Plan, apply and roll back changes to a production ontology, with a blast radius report and a proof an auditor can re-check.
Rust ai-nativedescription-logicsformal-verificationinfrastructure-as-codeisabelle-languageknowledge-graphleanlean4mcpmcp-serverontologyowlowl2reasoningrustshaclsparqltheorem-proving
Add cvc5 as a second SMT oracle, and measure whether it disagrees with Z3 (#184)
Fabio Rovai83f1369e88bf
diff --git a/.github/workflows/ci.yml b/.github/workflows/ci.ymlindex 31c376be..de741b64 100644--- a/.github/workflows/ci.yml+++ b/.github/workflows/ci.yml@@ -497,8 +497,8 @@ jobs:# reason every step above does.run: OO_REQUIRE_FIXTURES=1 cargo test --test demo_asset_claims_test -- --nocapture- name: Install the model finders- # Z3 reads SMT-LIB and is the only one of the two that can be asked the- # UNBOUNDED question, which is the only route to `unsatisfiable_oracle`.+ # Z3 reads SMT-LIB and can be asked the UNBOUNDED question, which is the+ # only route to `unsatisfiable_oracle`.# Mace4 ships in the LADR/Prover9 distribution: Prover9's refutations# are uncheckable and by decision 0005 an oracle opinion for ever, but# Mace4 is a FINITE MODEL FINDER and a finite model is exactly what@@ -526,6 +526,30 @@ jobs:make -C /tmp/ladr/mace4.src all XFLAGS="-std=gnu89" >> /tmp/ladr-build.log 2>&1 || { tail -30 /tmp/ladr-build.log; exit 1; }sudo install -m 755 /tmp/ladr/bin/mace4 /usr/local/bin/mace4command -v z3 mace4+ - name: Install cvc5, the second SMT oracle+ # PINNED BY VERSION AND BY DIGEST, and the digest is the load-bearing+ # half. The release asset URL is stable and the zip is not signed, so+ # the hash is the only thing that says the bytes CI runs are the bytes+ # that were checked by hand. This is the same rule the Poly/ML step+ # below follows, and for the same reason.+ #+ # The version is pinned rather than tracked because the disagreement+ # counts this repository publishes are a property of a VERSION PAIR.+ # `latest` would silently change what the measurement is about, and the+ # next person to read the number would have no way to know.+ #+ # NOT `apt-get install cvc5`: Ubuntu noble carries no such package, and+ # `prover9` having no installation candidate on noble is exactly what+ # broke this job the first time it ran on main, so the check was done+ # rather than assumed.+ run: |+ set -euo pipefail+ curl -fsSL -o /tmp/cvc5.zip \+ https://github.com/cvc5/cvc5/releases/download/cvc5-1.3.4/cvc5-Linux-x86_64-static.zip+ echo "dcdbfada0ce493ee98259c0816e0daafc561c223aadb3af298c2968e73ea39c6 /tmp/cvc5.zip" | sha256sum -c -+ unzip -q -o /tmp/cvc5.zip -d /tmp/cvc5+ sudo install -m 755 /tmp/cvc5/cvc5-Linux-x86_64-static/bin/cvc5 /usr/local/bin/cvc5+ cvc5 --version | head -1- name: Check the first-order model certificates end to end# `lake build` already compiles these proofs, because `Fol` and# `oo-folmodel` are both in defaultTargets. What this leg adds is the@@ -542,6 +566,32 @@ jobs:run: OO_REQUIRE_FIXTURES=1 cargo test --test fol_solver_verdict_test -- --nocapture- name: Check the model ingestion, both front endsrun: OO_REQUIRE_FIXTURES=1 cargo test --test fol_model_ingest_test -- --nocapture+ - name: Build the release binary the SMT differential drives+ # The differential compares the SMT-LIB THE PRODUCT EMITS, so it runs+ # the real binary rather than linking the library. `cargo test` does not+ # build it, and without this step the file would skip on a job that+ # provides everything else it needs, which is the shape of hole+ # `tests/ci_gate_coverage_test.rs` exists to close.+ run: cargo build --release --bin open-ontologies+ - name: Run Z3 and cvc5 over the same problems, and require them not to contradict+ # The SECOND SMT ORACLE, and the reason it is here at all.+ #+ # Decision 0006 upgrades a `sat` to a certificate when the verified+ # checker accepts the model, and leaves every `unsat` an oracle opinion,+ # because checking a CDCL(T) refutation needs a mechanised calculus this+ # repository does not have. So the `unsat` half of this layer has NO+ # defence that runs inside the architecture: nothing can check it, and a+ # wrong one would be published as `unsatisfiable_oracle` with a straight+ # face. A second solver is the only thing that can contradict it.+ #+ # --nocapture because the corpus size and the agreement counts are+ # PRINTED by the test and read out of this log. No document is allowed+ # to carry them by hand.+ #+ # The last leg of this file puts a LYING z3 on PATH and requires the run+ # to go red, so the gate is known to be able to fail rather than assumed+ # to be.+ run: OO_REQUIRE_FIXTURES=1 cargo test --test smt_second_oracle_test -- --nocapture- name: Check that a projection preserves the claims an answer rests on# Coverage is a proxy, and the first two legs here are the argument for# that sentence: a slice of a SHIPPED ontology at coverage 1.0 withdiff --git a/docs/ci-gates.md b/docs/ci-gates.mdindex 55f50160..abb618a1 100644--- a/docs/ci-gates.md+++ b/docs/ci-gates.md@@ -66,6 +66,7 @@ job invokes the file at all.| `demo_asset_claims_test.rs` | lake | `lean` job | **strict** || `lean_fol_model_test.rs` | lake + `oo-folmodel` + z3 | `lean` job | **strict** || `fol_solver_verdict_test.rs` | z3 + `oo-folmodel` + the debug CLI | `lean` job | **strict** |+| `smt_second_oracle_test.rs` | z3 **and** cvc5 1.3.4 + `oo-folmodel` + the release binary | `lean` job installs cvc5 by digest and builds the release binary | **strict** || `lean_projection_entailment_test.rs` | lake | `lean` job | **strict** || `closure_diff_test.rs` | lake | `lean` job | **strict** || `projection_monotonicity_corpus_test.rs` | lake | `lean` job | **strict** |diff --git a/docs/decisions/0013-a-second-oracle-can-contradict-and-cannot-confirm.md b/docs/decisions/0013-a-second-oracle-can-contradict-and-cannot-confirm.mdnew file mode 100644index 00000000..2e44c6d6--- /dev/null+++ b/docs/decisions/0013-a-second-oracle-can-contradict-and-cannot-confirm.md@@ -0,0 +1,240 @@+# 0013 · A second oracle can contradict, and cannot confirm++- **Status**: Implemented · cvc5 1.3.4 driven from `src/fol_solve.rs` as `Solver::Cvc5` over the+ SMT-LIB `src/tptp.rs` already emits, model ingestion in `src/fol_model.rs`'s `cvc5` module,+ differential in `tools/smt_differential.py`, gate in `tests/smt_second_oracle_test.rs`, installed+ by digest in the `lean` CI job+- **Written**: 2026-09-18+- **Related**: decision 0006 (a model is a certificate, and a refutation is not), whose line this+ decision does not move and exists to defend; decision 0005 (a prover is an oracle), whose+ disagreement discipline is reused verbatim; decision 0008, which is the same argument about two+ verified kernels rather than two unverified solvers++## The problem++Decision 0006 split the SAT and SMT family in half and was right to. A `sat` answer comes with a+finite structure, `lean/Fol/` checks it, and `Fol.satisfiable_of_check` turns the solver's opinion+into a proof of satisfiability. That half is defended by a machine-checked theorem, and it is+defended against a solver that is wrong, a solver that is lying and a solver that is broken in a way+nobody has thought of, because the checker re-evaluates the formulas against the structure and reads+nothing else.++The other half has no defence at all.++An `unsat` from Z3 is written into a report as `unsatisfiable_oracle` and there it stays. Nothing in+this repository can check it, by construction rather than by omission: replaying a CDCL(T) refutation+needs a verified theory solver for every theory involved plus a verified propositional core, which is+the research project decision 0005 declines. So the layer has one arm with a proof behind it and one+arm with a single vendor's word behind it, and until this decision the second arm had never been+questioned by anything.++That asymmetry is invisible in a green run, which is what makes it worth a decision record. Every+test of the SMT layer exercises the arm that is checked. A wrong `unsat` would pass all of them.++## The asymmetry, again, because it decides what a second solver is for++A second solver adds nothing to the `sat` arm. If Z3 says `sat` and the checker accepts the+structure, cvc5's opinion is of no interest whatsoever: the certificate does not rest on Z3 and would+not rest on cvc5. Running both and calling the agreement corroboration would be theatre.++A second solver is the **only** available evidence on the `unsat` arm. Not proof, and this record+says so as often as it can: two solvers agreeing that a theory has no model is two opinions. What it+can do is the one thing a single solver cannot do at any price, which is to be WRONG IN THE OPPOSITE+DIRECTION and say so. A contradiction between them is a fact, and it is a fact that implicates one of+them without saying which.++So the value of this work is entirely in the disagreement count, and a run that finds none has+established something much weaker than a reader will assume. The measurement section below is written+with that in mind.++## Decisions++1. **The verdict vocabulary does not grow, and this is the load-bearing decision.** Decision 0006+ fixes five words. Adding a second solver adds none. In particular there is deliberately no+ `unsatisfiable_corroborated`, no `unsat_by_two_solvers` and no confidence field, because every one+ of those would be a way of writing "more than an oracle said so" without having earned it. A+ report from a cvc5 run is the same five fields with the same five possible words, and the only+ thing that changes is which binary produced the output.++2. **A cvc5 `sat` reaches the certified word by exactly the route a Z3 `sat` does, and for a reason+ worth stating.** `Fol.satisfiable_of_check` is a theorem about a structure and a formula list. Its+ statement does not mention the producer, so a second producer needs no second soundness argument+ and gets no second word. `tests/smt_second_oracle_test.rs` runs the chain end to end and reads+ `"source":"cvc5"` out of the checker's own report.++3. **Both solvers are handed ONE file, written by ONE emitter.** `fol_solve::attempt` writes+ `problem_k{k}.smt2` with no solver in the name and `to_smtlib` is the only thing that writes it.+ If the two were ever given different bytes, a disagreement between them would be a fact about the+ emitter rather than about either solver, and that is the one thing a differential must not be able+ to measure.++4. **cvc5's one option is keyed on the ENCODING and never on the caller.** With default options cvc5+ answers `unknown` on the engine's quantified problems, because its default quantifier strategy is+ E-matching and E-matching is incomplete; `--finite-model-find` makes it answer. On the finite+ encoding that flag adds nothing, since `(declare-datatypes ((U 0)) ((e0) … ))` already fixes a+ finite carrier of known size and "look for a finite model" is precisely the question the file asks.+ On the unbounded encoding it would ask a different question, and the unbounded probe is the ONLY+ route to `unsatisfiable_oracle`. Passing it there would let a bounded search's answer be filed+ under the unbounded encoding's name, which is decision 0006 item 4's ten-minute mistake with a+ solver flag standing in for the cardinality constraint. `Solver::extra_args` therefore takes the+ encoding and not a preference, and a test asserts both halves.++5. **A model is ingested only on `sat`, and with cvc5 that is load-bearing rather than tidy.**+ Measured on cvc5 1.3.4: over a problem asserting `(forall ((X0 U)) (thing X0))` on a two-element+ datatype carrier, cvc5 answered `unknown` and then printed+ `(define-fun thing ((_arg_1 U)) Bool false)`, a structure that falsifies an asserted axiom. Z3 in+ the same position prints `(error "model is not available")`. A pipeline that read the block anyway+ would hand the checker something cvc5 never claimed was a model, the checker would reject it, and+ the run would report a `model_not_confirmed` STOP_THE_LINE against a solver that had done nothing+ wrong. A false stop-the-line costs as much credibility as a missed one.+ `cvc5_prints_a_structure_after_unknown_and_the_checker_rejects_it` runs cvc5 in exactly that+ configuration, ingests the block deliberately, and requires `oo-folmodel` to reject it.++6. **Provenance is rewritten, never inherited.** Both solvers print standard SMT-LIB `(get-model)`+ output, so one parser reads both; the differences measured are cosmetic, cvc5 naming its parameters+ `_arg_1` or `$x1` where Z3 uses `x!0`. What is NOT shared is the name. `FiniteModel::source` is+ `cvc5` on a cvc5 model and every `IngestError` arm is re-attributed by `IngestError::with_solver`,+ because a diagnostic reading "could not parse z3's model" over cvc5's bytes sends a reader to the+ wrong tool. Decision 0006 item 6 records `source` as untrusted and echoed; untrusted is not a+ licence to write the name of a solver that did not produce the file.++7. **The differential refuses to report a comparison it did not make.** `tools/smt_differential.py`+ exits 3, not 0, when no problem got a decisive answer from both solvers, and prints `NO_SIGNAL`. A+ run in which every row was `unknown` would otherwise print `CONTRADICTION 0` and read as a clean+ sweep. `ONE_SIDED` and `BOTH_UNKNOWN` are counted under their own names for the same reason and are+ never folded into agreement: one solver answering and the other giving up is a difference in+ completeness, not corroboration.++8. **The gate is known to be able to fail, because it has been made to.**+ `a_lying_solver_turns_the_differential_red` puts a shell script named `z3` on `PATH` that answers+ `unsat` to everything, and requires the differential to report a contradiction and exit non-zero.+ The stub says `unsat` rather than `sat` on purpose: a stub that said `sat` would be caught by the+ verified checker one step later anyway, whereas `unsat` is the answer nothing in this architecture+ can check, which makes it the exact failure a second solver is the only defence against. That is+ the argument for this whole decision in one test.++## What was measured++`tools/smt_differential.py --json` writes the run, `tools/smt_differential_report.py` turns it into+everything below the marker, and nothing below the marker was typed by hand. The corpus is every RDF+file under `case-studies/` that `git ls-files` reports, plus `tests/data/sample.ttl`, at+`finite(1)`, `finite(2)` and `unbounded`, with four goal triples per ontology taken from the+reasoner's own certificate.++<!-- MEASUREMENT -->++Measured on 65 ontologies producing **744 SMT-LIB problems**, each handed to both solvers at every encoding, with a 5 second limit per invocation.++* z3: `Z3 version 4.16.0 - 64 bit`+* cvc5: `cvc5 1.3.4 [git f3b21c4 on branch HEAD]`, pinned at 1.3.4++| outcome | problems | what it means |+|---|---|---|+| CONTRADICTION | 0 | one said `sat` and the other `unsat` on the same bytes. One of them is wrong |+| ERROR | 0 | a solver refused the file. A defect in the emitter until shown otherwise |+| ONE_SIDED | 70 | one answered and the other gave up. A difference in completeness, and NOT corroboration |+| BOTH_UNKNOWN | 2 | neither answered. No second opinion was obtained |+| AGREE | 672 | the same answer from both. Two opinions, and on the `unsat` rows that is all it will ever be |++The 672 agreements split 537 on `unsat` and 135 on `sat`. The first of those numbers is the whole point of the exercise: those 537 answers had, before this, been checked by nothing at all, and they still have not been PROVED by anything. What changed is that a second implementation was in a position to contradict them and did not.++The one-sided rows, by who answered:++* 68: z3 said sat, cvc5 said unknown+* 2: cvc5 said sat, z3 said unknown++By encoding:++| encoding | AGREE | ONE_SIDED | BOTH_UNKNOWN | ERROR | CONTRADICTION |+|---|---|---|---|---|---|+| finite(1) | 248 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 |+| finite(2) | 245 | 3 | 0 | 0 | 0 |+| unbounded | 179 | 67 | 2 | 0 | 0 |++`--finite-model-find` changed cvc5's answer on 137 of 744 problems: 137 from `unknown` to `sat`. It never turned one decisive answer into the other, which is the property that matters: the flag recovers completeness on problems cvc5 would otherwise abandon, and on this corpus it never changed what cvc5 concluded. That is a measurement and not a guarantee, and it is the reason the flag is still refused on the unbounded encoding, where no such measurement exists.++4 files produced no problems and are named rather than dropped:++* `case-studies/heritage-aerial/deliverables/07-templates/rights-statement-template.ttl`: the certificate named no triples, so there was nothing to ask+* `case-studies/heritage-aerial/registry/compliance-declaration-template.ttl`: the certificate named no triples, so there was nothing to ask+* `case-studies/heritage-aerial/registry/registry-shapes.ttl`: the certificate named no triples, so there was nothing to ask+* `case-studies/skills-england-occupational-maps/ontology/occupational-map.ttl`: 5.7 MB over the 4 MB cap++The run this section was generated from is committed at [`docs/measurements-smt-differential-2026-09-18.json`](../measurements-smt-differential-2026-09-18.json), and `tools/smt_differential_report.py` regenerates the section from it. Neither the table nor the sentences around it were typed by hand, which is the only way a record and the run behind it stay in step.++**Zero contradictions is a negative result and is reported as one.** It is not evidence that either solver is correct, and it is weaker evidence than it looks: the two are different programs, but they implement the same family of algorithms over the same standard, and on problems this exporter produces both are running an essentially mechanical search. The comparison that would be worth more is the one decision 0008 describes, between two independent formalisations of a specification, and it is a different kind of evidence rather than a larger amount of this one.++## The rows that looked like a capability gain, and were not++The table has rows where cvc5 decided a problem Z3 could not. That is the result in the run a reader+would naturally take as the practical argument for a second solver, so it was checked rather than+quoted, and it does not survive the check.++Both rows are the `finite(2)` encoding of `case-studies/foundry-owl-crosswalk/ontology/foundry-crosswalk.ttl`+and `case-studies/skills-england-occupational-maps/ontology/seom-vocabulary.ttl`, where Z3 hit the+five second limit and cvc5 answered `sat`. But the shipped pipeline never asks those problems. The+bounded ladder in `fol_solve::solve` starts at carrier 1 and STOPS at the first model, and on both+ontologies both solvers find one at carrier 1. Measured, running the real pipeline at a five second+and a thirty second limit, four runs per ontology:++| ontology | solver | verdict | encoding | seconds |+|---|---|---|---|---|+| foundry-crosswalk.ttl | z3 | `model_checked` | finite(1) | 0.09 |+| foundry-crosswalk.ttl | cvc5 | `model_checked` | finite(1) | 0.09 |+| seom-vocabulary.ttl | z3 | `model_checked` | finite(1) | 0.15 |+| seom-vocabulary.ttl | cvc5 | `model_checked` | finite(1) | 0.17 |++So the honest reading of the whole run is that cvc5 changed no verdict this engine would ever+produce, on any ontology in the corpus. It is a second opinion on the arm that had none, and on this+corpus that is the entirety of what it bought. The measurement is kept because the next corpus may+answer differently and because the number that matters is the one nobody has yet seen go non-zero.++## What this does not claim++1. **Not that the `unsat` answers are right.** Zero contradictions over this corpus means the two+ solvers were not caught disagreeing on it. It is not evidence that either is correct, and it is+ much weaker evidence than a reader's instinct suggests, for the reason in the next item.++2. **Not that agreement here is independent evidence.** Z3 and cvc5 are different programs with+ different authors, but they implement the same family of algorithms over the same standard, and on+ problems in the decidable fragment this engine emits they are both doing an essentially mechanical+ search. Two implementations of a well-understood decision procedure agreeing is much less+ surprising than two independent formalisations agreeing, which is the comparison decision 0008 is+ about and is a genuinely different kind of evidence.++3. **Nothing about unsatisfiability, in any direction, ever.** Unchanged from decision 0006 and+ restated here because a second solver is precisely the sort of addition that invites someone to+ relax it.++4. **Not that cvc5 is better or worse than Z3 at this.** The runs below use one option setting per+ encoding, one time limit, and one problem shape. A benchmark would need to vary all three and is+ not what this is.++5. **Not that the corpus is the interesting part of the space.** Every problem here comes from an+ OWL export, so they share a shape: one sort, unary and binary predicates, nullary constants, and+ quantifier nesting bounded by the translation. A disagreement, if one exists, is more likely to+ live in a shape this exporter cannot produce.++## Still not done++- **cvc5's proofs are not read.** cvc5 can emit proofs in several formats, including LFSC and Alethe,+ and unlike Z3's proof logs some of those are designed to be checked. That does not make them+ checkable HERE, because checking one still needs a mechanised calculus in core Lean, but it is a+ materially better starting point than anything the first-order provers offer and it is the obvious+ next question for the `unsat` arm. Nothing in this decision touches it.++- **The unbounded encoding's models are still not ingested, now for two solvers rather than one.**+ Z3 prints a universe block and cvc5 prints `(as @U_0 U)` qualified identifiers; neither is the+ enumeration the finite encoding declares. Decision 0006 listed this as open and it stays open.+ `an_ingestion_failure_names_the_solver_that_produced_the_output` pins the refusal so it stays a+ named `Unsupported` rather than becoming an approximation.++- **The differential is not run over the whole repository corpus in CI.** The `lean` job runs it over+ two ontologies, which takes seconds; a whole-corpus run takes hours on one machine, largely in the+ solvers rather than the engine. The run recorded above was done by hand. A scheduled workflow is+ the obvious home for the larger one and does not exist.++- **Mace4 is not in the differential.** It reads LADR rather than SMT-LIB, so it is not being handed+ the same bytes, and decision 0006's own rule is that the two solvers must read one file. A+ three-way comparison would need the comparison to be over the problem rather than over the file,+ which is a different tool with a different argument behind it.diff --git a/docs/decisions/README.md b/docs/decisions/README.mdindex 957ca542..f9ce9296 100644--- a/docs/decisions/README.md+++ b/docs/decisions/README.md@@ -16,10 +16,16 @@ and whose benefit is not gets dropped the first time it is inconvenient.| [0010](0010-the-input-is-a-value-and-not-a-store.md) | The input is a value and not a store | Certifying a run against a store that can change under it || [0011](0011-a-module-carries-a-theorem-and-a-slice-carries-a-measurement.md) | A module carries a theorem, a slice carries a measurement | Reading a measured slice as though it carried the theorem a module does || [0012](0012-concurrency-lives-below-the-certificate.md) | Concurrency lives below the certificate, and a proof cannot follow it there | Adopting a program logic for a hazard that lives in a dependency, and calling the result assurance |+| [0013](0013-a-second-oracle-can-contradict-and-cannot-confirm.md) | A second oracle can contradict, and cannot confirm | A second solver's agreement being read as corroboration of the one answer nothing can check || [0014](0014-a-verifier-that-cannot-read-the-code-verifies-a-rewrite.md) | A verifier that cannot read the code verifies a rewrite | Counting a green verifier as evidence about code it never read || [0015](0015-a-blank-line-is-a-line-or-it-is-not.md) | A blank line is a line, or it is not, and the format never said which | The same failure again, found by a third kernel and still OPEN: two checkers reading one file differently because nobody wrote down what an empty line is || [0016](0016-a-conclusion-names-the-axioms-responsible-for-it.md) | A conclusion names the axioms responsible for it, and minimality is re-run | Presenting a justification as minimal when nothing re-ran it |+This table is not the whole set. Decisions 0009, 0010 and 0011 are in this directory and have no row+here, and the number 0009 was used twice by two records written in parallel. Both are stated rather+than quietly left for a reader to discover, because an index that looks complete and is not is worse+than one that admits the gap.+There is no 0004. The decision now numbered 0006 was drafted as 0004 on a branch that never merged,so the number never reached `main`. It is left as a hole rather than reused, because a reused numbermakes an old citation silently come to mean something else.diff --git a/docs/measurements-smt-differential-2026-09-18.json b/docs/measurements-smt-differential-2026-09-18.jsonnew file mode 100644index 00000000..b0b6fc9a--- /dev/null+++ b/docs/measurements-smt-differential-2026-09-18.json@@ -0,0 +1,900 @@+{ "counts": {"AGREE": 672, "BOTH_UNKNOWN": 2, "ONE_SIDED": 70},+ "versions": {"cvc5": "cvc5 1.3.4 [git f3b21c4 on branch HEAD]", "z3": "Z3 version 4.16.0 - 64 bit"},+ "cvc5_pinned": "1.3.4",+ "version_drift": null,+ "domains": ["1", "2", "unbounded"],+ "timeout_secs": 5,+ "problems": 744,+ "decisive_both": 672,+ "not_run": [+ {"name": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/deliverables/07-templates/rights-statement-template.ttl", "reason": "the certificate named no triples, so there was nothing to ask"},+ {"name": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/registry/compliance-declaration-template.ttl", "reason": "the certificate named no triples, so there was nothing to ask"},+ {"name": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/registry/registry-shapes.ttl", "reason": "the certificate named no triples, so there was nothing to ask"},+ {"name": "case-studies/skills-england-occupational-maps/ontology/occupational-map.ttl", "reason": "5.7 MB over the 4 MB cap"}+ ],+ "cvc5_tuning_changed": [+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "1", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmprehco9az/export_1/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "2", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmprehco9az/export_2/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "1", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmp1th5q3cc/export_1/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "2", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmp1th5q3cc/export_2/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "1", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmpjdq7e232/export_1/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "2", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmpjdq7e232/export_2/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "1", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmpphcag8h_/export_1/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "2", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmpphcag8h_/export_2/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "1", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmpdv4igxe0/export_1/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "1", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmpdv4igxe0/export_1/goals/goal_00000.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "1", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmpdv4igxe0/export_1/goals/goal_00001.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "1", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmpdv4igxe0/export_1/goals/goal_00003.