Nota — a free DAW for macOS, Windows and Linux. No subscription, no account — just open it and make music.
Validation: Controls inside MIDI CC lanes
Date: 2026-11-04
Branch: feat/multiple-midi-cc-lanes, existing nota-daw/nota PR #425.
Original head: 957d52865886483dd63f81f1065c70915c3f3667.
Implementation
Primary and extra controller lanes share one compact controller-name/CC-number dropdown and adjacent close button. Controls have their own shallow row, leaving every graph point reachable. Unused header width retains the graph background. The former full-width CC lanes toolbar is replaced by a sidebar + lane action. The gutter scale reads graph coordinates directly: 127/64/0 for ordinary MIDI controllers, signed normalized values for the pitch wheel. Resize hit zones retain their six-pixel extent and paint only a thin seam. Settings keys and MIDI routing are unchanged. Clip strips with many overlapping clips now scroll within the layout budget so they cannot consume the entire note viewport.
Checks
| Check | Result |
|---|---|
| .NET Release solution build | Passed; no errors, existing compiler warnings |
| Windows native engine and scanner build | Passed |
scripts/build-win.ps1 full gate |
Passed on final revision, including smoke, render-pool and scanner-scale suites |
| Real Windows Avalonia CCProbe | 85 assertions passed |
| Separate-process lane-height restoration | Passed |
| Controller picker, primary/extra removal and MIDI preservation | Passed |
| Menus invalidated by clip reload or lane removal | Passed |
| Close control in a 180 px wide roll | Passed |
| Minimum/expanded value scale and inverse pointer mapping | Passed |
| Folded Drum Rack, unfold/refold and re-added lane origins | Passed |
| Zoom/scroll and independent duplicate-controller heights | Passed |
| Floating and real docked editor, Mixer, restored heights, panel-edge resizing | Passed |
| Twelve stacked clips, scrolling and active-clip changes in both hosts | Passed |
| Preferences Shortcuts filtered to the controller rows | Passed; rendered and visually inspected |
| Studio Dark/Light screenshots | Rendered and visually inspected |
git diff --check |
Passed |
External manual npm run build / npm run check |
Passed; 106 pages, zero errors, 72 existing warnings |
| Manual screenshots | Clip editor, multi-clip editor and Shortcuts retaken in Dark/Light |
| Manual publication patch | Zero-context patch reverse-checked against the locally updated EN/RU pages |
Commands are in quickstart.md. Logs and generated harness output
remain in ignored build/. The existing CCProbe is extended instead of adding a
duplicate editor test harness.
Before and after
Same 1100 × 850 window, Studio Dark, 100% scale, identical notes/controller curves;
before uses the original PR head. Evidence is stored on the existing pr-assets
branch of the PR author's fork, without adding images to the code branch.
| Before | After |
|---|---|
![]() |
![]() |
Additional Studio Light and stacked-clip captures.
Limits and observed failures
- Windows x64 was tested locally; macOS and Linux were not run.
- The first smoke run found an obsolete French
CC laneskey; it and the old controller-tab instruction were removed. Localization guards then passed. - A concurrent rerun exceeded the render-pool timing limit (55/4125 late blocks) while documentation screenshots were rendering. The previous full run passed; the final quiet run passed with 0/4125 late blocks and completed the full gate.
dotnet format whitespace --verify-no-changesis not clean on the untouched PR baseline either: 260 diagnostics in the same six files. This change follows the surrounding compact formatting; no repository-wide reformat was made.- The separate manual repository contains pre-existing local work. Only relevant
pages/screenshots were updated; the shortcut generator used the existing workspace
source plus the new controller rows to preserve its other pending feature entries.
No manual commit or push is included in this app-only PR. Apply manual.patch
with
git apply --unidiff-zeroin nota-docs and regenerate shortcuts when publishing its separate update.
Submission
Implementation converged: nine functional requirements, four buildable success criteria,
nine story acceptance scenarios and all eight constitution principles reviewed; zero
remaining code findings. SC-005 and task T016 also passed: commit 54a69e30259e1ebb2de9bc87c6382a366ba213c3
was pushed with an ordinary fast forward and the GitHub API confirmed it as the head
of the still-open PR #425 on the same fork/branch. The original PR head remains an
ancestor. No new branch or PR was created. All 16 tasks are complete.
Final quiet gate: build/build-win-quiet.log ends with SMOKE TEST PASSED and
SCAN SCALE PASSED (exit 0). The concurrent timing failure was not reproduced.
Merge with develop — 2026-11-04
Integrated develop at d57d86dc839433c654ae17f67267a96b328fa35b into the existing PR
branch, preserving the prior PR head 273051768eabd99201810044a37ca0d5e610c623.
Three conflict paths were resolved:
PianoRollView.Controllers.cs: retain the PR's cache/gesture generation checks while using develop's stable localization key for the clear menu.PreferencesWindow.cs: retain develop's Bend-range instruction and key-based strings, plus the PR's in-lane dropdown, sidebar action and divider instructions.Languages/fr.json: accept develop's removal of bundled translations. Migrate the lane UI's English texts to stable keys inNota.Application/Localization/en.json; translations follow develop's downloaded-language and English-fallback model.
Validation after integration:
- 86 real Windows UI checks passed, including the retained Bend-range instruction.
- Independent lane heights restored in a fresh process.
- Final
scripts/build-win.ps1passed, exit 0: native/managed build, scanner self-test, full smoke suite and scan-scale suite. Logs are in ignoredbuild/merge-develop-build-win-final.log. - Localization guards passed: every key resolves, no reference entries are unused, and translations are no longer bundled. The redesign has 11 new stable text keys; the superseded primary-controller instruction key was removed.
- The first full run missed one render timing guard (five late blocks in 50 ms, limit four). A standalone recheck passed, and the final full run also passed (maximum burst three). No guard thresholds or native code were changed relative to develop.
- No unresolved Git entries remain; the PR diff against develop passes whitespace checks. The original redesign spec and integration plan converge with no remaining implementation gaps. macOS and Linux were not run locally.

