linux administration | ◐ | ● | ◐ | ◐ | ● | — |
-| **Coolify** | Self-hosted Git/PaaS delivery | ◐ | ◐ | ● | ◐ | ● | — |
-| **Portainer** | Container and stack operations | ◐ | ◐ | ● | ◐ | ◐ | — |
-| **Netdata** | High-resolution observability and RCA | ◐ | — | — | ● | ◐ | ◐ |
-| **Tailscale SSH** | Identity-aware private remote access | — | ◐ | — | — | ● | — |
-| **File Browser** | Focused web file management | ◐ | — | — | — | ◐ | — |
-| **ttyd** | Small, focused web terminal | ◐ | — | — | — | ◐ | — |
-| **CasaOS** | Friendly personal-cloud home server | ◐ | ◐ | ◐ | ◐ | — | — |
-| **Runtipi** | Curated one-click self-hosted apps | ◐ | — | ● | ◐ | — | — |
+| **MSO** | Mobile-first private Linux workspace | Strong | Partial | Partial | Partial | Partial | Strong |
+| **Cockpit** | Deep graphical Linux administration | Partial | Strong | Partial | Partial | Strong | Not offered |
+| **Coolify** | Self-hosted Git/PaaS delivery | Partial | Partial | Strong | Partial | Strong | Not offered |
+| **Portainer** | Container and stack operations | Partial | Partial | Strong | Partial | Partial | Not offered |
+| **Netdata** | High-resolution observability and RCA | Partial | Not offered | Not offered | Strong | Partial | Partial |
+| **Tailscale SSH** | Identity-aware private remote access | Not offered | Partial | Not offered | Not offered | Strong | Not offered |
+| **File Browser** | Focused web file management | Partial | Not offered | Not offered | Not offered | Partial | Not offered |
+| **ttyd** | Small, focused web terminal | Partial | Not offered | Not offered | Not offered | Partial | Not offered |
+| **CasaOS** | Friendly personal-cloud home server | Partial | Partial | Partial | Partial | Not offered | Not offered |
+| **Runtipi** | Curated one-click self-hosted apps | Partial | Not offered | Strong | Partial | Not offered | Not offered |
## Notes and evidence
@@ -60,12 +60,12 @@ Built-in AI assistance plus structured remote tool/API control of the workspace.
**Best fit:** Mobile-first private Linux workspace
-- **Workspace ●:** Files, real PTY, code/media editors, managed apps, responsive shells, PWA, and CLI share one API surface. Evidence: `app/os-root.tsx`, `frontend/slices/files-manager/app.tsx`, `frontend/slices/os-terminal/components/pty-terminal.tsx`, `frontend/slices/appshell/responsive/responsive-provider.tsx`.
-- **Host ops ◐:** Live metrics/processes, service inventory and logs, exact allowlisted systemd lifecycle, package-cache visibility, full owner shell. No first-class network/storage/user administration yet. Evidence: `lib/host/sys.ts`, `lib/host/services.ts`, `lib/host/package-updates.ts`, `frontend/slices/system-monitor/app.tsx`.
-- **Delivery ◐:** Pinned managed-app install/update/backup/rollback paths exist, but MSO is not yet a general Git-to-container PaaS. Evidence: `lib/managed-apps/install.ts`, `lib/managed-apps/update.ts`, `lib/managed-apps/backups.ts`.
-- **Observability ◐:** Live host metrics and processes are built in; long-term history, alert rules, anomaly correlation, and RCA remain specialist gaps. Evidence: `frontend/slices/system-monitor/app.tsx`, `frontend/slices/system-monitor/lib/use-stats-history.ts`, `lib/host/sys.ts`.
-- **Delegation ◐:** Approved devices have live Viewer, Operator, and Owner roles with audit and immediate revocation. This is not a full user directory, Linux-account mapping, or SSO system. Evidence: `lib/auth/roles.ts`, `lib/auth/device-store.ts`, `app/api/auth/devices/route.ts`, `app/os-root.tsx`.
-- **AI / MCP ●:** BYOK Alfa, structured host/editor tools, remote OAuth/PKCE MCP, CLI parity, and project-aware tool discovery are native product surfaces. Evidence: `app/api/assistant/route.ts`, `app/mcp/route.ts`, `lib/mcp/dispatch.ts`, `frontend/slices/assistant/app.tsx`.
+- **Browser workspace (Strong):** Files, real PTY, code/media editors, managed apps, responsive shells, PWA, and CLI share one API surface. Evidence: `app/os-root.tsx`, `frontend/slices/files-manager/app.tsx`, `frontend/slices/os-terminal/components/pty-terminal.tsx`, `frontend/slices/appshell/responsive/responsive-provider.tsx`.
+- **Linux host administration (Partial):** Live metrics/processes, service inventory and logs, exact allowlisted systemd lifecycle, package-cache visibility, full owner shell. No first-class network/storage/user administration yet. Evidence: `lib/host/sys.ts`, `lib/host/services.ts`, `lib/host/package-updates.ts`, `frontend/slices/system-monitor/app.tsx`.
+- **Application delivery (Partial):** Pinned managed-app install/update/backup/rollback paths exist, but MSO is not yet a general Git-to-container PaaS. Evidence: `lib/managed-apps/install.ts`, `lib/managed-apps/update.ts`, `lib/managed-apps/backups.ts`.
