AI agent skills for startup validation, competitive intelligence, and planning
ai-agentsbattle-cardsclaude-codeclaude-skillscompetitive-analysiscompetitive-intelligencemarket-researchpricing-analysisstartupstartup-validation
Improve skill: split research agents, add fast track, TOC, error handling
Ferdinando Bonsegna3ab22a5fcefe
diff --git a/startup-design/SKILL.md b/startup-design/SKILL.mdindex 1e844c6..bbded22 100644--- a/startup-design/SKILL.md+++ b/startup-design/SKILL.md@@ -1,22 +1,50 @@---name: startup-design-description: |- Comprehensive startup design and idea validation — from market research to brand identity to financial projections. Use this skill whenever the user wants to design a startup, validate a business idea, create a business plan, define brand positioning, analyze a market opportunity, or build a go-to-market strategy. Also trigger when the user mentions "startup," "business idea," "business plan," "market research," "lean canvas," "value proposition," "MVP," "go-to-market," "brand identity," "competitive analysis," or wants to evaluate whether an idea is worth pursuing. Even if the user just says "I have an idea for..." — this skill applies.+description: Comprehensive startup design and idea validation — from market research to brand identity to financial projections. Use this skill whenever the user wants to design a startup, validate a business idea, create a business plan, define brand positioning, analyze a market opportunity, or build a go-to-market strategy. Also trigger when the user mentions startup, business idea, business plan, market research, lean canvas, value proposition, MVP, go-to-market, brand identity, competitive analysis, or wants to evaluate whether an idea is worth pursuing. Even if the user just says I have an idea for — this skill applies.---# Startup DesignA structured, multi-phase skill that takes a startup idea from raw concept to validated design. It produces a complete set of markdown documents organized by domain, with built-in progress tracking so work survives session interruptions.+## Table of Contents++- [How It Works](#how-it-works) — Modes, language, phases overview+- [Phase 0: Resume Check](#phase-0-resume-check) — Detect and resume from checkpoint+- [Phase 1: Intake Interview](#phase-1-intake-interview) — Extract maximum context from the user+- [Phase 2: Brainstorm](#phase-2-brainstorm) — Explore idea variations before committing+- [Phase 3: Market Research](#phase-3-market-research) — Multi-agent web research in 4 waves+- [Phase 4: Strategy](#phase-4-strategy) — Lean Canvas, positioning, business model, GTM+- [Phase 5: Brand](#phase-5-brand) — Mission, vision, tone of voice, personality+- [Phase 6: Product](#phase-6-product) — MVP, feature prioritization, user journey+- [Phase 7: Financial](#phase-7-financial) — Revenue model, costs, projections+- [Phase 8: Validation](#phase-8-validation) — Experiments, risk analysis, scorecard+- [Reference Files](#reference-files) — Index of bundled resources+## How It Works-The process has 7 phases executed sequentially. Each phase produces output files and updates the progress tracker. If a session is interrupted, resume from the last completed checkpoint.+The process has 8 phases executed sequentially. Each phase produces output files and updates the progress tracker. If a session is interrupted, resume from the last completed checkpoint.```INTAKE → BRAINSTORM → RESEARCH → STRATEGY → BRAND → PRODUCT → FINANCIAL → VALIDATION```-## Language+### Modes++**Full Mode (default):** Execute all 8 phases in order. Best for thoroughly designing a startup from scratch.++**Fast Track Mode:** When the user says they want a "quick validation," "rapid assessment," or similar, or when time/budget is clearly limited, run a compressed version:+1. Phase 1 (Intake) — shortened to 1 round of questions+2. Phase 2 (Brainstorm) — 3 variations instead of 5-8+3. Phase 3 (Research) — Wave 1 + Wave 2 only (skip customer voice and distribution deep-dives)+4. Phase 4 (Strategy) — Lean Canvas only+5. Skip Phase 5 (Brand) and Phase 6 (Product)+6. Phase 7 (Financial) — Revenue model only, no full projections+7. Phase 8 (Validation) — Scorecard + top 3 experiments only++Fast Track produces fewer files but still gives the founder a clear go/no-go signal with evidence. Note in PROGRESS.md that Fast Track mode was used, so a future session can expand to full mode if the idea passes validation.++### LanguageDefault output language is **English**. If the user writes in another language or explicitly requests one, use that language for all outputs instead.@@ -134,72 +162,69 @@ Save to `{project-name}/00-intake/brainstorm.md`. Update PROGRESS.md.## Phase 3: Market Research-This is the most resource-intensive phase. Use multiple subagents running in parallel to search the web, organized in waves to avoid context saturation.--### Research Waves--Each wave spawns 2-4 subagents in parallel. Wait for a wave to complete before starting the next, because later waves build on earlier findings.--**Wave 1: Market Landscape**-Spawn agents for:-- Market size and growth (TAM/SAM/SOM for the target market)-- Industry trends and recent developments-- Regulatory environment (if applicable)+This is the most resource-intensive phase. Use multiple subagents running in parallel to search the web, organized in 4 sequential waves. Each wave builds on the previous one's findings.-Each agent should use WebSearch with specific, targeted queries. Example queries for a pet health app:-- "pet health technology market size 2025"-- "pet wellness app industry growth trends"-- "veterinary telemedicine market report"+> **References** — Read the relevant file for each wave:+> - `references/research-principles.md` — Cross-cutting rules (source quality, cross-referencing, quantification, handling search failures). Read this FIRST.+> - `references/research-wave-1-market.md` — Agent templates for Wave 1 (market sizing, trends, regulatory)+> - `references/research-wave-2-competitors.md` — Agent templates for Wave 2 (direct, indirect, GTM analysis)+> - `references/research-wave-3-customers.md` — Agent templates for Wave 3 (customer voice, demand, audience)+> - `references/research-wave-4-distribution.md` — Agent templates for Wave 4 (channels, geographic entry)+> - `references/research-synthesis.md` — How to synthesize raw findings into final deliverables+>+> Read only the principles file + the wave file you're currently executing. Don't load all wave files at once.-**Wave 2: Competitive Analysis**-Based on Wave 1 findings, spawn agents for:-- Direct competitors (products solving the same problem)-- Indirect competitors (alternative approaches to the same problem)-- Potential future competitors (adjacent companies that could enter)+### Research Principles-For each competitor, research: product offering, pricing, target market, strengths, weaknesses, funding, traction signals (reviews, social media presence, job postings).