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "2", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmpdv4igxe0/export_2/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "2", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmpdv4igxe0/export_2/goals/goal_00000.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "2", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmpdv4igxe0/export_2/goals/goal_00001.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "2", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmpdv4igxe0/export_2/goals/goal_00003.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "1", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmp7g_w23bg/export_1/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "2", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmp7g_w23bg/export_2/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "1", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmp7f4ith1_/export_1/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "2", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmp7f4ith1_/export_2/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "1", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmpsxjpouym/export_1/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "2", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmpsxjpouym/export_2/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "1", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmp_2toeptu/export_1/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "2", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmp_2toeptu/export_2/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "1", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmpijkd31qo/export_1/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "2", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmpijkd31qo/export_2/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "1", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmpvlt99z9u/export_1/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "2", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmpvlt99z9u/export_2/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "1", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmpqqzl3ijs/export_1/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "2", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmpqqzl3ijs/export_2/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "1", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmpbionpcwr/export_1/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "2", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmpbionpcwr/export_2/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "1", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmp50w_026h/export_1/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "1", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmp8wdfygob/export_1/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "2", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmp8wdfygob/export_2/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "1", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmpzyd5go2u/export_1/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "2", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmpzyd5go2u/export_2/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "1", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmp93j4nzeg/export_1/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "2", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmp93j4nzeg/export_2/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "1", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmpjdzwp543/export_1/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "2", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmpjdzwp543/export_2/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "1", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmpa_p8eyp9/export_1/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "2", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmpa_p8eyp9/export_2/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "1", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmp8xgfo0jl/export_1/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "2", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmp8xgfo0jl/export_2/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "1", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmpler5xc2d/export_1/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "2", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmpler5xc2d/export_2/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "1", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmp1tkhswr5/export_1/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "2", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmp1tkhswr5/export_2/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "1", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmpbvc1vg9x/export_1/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "2", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmpbvc1vg9x/export_2/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "1", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmphww0j6b8/export_1/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "2", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmphww0j6b8/export_2/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "1", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmpzazy5owk/export_1/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "2", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmpzazy5owk/export_2/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "1", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmp0dgt_5ss/export_1/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "2", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmp0dgt_5ss/export_2/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "1", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmpwyse8v9n/export_1/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "2", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmpwyse8v9n/export_2/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "1", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmpx_xdww2o/export_1/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "2", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmpx_xdww2o/export_2/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "1", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmppttoetih/export_1/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "2", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmppttoetih/export_2/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "1", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmpogepg6id/export_1/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "2", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmpogepg6id/export_2/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "1", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmpnz1xmw1p/export_1/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "2", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmpnz1xmw1p/export_2/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "1", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmpty88ov84/export_1/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "2", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmpty88ov84/export_2/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "1", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmpm6fzbvlx/export_1/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "2", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmpm6fzbvlx/export_2/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "1", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmpoz0bkez0/export_1/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "1", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmpoz0bkez0/export_1/goals/goal_00002.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "2", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmpoz0bkez0/export_2/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "2", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmpoz0bkez0/export_2/goals/goal_00002.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "1", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmpxbgnsruu/export_1/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "2", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmpxbgnsruu/export_2/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "1", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmpe_4y0imo/export_1/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "2", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmpe_4y0imo/export_2/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "1", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmpfmaqn5ig/export_1/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "2", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmpfmaqn5ig/export_2/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "1", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmpqidha9u_/export_1/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "2", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmpqidha9u_/export_2/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "1", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmp2vgk2ixd/export_1/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "2", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmp2vgk2ixd/export_2/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "1", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmp_xrhmqm9/export_1/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "2", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmp_xrhmqm9/export_2/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "1", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmpu2rlxj11/export_1/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "2", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmpu2rlxj11/export_2/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "1", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmpc_zc1kch/export_1/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "2", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmpc_zc1kch/export_2/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "1", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmp19kzypl_/export_1/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "2", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmp19kzypl_/export_2/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "1", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmpksjcz6ff/export_1/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "2", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmpksjcz6ff/export_2/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "1", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmpzaqg8gur/export_1/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "2", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmpzaqg8gur/export_2/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "1", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmpxe_jqcar/export_1/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "2", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmpxe_jqcar/export_2/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "1", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmp_9wmojsh/export_1/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "2", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmp_9wmojsh/export_2/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "1", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmp9acjisbr/export_1/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "2", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmp9acjisbr/export_2/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "1", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmpgilm8r50/export_1/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "2", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmpgilm8r50/export_2/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "1", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmp0eliu8fk/export_1/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "2", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmp0eliu8fk/export_2/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "1", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmp8lo9e7mr/export_1/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "2", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmp8lo9e7mr/export_2/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "1", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmp1_lcnpc9/export_1/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "2", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmp1_lcnpc9/export_2/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "1", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmpg1m7jdoi/export_1/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "2", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmpg1m7jdoi/export_2/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "1", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmpzhlcpp8a/export_1/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "2", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmpzhlcpp8a/export_2/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "1", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmp3hqzb4m0/export_1/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "2", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmp3hqzb4m0/export_2/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "1", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmp3ukpct0s/export_1/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "2", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmp3ukpct0s/export_2/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "1", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmpgvy0emla/export_1/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "2", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmpgvy0emla/export_2/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "1", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmp0gzw8q5q/export_1/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "2", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmp0gzw8q5q/export_2/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "1", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmp161hlfzl/export_1/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "2", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmp161hlfzl/export_2/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "1", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmpb2bhrs3z/export_1/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "2", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmpb2bhrs3z/export_2/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "1", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmp5zxg3woh/export_1/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "2", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmp5zxg3woh/export_2/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "1", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmpflq4xmh0/export_1/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "2", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmpflq4xmh0/export_2/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "1", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmpdkvq62i0/export_1/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "2", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmpdkvq62i0/export_2/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "1", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmp_s9g1o5u/export_1/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "2", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmp_s9g1o5u/export_2/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "1", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmpuyfgkujn/export_1/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"},+ {"default": "unknown", "encoding": "2", "file": "/var/folders/6_/xyrdjc_55595gmh482yt84w80000gn/T/tmpuyfgkujn/export_2/ontology.smt2", "tuned": "sat"}+ ],+ "rows": [+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "ontology", "label": "amr-kg-grounded.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/bio-kg-triage/build/amr-kg-grounded.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/bio-kg-triage/build/amr-kg-grounded.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/bio-kg-triage/build/amr-kg-grounded.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "ontology", "label": "amr-kg-grounded.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/bio-kg-triage/build/amr-kg-grounded.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/bio-kg-triage/build/amr-kg-grounded.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/bio-kg-triage/build/amr-kg-grounded.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unknown", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "z3 said sat, cvc5 said unknown", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "ontology", "label": "amr-kg-grounded.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/bio-kg-triage/build/amr-kg-grounded.ttl", "verdict": "ONE_SIDED", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/bio-kg-triage/build/amr-kg-grounded.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/bio-kg-triage/build/amr-kg-grounded.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "ontology", "label": "bio-kg-grounded.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/bio-kg-triage/build/bio-kg-grounded.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/bio-kg-triage/build/bio-kg-grounded.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/bio-kg-triage/build/bio-kg-grounded.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "ontology", "label": "bio-kg-grounded.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/bio-kg-triage/build/bio-kg-grounded.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/bio-kg-triage/build/bio-kg-grounded.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/bio-kg-triage/build/bio-kg-grounded.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unknown", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "z3 said sat, cvc5 said unknown", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "ontology", "label": "bio-kg-grounded.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/bio-kg-triage/build/bio-kg-grounded.ttl", "verdict": "ONE_SIDED", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/bio-kg-triage/build/bio-kg-grounded.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/bio-kg-triage/build/bio-kg-grounded.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "ontology", "label": "bio-kg-ungrounded.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/bio-kg-triage/build/bio-kg-ungrounded.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/bio-kg-triage/build/bio-kg-ungrounded.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/bio-kg-triage/build/bio-kg-ungrounded.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "ontology", "label": "bio-kg-ungrounded.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/bio-kg-triage/build/bio-kg-ungrounded.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/bio-kg-triage/build/bio-kg-ungrounded.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/bio-kg-triage/build/bio-kg-ungrounded.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unknown", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "z3 said sat, cvc5 said unknown", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "ontology", "label": "bio-kg-ungrounded.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/bio-kg-triage/build/bio-kg-ungrounded.ttl", "verdict": "ONE_SIDED", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/bio-kg-triage/build/bio-kg-ungrounded.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/bio-kg-triage/build/bio-kg-ungrounded.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "ontology", "label": "lit-kg-grounded.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/bio-kg-triage/build/lit-kg-grounded.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/bio-kg-triage/build/lit-kg-grounded.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/bio-kg-triage/build/lit-kg-grounded.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/bio-kg-triage/build/lit-kg-grounded.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00003", "ontology": "case-studies/bio-kg-triage/build/lit-kg-grounded.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "ontology", "label": "lit-kg-grounded.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/bio-kg-triage/build/lit-kg-grounded.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/bio-kg-triage/build/lit-kg-grounded.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/bio-kg-triage/build/lit-kg-grounded.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/bio-kg-triage/build/lit-kg-grounded.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00003", "ontology": "case-studies/bio-kg-triage/build/lit-kg-grounded.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unknown", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "z3 said sat, cvc5 said unknown", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "ontology", "label": "lit-kg-grounded.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/bio-kg-triage/build/lit-kg-grounded.ttl", "verdict": "ONE_SIDED", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/bio-kg-triage/build/lit-kg-grounded.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/bio-kg-triage/build/lit-kg-grounded.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/bio-kg-triage/build/lit-kg-grounded.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00003", "ontology": "case-studies/bio-kg-triage/build/lit-kg-grounded.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "ontology", "label": "blast-furnace-ontology.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/blast-furnace-ironmaking/blast-furnace-ontology.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/blast-furnace-ironmaking/blast-furnace-ontology.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/blast-furnace-ironmaking/blast-furnace-ontology.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/blast-furnace-ironmaking/blast-furnace-ontology.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00003", "ontology": "case-studies/blast-furnace-ironmaking/blast-furnace-ontology.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "ontology", "label": "blast-furnace-ontology.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/blast-furnace-ironmaking/blast-furnace-ontology.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/blast-furnace-ironmaking/blast-furnace-ontology.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/blast-furnace-ironmaking/blast-furnace-ontology.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/blast-furnace-ironmaking/blast-furnace-ontology.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00003", "ontology": "case-studies/blast-furnace-ironmaking/blast-furnace-ontology.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unknown", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "z3 said sat, cvc5 said unknown", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "ontology", "label": "blast-furnace-ontology.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/blast-furnace-ironmaking/blast-furnace-ontology.ttl", "verdict": "ONE_SIDED", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unknown", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "z3 said sat, cvc5 said unknown", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/blast-furnace-ironmaking/blast-furnace-ontology.ttl", "verdict": "ONE_SIDED", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unknown", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "z3 said sat, cvc5 said unknown", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/blast-furnace-ironmaking/blast-furnace-ontology.ttl", "verdict": "ONE_SIDED", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/blast-furnace-ironmaking/blast-furnace-ontology.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unknown", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "z3 said sat, cvc5 said unknown", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00003", "ontology": "case-studies/blast-furnace-ironmaking/blast-furnace-ontology.ttl", "verdict": "ONE_SIDED", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "ontology", "label": "safety-invariants.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/blast-furnace-ironmaking/safety-invariants.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/blast-furnace-ironmaking/safety-invariants.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/blast-furnace-ironmaking/safety-invariants.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/blast-furnace-ironmaking/safety-invariants.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00003", "ontology": "case-studies/blast-furnace-ironmaking/safety-invariants.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "ontology", "label": "safety-invariants.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/blast-furnace-ironmaking/safety-invariants.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/blast-furnace-ironmaking/safety-invariants.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/blast-furnace-ironmaking/safety-invariants.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/blast-furnace-ironmaking/safety-invariants.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00003", "ontology": "case-studies/blast-furnace-ironmaking/safety-invariants.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unknown", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "z3 said sat, cvc5 said unknown", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "ontology", "label": "safety-invariants.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/blast-furnace-ironmaking/safety-invariants.ttl", "verdict": "ONE_SIDED", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/blast-furnace-ironmaking/safety-invariants.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/blast-furnace-ironmaking/safety-invariants.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/blast-furnace-ironmaking/safety-invariants.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00003", "ontology": "case-studies/blast-furnace-ironmaking/safety-invariants.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "ontology", "label": "sensor-snapshots.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/blast-furnace-ironmaking/sensor-snapshots.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/blast-furnace-ironmaking/sensor-snapshots.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00003", "ontology": "case-studies/blast-furnace-ironmaking/sensor-snapshots.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "ontology", "label": "sensor-snapshots.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/blast-furnace-ironmaking/sensor-snapshots.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/blast-furnace-ironmaking/sensor-snapshots.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00003", "ontology": "case-studies/blast-furnace-ironmaking/sensor-snapshots.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unknown", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "z3 said sat, cvc5 said unknown", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "ontology", "label": "sensor-snapshots.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/blast-furnace-ironmaking/sensor-snapshots.ttl", "verdict": "ONE_SIDED", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/blast-furnace-ironmaking/sensor-snapshots.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00003", "ontology": "case-studies/blast-furnace-ironmaking/sensor-snapshots.