+- **Monitoring and observability (Partial):** Live host metrics and processes are built in; long-term history, alert rules, anomaly correlation, and RCA remain specialist gaps. Evidence: `frontend/slices/system-monitor/app.tsx`, `frontend/slices/system-monitor/lib/use-stats-history.ts`, `lib/host/sys.ts`.
+- **Roles and delegation (Partial):** Approved devices have live Viewer, Operator, and Owner roles with audit and immediate revocation. This is not a full user directory, Linux-account mapping, or SSO system. Evidence: `lib/auth/roles.ts`, `lib/auth/device-store.ts`, `app/api/auth/devices/route.ts`, `app/os-root.tsx`.
+- **Built-in AI and MCP (Strong):** BYOK Alfa, structured host/editor tools, remote OAuth/PKCE MCP, CLI parity, and project-aware tool discovery are native product surfaces. Evidence: `app/api/assistant/route.ts`, `app/mcp/route.ts`, `lib/mcp/dispatch.ts`, `frontend/slices/assistant/app.tsx`.
Official sources:
- [MSO repository](https://github.com/rahmanef63/mso)
@@ -74,12 +74,12 @@ Official sources:
**Best fit:** Deep graphical Linux administration
-- **Workspace ◐:** Integrated browser administration and terminal, with optional applications; not an editor-centric mobile workspace.
-- **Host ops ●:** Network, firewall, storage, logs, software updates, users, systemd, VMs, containers, and multi-server administration.
-- **Delivery ◐:** Can administer containers and VMs, but is not primarily a Git-to-production PaaS.
-- **Observability ◐:** Detailed host metrics and journal correlation, without Netdata-class alerting/anomaly depth.
-- **Delegation ●:** Uses normal Linux users and privileges and supports network-wide login/SSO approaches.
-- **AI / MCP —:** No built-in AI assistant or remote MCP control plane in the core product.
+- **Browser workspace (Partial):** Integrated browser administration and terminal, with optional applications; not an editor-centric mobile workspace.
+- **Linux host administration (Strong):** Network, firewall, storage, logs, software updates, users, systemd, VMs, containers, and multi-server administration.
+- **Application delivery (Partial):** Can administer containers and VMs, but is not primarily a Git-to-production PaaS.
+- **Monitoring and observability (Partial):** Detailed host metrics and journal correlation, without Netdata-class alerting/anomaly depth.
+- **Roles and delegation (Strong):** Uses normal Linux users and privileges and supports network-wide login/SSO approaches.
+- **Built-in AI and MCP (Not offered):** No built-in AI assistant or remote MCP control plane in the core product.
Official sources:
- [Cockpit project overview](https://cockpit-project.org/)
@@ -88,12 +88,12 @@ Official sources:
**Best fit:** Self-hosted Git/PaaS delivery
-- **Workspace ◐:** Dashboard and real-time terminal center on deployed resources rather than a general files/editors workspace.
-- **Host ops ◐:** Server setup automations, terminal, monitoring, and cleanup; not a general Linux administration cockpit.
-- **Delivery ●:** Git integrations, automatic and preview deployments, one-click services, SSL, databases, backups, webhooks, and API.
-- **Observability ◐:** Deployment/server/container monitoring and notifications, but not deep per-second anomaly/RCA analytics.
-- **Delegation ●:** Team projects, roles, and permissions are first-class product features.
-- **AI / MCP —:** No native AI workspace or MCP host control comparable to MSO.
+- **Browser workspace (Partial):** Dashboard and real-time terminal center on deployed resources rather than a general files/editors workspace.
+- **Linux host administration (Partial):** Server setup automations, terminal, monitoring, and cleanup; not a general Linux administration cockpit.
+- **Application delivery (Strong):** Git integrations, automatic and preview deployments, one-click services, SSL, databases, backups, webhooks, and API.
+- **Monitoring and observability (Partial):** Deployment/server/container monitoring and notifications, but not deep per-second anomaly/RCA analytics.
+- **Roles and delegation (Strong):** Team projects, roles, and permissions are first-class product features.
+- **Built-in AI and MCP (Not offered):** No native AI workspace or MCP host control comparable to MSO.
Official sources:
- [Coolify features](https://coolify.io/docs)
@@ -103,12 +103,12 @@ Official sources:
**Best fit:** Container and stack operations
-- **Workspace ◐:** Container consoles, logs, stack editors, and resource views; not a general host files/editor workspace.
-- **Host ops ◐:** Strong container-platform operations, but host systemd/network/storage administration is outside the core scope.
-- **Delivery ●:** Docker/Swarm/Kubernetes/Podman resources, stacks, GitOps updates, environment management, and migration/duplication.
-- **Observability ◐:** Container state, logs, and resource inspection; not a Netdata-class observability system.
-- **Delegation ◐:** Access controls are available; advanced RBAC is edition-dependent.
-- **AI / MCP —:** No native AI/MCP workspace control plane.
+- **Browser workspace (Partial):** Container consoles, logs, stack editors, and resource views; not a general host files/editor workspace.
+- **Linux host administration (Partial):** Strong container-platform operations, but host systemd/network/storage administration is outside the core scope.
