Skip to content

AI agent skills for startup validation, competitive intelligence, and planning

feat: add synthesis protocol with Dunford process and output templates

Ferdinando Bonsegna8f01202f627a
diff --git a/startup-positioning/references/research-synthesis.md b/startup-positioning/references/research-synthesis.md
new file mode 100644
index 0000000..bf9df7a
--- /dev/null
+++ b/startup-positioning/references/research-synthesis.md
@@ -0,0 +1,272 @@
+# Positioning Research Synthesis Protocol
+
+## Before Writing
+
+1. Read ALL raw files in `{project-name}/raw/` before writing anything
+2. Look for patterns that repeat across multiple sources
+3. Identify contradictions — explain which source to trust and why
+4. Connect the dots across Wave 1 and Wave 2
+
+## Cross-Wave Connections to Look For
+
+These are positioning-specific patterns that emerge when you combine raw research:
+
+- **Customer pain + alternative limitation = positioning opportunity** — your product addresses the pain where alternatives fall short
+- **Best-fit customer characteristics + category expectations = right market frame** — the category where your best customers already shop
+- **Customer language + switching triggers = messaging foundation** — position in the words customers already use
+- **Trend + buyer expectation shift = timing advantage** — position now while the frame is forming
+- **Multiple alternatives failing at the same job = underserved JTBD** — opportunity to own a job that nobody does well
+
+## Confidence Rating
+
+Apply to every major claim in the final deliverables:
+
+- **High:** Multiple Tier 1/2 sources agree, recent data, matches customer voice
+- **Medium:** Some evidence but gaps, or sources partially disagree
+- **Low:** Limited data, mostly inferred, or data older than 12 months
+
+---
+
+## Dunford's 5+1 Components — Detailed Synthesis Process
+
+Work through each component in order. Each one builds on the last.
+
+### 1. Competitive Alternatives
+
+- Pull from `raw/alternative-mapping.md`
+- Organize by job-match relevance (closest job match first)
+- Include non-obvious alternatives — the "do nothing" option is often the real competitor
+- Common mistake: Only listing direct competitors. The founder already knows those. The value is surfacing alternatives they haven't considered.
+- For each alternative, note: what job it solves, how well, and where it breaks down
+
+### 2. Unique Attributes
+
+- This step is COLLABORATIVE — present what research reveals, then ask the founder to confirm and add
+- Look for attributes in: product capabilities, technical architecture, team expertise, business model, speed, integrations, data access
+- Be specific: "Drag-and-drop workflow builder requiring zero code" not "easy to use"
+- Test each attribute: Is it truly unique? Or do alternatives have it too?
+- If alternatives have it, it's not a positioning attribute — it's table stakes
+- Aim for 5-10 candidates; the best positioning uses 3-5
+
+### 3. Value Themes
+
+- For each unique attribute, ask: "So what? What does this enable for the customer?"
+- Chain: Attribute → "which means that..." → customer outcome
+- Group related attributes into 2-3 themes maximum (more than 3 dilutes the message)
+- USE THE LANGUAGE MAP from customer intelligence — frame value in the words customers already use
+- Test: Would a customer care about this? Would they pay for it?
+- If a value theme doesn't connect to a real customer pain from Wave 2, drop it
+
+### 4. Best-Fit Customers
+
+- Pull from `raw/customer-intelligence.md` — best-fit customer profile
+- Define by characteristics that make them CARE MORE, not demographics
+- Good: "Mid-market teams with 5-15 people who outgrew spreadsheets but can't afford enterprise tools"
+- Bad: "Companies with 50-200 employees in the US"
+- The right best-fit customers: get value fast, don't haggle price, become champions
+- Cross-check: do these customers actually experience the pains your value themes address?
+
+### 5. Market Category
+
+- Pull from `raw/market-categories.md`
+- Present 2-3 top candidates with pros/cons for each
+- Recommend one with clear reasoning
+- The right category makes the value OBVIOUS without explanation
+- If unsure between two: default to the one where the product has the strongest existing proof points
+- Consider: existing category, subcategory, or new category (new is highest risk)
+
+### 6. Trend Overlay (Optional)
+
+- Pull from `raw/trends-timing.md`
+- Only include if a trend genuinely amplifies the positioning
+- "None" is a valid and often better answer than a forced trend
+- A bad trend overlay makes positioning feel gimmicky
+- Good test: Would the positioning still work without the trend? If yes, the trend is a bonus. If no, the positioning is too dependent on hype.
+
+---
+
+## Validation Tests
+
+Run all three tests on the synthesized positioning. If any test fails, iterate on the 5+1 components before finalizing.
+
+### Test 1: Neumeier Onliness Statement
+
+Basic form:
+> "Our [product] is the only [category] that [key differentiator]."
+
