Python
"""The decision path of a tool call: how it was allowed or refused, stage by stage
(observability E4, technical design §8.3).
`_authorize` in the engine records each stage it passes through a `DecisionPath`; the
tool step gets `attrs.decision = {path, origin}`. Every value is an id from a fixed list;
rule or reason text never goes here.
Stages, in order: `permission`, `grant`, `auto_approver`, `card`, `resolved`. `origin` names
the single stage that decided.
"""
from __future__ import annotations
from typing import Any, Optional
# Permission engine allow reasons -> grant ids (§8.3). Matched as prefixes.
_GRANTS = (
("command on allowlist", "config_allowlist"),
("domain on allowlist", "config_allowlist"),
("auto-allowed by config", "config_allowlist"),
("site on the allowed sites", "config_allowlist"),
("already on the allowed sites", "config_allowlist"),
("command allowed for session", "session_grant"),
("read-only command (session grant)", "session_grant"),
("tool allowed for session", "session_grant"),
("tool allowed for this request", "run_grant"),
("trusted MCP tool (user trust rule)", "trusted_rule"),
("trusted MCP tool", "trusted_server"),
("allowed by standing rule", "standing_rule"),
)
# Outcomes of an approval card -> the `resolved` stage (§8.3).
_RESOLVED = {
"once": ("approved_once", None),
"always_tool": ("approved_session", "always_tool"),
"always_command": ("approved_session", "always_command"),
"always_domain": ("approved_session", "always_domain"),
"always_site": ("approved_session", "always_site"),
"readonly_session": ("approved_session", "readonly_session"),
"this_run": ("approved_run", None),
"always_trust": ("approved_always", None),
"deny": ("denied", None),
"superseded": ("superseded", None),
}
# A grant stage that decided a call that ran is its origin.
_GRANT_ORIGINS = {"config_allowlist", "session_grant", "standing_rule", "trusted_rule",
"trusted_server", "run_grant", "allow_anyway", "lead_denial",
"readonly_tier", "gate_tier"}
class DecisionPath:
def __init__(self) -> None:
self.path: list[dict[str, Any]] = []
def add(self, stage: str, outcome: str, detail: Optional[str] = None) -> None:
entry: dict[str, Any] = {"stage": stage, "outcome": outcome}
if detail:
entry["detail"] = detail
self.path.append(entry)
def permission(self, *, allowed: bool, needs_user: bool, human_only: bool, reason: str,
tier: Optional[str] = None) -> None:
"""The permission engine's answer, and the grant behind an allow."""
if allowed:
if tier:
# An Auto-Approve gate tier (OPE-233/234) cleared it without the reviewer.
self.add("permission", "allowed")
self.add("grant", "readonly_tier" if tier == "readonly_command" else "gate_tier")
return
if reason == "low risk":
self.add("permission", "allowed", "low_risk")
elif reason == "full access":
self.add("permission", "allowed", "bypass")
elif reason.startswith("cleared by mode"):
self.add("permission", "allowed", "cleared_by_mode")
else:
grant = next((g for prefix, g in _GRANTS if reason.startswith(prefix)), None)
self.add("permission", "allowed")
if grant:
self.add("grant", grant)
return
if needs_user:
self.add("permission", "human_only" if human_only else "needs_user")
else:
self.add("permission", "denied")
def resolved(self, outcome_value: str, *, interrupted: bool = False) -> None:
if interrupted:
self.add("resolved", "interrupted")
return
outcome, detail = _RESOLVED.get(outcome_value, ("approved_once", None))
self.add("resolved", outcome, detail)
def stage(self, name: str) -> Optional[dict[str, Any]]:
return next((s for s in reversed(self.path) if s["stage"] == name), None)
def finish(self, *, ran: bool) -> dict[str, Any]:
"""`{path, origin}` for the tool step."""
return {"path": list(self.path), "origin": self._origin(ran)}
def _origin(self, ran: bool) -> Optional[str]:
resolved, reviewer = self.stage("resolved"), self.stage("auto_approver")
card, grant, perm = self.stage("card"), self.stage("grant"), self.stage("permission")
if ran:
if resolved and resolved["outcome"].startswith("approved"):
return "user"
if reviewer and reviewer["outcome"] == "allow":
return "reviewer"
if grant and grant["outcome"] in _GRANT_ORIGINS:
return grant["outcome"]
if perm and perm.get("detail") in ("low_risk", "bypass"):
return perm["detail"]
if perm and perm.get("detail") == "cleared_by_mode":
return "bypass"
return None
if reviewer and reviewer["outcome"] == "deny":
return "reviewer_denied"
if card and card["outcome"] == "auto_refused":
return "unattended_auto"
if resolved:
return "user"
if perm and perm["outcome"] == "denied":
return "denied_by_rule"
return None