+- **Application delivery (Strong):** Docker/Swarm/Kubernetes/Podman resources, stacks, GitOps updates, environment management, and migration/duplication.
+- **Monitoring and observability (Partial):** Container state, logs, and resource inspection; not a Netdata-class observability system.
+- **Roles and delegation (Partial):** Access controls are available; advanced RBAC is edition-dependent.
+- **Built-in AI and MCP (Not offered):** No native AI/MCP workspace control plane.
Official sources:
- [Portainer documentation](https://docs.portainer.io/)
@@ -118,12 +118,12 @@ Official sources:
**Best fit:** High-resolution observability and RCA
-- **Workspace ◐:** Rich monitoring dashboard rather than a files/terminal/editor workspace.
-- **Host ops —:** Observes hosts and services; it is not a general administration shell.
-- **Delivery —:** Does not provide general application deployment workflows.
-- **Observability ●:** Per-second metrics, alerts, anomaly scores, correlation, cross-node analysis, and AI-generated incident insights.
-- **Delegation ◐:** Cloud/team access exists, but identity and remote host access are not its primary comparison axis.
-- **AI / MCP ◐:** AI Insights explains telemetry and recommends actions; it does not expose a general host-action MCP surface.
+- **Browser workspace (Partial):** Rich monitoring dashboard rather than a files/terminal/editor workspace.
+- **Linux host administration (Not offered):** Observes hosts and services; it is not a general administration shell.
+- **Application delivery (Not offered):** Does not provide general application deployment workflows.
+- **Monitoring and observability (Strong):** Per-second metrics, alerts, anomaly scores, correlation, cross-node analysis, and AI-generated incident insights.
+- **Roles and delegation (Partial):** Cloud/team access exists, but identity and remote host access are not its primary comparison axis.
+- **Built-in AI and MCP (Partial):** AI Insights explains telemetry and recommends actions; it does not expose a general host-action MCP surface.
Official sources:
- [Netdata charts](https://learn.netdata.cloud/docs/dashboards-and-charts/charts)
@@ -133,12 +133,12 @@ Official sources:
**Best fit:** Identity-aware private remote access
-- **Workspace —:** An access layer, not a graphical workspace.
-- **Host ops ◐:** Carries SSH sessions to the host; administration remains command-line tooling on the target.
-- **Delivery —:** No application delivery control plane.
-- **Observability —:** Connection/audit data is not host observability.
-- **Delegation ●:** Identity, ACLs, SSH checks, session controls, revocation, and recording integrations are core strengths.
-- **AI / MCP —:** No built-in AI/MCP host workspace.
+- **Browser workspace (Not offered):** An access layer, not a graphical workspace.
+- **Linux host administration (Partial):** Carries SSH sessions to the host; administration remains command-line tooling on the target.
+- **Application delivery (Not offered):** No application delivery control plane.
+- **Monitoring and observability (Not offered):** Connection/audit data is not host observability.
+- **Roles and delegation (Strong):** Identity, ACLs, SSH checks, session controls, revocation, and recording integrations are core strengths.
+- **Built-in AI and MCP (Not offered):** No built-in AI/MCP host workspace.
Official sources:
- [Tailscale SSH](https://tailscale.com/docs/features/tailscale-ssh)
@@ -147,12 +147,12 @@ Official sources:
**Best fit:** Focused web file management
-- **Workspace ◐:** Strong upload/delete/preview/edit file surface, without a complete server workspace.
-- **Host ops —:** No general service, package, network, or storage administration.
-- **Delivery —:** No application deployment control plane.
-- **Observability —:** No host metrics/alerting system.
-- **Delegation ◐:** File-focused users/scopes, not a complete host privilege model.
-- **AI / MCP —:** No native AI/MCP control.
+- **Browser workspace (Partial):** Strong upload/delete/preview/edit file surface, without a complete server workspace.
+- **Linux host administration (Not offered):** No general service, package, network, or storage administration.
+- **Application delivery (Not offered):** No application deployment control plane.
+- **Monitoring and observability (Not offered):** No host metrics/alerting system.
+- **Roles and delegation (Partial):** File-focused users/scopes, not a complete host privilege model.
+- **Built-in AI and MCP (Not offered):** No native AI/MCP control.
Official sources:
- [File Browser repository](https://github.com/filebrowser/filebrowser)
@@ -161,12 +161,12 @@ Official sources:
**Best fit:** Small, focused web terminal
-- **Workspace ◐:** Excellent terminal transport, but intentionally only one command/terminal surface.
-- **Host ops —:** Any operations come from the command it exposes, not from structured host controls.
-- **Delivery —:** No application deployment workflow.
-- **Observability —:** No host observability system.
-- **Delegation ◐:** Basic/auth-proxy options and read-only mode, without a product-wide role model.
-- **AI / MCP —:** No native AI/MCP workspace.
+- **Browser workspace (Partial):** Excellent terminal transport, but intentionally only one command/terminal surface.
+- **Linux host administration (Not offered):** Any operations come from the command it exposes, not from structured host controls.
+- **Application delivery (Not offered):** No application deployment workflow.
+- **Monitoring and observability (Not offered):** No host observability system.