+Extended (6 elements):
+> - **WHAT:** The category
+> - **HOW:** The point of radical differentiation
+> - **WHO:** The target audience
+> - **WHERE:** The market geography
+> - **WHY:** The need it fulfills
+> - **WHEN:** The underlying trend
+
+If the basic statement isn't convincing — if "only" feels like a stretch — the positioning needs more work. Go back to components 2-3 and sharpen.
+
+### Test 2: Moore Positioning Statement
+
+> **For** [target customer]
+> **who** [statement of need/opportunity],
+> **the** [product name] **is a** [market category]
+> **that** [statement of key benefit].
+> **Unlike** [primary competitive alternative],
+> **our product** [statement of primary differentiation].
+
+Every field must be fillable with confidence. If any field is vague or generic, the component it draws from needs work.
+
+### Test 3: Ries/Trout Mental Ladder
+
+- Can you state the position in 10 words or fewer?
+- Does it claim ONE clear rung (not "best at everything")?
+- Is that rung available (not already owned by a stronger competitor)?
+- Would a customer use these words to describe you to a colleague?
+
+If any test fails, iterate on the 5+1 components. Do not ship weak positioning.
+
+---
+
+## Output File Templates
+
+### positioning-doc.md
+
+```markdown
+# Market Positioning: {product}
+*Generated: {date}*
+
+## Executive Summary
+{Positioning in 3 sentences: who you are, for whom, why you win.}
+
+## 1. Competitive Alternatives
+{What customers would do if your product didn't exist. Full map from research.}
+
+### Alternative Landscape
+| Alternative | Type | Job Match | Where It Falls Short |
+|---|---|---|---|
+
+## 2. Unique Attributes
+| Attribute | Evidence | Defensible? |
+|---|---|---|
+
+## 3. Value Themes
+### Theme 1: {name}
+- **Attributes:** {which unique attributes drive this}
+- **Customer outcome:** {in their language}
+- **Evidence:** {from research}
+
+### Theme 2: {name}
+[same structure]
+
+## 4. Best-Fit Customers
+**Profile:** {characteristics that predict high value and fast adoption}
+**Evidence:** {from customer intelligence}
+**Why they care more:** {what makes this value theme critical for them vs. others}
+
+## 5. Market Category
+**Chosen category:** {name} ({type: existing / subcategory / new})
+**Why this frame:** {reasoning — how it makes unique value obvious}
+**Buyer expectations:** {what this category signals to buyers}
+**Risk:** {what expectations might work against you}
+
+## 6. Trend Overlay
+{Trend and how it amplifies positioning — or "None. The positioning stands on its own."}
+
+## Positioning Strength Assessment
+| Component | Strength | Notes |
+|---|---|---|
+| Competitive Alternatives | Strong/Moderate/Needs Work | {brief} |
+| Unique Attributes | ... | ... |
+| Value Themes | ... | ... |
+| Best-Fit Customers | ... | ... |
+| Market Category | ... | ... |
+| Overall | ... | ... |
+
+## Red Flags
+- {issues that could undermine this positioning}
+
+## Yellow Flags
+- {concerns to monitor}
+
+## Data Gaps & Limitations
+- {what data is missing and how to fill it}
+
+## Sources
+- {key sources with tier ratings}
+```
+
+### positioning-statement.md
+
+```markdown
+# Positioning Statements: {product}
+*Generated: {date}*
+
+## Moore Positioning Statement
+For [target customer] who [need/opportunity], [product] is a [category] that [key benefit]. Unlike [primary alternative], our product [primary differentiation].
+
+## Neumeier Onliness Statement
+[product] is the only [category] that [key differentiator].
+
+## Onliness Statement (Extended)
+- **WHAT:** {category}
+- **HOW:** {point of differentiation}
+- **WHO:** {target audience}
+- **WHERE:** {market}
+- **WHY:** {need it fulfills}
+- **WHEN:** {underlying trend}
+
+## Elevator Pitch (30 seconds)
+{Conversational version of the positioning — what you'd say at a dinner party}
+
+## Validation Notes
+- Onliness Test: {Pass/Fail + notes}
+- Moore Template: {Pass/Fail + notes}
+- Mental Ladder: {Pass/Fail + notes}
+- Overall Positioning Strength: Strong / Moderate / Needs Work
+```
+
+### competitive-alternatives.md
+
+```markdown
+# Competitive Alternatives Map: {product}
+*Generated: {date}*
+
+## The Job to Be Done
+{Core job customers are hiring for}
+
+## Direct Competitors
+[table or structured sections from raw data]
+
+## Adjacent Alternatives
+[from raw data]
+
+## Manual / Status Quo
+[from raw data]
+
+## Your Unique Attributes vs. Each Alternative
+| Alternative | What They Offer | Where You Win | Where They Win |
+|---|---|---|---|
+
+## Key Positioning Insights
+- {what the alternative landscape tells us about positioning}
+```
+
+### market-category-analysis.md
+
+```markdown
+# Market Category Analysis: {product}
+*Generated: {date}*
+
+## Candidate Categories
+### {Category 1}: {type}
+[from raw data + synthesis]
+
+## Recommendation
+{Chosen category with reasoning}
+
+## Implementation
+- **Category label:** {exact words to use}
+- **Tagline direction:** {how to frame it}
+- **Buyer expectation alignment:** {what expectations you meet, which you need to manage}
+
+## Red Flags / Yellow Flags
+```