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "ontology", "label": "foundry-crosswalk.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/foundry-owl-crosswalk/ontology/foundry-crosswalk.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/foundry-owl-crosswalk/ontology/foundry-crosswalk.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00003", "ontology": "case-studies/foundry-owl-crosswalk/ontology/foundry-crosswalk.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "cvc5 said sat, z3 said unknown", "encoding": "2", "kind": "ontology", "label": "foundry-crosswalk.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/foundry-owl-crosswalk/ontology/foundry-crosswalk.ttl", "verdict": "ONE_SIDED", "z3": "unknown", "z3_detail": "z3 stopped on a resource limit: timeout"},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/foundry-owl-crosswalk/ontology/foundry-crosswalk.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00003", "ontology": "case-studies/foundry-owl-crosswalk/ontology/foundry-crosswalk.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unknown", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "cvc5 stopped on a resource limit: interrupted by timeout", "detail": "neither solver answered", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "ontology", "label": "foundry-crosswalk.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/foundry-owl-crosswalk/ontology/foundry-crosswalk.ttl", "verdict": "BOTH_UNKNOWN", "z3": "unknown", "z3_detail": "z3 stopped on a resource limit: timeout"},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/foundry-owl-crosswalk/ontology/foundry-crosswalk.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00003", "ontology": "case-studies/foundry-owl-crosswalk/ontology/foundry-crosswalk.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "ontology", "label": "ies-common.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/foundry-owl-crosswalk/vendor/ies-common.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/foundry-owl-crosswalk/vendor/ies-common.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/foundry-owl-crosswalk/vendor/ies-common.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/foundry-owl-crosswalk/vendor/ies-common.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00003", "ontology": "case-studies/foundry-owl-crosswalk/vendor/ies-common.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "ontology", "label": "ies-common.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/foundry-owl-crosswalk/vendor/ies-common.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/foundry-owl-crosswalk/vendor/ies-common.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/foundry-owl-crosswalk/vendor/ies-common.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/foundry-owl-crosswalk/vendor/ies-common.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00003", "ontology": "case-studies/foundry-owl-crosswalk/vendor/ies-common.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unknown", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "cvc5 stopped on a resource limit: interrupted by timeout", "detail": "z3 said sat, cvc5 said unknown", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "ontology", "label": "ies-common.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/foundry-owl-crosswalk/vendor/ies-common.ttl", "verdict": "ONE_SIDED", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/foundry-owl-crosswalk/vendor/ies-common.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/foundry-owl-crosswalk/vendor/ies-common.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/foundry-owl-crosswalk/vendor/ies-common.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00003", "ontology": "case-studies/foundry-owl-crosswalk/vendor/ies-common.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "ontology", "label": "real-napl-sample.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/data/real-napl-sample.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/data/real-napl-sample.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/data/real-napl-sample.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "ontology", "label": "real-napl-sample.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/data/real-napl-sample.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/data/real-napl-sample.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/data/real-napl-sample.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unknown", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "z3 said sat, cvc5 said unknown", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "ontology", "label": "real-napl-sample.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/data/real-napl-sample.ttl", "verdict": "ONE_SIDED", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/data/real-napl-sample.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/data/real-napl-sample.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "ontology", "label": "real-ncap-sample.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/data/real-ncap-sample.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/data/real-ncap-sample.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "ontology", "label": "real-ncap-sample.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/data/real-ncap-sample.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/data/real-ncap-sample.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unknown", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "z3 said sat, cvc5 said unknown", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "ontology", "label": "real-ncap-sample.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/data/real-ncap-sample.ttl", "verdict": "ONE_SIDED", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/data/real-ncap-sample.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "ontology", "label": "real-whai-sample.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/data/real-whai-sample.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/data/real-whai-sample.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "ontology", "label": "real-whai-sample.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/data/real-whai-sample.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/data/real-whai-sample.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unknown", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "z3 said sat, cvc5 said unknown", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "ontology", "label": "real-whai-sample.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/data/real-whai-sample.ttl", "verdict": "ONE_SIDED", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/data/real-whai-sample.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "ontology", "label": "sample-photographs.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/data/sample-photographs.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/data/sample-photographs.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00003", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/data/sample-photographs.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "ontology", "label": "sample-photographs.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/data/sample-photographs.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/data/sample-photographs.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00003", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/data/sample-photographs.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unknown", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "z3 said sat, cvc5 said unknown", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "ontology", "label": "sample-photographs.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/data/sample-photographs.ttl", "verdict": "ONE_SIDED", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/data/sample-photographs.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00003", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/data/sample-photographs.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "ontology", "label": "ncap-commerce.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/extensions/commerce/build/ncap-commerce.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/extensions/commerce/build/ncap-commerce.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unknown", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "cvc5 stopped on a resource limit: interrupted by timeout", "detail": "z3 said sat, cvc5 said unknown", "encoding": "2", "kind": "ontology", "label": "ncap-commerce.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/extensions/commerce/build/ncap-commerce.ttl", "verdict": "ONE_SIDED", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/extensions/commerce/build/ncap-commerce.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unknown", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "z3 said sat, cvc5 said unknown", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "ontology", "label": "ncap-commerce.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/extensions/commerce/build/ncap-commerce.ttl", "verdict": "ONE_SIDED", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/extensions/commerce/build/ncap-commerce.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "ontology", "label": "c1_licensable_no_offer.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/extensions/commerce/controls/c1_licensable_no_offer.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/extensions/commerce/controls/c1_licensable_no_offer.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/extensions/commerce/controls/c1_licensable_no_offer.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "ontology", "label": "c1_licensable_no_offer.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/extensions/commerce/controls/c1_licensable_no_offer.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/extensions/commerce/controls/c1_licensable_no_offer.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/extensions/commerce/controls/c1_licensable_no_offer.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unknown", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "z3 said sat, cvc5 said unknown", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "ontology", "label": "c1_licensable_no_offer.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/extensions/commerce/controls/c1_licensable_no_offer.ttl", "verdict": "ONE_SIDED", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/extensions/commerce/controls/c1_licensable_no_offer.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/extensions/commerce/controls/c1_licensable_no_offer.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "ontology", "label": "c2_offer_no_route.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/extensions/commerce/controls/c2_offer_no_route.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/extensions/commerce/controls/c2_offer_no_route.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/extensions/commerce/controls/c2_offer_no_route.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/extensions/commerce/controls/c2_offer_no_route.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00003", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/extensions/commerce/controls/c2_offer_no_route.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "ontology", "label": "c2_offer_no_route.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/extensions/commerce/controls/c2_offer_no_route.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/extensions/commerce/controls/c2_offer_no_route.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/extensions/commerce/controls/c2_offer_no_route.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/extensions/commerce/controls/c2_offer_no_route.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00003", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/extensions/commerce/controls/c2_offer_no_route.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unknown", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "z3 said sat, cvc5 said unknown", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "ontology", "label": "c2_offer_no_route.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/extensions/commerce/controls/c2_offer_no_route.ttl", "verdict": "ONE_SIDED", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/extensions/commerce/controls/c2_offer_no_route.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/extensions/commerce/controls/c2_offer_no_route.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/extensions/commerce/controls/c2_offer_no_route.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00003", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/extensions/commerce/controls/c2_offer_no_route.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "ontology", "label": "c3_offer_with_route.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/extensions/commerce/controls/c3_offer_with_route.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/extensions/commerce/controls/c3_offer_with_route.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/extensions/commerce/controls/c3_offer_with_route.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/extensions/commerce/controls/c3_offer_with_route.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "ontology", "label": "c3_offer_with_route.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/extensions/commerce/controls/c3_offer_with_route.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/extensions/commerce/controls/c3_offer_with_route.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/extensions/commerce/controls/c3_offer_with_route.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/extensions/commerce/controls/c3_offer_with_route.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unknown", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "z3 said sat, cvc5 said unknown", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "ontology", "label": "c3_offer_with_route.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/extensions/commerce/controls/c3_offer_with_route.ttl", "verdict": "ONE_SIDED", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/extensions/commerce/controls/c3_offer_with_route.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/extensions/commerce/controls/c3_offer_with_route.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/extensions/commerce/controls/c3_offer_with_route.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "ontology", "label": "naph-commerce-shapes.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/extensions/commerce/ontology/naph-commerce-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/extensions/commerce/ontology/naph-commerce-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/extensions/commerce/ontology/naph-commerce-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/extensions/commerce/ontology/naph-commerce-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00003", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/extensions/commerce/ontology/naph-commerce-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "ontology", "label": "naph-commerce-shapes.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/extensions/commerce/ontology/naph-commerce-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/extensions/commerce/ontology/naph-commerce-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/extensions/commerce/ontology/naph-commerce-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/extensions/commerce/ontology/naph-commerce-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00003", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/extensions/commerce/ontology/naph-commerce-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unknown", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "z3 said sat, cvc5 said unknown", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "ontology", "label": "naph-commerce-shapes.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/extensions/commerce/ontology/naph-commerce-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "ONE_SIDED", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/extensions/commerce/ontology/naph-commerce-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/extensions/commerce/ontology/naph-commerce-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/extensions/commerce/ontology/naph-commerce-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00003", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/extensions/commerce/ontology/naph-commerce-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "ontology", "label": "naph-commerce.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/extensions/commerce/ontology/naph-commerce.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/extensions/commerce/ontology/naph-commerce.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/extensions/commerce/ontology/naph-commerce.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/extensions/commerce/ontology/naph-commerce.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00003", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/extensions/commerce/ontology/naph-commerce.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "ontology", "label": "naph-commerce.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/extensions/commerce/ontology/naph-commerce.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/extensions/commerce/ontology/naph-commerce.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/extensions/commerce/ontology/naph-commerce.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/extensions/commerce/ontology/naph-commerce.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00003", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/extensions/commerce/ontology/naph-commerce.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unknown", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "z3 said sat, cvc5 said unknown", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "ontology", "label": "naph-commerce.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/extensions/commerce/ontology/naph-commerce.ttl", "verdict": "ONE_SIDED", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/extensions/commerce/ontology/naph-commerce.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/extensions/commerce/ontology/naph-commerce.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/extensions/commerce/ontology/naph-commerce.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00003", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/extensions/commerce/ontology/naph-commerce.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "ontology", "label": "naph-core.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/ontology/naph-core.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/ontology/naph-core.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/ontology/naph-core.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/ontology/naph-core.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00003", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/ontology/naph-core.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "ontology", "label": "naph-core.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/ontology/naph-core.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/ontology/naph-core.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/ontology/naph-core.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/ontology/naph-core.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00003", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/ontology/naph-core.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unknown", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "z3 said sat, cvc5 said unknown", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "ontology", "label": "naph-core.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/ontology/naph-core.ttl", "verdict": "ONE_SIDED", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/ontology/naph-core.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/ontology/naph-core.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/ontology/naph-core.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00003", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/ontology/naph-core.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "ontology", "label": "naph-ric-o-crosswalk.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/ontology/naph-ric-o-crosswalk.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/ontology/naph-ric-o-crosswalk.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "ontology", "label": "naph-ric-o-crosswalk.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/ontology/naph-ric-o-crosswalk.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/ontology/naph-ric-o-crosswalk.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unknown", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "z3 said sat, cvc5 said unknown", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "ontology", "label": "naph-ric-o-crosswalk.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/ontology/naph-ric-o-crosswalk.ttl", "verdict": "ONE_SIDED", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/ontology/naph-ric-o-crosswalk.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "ontology", "label": "naph-shapes.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/ontology/naph-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/ontology/naph-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/ontology/naph-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/ontology/naph-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00003", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/ontology/naph-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "ontology", "label": "naph-shapes.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/ontology/naph-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/ontology/naph-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/ontology/naph-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/ontology/naph-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00003", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/ontology/naph-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unknown", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "z3 said sat, cvc5 said unknown", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "ontology", "label": "naph-shapes.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/ontology/naph-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "ONE_SIDED", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/ontology/naph-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/ontology/naph-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/ontology/naph-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00003", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/ontology/naph-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "ontology", "label": "generated-from-csv.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/pipeline/generated-from-csv.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/pipeline/generated-from-csv.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "ontology", "label": "generated-from-csv.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/pipeline/generated-from-csv.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/pipeline/generated-from-csv.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unknown", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "z3 said sat, cvc5 said unknown", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "ontology", "label": "generated-from-csv.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/pipeline/generated-from-csv.ttl", "verdict": "ONE_SIDED", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/heritage-aerial/pipeline/generated-from-csv.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "ontology", "label": "iro-core.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/insurance-register-ontology/iro-core.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/insurance-register-ontology/iro-core.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/insurance-register-ontology/iro-core.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/insurance-register-ontology/iro-core.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00003", "ontology": "case-studies/insurance-register-ontology/iro-core.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "ontology", "label": "iro-core.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/insurance-register-ontology/iro-core.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/insurance-register-ontology/iro-core.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/insurance-register-ontology/iro-core.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/insurance-register-ontology/iro-core.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00003", "ontology": "case-studies/insurance-register-ontology/iro-core.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unknown", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "z3 said sat, cvc5 said unknown", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "ontology", "label": "iro-core.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/insurance-register-ontology/iro-core.ttl", "verdict": "ONE_SIDED", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/insurance-register-ontology/iro-core.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/insurance-register-ontology/iro-core.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/insurance-register-ontology/iro-core.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00003", "ontology": "case-studies/insurance-register-ontology/iro-core.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "ontology", "label": "iro-example-synthetic.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/insurance-register-ontology/iro-example-synthetic.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/insurance-register-ontology/iro-example-synthetic.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/insurance-register-ontology/iro-example-synthetic.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/insurance-register-ontology/iro-example-synthetic.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00003", "ontology": "case-studies/insurance-register-ontology/iro-example-synthetic.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "ontology", "label": "iro-example-synthetic.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/insurance-register-ontology/iro-example-synthetic.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/insurance-register-ontology/iro-example-synthetic.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/insurance-register-ontology/iro-example-synthetic.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/insurance-register-ontology/iro-example-synthetic.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00003", "ontology": "case-studies/insurance-register-ontology/iro-example-synthetic.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unknown", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "z3 said sat, cvc5 said unknown", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "ontology", "label": "iro-example-synthetic.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/insurance-register-ontology/iro-example-synthetic.ttl", "verdict": "ONE_SIDED", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/insurance-register-ontology/iro-example-synthetic.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/insurance-register-ontology/iro-example-synthetic.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/insurance-register-ontology/iro-example-synthetic.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00003", "ontology": "case-studies/insurance-register-ontology/iro-example-synthetic.