+- **Roles and delegation (Partial):** Basic/auth-proxy options and read-only mode, without a product-wide role model.
+- **Built-in AI and MCP (Not offered):** No native AI/MCP workspace.
Official sources:
- [ttyd repository](https://github.com/tsl0922/ttyd)
@@ -175,12 +175,12 @@ Official sources:
**Best fit:** Friendly personal-cloud home server
-- **Workspace ◐:** Friendly personal-cloud dashboard, files, widgets, and apps, but not a developer/operations workspace with full PTY/editor depth.
-- **Host ops ◐:** Home-server status and storage/app management rather than deep Linux administration.
-- **Delivery ◐:** One-click Docker application ecosystem, not Git/preview-oriented PaaS delivery.
-- **Observability ◐:** Dashboard status/widgets without specialist alerting and RCA depth.
-- **Delegation —:** Not positioned around least-privilege team administration.
-- **AI / MCP —:** No native AI/MCP workspace control.
+- **Browser workspace (Partial):** Friendly personal-cloud dashboard, files, widgets, and apps, but not a developer/operations workspace with full PTY/editor depth.
+- **Linux host administration (Partial):** Home-server status and storage/app management rather than deep Linux administration.
+- **Application delivery (Partial):** One-click Docker application ecosystem, not Git/preview-oriented PaaS delivery.
+- **Monitoring and observability (Partial):** Dashboard status/widgets without specialist alerting and RCA depth.
+- **Roles and delegation (Not offered):** Not positioned around least-privilege team administration.
+- **Built-in AI and MCP (Not offered):** No native AI/MCP workspace control.
Official sources:
- [CasaOS repository](https://github.com/IceWhaleTech/CasaOS)
@@ -189,12 +189,12 @@ Official sources:
**Best fit:** Curated one-click self-hosted apps
-- **Workspace ◐:** App-centric home-server dashboard rather than a unified developer/operations workspace.
-- **Host ops —:** General Linux host administration is not the primary product surface.
-- **Delivery ●:** Curated/custom app stores, preconfigured Compose apps, lifecycle, logs, updates, persistence, and per-app backups.
-- **Observability ◐:** App state/logs, not deep infrastructure observability.
-- **Delegation —:** Not positioned as a multi-admin identity/RBAC control plane.
-- **AI / MCP —:** No native AI/MCP host workspace.
+- **Browser workspace (Partial):** App-centric home-server dashboard rather than a unified developer/operations workspace.
+- **Linux host administration (Not offered):** General Linux host administration is not the primary product surface.
+- **Application delivery (Strong):** Curated/custom app stores, preconfigured Compose apps, lifecycle, logs, updates, persistence, and per-app backups.
+- **Monitoring and observability (Partial):** App state/logs, not deep infrastructure observability.
+- **Roles and delegation (Not offered):** Not positioned as a multi-admin identity/RBAC control plane.
+- **Built-in AI and MCP (Not offered):** No native AI/MCP host workspace.
Official sources:
- [Runtipi app store](https://runtipi.io/docs/learn/apps-and-app-store)
diff --git a/docs/comparison-data.json b/docs/comparison-data.json
index fc92dfb3..39828116 100644
--- a/docs/comparison-data.json
+++ b/docs/comparison-data.json
@@ -4,39 +4,39 @@
"expiresAfterDays": 90,
"positioning": "MSO is designed to be the most complete mobile-first, AI-native private Linux workspace for an owner or small trusted team. It does not claim to replace specialist products at their strongest specialty.",
"legend": {
- "strong": "●",
- "partial": "◐",
- "none": "—"
+ "strong": "Strong",
+ "partial": "Partial",
+ "none": "Not offered"
},
"criteria": [
{
"id": "workspace",
- "label": "Workspace",
+ "label": "Browser workspace",
"definition": "A unified browser workspace with mobile-aware navigation across files, terminal, editors, apps, and host views."
},
{
"id": "hostOps",
- "label": "Host ops",
+ "label": "Linux host administration",
"definition": "General Linux host operations such as services, logs, package visibility, network, storage, users, and system configuration."
},
{
"id": "delivery",
- "label": "Delivery",
+ "label": "Application delivery",
"definition": "Application/container deployment, Git integration, previews, lifecycle, backups, and rollback."
},
{
"id": "observability",
- "label": "Observability",
+ "label": "Monitoring and observability",
"definition": "Metrics, history, alerting, anomaly detection, correlations, and incident analysis."
},
{
"id": "delegation",
- "label": "Delegation",
+ "label": "Roles and delegation",
"definition": "Least-privilege roles, multiple identities/devices, auditability, and SSO or policy integration."
},
{
"id": "aiControl",
- "label": "AI / MCP",
+ "label": "Built-in AI and MCP",
"definition": "Built-in AI assistance plus structured remote tool/API control of the workspace."