+- Each agent performs **5-8 web searches minimum**, drilling deeper with each round+- Cross-reference every key finding across 2-3 independent sources+- Rate source quality (Tier 1: analyst reports, Tier 2: tech press, Tier 3: blogs/social)+- Quantify everything — "$4.2B at 12.3% CAGR" not "the market is growing"+- Date all data and flag anything older than 18 months+- Note contradictions between sources rather than picking one-**Wave 3: Customer & Demand**-Spawn agents for:-- Customer pain points (forums, Reddit, social media complaints)-- Existing demand signals (search volume, trending topics)-- Customer willingness to pay (pricing benchmarks in the space)+### Research Waves-**Wave 4: Distribution & Channels**-Spawn agents for:-- How competitors acquire customers-- Relevant communities and platforms where target users gather-- Partnership and distribution opportunities+**Wave 1: Market Landscape** (3 agents in parallel)+- Agent 1A: Market Sizing & Economics — TAM/SAM/SOM, unit economics benchmarks, market headwinds+- Agent 1B: Industry Trends & Timing — tech trends, investment/M&A activity, behavioral shifts, expert predictions+- Agent 1C: Regulatory & Compliance — current regulations, data privacy, upcoming changes, compliance costs+ *(Skip 1C if the startup has no regulatory exposure)*-### Agent Instructions+Wait for Wave 1 to complete. Pass key findings as context to Wave 2.-When spawning research agents, give each a focused brief:+**Wave 2: Competitive Analysis** (3 agents in parallel)+- Agent 2A: Direct Competitor Deep-Dives — full profiles on 5-8 competitors (product, pricing, funding, traction, strengths, weaknesses)+- Agent 2B: Indirect Competitors & Substitutes — alternative approaches, platform risk, switching costs+- Agent 2C: Competitor Go-to-Market — how competitors acquire customers, channel analysis, content strategy-```-Research task: {specific topic}-Context: We're designing a startup that {one-sentence description}.-Target market: {market}+Wait for Wave 2 to complete. Pass competitor list and GTM findings to Wave 3.-Search the web for current, factual data on: {specific questions}+**Wave 3: Customer & Demand** (3 agents in parallel)+- Agent 3A: Customer Voice & Pain Points — Reddit, forums, reviews mining with verbatim quotes, pain hierarchy, language map+- Agent 3B: Demand Signals & Market Validation — search trends, pricing intelligence, Product Hunt signals, WTP evidence+- Agent 3C: Target Audience Profiling — personas, buying behavior, decision-making process, where to reach them-Structure your findings as:-- Key data points (with sources where possible)-- Notable insights or surprises-- Gaps in available information+Wait for Wave 3 to complete.-Save your findings to: {specific file path}-```+**Wave 4: Distribution & Partnerships** (2 agents in parallel)+- Agent 4A: Distribution Channel Deep-Dive — channel ranking by ROI, SEO opportunity, partnership opportunities, first 90 days plan+- Agent 4B: Geographic & Market Entry — beachhead market recommendation, entry barriers, expansion path-### Synthesizing Results+### Raw → Synthesized-After all waves complete, read through all the raw research and synthesize into the output files. The synthesis is where you add value — don't just concatenate, but identify patterns, contradictions, and implications.+All agents save raw findings to `{project-name}/01-discovery/raw/`. After all waves complete, synthesize into 4 polished deliverables. The synthesis must:+- Connect dots across research areas (competitive gaps → customer pains → positioning opportunities)+- Highlight contradictions and explain which data to trust+- Rate confidence for each major claim (High / Medium / Low)+- Extract explicit strategic implications, not just facts### Output Files-- `{project-name}/01-discovery/market-analysis.md` — Market size (TAM/SAM/SOM), growth trajectory, key drivers, market maturity stage-- `{project-name}/01-discovery/competitor-landscape.md` — Competitor matrix, positioning map, gaps in the market, competitive advantages to pursue-- `{project-name}/01-discovery/target-audience.md` — Persona(s), pain points, current alternatives, willingness to pay, where they hang out-- `{project-name}/01-discovery/industry-trends.md` — Macro trends, technology shifts, regulatory changes, timing considerations+- `{project-name}/01-discovery/market-analysis.md` — Market size (TAM/SAM/SOM), growth, maturity, regulatory summary, timing assessment+- `{project-name}/01-discovery/competitor-landscape.md` — Competitor profiles, comparison matrix, positioning map, platform risk, vulnerability analysis+- `{project-name}/01-discovery/target-audience.md` — Persona(s), pain hierarchy, jobs-to-be-done, language map, buying behavior, channels+- `{project-name}/01-discovery/industry-trends.md` — Tech trends, investment signals, behavioral shifts, regulatory trajectory, strategic implicationsUpdate PROGRESS.md.@@ -209,6 +234,8 @@ Update PROGRESS.md.With research in hand, define the strategic foundations. Each document should reference specific findings from Phase 3 — strategy disconnected from research is just guessing.+> **Reference:** Read `references/frameworks.md` for canonical definitions of Lean Canvas, April Dunford Positioning, Value Proposition Canvas, and RICE/MoSCoW prioritization. Use these to ensure consistent, accurate application of each framework.+### Lean CanvasBuild a complete Lean Canvas (1-page business model) in `02-strategy/lean-canvas.md`:@@ -295,7 +322,9 @@ Update PROGRESS.md.## Phase 6: Product-Define the product enough to start building or to brief a development team.+Define the product enough to start building or to brief a development team. Use the competitor feature analysis from `01-discovery/competitor-landscape.md` and customer pain hierarchy from `01-discovery/target-audience.md` to inform feature decisions — don't design in a vacuum.++> **Reference:** Use RICE or MoSCoW from `references/frameworks.md` for feature prioritization.### MVP Definition@@ -328,7 +357,7 @@ Update PROGRESS.md.## Phase 7: Financial-Ground the strategy in numbers. Be honest about assumptions — label everything as estimated and explain the reasoning.+Ground the strategy in numbers. Be honest about assumptions — label everything as estimated and explain the reasoning. Pull unit economics benchmarks (CAC, LTV, churn, ACV) from `01-discovery/market-analysis.md` and competitor pricing from `01-discovery/competitor-landscape.md` to anchor projections in real data.### Revenue Model@@ -447,3 +476,19 @@ After all phases are complete, create a `README.md` at the project root that ser4. **Respect the founder's time.** Don't generate filler. If a section isn't relevant to this particular startup, skip it and note why in PROGRESS.md.5. **Track everything.** Always update PROGRESS.md after completing each phase. This is the user's lifeline if the session breaks.++---++## Reference Files++The `references/` directory contains supporting documentation. Read only what you need for the current phase.