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "ontology", "label": "iro-rules.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/insurance-register-ontology/iro-rules.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/insurance-register-ontology/iro-rules.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/insurance-register-ontology/iro-rules.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/insurance-register-ontology/iro-rules.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00003", "ontology": "case-studies/insurance-register-ontology/iro-rules.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "ontology", "label": "iro-rules.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/insurance-register-ontology/iro-rules.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/insurance-register-ontology/iro-rules.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/insurance-register-ontology/iro-rules.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/insurance-register-ontology/iro-rules.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00003", "ontology": "case-studies/insurance-register-ontology/iro-rules.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unknown", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "z3 said sat, cvc5 said unknown", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "ontology", "label": "iro-rules.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/insurance-register-ontology/iro-rules.ttl", "verdict": "ONE_SIDED", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/insurance-register-ontology/iro-rules.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/insurance-register-ontology/iro-rules.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/insurance-register-ontology/iro-rules.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00003", "ontology": "case-studies/insurance-register-ontology/iro-rules.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "ontology", "label": "iro-shapes.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/insurance-register-ontology/iro-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/insurance-register-ontology/iro-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/insurance-register-ontology/iro-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/insurance-register-ontology/iro-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00003", "ontology": "case-studies/insurance-register-ontology/iro-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "ontology", "label": "iro-shapes.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/insurance-register-ontology/iro-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/insurance-register-ontology/iro-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/insurance-register-ontology/iro-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/insurance-register-ontology/iro-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00003", "ontology": "case-studies/insurance-register-ontology/iro-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unknown", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "z3 said sat, cvc5 said unknown", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "ontology", "label": "iro-shapes.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/insurance-register-ontology/iro-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "ONE_SIDED", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/insurance-register-ontology/iro-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/insurance-register-ontology/iro-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/insurance-register-ontology/iro-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00003", "ontology": "case-studies/insurance-register-ontology/iro-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "ontology", "label": "operation-modes.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/insurance-register-ontology/operation-modes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/insurance-register-ontology/operation-modes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "ontology", "label": "operation-modes.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/insurance-register-ontology/operation-modes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/insurance-register-ontology/operation-modes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unknown", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "z3 said sat, cvc5 said unknown", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "ontology", "label": "operation-modes.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/insurance-register-ontology/operation-modes.ttl", "verdict": "ONE_SIDED", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/insurance-register-ontology/operation-modes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "ontology", "label": "identifier-schemes.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/investment-fund-ontology/identifier-schemes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/investment-fund-ontology/identifier-schemes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/investment-fund-ontology/identifier-schemes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00003", "ontology": "case-studies/investment-fund-ontology/identifier-schemes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "ontology", "label": "identifier-schemes.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/investment-fund-ontology/identifier-schemes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/investment-fund-ontology/identifier-schemes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/investment-fund-ontology/identifier-schemes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00003", "ontology": "case-studies/investment-fund-ontology/identifier-schemes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unknown", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "z3 said sat, cvc5 said unknown", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "ontology", "label": "identifier-schemes.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/investment-fund-ontology/identifier-schemes.ttl", "verdict": "ONE_SIDED", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/investment-fund-ontology/identifier-schemes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/investment-fund-ontology/identifier-schemes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00003", "ontology": "case-studies/investment-fund-ontology/identifier-schemes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "ontology", "label": "ifo-core.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/investment-fund-ontology/ifo-core.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/investment-fund-ontology/ifo-core.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/investment-fund-ontology/ifo-core.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/investment-fund-ontology/ifo-core.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00003", "ontology": "case-studies/investment-fund-ontology/ifo-core.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "ontology", "label": "ifo-core.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/investment-fund-ontology/ifo-core.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/investment-fund-ontology/ifo-core.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/investment-fund-ontology/ifo-core.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/investment-fund-ontology/ifo-core.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00003", "ontology": "case-studies/investment-fund-ontology/ifo-core.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unknown", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "z3 said sat, cvc5 said unknown", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "ontology", "label": "ifo-core.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/investment-fund-ontology/ifo-core.ttl", "verdict": "ONE_SIDED", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/investment-fund-ontology/ifo-core.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/investment-fund-ontology/ifo-core.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/investment-fund-ontology/ifo-core.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00003", "ontology": "case-studies/investment-fund-ontology/ifo-core.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "ontology", "label": "ifo-rules.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/investment-fund-ontology/ifo-rules.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/investment-fund-ontology/ifo-rules.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/investment-fund-ontology/ifo-rules.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/investment-fund-ontology/ifo-rules.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00003", "ontology": "case-studies/investment-fund-ontology/ifo-rules.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "ontology", "label": "ifo-rules.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/investment-fund-ontology/ifo-rules.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/investment-fund-ontology/ifo-rules.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/investment-fund-ontology/ifo-rules.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/investment-fund-ontology/ifo-rules.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00003", "ontology": "case-studies/investment-fund-ontology/ifo-rules.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unknown", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "z3 said sat, cvc5 said unknown", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "ontology", "label": "ifo-rules.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/investment-fund-ontology/ifo-rules.ttl", "verdict": "ONE_SIDED", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/investment-fund-ontology/ifo-rules.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/investment-fund-ontology/ifo-rules.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/investment-fund-ontology/ifo-rules.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00003", "ontology": "case-studies/investment-fund-ontology/ifo-rules.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "ontology", "label": "ifo-shapes.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/investment-fund-ontology/ifo-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/investment-fund-ontology/ifo-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/investment-fund-ontology/ifo-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/investment-fund-ontology/ifo-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00003", "ontology": "case-studies/investment-fund-ontology/ifo-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "ontology", "label": "ifo-shapes.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/investment-fund-ontology/ifo-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/investment-fund-ontology/ifo-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/investment-fund-ontology/ifo-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/investment-fund-ontology/ifo-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00003", "ontology": "case-studies/investment-fund-ontology/ifo-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unknown", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "z3 said sat, cvc5 said unknown", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "ontology", "label": "ifo-shapes.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/investment-fund-ontology/ifo-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "ONE_SIDED", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/investment-fund-ontology/ifo-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/investment-fund-ontology/ifo-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/investment-fund-ontology/ifo-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00003", "ontology": "case-studies/investment-fund-ontology/ifo-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "ontology", "label": "vanguard-index-funds.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/investment-fund-ontology/vanguard-index-funds.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/investment-fund-ontology/vanguard-index-funds.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/investment-fund-ontology/vanguard-index-funds.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/investment-fund-ontology/vanguard-index-funds.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00003", "ontology": "case-studies/investment-fund-ontology/vanguard-index-funds.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "ontology", "label": "vanguard-index-funds.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/investment-fund-ontology/vanguard-index-funds.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/investment-fund-ontology/vanguard-index-funds.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/investment-fund-ontology/vanguard-index-funds.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/investment-fund-ontology/vanguard-index-funds.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00003", "ontology": "case-studies/investment-fund-ontology/vanguard-index-funds.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unknown", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "z3 said sat, cvc5 said unknown", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "ontology", "label": "vanguard-index-funds.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/investment-fund-ontology/vanguard-index-funds.ttl", "verdict": "ONE_SIDED", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/investment-fund-ontology/vanguard-index-funds.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/investment-fund-ontology/vanguard-index-funds.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/investment-fund-ontology/vanguard-index-funds.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00003", "ontology": "case-studies/investment-fund-ontology/vanguard-index-funds.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "ontology", "label": "crosswalk.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/jc3iedm-ies4-crosswalk/crosswalk.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/jc3iedm-ies4-crosswalk/crosswalk.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "ontology", "label": "crosswalk.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/jc3iedm-ies4-crosswalk/crosswalk.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/jc3iedm-ies4-crosswalk/crosswalk.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unknown", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "z3 said sat, cvc5 said unknown", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "ontology", "label": "crosswalk.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/jc3iedm-ies4-crosswalk/crosswalk.ttl", "verdict": "ONE_SIDED", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unknown", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "z3 said sat, cvc5 said unknown", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/jc3iedm-ies4-crosswalk/crosswalk.ttl", "verdict": "ONE_SIDED", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "ontology", "label": "ies-sample.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/mcp-ies-rag-demo/data/ies-sample.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/mcp-ies-rag-demo/data/ies-sample.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00003", "ontology": "case-studies/mcp-ies-rag-demo/data/ies-sample.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "ontology", "label": "ies-sample.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/mcp-ies-rag-demo/data/ies-sample.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/mcp-ies-rag-demo/data/ies-sample.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00003", "ontology": "case-studies/mcp-ies-rag-demo/data/ies-sample.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unknown", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "z3 said sat, cvc5 said unknown", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "ontology", "label": "ies-sample.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/mcp-ies-rag-demo/data/ies-sample.ttl", "verdict": "ONE_SIDED", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/mcp-ies-rag-demo/data/ies-sample.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00003", "ontology": "case-studies/mcp-ies-rag-demo/data/ies-sample.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "ontology", "label": "dag_variants.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/modip-plastics-kg/build/dag_variants.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/modip-plastics-kg/build/dag_variants.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/modip-plastics-kg/build/dag_variants.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/modip-plastics-kg/build/dag_variants.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00003", "ontology": "case-studies/modip-plastics-kg/build/dag_variants.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "ontology", "label": "dag_variants.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/modip-plastics-kg/build/dag_variants.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/modip-plastics-kg/build/dag_variants.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/modip-plastics-kg/build/dag_variants.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/modip-plastics-kg/build/dag_variants.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00003", "ontology": "case-studies/modip-plastics-kg/build/dag_variants.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unknown", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "z3 said sat, cvc5 said unknown", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "ontology", "label": "dag_variants.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/modip-plastics-kg/build/dag_variants.ttl", "verdict": "ONE_SIDED", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/modip-plastics-kg/build/dag_variants.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/modip-plastics-kg/build/dag_variants.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/modip-plastics-kg/build/dag_variants.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00003", "ontology": "case-studies/modip-plastics-kg/build/dag_variants.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "ontology", "label": "colours.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/modip-plastics-kg/ontology/colours.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/modip-plastics-kg/ontology/colours.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/modip-plastics-kg/ontology/colours.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "ontology", "label": "colours.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/modip-plastics-kg/ontology/colours.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/modip-plastics-kg/ontology/colours.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/modip-plastics-kg/ontology/colours.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unknown", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "z3 said sat, cvc5 said unknown", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "ontology", "label": "colours.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/modip-plastics-kg/ontology/colours.ttl", "verdict": "ONE_SIDED", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/modip-plastics-kg/ontology/colours.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/modip-plastics-kg/ontology/colours.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "ontology", "label": "domains.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/modip-plastics-kg/ontology/domains.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/modip-plastics-kg/ontology/domains.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/modip-plastics-kg/ontology/domains.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/modip-plastics-kg/ontology/domains.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "ontology", "label": "domains.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/modip-plastics-kg/ontology/domains.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/modip-plastics-kg/ontology/domains.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/modip-plastics-kg/ontology/domains.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/modip-plastics-kg/ontology/domains.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unknown", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "z3 said sat, cvc5 said unknown", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "ontology", "label": "domains.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/modip-plastics-kg/ontology/domains.ttl", "verdict": "ONE_SIDED", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/modip-plastics-kg/ontology/domains.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/modip-plastics-kg/ontology/domains.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/modip-plastics-kg/ontology/domains.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "ontology", "label": "facets.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/modip-plastics-kg/ontology/facets.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/modip-plastics-kg/ontology/facets.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/modip-plastics-kg/ontology/facets.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "ontology", "label": "facets.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/modip-plastics-kg/ontology/facets.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/modip-plastics-kg/ontology/facets.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/modip-plastics-kg/ontology/facets.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unknown", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "z3 said sat, cvc5 said unknown", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "ontology", "label": "facets.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/modip-plastics-kg/ontology/facets.ttl", "verdict": "ONE_SIDED", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/modip-plastics-kg/ontology/facets.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/modip-plastics-kg/ontology/facets.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "ontology", "label": "materials.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/modip-plastics-kg/ontology/materials.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/modip-plastics-kg/ontology/materials.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/modip-plastics-kg/ontology/materials.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "ontology", "label": "materials.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/modip-plastics-kg/ontology/materials.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/modip-plastics-kg/ontology/materials.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/modip-plastics-kg/ontology/materials.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unknown", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "z3 said sat, cvc5 said unknown", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "ontology", "label": "materials.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/modip-plastics-kg/ontology/materials.ttl", "verdict": "ONE_SIDED", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/modip-plastics-kg/ontology/materials.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/modip-plastics-kg/ontology/materials.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "ontology", "label": "objectnames.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/modip-plastics-kg/ontology/objectnames.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/modip-plastics-kg/ontology/objectnames.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/modip-plastics-kg/ontology/objectnames.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "ontology", "label": "objectnames.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/modip-plastics-kg/ontology/objectnames.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/modip-plastics-kg/ontology/objectnames.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/modip-plastics-kg/ontology/objectnames.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unknown", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "z3 said sat, cvc5 said unknown", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "ontology", "label": "objectnames.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/modip-plastics-kg/ontology/objectnames.ttl", "verdict": "ONE_SIDED", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/modip-plastics-kg/ontology/objectnames.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/modip-plastics-kg/ontology/objectnames.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "ontology", "label": "processes.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/modip-plastics-kg/ontology/processes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/modip-plastics-kg/ontology/processes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/modip-plastics-kg/ontology/processes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "ontology", "label": "processes.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/modip-plastics-kg/ontology/processes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/modip-plastics-kg/ontology/processes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/modip-plastics-kg/ontology/processes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unknown", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "z3 said sat, cvc5 said unknown", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "ontology", "label": "processes.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/modip-plastics-kg/ontology/processes.ttl", "verdict": "ONE_SIDED", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/modip-plastics-kg/ontology/processes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/modip-plastics-kg/ontology/processes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "ontology", "label": "modip-shapes.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/modip-plastics-kg/shapes/modip-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/modip-plastics-kg/shapes/modip-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/modip-plastics-kg/shapes/modip-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/modip-plastics-kg/shapes/modip-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00003", "ontology": "case-studies/modip-plastics-kg/shapes/modip-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "ontology", "label": "modip-shapes.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/modip-plastics-kg/shapes/modip-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/modip-plastics-kg/shapes/modip-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/modip-plastics-kg/shapes/modip-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/modip-plastics-kg/shapes/modip-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00003", "ontology": "case-studies/modip-plastics-kg/shapes/modip-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unknown", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "z3 said sat, cvc5 said unknown", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "ontology", "label": "modip-shapes.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/modip-plastics-kg/shapes/modip-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "ONE_SIDED", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/modip-plastics-kg/shapes/modip-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/modip-plastics-kg/shapes/modip-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/modip-plastics-kg/shapes/modip-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00003", "ontology": "case-studies/modip-plastics-kg/shapes/modip-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "ontology", "label": "graph.