Skip to content

Open-source SEO, GEO, and marketing skills for AI agents.

8.7 KB
Raw Blame

Repeatable Optimization Loops

This reference turns the generalized paid-search patterns in ../../shared/ppc-optimization-pattern-playbook.md plus NotFair/Tong operating patterns into reusable Google Ads workflows. Use it when the user asks for recurring improvement, daily/weekly checks, campaign cleanup, or "what should I do next?"

Core principle: diagnose the bottleneck before changing the account. Most failed optimizations come from treating symptoms — low conversions, high CPA, limited spend — without separating measurement, query quality, rank, budget, ad message, and landing-page fit.


Loop 1 — Daily / recent-day keyword and search-term check

Use for: "check today's keyword", "what spent today", "overview and proposal", small-account monitoring, post-change watch.

Pull once

Use available read capabilities and batch related data when useful. Consider:

  • Campaign metrics for today, yesterday, 7d, and 30d.
  • Keyword metrics for the active/recent day.
  • Search terms for the active/recent day.
  • Campaign budgets, bidding strategy, search lost IS budget/rank, top IS / absolute top IS where available.
  • Recent account change history for context.

Interpret

Report in this order:

  1. Evaluated — spend, clicks, impressions, conversions, avg CPC, CTR, and whether the campaign is enabled/serving.
  2. Changed — what was changed recently, or "nothing today".
  3. Saw — 1–3 concrete search-term / keyword observations.
  4. Proposal — either a small action or "no change proposed yet".

Decision rules

  • Thin or immature data: do not overfit a recent day. Compare with a complete baseline, account for conversion lag, and say what evidence or business guardrail will trigger the next review.
  • Query quality problem: propose negatives only for clearly irrelevant terms or repeated expensive bad patterns.
  • Clean traffic but no conversions: check landing page / form / tracking before touching bids.
  • Rank-limited and far under budget: prioritize ad relevance, Quality Score, landing-page message match, and bid competitiveness; do not recommend more budget.
  • Budget-limited with good CPA: budget increase can be reasonable, but first verify marginal query quality and search partners.

Tong-facing output should be short, like an operator note — not a full audit.


Loop 2 — Search-term → n-gram → action buckets

Use for: wasted spend, add negatives, broad match cleanup, low conversion quality, PMax/Search overlap.

Pull once

Search term data for 30–90 days by campaign/ad group/network:

  • search term, campaign/ad group, keyword where available
  • cost, clicks, impressions, conversions, conversion value
  • network segment if available
  • campaign type / bidding strategy

Aggregate

Inside the script, tokenize search terms into 1-, 2-, and 3-grams. For each n-gram capture:

  • total cost, clicks, impressions, conversions, CPA / ROAS
  • distinct search terms, campaigns, ad groups
  • example queries by spend
  • whether the n-gram appears in existing positives or negatives

Action buckets

Do not output one raw list. Classify:

  1. Negative candidates — irrelevant intent, wrong geography, job seeker, DIY/info, free/cheap when not offered, competitor/name-seeking when not intentionally conquesting.
  2. Keyword candidates — converting search terms not present as exact/phrase positives.
  3. Routing candidates — same query/n-gram served by multiple ad groups with materially different CPA/CVR.
  4. Ad / landing-page mismatch — relevant query, poor performance, weak message match or QS component.
  5. Product / content opportunity — repeated relevant demand the business does not currently target or sell.

Safeguards

  • Never negative a brand/protected/core service term without explicit user confirmation.
  • Check positive-keyword and high-value search-term conflicts before adding negatives.
  • Prefer shared negative lists for universal disqualifiers; use campaign/ad-group negatives for routing.
  • Negative match variants matter: plurals, misspellings, and close variants are not as forgiving as positive keywords.
  • Treat high-spend/no-conversion n-grams as review triggers, not automatic negatives.

Loop 3 — Budget / impression-share triage

Use for: "raise budget", "limited by budget", "not spending", "more conversions", "rank loss", "why did conversions drop?"