++| File | When to Read | Lines |+|------|-------------|-------|+| `research-principles.md` | Before starting Phase 3 (once) | ~60 |+| `research-wave-1-market.md` | When spawning Wave 1 agents | ~130 |+| `research-wave-2-competitors.md` | When spawning Wave 2 agents | ~170 |+| `research-wave-3-customers.md` | When spawning Wave 3 agents | ~170 |+| `research-wave-4-distribution.md` | When spawning Wave 4 agents | ~110 |+| `research-synthesis.md` | After all waves complete, before writing final files | ~90 |+| `frameworks.md` | During Phase 4 (Strategy) and Phase 6 (Product) | ~110 |diff --git a/startup-design/references/frameworks.md b/startup-design/references/frameworks.mdnew file mode 100644index 0000000..5704da1--- /dev/null+++ b/startup-design/references/frameworks.md@@ -0,0 +1,107 @@+# Strategic Frameworks Reference++Use this document when applying frameworks during Phase 4 (Strategy) and Phase 8 (Validation). These are the canonical definitions — follow them to ensure consistency.++---++## Lean Canvas (Ash Maurya)++A 1-page business model adapted from the Business Model Canvas for startups. Fill in this order for best results:++1. **Problem** — Top 3 problems your customers have. List existing alternatives for each.+2. **Customer Segments** — Target customers. Identify early adopters separately.+3. **Unique Value Proposition** — Single, clear, compelling message that turns an unaware visitor into an interested prospect. Follow the formula: "We help [customer] [solve problem] by [mechanism]."+4. **Solution** — Top 3 features that address the top 3 problems. Keep it minimal.+5. **Channels** — Path to customers. Distinguish between inbound (SEO, content, referrals) and outbound (ads, sales, partnerships).+6. **Revenue Streams** — Revenue model, pricing, lifetime value, gross margin.+7. **Cost Structure** — Customer acquisition costs, distribution costs, hosting, people, etc.+8. **Key Metrics** — The 3-5 numbers that tell you how the business is doing. Use the pirate metrics framework (AARRR): Acquisition, Activation, Retention, Revenue, Referral.+9. **Unfair Advantage** — Something that cannot be easily copied or bought. Examples: insider knowledge, personal authority, community, network effects, proprietary data, existing platform.++---++## April Dunford's Positioning Framework++From "Obviously Awesome." Positioning defines how your product is the best in the world at providing something that a well-defined set of customers cares a lot about.++**The 5 components (work through in this order):**++1. **Competitive Alternatives** — What would customers do if your solution didn't exist? Not just direct competitors — include manual processes, spreadsheets, hiring someone, doing nothing. This grounds the positioning in reality.++2. **Unique Attributes** — What do you have that the alternatives don't? Be specific and factual. Not "better UX" but "drag-and-drop workflow builder that requires zero code." Capabilities, features, expertise, integrations, data, speed, etc.++3. **Value** — What do those attributes enable for the customer? Map each attribute to a customer benefit. Attributes are features; value is the outcome. "Drag-and-drop builder" → "Non-technical teams can build workflows without waiting for engineering."++4. **Target Customer** — Who cares the most about this value? The best customers are those for whom your unique value is critical, not just nice-to-have. Define by characteristics that make them care more than others.++5. **Market Category** — The context you position your product in so the value is obvious. Three options:+ - **Existing category**: You're a better version of something people already buy (e.g., "CRM for real estate agents")+ - **New sub-category**: You take an existing category and add a qualifier (e.g., "AI-powered recruiting platform")+ - **New category**: Rare and expensive to do. Only if nothing else frames your value well.++---++## Value Proposition Canvas (Strategyzer)++Two sides that must fit together:++### Customer Profile (right side)+- **Jobs-to-be-done** — What the customer is trying to accomplish. Include functional jobs (tasks), social jobs (how they want to be perceived), and emotional jobs (how they want to feel).+- **Pains** — What annoys, frustrates, or blocks them before, during, or after getting a job done. Include risks, undesired outcomes, and obstacles.+- **Gains** — What outcomes and benefits customers want. Include required gains (must-haves), expected gains (standard), desired gains (nice-to-have), and unexpected gains (delighters).++### Value Map (left side)+- **Products & Services** — What you offer (features, services, support).+- **Pain Relievers** — How your offering alleviates specific customer pains. Map each to a specific pain.+- **Gain Creators** — How your offering creates specific customer gains. Map each to a specific gain.++**Fit** exists when your pain relievers and gain creators match the most important pains and gains.++---++## RICE Prioritization (Intercom)++Score features to decide build order. Each feature gets four scores:++- **Reach** — How many customers will this affect per quarter? Use a concrete number (e.g., 500 users/quarter).+- **Impact** — How much will this move the needle for each person reached? Score: 3 = massive, 2 = high, 1 = medium, 0.5 = low, 0.25 = minimal.+- **Confidence** — How sure are you about reach and impact estimates? Score: 100% = high confidence (data-backed), 80% = medium, 50% = low (gut feel).+- **Effort** — How many person-months will this take? Higher effort = lower priority.++**Formula:** `RICE = (Reach × Impact × Confidence) / Effort`++Sort features by RICE score descending. The highest scores should be built first.++---++## MoSCoW Prioritization++Simpler alternative to RICE. Categorize every feature into one bucket:++- **Must have** — Without these, the product doesn't solve the core problem. Non-negotiable for MVP.+- **Should have** — Important but not critical. The product works without them, but it's notably weaker.+- **Could have** — Nice to have. Include if time/budget allows, but cut first when scope is tight.+- **Won't have (this time)** — Explicitly out of scope. Important to name these to prevent scope creep.++---++## Risk Matrix++Used in Phase 8 (Validation) for risk analysis. Plot each risk on two axes:++**Likelihood:** How probable is this risk?+- High (>60% chance)+- Medium (20-60%)+- Low (<20%)++**Impact:** If it happens, how bad is it?+- Critical — Business fails or pivots required+- Major — Significant delay or revenue loss+- Moderate — Manageable but painful+- Minor — Inconvenience, easily absorbed++**Priority quadrants:**+1. High likelihood + Critical/Major impact → Address immediately, design mitigation+2. Low likelihood + Critical impact → Monitor, have contingency plan+3. High likelihood + Minor impact → Accept and manage+4. Low likelihood + Minor impact → Acknowledge and move ondiff --git a/startup-design/references/research-principles.md b/startup-design/references/research-principles.mdnew file mode 100644index 0000000..f76ab2d--- /dev/null+++ b/startup-design/references/research-principles.md@@ -0,0 +1,54 @@+# Research Principles++These principles apply to ALL research agents across all waves. Every agent must follow them.