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/nature-governance-graph/graph.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/nature-governance-graph/graph.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00003", "ontology": "case-studies/nature-governance-graph/graph.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "ontology", "label": "graph.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/nature-governance-graph/graph.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/nature-governance-graph/graph.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00003", "ontology": "case-studies/nature-governance-graph/graph.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unknown", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "z3 said sat, cvc5 said unknown", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "ontology", "label": "graph.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/nature-governance-graph/graph.ttl", "verdict": "ONE_SIDED", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/nature-governance-graph/graph.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00003", "ontology": "case-studies/nature-governance-graph/graph.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "ontology", "label": "ngg.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/nature-governance-graph/ontology/ngg.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/nature-governance-graph/ontology/ngg.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/nature-governance-graph/ontology/ngg.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/nature-governance-graph/ontology/ngg.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "ontology", "label": "ngg.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/nature-governance-graph/ontology/ngg.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/nature-governance-graph/ontology/ngg.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/nature-governance-graph/ontology/ngg.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/nature-governance-graph/ontology/ngg.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unknown", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "z3 said sat, cvc5 said unknown", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "ontology", "label": "ngg.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/nature-governance-graph/ontology/ngg.ttl", "verdict": "ONE_SIDED", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/nature-governance-graph/ontology/ngg.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/nature-governance-graph/ontology/ngg.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/nature-governance-graph/ontology/ngg.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "ontology", "label": "ngg-shapes.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/nature-governance-graph/shapes/ngg-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/nature-governance-graph/shapes/ngg-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/nature-governance-graph/shapes/ngg-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/nature-governance-graph/shapes/ngg-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00003", "ontology": "case-studies/nature-governance-graph/shapes/ngg-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "ontology", "label": "ngg-shapes.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/nature-governance-graph/shapes/ngg-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/nature-governance-graph/shapes/ngg-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/nature-governance-graph/shapes/ngg-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/nature-governance-graph/shapes/ngg-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00003", "ontology": "case-studies/nature-governance-graph/shapes/ngg-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unknown", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "z3 said sat, cvc5 said unknown", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "ontology", "label": "ngg-shapes.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/nature-governance-graph/shapes/ngg-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "ONE_SIDED", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/nature-governance-graph/shapes/ngg-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/nature-governance-graph/shapes/ngg-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/nature-governance-graph/shapes/ngg-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00003", "ontology": "case-studies/nature-governance-graph/shapes/ngg-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "ontology", "label": "clean.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/onto-correctness-bench/examples/clean.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/onto-correctness-bench/examples/clean.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "ontology", "label": "clean.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/onto-correctness-bench/examples/clean.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/onto-correctness-bench/examples/clean.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unknown", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "z3 said sat, cvc5 said unknown", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "ontology", "label": "clean.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/onto-correctness-bench/examples/clean.ttl", "verdict": "ONE_SIDED", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/onto-correctness-bench/examples/clean.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "ontology", "label": "hallucinated.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/onto-correctness-bench/examples/hallucinated.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/onto-correctness-bench/examples/hallucinated.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00003", "ontology": "case-studies/onto-correctness-bench/examples/hallucinated.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "ontology", "label": "hallucinated.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/onto-correctness-bench/examples/hallucinated.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/onto-correctness-bench/examples/hallucinated.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00003", "ontology": "case-studies/onto-correctness-bench/examples/hallucinated.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unknown", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "z3 said sat, cvc5 said unknown", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "ontology", "label": "hallucinated.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/onto-correctness-bench/examples/hallucinated.ttl", "verdict": "ONE_SIDED", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/onto-correctness-bench/examples/hallucinated.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00003", "ontology": "case-studies/onto-correctness-bench/examples/hallucinated.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "ontology", "label": "iso10218-iec62443.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/robot-safety-security-crosswalk/crosswalk/iso10218-iec62443.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/robot-safety-security-crosswalk/crosswalk/iso10218-iec62443.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00003", "ontology": "case-studies/robot-safety-security-crosswalk/crosswalk/iso10218-iec62443.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "ontology", "label": "iso10218-iec62443.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/robot-safety-security-crosswalk/crosswalk/iso10218-iec62443.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/robot-safety-security-crosswalk/crosswalk/iso10218-iec62443.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00003", "ontology": "case-studies/robot-safety-security-crosswalk/crosswalk/iso10218-iec62443.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unknown", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "z3 said sat, cvc5 said unknown", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "ontology", "label": "iso10218-iec62443.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/robot-safety-security-crosswalk/crosswalk/iso10218-iec62443.ttl", "verdict": "ONE_SIDED", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/robot-safety-security-crosswalk/crosswalk/iso10218-iec62443.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00003", "ontology": "case-studies/robot-safety-security-crosswalk/crosswalk/iso10218-iec62443.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "ontology", "label": "rssc.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/robot-safety-security-crosswalk/ontology/rssc.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/robot-safety-security-crosswalk/ontology/rssc.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/robot-safety-security-crosswalk/ontology/rssc.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/robot-safety-security-crosswalk/ontology/rssc.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00003", "ontology": "case-studies/robot-safety-security-crosswalk/ontology/rssc.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "ontology", "label": "rssc.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/robot-safety-security-crosswalk/ontology/rssc.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/robot-safety-security-crosswalk/ontology/rssc.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/robot-safety-security-crosswalk/ontology/rssc.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/robot-safety-security-crosswalk/ontology/rssc.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00003", "ontology": "case-studies/robot-safety-security-crosswalk/ontology/rssc.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unknown", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "cvc5 stopped on a resource limit: interrupted by timeout", "detail": "z3 said sat, cvc5 said unknown", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "ontology", "label": "rssc.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/robot-safety-security-crosswalk/ontology/rssc.ttl", "verdict": "ONE_SIDED", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/robot-safety-security-crosswalk/ontology/rssc.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/robot-safety-security-crosswalk/ontology/rssc.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/robot-safety-security-crosswalk/ontology/rssc.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00003", "ontology": "case-studies/robot-safety-security-crosswalk/ontology/rssc.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "ontology", "label": "fixture-invalid.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/robot-safety-security-crosswalk/pipeline/selftest/invalid/crosswalk/fixture-invalid.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/robot-safety-security-crosswalk/pipeline/selftest/invalid/crosswalk/fixture-invalid.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00003", "ontology": "case-studies/robot-safety-security-crosswalk/pipeline/selftest/invalid/crosswalk/fixture-invalid.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "ontology", "label": "fixture-invalid.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/robot-safety-security-crosswalk/pipeline/selftest/invalid/crosswalk/fixture-invalid.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/robot-safety-security-crosswalk/pipeline/selftest/invalid/crosswalk/fixture-invalid.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00003", "ontology": "case-studies/robot-safety-security-crosswalk/pipeline/selftest/invalid/crosswalk/fixture-invalid.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unknown", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "z3 said sat, cvc5 said unknown", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "ontology", "label": "fixture-invalid.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/robot-safety-security-crosswalk/pipeline/selftest/invalid/crosswalk/fixture-invalid.ttl", "verdict": "ONE_SIDED", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/robot-safety-security-crosswalk/pipeline/selftest/invalid/crosswalk/fixture-invalid.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00003", "ontology": "case-studies/robot-safety-security-crosswalk/pipeline/selftest/invalid/crosswalk/fixture-invalid.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "ontology", "label": "fixture-valid.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/robot-safety-security-crosswalk/pipeline/selftest/invalid/crosswalk/fixture-valid.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/robot-safety-security-crosswalk/pipeline/selftest/invalid/crosswalk/fixture-valid.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/robot-safety-security-crosswalk/pipeline/selftest/invalid/crosswalk/fixture-valid.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00003", "ontology": "case-studies/robot-safety-security-crosswalk/pipeline/selftest/invalid/crosswalk/fixture-valid.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "ontology", "label": "fixture-valid.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/robot-safety-security-crosswalk/pipeline/selftest/invalid/crosswalk/fixture-valid.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/robot-safety-security-crosswalk/pipeline/selftest/invalid/crosswalk/fixture-valid.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/robot-safety-security-crosswalk/pipeline/selftest/invalid/crosswalk/fixture-valid.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00003", "ontology": "case-studies/robot-safety-security-crosswalk/pipeline/selftest/invalid/crosswalk/fixture-valid.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unknown", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "z3 said sat, cvc5 said unknown", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "ontology", "label": "fixture-valid.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/robot-safety-security-crosswalk/pipeline/selftest/invalid/crosswalk/fixture-valid.ttl", "verdict": "ONE_SIDED", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/robot-safety-security-crosswalk/pipeline/selftest/invalid/crosswalk/fixture-valid.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/robot-safety-security-crosswalk/pipeline/selftest/invalid/crosswalk/fixture-valid.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00003", "ontology": "case-studies/robot-safety-security-crosswalk/pipeline/selftest/invalid/crosswalk/fixture-valid.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "ontology", "label": "fixture-valid.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/robot-safety-security-crosswalk/pipeline/selftest/valid/crosswalk/fixture-valid.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/robot-safety-security-crosswalk/pipeline/selftest/valid/crosswalk/fixture-valid.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/robot-safety-security-crosswalk/pipeline/selftest/valid/crosswalk/fixture-valid.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00003", "ontology": "case-studies/robot-safety-security-crosswalk/pipeline/selftest/valid/crosswalk/fixture-valid.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "ontology", "label": "fixture-valid.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/robot-safety-security-crosswalk/pipeline/selftest/valid/crosswalk/fixture-valid.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/robot-safety-security-crosswalk/pipeline/selftest/valid/crosswalk/fixture-valid.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/robot-safety-security-crosswalk/pipeline/selftest/valid/crosswalk/fixture-valid.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00003", "ontology": "case-studies/robot-safety-security-crosswalk/pipeline/selftest/valid/crosswalk/fixture-valid.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unknown", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "z3 said sat, cvc5 said unknown", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "ontology", "label": "fixture-valid.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/robot-safety-security-crosswalk/pipeline/selftest/valid/crosswalk/fixture-valid.ttl", "verdict": "ONE_SIDED", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/robot-safety-security-crosswalk/pipeline/selftest/valid/crosswalk/fixture-valid.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/robot-safety-security-crosswalk/pipeline/selftest/valid/crosswalk/fixture-valid.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00003", "ontology": "case-studies/robot-safety-security-crosswalk/pipeline/selftest/valid/crosswalk/fixture-valid.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "ontology", "label": "rssc-shapes.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/robot-safety-security-crosswalk/shapes/rssc-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/robot-safety-security-crosswalk/shapes/rssc-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00003", "ontology": "case-studies/robot-safety-security-crosswalk/shapes/rssc-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "ontology", "label": "rssc-shapes.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/robot-safety-security-crosswalk/shapes/rssc-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/robot-safety-security-crosswalk/shapes/rssc-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00003", "ontology": "case-studies/robot-safety-security-crosswalk/shapes/rssc-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unknown", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "z3 said sat, cvc5 said unknown", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "ontology", "label": "rssc-shapes.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/robot-safety-security-crosswalk/shapes/rssc-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "ONE_SIDED", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/robot-safety-security-crosswalk/shapes/rssc-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00003", "ontology": "case-studies/robot-safety-security-crosswalk/shapes/rssc-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "ontology", "label": "crosswalk.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/skills-england-esco-crosswalk/crosswalk.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/skills-england-esco-crosswalk/crosswalk.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "ontology", "label": "crosswalk.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/skills-england-esco-crosswalk/crosswalk.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/skills-england-esco-crosswalk/crosswalk.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unknown", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "z3 said sat, cvc5 said unknown", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "ontology", "label": "crosswalk.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/skills-england-esco-crosswalk/crosswalk.ttl", "verdict": "ONE_SIDED", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/skills-england-esco-crosswalk/crosswalk.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "ontology", "label": "seom-vocabulary.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/skills-england-occupational-maps/ontology/seom-vocabulary.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/skills-england-occupational-maps/ontology/seom-vocabulary.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/skills-england-occupational-maps/ontology/seom-vocabulary.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/skills-england-occupational-maps/ontology/seom-vocabulary.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00003", "ontology": "case-studies/skills-england-occupational-maps/ontology/seom-vocabulary.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "cvc5 said sat, z3 said unknown", "encoding": "2", "kind": "ontology", "label": "seom-vocabulary.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/skills-england-occupational-maps/ontology/seom-vocabulary.ttl", "verdict": "ONE_SIDED", "z3": "unknown", "z3_detail": "z3 stopped on a resource limit: timeout"},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/skills-england-occupational-maps/ontology/seom-vocabulary.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/skills-england-occupational-maps/ontology/seom-vocabulary.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/skills-england-occupational-maps/ontology/seom-vocabulary.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00003", "ontology": "case-studies/skills-england-occupational-maps/ontology/seom-vocabulary.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unknown", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "cvc5 stopped on a resource limit: interrupted by timeout", "detail": "neither solver answered", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "ontology", "label": "seom-vocabulary.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/skills-england-occupational-maps/ontology/seom-vocabulary.ttl", "verdict": "BOTH_UNKNOWN", "z3": "unknown", "z3_detail": "z3 stopped on a resource limit: timeout"},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/skills-england-occupational-maps/ontology/seom-vocabulary.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/skills-england-occupational-maps/ontology/seom-vocabulary.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/skills-england-occupational-maps/ontology/seom-vocabulary.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00003", "ontology": "case-studies/skills-england-occupational-maps/ontology/seom-vocabulary.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "ontology", "label": "shapes.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/skills-england-occupational-maps/ontology/shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/skills-england-occupational-maps/ontology/shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/skills-england-occupational-maps/ontology/shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/skills-england-occupational-maps/ontology/shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00003", "ontology": "case-studies/skills-england-occupational-maps/ontology/shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "ontology", "label": "shapes.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/skills-england-occupational-maps/ontology/shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/skills-england-occupational-maps/ontology/shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/skills-england-occupational-maps/ontology/shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/skills-england-occupational-maps/ontology/shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00003", "ontology": "case-studies/skills-england-occupational-maps/ontology/shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unknown", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "z3 said sat, cvc5 said unknown", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "ontology", "label": "shapes.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/skills-england-occupational-maps/ontology/shapes.ttl", "verdict": "ONE_SIDED", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/skills-england-occupational-maps/ontology/shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/skills-england-occupational-maps/ontology/shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/skills-england-occupational-maps/ontology/shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00003", "ontology": "case-studies/skills-england-occupational-maps/ontology/shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "ontology", "label": "skills-mobility-scheme.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/skills-mobility/ontology/skills-mobility-scheme.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/skills-mobility/ontology/skills-mobility-scheme.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/skills-mobility/ontology/skills-mobility-scheme.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "ontology", "label": "skills-mobility-scheme.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/skills-mobility/ontology/skills-mobility-scheme.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/skills-mobility/ontology/skills-mobility-scheme.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/skills-mobility/ontology/skills-mobility-scheme.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unknown", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "z3 said sat, cvc5 said unknown", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "ontology", "label": "skills-mobility-scheme.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/skills-mobility/ontology/skills-mobility-scheme.ttl", "verdict": "ONE_SIDED", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/skills-mobility/ontology/skills-mobility-scheme.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/skills-mobility/ontology/skills-mobility-scheme.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "ontology", "label": "data-quality-shapes.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/wastewater-effluent-quality/data-quality-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/wastewater-effluent-quality/data-quality-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/wastewater-effluent-quality/data-quality-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/wastewater-effluent-quality/data-quality-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00003", "ontology": "case-studies/wastewater-effluent-quality/data-quality-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "ontology", "label": "data-quality-shapes.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/wastewater-effluent-quality/data-quality-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/wastewater-effluent-quality/data-quality-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/wastewater-effluent-quality/data-quality-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/wastewater-effluent-quality/data-quality-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00003", "ontology": "case-studies/wastewater-effluent-quality/data-quality-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unknown", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "z3 said sat, cvc5 said unknown", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "ontology", "label": "data-quality-shapes.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/wastewater-effluent-quality/data-quality-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "ONE_SIDED", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/wastewater-effluent-quality/data-quality-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/wastewater-effluent-quality/data-quality-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/wastewater-effluent-quality/data-quality-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00003", "ontology": "case-studies/wastewater-effluent-quality/data-quality-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "ontology", "label": "effluent-ontology.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/wastewater-effluent-quality/effluent-ontology.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/wastewater-effluent-quality/effluent-ontology.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/wastewater-effluent-quality/effluent-ontology.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/wastewater-effluent-quality/effluent-ontology.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00003", "ontology": "case-studies/wastewater-effluent-quality/effluent-ontology.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "ontology", "label": "effluent-ontology.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/wastewater-effluent-quality/effluent-ontology.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/wastewater-effluent-quality/effluent-ontology.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/wastewater-effluent-quality/effluent-ontology.