Skip to content

An agentic skills framework & software development methodology that works.

Spec: record iterations 2-3 results and final frozen-config matrix

Jesse Vincentaa803993554f
diff --git a/docs/superpowers/specs/2026-06-09-sdd-task-scoped-review-dispatch-design.md b/docs/superpowers/specs/2026-06-09-sdd-task-scoped-review-dispatch-design.md
index 0f6e6b98a..bd60bc665 100644
--- a/docs/superpowers/specs/2026-06-09-sdd-task-scoped-review-dispatch-design.md
+++ b/docs/superpowers/specs/2026-06-09-sdd-task-scoped-review-dispatch-design.md
@@ -52,10 +52,27 @@ evidence-rule narration.
flat; controllers pasted the diff in only 2 of 22 review dispatches when
phrasing was optional.
- **Iteration 2:** per-task spec and quality reviews merged into one
- `task-reviewer-prompt.md` (one reviewer, one reading of a pasted diff, two
- verdicts; one fix dispatch addresses both kinds of findings); diff-pasting
- made imperative (controller runs `git diff` itself); implementers run the
- focused test while iterating, full suite once before commit.
+ `task-reviewer-prompt.md` (one reviewer, one reading of the diff, two
+ verdicts; one fix dispatch addresses both kinds of findings); implementers
+ run the focused test while iterating, full suite once before commit.
+ Result (go-fractals): 47.5 min / 15.7M / $13.55 — beat baseline on every
+ axis, blind-judged 9/10 vs baseline 7/10.
+- **Iteration 3:** Calibration names merge-blocking maintainability damage
+ (verbatim duplication, swallowed errors, assertion-free tests) as
+ Important and Minor findings must be pasted into the final review for
+ triage; reviewer skepticism extended to the implementer's design
+ rationales ("left it per YAGNI" is a claim, not a verdict); diff handed
+ to reviewers as a file (`git diff > /tmp/sdd-task-N.diff`, redirected so
+ it never enters the controller's context; one Read call for the
+ reviewer) after paste-into-prompt guidance went unadopted (0-6 of 11-17
+ dispatches) for locally-rational context-economics reasons.
+- **Final frozen config (e355795), all five scenarios pass:** go-fractals
+ 44.4 min / 13.4M / $11.67 (-32% time, -37% tokens, -27% dollars vs
+ baseline); svelte-todo 62.8 / 19.7M / $15.76 (-21% / -28% / -25%);
+ rejects-extra-features $1.31 (vs $1.88); spec-reviewer-flaws flat; the
+ planted-defect scenario (v3: open-flag transparency bar for judgment
+ calls, must-fix bar for a test whose name promises verification it
+ never performs) passes with the defect caught and fixed.
## Design