++## Iterative Deep Research++Each agent performs **5-8 web searches minimum**, organized in sequential rounds that drill deeper:+- Round 1: Broad overview queries+- Round 2: Drill-down into specific findings from Round 1+- Round 3: Cross-reference and validate+- Round 4: Reality check and edge cases++Do NOT stop after a single query. The first search gives you the surface — the follow-ups give you the insight.++## Source Quality Tiers++Rank every finding by source reliability:++| Tier | Source Type | Use For |+|------|-----------|---------|+| **Tier 1** | Industry reports (Gartner, Forrester, McKinsey, IBISWorld), SEC filings, government data, academic papers | Hard numbers, market size, growth rates |+| **Tier 2** | Reputable tech press (TechCrunch, Bloomberg, WSJ), company press releases, investor presentations | Funding data, company news, expert opinions |+| **Tier 3** | Blog posts, opinion pieces, social media | Sentiment, customer voice, anecdotal evidence |++A Tier 3 source saying "the market is $5B" is not reliable. A Tier 1 report saying the same thing is.++## Cross-Referencing++Never trust a single source for important claims. For every key finding:+- Look for 2-3 independent sources+- If sources agree: note convergence and cite all+- If sources disagree: note both figures, explain the discrepancy, and state which you trust more and why++## Quantification++Vague claims are worthless. Always push for numbers:+- Bad: "The market is growing fast"+- Good: "$4.2B market growing at 12.3% CAGR (Grand View Research, 2025)"+- Bad: "Many companies use this"+- Good: "67% of mid-size companies report using at least one AP automation tool (Ardent Partners, 2025)"++## Dating++Always note when data was published. Flag anything older than 18 months as potentially outdated. Markets can shift significantly in that time, especially in tech.++## Handling Research Failures++Sometimes WebSearch won't find what you need. When this happens:++1. **Try alternative queries.** Rephrase, use synonyms, try different angles. At least 3 variations before declaring a gap.+2. **Use proxy data.** If you can't find market size for your exact segment, find the broader market and estimate the segment share. Show your math.+3. **Declare the gap explicitly.** Write: "DATA GAP: Could not find reliable data on [X]. Closest proxy: [Y]. Confidence: Low."+4. **Never fabricate.** If you don't have data, say so. An honest "unknown" is infinitely more valuable than a made-up number.+5. **Suggest how to fill the gap.** Point to specific reports that might have the data (even if paywalled), or recommend primary research the founder could do.diff --git a/startup-design/references/research-synthesis.md b/startup-design/references/research-synthesis.mdnew file mode 100644index 0000000..91f05f1--- /dev/null+++ b/startup-design/references/research-synthesis.md@@ -0,0 +1,84 @@+# Research Synthesis Protocol++After ALL waves complete (8-11 agents), synthesize the raw findings into polished deliverables. This step creates the real analytical value — it's not copying, it's connecting.++## How to Synthesize++1. **Read all raw files** in `01-discovery/raw/` before writing anything.+2. **Look for patterns** across sources: what themes repeat? What surprised you?+3. **Identify contradictions** between sources and explain which you trust more and why.+4. **Connect the dots** between research areas: how do competitive gaps connect to customer pains? How do market trends affect the go-to-market?+5. **Highlight strategic implications** — don't just report facts; say what they mean for this startup.+6. **Rate your confidence** for each major finding: High (multiple Tier 1 sources agree), Medium (some evidence but gaps), Low (limited data, mostly inferred).+7. **Aggregate data gaps** from all raw files and present them clearly — these become inputs for Phase 8 (Validation).++## Output Files++### `01-discovery/market-analysis.md`+Synthesize from: `raw/market-size.md`, `raw/trends.md`, `raw/regulatory.md`, `raw/geographic.md`++Structure:+- **Executive summary** (5-sentence overview of the market opportunity)+- **Market size** with TAM/SAM/SOM breakdown and confidence ratings+- **Growth trajectory** with key drivers and headwinds+- **Market maturity assessment** (emerging / growing / mature / declining)+- **Unit economics benchmarks** (carried from market sizing, used by Phase 7)+- **Regulatory summary** (key requirements, compliance costs, timeline)+- **Geographic analysis** (beachhead market, expansion path)+- **Timing assessment:** why now? What tailwinds and headwinds exist?+- **Data gaps** aggregated from all market-related research++### `01-discovery/competitor-landscape.md`+Synthesize from: `raw/direct-competitors.md`, `raw/indirect-competitors.md`, `raw/competitor-gtm.md`++Structure:+- **Competitive overview** (how crowded, market concentration, overall threat level)+- **Competitor comparison matrix** (features × competitors table)+- **Positioning map** (describe how competitors position themselves, where the whitespace is)+- **Competitor GTM summary** (what acquisition channels work, what's saturated)+- **Platform risk assessment** (which platforms could absorb our functionality)+- **Switching cost analysis** (what keeps people on current solutions)+- **Strategic recommendations:** where to compete, where to avoid, how to differentiate+- **Vulnerability analysis:** which competitors are weakest and why — where can we win?+- **Data gaps**++### `01-discovery/target-audience.md`+Synthesize from: `raw/customer-voice.md`, `raw/target-audience.md`, `raw/demand-signals.md`++Structure:+- **Primary persona** (vivid, data-backed, with representative quote)+- **Secondary persona** (if applicable)+- **Anti-persona** (who NOT to target)+- **Customer pain hierarchy** (ranked by frequency × intensity, from customer voice)+- **Jobs-to-be-done framework** (functional, social, emotional)+- **Language map** (exact words customers use — feed directly into copywriting)+- **Buying behavior** (decision process, criteria, cycle length, objections)+- **Where to reach them** (ranked channels with density and cost)+- **Demand validation** (search trends, WTP evidence, market validation score)+- **Data gaps**++### `01-discovery/industry-trends.md`+Synthesize from: `raw/trends.md`, `raw/regulatory.md`, `raw/demand-signals.md`++Structure:+- **Macro trends** affecting the industry (with timeline and impact assessment)+- **Technology shifts** and their adoption curve+- **Investment and M&A signals** (what smart money is doing)+- **Behavioral shifts** in target customers+- **Regulatory trajectory** (direction of travel, not just current state)+- **What this means for our startup** — explicit strategic implications+- **Timing scorecard:** is now the right time? Rate: tailwinds vs. headwinds+- **Data gaps**++## Cross-Document Connections++After writing all 4 files, add a "Strategic Connections" section at the end of each that links to insights from the other documents. For example:++- In market-analysis.md: "The growth in [trend X] (see industry-trends.md) creates an opening in [segment Y] that [competitor Z] (see competitor-landscape.md) hasn't addressed."