}
],
@@ -123,12 +123,30 @@
}
],
"ratings": {
- "workspace": { "value": "partial", "note": "Integrated browser administration and terminal, with optional applications; not an editor-centric mobile workspace." },
- "hostOps": { "value": "strong", "note": "Network, firewall, storage, logs, software updates, users, systemd, VMs, containers, and multi-server administration." },
- "delivery": { "value": "partial", "note": "Can administer containers and VMs, but is not primarily a Git-to-production PaaS." },
- "observability": { "value": "partial", "note": "Detailed host metrics and journal correlation, without Netdata-class alerting/anomaly depth." },
- "delegation": { "value": "strong", "note": "Uses normal Linux users and privileges and supports network-wide login/SSO approaches." },
- "aiControl": { "value": "none", "note": "No built-in AI assistant or remote MCP control plane in the core product." }
+ "workspace": {
+ "value": "partial",
+ "note": "Integrated browser administration and terminal, with optional applications; not an editor-centric mobile workspace."
+ },
+ "hostOps": {
+ "value": "strong",
+ "note": "Network, firewall, storage, logs, software updates, users, systemd, VMs, containers, and multi-server administration."
+ },
+ "delivery": {
+ "value": "partial",
+ "note": "Can administer containers and VMs, but is not primarily a Git-to-production PaaS."
+ },
+ "observability": {
+ "value": "partial",
+ "note": "Detailed host metrics and journal correlation, without Netdata-class alerting/anomaly depth."
+ },
+ "delegation": {
+ "value": "strong",
+ "note": "Uses normal Linux users and privileges and supports network-wide login/SSO approaches."
+ },
+ "aiControl": {
+ "value": "none",
+ "note": "No built-in AI assistant or remote MCP control plane in the core product."
+ }
}
},
{
@@ -136,16 +154,40 @@
"name": "Coolify",
"bestFor": "Self-hosted Git/PaaS delivery",
"sources": [
- { "label": "Coolify features", "url": "https://coolify.io/docs" },
- { "label": "Coolify CI/CD", "url": "https://coolify.io/docs/applications/ci-cd" }
+ {
+ "label": "Coolify features",
+ "url": "https://coolify.io/docs"
+ },
+ {
+ "label": "Coolify CI/CD",
+ "url": "https://coolify.io/docs/applications/ci-cd"
+ }
],
"ratings": {
- "workspace": { "value": "partial", "note": "Dashboard and real-time terminal center on deployed resources rather than a general files/editors workspace." },
- "hostOps": { "value": "partial", "note": "Server setup automations, terminal, monitoring, and cleanup; not a general Linux administration cockpit." },
- "delivery": { "value": "strong", "note": "Git integrations, automatic and preview deployments, one-click services, SSL, databases, backups, webhooks, and API." },
- "observability": { "value": "partial", "note": "Deployment/server/container monitoring and notifications, but not deep per-second anomaly/RCA analytics." },
- "delegation": { "value": "strong", "note": "Team projects, roles, and permissions are first-class product features." },
- "aiControl": { "value": "none", "note": "No native AI workspace or MCP host control comparable to MSO." }
+ "workspace": {
+ "value": "partial",
+ "note": "Dashboard and real-time terminal center on deployed resources rather than a general files/editors workspace."
+ },
+ "hostOps": {
+ "value": "partial",
+ "note": "Server setup automations, terminal, monitoring, and cleanup; not a general Linux administration cockpit."
+ },
+ "delivery": {
+ "value": "strong",
+ "note": "Git integrations, automatic and preview deployments, one-click services, SSL, databases, backups, webhooks, and API."
+ },
+ "observability": {
+ "value": "partial",
+ "note": "Deployment/server/container monitoring and notifications, but not deep per-second anomaly/RCA analytics."
+ },
+ "delegation": {
+ "value": "strong",
+ "note": "Team projects, roles, and permissions are first-class product features."
+ },
+ "aiControl": {
+ "value": "none",
+ "note": "No native AI workspace or MCP host control comparable to MSO."
+ }
}
},
{
@@ -153,16 +195,40 @@
"name": "Portainer",
"bestFor": "Container and stack operations",
"sources": [
- { "label": "Portainer documentation", "url": "https://docs.portainer.io/" },
- { "label": "Portainer stack operations", "url": "https://docs.portainer.io/2.33-lts/user/docker/stacks/edit" }
+ {
+ "label": "Portainer documentation",
+ "url": "https://docs.portainer.io/"
+ },
+ {
+ "label": "Portainer stack operations",
+ "url": "https://docs.portainer.io/2.33-lts/user/docker/stacks/edit"
+ }
],
"ratings": {
- "workspace": { "value": "partial", "note": "Container consoles, logs, stack editors, and resource views; not a general host files/editor workspace." },
- "hostOps": { "value": "partial", "note": "Strong container-platform operations, but host systemd/network/storage administration is outside the core scope." },
- "delivery": { "value": "strong", "note": "Docker/Swarm/Kubernetes/Podman resources, stacks, GitOps updates, environment management, and migration/duplication." },
- "observability": { "value": "partial", "note": "Container state, logs, and resource inspection; not a Netdata-class observability system." },
- "delegation": { "value": "partial", "note": "Access controls are available; advanced RBAC is edition-dependent." },
- "aiControl": { "value": "none", "note": "No native AI/MCP workspace control plane." }
+ "workspace": {
+ "value": "partial",
+ "note": "Container consoles, logs, stack editors, and resource views; not a general host files/editor workspace."
+ },
+ "hostOps": {
+ "value": "partial",
+ "note": "Strong container-platform operations, but host systemd/network/storage administration is outside the core scope."