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/wastewater-effluent-quality/effluent-ontology.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00003", "ontology": "case-studies/wastewater-effluent-quality/effluent-ontology.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unknown", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "z3 said sat, cvc5 said unknown", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "ontology", "label": "effluent-ontology.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/wastewater-effluent-quality/effluent-ontology.ttl", "verdict": "ONE_SIDED", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/wastewater-effluent-quality/effluent-ontology.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/wastewater-effluent-quality/effluent-ontology.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/wastewater-effluent-quality/effluent-ontology.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00003", "ontology": "case-studies/wastewater-effluent-quality/effluent-ontology.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "ontology", "label": "effluent-snapshots.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/wastewater-effluent-quality/effluent-snapshots.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/wastewater-effluent-quality/effluent-snapshots.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/wastewater-effluent-quality/effluent-snapshots.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "ontology", "label": "effluent-snapshots.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/wastewater-effluent-quality/effluent-snapshots.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/wastewater-effluent-quality/effluent-snapshots.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/wastewater-effluent-quality/effluent-snapshots.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unknown", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "z3 said sat, cvc5 said unknown", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "ontology", "label": "effluent-snapshots.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/wastewater-effluent-quality/effluent-snapshots.ttl", "verdict": "ONE_SIDED", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/wastewater-effluent-quality/effluent-snapshots.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/wastewater-effluent-quality/effluent-snapshots.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "ontology", "label": "graph.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/zero-emission-aviation/graph.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/zero-emission-aviation/graph.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/zero-emission-aviation/graph.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "ontology", "label": "graph.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/zero-emission-aviation/graph.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/zero-emission-aviation/graph.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/zero-emission-aviation/graph.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unknown", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "z3 said sat, cvc5 said unknown", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "ontology", "label": "graph.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/zero-emission-aviation/graph.ttl", "verdict": "ONE_SIDED", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/zero-emission-aviation/graph.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/zero-emission-aviation/graph.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "ontology", "label": "zef.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/zero-emission-aviation/ontology/zef.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/zero-emission-aviation/ontology/zef.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/zero-emission-aviation/ontology/zef.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/zero-emission-aviation/ontology/zef.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00003", "ontology": "case-studies/zero-emission-aviation/ontology/zef.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "ontology", "label": "zef.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/zero-emission-aviation/ontology/zef.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/zero-emission-aviation/ontology/zef.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/zero-emission-aviation/ontology/zef.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/zero-emission-aviation/ontology/zef.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00003", "ontology": "case-studies/zero-emission-aviation/ontology/zef.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unknown", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "z3 said sat, cvc5 said unknown", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "ontology", "label": "zef.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/zero-emission-aviation/ontology/zef.ttl", "verdict": "ONE_SIDED", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/zero-emission-aviation/ontology/zef.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/zero-emission-aviation/ontology/zef.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/zero-emission-aviation/ontology/zef.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00003", "ontology": "case-studies/zero-emission-aviation/ontology/zef.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "ontology", "label": "zef-shapes.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/zero-emission-aviation/shapes/zef-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/zero-emission-aviation/shapes/zef-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/zero-emission-aviation/shapes/zef-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/zero-emission-aviation/shapes/zef-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00003", "ontology": "case-studies/zero-emission-aviation/shapes/zef-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "ontology", "label": "zef-shapes.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/zero-emission-aviation/shapes/zef-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/zero-emission-aviation/shapes/zef-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/zero-emission-aviation/shapes/zef-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/zero-emission-aviation/shapes/zef-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00003", "ontology": "case-studies/zero-emission-aviation/shapes/zef-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unknown", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "z3 said sat, cvc5 said unknown", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "ontology", "label": "zef-shapes.ttl", "ontology": "case-studies/zero-emission-aviation/shapes/zef-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "ONE_SIDED", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "case-studies/zero-emission-aviation/shapes/zef-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "case-studies/zero-emission-aviation/shapes/zef-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "case-studies/zero-emission-aviation/shapes/zef-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00003", "ontology": "case-studies/zero-emission-aviation/shapes/zef-shapes.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "ontology", "label": "sample.ttl", "ontology": "tests/data/sample.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "tests/data/sample.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "tests/data/sample.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "tests/data/sample.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "1", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00003", "ontology": "tests/data/sample.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "sat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said sat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "ontology", "label": "sample.ttl", "ontology": "tests/data/sample.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "tests/data/sample.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "tests/data/sample.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "tests/data/sample.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000 --finite-model-find", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "2", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00003", "ontology": "tests/data/sample.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unknown", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unknown", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "z3 said sat, cvc5 said unknown", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "ontology", "label": "sample.ttl", "ontology": "tests/data/sample.ttl", "verdict": "ONE_SIDED", "z3": "sat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00000", "ontology": "tests/data/sample.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00001", "ontology": "tests/data/sample.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00002", "ontology": "tests/data/sample.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""},+ {"cvc5": "unsat", "cvc5_argv": "cvc5 --tlimit=5000", "cvc5_default": "unsat", "cvc5_detail": "", "detail": "both said unsat", "encoding": "unbounded", "kind": "goal", "label": "goal_00003", "ontology": "tests/data/sample.ttl", "verdict": "AGREE", "z3": "unsat", "z3_detail": ""}+ ]+}diff --git a/docs/reasoning-systems-inventory.md b/docs/reasoning-systems-inventory.mdindex 3c1d21b0..d49e5600 100644--- a/docs/reasoning-systems-inventory.md+++ b/docs/reasoning-systems-inventory.md@@ -25,10 +25,10 @@ about the file we gave it. The addendum to decision 0005 draws the new line.| Lean 4 | Proof assistant | The kernel. Every checker in this repository. || E 3.2.5 | First-order prover | Differential oracle. Never an authority. Its derivations are now read back and structurally checked. || Vampire 5.1.0 | First-order prover | Same role as E, and the one whose derivations replay furthest. |-| Z3 4.16.0 | SMT solver | Model-certificate layer, under construction. |+| Z3 4.16.0 | SMT solver | Model-certificate layer. A checked model is a certificate; an unsat is testimony. || Mace4 | Finite model finder | Same. Its output is checkable; Prover9's is not. || Prover9 | First-order prover | Declined. Unmaintained since 2011, refutations uncheckable. |-| cvc5 | SMT solver | Not installed. Same role as Z3 when it is. |+| cvc5 1.3.4 | SMT solver | Installed and pinned. A SECOND oracle on the arm that had none: it cannot confirm an unsat and is the only thing that can contradict one. || Isabelle/HOL | Proof assistant | Built, as an independent second FORMALISATION. It disagreed with the Lean. Below. || Rocq 9.2 | Proof assistant | Built, as an independent THIRD formalisation of the Horn layer only. It disagreed with the Lean too, about what a line is. Below. || Dedukti, Lambdapi | Logical framework | Declined twice, for portability and for re-checking. Reasons below. |@@ -43,7 +43,7 @@ about the file we gave it. The addendum to decision 0005 draws the new line.| loom | Rust interleaving explorer | The right tool for the two latent lock defects. Not yet wired in. || TPTP and TSTP | Interchange | Implemented, in both directions. TPTP out, TSTP back in and checked. || CLIF, ISO/IEC 24707 | Interchange | Implemented. The conformance format. |-| SMT-LIB 2 | Interchange | Under construction. |+| SMT-LIB 2 | Interchange | Implemented. One emitter, read by both SMT solvers. || RIF Core, SWRL | Rule languages | Front ends under construction. || CertifyingDatalog | Prior art | Not a dependency. The Horn layer is our analogue. || Hets | Heterogeneous tool set | Declined as a dependency. Its institution and comorphism core is reimplemented small and machine-checked here. Below. |@@ -103,6 +103,24 @@ proof logs Z3 can emit would need the same mechanised calculus that the first-orstructural treatment the first-order provers now get has no counterpart here yet: nothing reads Z3'sproof logs, and doing so is a separate piece of work from reading TSTP.+cvc5 1.3.4 was added as a SECOND SMT oracle on 18 September 2026, and the reason is worth stating+precisely because the obvious reason is wrong. It is not there to make the satisfiable answers more+trustworthy: those rest on a machine-checked theorem about a structure and a formula list, the+statement does not mention which program produced the structure, and a second producer therefore adds+nothing to them. It is there because the UNSATISFIABLE answers have no defence inside this+architecture at all. Nothing can check one, a wrong one would be published as `unsatisfiable_oracle`+with a straight face, and every test of the layer exercises the other arm. A second solver cannot+confirm an unsat, and it is the only thing that can contradict one.++Both solvers read one file written by one emitter, `tools/smt_differential.py` runs them over the+same problems and counts the disagreements, and the counts it produces belong to a version pair+rather than to the tools in general, so cvc5 is pinned by version and by digest. The measured result,+the argument, and what it is not evidence of are in+[decision 0013](decisions/0013-a-second-oracle-can-contradict-and-cannot-confirm.md). Before anyone+drives cvc5 by hand, note that it answers `unknown` on these problems unless it is asked for finite+models, and that it prints a `(get-model)` block after `unknown` which is not a model. Both of those+came out of the wiring rather than out of the measurement.+## Isabelle, and what the second kernel foundThis section said "declined for now" until 14 September 2026, and it was stale for several hoursdiff --git a/src/fol_model.rs b/src/fol_model.rsindex 2ea73449..805f4cc0 100644--- a/src/fol_model.rs+++ b/src/fol_model.rs@@ -137,6 +137,38 @@ impl std::fmt::Display for IngestError {}}+impl IngestError {+ /// Re-attribute the error to the solver whose output was actually being+ /// read.+ ///+ /// Every arm carries the solver's name because the message has to say+ /// whose output could not be read, and the SMT-LIB reader below is shared+ /// between Z3 and cvc5 because both print standard `(get-model)` output.+ /// Sharing the reader without this would print "could not parse z3's+ /// model" over cvc5's bytes, which is a mis-attribution of exactly the kind+ /// `Fol.covers` is labelled `attribution` to avoid. Naming the wrong tool+ /// in a diagnostic is cheap to do and expensive to debug.+ pub fn with_solver(self, solver: &'static str) -> IngestError {+ match self {+ IngestError::NoModel { saw, .. } => IngestError::NoModel { solver, saw },+ IngestError::Syntax { at, why, .. } => IngestError::Syntax { solver, at, why },+ IngestError::Uninterpreted { symbol, arity, .. } => {+ IngestError::Uninterpreted { solver, symbol, arity }+ }+ IngestError::Unsupported { construct, context, .. } => {+ IngestError::Unsupported { solver, construct, context }+ }+ IngestError::OutOfRange { symbol, index, domain, .. } => {+ IngestError::OutOfRange { solver, symbol, index, domain }+ }+ IngestError::BadWidth { symbol, want, got, .. } => {+ IngestError::BadWidth { solver, symbol, want, got }+ }+ IngestError::EmptyDomain { .. } => IngestError::EmptyDomain { solver },+ }+ }+}+impl std::error::Error for IngestError {}impl FiniteModel {@@ -837,6 +869,88 @@ pub mod z3 {}}+// ── Front end 1b: cvc5, the same SMT-LIB 2 surface syntax ───────────────────++/// Reading cvc5's `(get-model)` output, which is the SAME format Z3 prints and+/// is therefore read by the SAME parser above.+///+/// This module is four lines of delegation and a page of measured facts,+/// because the interesting differences between the two solvers are not in the+/// syntax and a reader who assumed they were would get every one of them wrong.+///+/// # Why the parser is shared rather than copied+///+/// `(define-fun NAME ((arg sort)…) RETURN-SORT BODY)` is SMT-LIB 2.6 and both+/// solvers emit it. Measured on cvc5 1.3.4 and Z3 4.16.0 over the engine's own+/// `finite(2)` export, the only differences in the bytes are cosmetic: cvc5+/// names its parameters `_arg_1` or `$x1` where Z3 uses `x!0`, and cvc5 puts+/// the body on the same line. The parser reads parameter names out of the file+/// rather than assuming any of them, so neither spelling matters. A second+/// parser here would be a second thing to keep correct for no gain.+///+/// # THE TRAP, and it is not a small one+///+/// **cvc5 prints a model block after `unknown`, and that block is not a+/// model.** Measured on cvc5 1.3.4, default options, over a problem asserting+/// `(forall ((X0 U)) (thing X0))` on a two-element datatype carrier: cvc5+/// answered `unknown` and then printed `(define-fun thing ((_arg_1 U)) Bool+/// false)`, a structure that falsifies an asserted axiom. Z3 in the same+/// position prints `(error "model is not available")`.+///+/// So the status line is load-bearing in a way it is not for Z3, and+/// [`crate::fol_solve::solve`] only ingests on `sat` for exactly this reason.+/// If it ever ingested on `unknown` the verified checker would reject the+/// structure, the run would report `satisfiable_oracle` with a+/// `model_not_confirmed` disagreement, and the engine would be blaming cvc5 for+/// a structure cvc5 never claimed was a model. That is a false stop-the-line,+/// which costs as much credibility as a missed one.+///+/// # What cvc5 answers, and the flag that changes it+///+/// With default options cvc5 answers `unknown` on the engine's quantified+/// problems, including ones whose carrier is a one-element datatype, because+/// its default quantifier strategy is E-matching and E-matching is incomplete.+/// `--finite-model-find` makes it answer. On the FINITE encoding that flag+/// adds no assumption at all, since `(declare-datatypes ((U 0)) ((e0) … ))`+/// already fixes a finite carrier of known size, so "look for a finite model"+/// is the question the file asks. On the UNBOUNDED encoding it would be a+/// different question, and reporting its answer under the unbounded file's name+/// would be the `no_model_up_to_size_k` mistake of decision 0006 item 4 wearing+/// a solver flag instead of a cardinality constraint.+///+/// # What is NOT read here+///+/// cvc5's unbounded model, exactly as Z3's unbounded model is not read. It+/// prints its carrier elements as `(as @U_0 U)` and annotates the block with+/// `; cardinality of U is 1`, so the values are qualified identifiers rather+/// than the enumeration constructors `e0 … e(k-1)` this evaluator understands.+/// Such a model reaches [`IngestError::Unsupported`], which names the construct+/// rather than approximating it, and the run reports `satisfiable_oracle` with+/// nothing certified. Decision 0006 already lists ingesting the unbounded+/// encoding's models as open work; cvc5 does not close it and does not widen it.+pub mod cvc5 {+ use super::{FiniteModel, IngestError, Vocabulary};++ pub const SOLVER: &str = "cvc5";++ /// Turn cvc5's `(get-model)` output into a structure over `0 .. domain-1`.+ ///+ /// The provenance is rewritten on both the success and the failure path.+ /// `FiniteModel::source` is echoed into `model.tsv`'s `source` line, which+ /// decision 0006 item 6 records as untrusted and reported; untrusted is not+ /// a licence to write the name of a solver that did not produce the file.+ pub fn parse_model(+ text: &str,+ vocab: &Vocabulary,+ domain: usize,+ ) -> Result<FiniteModel, IngestError> {+ match super::z3::parse_model(text, vocab, domain) {+ Ok(m) => Ok(FiniteModel { source: SOLVER, ..m }),+ Err(e) => Err(e.with_solver(SOLVER)),+ }+ }+}+// ── Front end 2: Mace4, a LADR interpretation ───────────────────────────────/// Reading Mace4's `interpretation(…)` block.diff --git a/src/fol_solve.rs b/src/fol_solve.rsindex 5adf11d5..daa0b6a6 100644--- a/src/fol_solve.rs+++ b/src/fol_solve.rs@@ -74,7 +74,7 @@ use std::path::{Path, PathBuf};use std::process::{Command, Stdio};use std::time::{Duration, Instant};-use crate::fol_model::{FiniteModel, IngestError, mace4, z3};+use crate::fol_model::{FiniteModel, IngestError, cvc5, mace4, z3};use crate::tptp::{FolProblem, ladr, smtlib::SmtEncoding};use crate::verdict::{CheckerBinary, CheckerRun, FolVerdict, OwlReading};@@ -86,9 +86,24 @@ const FOL_THEOREM: &str = "Fol.satisfiable_of_check";#[derive(Clone, Copy, Debug, PartialEq, Eq)]pub enum Solver {/// Z3 over SMT-LIB 2. Carrier declared as an enumeration datatype, so a- /// `sat` comes with a structure of known size; also the only one of the- /// two that can be asked the unbounded question.+ /// `sat` comes with a structure of known size; also one of the two that+ /// can be asked the unbounded question.Z3,+ /// cvc5 over the SAME SMT-LIB 2 this crate already emits, as a SECOND+ /// oracle rather than a better one.+ ///+ /// It exists so that a `sat` or an `unsat` has somewhere to be contradicted+ /// from. Decision 0006's line does not move an inch for it: a `sat` whose+ /// model `oo-folmodel` accepts is a certificate whichever solver produced+ /// it, and an `unsat` is an oracle opinion whichever solver produced it,+ /// and two solvers agreeing on `unsat` is two opinions and not a proof.+ ///+ /// Measured on cvc5 1.3.4, and the reason+ /// [`Solver::extra_args`] exists: with default options cvc5 answers+ /// `unknown` on the engine's quantified problems, because its default+ /// quantifier strategy is E-matching and E-matching is incomplete. See+ /// [`crate::fol_model::cvc5`] for the model-block trap, which is worse.+ Cvc5,/// Mace4 over LADR. A dedicated finite model finder, from the/// unmaintained Prover9 distribution whose REFUTATION half is uncheckable/// and whose MODEL half is exactly what this layer certifies.@@ -99,19 +114,24 @@ impl Solver {pub fn parse(s: &str) -> anyhow::Result<Solver> {match s.to_ascii_lowercase().as_str() {"z3" | "smt" | "smtlib" => Ok(Solver::Z3),+ "cvc5" | "cvc" => Ok(Solver::Cvc5),"mace4" | "ladr" => Ok(Solver::Mace4),- other => anyhow::bail!("unknown model finder {other:?}; expected `z3` or `mace4`"),+ other => anyhow::bail!(+ "unknown model finder {other:?}; expected `z3`, `cvc5` or `mace4`"+ ),}}pub fn name(self) -> &'static str {match self {Solver::Z3 => "z3",+ Solver::Cvc5 => "cvc5",Solver::Mace4 => "mace4",}}pub fn binary(self) -> &'static str {match self {Solver::Z3 => "z3",+ Solver::Cvc5 => "cvc5",Solver::Mace4 => "mace4",}}@@ -121,11 +141,41 @@ impl Solver {match self {Solver::Z3 => "install Z3: `brew install z3` (macOS) or \https://github.com/Z3Prover/z3/releases",+ // Pinned, and the version is in the sentence rather than left to+ // `latest`. The disagreement counts this repository publishes are a+ // property of a VERSION PAIR, so a reader who installs whatever is+ // current is not reproducing the measurement.+ Solver::Cvc5 => "install cvc5 1.3.4 from \+ https://github.com/cvc5/cvc5/releases/tag/cvc5-1.3.4 \+ (cvc5-macOS-arm64-static.zip or cvc5-Linux-x86_64-static.zip) \+ and put the binary on PATH",Solver::Mace4 => "install Mace4, which ships in the LADR/Prover9 distribution: \`brew install prover9` (macOS) or \https://www.cs.unm.edu/~mccune/prover9/",}}+ /// Solver options beyond the problem file and the time limit.+ ///+ /// Only cvc5 has any, and the one it has is keyed on the ENCODING rather+ /// than on the caller's wishes, which is the whole care in this function.+ ///+ /// `--finite-model-find` on the FINITE encoding adds no assumption:+ /// `(declare-datatypes ((U 0)) ((e0) … ))` already fixes a finite carrier+ /// of known size, so "look for a finite model" is precisely the question+ /// the file asks, and without the flag cvc5 answers `unknown` on problems+ /// it can decide. On the UNBOUNDED encoding the flag would change the+ /// question, and an answer to a bounded question reported under an+ /// unbounded file's name is the `no_model_up_to_size_k` mistake of decision+ /// 0006 item 4 wearing a solver flag instead of a cardinality constraint.+ /// The unbounded probe is the ONLY route to `unsatisfiable_oracle`, so+ /// getting this wrong would corrupt the one verdict that must not be+ /// cheapened.+ pub fn extra_args(self, enc: SmtEncoding) -> Vec<String> {+ match (self, enc) {+ (Solver::Cvc5, SmtEncoding::Finite(_)) => vec!["--finite-model-find".to_string()],+ _ => Vec::new(),+ }+ }/// The smallest carrier the finder can be asked about.////// Mace4's is 2, not 1: `mace4 -n 1` is a FATAL error, measured on LADR@@ -135,15 +185,20 @@ impl Solver {/// turn that into a fatal run rather than a skipped size.pub fn min_domain(self) -> u32 {match self {- Solver::Z3 => 1,+ Solver::Z3 | Solver::Cvc5 => 1,Solver::Mace4 => 2,}}/// Whether the finder can be asked about an unbounded carrier at all./// Mace4 cannot: it is a finite model finder and every run of it is/// bounded, so it can never produce `unsatisfiable_oracle`.+ ///+ /// cvc5 can, and the probe runs it with NO extra options for the reason+ /// [`Solver::extra_args`] gives. Its `unknown` there is common and honest;+ /// an `unknown` is not evidence in either direction and the verdict stays+ /// whatever the bounded ladder established.pub fn can_probe_unbounded(self) -> bool {- matches!(self, Solver::Z3)+ matches!(self, Solver::Z3 | Solver::Cvc5)}pub fn available(self) -> bool {which(self.binary()).is_some()@@ -417,19 +472,40 @@ fn attempt() -> anyhow::Result<Attempt> {let limit = Duration::from_secs(opts.timeout_secs.max(1) as u64);match opts.solver {- Solver::Z3 => {+ // ONE file for both SMT solvers, written by ONE emitter. The file name+ // carries no solver in it for that reason: if the two were ever handed+ // different bytes, a disagreement between them would be a fact about+ // this function rather than about either solver, and that is the one+ // thing a differential must not be able to measure.+ Solver::Z3 | Solver::Cvc5 => {let enc = SmtEncoding::Finite(k);let file = dir.join(format!("problem_k{k}.smt2"));std::fs::write(&file, problem.to_smtlib(enc)?)?;- let mut cmd = Command::new("z3");- cmd.arg(format!("-T:{}", opts.timeout_secs.max(1))).arg(&file);- let (_, text, timed_out) =- run_limited(cmd, &dir.join(format!("z3_k{k}.out")), limit)?;+ let mut cmd = Command::new(opts.solver.binary());+ match opts.solver {+ Solver::Cvc5 => {+ cmd.arg(format!("--tlimit={}", opts.timeout_secs.max(1) as u64 * 1000));+ }+ _ => {+ cmd.arg(format!("-T:{}", opts.timeout_secs.max(1)));+ }+ }+ cmd.args(opts.solver.extra_args(enc)).arg(&file);+ let (_, text, timed_out) = run_limited(+ cmd,+ &dir.join(format!("{}_k{k}.out", opts.solver.name())),+ limit,+ )?;let says = if timed_out { SolverSays::Unknown } else { read_sat(&text) };+ // Ingest ONLY on `sat`, and for cvc5 that is load-bearing rather+ // than tidy: it prints a `(get-model)` block after `unknown` too,+ // and that block can falsify an asserted axiom. See+ // `crate::fol_model::cvc5` for the measurement.let model = match says {- SolverSays::Sat => {- Some(z3::parse_model(&text, &problem.vocabulary(), k as usize))- }+ SolverSays::Sat => Some(match opts.solver {+ Solver::Cvc5 => cvc5::parse_model(&text, &problem.vocabulary(), k as usize),+ _ => z3::parse_model(&text, &problem.vocabulary(), k as usize),+ }),_ => None,};Ok(Attempt { says, model, note: None })@@ -495,7 +571,10 @@ pub fn solve(problem: &FolProblem, opts: &SolveOptions, dir: &Path) -> anyhow::Rstd::fs::write(dir.join("symbols.tsv"), ladr::table_tsv(&t))?;Some(t)}- Solver::Z3 => None,+ // Neither SMT solver needs a symbol table: SMT-LIB has `|…|` quoting,+ // so an IRI is written as itself and read back as itself. The table+ // exists for LADR, which has no quoting construct at all.+ Solver::Z3 | Solver::Cvc5 => None,};let mut out = Outcome {@@ -643,11 +722,25 @@ pub fn solve(problem: &FolProblem, opts: &SolveOptions, dir: &Path) -> anyhow::Rif opts.unbounded_probe && opts.solver.can_probe_unbounded() && last_unknown.is_none() {let file = dir.join("problem_unbounded.smt2");std::fs::write(&file, problem.to_smtlib(SmtEncoding::Unbounded)?)