Skip to content

armgit / nota

Public Imported from GitHub
0

Nota — a free DAW for macOS, Windows and Linux. No subscription, no account — just open it and make music.

3.6 KB
Raw Blame

Bug Verification: Audio Unit plug-ins get 31 channels per block — JUCE assertion and dropouts

  • Slug: au-process-assert
  • Tested: 2026-10-20
  • Assessment: ./assessment.md
  • Fix: ./fix.md
  • Result: partial

Summary

The engine-level reproduction no longer triggers the assertion. On a Debug engine (assertions on), the AU instrument plus AU effect render from --hostcheck produces 0 × juce_AudioUnitPluginFormatImpl.h:1346, against 38 before the fix. Audio still flows. The full build and smoke test pass on the Release engine. The reporter's own scenario has not been re-run: the reporter's project in the GUI app, under a debugger. Neither has the VST3 layout-widening guard (Reaktor 6). Hence partial.

Checks Performed

Check Command / Action Result Notes
Reproduction (post-fix), Debug engine cmake … -B build-debug -DCMAKE_BUILD_TYPE=Debug + Nota.SmokeTest --hostcheck build-debug/nota-scanworker (bin copy with the Debug dylib, NOTA_DATA_DIR isolated) pass 0 × :1346 (38 before the fix, see fix.md). AUSampler + AUVectorPanner audible. The 13 repo root located FAILs come from running the binary copy outside the repo (design checks look for Nota.sln) and are unrelated
Hosted AU check, Release engine tests/Nota.SmokeTest/bin/Release/net10.0/Nota.SmokeTest --hostcheck build/nota-scanworker pass HOSTCHECK PASSED, instrument rms 0.2157, through effect 0.0096, restored project audible, 0 JUCE assertions
Regression suite scripts/build.sh (Release engine + managed build + full smoke test) pass SMOKE TEST PASSED, 3688 PASS / 0 FAIL, exit 0
In-app reproduction (reporter's project, press play) GUI app on the Debug engine not-run Needs the GUI and the reporter's AU project; to be done by the user
VST3 regression guard (Reaktor 6 Play/Patch/Build) plugin-add-crash-windows harness not-run Harness /tmp/widenharness no longer exists. The VST3 width is algebraically unchanged: max(max(31, have), in, out)
Lint / type-check — skipped No separate C++ lint step in the project. Both engine configs compile cleanly

Output Excerpts

# Debug engine (build-debug), post-fix
  [PASS] hosted instrument produces audio (rms=0,2157)
  [PASS] audio flows through the effect (rms=0,0096)
  [PASS] restored plugin project is audible (rms=0,0038)
   5 JUCE Assertion failure in juce_LeakedObjectDetector.h:116
   2 JUCE Assertion failure in juce_MessageListener.cpp:50
   (no juce_AudioUnitPluginFormatImpl.h:1346)

# scripts/build.sh
SMOKE TEST PASSED
exit=0

Residual Risks

  • The --hostcheck AUs are Apple's (AUSampler, AUVectorPanner), both stereo. A mono-output AU (now handed 1 channel) and the reporter's Massive AU were not exercised.
  • The reporter's dropouts had a second cause that this fix does not cover: the engine in build/ had been reconfigured as Debug (-O0) and the app ran under netcoredbg. The VSCodium setup now keeps build/ Release (CMake Tools → build-debug/). On a -O0 engine, heavy projects can still drop out regardless of this fix.
  • The VST3 path is unchanged by construction but was not exercised with a layout-changing plug-in.

Recommendation

Hold for one manual check, then close. Open the AU project in the app with Run Nota (Release engine): no dropouts. Then open it once with Nota + Debug engine (LLDB): no :1346. If Reaktor 6 is handy, switch its Play/Patch/Build modes once to confirm the VST3 guard. Before merging, move the change to its own fix/… branch from develop, with a CHANGELOG [Unreleased] → Fixed entry (fix.md § Follow-ups).