Nota — a free DAW for macOS, Windows and Linux. No subscription, no account — just open it and make music.
Feature Specification: Controls inside MIDI CC lanes
Feature Branch: feat/multiple-midi-cc-lanes (existing PR #425)
Created: 2026-11-04
Status: Ready for planning
Input: Redesign PR #425 with in-lane controller dropdowns and remove buttons,
a sidebar + lane action, and a 127/64/0 value scale, preserving editing and layouts.
User Scenarios & Testing
US1 — Manage controllers where their curves appear (P1)
A musician identifies and changes each lane's controller using its in-lane dropdown, and hides a lane using the adjacent × control. Independent test: Add three lanes, select different controllers, hide and restore one, and compare all notes and MIDI curves before and after.
Acceptance scenarios:
- Given multiple lanes, each dropdown displays its controller name and CC number.
- Changing a dropdown affects only that lane; hiding it preserves its MIDI data.
- Clicking controls or opening their menus never starts an automation gesture.
US2 — Add lanes without a full-width toolbar (P1)
A musician uses a compact + lane control below the left sidebar's existing entries. Independent test: Add lanes from each primary lane mode and in a short editor.
Acceptance scenarios:
- The full-width CC lanes toolbar and its external plus button are absent.
- The sidebar action adds an independent lane using the current creation rules.
- The action, primary tabs and note viewport remain usable when clips are stacked.
US3 — Read and edit controller values consistently (P1)
A musician uses the left-hand scale to relate curve position to MIDI values. Independent test: Compare graph and pointer mapping at scale endpoints and midpoint, then resize, zoom, scroll, fold Drum Rack rows and reopen the editor.
Acceptance scenarios:
- Each CC lane shows 127 at the top, 64 near the middle and 0 at the bottom.
- Graph values and pointer edits align with the scale at every supported lane height.
- Resizing persists independent heights; layouts work docked and floating, with several independent or stacked clips and folded Drum Rack rows.
Edge cases
- Minimum-height lanes, narrow editors and long controller labels.
- Pitch wheel and channel pressure entries (no invented CC numbers).
- Stale dropdown callbacks after a clip changes or its lane is removed.
- Many extra lanes require scrolling without hiding all notes.
- Scale labels and lane controls must not obscure editable graph points.
Requirements
Functional Requirements
- FR-001: Each visible controller lane MUST contain a dropdown showing its name and CC number where applicable, and an adjacent × hide action.
- FR-002: Controller selection and lane removal MUST retain their current routing, reserved-controller restrictions, gesture cancellation and MIDI preservation.
- FR-003: The left sidebar MUST offer a compact + lane action below its entries; the full-width CC lanes toolbar MUST be removed.
- FR-004: Each CC lane MUST show 127, 64 and 0 aligned with its graph value mapping.
- FR-005: Lane controls and the value scale MUST not trigger automation edits.
- FR-006: Multiple lanes, independent resizing and saved heights MUST keep working.
- FR-007: Notes and curves MUST stay aligned through zoom, scrolling, Drum Rack folding, clip changes, stacked clips, and docked or floating editor layouts.
- FR-008: The interface MUST follow Nota's themes, typography and localization.
- FR-009: The change MUST append commits to PR #425's existing branch and preserve all existing commits; it MUST NOT create or replace a pull request.
Key Entities
- Controller lane: Selected controller, independent height and transient gesture.
- Controller curve: Existing clip MIDI data, unaffected by lane visibility.
- Editor layout: Shared time axis and gutter, primary tabs and scrollable extra lanes.
Success Criteria
- SC-001: All visible CC lanes identify their controller and expose adjacent removal.
- SC-002: The editor has one sidebar + lane action and no CC lanes toolbar.
- SC-003: Endpoint and midpoint edits agree with the value scale after resizing.
- SC-004: Regression checks pass for MIDI preservation, saved heights, folded rows, stacked clips, zoom/scroll and both editor hosts; Windows build/smoke gates pass.
- SC-005: PR #425's head includes the redesign commit as a descendant of its
original head
957d52865886483dd63f81f1065c70915c3f3667.
Assumptions and clarification
- Reference: PR #425's design-review image, section “Proposed — controls inside the lane”
(
pr-assets/pr425-cc-lanes-review/cc-lanes-mockup.png). Compact backed controls, sidebar creation and gutter scales guide the layout. A shallow control row preserves access to every graph point; its unused width uses the graph background. - Existing pitch wheel/channel pressure semantics and ranges remain intact; CC value labels apply to CC controllers, with appropriate signed labels for pitch wheel.
- Hiding the primary controller lane returns its existing panel to Velocity.
- Scope excludes reordering, collapse controls and persistence of visible lane choices.
- Clarification review: behavior, scope, data retention and validation are clear; no blocking questions or unresolved markers remain.