+- In target-audience.md: "The pricing sensitivity found here aligns with the $X-Y range from competitor pricing analysis (see competitor-landscape.md)."++These connections help Phase 4 (Strategy) build on concrete research rather than abstract claims.++## Cleanup++Keep the `raw/` directory for reference. Note in PROGRESS.md that raw research files are available at `01-discovery/raw/`.diff --git a/startup-design/references/research-wave-1-market.md b/startup-design/references/research-wave-1-market.mdnew file mode 100644index 0000000..ee37a4c--- /dev/null+++ b/startup-design/references/research-wave-1-market.md@@ -0,0 +1,206 @@+# Wave 1: Market Landscape (3 agents)++Read `research-principles.md` first for cross-cutting rules on source quality, cross-referencing, and quantification.++---++## Agent 1A: Market Sizing & Economics++```+Research task: Deep market sizing for {industry/product category}+Context: We're designing a startup that {one-sentence description}.+Target market: {geography}, {customer segment}++RESEARCH PROTOCOL — perform these searches in sequence, each building on the last:++ROUND 1 — Broad market overview (2-3 searches):+- "{broad category} market size {current year}"+- "{broad category} market report {current year}"+- "{industry} industry overview statistics"+Capture: TAM figures, growth rates, key players. Note which reports are cited most.++ROUND 2 — Segment drill-down (2-3 searches):+- "{specific segment} market size {geography}"+- "{specific segment} spending trends"+- "{customer type} budget for {product category}"+Capture: SAM figures, segment-specific growth, spending patterns per customer.++ROUND 3 — Unit economics research (2-3 searches):+- "{product category} average contract value"+- "{product category} customer acquisition cost benchmarks"+- "{product category} churn rate benchmarks"+- "{product category} pricing survey"+Capture: Industry benchmarks for ACV, CAC, LTV, churn. These ground the financial model later.++ROUND 4 — Reality check (1-2 searches):+- "{product category} market challenges {current year}"+- "why {product category} startups fail"+Capture: Headwinds, saturation signals, common failure modes.++OUTPUT FORMAT:+# Market Sizing: {industry}++## TAM (Total Addressable Market)+- Figure: $X (Source, Date)+- Figure: $Y (Source, Date) — [note if different and why]+- Growth rate: X% CAGR (Source)++## SAM (Serviceable Addressable Market)+- Segment: {specific segment}+- Figure: $X (Source, Date)+- Reasoning: [how SAM was derived from TAM]++## SOM (Serviceable Obtainable Market)+- Realistic Year 1 capture: $X+- Reasoning: [based on comparable company trajectories]++## Unit Economics Benchmarks+- Average contract value: $X/mo or $X/yr+- Customer acquisition cost: $X+- Lifetime value: $X+- Churn rate: X%/mo or X%/yr+- [Note if benchmarks are for this specific segment or broader industry]++## Market Headwinds & Risks+- [List specific challenges with sources]++## Source Quality Assessment+- [Rate each major source as Tier 1/2/3 and note any data gaps]++## Data Gaps+- [List anything you couldn't find with suggested ways to fill the gap]++Save to: {project-name}/01-discovery/raw/market-size.md+```++---++## Agent 1B: Industry Trends & Timing++```+Research task: Industry trends, timing signals, and future trajectory for {industry}+Context: We're designing a startup that {one-sentence description}.++RESEARCH PROTOCOL — perform these searches in sequence:++ROUND 1 — Technology trends (2-3 searches):+- "{industry} technology trends {current year}"+- "AI impact on {industry}"+- "{industry} innovation report {current year}"+Capture: Which technologies are reshaping the space. Adoption curves. Maturity levels.++ROUND 2 — Investment & M&A activity (2-3 searches):+- "{industry} startup funding {current year}"+- "{industry} acquisitions {current year}"+- "{product category} venture capital deals"+Search Crunchbase, PitchBook summaries, TechCrunch funding roundups.+Capture: Deal sizes, acquiring companies (signals of where big players see value), accelerating or decelerating investment.++ROUND 3 — Behavioral shifts (2 searches):+- "{customer type} changing expectations {industry}"+- "remote work impact on {industry}" OR "{customer type} digital adoption"+Capture: How customer behavior is evolving. New expectations. Generational shifts.++ROUND 4 — Expert predictions (1-2 searches):+- "{industry} predictions {current year + 1}"+- "{industry} future outlook analyst"+Capture: Where credible analysts think this is heading. Consensus vs. contrarian views.++OUTPUT FORMAT:+# Industry Trends: {industry}++## Technology Trends+For each trend:+- Trend name and description+- Current adoption stage (early/growing/mature/declining)+- Impact on our startup (opportunity/threat/neutral)+- Timeline: when does this become mainstream?+- Source and date++## Investment Activity+- Total funding in space (last 12 months): $X across N deals+- Notable rounds: [company, amount, stage, date]+- Notable acquisitions: [acquirer → target, amount, date, strategic rationale]+- Investment trend: accelerating / stable / decelerating+- What this signals for our startup++## Behavioral Shifts+- [Specific shift with data]+- [How this affects demand for our product]++## Expert Predictions+- [Prediction, source, credibility assessment]++## Timing Assessment+- Is now a good time to enter this market? Why or why not?+- What would make the timing better or worse?++## Data Gaps+- [List anything you couldn't find]++Save to: {project-name}/01-discovery/raw/trends.md+```++---++## Agent 1C: Regulatory & Compliance Landscape++Skip this agent if the startup has no obvious regulatory exposure. When in doubt, run it — better to discover regulatory requirements early than late.++```+Research task: Regulatory landscape for {industry} in {geography}+Context: We're designing a startup that {one-sentence description}.++RESEARCH PROTOCOL:++ROUND 1 — Current regulations (2-3 searches):+- "{industry} regulations {geography} {current year}"+- "{product type} compliance requirements"+- "{industry} licensing requirements {geography}"++ROUND 2 — Data & privacy (2 searches):+- "{industry} data privacy requirements"+- "GDPR CCPA impact on {industry}" OR "{industry} data handling regulations"++ROUND 3 — Upcoming changes (1-2 searches):+- "{industry} new regulations {current year}"+- "{industry} regulatory changes pending legislation"++ROUND 4 — Enforcement & precedent (1 search):+- "{industry} regulatory enforcement actions" OR "{industry} compliance fines"++OUTPUT FORMAT:+# Regulatory Landscape: {industry} in {geography}++## Current Regulations+For each regulation:+- Name and jurisdiction+- What it requires+- Who it applies to (does it apply to us at launch? At scale?)+- Compliance cost estimate+- Timeline to compliance++## Data & Privacy+- Applicable frameworks (GDPR, CCPA, HIPAA, etc.)+- Data handling requirements specific to this industry+- Impact on product architecture++## Upcoming Changes+- Pending legislation or proposed rules+- Expected timeline+- Potential impact++## Compliance Cost Estimate+- Minimum viable compliance: $X (what you need at launch)+- Full compliance: $X (what you need at scale)+- Certifications needed: [SOC 2, ISO 27001, HIPAA, etc.]