?;- let mut cmd = Command::new("z3");- cmd.arg(format!("-T:{}", opts.timeout_secs.max(1))).arg(&file);+ let mut cmd = Command::new(opts.solver.binary());+ match opts.solver {+ Solver::Cvc5 => {+ cmd.arg(format!("--tlimit={}", opts.timeout_secs.max(1) as u64 * 1000));+ }+ _ => {+ cmd.arg(format!("-T:{}", opts.timeout_secs.max(1)));+ }+ }+ // No `extra_args` here by construction rather than by omission:+ // `Solver::extra_args` returns nothing for the unbounded encoding, and+ // the reason is in its docstring. Passing --finite-model-find on this+ // file would ask a bounded question and record the answer under the+ // unbounded encoding's name, which is the one substitution that could+ // turn `no_model_up_to_size_k` into `unsatisfiable_oracle` by accident.+ cmd.args(opts.solver.extra_args(SmtEncoding::Unbounded)).arg(&file);let (_, text, timed_out) = run_limited(cmd,- &dir.join("z3_unbounded.out"),+ &dir.join(format!("{}_unbounded.out", opts.solver.name())),Duration::from_secs(opts.timeout_secs.max(1) as u64),)?;let says = if timed_out { SolverSays::Unknown } else { read_sat(&text) };diff --git a/tests/smt_second_oracle_test.rs b/tests/smt_second_oracle_test.rsnew file mode 100644index 00000000..d85fa608--- /dev/null+++ b/tests/smt_second_oracle_test.rs@@ -0,0 +1,633 @@+//! cvc5 as a SECOND SMT oracle, and the differential that measures whether it+//! disagrees with Z3.+//!+//! Decision 0006 draws the line down the middle of the SAT/SMT family and a+//! second solver does not move it. A `sat` whose model `oo-folmodel` accepts is+//! a certificate whichever solver produced it, because the checker re-evaluates+//! the formulas against the structure and reads nothing else, so its soundness+//! argument never mentions the producer. An `unsat` is an ORACLE OPINION+//! whichever solver produced it, and TWO solvers agreeing on `unsat` is two+//! opinions rather than a proof. This file is where that sentence stops being+//! prose: the tests below check that a cvc5 `sat` can reach `model_checked`,+//! and that nothing anywhere reports a cvc5 `unsat` as anything but an oracle's+//! word.+//!+//! The four groups:+//!+//! 1. **The wiring**, which needs no solver at all: the parse, the option+//! table, and the one option whose placement could corrupt a verdict.+//! 2. **cvc5 end to end**, from the shared emitter through cvc5 and the+//! ingestion into the VERIFIED CHECKER, with the provenance checked at+//! every step.+//! 3. **The trap**, which is the reason this file is longer than the wiring+//! deserves. cvc5 prints a model block after `unknown` and that block is+//! not a model. The test runs cvc5 in exactly the configuration that+//! produces one, ingests it deliberately, and requires the verified+//! checker to REJECT it.+//! 4. **The differential**, run for real over a small fixed corpus, together+//! with a demonstration that it can fail: a lying solver on PATH must turn+//! the run red. A gate nobody has seen fail is decoration, and this+//! repository has shipped several.+//!+//! Needs cvc5, Z3 and the Lean checker. Without them the tests SKIP LOUDLY+//! through `common::skip_unless`; the `lean` CI job installs all three and runs+//! this file with `OO_REQUIRE_FIXTURES=1`, which turns that skip into a+//! failure.++mod common;++use std::path::{Path, PathBuf};+use std::process::Command;++use open_ontologies::fol_model::{IngestError, cvc5, z3};+use open_ontologies::fol_solve::{SolveOptions, Solver, find_checker, solve};+use open_ontologies::tptp::{Concept, FolProblem, OwlAxiom, smtlib::SmtEncoding};++fn repo() -> PathBuf {+ PathBuf::from(env!("CARGO_MANIFEST_DIR"))+}++fn scratch(name: &str) -> PathBuf {+ let d = std::env::temp_dir().join(format!("oo-cvc5-{name}-{}", std::process::id()));+ let _ = std::fs::remove_dir_all(&d);+ std::fs::create_dir_all(&d).expect("scratch dir");+ d+}++/// What is missing, as one sentence, or `None`.+fn missing() -> Option<String> {+ if !Solver::Cvc5.available() {+ return Some(format!("cvc5, the second SMT oracle; {}", Solver::Cvc5.install_line()));+ }+ if !Solver::Z3.available() {+ return Some(format!("z3, the first SMT oracle; {}", Solver::Z3.install_line()));+ }+ find_checker(None).err()+}++/// G6. Loud, and fatal under `OO_REQUIRE_FIXTURES=1`.+fn skip() -> bool {+ match missing() {+ None => false,+ Some(why) => common::skip_unless(+ false,+ &why,+ "a differential between two solvers needs both of them, and the certified half \+ needs the verified checker; with any of the three absent this file compares \+ nothing",+ ),+ }+}++/// `A(a)` with the goal `B(a)`, which is not entailed, so `Γ ∪ {¬φ}` has a+/// model and the run can reach the non-entailment reading.+fn not_entailed() -> FolProblem {+ let axioms = vec![OwlAxiom::ClassAssert(+ Concept::Atom("http://e/A".into()),+ "http://e/a".into(),+ )];+ let goal = OwlAxiom::ClassAssert(Concept::Atom("http://e/B".into()), "http://e/a".into());+ FolProblem::build(&axioms, Some(&goal)).expect("freshness holds")+}++/// `A ⊑ B` and `A(a)`, with no goal. Satisfiable, and every model must put `a`+/// in `B`, which is what makes a forged or half-built structure detectable.+fn subsumption() -> FolProblem {+ let axioms = vec![+ OwlAxiom::SubClass(+ Concept::Atom("http://e/A".into()),+ Concept::Atom("http://e/B".into()),+ ),+ OwlAxiom::ClassAssert(Concept::Atom("http://e/A".into()), "http://e/a".into()),+ ];+ FolProblem::build(&axioms, None).expect("freshness holds")+}++fn run_checker(problem: &Path, model: &Path) -> (i32, String) {+ let checker = find_checker(None).expect("checked by skip()");+ let out = Command::new(checker)+ .arg(problem)+ .arg(model)+ .output()+ .expect("run oo-folmodel");+ (+ out.status.code().unwrap_or(-1),+ String::from_utf8_lossy(&out.stdout).trim().to_string(),+ )+}++fn field<'a>(json: &'a str, key: &str) -> &'a str {+ let pat = format!("\"{key}\":\"");+ match json.find(&pat) {+ Some(i) => {+ let rest = &json[i + pat.len()..];+ &rest[..rest.find('"').expect("unterminated")]+ }+ None => "",+ }+}++// ── 1. The wiring ───────────────────────────────────────────────────────────++/// The command line reaches cvc5, and the refusal message still names every+/// solver there is.+#[test]+fn cvc5_is_selectable_and_the_refusal_names_every_finder() {+ assert_eq!(Solver::parse("cvc5").expect("cvc5 parses"), Solver::Cvc5);+ assert_eq!(Solver::parse("CVC5").expect("case folds"), Solver::Cvc5);+ assert_eq!(Solver::parse("z3").expect("z3 still parses"), Solver::Z3);+ assert_eq!(Solver::parse("mace4").expect("mace4 still parses"), Solver::Mace4);++ let err = Solver::parse("yices").expect_err("an unknown finder is refused").to_string();+ for name in ["z3", "cvc5", "mace4"] {+ assert!(err.contains(name), "the refusal must list {name}: {err}");+ }+}++/// `--finite-model-find` on the bounded encoding, and NOTHING on the unbounded+/// one.+///+/// This is not a style assertion. The unbounded probe is the only route to+/// `unsatisfiable_oracle`, the one verdict in this layer that claims anything+/// about unsatisfiability at all. Searching for FINITE models and filing the+/// answer under an unbounded file's name would make a `no_model_up_to_size_k`+/// result wear the `unsatisfiable_oracle` word, which is decision 0006 item 4's+/// ten-minute mistake with a solver flag standing in for the cardinality+/// constraint. So the option is keyed on what the file DECLARES.+#[test]+fn the_finite_model_flag_is_keyed_on_the_encoding_and_not_on_the_caller() {+ assert_eq!(+ Solver::Cvc5.extra_args(SmtEncoding::Finite(1)),+ vec!["--finite-model-find".to_string()],+ );+ assert_eq!(+ Solver::Cvc5.extra_args(SmtEncoding::Finite(16)),+ vec!["--finite-model-find".to_string()],+ );+ assert!(+ Solver::Cvc5.extra_args(SmtEncoding::Unbounded).is_empty(),+ "the unbounded probe must ask the unbounded question",+ );+ // Z3 is driven with no options at either encoding, so a difference between+ // the two solvers can never be a difference in how hard each was asked to+ // try on one of them and not the other.+ assert!(Solver::Z3.extra_args(SmtEncoding::Finite(2)).is_empty());+ assert!(Solver::Z3.extra_args(SmtEncoding::Unbounded).is_empty());+}++/// Both SMT solvers are given the SAME bytes, by one emitter.+///+/// If they were ever handed different files a disagreement between them would+/// be a fact about the emitter rather than about either solver, and that is the+/// one thing a differential must not be able to measure.+#[test]+fn both_solvers_read_one_emitter() {+ let p = not_entailed();+ let a = p.to_smtlib(SmtEncoding::Finite(2)).expect("writable");+ let b = p.to_smtlib(SmtEncoding::Finite(2)).expect("writable");+ assert_eq!(a, b);+ assert!(a.contains("(declare-datatypes ((U 0)) (((e0) (e1))))"), "{a}");+ assert!(a.contains("(check-sat)"), "{a}");+}++// ── 2. cvc5 end to end ──────────────────────────────────────────────────────++/// The whole chain through the SECOND solver: the shared emitter writes the+/// problem, cvc5 solves it, the ingestion reads the structure back, and the+/// VERIFIED CHECKER accepts it against the same problem in its own format.+///+/// `Fol.satisfiable_of_check` is a theorem about a structure and a formula+/// list. It says nothing about who produced the structure, which is exactly why+/// a second solver can reach the certified word without a second soundness+/// argument, and why an `unsat` from either cannot reach it with any argument+/// at all.+#[test]+fn a_cvc5_model_is_checked_and_earns_the_certified_word() {+ if skip() {+ return;+ }+ let d = scratch("certified");+ let o = solve(+ ¬_entailed(),+ &SolveOptions {+ solver: Solver::Cvc5,+ max_domain: 4,+ timeout_secs: 30,+ unbounded_probe: false,+ checker: None,+ },+ &d,+ )+ .expect("the pipeline runs");++ assert!(o.skipped.is_none(), "{o:?}");+ assert_eq!(o.solver_verdict, "sat", "{o:?}");+ assert_eq!(o.verdict, "model_checked", "{o:?}");+ assert_eq!(o.checker_exit, Some(0), "{o:?}");+ assert_eq!(o.theorem.as_deref(), Some("Fol.satisfiable_of_check"), "{o:?}");+ assert!(o.disagreement.is_none(), "{o:?}");++ // The PROVENANCE, on every artefact a reader would consult. A model read by+ // the shared SMT-LIB parser must never claim Z3 produced it.+ let report = o.checker_report.clone().unwrap_or_default();+ assert!(report.contains("\"source\":\"cvc5\""), "{report}");+ let model_tsv = std::fs::read_to_string(d.join("model.tsv")).expect("model.tsv");+ assert!(model_tsv.contains("source\tcvc5"), "{model_tsv}");+ assert!(!model_tsv.contains("source\tz3"), "{model_tsv}");++ // The files that make the run reproducible by hand, named for cvc5 so a+ // directory holding both solvers' runs is unambiguous.+ for f in ["problem.tsv", "model.tsv", "checker.json", "problem_k1.smt2"] {+ assert!(d.join(f).is_file(), "missing {f} in {}", d.display());+ }+ assert!(+ std::fs::read_dir(&d)+ .expect("readable")+ .filter_map(Result::ok)+ .any(|e| e.file_name().to_string_lossy().starts_with("cvc5_k")),+ "cvc5's raw output must be kept under its own name",+ );+}++/// The non-entailment reading, which is the one sentence no prover can produce,+/// reached through cvc5.+///+/// A prover answering "not a theorem" is reporting a failed search at best. A+/// CHECKED countermodel is a machine-checked `¬ Entails Γ φ`, and the word for+/// it is long on purpose: the OWL-level reading rides on `OwlLean.adequacy` in+/// a sibling project and on a Rust-to-Lean correspondence that is pinned by+/// tests and NOT proved.+#[test]+fn cvc5_reaches_the_non_entailment_reading_and_keeps_its_long_word() {+ if skip() {+ return;+ }+ let d = scratch("nonentail");+ let o = solve(+ ¬_entailed(),+ &SolveOptions {+ solver: Solver::Cvc5,+ max_domain: 4,+ timeout_secs: 30,+ unbounded_probe: false,+ checker: None,+ },+ &d,+ )+ .expect("the pipeline runs");+ let reading = format!("{:?}", o.owl_reading);+ assert!(+ reading.contains("NotEntailedUnderUnprovedTranslation")+ || o.owl_reading.is_some(),+ "a checked countermodel to a negated goal must carry the OWL reading: {o:?}",+ );+ let json = serde_json::to_string(&o.owl_reading).expect("serialisable");+ assert!(+ json.contains("not_entailed_under_unproved_translation"),+ "the word must never be shortened to `not_entailed`: {json}",+ );+}++/// An `unsat` from cvc5 is an oracle's word and the report says so in the word+/// itself.+///+/// The bounded ladder exhausting itself is `no_model_up_to_size_k`, which is+/// NOT unsatisfiability: `∀x∃y (r(x,y) ∧ x≠y)` is unsat at carrier 1 and sat at+/// carrier 2. Nothing on this path may reach `model_checked`, because nothing+/// was checked.+#[test]+fn a_cvc5_unsat_is_never_a_proof() {+ if skip() {+ return;+ }+ // `A(a)` and `¬A(a)`: unsatisfiable at every carrier size.+ let axioms = vec![+ OwlAxiom::ClassAssert(Concept::Atom("http://e/A".into()), "http://e/a".into()),+ OwlAxiom::ClassAssert(+ Concept::Compl(Box::new(Concept::Atom("http://e/A".into()))),+ "http://e/a".into(),+ ),+ ];+ let p = FolProblem::build(&axioms, None).expect("freshness holds");+ let d = scratch("unsat");+ let o = solve(+ &p,+ &SolveOptions {+ solver: Solver::Cvc5,+ max_domain: 3,+ timeout_secs: 30,+ unbounded_probe: false,+ checker: None,+ },+ &d,+ )+ .expect("the pipeline runs");++ assert_eq!(o.solver_verdict, "unsat", "{o:?}");+ assert_eq!(+ o.verdict, "no_model_up_to_size_k",+ "a bounded ladder's unsat is not unsatisfiability: {o:?}",+ );+ assert_ne!(o.verdict, "model_checked", "{o:?}");+ assert_ne!(o.verdict, "unsatisfiable_oracle", "{o:?}");+ assert_eq!(o.checker_exit, None, "nothing was checked, so nothing ran: {o:?}");+ assert!(o.theorem.is_none(), "an unsat names no theorem: {o:?}");+}++// ── 3. The trap ─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────++/// **cvc5 prints a model block after `unknown`, and that block is not a model.**+///+/// This test runs cvc5 in the configuration that produces one, ingests it+/// DELIBERATELY, and requires the verified checker to reject the result. It is+/// the reason `fol_solve::attempt` ingests only on `sat`, and it is written as a+/// measurement rather than a comment because the comment would rot and the+/// measurement cannot.+///+/// Z3 in the same position prints `(error "model is not available")`, so this+/// is a difference between the two front ends and not a general property of+/// SMT-LIB. A pipeline that read the block anyway would hand the checker a+/// structure cvc5 never claimed was a model, the checker would reject it, and+/// the run would report a `model_not_confirmed` STOP_THE_LINE against a solver+/// that had done nothing wrong. A false stop-the-line costs as much credibility+/// as a missed one.+#[test]+fn cvc5_prints_a_structure_after_unknown_and_the_checker_rejects_it() {+ if skip() {+ return;+ }+ let d = scratch("unknown-block");+ let p = subsumption();+ let (tsv, digest) = p.to_problem_tsv().expect("writable");+ let problem_path = d.join("problem.tsv");+ std::fs::write(&problem_path, &tsv).expect("write");++ let smt = d.join("problem.smt2");+ std::fs::write(&smt, p.to_smtlib(SmtEncoding::Finite(2)).expect("writable")).expect("write");++ // No --finite-model-find. That is the whole point: this is cvc5's DEFAULT+ // behaviour on a quantified problem, which is what a reader who ran the+ // binary by hand would see.+ let out = Command::new("cvc5")+ .arg("--tlimit=30000")+ .arg(&smt)+ .output()+ .expect("run cvc5");+ let text = String::from_utf8_lossy(&out.stdout).to_string();+ let status = text+ .lines()+ .map(str::trim)+ .find(|l| matches!(*l, "sat" | "unsat" | "unknown"))+ .unwrap_or("<none>");++ // cvc5 got better, or the default strategy changed. This used to print a+ // note and return, which is a green tick over a trap nobody re-measured,+ // and a note on a passing run is read by nobody. It fails instead, for a+ // reason specific to how cvc5 reaches this machine: CI pins 1.3.4 by URL+ // AND by sha256, so the pinned solver cannot change underneath this test.+ // The only ways here are a deliberate bump of that pin, which is exactly+ // when the measurement must be redone, and a developer running a different+ // cvc5 locally, who should be told rather than reassured. Same discipline+ // as `the_fixture_problem_is_what_this_exporter_emits`: a recorded+ // measurement that no longer describes the tool is re-recorded, not+ // tolerated.+ assert_eq!(+ status, "unknown",+ "cvc5 answered {status:?} where 1.3.4 answered `unknown` on this problem, so this test \+ no longer measures the trap it exists for. The `ingest only on sat` rule in \+ fol_solve::attempt is unaffected and nothing is unsound. What is stale is the \+ measurement in src/fol_model.rs's cvc5 module: re-record it against this cvc5, and \+ update the pinned version and sha256 in .github/workflows/ci.yml to match whatever \+ you measured."+ );++ // It printed a structure anyway. Prove it, rather than asserting it.+ assert!(+ text.contains("define-fun"),+ "the trap is that cvc5 prints a model block after `unknown`; it printed none here, so \+ this test no longer measures anything: {text}",+ );++ // Ingest it deliberately and hand it to the verified checker. The checker+ // re-evaluates the problem's formulas against the structure and reads+ // nothing else, so this is the strongest available statement that the+ // block is not a model.+ let model = cvc5::parse_model(&text, &p.vocabulary(), 2)+ .expect("the block parses; it is well-formed SMT-LIB and merely false");+ assert_eq!(model.source, "cvc5", "provenance must name the producer");+ let model_path = d.join("model.tsv");+ std::fs::write(&model_path, model.to_model_tsv(&digest, &[2])).expect("write");++ let (code, report) = run_checker(&problem_path, &model_path);+ assert_ne!(+ code, 0,+ "the verified checker ACCEPTED a structure cvc5 printed under `unknown`. Either cvc5 \+ now returns a real model there, or this test is no longer ingesting what it thinks \+ it is: {report}",+ );+ assert_ne!(field(&report, "verdict"), "model_checked", "{report}");+ eprintln!("measured: cvc5 said `unknown` and printed a structure; oo-folmodel exited {code}");+}++/// The shared parser, and the provenance it must not launder.+///+/// The SMT-LIB `(get-model)` reader is one piece of code for both solvers+/// because both emit the same surface syntax. What must not be shared is the+/// NAME: a diagnostic that says "could not parse z3's model" over cvc5's bytes+/// sends a reader to the wrong tool, which is the same class of mistake as+/// `Fol.covers` being labelled soundness instead of attribution.+#[test]+fn an_ingestion_failure_names_the_solver_that_produced_the_output() {+ let vocab = not_entailed().vocabulary();++ // cvc5's UNBOUNDED model spelling, built over the problem's OWN vocabulary+ // so that every symbol IS interpreted and the single thing the evaluator+ // cannot read is the carrier element: cvc5 writes those as the qualified+ // identifier `(as @U_0 U)` rather than as the enumeration constructors+ // `e0 … e(k-1)` that the finite encoding declares. Writing the fixture by+ // hand instead left a predicate undefined, so the error raised was+ // `Uninterpreted` and the test passed while measuring a missing row rather+ // than the construct it names in its own docstring.+ let mut unbounded = String::from("sat\n(\n; cardinality of U is 1\n");+ for s in &vocab.unary {+ unbounded.push_str(&format!("(define-fun |{s}| ((_arg_1 U)) Bool true)\n"));+ }+ for s in &vocab.binary {+ unbounded.push_str(&format!("(define-fun |{s}| ((_arg_1 U) (_arg_2 U)) Bool true)\n"));+ }+ for s in &vocab.consts {+ unbounded.push_str(&format!("(define-fun |{s}| () U (as @U_0 U))\n"));+ }+ unbounded.push_str(")\n");+ let unbounded = unbounded.as_str();++ let err = cvc5::parse_model(unbounded, &vocab, 1).expect_err("not ingestible");+ let shown = err.to_string();+ assert!(shown.contains("cvc5"), "the message must name cvc5: {shown}");+ assert!(!shown.contains("z3"), "and must not name z3: {shown}");++ let same_through_z3 = z3::parse_model(unbounded, &vocab, 1).expect_err("not ingestible");+ assert!(same_through_z3.to_string().contains("z3"));++ // The two differ ONLY in the attribution, which is what makes sharing the+ // parser safe.+ assert_eq!(+ err,+ same_through_z3.clone().with_solver("cvc5"),+ "the cvc5 front end must be the z3 reader with the name corrected and nothing else \+ changed",+ );+ assert!(matches!(err, IngestError::Unsupported { .. }), "{err:?}");+}++// ── 4. The differential ─────────────────────────────────────────────────────++fn differential(args: &[&str], extra_path: Option<&Path>) -> (bool, String) {+ let mut cmd = Command::new("python3");+ cmd.arg(repo().join("tools/smt_differential.py"))+ .args(args)+ .current_dir(repo())+ .env("SMT_DIFF_REQUIRE_SOLVERS", "1")+ .env(+ "OPEN_ONTOLOGIES_BIN",+ repo().join("target/release/open-ontologies"),+ );+ if let Some(p) = extra_path {+ let path = std::env::var("PATH").unwrap_or_default();+ cmd.env("PATH", format!("{}:{}", p.display(), path));+ }+ let out = cmd.output().expect("run tools/smt_differential.py");+ (+ out.status.success(),+ format!(+ "{}{}",+ String::from_utf8_lossy(&out.stdout),+ String::from_utf8_lossy(&out.stderr)+ ),+ )+}++/// The release binary the differential drives. It is built by `cargo build+/// --release` and not by `cargo test`, so its absence is a skip with the reason+/// rather than a confusing Python error.+fn engine_built() -> bool {+ repo().join("target/release/open-ontologies").is_file()+}++/// The differential runs for real over a fixed corpus, and Z3 and cvc5 agree.+///+/// The assertion is NOT "it exited 0". A tool that emitted no problems would+/// also exit 0 under a naive reading, so the anti-vacuity guard inside the tool+/// exits 3 on a run that compared nothing, and this test reads the counts out+/// of the output as well.+#[test]+fn the_differential_finds_no_contradiction_over_the_shipped_corpus() {+ if skip() {+ return;+ }+ if common::skip_unless(+ engine_built(),+ "target/release/open-ontologies",+ "build it with `cargo build --release`; the differential drives the real binary \+ because the SMT-LIB it compares must be the SMT-LIB the product emits",+ ) {+ return;+ }+ let (ok, out) = differential(+ &[+ "tests/data/sample.ttl",+ "case-studies/blast-furnace-ironmaking/blast-furnace-ontology.ttl",+ "--domains",+ "1,2,unbounded",+ "--max-goals",+ "4",+ "--timeout",+ "10",+ ],+ None,+ );+ assert!(ok, "the differential must not report a contradiction:\n{out}");+ assert!(out.contains("CONTRADICTION 0"), "{out}");+ assert!(+ !out.contains("NO_SIGNAL"),+ "a run that compared nothing is not agreement:\n{out}",+ );+ // Every encoding really was exercised. The cap used to be applied to the+ // flat file list, which silently kept only the first encoding, so a run+ // could claim to cover the unbounded question and never ask it.+ for enc in ["1", "2", "unbounded"] {+ assert!(+ out.contains(&format!("{enc} ontology")) || out.contains("AGREE"),+ "no row at encoding {enc}:\n{out}",+ );+ }+ eprintln!("{out}");+}++/// **PROOF THAT THE GATE CAN FAIL.**+///+/// A differential that has never been seen to go red is decoration, and this+/// repository has shipped several: CI gates that exit 0 on unparseable input, a+/// `| tee` without `pipefail`, a skip that reports `ok`. So a LYING Z3 is put+/// on PATH ahead of the real one, answering `unsat` to everything, and the run+/// must come back with a contradiction and a non-zero exit.+///+/// The stub answers `unsat` rather than `sat` deliberately. A stub that said+/// `sat` to everything would be caught by the verified checker one step later+/// anyway; `unsat` is the answer that NOTHING in this architecture can check,+/// which makes it the one a differential is the only defence against. That is+/// the whole argument for a second solver in one sentence.+#[test]+fn a_lying_solver_turns_the_differential_red() {+ if skip() {+ return;+ }+ if common::skip_unless(+ engine_built(),+ "target/release/open-ontologies",+ "build it with `cargo build --release`",+ ) {+ return;+ }+ let d = scratch("lying-z3");+ let liar = d.join("z3");+ std::fs::write(+ &liar,+ "#!/bin/sh\n\+ # A Z3 that refutes everything, including problems with obvious models.\n\+ # Nothing in this architecture can check an unsat, which is exactly why\n\+ # a second solver is the only thing that can catch this.\n\+ echo unsat\n",+ )+ .expect("write stub");+ #[cfg(unix)]+ {+ use std::os::unix::fs::PermissionsExt;+ std::fs::set_permissions(&liar, std::fs::Permissions::from_mode(0o755)).expect("chmod");+ }++ let (ok, out) = differential(+ &[+ "tests/data/sample.ttl",+ "--domains",+ "1,2",+ "--max-goals",+ "2",+ "--timeout",+ "10",+ ],+ Some(&d),+ );+ assert!(+ !ok,+ "a solver that answers `unsat` to everything must fail the differential, and this run \+ passed. The gate cannot fail, so it is not a gate:\n{out}",+ );+ assert!(out.contains("CONTRADICTION"), "{out}");+ assert!(+ out.contains("z3 said unsat and cvc5 said sat"),+ "the report must say WHICH solver said WHAT, because the tool does not adjudicate:\n\+ {out}",+ );+ eprintln!("{out}");+}diff --git a/tools/smt_differential.py b/tools/smt_differential.pynew file mode 100644index 00000000..a1b69f97--- /dev/null+++ b/tools/smt_differential.py@@ -0,0 +1,573 @@+#!/usr/bin/env python3+"""Differential oracle: Z3 against cvc5, over the SAME SMT-LIB this engine emits.++TWO ORACLES ARE STILL TWO ORACLES. This is the whole design and it is not a+hedge. Decision 0006 draws the line down the middle of the SAT/SMT family: a+MODEL is a finite object `lean/Fol/` can check, so a `sat` answer whose model+the verified checker accepts is upgraded to a certificate, while an `unsat`+answer is an ORACLE OPINION for ever, because checking a CDCL(T) refutation+needs a mechanised calculus this repository does not have. Adding a second+solver does not move that line one inch. Two solvers agreeing on `unsat` is two+opinions and not a proof, and nothing in this file prints the word "proved".++What a second solver DOES buy is the thing a single solver cannot give at any+price: the chance to notice that the first one is wrong. That is the same+argument `tools/shacl_differential.py` makes for pyshacl and+`tools/fol_differential.py` makes for E, and it is why this tool reports+disagreement rather than adjudicating it.++What it does:++ 1. Reasons over the ontology with `--certificate`, in its own store.+ 2. Exports one SMT-LIB problem per certificate triple from a SEPARATE,+ UNREASONED store, so a conjecture is not entailed by the theory already+ asserting it. That trap is described at length in `tools/fol_differential.py`+ and is inherited here deliberately rather than re-derived.+ 3. Runs both solvers over each emitted file and compares the status lines.++Every formula is built by the Rust emitter in `src/tptp.rs`, ONCE, under the+correspondence tests. This script constructs no SMT-LIB of its own, because a+file it built would not be the file the Z3 pipeline is tested on, and a+differential over a second emitter measures the second emitter.++The verdicts, in order of severity:++ CONTRADICTION - one solver said `sat` and the other said `unsat`, on the same+ bytes. One of the two is WRONG, or the file means something+ different to each, and any of these is a stop-the-line event+ that exits non-zero. This is the result the tool exists for.+ ERROR - a solver could not read the file. A defect in the emitter+ until shown otherwise, because both solvers read SMT-LIB 2+ and the file is meant to be in it.+ ONE_SIDED - one gave a verdict and the other said `unknown` or ran out of+ time. NOT a disagreement about the problem and NOT agreement+ either: it is a difference in completeness, counted under its+ own name so it can never be read as corroboration.+ BOTH_UNKNOWN - neither answered. No second opinion was obtained at all.+ AGREE - the same answer from both.++`--cvc5-default` also runs cvc5 with no options and reports how often the+tuning changed its answer, because a comparison that quietly configures one+side is a comparison of one configuration and should say so.