Pull once

Campaign-level:

  • cost, clicks, impressions, conversions, CPA / ROAS for 7d, 30d, and prior comparable window
  • daily budget and actual daily spend
  • search impression share, lost IS due to budget, lost IS due to rank, top IS, absolute top IS
  • bidding strategy, target CPA/ROAS, learning/primary status if available
  • search-term quality and network split
  • recent changes

Classify the blocker

  • Budget-constrained: spend reaches budget and lost IS budget is material.
  • Rank-constrained: spend is below budget and lost IS rank is material.
  • Demand-constrained: low impressions with low lost IS; market/search volume is limited.
  • Quality-constrained: rank loss plus weak QS/ad relevance/LPX.
  • Query-quality constrained: spend scales into irrelevant/non-converting terms.
  • Tracking-constrained: conversion signal is broken or inconsistent.

Recommendation rules

  • Lost IS budget near zero → budget increase is unlikely to help.
  • Spend far below budget + high rank-lost IS → improve relevance / landing page / bid competitiveness before increasing budget.
  • Budget-limited + profitable CPA/ROAS + clean search terms → propose a measured budget increase within guardrails.
  • Budget-limited + broad/search-partner waste → clean traffic first; more budget will scale waste.
  • PMax overlap can distort Search impression share. Check PMax/Search term overlap before declaring Search demand missing.

Loop 4 — Broad match readiness and containment

Use for: "should we use broad", Google recommendations, scaling a campaign, broad match waste.

Readiness gate

Broad match is only testable when most of these are true:

  • Conversion tracking is trustworthy and primary actions match the business goal.
  • The campaign has enough conversion volume for automated bidding to learn.
  • Budget can absorb exploration without starving proven exact/phrase terms.
  • Landing pages are focused enough that broader query intent still receives a relevant page.
  • Existing search-term review cadence and negative/shared-list hygiene exist.
  • The campaign is not a very short buying-cycle / tiny-budget / weak-signal account where every bad click hurts.

Safer rollout

  • Prefer experiment or limited ad-group rollout over account-wide broad expansion.
  • Pre-build obvious negatives and brand/geography controls.
  • Monitor query mix, CPA/ROAS, CTR, CVR, and incremental conversions against exact/phrase baseline.
  • Do not assume exact always beats broad; with strong Smart Bidding, broad can sometimes find better converting auctions. Keep what wins on business metrics.

Loop 5 — Conversion tracking integrity before optimization

Use for: first audit, CPA/ROAS seems wrong, Smart Bidding, offline conversions, low-volume client accounts.

Before aggressive bid/budget/keyword decisions, verify:

  • At least one relevant primary conversion action is enabled.
  • Lead-gen uses one-per-click counting unless there is a clear reason not to.
  • Purchase/value accounts have sane values and currency.
  • Imported/read-only actions are understood before trying to mutate them.
  • Campaign-specific goals do not accidentally optimize for irrelevant actions.
  • Duplicate tags/actions are not double-counting.
  • Phone, form, and offline conversion coverage matches how leads actually close.

If tracking is materially broken, stop. Fix measurement first; do not optimize bidding on bad signal.


Loop 6 — Small client-account posture

This captures the pattern from CentsIQ-style accounts: expensive clicks, low volume, high need for message match.

  • Use exact/phrase and clean query review before broad exploration.
  • Do not jump to Smart Bidding or budget increases just because volume is low.
  • If spend is far below budget, inspect rank loss and Quality Score before touching budget.
  • For high-CPC lead gen, a single bad competitor/info click matters. Daily notes should propose small negatives only when the intent is clearly wrong.
  • Landing page clarity and trust can be the highest-leverage change when query intent is clean but clicks do not convert.

Sources

  • ../../shared/ppc-optimization-pattern-playbook.md
  • Generalized paid-search operations: n-gram analysis, negative keyword hygiene, broad match readiness, RSA testing, Quality Score, impression share, conversion tracking, Search Partners, landing-page testing, and audit automation patterns.