++## Risk Assessment+- Regulatory risk level: Low / Medium / High+- Key regulatory risks for this specific startup++## Data Gaps+- [List anything you couldn't find]++Save to: {project-name}/01-discovery/raw/regulatory.md+```diff --git a/startup-design/references/research-wave-2-competitors.md b/startup-design/references/research-wave-2-competitors.mdnew file mode 100644index 0000000..2df557d--- /dev/null+++ b/startup-design/references/research-wave-2-competitors.md@@ -0,0 +1,220 @@+# Wave 2: Competitive Analysis (3 agents)++Read `research-principles.md` first. Wave 2 agents receive findings from Wave 1 as context — pass them a summary of market size, key players identified, and relevant trends.++---++## Agent 2A: Direct Competitor Deep-Dives++```+Research task: Deep analysis of direct competitors for {product description}+Context: We're designing a startup that {one-sentence description}.+Market context from Wave 1: {brief summary of market size, key players found}++RESEARCH PROTOCOL — for each competitor (aim for 5-8 direct competitors):++ROUND 1 — Identify competitors (3-4 searches):+- "{problem} software/app/tool {current year}"+- "best {product category} tools {current year}"+- "{known competitor 1} vs {known competitor 2} alternatives"+- "G2 {product category} grid"+- "{product category} Product Hunt"++ROUND 2 — Deep-dive each competitor (2-3 searches per competitor):+- Visit their website directly: capture pricing, features, positioning+- "{competitor name} review" on G2, Capterra, TrustRadius+- "{competitor name} funding crunchbase" OR "{competitor name} investors"+- "{competitor name} employees linkedin" (for team size signals)+- "{competitor name} complaints" OR "{competitor name} problems reddit"++ROUND 3 — Competitive dynamics (2 searches):+- "{product category} market share"+- "{competitor 1} vs {competitor 2}" comparison articles++For EACH competitor, build a complete profile:++COMPETITOR PROFILE TEMPLATE:+## {Competitor Name}+- **Website:** {url}+- **Founded:** {year}+- **Headquarters:** {location}+- **Team size:** {estimate from LinkedIn/Crunchbase}+- **Funding:** {total raised, last round, investors}+- **Stage:** bootstrapped / seed / Series A / Series B+ / public++### Product+- **Core offering:** {what they sell}+- **Key features:** {top 5 features}+- **Tech stack signals:** {any public info on their technology}+- **Integrations:** {what they connect with}++### Pricing+- **Model:** {subscription / per-user / usage-based / freemium}+- **Tiers:** {list each tier with price and what's included}+- **Free plan:** yes/no, what's included+- **Enterprise:** custom pricing? sales-led?++### Market Position+- **Target customer:** {who they serve}+- **Positioning:** {how they describe themselves — capture their actual tagline}+- **Key differentiator:** {what they claim makes them unique}++### Traction Signals+- **G2/Capterra reviews:** {count and average rating}+- **Product Hunt:** {upvotes if launched there}+- **Social media:** {follower counts on LinkedIn, Twitter}+- **Job postings:** {number and type — engineering heavy = building; sales heavy = scaling}+- **Notable customers:** {logos or case studies on their site}++### Strengths (based on reviews and positioning)+- {strength 1}+- {strength 2}++### Weaknesses (based on negative reviews, missing features, complaints)+- {weakness 1}+- {weakness 2}++### Threat Level to Our Startup: Low / Medium / High+- {why}++---++After all profiles, add:++## Competitive Landscape Summary+- **Market concentration:** fragmented / consolidating / dominated by 1-2 players+- **Gaps in the market:** {what no competitor does well}+- **Positioning opportunities:** {where we can differentiate}+- **Competitive moat assessment:** {how defensible is this market}++## Data Gaps+- [Competitors you suspect exist but couldn't find info on]+- [Data points missing for specific competitors]++Save to: {project-name}/01-discovery/raw/direct-competitors.md+```++---++## Agent 2B: Indirect Competitors & Substitutes++```+Research task: Indirect competitors, substitutes, and alternative approaches for {problem}+Context: We're designing a startup that {one-sentence description}.+Direct competitors found: {list from Agent 2A if available, otherwise "to be determined"}++RESEARCH PROTOCOL:++ROUND 1 — Alternative approaches (2-3 searches):+- "how do {customer type} currently handle {problem}"+- "{problem} without software"+- "{problem} excel template" OR "{problem} manual process"+- "{problem} outsource"++ROUND 2 — Adjacent products (2-3 searches):+- "{adjacent category} that also does {related function}"+- "{large platform} {related feature}" (e.g., "Salesforce reporting" if you're building analytics)+- "open source {product category}"++ROUND 3 — Platform risk (1-2 searches):+- "{major platform} adding {our feature}"+- "{major platform} AI features {current year}"++OUTPUT FORMAT:+# Indirect Competitors & Substitutes++## Status Quo Solutions (what people do today without a dedicated tool)+For each:+- What it is+- How common it is+- Why people stick with it (cost, familiarity, "good enough")+- Where it breaks down (the pain that creates our opportunity)++## Adjacent Products+For each:+- Product name and what it primarily does+- How it partially solves our problem+- What it's missing (our wedge)+- Risk: could they add our feature?++## Platform Risk Assessment+- Which major platforms could absorb our functionality?+- How likely is this? (based on roadmap signals, acquisitions, public statements)+- Timeline estimate+- Mitigation strategies++## Open Source & Free Alternatives+- What exists+- Quality and adoption level+- Why someone would pay for our solution instead++## Switching Cost Analysis+- What keeps people on current solutions?+- What would make them switch?+- Estimated effort to migrate to our product++## Data Gaps+- [List anything you couldn't find]++Save to: {project-name}/01-discovery/raw/indirect-competitors.md+```++---++## Agent 2C: Competitor Go-to-Market Analysis++```+Research task: How competitors in {product category} acquire and retain customers+Context: We're designing a startup that {one-sentence description}.+Key competitors: {list top 3-5 from Agent 2A}++RESEARCH PROTOCOL:++ROUND 1 — Marketing channels (2-3 searches per competitor):+- Check competitor websites for blog, resources, webinars, case studies+- "{competitor name} marketing strategy"+- Search for competitor ads (Google Ads transparency, Facebook Ad Library)+- Check their social media activity and content frequency++ROUND 2 — Sales motion (2 searches):+- "{competitor name} sales team" linkedin+- "{product category} sales cycle length"+- Look for: self-serve signup vs. demo request vs. "contact sales"++ROUND 3 — Content & SEO (2 searches):+- "{product category} blog" — who ranks for key terms?