+ },
+ "delivery": {
+ "value": "strong",
+ "note": "Docker/Swarm/Kubernetes/Podman resources, stacks, GitOps updates, environment management, and migration/duplication."
+ },
+ "observability": {
+ "value": "partial",
+ "note": "Container state, logs, and resource inspection; not a Netdata-class observability system."
+ },
+ "delegation": {
+ "value": "partial",
+ "note": "Access controls are available; advanced RBAC is edition-dependent."
+ },
+ "aiControl": {
+ "value": "none",
+ "note": "No native AI/MCP workspace control plane."
+ }
}
},
{
@@ -170,16 +236,40 @@
"name": "Netdata",
"bestFor": "High-resolution observability and RCA",
"sources": [
- { "label": "Netdata charts", "url": "https://learn.netdata.cloud/docs/dashboards-and-charts/charts" },
- { "label": "Netdata AI Insights", "url": "https://learn.netdata.cloud/docs/netdata-ai/insights" }
+ {
+ "label": "Netdata charts",
+ "url": "https://learn.netdata.cloud/docs/dashboards-and-charts/charts"
+ },
+ {
+ "label": "Netdata AI Insights",
+ "url": "https://learn.netdata.cloud/docs/netdata-ai/insights"
+ }
],
"ratings": {
- "workspace": { "value": "partial", "note": "Rich monitoring dashboard rather than a files/terminal/editor workspace." },
- "hostOps": { "value": "none", "note": "Observes hosts and services; it is not a general administration shell." },
- "delivery": { "value": "none", "note": "Does not provide general application deployment workflows." },
- "observability": { "value": "strong", "note": "Per-second metrics, alerts, anomaly scores, correlation, cross-node analysis, and AI-generated incident insights." },
- "delegation": { "value": "partial", "note": "Cloud/team access exists, but identity and remote host access are not its primary comparison axis." },
- "aiControl": { "value": "partial", "note": "AI Insights explains telemetry and recommends actions; it does not expose a general host-action MCP surface." }
+ "workspace": {
+ "value": "partial",
+ "note": "Rich monitoring dashboard rather than a files/terminal/editor workspace."
+ },
+ "hostOps": {
+ "value": "none",
+ "note": "Observes hosts and services; it is not a general administration shell."
+ },
+ "delivery": {
+ "value": "none",
+ "note": "Does not provide general application deployment workflows."
+ },
+ "observability": {
+ "value": "strong",
+ "note": "Per-second metrics, alerts, anomaly scores, correlation, cross-node analysis, and AI-generated incident insights."
+ },
+ "delegation": {
+ "value": "partial",
+ "note": "Cloud/team access exists, but identity and remote host access are not its primary comparison axis."
+ },
+ "aiControl": {
+ "value": "partial",
+ "note": "AI Insights explains telemetry and recommends actions; it does not expose a general host-action MCP surface."
+ }
}
},
{
@@ -187,15 +277,36 @@
"name": "Tailscale SSH",
"bestFor": "Identity-aware private remote access",
"sources": [
- { "label": "Tailscale SSH", "url": "https://tailscale.com/docs/features/tailscale-ssh" }
+ {
+ "label": "Tailscale SSH",
+ "url": "https://tailscale.com/docs/features/tailscale-ssh"
+ }
],
"ratings": {
- "workspace": { "value": "none", "note": "An access layer, not a graphical workspace." },
- "hostOps": { "value": "partial", "note": "Carries SSH sessions to the host; administration remains command-line tooling on the target." },
- "delivery": { "value": "none", "note": "No application delivery control plane." },
- "observability": { "value": "none", "note": "Connection/audit data is not host observability." },
- "delegation": { "value": "strong", "note": "Identity, ACLs, SSH checks, session controls, revocation, and recording integrations are core strengths." },
- "aiControl": { "value": "none", "note": "No built-in AI/MCP host workspace." }
+ "workspace": {
+ "value": "none",
+ "note": "An access layer, not a graphical workspace."
+ },
+ "hostOps": {
+ "value": "partial",
+ "note": "Carries SSH sessions to the host; administration remains command-line tooling on the target."
+ },
+ "delivery": {
+ "value": "none",
+ "note": "No application delivery control plane."
+ },
+ "observability": {
+ "value": "none",
+ "note": "Connection/audit data is not host observability."
+ },
+ "delegation": {
+ "value": "strong",
+ "note": "Identity, ACLs, SSH checks, session controls, revocation, and recording integrations are core strengths."
+ },
+ "aiControl": {
+ "value": "none",
+ "note": "No built-in AI/MCP host workspace."
+ }
}
},
{
@@ -203,15 +314,36 @@
"name": "File Browser",
"bestFor": "Focused web file management",
"sources": [
- { "label": "File Browser repository", "url": "https://github.com/filebrowser/filebrowser" }
+ {
+ "label": "File Browser repository",
+ "url": "https://github.com/filebrowser/filebrowser"
+ }
],
"ratings": {
- "workspace": { "value": "partial", "note": "Strong upload/delete/preview/edit file surface, without a complete server workspace." },
- "hostOps": { "value": "none", "note": "No general service, package, network, or storage administration." },
- "delivery": { "value": "none", "note": "No application deployment control plane." },
- "observability": { "value": "none", "note": "No host metrics/alerting system." },
- "delegation": { "value": "partial", "note": "File-focused users/scopes, not a complete host privilege model." },
- "aiControl": { "value": "none", "note": "No native AI/MCP control." }
+ "workspace": {
+ "value": "partial",
+ "note": "Strong upload/delete/preview/edit file surface, without a complete server workspace."
