Skip to content

armgit / mwmbl

Public Imported from GitHub
0

An open source, non-profit web search engine

Write readme

Daoud Clarke722328efa522
diff --git a/README.md b/README.md
index 30bcdc4..c00a84d 100644
--- a/README.md
+++ b/README.md
@@ -1,4 +1,109 @@
-Tiny Search Engine
+Mwmbl: No ads, no tracking, no cruft, no profit
+===============================================
+
+Mwmbl is a non-profit, ad-free, free-libre and free-lunch search
+engine with a focus on useability and speed. At the moment it is
+little more than an idea together with a [proof of concept
+implementation](https://tinysearchengine-oq4r5q2hsq-ue.a.run.app/) of
+the web front-end and search technology on a very small index. A
+crawler is still to be implemented.
+
+Our vision is a community working to provide top quality search
+particularly for hackers, funded purely by donations.
+
+Why a non-profit search engine?
+===============================
+
+The motives of ad-funded search engine are at odds with providing an
+optimal user experience. These sites are optimised for ad revenue,
+with user experience taking second place. This means that pages are
+loaded with ads which are often not clearly distinguished from search
+results. Also, eitland on Hacker News
+[comments](https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29427442):
+
+> Thinking about it it seems logical that for a search engine that
+> practically speaking has monopoly both on users and as mattgb points
+> out - [to some] degree also on indexing - serving the correct answer
+> first is just dumb: if they can keep me going between their search
+> results and tech blogs with their ads embedded one, two or five
+> times extra that means one, two or five times more ad impressions.
+
+But what about...?
==================
-TBD
+The space of alternative search engines has expanded rapidly in recent
+years. Here's a very incomplete list of some that have interested me:
+
+ - [YaCy](https://yacy.net/) - an open source distributed search engine
+ - [search.marginalia.nu](https://search.marginalia.nu/) - a search
+ engine favouring text-heavy websites
+ - [Gigablast](https://gigablast.com/) - a privacy-focused search
+ engine whose owner makes money by selling the technology to third
+ parties
+ - [Brave](https://search.brave.com/)
+ - [DuckDuckGo](https://duckduckgo.com/)
+
+Of these, YaCy is the closest in spirit to the idea of a non-profit
+search engine. The index is distributed across a peer-to-peer
+network. Unfortunately this design decision makes search very slow.
+
+Marginalia Search is fantastic, but it is more of a personal project
+than an open source community.
+
+All other search engines that I've come across are for-profit. Please
+let me know if I've missed one!
+
+Designing for non-profit
+========================
+
+To be a good search engine, we need to store many items, but the cost
+of running the engine is at least proportional to the number of items
+stored. Our main consideration is thus to reduce the cost per item
+stored.
+
+The design is founded on the observation that most items rank for a
+small set of terms. In the extreme version of this, where each item
+ranks for a single term, the usual inverted index design is grossly
+inefficient, since we have to store each term at least twice: once in
+the index and once in the item data itself.
+
+Our design is a giant hash map. We have a single store consisting of a
+fixed number N of pages. Each page is of a fixed size (currently 4096
+bytes to match a page of memory), and consists of a compressed list of
+items. Given a term for which we want an item to rank, we compute a
+hash of the term, a value between 0 and N - 1. The item is then stored
+in the corresponding page.
+
+To retrieve pages, we simply compute the hash of the terms in the user
+query and load the corresponding pages, filter the items to those
+containing the term and rank the items. Since each page is small, this
+can be done very quickly.
+
+Because we compress the list of items, we can rank for more than a
+single term and maintain an index smaller than the inverted index
+design. Well, that's the theory. This idea has yet to be tested out on
+a large scale.
+
+Crawling
+========
+
+Our current index is a small sample of the excellent Common Crawl,
+restricted to English content and domains which score highly on
+average in Hacker News submissions. It is likely for a variety of
+reasons that we will want to go beyond Common Crawl data at some
+point, so building a crawler becomes inevitable. We plan to start work
+on a distributed crawler, probably implemented as a browser extension
+that can be installed by volunteers.
+
+How to contribute
+=================
+
+There are lots of ways to help:
+ - Volunteer to test out the distributed crawler when it's ready
+ - Help out with development of the engine itself
+ - Donate some money towards hosting costs and/or founding an official
+ non-profit organisation
+
+If you would like to help in any of these or other ways, thank you!
+Please email the main author (email address is in the git commit
+history).