+- Check competitors on Similarweb or similar tools for traffic estimates++OUTPUT FORMAT:+# Competitor Go-to-Market Analysis++For each competitor:+## {Competitor Name} — GTM Breakdown+- **Primary acquisition channel:** {SEO / paid ads / outbound sales / partnerships / community / PLG}+- **Sales motion:** {self-serve / sales-assisted / enterprise sales}+- **Content strategy:** {blog frequency, topics, quality assessment}+- **Social presence:** {which platforms, posting frequency, engagement level}+- **Paid advertising:** {visible ads? what channels? what messaging?}+- **Partnership plays:** {integrations, co-marketing, channel partners}+- **Pricing as GTM:** {freemium? free trial? money-back guarantee?}++## Channel Opportunity Map+| Channel | Competitor Saturation | Our Opportunity | Estimated CAC |+|---------|----------------------|-----------------|---------------|+| SEO/Content | High/Medium/Low | ... | ... |+| Paid Search | ... | ... | ... |+| Social/Community | ... | ... | ... |+| Outbound Sales | ... | ... | ... |+| Partnerships | ... | ... | ... |+| Product-Led Growth | ... | ... | ... |++## Key Takeaway+- What's working for competitors?+- What channels are underexploited?+- Where can we win with limited budget?++## Data Gaps+- [List anything you couldn't find]++Save to: {project-name}/01-discovery/raw/competitor-gtm.md+```diff --git a/startup-design/references/research-wave-3-customers.md b/startup-design/references/research-wave-3-customers.mdnew file mode 100644index 0000000..ab59f59--- /dev/null+++ b/startup-design/references/research-wave-3-customers.md@@ -0,0 +1,233 @@+# Wave 3: Customer & Demand (3 agents)++Read `research-principles.md` first. Wave 3 agents receive competitor findings from Wave 2 as context.++---++## Agent 3A: Customer Voice & Pain Points++```+Research task: Deep customer research — real voices discussing {problem}+Context: We're designing a startup that {one-sentence description}.+Target customer: {customer description}+Key competitors found: {list from Wave 2}++The goal is to hear how real people talk about this problem in their own words. This directly informs positioning, copywriting, and product decisions.++RESEARCH PROTOCOL:++ROUND 1 — Reddit deep-dive (3-4 searches):+- "site:reddit.com {problem keywords}"+- "site:reddit.com {industry} frustration"+- "site:reddit.com {existing solution} complaints"+- Browse top posts in relevant subreddits: r/{industry}, r/{role}, r/{related topic}+For each relevant thread: capture the original post, top comments, and upvote counts (upvotes = agreement).++ROUND 2 — Professional forums (2-3 searches):+- "site:news.ycombinator.com {problem keywords}"+- "{problem} forum discussion"+- "{industry} community {problem}"+- Check industry-specific forums (e.g., Stack Overflow for devtools, Bogleheads for finance)++ROUND 3 — Review mining (2-3 searches):+- "{existing solution} reviews" on G2, Capterra, TrustRadius+- Focus on 1-3 star reviews — these reveal unmet needs+- "{existing solution} worst thing about"++ROUND 4 — Social media sentiment (1-2 searches):+- "site:twitter.com {problem keywords}" OR "site:linkedin.com {problem keywords}"+- "{problem} rant" OR "{problem} hate"++OUTPUT FORMAT:+# Customer Voice Research: {problem}++## Verbatim Quotes (Top 20)+Capture exact quotes that express the pain. For each:+- Quote (verbatim)+- Source (Reddit, G2, etc. — with thread/review link if possible)+- Context (who is this person? what role/industry?)+- Upvotes/agreement signals+- Pain category (see below)++## Pain Categories (grouped from quotes)+For each category:+- Name of pain (e.g., "Time wasted on manual process")+- Frequency: how often does this come up across all sources?+- Intensity: mild annoyance vs. hair-on-fire problem?+- Current workarounds people mention+- Quotes that best represent this pain++## Jobs-to-Be-Done (extracted from customer voice)+- Functional jobs: what are they trying to accomplish?+- Social jobs: how do they want to be perceived?+- Emotional jobs: how do they want to feel?++## Language Map+Words and phrases customers actually use to describe:+- The problem: [list exact words]+- The desired outcome: [list exact words]+- Their frustrations: [list exact words]+This language should be used verbatim in positioning and copy — it resonates because it mirrors their own words.++## Unmet Needs (things people ask for that don't exist yet)+- [Need 1 — evidence from quotes]+- [Need 2 — evidence from quotes]++## Data Gaps+- [Communities you couldn't access or find]+- [Customer segments with no voice data]++Save to: {project-name}/01-discovery/raw/customer-voice.md+```++---++## Agent 3B: Demand Signals & Market Validation++```+Research task: Quantitative demand signals for {product category}+Context: We're designing a startup that {one-sentence description}.++RESEARCH PROTOCOL:++ROUND 1 — Search demand (2-3 searches):+- Google Trends for: "{product category}", "{problem} solution", "{competitor name}"+- "{product category} search volume"+- "keyword research {product category}"+Capture: trend direction (rising/flat/declining), seasonal patterns, geographic hotspots.++ROUND 2 — Product launch signals (2 searches):+- Search Product Hunt for similar products — upvotes, comments, maker responses+- Search Indie Hackers for people building in this space — revenue numbers if shared+- Check beta list / landing page tools for pre-launch products in the space++ROUND 3 — Pricing intelligence (3-4 searches):+- Visit pricing pages of top 5 competitors (directly)+- "{product category} pricing comparison {current year}"+- "{product category} how much do companies spend"+- "{customer type} software budget survey"+Capture: exact pricing tiers from each competitor in a comparison table.++ROUND 4 — Willingness to pay signals (1-2 searches):+- "{product category} survey willingness to pay"+- "{problem} worth paying for"+- Check subreddits and forums for discussions about pricing of similar tools++OUTPUT FORMAT:+# Demand Signals: {product category}++## Search Demand+- Google Trends summary: [rising / stable / declining over what period]+- Peak months (if seasonal): [months]+- Geographic hotspots: [regions/countries with highest interest]+- Related rising queries: [list — these reveal adjacent opportunities]++## Product Launch Signals+| Product | Platform | Date | Upvotes/Reception | Key Takeaway |+|---------|----------|------|-------------------|-------------|+| ... | ... | ... | ... | ... |++## Pricing Landscape+| Competitor | Free Plan | Starter | Pro | Enterprise | Model |+|-----------|-----------|---------|-----|-----------|-------|+| ... | ... | ... | ... | ... | ... |++- Median price point: $X/mo+- Price range: $X - $Y/mo+- Most common model: [subscription / per-user / usage-based]+- Pricing trends: [racing to bottom? premium tier growing? usage-based gaining?]++## Willingness to Pay Assessment+- Evidence for strong WTP: [list]+- Evidence for weak WTP: [list]+- Recommended pricing range for our startup: $X - $Y/mo+- Rationale: [why this range, based on competitor benchmarks and value delivered]++## Market Validation Score+- Search demand: Strong / Moderate / Weak+- Competitive activity: High / Medium / Low (high = proven market; low = unproven)+- Customer spending: Growing / Stable / Declining+- Overall demand signal: [assessment]++## Data Gaps+- [Keywords with no trend data]+- [Competitors with hidden pricing]++Save to: {project-name}/01-discovery/raw/demand-signals.md+```++---++## Agent 3C: Target Audience Profiling++```+Research task: Deep target audience research for {customer description}+Context: We're designing a startup that {one-sentence description}.