Skip to content

A skill file for removing AI tells from prose

Add false agency rule: no inanimate objects performing human actions

Hardik Pandya8da1f030185b
diff --git a/README.md b/README.md
index cada42a..3c98256 100644
--- a/README.md
+++ b/README.md
@@ -35,7 +35,7 @@ stop-slop/
**Banned phrases** - Throat-clearing openers, emphasis crutches, business jargon, all adverbs, vague declaratives, meta-commentary. See `references/phrases.md`.
-**Structural clichés** - Binary contrasts, negative listings, dramatic fragmentation, rhetorical setups, narrator-from-a-distance voice, passive voice. See `references/structures.md`.
+**Structural clichés** - Binary contrasts, negative listings, dramatic fragmentation, rhetorical setups, false agency, narrator-from-a-distance voice, passive voice. See `references/structures.md`.
**Sentence-level rules** - No Wh- sentence starters, no em dashes, no staccato fragmentation, no lazy extremes, active voice required.
diff --git a/SKILL.md b/SKILL.md
index 465dd7e..83f2032 100644
--- a/SKILL.md
+++ b/SKILL.md
@@ -14,9 +14,9 @@ Eliminate predictable AI writing patterns from prose.
1. **Cut filler phrases.** Remove throat-clearing openers, emphasis crutches, and all adverbs. See [references/phrases.md](references/phrases.md).
-2. **Break formulaic structures.** Avoid binary contrasts, negative listings, dramatic fragmentation, rhetorical setups. See [references/structures.md](references/structures.md).
+2. **Break formulaic structures.** Avoid binary contrasts, negative listings, dramatic fragmentation, rhetorical setups, false agency. See [references/structures.md](references/structures.md).
-3. **Use active voice.** Every sentence needs a subject doing something. No passive constructions.
+3. **Use active voice.** Every sentence needs a human subject doing something. No passive constructions. No inanimate objects performing human actions ("the complaint becomes a fix").
4. **Be specific.** No vague declaratives ("The reasons are structural"). Name the specific thing. No lazy extremes ("every," "always," "never") doing vague work.
@@ -34,6 +34,7 @@ Before delivering prose:
- Any adverbs? Kill them.
- Any passive voice? Find the actor, make them the subject.
+- Inanimate thing doing a human verb ("the decision emerges")? Name the person.
- Sentence starts with a Wh- word? Restructure it.
- Any "here's what/this/that" throat-clearing? Cut to the point.
- Any "not X, it's Y" contrasts? State Y directly.
diff --git a/references/structures.md b/references/structures.md
index df587cd..bbcc359 100644
--- a/references/structures.md
+++ b/references/structures.md
@@ -63,6 +63,22 @@ These announce insight rather than deliver it.
| "By the time X, I was Y." | Narrative template |
| "X that isn't Y" | Indirect. Say "X is broken" |
+## False Agency
+
+Giving inanimate things human verbs. Complaints don't "become" fixes. Bets don't "live or die." Decisions don't "emerge." A person does something to make those things happen. AI loves this because it avoids naming the actor.
+
+| Pattern | Problem |
+|---------|---------|
+| "a complaint becomes a fix" | The complaint did nothing. Someone fixed it. |
+| "a bet lives or dies in days" | Bets don't have lifespans. Someone kills the project or ships it. |
+| "the decision emerges" | Decisions don't emerge. Someone decides. |
+| "the culture shifts" | Cultures don't shift on their own. People change behavior. |
+| "the conversation moves toward" | Conversations don't move. Someone steers. |
+| "the data tells us" | Data sits there. Someone reads it and draws a conclusion. |
+| "the market rewards" | Markets don't reward. Buyers pay for things. |
+
+**Instead:** Name the human. "The team fixed it that week" beats "the complaint becomes a fix." If no specific person fits, use "you" to put the reader in the seat.
+
## Narrator-from-a-Distance
Floating above the scene instead of putting the reader in it.