+ },
+ "hostOps": {
+ "value": "none",
+ "note": "No general service, package, network, or storage administration."
+ },
+ "delivery": {
+ "value": "none",
+ "note": "No application deployment control plane."
+ },
+ "observability": {
+ "value": "none",
+ "note": "No host metrics/alerting system."
+ },
+ "delegation": {
+ "value": "partial",
+ "note": "File-focused users/scopes, not a complete host privilege model."
+ },
+ "aiControl": {
+ "value": "none",
+ "note": "No native AI/MCP control."
+ }
}
},
{
@@ -219,15 +351,36 @@
"name": "ttyd",
"bestFor": "Small, focused web terminal",
"sources": [
- { "label": "ttyd repository", "url": "https://github.com/tsl0922/ttyd" }
+ {
+ "label": "ttyd repository",
+ "url": "https://github.com/tsl0922/ttyd"
+ }
],
"ratings": {
- "workspace": { "value": "partial", "note": "Excellent terminal transport, but intentionally only one command/terminal surface." },
- "hostOps": { "value": "none", "note": "Any operations come from the command it exposes, not from structured host controls." },
- "delivery": { "value": "none", "note": "No application deployment workflow." },
- "observability": { "value": "none", "note": "No host observability system." },
- "delegation": { "value": "partial", "note": "Basic/auth-proxy options and read-only mode, without a product-wide role model." },
- "aiControl": { "value": "none", "note": "No native AI/MCP workspace." }
+ "workspace": {
+ "value": "partial",
+ "note": "Excellent terminal transport, but intentionally only one command/terminal surface."
+ },
+ "hostOps": {
+ "value": "none",
+ "note": "Any operations come from the command it exposes, not from structured host controls."
+ },
+ "delivery": {
+ "value": "none",
+ "note": "No application deployment workflow."
+ },
+ "observability": {
+ "value": "none",
+ "note": "No host observability system."
+ },
+ "delegation": {
+ "value": "partial",
+ "note": "Basic/auth-proxy options and read-only mode, without a product-wide role model."
+ },
+ "aiControl": {
+ "value": "none",
+ "note": "No native AI/MCP workspace."
+ }
}
},
{
@@ -235,15 +388,36 @@
"name": "CasaOS",
"bestFor": "Friendly personal-cloud home server",
"sources": [
- { "label": "CasaOS repository", "url": "https://github.com/IceWhaleTech/CasaOS" }
+ {
+ "label": "CasaOS repository",
+ "url": "https://github.com/IceWhaleTech/CasaOS"
+ }
],
"ratings": {
- "workspace": { "value": "partial", "note": "Friendly personal-cloud dashboard, files, widgets, and apps, but not a developer/operations workspace with full PTY/editor depth." },
- "hostOps": { "value": "partial", "note": "Home-server status and storage/app management rather than deep Linux administration." },
- "delivery": { "value": "partial", "note": "One-click Docker application ecosystem, not Git/preview-oriented PaaS delivery." },
- "observability": { "value": "partial", "note": "Dashboard status/widgets without specialist alerting and RCA depth." },
- "delegation": { "value": "none", "note": "Not positioned around least-privilege team administration." },
- "aiControl": { "value": "none", "note": "No native AI/MCP workspace control." }
+ "workspace": {
+ "value": "partial",
+ "note": "Friendly personal-cloud dashboard, files, widgets, and apps, but not a developer/operations workspace with full PTY/editor depth."
+ },
+ "hostOps": {
+ "value": "partial",
+ "note": "Home-server status and storage/app management rather than deep Linux administration."
+ },
+ "delivery": {
+ "value": "partial",
+ "note": "One-click Docker application ecosystem, not Git/preview-oriented PaaS delivery."
+ },
+ "observability": {
+ "value": "partial",
+ "note": "Dashboard status/widgets without specialist alerting and RCA depth."
+ },
+ "delegation": {
+ "value": "none",
+ "note": "Not positioned around least-privilege team administration."
+ },
+ "aiControl": {
+ "value": "none",
+ "note": "No native AI/MCP workspace control."
+ }
}
},
{
@@ -251,16 +425,40 @@
"name": "Runtipi",
"bestFor": "Curated one-click self-hosted apps",
"sources": [
- { "label": "Runtipi app store", "url": "https://runtipi.io/docs/learn/apps-and-app-store" },
- { "label": "Runtipi folder and backup model", "url": "https://runtipi.io/docs/reference/folder-structure" }
+ {
+ "label": "Runtipi app store",
+ "url": "https://runtipi.io/docs/learn/apps-and-app-store"
+ },
+ {
+ "label": "Runtipi folder and backup model",
+ "url": "https://runtipi.io/docs/reference/folder-structure"
+ }
],
"ratings": {
- "workspace": { "value": "partial", "note": "App-centric home-server dashboard rather than a unified developer/operations workspace." },
- "hostOps": { "value": "none", "note": "General Linux host administration is not the primary product surface." },
- "delivery": { "value": "strong", "note": "Curated/custom app stores, preconfigured Compose apps, lifecycle, logs, updates, persistence, and per-app backups." },
- "observability": { "value": "partial", "note": "App state/logs, not deep infrastructure observability." },
- "delegation": { "value": "none", "note": "Not positioned as a multi-admin identity/RBAC control plane." },
- "aiControl": { "value": "none", "note": "No native AI/MCP host workspace." }
+ "workspace": {
+ "value": "partial",
+ "note": "App-centric home-server dashboard rather than a unified developer/operations workspace."