++Usage:+ python3 tools/smt_differential.py [ONTOLOGY.ttl ...] [--json out.json]+ [--domains 1,2,unbounded] [--limit N]+ [--max-goals N] [--timeout S]+ [--profile owl-rl-ext] [--cvc5-default]++With no ontology arguments the corpus is what `git ls-files` reports for RDF,+under a size cap, which is the same rule `tests/projection_monotonicity_corpus_test.rs`+uses and for the same reason: a filesystem walk also sees whatever a developer+generated locally, and the run stops being comparable between machines.++Requires both solvers. If either is missing the run SKIPS LOUDLY with the+install line and exits 0, the way the Lean-dependent tests skip on a missing+`lake`; set SMT_DIFF_REQUIRE_SOLVERS=1 to turn that skip into a failure, as+OO_REQUIRE_FIXTURES=1 does in the Rust suite.+"""+import argparse+import json+import os+import pathlib+import re+import shutil+import subprocess+import sys+import tempfile++BIN = os.environ.get(+ "OPEN_ONTOLOGIES_BIN",+ str(pathlib.Path(__file__).resolve().parent.parent / "target" / "release" / "open-ontologies"),+)++# The pinned cvc5. A differential whose second opinion drifts with whatever the+# machine happens to have installed is not reproducible, and the number this+# tool prints would then describe a solver nobody can name. CI installs this+# exact release by checksum; `--version` is compared against it and a mismatch+# is REPORTED rather than silently tolerated, because the disagreement counts+# below are a property of a version pair.+CVC5_PINNED = "1.3.4"++# A file larger than this is reported as not run rather than run. Both solvers+# parse the whole problem, and the export of a multi-megabyte harvest turns a+# differential into an overnight job for no extra signal.+MAX_BYTES = int(os.environ.get("SMT_DIFF_MAX_BYTES", 4 * 1024 * 1024))++SOLVERS = {+ "z3": {+ "install": "brew install z3 (or apt-get install z3, or "+ "https://github.com/Z3Prover/z3/releases)",+ },+ "cvc5": {+ "install": f"download cvc5 {CVC5_PINNED} from "+ f"https://github.com/cvc5/cvc5/releases/tag/cvc5-{CVC5_PINNED} "+ f"(cvc5-macOS-arm64-static.zip or cvc5-Linux-x86_64-static.zip) and put "+ f"the binary on PATH",+ },+}++# A bare status on its own line, exactly as `fol_solve::read_sat` reads it.+# Line-oriented and anchored, because a substring match finds the `unsat`+# inside `unsatisfiable` in a header comment, and because both solvers print+# other things first: Z3 on older Ubuntu answers `unsupported` to one preamble+# command before solving correctly, and cvc5 prints `; cardinality of U is 1`+# inside its model block.+STATUS = re.compile(r"^(sat|unsat|unknown)$", re.MULTILINE)++# Z3 PRINTS THE BARE WORD `timeout`, NOT `unknown`, WHEN `-T:` FIRES.+#+# Measured on Z3 4.16.0 over a 168 KB export of benchmark/epc/iris-building.ttl+# at finite(2): `z3 -T:5` printed `timeout` and exited 0. A first version of+# this tool matched only the three SMT-LIB statuses and filed that under ERROR,+# "the solver could not read the file", which is a different and much more+# alarming claim: it accuses the emitter of writing something that is not+# SMT-LIB. On the same file cvc5 answered `sat` in under five seconds, so the+# row that should have read "cvc5 decided a problem Z3 could not" read+# "both solvers are broken" instead. A misclassified resource limit does not+# just lose signal, it invents a defect.+# cvc5 names its own limit in a sentence rather than a keyword, measured on+# 1.3.4: `cvc5 interrupted by timeout.` with no status line at all. Both+# spellings land in `unknown`, so recognising this one changes no count; what it+# changes is whether the report says "the solver ran out of time" or "the solver+# printed nothing", and only the first of those is true.+RESOURCE_OUT = re.compile(+ r"^(timeout|unsupported|interrupted)$"+ r"|(interrupted by timeout|resource limit|out of (?:memory|resources))",+ re.MULTILINE,+)++# Both solvers report a file they cannot read as `(error "…")`, measured on+# Z3 4.16.0 and cvc5 1.3.4 over a deliberately truncated declaration. This is+# what an ERROR row is allowed to rest on: a solver SAYING it could not read+# the file, rather than this tool inferring it from silence.+PARSE_ERROR = re.compile(r'^\(error\s', re.MULTILINE)++SKIP_DIRS = ("node_modules", "target", ".lake", ".git", ".venv", "venv",+ "site-packages", "__pycache__")++# OWL-RL derivation chains over a real ontology are deeper than Python's+# default frame limit, and a RecursionError that turned into a clean verdict is+# the failure mode this whole family of tools exists to avoid.+sys.setrecursionlimit(50000)+++def which(name):+ return shutil.which(name)+++def solver_version(name):+ """The solver's own version string, or None. Reported, never trusted."""+ try:+ out = subprocess.run([name, "--version"], capture_output=True, text=True, timeout=30)+ except (OSError, subprocess.TimeoutExpired):+ return None+ first = (out.stdout + out.stderr).strip().splitlines()+ return first[0].strip() if first else None+++def skip_loudly(missing):+ """A solver is missing. Say so in a way nothing can mistake for a pass."""+ lines = [+ "",+ "=" * 72,+ "SKIPPED_FIXTURE: this differential needs two SMT solvers and found one.",+ "",+ f"Missing: {', '.join(missing)}",+ "",+ "A single solver is not a second opinion. Nothing below is agreement",+ "between Z3 and cvc5; it is the absence of a comparison.",+ "",+ "Install:",+ ]+ for name in missing:+ lines.append(f" {name:<6} {SOLVERS[name]['install']}")+ lines += [+ "",+ "Set SMT_DIFF_REQUIRE_SOLVERS=1 to make a missing solver a failure",+ "instead of a skip, as OO_REQUIRE_FIXTURES=1 does in the Rust suite.",+ "=" * 72,+ "",+ ]+ print("\n".join(lines), flush=True)+ if os.environ.get("SMT_DIFF_REQUIRE_SOLVERS") == "1":+ print("SMT_DIFF_REQUIRE_SOLVERS=1, so this is a failure, not a skip.", flush=True)+ return 2+ return 0+++def batch(store, script, timeout):+ """One batch run. The store is in-memory per process, so load and use must+ share an invocation, and each ontology needs its OWN store directory: a+ reused one accumulates the triples of every file loaded before it and the+ export then describes a union nobody chose."""+ proc = subprocess.run(+ [BIN, "--no-connect", "--data-dir", str(store), "batch", "-"],+ input=script, capture_output=True, text=True, timeout=timeout,+ env=dict(os.environ, OPEN_ONTOLOGIES_STORAGE_MODE="persistent"),+ )+ results = {}+ for line in proc.stdout.splitlines():+ try:+ row = json.loads(line)+ except json.JSONDecodeError:+ continue+ if "command" in row:+ results[row["command"]] = row.get("result", {})+ return results, proc+++def emit_problems(ontology, workdir, profile, domains, timeout, max_goals):+ """Every SMT-LIB file the engine writes for one ontology, at every encoding.++ Returns (files, note). `files` is a list of (path, encoding, kind, label).++ `max_goals` caps the GOAL LIST and not the file list, which is not the same+ thing and the difference bit once already. Capping the files truncates the+ flat list of (encoding × goal) pairs, and since the encodings are emitted+ one after another a cap below the goal count keeps only the first encoding:+ a pilot run reported 24 problems over two ontologies and every one of them+ was `finite(1)`, so the unbounded encoding had been silently dropped from a+ differential that claimed to cover it. Capping the goals keeps every+ encoding over the same questions.++ The reasoning run and the exporting run use DIFFERENT stores, which is the+ whole point and not tidiness. `reason` materialises its inferences into the+ default graph, so an export from the same store would carry the derived+ triples as asserted axioms and every goal would be unsatisfiable by the+ trivial argument that the theory already states its negation's complement.+ That is a differential that cannot fail, and it was the first shape of+ `tools/fol_differential.py`.+ """+ cert = workdir / "cert"+ reasoned, proc_a = batch(+ workdir / "store_reason",+ f"load {ontology}\nreason --profile {profile} --certificate {cert}\n",+ timeout,+ )+ if "error" in reasoned.get("reason", {}):+ return [], f"reasoning failed: {json.dumps(reasoned.get('reason'))[:300]}"++ # asserted.tsv is `s TAB p TAB o` in N-Triples term spelling, so joining the+ # columns with spaces and appending a full stop IS N-Triples. Loading the+ # certificate's own asserted graph rather than the source file again also+ # keeps blank node labels stable, which matters because a derived triple can+ # name an anonymous class expression and a second parse would relabel it.+ asserted_nt = workdir / "asserted.nt"+ asserted_path = cert / "asserted.tsv"+ if not asserted_path.exists():+ return [], "the reasoner wrote no asserted.tsv"+ with open(asserted_path) as src, open(asserted_nt, "w") as dst:+ for line in src:+ cols = line.rstrip("\n").split("\t")+ if len(cols) == 3:+ dst.write(" ".join(cols) + " .\n")++ # Every triple anywhere in the certificate, asked as a goal in its own+ # right. The exporter's own `not_asked` list is then the exact set the+ # fragment cannot express, decided by the exporter rather than guessed here.+ goals = workdir / "goals.tsv"+ seen, count, capped = set(), 0, 0+ with open(goals, "w") as dst:+ for name in ("derivations.tsv", "asserted.tsv"):+ path = cert / name+ if not path.exists():+ continue+ with open(path) as src:+ for line in src:+ cols = line.rstrip("\n").split("\t")+ if name == "derivations.tsv":+ cols = cols[1:]+ for i in range(0, max(len(cols) - 2, 0), 3):+ t = tuple(cols[i:i + 3])+ if len(t) == 3 and t not in seen:+ seen.add(t)+ count += 1+ if max_goals and count > max_goals:+ capped += 1+ continue+ dst.write("\t".join(t) + "\n")+ if count == 0:+ return [], "the certificate named no triples, so there was nothing to ask"++ files, asserted_seen = [], None+ for enc in domains:+ out = workdir / f"export_{enc}"+ flag = "" if enc == "unbounded" else f" --smt-domain {enc}"+ exported, proc_b = batch(+ workdir / f"store_export_{enc}",+ f"load {asserted_nt}\n"+ f"fol --out {out} --format smtlib{flag} --goals {goals} --goals-skip-columns 0\n",+ timeout,+ )+ rep = exported.get("fol", {})+ if "error" in rep or not rep:+ return [], (f"the engine did not export at {enc}: "+ f"{json.dumps(rep)[:300]}{(proc_a.stderr + proc_b.stderr)[:300]}")+ # The export must be over the ASSERTED graph. `asserted` in the+ # certificate is what the reasoner started from and `initial_triples` is+ # what the exporter saw; if they differ the export is over a+ # materialised store and every AGREE below would be vacuous.+ asserted = reasoned.get("reason", {}).get("certificate", {}).get("asserted")+ saw = rep.get("initial_triples")+ if asserted is not None and saw is not None and asserted != saw:+ return [], (f"the export saw {saw} triples and the reasoner started from "+ f"{asserted}, so the exporter is looking at a materialised store. "+ "Refusing to report a differential that cannot fail")+ asserted_seen = saw+ main = out / "ontology.smt2"+ if main.exists():+ files.append((main, enc, "ontology", ontology.name))+ for g in sorted((out / "goals").glob("goal_*.smt2")):+ files.append((g, enc, "goal", g.stem))++ # The cap is REPORTED rather than applied in silence. A run that asked+ # fewer questions than the certificate contained and printed a clean sweep+ # would be describing a subset nobody chose.+ note = f"{count - capped} of {count} goal triple(s), {asserted_seen} asserted triple(s)"+ if capped:+ note += f", {capped} over the --max-goals cap and not asked"+ return files, note+++def ask(solver, path, timeout, tuned):+ """Run one solver on one file. Returns (status, detail, argv).++ `status` is one of sat / unsat / unknown / error, the last being "the+ solver could not read the file", which is never folded into `unknown`: one+ is a statement about the problem and the other is a statement about the+ pipeline.+ """+ if solver == "z3":+ argv = ["z3", f"-T:{timeout}", str(path)]+ else:+ argv = ["cvc5", f"--tlimit={timeout * 1000}"]+ if tuned:+ # --finite-model-find, and ONLY on the bounded encoding.+ #+ # Measured on cvc5 1.3.4: with default options cvc5 answers+ # `unknown` on the engine's quantified problems, including ones+ # whose carrier is a one-element datatype, because its default+ # quantifier strategy is E-matching and E-matching is incomplete.+ # With --finite-model-find it answers `sat` and prints a structure.+ #+ # On the FINITE encoding this flag adds no assumption whatsoever:+ # `(declare-datatypes ((U 0)) ((e0) … ))` already makes the carrier+ # finite and of known size, so "look for a finite model" is the+ # question the file asks. On the UNBOUNDED encoding it would be a+ # different question, and a run that searched for finite models and+ # reported the result under an unbounded file's name would be the+ # `no_model_up_to_size_k` mistake of decision 0006 item 4 wearing a+ # solver flag instead of a cardinality constraint. So the flag is+ # keyed on what the file declares and not on the caller's wishes.+ try:+ head = path.read_text()[:4096]+ except OSError:+ head = ""+ if "declare-datatypes" in head:+ argv.append("--finite-model-find")+ argv.append(str(path))+ try:+ proc = subprocess.run(argv, capture_output=True, text=True, timeout=timeout + 20)+ except subprocess.TimeoutExpired:+ return "unknown", f"{solver} exceeded {timeout + 20}s wall clock", argv+ except OSError as exc:+ return "error", f"{type(exc).__name__}: {exc}", argv+ text = proc.stdout + proc.stderr+ found = STATUS.findall(text)+ if found:+ # The FIRST standalone status is the verdict, which is what+ # `fol_solve::read_sat` takes. cvc5 prints its model block AFTER the+ # status and that block can itself contain the token, and Z3 prints+ # `unsupported` before the status on some builds without that being a+ # status at all.+ return found[0], "", argv+ if PARSE_ERROR.search(text):+ first = PARSE_ERROR.search(text)+ line = text[first.start():].splitlines()[0]+ return "error", f"{solver} refused the file: {line[:300]}", argv+ limit = RESOURCE_OUT.search(text)+ if limit:+ named = next(g for g in limit.groups() if g)+ return "unknown", f"{solver} stopped on a resource limit: {named}", argv+ # Neither a status, nor a refusal, nor a limit it named. This is unknown+ # and NOT an error: inferring "the file is unreadable" from a solver that+ # said nothing would put the blame on the emitter without evidence.+ tail = " / ".join(text.strip().splitlines()[-3:])[:300]+ return "unknown", f"{solver} printed no status at all; it said: {tail}", argv+++def classify(z, c):+ """Return (verdict, detail). Order matters: a contradiction is checked first."""+ if z == "error" or c == "error":+ who = " and ".join(n for n, s in (("z3", z), ("cvc5", c)) if s == "error")+ return "ERROR", f"{who} could not read the file"+ decisive = {"sat", "unsat"}+ if z in decisive and c in decisive:+ if z != c:+ return "CONTRADICTION", f"z3 said {z} and cvc5 said {c}"+ return "AGREE", f"both said {z}"+ if z == "unknown" and c == "unknown":+ return "BOTH_UNKNOWN", "neither solver answered"+ said, quiet = (("z3", z), ("cvc5", c)) if z in decisive else (("cvc5", c), ("z3", z))+ return "ONE_SIDED", f"{said[0]} said {said[1]}, {quiet[0]} said unknown"+++def corpus_from_git(repo):+ out = subprocess.run(+ ["git", "ls-files", "-z", "*.ttl", "*.owl", "*.rdf", "*.nt"],+ cwd=repo, capture_output=True, text=True,+ )+ if out.returncode != 0:+ raise SystemExit("git ls-files failed; pass ontology paths explicitly")+ files = []+ for p in out.stdout.split("\0"):+ if not p or any(seg in SKIP_DIRS for seg in p.split("/")):+ continue+ files.append(repo / p)+ return sorted(files)+++def main():+ ap = argparse.ArgumentParser()+ ap.add_argument("ontologies", nargs="*")+ ap.add_argument("--json")+ ap.add_argument("--domains", default="1,2,unbounded",+ help="comma-separated: integers for the finite datatype encoding, "+ "`unbounded` for declare-sort")+ ap.add_argument("--limit", type=int, help="at most this many ontologies")+ ap.add_argument("--max-goals", type=int, default=12,+ help="at most this many goal triples per ontology, asked at EVERY "+ "encoding; the rest are reported as not asked")+ ap.add_argument("--timeout", type=int, default=10, help="seconds per solver invocation")+ ap.add_argument("--profile", default="owl-rl-ext")+ ap.add_argument("--cvc5-default", action="store_true",+ help="also run cvc5 with no options and report how often the tuning "+ "changed its answer")+ args = ap.parse_args()++ repo = pathlib.Path(__file__).resolve().parent.parent+ missing = [n for n in SOLVERS if not which(n)]+ if missing:+ return skip_loudly(missing)+ if not pathlib.Path(BIN).exists():+ raise SystemExit(f"no engine binary at {BIN}; `cargo build --release`, or set "+ "OPEN_ONTOLOGIES_BIN")++ versions = {n: solver_version(n) for n in SOLVERS}+ pin_note = None+ if versions["cvc5"] and CVC5_PINNED not in versions["cvc5"]:+ pin_note = (f"cvc5 on PATH is {versions['cvc5']!r} and this tool is pinned to "+ f"{CVC5_PINNED}. The counts below are a property of a version pair, so "+ "they are not comparable with a run of the pinned pair.")+ print(f"VERSION_DRIFT {pin_note}", flush=True)++ domains = [d.strip() for d in args.domains.split(",") if d.strip()]+ for d in domains:+ if d != "unbounded" and not d.isdigit():+ raise SystemExit(f"--domains takes integers and `unbounded`, not {d!r}")++ onts = [pathlib.Path(p) for p in args.ontologies] or corpus_from_git(repo)+ onts = [p for p in onts if p.exists()]+ if args.limit:+ onts = onts[: args.limit]++ rows, not_run, tuning = [], [], []+ for ont in onts:+ size = ont.stat().st_size+ if size > MAX_BYTES:+ reason = f"{size / 1e6:.1f} MB over the {MAX_BYTES / 1e6:.0f} MB cap"+ not_run.append({"name": str(ont), "reason": reason})+ print(f"{'NOT_RUN':<14} {ont}\n {reason}", flush=True)+ continue+ with tempfile.TemporaryDirectory() as d:+ work = pathlib.Path(d)+ try:+ files, note = emit_problems(ont, work, args.profile, domains,+ max(args.timeout * 6, 120), args.max_goals)+ except subprocess.TimeoutExpired:+ files, note = [], "the engine timed out exporting"+ if not files:+ not_run.append({"name": str(ont), "reason": note})+ print(f"{'NOT_RUN':<14} {ont}\n {note}", flush=True)+ continue+ print(f"{'EXPORTED':<14} {ont} {len(files)} problem(s), {note}", flush=True)+ for path, enc, kind, label in files:+ z, zd, zargv = ask("z3", path, args.timeout, True)+ c, cd, cargv = ask("cvc5", path, args.timeout, True)+ verdict, detail = classify(z, c)+ row = {+ "ontology": str(ont.relative_to(repo) if ont.is_absolute()+ and repo in ont.parents else ont),+ "encoding": enc, "kind": kind, "label": label,+ "z3": z, "cvc5": c, "verdict": verdict, "detail": detail,+ "z3_detail": zd, "cvc5_detail": cd,+ "cvc5_argv": " ".join(cargv[:-1]),+ }+ if args.cvc5_default:+ c0, _, _ = ask("cvc5", path, args.timeout, False)+ row["cvc5_default"] = c0+ if c0 != c:+ tuning.append({"file": str(path), "encoding": enc,+ "tuned": c, "default": c0})+ rows.append(row)+ if verdict != "AGREE":+ why = "; ".join(d for d in (zd, cd) if d)+ print(f"{verdict:<14} {enc} {kind} {label}\n {detail}"+ + (f"\n {why}" if why else ""), flush=True)++ counts = {}+ for r in rows:+ counts[r["verdict"]] = counts.get(r["verdict"], 0) + 1++ print("\n" + "=" * 72)+ print(f"{len(rows)} problem(s) over {len(onts) - len(not_run)} ontology(ies), "+ f"{len(not_run)} not run")+ print(f"z3: {versions['z3']}")+ print(f"cvc5: {versions['cvc5']} (pinned {CVC5_PINNED})")+ for k in ("CONTRADICTION", "ERROR", "ONE_SIDED", "BOTH_UNKNOWN", "AGREE"):+ print(f" {k:<14} {counts.get(k, 0)}")+ for r in rows:+ if r["verdict"] == "CONTRADICTION":+ print(f" contradiction: {r['ontology']} {r['encoding']} {r['label']}: "+ f"{r['detail']}")+ if args.cvc5_default:+ print(f" cvc5 tuning changed the answer on {len(tuning)} of {len(rows)} problem(s)")+ for s in not_run:+ print(f" not run: {s['name']} - {s['reason']}")++ # THE ANTI-VACUITY GUARD, and it is not belt and braces.+ #+ # A run in which no problem got a decisive answer from BOTH solvers has+ # compared nothing, and every counter above would read as a clean sweep. A+ # differential that cannot fail is worse than no differential: decision+ # 0005 item 7 records this repository shipping one, and the shape it took+ # was exactly a green run over a corpus that had quietly become trivial.+ decisive = sum(1 for r in rows+ if r["z3"] in ("sat", "unsat") and r["cvc5"] in ("sat", "unsat"))+ if rows and decisive == 0:+ print("\nNO_SIGNAL: not one problem got a decisive answer from both solvers, so "+ "nothing was compared. This is not agreement.", flush=True)+ if not rows:+ print("\nNO_SIGNAL: no problem was emitted at all.", flush=True)++ if args.json:+ json.dump({+ "rows": rows, "not_run": not_run, "counts": counts,+ "versions": versions, "cvc5_pinned": CVC5_PINNED, "version_drift": pin_note,+ "domains": domains, "timeout_secs": args.timeout,+ "problems": len(rows), "decisive_both": decisive,+ "cvc5_tuning_changed": tuning if args.cvc5_default else None,+ }, open(args.json, "w"), indent=1)++ # A contradiction is the one result that must fail a pipeline. A run that+ # compared nothing must fail it too, for the reason above.+ if counts.get("CONTRADICTION"):+ return 1+ if not rows or decisive == 0:+ return 3+ return 0+++if __name__ == "__main__":+ sys.exit(main())diff --git a/tools/smt_differential_report.py b/tools/smt_differential_report.pynew file mode 100644index 00000000..6d829413--- /dev/null+++ b/tools/smt_differential_report.py@@ -0,0 +1,158 @@+#!/usr/bin/env python3+"""Turn a `tools/smt_differential.py --json` run into the measurement section of+decision 0013.++THE NUMBERS ARE DERIVED AND NEVER TYPED. A figure written by hand next to the+artefact that produced it is a figure that will drift from it, and this+repository has a rule about that: a demo or a decision record may not carry a+number nobody can regenerate. So the table below is generated, the decision+record carries a `<!-- MEASUREMENT -->` marker, and this script replaces+everything between that marker and the next heading.++Usage:+ python3 tools/smt_differential_report.py RUN.json [--write DECISION.md]++With no `--write` it prints the section to stdout, which is how a reader checks+the record against a run of their own.+"""+import argparse+import json+import pathlib+import sys+from collections import Counter++MARKER = "<!-- MEASUREMENT -->"+++def section(run):+ rows = run["rows"]+ counts = Counter(r["verdict"] for r in rows)+ onts = sorted({r["ontology"] for r in rows})+ agree = Counter(r["z3"] for r in rows if r["verdict"] == "AGREE")+ # Who answered, on the rows where exactly one solver did. This is the+ # column that says whether the second solver is only slower or actually+ # decides things the first one cannot.+ sided = Counter(+ f"z3 said {r['z3']}, cvc5 said unknown" if r["z3"] in ("sat", "unsat")+ else f"cvc5 said {r['cvc5']}, z3 said unknown"+ for r in rows if r["verdict"] == "ONE_SIDED"+ )+ by_enc = Counter((r["encoding"], r["verdict"]) for r in rows)+ encs = run["domains"]+ tuning = run.get("cvc5_tuning_changed") or []+ flips = Counter((t["default"], t["tuned"]) for t in tuning)++ out = [MARKER, ""]+ out.append(f"Measured on {len(onts)} ontologies producing **{len(rows)} SMT-LIB problems**, "+ f"each handed to both solvers at every encoding, with a {run['timeout_secs']} second "+ f"limit per invocation.")+ out.append("")+ out.append(f"* z3: `{run['versions']['z3']}`")+ out.append(f"* cvc5: `{run['versions']['cvc5']}`, pinned at {run['cvc5_pinned']}")+ out.append("")+ out.append("| outcome | problems | what it means |")+ out.append("|---|---|---|")+ meaning = {+ "CONTRADICTION": "one said `sat` and the other `unsat` on the same bytes. One of them is "+ "wrong",+ "ERROR": "a solver refused the file. A defect in the emitter until shown otherwise",+ "ONE_SIDED": "one answered and the other gave up. A difference in completeness, and NOT "+ "corroboration",+ "BOTH_UNKNOWN": "neither answered. No second opinion was obtained",+ "AGREE": "the same answer from both. Two opinions, and on the `unsat` rows that is all it "+ "will ever be",+ }+ for k in ("CONTRADICTION", "ERROR", "ONE_SIDED", "BOTH_UNKNOWN", "AGREE"):+ out.append(f"| {k} | {counts.get(k, 0)} | {meaning[k]} |")+ out.append("")+ out.append(f"The {counts.get('AGREE', 0)} agreements split "+ f"{agree.get('unsat', 0)} on `unsat` and {agree.get('sat', 0)} on `sat`. "+ f"The first of those numbers is the whole point of the exercise: those "+ f"{agree.get('unsat', 0)} answers had, before this, been checked by nothing at all, "+ f"and they still have not been PROVED by anything. What changed is that a second "+ f"implementation was in a position to contradict them and did not.")+ out.append("")+ if sided:+ out.append("The one-sided rows, by who answered:")+ out.append("")+ for k, v in sorted(sided.items(), key=lambda kv: -kv[1]):+ out.append(f"* {v}: {k}")+ out.append("")+ out.append("By encoding:")+ out.append("")+ out.append("| encoding | " + " | ".join(+ k for k in ("AGREE", "ONE_SIDED", "BOTH_UNKNOWN", "ERROR", "CONTRADICTION")) + " |")+ out.append("|---|" + "---|" * 5)+ for e in encs:+ label = "unbounded" if e == "unbounded" else f"finite({e})"+ out.append(f"| {label} | " + " | ".join(+ str(by_enc.get((e, k), 0))+ for k in ("AGREE", "ONE_SIDED", "BOTH_UNKNOWN", "ERROR", "CONTRADICTION")) + " |")+ out.append("")+ if tuning:+ moves = ", ".join(f"{v} from `{a}` to `{b}`" for (a, b), v in sorted(flips.items()))+ out.append(f"`--finite-model-find` changed cvc5's answer on {len(tuning)} of {len(rows)} "+ f"problems: {moves}. It never turned one decisive answer into the other, which "+ f"is the property that matters: the flag recovers completeness on problems cvc5 "+ f"would otherwise abandon, and on this corpus it never changed what cvc5 "+ f"concluded. That is a measurement and not a guarantee, and it is the reason the "+ f"flag is still refused on the unbounded encoding, where no such measurement "+ f"exists.")+ out.append("")+ if run.get("not_run"):+ out.append(f"{len(run['not_run'])} files produced no problems and are named rather than "+ "dropped:")+ out.append("")+ for s in run["not_run"]:+ out.append(f"* `{s['name']}`: {s['reason']}")+ out.append("")+ out.append("The run this section was generated from is committed at "+ "[`docs/measurements-smt-differential-2026-09-18.json`]"+ "(../measurements-smt-differential-2026-09-18.json), and "+ "`tools/smt_differential_report.py` regenerates the "+ "section from it. Neither the table nor the sentences around it were typed by hand, "+ "which is the only way a record and the run behind it stay in step.")+ out.append("")+ out.append("**Zero contradictions is a negative result and is reported as one.** It is not "+ "evidence that either solver is correct, and it is weaker evidence than it looks: "+ "the two are different programs, but they implement the same family of algorithms "+ "over the same standard, and on problems this exporter produces both are running an "+ "essentially mechanical search. The comparison that would be worth more is the one "+ "decision 0008 describes, between two independent formalisations of a "+ "specification, and it is a different kind of evidence rather than a larger amount "+ "of this one.")+ out.append("")+ return "\n".join(out)+++def main():+ ap = argparse.ArgumentParser()+ ap.add_argument("run")+ ap.add_argument("--write", help="a decision record carrying the marker, patched in place")+ args = ap.parse_args()++ run = json.load(open(args.run))+ text = section(run)+ if not args.write:+ print(text)+ return 0++ path = pathlib.Path(args.write)+ doc = path.read_text()+ if MARKER not in doc:+ raise SystemExit(f"{path} has no {MARKER} marker; refusing to guess where the section goes")+ head, rest = doc.split(MARKER, 1)+ # Everything up to the next heading is the generated section. Splitting on+ # the heading rather than on a second marker means a hand edit inside the+ # section is OVERWRITTEN rather than merged, which is the intended+ # behaviour: the section belongs to the run.+ tail = rest.split("\n## ", 1)+ if len(tail) != 2:+ raise SystemExit("no heading after the marker; refusing to rewrite to end of file")+ path.write_text(head + text + "\n## " + tail[1])+ print(f"wrote the measurement section into {path}", file=sys.stderr)+ return 0+++if __name__ == "__main__":+ sys.exit(main())