++RESEARCH PROTOCOL:++ROUND 1 — Demographic & firmographic data (2-3 searches):+- "{customer type} demographics statistics"+- "how many {customer type} in {geography}"+- "{customer type} company size distribution"+Capture: population size, segmentation data, geographic distribution.++ROUND 2 — Behavioral patterns (2-3 searches):+- "{customer type} software adoption habits"+- "{customer type} buying process for {product category}"+- "how do {customer type} discover new tools"+Capture: where they research, who influences them, decision-making process.++ROUND 3 — Day-in-the-life (2 searches):+- "{role} daily challenges"+- "{role} workflow {industry}"+Capture: what their day looks like, where our product fits in their workflow.++ROUND 4 — Decision-making (1-2 searches):+- "{product category} buying criteria"+- "who decides on {product category} at {company type}"+Capture: who are the buyers, influencers, blockers? What's the typical sales cycle?++OUTPUT FORMAT:+# Target Audience Profile: {customer description}++## Primary Persona+- **Name:** {fictional representative name}+- **Role:** {job title}+- **Company:** {company type, size, industry}+- **Demographics:** {age range, location, education}+- **Goals:** {what they're trying to achieve}+- **Frustrations:** {specific pains related to our problem}+- **Current tools:** {what they use today}+- **Quote:** {a representative quote from customer voice research}++## Buying Behavior+- **How they discover tools:** {channels, sources}+- **Who's involved in the decision:** {buyer, influencer, approver, blocker}+- **Decision criteria:** {top 5 factors ranked}+- **Typical budget:** {what they spend on similar tools}+- **Sales cycle length:** {days/weeks/months}+- **Common objections:** {why they might say no}++## Secondary Persona (if applicable)+[Same structure as primary]++## Anti-Persona (who is NOT our customer)+- {description of who we should NOT target and why}++## Where to Reach Them+| Channel | Density | Cost | Notes |+|---------|---------|------|-------|+| {specific subreddits} | ... | Free | ... |+| {specific LinkedIn groups} | ... | ... | ... |+| {specific conferences} | ... | ... | ... |+| {specific newsletters} | ... | ... | ... |+| {specific podcasts} | ... | ... | ... |+| {specific communities} | ... | ... | ... |++## Data Gaps+- [Audience segments with no data]+- [Behavioral data you couldn't find]++Save to: {project-name}/01-discovery/raw/target-audience.md+```diff --git a/startup-design/references/research-wave-4-distribution.md b/startup-design/references/research-wave-4-distribution.mdnew file mode 100644index 0000000..f4de9bc--- /dev/null+++ b/startup-design/references/research-wave-4-distribution.md@@ -0,0 +1,132 @@+# Wave 4: Distribution & Partnerships (2 agents)++Read `research-principles.md` first. Wave 4 agents receive all prior wave findings as context.++---++## Agent 4A: Distribution Channel Deep-Dive++```+Research task: Viable distribution channels for {product category} targeting {customer type}+Context: We're designing a startup that {one-sentence description}.+Competitor GTM findings: {summary from Agent 2C}+Target audience: {summary from Agent 3C}++RESEARCH PROTOCOL:++ROUND 1 — Content & SEO opportunity (3 searches):+- "{product category} keywords" — look for keyword lists, SEO analyses+- Check Ahrefs/Semrush free tools for domain ratings of competitor content+- "{problem} how to" — are there informational queries we could rank for?+Capture: keyword opportunities, content gaps, estimated difficulty.++ROUND 2 — Community & organic (2-3 searches):+- Find the top 5 communities where target customers are active+- Check community rules on self-promotion (some ban it, some welcome it)+- "{product category} referral program" — do competitors use referrals?++ROUND 3 — Paid acquisition benchmarks (2 searches):+- "{industry} Google Ads CPC"+- "{product category} Facebook ads cost per lead"+- "{industry} LinkedIn ads benchmark"+Capture: estimated CPCs, CPLs for relevant channels.++ROUND 4 — Partnership opportunities (2 searches):+- "{product category} integrations marketplace"+- "{adjacent tool} partner program"++OUTPUT FORMAT:+# Distribution Channel Analysis++## Channel Ranking (by expected ROI for a bootstrapped startup)++### Tier 1: High-Impact, Low-Cost+For each channel:+- Channel name+- Why it works for this startup+- Estimated reach+- Estimated CAC+- Time to first results+- How to get started (specific, actionable steps)++### Tier 2: Medium-Impact, Medium-Cost+[Same structure]++### Tier 3: Long-Term Bets+[Same structure]++### Channels to Avoid+- [Channel] — why it won't work for this startup++## SEO / Content Opportunity+- Top 10 keyword opportunities with estimated volume and difficulty+- Content gap analysis: what competitors haven't covered well+- Recommended content strategy (topics, format, frequency)++## Partnership Opportunities+For each potential partnership:+- Partner name/type+- What they get from us+- What we get from them+- How to approach them+- Priority: High / Medium / Low++## First 90 Days Channel Plan+- Week 1-4: [specific actions]+- Week 5-8: [specific actions]+- Week 9-12: [specific actions]++## Data Gaps+- [Channels you couldn't estimate costs for]++Save to: {project-name}/01-discovery/raw/channels.md+```++---++## Agent 4B: Geographic & Market Entry Analysis++```+Research task: Geographic and market entry analysis for {product} in {target geography}+Context: We're designing a startup that {one-sentence description}.+Target: {geography / market segment}++RESEARCH PROTOCOL:++ROUND 1 — Geographic market conditions (2-3 searches):+- "{industry} market {target city/country}"+- "{customer type} concentration {geography}"+- "{product category} adoption rate {geography}"++ROUND 2 — Local competitive dynamics (2 searches):+- "{product category} {target geography} startups"+- Local directories / review sites for competitors in target geography++ROUND 3 — Entry barriers (1-2 searches):+- "{industry} barriers to entry {geography}"+- Language, cultural, regulatory, payment differences (for international markets)++OUTPUT FORMAT:+# Geographic & Market Entry Analysis++## Target Market: {geography}+- Market size in this geography: $X+- Customer density: {how concentrated are target customers}+- Competitive intensity: Low / Medium / High+- Regulatory considerations specific to this geography++## Beachhead Market Recommendation+- Recommended first market: {specific city/region/segment}+- Why this market first: {density of target customers, lower competition, founder network, etc.}+- What winning here proves: {validation milestones}+- Expansion path: {market 1} → {market 2} → {market 3}++## Market Entry Risks+- [Risk specific to this geography]+- [Risk specific to this geography]++## Data Gaps+- [Geographic data you couldn't find]++Save to: {project-name}/01-discovery/raw/geographic.md+```