+ },
+ "hostOps": {
+ "value": "none",
+ "note": "General Linux host administration is not the primary product surface."
+ },
+ "delivery": {
+ "value": "strong",
+ "note": "Curated/custom app stores, preconfigured Compose apps, lifecycle, logs, updates, persistence, and per-app backups."
+ },
+ "observability": {
+ "value": "partial",
+ "note": "App state/logs, not deep infrastructure observability."
+ },
+ "delegation": {
+ "value": "none",
+ "note": "Not positioned as a multi-admin identity/RBAC control plane."
+ },
+ "aiControl": {
+ "value": "none",
+ "note": "No native AI/MCP host workspace."
+ }
}
}
]
diff --git a/scripts/gen-comparison.mjs b/scripts/gen-comparison.mjs
index 959b606a..17acea2f 100755
--- a/scripts/gen-comparison.mjs
+++ b/scripts/gen-comparison.mjs
@@ -10,6 +10,7 @@ const readmePath = path.join(root, "README.md");
const detailPath = path.join(root, "docs/COMPARISON.md");
const check = process.argv.includes("--check");
const allowedRatings = new Set(["strong", "partial", "none"]);
+const requiredLabels = { strong: "Strong", partial: "Partial", none: "Not offered" };
const officialHosts = new Set([
"github.com",
"cockpit-project.org",
@@ -28,6 +29,9 @@ const escape = (value) => String(value).replaceAll("|", "\\|").replaceAll("\n",
if (data.schemaVersion !== 1) fail("unsupported schemaVersion");
if (!Array.isArray(data.criteria) || !data.criteria.length) fail("criteria are required");
if (!Array.isArray(data.products) || !data.products.length) fail("products are required");
+for (const [rating, label] of Object.entries(requiredLabels)) {
+ if (data.legend?.[rating] !== label) fail(`legend.${rating} must be the SEO-readable text ${JSON.stringify(label)}`);
+}
const reviewed = new Date(`${data.reviewedAt}T00:00:00Z`);
if (!Number.isFinite(reviewed.getTime())) fail("reviewedAt must be YYYY-MM-DD");
const ageDays = Math.floor((Date.now() - reviewed.getTime()) / 86_400_000);
@@ -59,16 +63,16 @@ for (const product of data.products) {
}
}
-const symbol = (value) => data.legend[value];
+const ratingLabel = (value) => data.legend[value];
const tableHeader = `| Product | Best fit | ${data.criteria.map((criterion) => escape(criterion.label)).join(" | ")} |`;
const tableRule = `|---|---|${data.criteria.map(() => ":---:").join("|")}|`;
const tableRows = data.products.map((product) =>
- `| **${escape(product.name)}** | ${escape(product.bestFor)} | ${data.criteria.map((criterion) => symbol(product.ratings[criterion.id].value)).join(" | ")} |`
+ `| **${escape(product.name)}** | ${escape(product.bestFor)} | ${data.criteria.map((criterion) => ratingLabel(product.ratings[criterion.id].value)).join(" | ")} |`
);
const compact = [
`**Positioning:** ${data.positioning}`,
"",
- `${data.legend.strong} strong · ${data.legend.partial} partial/scope-limited · ${data.legend.none} not a product surface`,
+ `Strong = a first-class product strength · Partial = available with scope limitations · Not offered = not a core product surface`,
"",
tableHeader,
tableRule,
@@ -96,7 +100,7 @@ const details = [
"## Method",
"",
"- Ratings describe the documented product surface, not speed, popularity, or a universal winner.",
- "- `●` means a first-class strength, `◐` means partial or deliberately narrow scope, and `—` means it is not a meaningful product surface.",
+ "- `Strong` means a first-class product strength, `Partial` means available with deliberate scope limitations, and `Not offered` means it is not a core product surface.",
"- MSO cells must point to repository evidence that exists at build time.",
"- Competitor claims use official project documentation only and must be manually re-reviewed before the freshness window expires.",
"- Edition-dependent or adjacent capabilities are marked partial unless they are consistently core to the product.",
@@ -122,7 +126,7 @@ const details = [
const evidence = (rating.evidence ?? []).length
? ` Evidence: ${(rating.evidence ?? []).map((entry) => `\`${entry}\``).join(", ")}.`
: "";
- return [`- **${criterion.label} ${symbol(rating.value)}:** ${rating.note}${evidence}`];
+ return [`- **${criterion.label} (${ratingLabel(rating.value)}):** ${rating.note}${evidence}`];
}),
"",
"Official sources:",